Jan Nitzbon
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Jan Nitzbon has a total of 342 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Moritz Langer
39 shared publicationsSebastian Westermann
29 shared publications- Julia Boike
Permafrost Research Section, Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Telegrafenberg A45, 14473 Potsdam, Germany
25 shared publications - Brian Groenke
Permafrost Research Section, Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Potsdam, Germany
15 shared publications - Thomas Schneider von Deimling
Permafrost Research Section, Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Potsdam, Germany
15 shared publications - Simone Maria Stuenzi
Department of Geography Humboldt‐Universität zu Berlin Berlin Germany
12 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
High-impact climate events and tipping dynamics: assessing scientific understanding and future challenges
This paper is motivated by growing concern about tipping dynamics and processes that can cause abrupt, self-amplifying, and irreversible changes across the Earth system and societies. It assesses current scientific understanding of the most severe climate outcomes, and proposes ways to address the deep uncertainty surrounding them. We find substantial, though difficult-to-quantify, probabilities of major disruptions to large-scale ocean circulation, including the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation and the Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation, with the potential to cause global climate shifts. The probability of ice sheet instability in vulnerable sectors, particularly Antarctica's marine-based sectors, is already high and could accelerate sea level rise over centennial to multi-centennial timescales. Permafrost thaw is underway, with the potential for accelerated greenhouse gas release. Tropical forests face increasing risks of widespread tree mortality, with major consequences for biodiversity, regional climate, and water availability. Coral reef dieback and mountain glacier loss are also underway, while severe compound marine events may trigger irreversible ecosystem changes. Even gradual climate change can produce nonlinear, abrupt impacts when hazards breach physiological or socioecological thresholds, disrupting health, food, or economic systems. It is essential to determine how the probability of such outcomes depends on the level and rate of warming. Current modelling systems challenge our ability to reliably quantify these risks. Sustained investment in observations, process understanding and next-generation earth system modelling is critical to identify precursors and improve early warning. Decision frameworks are needed to support proactive, flexible, anticipatory adaptation. Effective mitigation reduces risks of these highly disruptive outcomes.
- 13 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessHigh-impact climate events and tipping dynamics: assessing scientific understanding and future challenges
This paper is motivated by growing concern about tipping dynamics and processes that can cause abrupt, self-amplifying, and irreversible changes across the Earth system and societies. It assesses current scientific understanding of the most severe climate outcomes, and proposes ways to address the deep uncertainty surrounding them. We find substantial, though difficult-to-quantify, probabilities of major disruptions to large-scale ocean circulation, including the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation and the Southern Ocean Abyssal Circulation, with the potential to cause global climate shifts. The probability of ice sheet instability in vulnerable sectors, particularly Antarctica's marine-based sectors, is already high and could accelerate sea level rise over centennial to multi-centennial timescales. Permafrost thaw is underway, with the potential for accelerated greenhouse gas release. Tropical forests face increasing risks of widespread tree mortality, with major consequences for biodiversity, regional climate, and water availability. Coral reef dieback and mountain glacier loss are also underway, while severe compound marine events may trigger irreversible ecosystem changes. Even gradual climate change can produce nonlinear, abrupt impacts when hazards breach physiological or socioecological thresholds, disrupting health, food, or economic systems. It is essential to determine how the probability of such outcomes depends on the level and rate of warming. Current modelling systems challenge our ability to reliably quantify these risks. Sustained investment in observations, process understanding and next-generation earth system modelling is critical to identify precursors and improve early warning. Decision frameworks are needed to support proactive, flexible, anticipatory adaptation. Effective mitigation reduces risks of these highly disruptive outcomes.
