Conor Duggan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Conor Duggan has a total of 75 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Nick Huband
Institute of Mental Health, Nottingham, UK
6 shared publications- Birgit Völlm
Clinic for Forensic Psychiatry, Rostock University, 18147 Rostock, Germany
4 shared publications Michael Ferriter
4 shared publicationsChristopher Cordess
2 shared publicationsClive Adams
University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
2 shared publicationsEmmet Larkin
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychiatry
- Vol. 17, 1767080
Challenges to court room mental health decision-making in the face of uncertainty
Mental health professionals are frequently faced with the challenge of not only having to make decisions that have far-reaching consequences for the individual being assessed, but having to do so with inevitable degrees of uncertainty. Acknowledging and attempting to quantify this uncertainty ought therefore to be central to such an endeavour but, we argue, it is insufficiently recognised by the professionals involved. Specifically, ‘experts’ who rely on scientific evidence in providing an opinion need to be aware of the challenges of applying such group data to an individual case. In this paper, first, we consider some criticisms of current practice in this respect. Second, we offer a rejoinder that considers the place of tacit knowledge in the clinical practice, the contribution of both Bayesian reasoning and an adapted epidemiological criteria for causal inference, all of which we believe would strengthen the provision of a forensic ‘expert’ opinion, in a courtroom setting.
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychiatry
- Vol. 17, 1767080
Open AccessChallenges to court room mental health decision-making in the face of uncertainty
Mental health professionals are frequently faced with the challenge of not only having to make decisions that have far-reaching consequences for the individual being assessed, but having to do so with inevitable degrees of uncertainty. Acknowledging and attempting to quantify this uncertainty ought therefore to be central to such an endeavour but, we argue, it is insufficiently recognised by the professionals involved. Specifically, ‘experts’ who rely on scientific evidence in providing an opinion need to be aware of the challenges of applying such group data to an individual case. In this paper, first, we consider some criticisms of current practice in this respect. Second, we offer a rejoinder that considers the place of tacit knowledge in the clinical practice, the contribution of both Bayesian reasoning and an adapted epidemiological criteria for causal inference, all of which we believe would strengthen the provision of a forensic ‘expert’ opinion, in a courtroom setting.
- Open Access
- 6 January 2026
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Advances
- Vol. 32 (4) , 257-265
The contribution of interpersonal theory to personality disorder’s diagnosis and treatment
SUMMARY: Despite the recent advances in its diagnosis (heralded by the revisions in ICD-11 and DSM-5) and the introduction of new approaches to treatment, managing personality disorder remains challenging to the psychiatric practitioner. I believe that one of the main reasons for this is that the condition lacks an overall theory that might guide practitioners in their assessment of it and what they might do to intervene. In this article, I suggest that interpersonal theory might be such a candidate, enabling practitioners to manage this condition more effectively. My aim is to provide a brief introduction to this theory in the hope that practitioners might be encouraged to explore its implications more fully.
- 6 January 2026
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Advances
- Vol. 32 (4) , 257-265
Open AccessThe contribution of interpersonal theory to personality disorder’s diagnosis and treatment
SUMMARY: Despite the recent advances in its diagnosis (heralded by the revisions in ICD-11 and DSM-5) and the introduction of new approaches to treatment, managing personality disorder remains challenging to the psychiatric practitioner. I believe that one of the main reasons for this is that the condition lacks an overall theory that might guide practitioners in their assessment of it and what they might do to intervene. In this article, I suggest that interpersonal theory might be such a candidate, enabling practitioners to manage this condition more effectively. My aim is to provide a brief introduction to this theory in the hope that practitioners might be encouraged to explore its implications more fully.
