BGBrent Goldfarb

Brent Goldfarb

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Brent Goldfarb has a total of 41 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    From hypothesis testing toward inference to the best explanation: A PEEBI testimonial structure for abductive studies in strategy

    by Sandeep Devanatha Pillai, Brent Goldfarb, David A. Kirsch, Seojin Kim, Evan Starr

    Research Summary: Though scholars employ abduction, there is no agreed‐upon structure to reporting their findings. Moreover, the traditional hypo‐deductive reasoning structure does not align with the epistemology of abduction. We propose an abductive testimonial structure, termed PEEBI, which consists of five sections in which the authors take prior knowledge and theories, establish the context and observations that are worthy of interest, identify and evaluate candidate explanations for the observed patterns, determine the best explanation and their reasoning for accepting it, and abstract the best explanation to a more generalizable theoretical contribution. Consistent with abductive epistemology, PEEBI advances knowledge in a modest, stepwise fashion. PEEBI foregrounds transparency and communication of the author's judgment and elevates the role of the readers by giving them information to better make judgments. Managerial Summary: Researchers frequently make discoveries by starting from a surprising observation and reasoning backward to the best explanation. Yet, the field has no shared way to write up this kind of work, and the conventional hypothesis‐testing template does not match how such reasoning unfolds. We propose a reporting structure, PEEBI, which consists of five sections in which the authors take prior knowledge and theories, establish the context and observations that are worthy of interest, identify and evaluate candidate explanations for the observed patterns, determine the best explanation and their reasoning for accepting it, and abstract the best explanation to a more generalizable theoretical contribution. PEEBI makes the author's judgment transparent, giving readers the information they need to weigh the evidence and reach their own conclusions.

  • The Changing Nature of Firm Innovation: Short-Termism and Influential Innovation in U.S. Public Firms

    by Yuan Shi, Rachelle C. Sampson, Brent Goldfarb, Rafael A. Corredoira

    We examine the link between short-term pressures and technologically significant innovation in U.S. public firms in 1997–2015. Using a market-based measure of short-term pressure, we estimate its relationship with influential and novel patents. We find that firms facing more intense short-term pressures are less likely to patent highly influential or novel innovations. To evaluate whether this relationship is causal, we use changes in ownership styles following financial institution mergers as instruments. Our analysis suggests that changing short-term pressures from investors had a causal impact on firm innovative outcomes; this finding is robust to a wide variety of empirical specifications. While public firms as a whole retained a constant share of highly influential patents, this activity has become more concentrated in fewer firms. This shift does not appear to be fully compensated by an increase in technologically significant patents by nonpublic firms such as venture-capital (VC)-backed start-ups. These findings raise questions about capital markets’ impact on firm R&D strategy and the nature of innovative activities in public firms. This paper was accepted by Ashish Arora, entrepreneurship and innovation. Funding: The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the inaugural Panmure House Prize for Long-term Thinking and Radical Innovation for this research, as well as Matt Marx for facilitating institutional support at Cornell for this research. B. Goldfarb and R. Corredoira received partial financial support from the National Science Foundation [Grant 1565553]. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.00857 .


  • Creating Radical Technologies and Competencies: Revisiting Interorganizational Dynamics in the Nascent Bionic Prosthetic Industry

    by Seojin Kim, Rajshree Agarwal, Brent Goldfarb

    Why were incumbents able to pioneer and dominate the nascent bionic prosthetic industry, even though entrants represented the majority of the firms investing in this radical technology? To answer this question, our abductive study builds on the novel base principles definition and uses a historical approach to investigate the incubation and early commercialization periods (1974–2018) of bionic prosthetics. We use comprehensive quantitative data on all technological entrants and historical analysis of significant firms to reveal that organizational prehistory affects both the knowledge and intent of technological entrants. Start-ups, incumbents in conventional prosthetics, and established firms in other industries created and integrated subtechnologies into a radical system. Although all firms invested in component technologies, incumbents played a key role as system integrators. Incumbents dominated product commercialization; start-ups captured value through alliances or by being acquired, and established firms in other industries leveraged their knowledge in adjacent value chains as a function of their prior histories and intents. In comparing the virtues of our explanation—the creating radical systems effects—with widely accepted alternative explanations, we develop a more generalized framework of interorganizational dynamics in nascent industries as an endogenous, coevolutionary process that goes beyond explanations that privilege competitive dynamics to also include collaborative dynamics in value creation (and capture). Funding: This paper was funded by the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets at the University of Maryland, the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation and the Strategic Research Foundation. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.16915 .