- Open Access
- 5 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Hydrological contaminant mobilisation from thawing permafrost in Alaska
Global warming and permafrost thaw increasingly threaten contaminated sites across Alaska, altering contaminant mobilisation risks in sensitive ecosystems and communities. To assess this threat, we used the SIRIUS database to identify 1261 active contaminated sites within Alaska’s permafrost region, noting that many sit near lakes, rivers, and coastlines. We evaluated current and future hydrological mobilisation potential at these sites using the CryoGridLite model under SSP1-2.6 and SSP5-8.5 climate scenarios, accounting for how permafrost thaw and shifting precipitation alter groundwater levels. We then determined overall aquatic hazard potential by integrating site-specific characteristics, including contaminant toxicity, solubility, and proximity to water bodies. Our results show that across Alaska 428 contaminated sites already carry a 'high' to 'very high' mobilisation risk. In the Alaska Tundra ecoregion, about 48% (238) of contaminated sites fall into these categories, while the Alaska Boreal Interior (110 sites, 9.6%) and Boreal Cordillera ecoregions (36 sites, 29.3%) contain fewer high-risk sites and show limited future change. These regional differences reflect distinct environmental controls: in tundra regions, proximity to water bodies and extensive wetland networks heighten mobilisation potential despite generally lower contaminant toxicity, whereas higher contaminant toxicity dominates the drier Boreal Interior where hydrological pathways are limited. While northern coastal regions show the largest relative increases in hydrological mobilisation potential, absolute values remain low, causing minor changes in risk classification. Conversely, drying in central Alaska, likely driven by increased evapotranspiration, could reduce future contaminant mobilisation potential despite enhanced permafrost thaw. Ultimately, these findings highlight the complex and regionally distinct controls on contaminant mobilisation under climate change, offering crucial guidance for targeted northern environmental management.
- 5 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Open AccessHydrological contaminant mobilisation from thawing permafrost in Alaska
Global warming and permafrost thaw increasingly threaten contaminated sites across Alaska, altering contaminant mobilisation risks in sensitive ecosystems and communities. To assess this threat, we used the SIRIUS database to identify 1261 active contaminated sites within Alaska’s permafrost region, noting that many sit near lakes, rivers, and coastlines. We evaluated current and future hydrological mobilisation potential at these sites using the CryoGridLite model under SSP1-2.6 and SSP5-8.5 climate scenarios, accounting for how permafrost thaw and shifting precipitation alter groundwater levels. We then determined overall aquatic hazard potential by integrating site-specific characteristics, including contaminant toxicity, solubility, and proximity to water bodies. Our results show that across Alaska 428 contaminated sites already carry a 'high' to 'very high' mobilisation risk. In the Alaska Tundra ecoregion, about 48% (238) of contaminated sites fall into these categories, while the Alaska Boreal Interior (110 sites, 9.6%) and Boreal Cordillera ecoregions (36 sites, 29.3%) contain fewer high-risk sites and show limited future change. These regional differences reflect distinct environmental controls: in tundra regions, proximity to water bodies and extensive wetland networks heighten mobilisation potential despite generally lower contaminant toxicity, whereas higher contaminant toxicity dominates the drier Boreal Interior where hydrological pathways are limited. While northern coastal regions show the largest relative increases in hydrological mobilisation potential, absolute values remain low, causing minor changes in risk classification. Conversely, drying in central Alaska, likely driven by increased evapotranspiration, could reduce future contaminant mobilisation potential despite enhanced permafrost thaw. Ultimately, these findings highlight the complex and regionally distinct controls on contaminant mobilisation under climate change, offering crucial guidance for targeted northern environmental management.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (30) , eaed1105
Westerly induced precipitation increase drives near-surface ground ice gain on the Tibetan Plateau despite warming
Near-surface ground ice loss is a key sign of permafrost degradation under global warming, dictating ground destabilization and carbon feedback. However, recent field evidence suggests that ground ice may locally accumulate, while the driving mechanisms remain unclear. Leveraging borehole ground ice observations, a physics-based permafrost model, and satellite-based ground deformation data, we identify an anomalous ice increase at the active layer bottom despite climate warming across the interior Tibetan Plateau, occupying 35% of plateau’s permafrost area. Strengthened westerlies have enhanced precipitation, supplying additional soil moisture that refreezes at the active layer bottom and drives this unexpected ice gain. Freeze-thaw process associated with the accumulated ice amplifies ground deformation, destabilizing permafrost landscapes and threatening socioeconomic activities. This anomalous ice gain in permafrost regions, together with the Karakoram anomalous glacier mass increase, represents a divergent cryospheric ice gain against global ice loss under climate warming, highlighting that rapid precipitation increase may locally outweigh temperature in driving cryosphere evolution on the Tibetan Plateau.