- Open Access
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Open
- Vol. 11 (3) , e84
A systematic environmental intervention, nidotherapy, given to whole communities: protocol for a randomised stepped-wedge trial
Background: Environmental changes can be positive in mental illness. Systematic, planned and guided environmental change in all its aspects is called nidotherapy. It has shown some benefit but has not been extended to whole communities. Aims: A cluster-randomised step-wedge trial is planned in six village communities in Nottinghamshire, England, covering an adult population of 400. Method: Adults in six villages will be offered a full personal environmental assessment followed by agreed change in different 3-month periods over the course of 1 year. All six villages have populations between 51 and 100 residents and are similar demographically. Assessments of mental health, personality status, social function, quality of life and environment satisfaction will be made. After the initial baseline period of 3 months, two villages will be randomised to nidotherapy for 3 months, a further two at 6 months and the last two at 9 months. Results: The primary outcome will be change in social function; secondary outcomes include health-related quality of life, anxiety and depressive symptoms, personality status, costs of nidotherapy and life satisfaction. Adverse events will also be recorded. The analysis will be carried out using a multimodal statistical approach examining (a) the change in scores of the primary outcome (social function); (b) change in scores of all secondary outcomes, including costs; and (c) changes in environmental satisfaction. Conclusions: The findings of this study should help to determine whether nidotherapy has a place in the early detection and treatment of mental pathology.
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Open
- Vol. 11 (3) , e84
Open AccessA systematic environmental intervention, nidotherapy, given to whole communities: protocol for a randomised stepped-wedge trial
Background: Environmental changes can be positive in mental illness. Systematic, planned and guided environmental change in all its aspects is called nidotherapy. It has shown some benefit but has not been extended to whole communities. Aims: A cluster-randomised step-wedge trial is planned in six village communities in Nottinghamshire, England, covering an adult population of 400. Method: Adults in six villages will be offered a full personal environmental assessment followed by agreed change in different 3-month periods over the course of 1 year. All six villages have populations between 51 and 100 residents and are similar demographically. Assessments of mental health, personality status, social function, quality of life and environment satisfaction will be made. After the initial baseline period of 3 months, two villages will be randomised to nidotherapy for 3 months, a further two at 6 months and the last two at 9 months. Results: The primary outcome will be change in social function; secondary outcomes include health-related quality of life, anxiety and depressive symptoms, personality status, costs of nidotherapy and life satisfaction. Adverse events will also be recorded. The analysis will be carried out using a multimodal statistical approach examining (a) the change in scores of the primary outcome (social function); (b) change in scores of all secondary outcomes, including costs; and (c) changes in environmental satisfaction. Conclusions: The findings of this study should help to determine whether nidotherapy has a place in the early detection and treatment of mental pathology.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 30 (1) , 38-49
A comparison of long‐term medium secure patients within NHS and private and charitable sector units in England
Background: In England, forensic psychiatric hospital services are provided at three security levels: high, medium and low. All are publicly funded and similarly regulated, but medium and low secure services are provided in the private and charitable (PCS) sector as well as the National Health Service (NHS). Originally, medium secure hospital services were conceived as for up to 2 years' inpatient stay, but numbers of longer stay patients have been rising. Little is known about their characteristics or whether they differ between NHS and PCS settings.Aims: To describe and compare characteristics of long‐stay patients in NHS and in PCS medium security hospital units.Methods: Data were extracted from clinical records in 14 NHS and 9 PCS hospital units for all patients fulfilling criteria for long stay: having been in high security for more than 10 years or medium security for more than 5 years or in a mix of both for more than 15 years in total.Results: 178 NHS and 107 PCS patients were eligible for inclusion, respectively, 16 and 22% of the total patient populations in these settings. The mean length of stay in a medium or high secure setting was similar: 163 and 164 months. Characteristics of the patients, however, differed between unit type. NHS services admitted more patients from prison and PCS services more from other hospitals. NHS services included a lower proportion of patients with personality disorder or intellectual disability. 'Challenging behaviour' was more prevalent in PCS; a history of absconding was found more often among NHS patients.Conclusions: The two systems of service appear to be used differently. More research is needed to explain why patients apparently without behavioural disturbances remain in specialist secure facilities for such a long time and whether their needs are truly being met in the least restrictive environment possible.