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    From perfect to practical: Partial identification methods for causal inference in strategic management research

    by Justin Frake, Anthony Gibbs, Brent Goldfarb, Takuya Hiraiwa, Evan Starr, Shotaro Yamaguchi

    Research Summary: Strategy and management scholars have increasingly used difference‐in‐differences (DD) and instrumental variables (IV) designs to identify causal effects. These methods rely on untestable identifying assumptions to interpret the results as causal. “partial identification” techniques allow researchers to draw causal inferences from imperfect identification strategies by quantifying how results change with the severity of a violation of the identifying assumption. We explain how these tools work in the context of DD and IV designs, provide practical guidance to apply them, and illustrate their use in an empirical example that investigates how first patents affect inventor mobility. In doing so, we emphasize the role of theory, context, and judgment when deciding how strongly to infer a causal relationship from an empirical result. Managerial Summary: Managers seeking to understand the causal effects of their strategic decisions may struggle to do so when their choices cannot be randomized. In such cases, difference‐in‐differences (DD) and instrumental variable (IV) approaches may be a viable estimation strategy. However, these methods still rely on untestable identifying assumptions and it may not be clear how to interpret the results if those identifying assumptions do not hold. In this study, we describe how “partial identification” methods for DD and IV designs allow managers to draw causal inferences even when the identifying assumptions do not hold exactly. We explain how these tools work, provide practical guidance to apply them, and illustrate their use in an empirical example that investigates how first patents affect inventor mobility. In doing so, we emphasize the role of theory, context, and judgment when deciding how strongly to infer a causal relationship from an empirical result.


  • Open Access

    From Hypothesis Testing Towards Inference to Best Explanation: A PEEBI Testimonial Structure for Abductive Studies in Strategy

    by Sandeep Pillai, Brent D. Goldfarb, David Kirsch, Seojin Kim, Evan Starr

    Though scholars employ abduction, there is no agreed-upon structure to reporting their findings. Moreover, the traditional hypo-deductive reasoning structure does not align with the epistemology of abduction. We propose an abductive testimonial structure, termed PEEBI, which consists of five sections in which the authors take prior knowledge and theories, establish the context and observations that are worthy of interest, identify and evaluate candidate explanations for the observed patterns, determine the best explanation and their reasoning for accepting it, and abstract the best explanation to a more generalizable theoretical contribution. Consistent with abductive epistemology, PEEBI advances knowledge in a modest, stepwise fashion. PEEBI foregrounds transparency and communication of the author’s judgment and elevates the role of the readers by giving them information to better make judgments.


  • Top Cited Papers

    Lovely and likely: Using historical methods to improve inference to the best explanation in strategy

    by Sandeep Devanatha Pillai, Brent Goldfarb, David Kirsch

    Research Summary: Many strategy studies implicitly rely upon inference to the best explanation (IBE) or modern abduction. We leverage recent work in the philosophy of science to consider how we arrive at “best” explanations, explanations that are lovely, in the sense that they are useful, general, and provide meaning, and likely, in the sense that they are close to the truth. Interpretation of observational results requires an understanding of context that statistical analysis alone cannot provide. At that point of encounter, historical methods—hermeneutics, contextualization and source criticism—can improve IBE by helping scholars (1) generate new candidate explanations and (2) systematically judge, privilege, and balance the explanatory virtues that constitute the loveliness and likeliness of explanations. Managerial Summary: Many strategy studies iteratively use data and theory to inference to the best explanation of observed phenomena. We leverage recent work in the philosophy of science to consider how we arrive at best explanations that are useful, general, provide meaning, and, at the same time, are close to the truth. Interpreting observational results requires an understanding of the context that statistical analysis alone cannot provide. At that point of encounter, methodological tools from the field of history can improve the process of determining the best explanation by helping scholars (1) generate new candidate explanations and (2) systematically judge and privilege explanations.