- 24 July 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (30) , eaed1105
Open AccessWesterly induced precipitation increase drives near-surface ground ice gain on the Tibetan Plateau despite warming
Near-surface ground ice loss is a key sign of permafrost degradation under global warming, dictating ground destabilization and carbon feedback. However, recent field evidence suggests that ground ice may locally accumulate, while the driving mechanisms remain unclear. Leveraging borehole ground ice observations, a physics-based permafrost model, and satellite-based ground deformation data, we identify an anomalous ice increase at the active layer bottom despite climate warming across the interior Tibetan Plateau, occupying 35% of plateau’s permafrost area. Strengthened westerlies have enhanced precipitation, supplying additional soil moisture that refreezes at the active layer bottom and drives this unexpected ice gain. Freeze-thaw process associated with the accumulated ice amplifies ground deformation, destabilizing permafrost landscapes and threatening socioeconomic activities. This anomalous ice gain in permafrost regions, together with the Karakoram anomalous glacier mass increase, represents a divergent cryospheric ice gain against global ice loss under climate warming, highlighting that rapid precipitation increase may locally outweigh temperature in driving cryosphere evolution on the Tibetan Plateau.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Permafrost Experimental Protocol within the Tipping Point Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP)
Within the Tipping Point Modeling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP; www.tipmip.org), we outline a coordinated experimental protocol designed for standalone land surface models (LSMs) as well as coupled Earth System Models (ESMs). The protocol targets key questions on permafrost feedbacks, thresholds, timescales, abrupt versus gradual, and irreversible changes, and interactions with other tipping elements, aiming to quantify plausible landscape transformations, associated greenhouse gas emissions, and their impacts on global energy, carbon, and hydrological cycles, as well as large scale circulation. Building on TIPMIP-ESM, the TIPMIP-permafrost Tier 1 experiments, defined as the core, priority experiments required for MIP participation, aim to use LSMs to quantify the extent to which permafrost area, ground ice volume, and soil carbon stocks exhibit path dependent behavior and reversibility when subjected to idealized warming, stabilization, and subsequent cooling phases. This includes evaluating whether the permafrost returns to its initial state as temperatures decline, or the extent to which certain changes, such as area loss, carbon redistribution, hydrological reorganization, or ground subsidence, persist despite cooling and thus remain effectively irreversible over time scales spanning a century to a several hundred years. In addition, during the stabilization phase we will examine whether permafrost degradation continues even after warming ceases. This involves assessing time lagged thaw response, identifying critical thresholds that may trigger rapid acceleration of degradation, and determining whether internal processes, such as shifts in soil moisture, ground subsidence and thermokarst lake formation, or carbon redistribution, amplify change through self reinforcing feedbacks. The emergence of such behaviors would indicate nonlinear system dynamics and a heightened susceptibility to tipping point transitions.Additional sensitivity experiments (Tier 2), aimed at understanding and quantifying specific processes that could induce permafrost tipping, will apply idealized forcing. The focus is on altering hydrologic conditions and modifying surface properties (e.g., vegetation, albedo, thermokarst lake distribution) to explore how these factors influence the onset and dynamics of tipping behavior.Tier 3 experiments, also sensitivity oriented, investigate the coupling between permafrost dynamics and other climate tipping elements using ESMs, for example, assessing the consequences of an AMOC collapse for high latitude permafrost stability, as well as the broader Earth system impacts of abrupt permafrost tipping.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessPermafrost Experimental Protocol within the Tipping Point Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP)