- 1 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 30 (1) , 38-49
Open AccessA comparison of long‐term medium secure patients within NHS and private and charitable sector units in England
Background: In England, forensic psychiatric hospital services are provided at three security levels: high, medium and low. All are publicly funded and similarly regulated, but medium and low secure services are provided in the private and charitable (PCS) sector as well as the National Health Service (NHS). Originally, medium secure hospital services were conceived as for up to 2 years' inpatient stay, but numbers of longer stay patients have been rising. Little is known about their characteristics or whether they differ between NHS and PCS settings.Aims: To describe and compare characteristics of long‐stay patients in NHS and in PCS medium security hospital units.Methods: Data were extracted from clinical records in 14 NHS and 9 PCS hospital units for all patients fulfilling criteria for long stay: having been in high security for more than 10 years or medium security for more than 5 years or in a mix of both for more than 15 years in total.Results: 178 NHS and 107 PCS patients were eligible for inclusion, respectively, 16 and 22% of the total patient populations in these settings. The mean length of stay in a medium or high secure setting was similar: 163 and 164 months. Characteristics of the patients, however, differed between unit type. NHS services admitted more patients from prison and PCS services more from other hospitals. NHS services included a lower proportion of patients with personality disorder or intellectual disability. 'Challenging behaviour' was more prevalent in PCS; a history of absconding was found more often among NHS patients.Conclusions: The two systems of service appear to be used differently. More research is needed to explain why patients apparently without behavioural disturbances remain in specialist secure facilities for such a long time and whether their needs are truly being met in the least restrictive environment possible.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 29 (4) , 189-195
Looking from the outside: No substitute for rigorous evaluation
Looking in from the outside, what would the ordinary person expect of forensic mental health services? I suggest that there are three questions he or she would ask: (a) Are there public health measures that can be introduced to prevent those with mental disorder going on to commit crimes? (b) Can we identify in advance the individual who is likely to go on and commit a violent act because of his or her mental health difficulties, and prevent that or limit damage? (c) If a seriously harmful act has already been committed, what interventions might prevent a repetition? All of these questions are about prevention of an untoward event in the future and anticipate knowledge. How secure can we be that current forensic mental health practitioners can make adequately evidenced responses? I fear that examination of current literature would indicate that they and their academic colleagues would fall short of these expectations. Reasons for this are undoubtedly numerous. The issues are complex, with the interplay of many variables from the vagaries of human nature through varying presentations of disorders, still often classified rather than diagnosed, to widely differing environments which, further, may suddenly change in a critical way. The impact of a serious offence can be so catastrophic that officialdom often decides that “something must be done.” Yet, without a good evidence base, such decision‐making is often ineffective and wasteful of resources. The limited evidence base has not been helped by the virtual extinction of an academic forensic psychiatry infrastructure and funding within British universities and the National Health Service. This does not bode well for the future.
- 1 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 29 (4) , 189-195
Open AccessLooking from the outside: No substitute for rigorous evaluation
Looking in from the outside, what would the ordinary person expect of forensic mental health services? I suggest that there are three questions he or she would ask: (a) Are there public health measures that can be introduced to prevent those with mental disorder going on to commit crimes? (b) Can we identify in advance the individual who is likely to go on and commit a violent act because of his or her mental health difficulties, and prevent that or limit damage? (c) If a seriously harmful act has already been committed, what interventions might prevent a repetition? All of these questions are about prevention of an untoward event in the future and anticipate knowledge. How secure can we be that current forensic mental health practitioners can make adequately evidenced responses? I fear that examination of current literature would indicate that they and their academic colleagues would fall short of these expectations. Reasons for this are undoubtedly numerous. The issues are complex, with the interplay of many variables from the vagaries of human nature through varying presentations of disorders, still often classified rather than diagnosed, to widely differing environments which, further, may suddenly change in a critical way. The impact of a serious offence can be so catastrophic that officialdom often decides that “something must be done.” Yet, without a good evidence base, such decision‐making is often ineffective and wasteful of resources. The limited evidence base has not been helped by the virtual extinction of an academic forensic psychiatry infrastructure and funding within British universities and the National Health Service. This does not bode well for the future.