  • Open Access

    Lovely and Likely: Using Historical Methods to Improve Inference to the Best Explanation in Strategy

    by Devanatha Sandeep Pillai, Brent D. Goldfarb, David Kirsch

    Many Strategy studies implicitly rely upon Inference to the Best Explanation (IBE) or Modern Abduction. We leverage recent work in the philosophy of science to consider how we arrive at “Best” explanations, explanations that are lovely, in the sense that they are useful, general, and provide meaning, and likely, in the sense that they are close to the truth. Interpretation of observational results requires an understanding of the context that statistical analysis alone cannot provide. At that point of encounter, historical methods -- hermeneutics, contextualization, and source criticism -- can improve IBE by helping scholars (1) generate new candidate explanations and (2) systematically judge, privilege, and balance the explanatory virtues that constitute the loveliness and likeliness of explanations.

  • Student regional origins and student entrepreneurship

    by Jonathan T. Eckhardt, Clint Harris, Chuan Chen, Bekhzod Khoshimov, Brent Goldfarb

    Using data from a large public research university in the United States, we examine the relationship between the characteristics of undergraduate college students’ regional origins and students’ interest in entrepreneurship. We find that several entrepreneurial indicators of students’ regional origins predict students’ entrepreneurial intent and ideation. One possible explanation for our results is that the extent of entrepreneurial activity in a region may imprint attitudes towards entrepreneurial careers on people growing up in those regions. Our findings suggest the composition of admitted students’ geographical origins may impact the entrepreneurial focus of universities’ student bodies.


  • Revisiting Zuckerman's (1999) categorical imperative: An application of epistemic maps for replication

    by Brent Goldfarb, Liyue Yan

    Research Summary: We revisit Zuckerman's (1999) “ The Categorical Imperative: Securities Analysts and the Illegitimacy Discount ,” which theorizes that when organizations are recognized as legitimate players in a category, they perform better. A replication exercise fails to reproduce two of three sets of results. Assisted by data shared by the original author, we find evidence that the inconsistency is due to a coding error in the original and differences between analyst data sets. We illustrate the use of epistemic maps and evaluate the theory's predictive power across a broad set of plausible empirical assumptions and also for a subsequent time period. The results are not robust. We conclude that these data provide little evidence to support strategic recommendations. Challenges and remedies for replication are discussed. Managerial Summary: This paper replicates a 1999 study “ The Categorical Imperative: Securities Analysts and the Illegitimacy Discount ” (Zuckerman, 1999). A key implication of the 1999 study is that firms should actively seek to be covered by analysts who specialize in their industries, and that a failure to be covered by analysts who are industry specialists will lead to lower capital market valuations. Our replication exercise indicates that there is insufficient evidence to recommend actively managing coverage along this dimension.


  • Binned scatterplots: A simple tool to make research easier and better

    by Evan Starr, Brent Goldfarb

    Research Summary: We seek to diffuse a graphical tool—binned scatterplots—which we argue can dramatically improve the quality and speed of research in strategic management. In contrast to the current practice of showing plots of predicted values, binned scatterplots graph the nonparametric relationship between two variables, either unconditionally or conditional on a set of controls, for multiple subgroups. This allows researchers to quickly detect the shape of that relationship, examine outliers, and assess which part of the support may be driving a relationship. We propose that the adoption of binned scatterplots will lead to the identification of new and interesting phenomena, raise the credibility of empirical research, and help create richer theories. Managerial Summary: Regression analysis often assumes linear or quadratic relationship forms between two variables. We seek to diffuse a graphical tool—binned scatterplots—that allow the researcher and reader to evaluate whether such assumptions are maintained throughout the data. For example, binned scatterplots may clarify that a regression relationship is nonlinear, or driven by an exceptional firm or a small set of firms. We propose that using binned scatterplots will improve the transparency and quality of empirical work, as well as aid in the development of new phenomena and enhance theory development.