Within the Tipping Point Modeling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP; www.tipmip.org), we outline a coordinated experimental protocol designed for standalone land surface models (LSMs) as well as coupled Earth System Models (ESMs). The protocol targets key questions on permafrost feedbacks, thresholds, timescales, abrupt versus gradual, and irreversible changes, and interactions with other tipping elements, aiming to quantify plausible landscape transformations, associated greenhouse gas emissions, and their impacts on global energy, carbon, and hydrological cycles, as well as large scale circulation. Building on TIPMIP-ESM, the TIPMIP-permafrost Tier 1 experiments, defined as the core, priority experiments required for MIP participation, aim to use LSMs to quantify the extent to which permafrost area, ground ice volume, and soil carbon stocks exhibit path dependent behavior and reversibility when subjected to idealized warming, stabilization, and subsequent cooling phases. This includes evaluating whether the permafrost returns to its initial state as temperatures decline, or the extent to which certain changes, such as area loss, carbon redistribution, hydrological reorganization, or ground subsidence, persist despite cooling and thus remain effectively irreversible over time scales spanning a century to a several hundred years. In addition, during the stabilization phase we will examine whether permafrost degradation continues even after warming ceases. This involves assessing time lagged thaw response, identifying critical thresholds that may trigger rapid acceleration of degradation, and determining whether internal processes, such as shifts in soil moisture, ground subsidence and thermokarst lake formation, or carbon redistribution, amplify change through self reinforcing feedbacks. The emergence of such behaviors would indicate nonlinear system dynamics and a heightened susceptibility to tipping point transitions.Additional sensitivity experiments (Tier 2), aimed at understanding and quantifying specific processes that could induce permafrost tipping, will apply idealized forcing. The focus is on altering hydrologic conditions and modifying surface properties (e.g., vegetation, albedo, thermokarst lake distribution) to explore how these factors influence the onset and dynamics of tipping behavior.Tier 3 experiments, also sensitivity oriented, investigate the coupling between permafrost dynamics and other climate tipping elements using ESMs, for example, assessing the consequences of an AMOC collapse for high latitude permafrost stability, as well as the broader Earth system impacts of abrupt permafrost tipping.
- Open Access
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Climate of the Past
- Vol. 22 (2) , 377-403
How temperature seasonality drives interglacial permafrost dynamics: implications for paleo reconstructions and future thaw trajectories
Various proxy records have suggested widespread permafrost degradation in northern high latitudes during interglacial warm climates, including the mid Holocene (MH, 6000 years before present) and the last interglacial (LIG, 127 ka BP), and linked this to substantially warmer high-latitude climates compared to the pre-industrial period (PI). However, most Earth system models suggest only modest warming or even slight cooling in terms of annual mean surface temperatures during these interglacials, seemingly contradicting the reconstructions of widespread permafrost degradation. Here, we combine paleo climate simulations of the Alfred Wegener Institute's Earth system model version 2.5 (AWI-ESM-2.5) with the CryoGridLite permafrost model to investigate the ground thermal regime and freeze-thaw dynamics in northern high-latitude land areas during the MH and the LIG in comparison to the PI. Specifically, we decompose how the annual mean and seasonal amplitude (that is, the difference between the maximum and minimum monthly mean) of surface temperatures affect the occurrence of permafrost, seasonal frost, thaw depth and duration, and thermal contraction cracking activity. For the MH (LIG) AWI-ESM-2.5 simulated global-mean surface temperatures in the simulation domain to be about 0.1 K lower (0.4 K higher), and the global-mean seasonal amplitudes to be 2.9 K (7.4 K) higher than for the PI. With respect to interglacial permafrost characteristics, our simulations revealed that (i) local permafrost probabilities and global permafrost extent are predominantly determined by mean temperatures, (ii) maximum thaw depths are increasing with both annual mean and seasonal amplitudes, and (iii) thermal contraction cracking within the permafrost domain is almost solely driven by the seasonal amplitudes of surface temperatures. Thus, not only mean warming, but also the enhanced seasonal temperature amplitude due to a different orbital forcing have driven permafrost and ground ice dynamics during past interglacial climates. Our results provide an additional explanation of reconstructed periods of marked permafrost degradation in the past, which was driven by deep surficial thaw during summer, while colder winters allowed for permafrost persistence in greater depths. Our results further suggest that past interglacial climates have limited suitability as analogues for future permafrost thaw trajectories, as rising mean temperatures paralleled by decreasing seasonal amplitudes expose the northern permafrost region to magnitudes of thaw that are likely unprecedented since at least Marine Isotope Stage 11c (about 400 ka BP).