- 8 February 2017
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 27 (1) , 1-7
Managing uncertainty in the clinical prediction of risk of harm: Bringing a Bayesian approach to forensic mental health
Predicting the likelihood of harm posed by mentally disordered offenders remains controversial. It is proposed that a Bayesian approach may help quantify the uncertainty surrounding such prediction. An example of this approach quantifying the risk of breast cancer in the event of a positive mammogram is provided. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 8 February 2017
- Published by Wiley in Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health
- Vol. 27 (1) , 1-7
Managing uncertainty in the clinical prediction of risk of harm: Bringing a Bayesian approach to forensic mental health
Predicting the likelihood of harm posed by mentally disordered offenders remains controversial. It is proposed that a Bayesian approach may help quantify the uncertainty surrounding such prediction. An example of this approach quantifying the risk of breast cancer in the event of a positive mammogram is provided. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 3 February 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Homicide Studies
- Vol. 20 (1) , 80-97
The Characteristics and Course After Discharge of Mentally Disordered Homicide and Non-Homicide Offenders
The aim of this article was to compare the characteristics and outcome of homicide and non-homicide mentally disordered patients all of whom had been hospitalised. Seventy-four patients with a homicide conviction were compared with 521 convicted of a non-homicide offense. The former group were older, were more likely to be diagnosed with schizophrenia but less likely to have suffered from childhood adversity, and had less criminality. They also had fewer convictions during the follow-up. Little distinguished these two groups with both suffering from multiple disadvantages suggesting the need for ongoing care and support.
- 3 February 2015
- Published by SAGE Publications in Homicide Studies
- Vol. 20 (1) , 80-97
The Characteristics and Course After Discharge of Mentally Disordered Homicide and Non-Homicide Offenders
The aim of this article was to compare the characteristics and outcome of homicide and non-homicide mentally disordered patients all of whom had been hospitalised. Seventy-four patients with a homicide conviction were compared with 521 convicted of a non-homicide offense. The former group were older, were more likely to be diagnosed with schizophrenia but less likely to have suffered from childhood adversity, and had less criminality. They also had fewer convictions during the follow-up. Little distinguished these two groups with both suffering from multiple disadvantages suggesting the need for ongoing care and support.
- 23 January 2015
- Published by Wiley in Personality and Mental Health
- Vol. 9 (2) , 107-123
Development and validation of a treatment progress scale for personality disordered offenders
Background There is a need for a measure to evaluate change in treatment for offenders with a personality disorder, and the Progress Rating Scale (PRS) was developed to meet this need taking account of multiprofessional input. Method The PRS comprises six process and five non‐process items developed via thematic analysis of routine CPA patient treatment reports at a forensic Personality Disorder Service. Rating for items was fully standardized and operationalized with revisions aiming to maximize inter‐rater agreement reflecting good face and content validity. Psychometric properties were examined using PRS ratings for 147 patients at three different time points in conjunction with relevant psychometrics. Results Following refinement, the instrument demonstrated good content validity. Intra‐class correlations suggested moderate to substantial inter‐rater agreement (intraclass correlations: 0.63–0.92). Item analyses indicated good internal consistency for process items (Cronbach's alpha: 0.82–0.88). Correlations with relevant psychometrics revealed meaningful relationships between PRS scores, defence styles and social problem solving. PRS score trajectories were in line with previously known treatment outcomes supporting predictive validity. Conclusion The PRS shows promise as process measure in clinical settings but requires further testing on other samples to confirm initial findings and demonstrate its utility. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 23 January 2015
- Published by Wiley in Personality and Mental Health
- Vol. 9 (2) , 107-123
Development and validation of a treatment progress scale for personality disordered offenders
Background There is a need for a measure to evaluate change in treatment for offenders with a personality disorder, and the Progress Rating Scale (PRS) was developed to meet this need taking account of multiprofessional input. Method The PRS comprises six process and five non‐process items developed via thematic analysis of routine CPA patient treatment reports at a forensic Personality Disorder Service. Rating for items was fully standardized and operationalized with revisions aiming to maximize inter‐rater agreement reflecting good face and content validity. Psychometric properties were examined using PRS ratings for 147 patients at three different time points in conjunction with relevant psychometrics. Results Following refinement, the instrument demonstrated good content validity. Intra‐class correlations suggested moderate to substantial inter‐rater agreement (intraclass correlations: 0.63–0.92). Item analyses indicated good internal consistency for process items (Cronbach's alpha: 0.82–0.88). Correlations with relevant psychometrics revealed meaningful relationships between PRS scores, defence styles and social problem solving. PRS score trajectories were in line with previously known treatment outcomes supporting predictive validity. Conclusion The PRS shows promise as process measure in clinical settings but requires further testing on other samples to confirm initial findings and demonstrate its utility. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2014
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-9
The recording of adverse events from psychological treatments in clinical trials: evidence from a review of NIHR-funded trials
There is a concern in the literature that harm from interventions is insufficiently documented in clinical trials in general, and in those assessing psychological treatments in particular. A recent decision by a trial steering committee to stop recruitment into a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of a psychological intervention for personality disorder led to an investigation of the recording of harm in trials funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR). The protocols and final reports of all 82 NIHR trials funded between 1995 and 2013 were examined for the reporting of adverse events. These were subdivided by category of intervention. None of the psychological intervention trials mentioned the occurrence of an adverse event in their final report. Trials of drug treatments were more likely to mention adverse events in their protocols compared with those using psychological treatments. When adverse events were mentioned, the protocols of psychological interventions relied heavily on severe adverse events guidelines from the National Research Ethics Service (NRES), which were developed for drug rather than psychological interventions and so may not be appropriate for the latter. This survey supported the belief that the reporting of adverse events in psychological treatments is weak and the criteria used may not be appropriate. Recommendations are made as to how current practice might be improved.