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Climate of the Past
- Vol. 22 (2) , 377-403
Open AccessHow temperature seasonality drives interglacial permafrost dynamics: implications for paleo reconstructions and future thaw trajectories
Various proxy records have suggested widespread permafrost degradation in northern high latitudes during interglacial warm climates, including the mid Holocene (MH, 6000 years before present) and the last interglacial (LIG, 127 ka BP), and linked this to substantially warmer high-latitude climates compared to the pre-industrial period (PI). However, most Earth system models suggest only modest warming or even slight cooling in terms of annual mean surface temperatures during these interglacials, seemingly contradicting the reconstructions of widespread permafrost degradation. Here, we combine paleo climate simulations of the Alfred Wegener Institute's Earth system model version 2.5 (AWI-ESM-2.5) with the CryoGridLite permafrost model to investigate the ground thermal regime and freeze-thaw dynamics in northern high-latitude land areas during the MH and the LIG in comparison to the PI. Specifically, we decompose how the annual mean and seasonal amplitude (that is, the difference between the maximum and minimum monthly mean) of surface temperatures affect the occurrence of permafrost, seasonal frost, thaw depth and duration, and thermal contraction cracking activity. For the MH (LIG) AWI-ESM-2.5 simulated global-mean surface temperatures in the simulation domain to be about 0.1 K lower (0.4 K higher), and the global-mean seasonal amplitudes to be 2.9 K (7.4 K) higher than for the PI. With respect to interglacial permafrost characteristics, our simulations revealed that (i) local permafrost probabilities and global permafrost extent are predominantly determined by mean temperatures, (ii) maximum thaw depths are increasing with both annual mean and seasonal amplitudes, and (iii) thermal contraction cracking within the permafrost domain is almost solely driven by the seasonal amplitudes of surface temperatures. Thus, not only mean warming, but also the enhanced seasonal temperature amplitude due to a different orbital forcing have driven permafrost and ground ice dynamics during past interglacial climates. Our results provide an additional explanation of reconstructed periods of marked permafrost degradation in the past, which was driven by deep surficial thaw during summer, while colder winters allowed for permafrost persistence in greater depths. Our results further suggest that past interglacial climates have limited suitability as analogues for future permafrost thaw trajectories, as rising mean temperatures paralleled by decreasing seasonal amplitudes expose the northern permafrost region to magnitudes of thaw that are likely unprecedented since at least Marine Isotope Stage 11c (about 400 ka BP).
- Open Access
- 14 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Accelerated destabilization of transportation networks across the Northern Hemisphere by permafrost-infrastructure interactions
Warming-induced permafrost thaw poses a threat to the structural integrity of transportation infrastructure across the northern permafrost region. In turn, the presence of roads and railways disrupts the thermal stability of permafrost ground. Incorporating these bidirectional interactions between permafrost and infrastructure is crucial for credible projections of future thaw risks. Here, we apply a process-based tiling model to quantify permafrost–infrastructure interactions across the Northern Hemisphere, and to project the future likelihood of thaw-induced infrastructure instability under two scenarios (Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) 1-2.6 and SSP5-8.5). Under recent climatic conditions (2000--2023), existing transportation infrastructure induces additional ground warming with mean values of 1.16℃ (roads) and 0.61℃ (railways) compared to the ambient ground. By the end of the century (2081-2100), the likelihood of thaw-induced instability rises by 0.10-0.22 for roads and 0.13-0.23 for railways across both scenarios, jeopardizing 84.3-92.0% of roads (serving 92.8-97.8% of the population) and 94.1-99.6% of railways (serving 98.2-99.9%). Our findings underscore the urgent need for implementing effective adaptation and mitigation measures to maintain infrastructure serviceability and resilience in rapidly warming permafrost environments.
- 14 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessAccelerated destabilization of transportation networks across the Northern Hemisphere by permafrost-infrastructure interactions
Warming-induced permafrost thaw poses a threat to the structural integrity of transportation infrastructure across the northern permafrost region. In turn, the presence of roads and railways disrupts the thermal stability of permafrost ground. Incorporating these bidirectional interactions between permafrost and infrastructure is crucial for credible projections of future thaw risks. Here, we apply a process-based tiling model to quantify permafrost–infrastructure interactions across the Northern Hemisphere, and to project the future likelihood of thaw-induced infrastructure instability under two scenarios (Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) 1-2.6 and SSP5-8.5). Under recent climatic conditions (2000--2023), existing transportation infrastructure induces additional ground warming with mean values of 1.16℃ (roads) and 0.61℃ (railways) compared to the ambient ground. By the end of the century (2081-2100), the likelihood of thaw-induced instability rises by 0.10-0.22 for roads and 0.13-0.23 for railways across both scenarios, jeopardizing 84.3-92.0% of roads (serving 92.8-97.8% of the population) and 94.1-99.6% of railways (serving 98.2-99.9%). Our findings underscore the urgent need for implementing effective adaptation and mitigation measures to maintain infrastructure serviceability and resilience in rapidly warming permafrost environments.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
Comment on egusphere-2025-1899
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- 23 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-1899
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 27 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
Comment on egusphere-2025-1899
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- 27 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-1899
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
The Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP): Assessing tipping point risks in the Earth system
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-52
Open AccessThe Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP): Assessing tipping point risks in the Earth system
The risk of transgressing critical thresholds triggering nonlinear change in the Earth system increases with rising human pressures from greenhouse gas emissions, land-use change and other drivers. Several key components of the Earth System such as the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets, permafrost, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and boreal and tropical forests as well as mountain glaciers, terrestrial hydrological systems and the Sahel region have been suggested to exhibit self-amplifying feedback processes that could lead to non-linear and often abrupt and/or irreversible transitions with far-reaching biophysical and socio-economic consequences. While concerns within the scientific community, general public and among policy- and decision-makers are growing, significant uncertainties remain regarding the critical thresholds, timescales, interactions and impacts of such tipping dynamics. To address these critical knowledge gaps, we here present the Tipping Points Modelling Intercomparison Project (TIPMIP), an international collaborative effort to systematically assess tipping point risks using state-of-the-art coupled Earth System Models and stand-alone domain models, e.g., ice sheet and land system models. Building on the success of established Model Intercomparison Projects (MIPs), TIPMIP aims to standardize model experiments, quantify uncertainty ranges for critical forcing thresholds, and provide a multi-model assessment of tipping dynamics across key Earth system components. TIPMIP will enhance our ability to anticipate and mitigate the risks associated with Earth system tipping points, and support science-based decision-making in the face of high-end impacts and deep uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-35
Reply on RC1
Various proxy records have suggested widespread permafrost degradation in northern high latitudes during interglacial warm climates, including the mid Holocene (MH, 6000 years before present) and the last interglacial (LIG, 127 ka BP), and linked this to substantially warmer high-latitude climates compared to the pre-industrial period (PI). However, most Earth system models suggest only modest warming or even slight cooling in terms of annual mean surface temperatures during these interglacials, seemingly contradicting the reconstructions of widespread permafrost degradation. Here, we combine paleo climate simulations of the Alfred Wegener Institute's Earth system model version 2.5 (AWI-ESM-2.5) with the CryoGridLite permafrost model to investigate the ground thermal regime and freeze-thaw dynamics in northern high-latitude land areas during the MH and the LIG in comparison to the PI. Specifically, we decompose how the annual mean and seasonal amplitude (that is, the difference between the maximum and minimum monthly mean) of surface temperatures affect the occurrence of permafrost, seasonal frost, thaw depths and durations, and thermal contraction cracking activity. Our simulations reveal that (i) local permafrost probabilities and global permafrost extent are predominantly determined by mean surface temperatures, (ii) maximum thaw depths are increasing with both annual mean and seasonal amplitudes, and (iii) thermal contraction cracking within the permafrost domain is almost solely driven by the seasonal amplitude of surface temperatures. Thus, not only mean warming, but also the enhanced seasonal temperature amplitude due to a different orbital forcing have driven permafrost and ground ice dynamics during past interglacial climates. Our results provide an additional explanation of reconstructed periods of marked permafrost degradation in the past, which was driven by deep surficial thaw during summer, while colder winters allowed for permafrost persistence in greater depths. Our results further suggest that past interglacial climates have limited suitability as analogues for future permafrost thaw trajectories, as rising mean temperatures paralleled by decreasing seasonal amplitudes expose the northern permafrost region to magnitudes of thaw that are likely unprecedented since at least Marine Isotope Stage 11c (about 400 ka BP).
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-35
Open AccessReply on RC1
Various proxy records have suggested widespread permafrost degradation in northern high latitudes during interglacial warm climates, including the mid Holocene (MH, 6000 years before present) and the last interglacial (LIG, 127 ka BP), and linked this to substantially warmer high-latitude climates compared to the pre-industrial period (PI). However, most Earth system models suggest only modest warming or even slight cooling in terms of annual mean surface temperatures during these interglacials, seemingly contradicting the reconstructions of widespread permafrost degradation. Here, we combine paleo climate simulations of the Alfred Wegener Institute's Earth system model version 2.5 (AWI-ESM-2.5) with the CryoGridLite permafrost model to investigate the ground thermal regime and freeze-thaw dynamics in northern high-latitude land areas during the MH and the LIG in comparison to the PI. Specifically, we decompose how the annual mean and seasonal amplitude (that is, the difference between the maximum and minimum monthly mean) of surface temperatures affect the occurrence of permafrost, seasonal frost, thaw depths and durations, and thermal contraction cracking activity. Our simulations reveal that (i) local permafrost probabilities and global permafrost extent are predominantly determined by mean surface temperatures, (ii) maximum thaw depths are increasing with both annual mean and seasonal amplitudes, and (iii) thermal contraction cracking within the permafrost domain is almost solely driven by the seasonal amplitude of surface temperatures. Thus, not only mean warming, but also the enhanced seasonal temperature amplitude due to a different orbital forcing have driven permafrost and ground ice dynamics during past interglacial climates. Our results provide an additional explanation of reconstructed periods of marked permafrost degradation in the past, which was driven by deep surficial thaw during summer, while colder winters allowed for permafrost persistence in greater depths. Our results further suggest that past interglacial climates have limited suitability as analogues for future permafrost thaw trajectories, as rising mean temperatures paralleled by decreasing seasonal amplitudes expose the northern permafrost region to magnitudes of thaw that are likely unprecedented since at least Marine Isotope Stage 11c (about 400 ka BP).