- 27 August 2014
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-9
Open AccessThe recording of adverse events from psychological treatments in clinical trials: evidence from a review of NIHR-funded trials
There is a concern in the literature that harm from interventions is insufficiently documented in clinical trials in general, and in those assessing psychological treatments in particular. A recent decision by a trial steering committee to stop recruitment into a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of a psychological intervention for personality disorder led to an investigation of the recording of harm in trials funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR). The protocols and final reports of all 82 NIHR trials funded between 1995 and 2013 were examined for the reporting of adverse events. These were subdivided by category of intervention. None of the psychological intervention trials mentioned the occurrence of an adverse event in their final report. Trials of drug treatments were more likely to mention adverse events in their protocols compared with those using psychological treatments. When adverse events were mentioned, the protocols of psychological interventions relied heavily on severe adverse events guidelines from the National Research Ethics Service (NRES), which were developed for drug rather than psychological interventions and so may not be appropriate for the latter. This survey supported the belief that the reporting of adverse events in psychological treatments is weak and the criteria used may not be appropriate. Recommendations are made as to how current practice might be improved.
- 21 July 2014
- Published by Wiley in Personality and Mental Health
- Vol. 8 (3) , 238-249
Defence styles in a sample of forensic patients with personality disorder
Background Ego defences, often considered central to clinical work, have received surprisingly little attention in the forensic literature. Method In this exploratory study, 114 male inpatients completed the Defence Style Questionnaire (DSQ) following their admission to a specialist personality disorder (PD) service. Change in DSQ scores over time was examined using mixed effects models for those (n = 48) remaining in treatment for at least 18 months. Results Defensive functioning at baseline was less mature in comparison with non-clinical norms, with two other non-forensic PD samples, and with a male paedophile sample, but was unrelated to criminal history. Axis II severity was negatively associated with overall defensive functioning (ODF). Antisocial PD was positively associated with a maladaptive defence style. Borderline PD was negatively associated with self-sacrificing defences. Avoidant PD was negatively associated with both self-sacrificing and adaptive styles. Non-completion of treatment was predicted by low ODF scores and high maladaptive defence style scores at baseline. ODF improved significantly over time in treatment and was predicted by strong antisocial and weak schizotypal PD pathologies. Conclusions Defence style, as measured by the DSQ, appears to have the potential to inform assessment and measure change in this group of offenders. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 21 July 2014
- Published by Wiley in Personality and Mental Health
- Vol. 8 (3) , 238-249
Defence styles in a sample of forensic patients with personality disorder
Background Ego defences, often considered central to clinical work, have received surprisingly little attention in the forensic literature. Method In this exploratory study, 114 male inpatients completed the Defence Style Questionnaire (DSQ) following their admission to a specialist personality disorder (PD) service. Change in DSQ scores over time was examined using mixed effects models for those (n = 48) remaining in treatment for at least 18 months. Results Defensive functioning at baseline was less mature in comparison with non-clinical norms, with two other non-forensic PD samples, and with a male paedophile sample, but was unrelated to criminal history. Axis II severity was negatively associated with overall defensive functioning (ODF). Antisocial PD was positively associated with a maladaptive defence style. Borderline PD was negatively associated with self-sacrificing defences. Avoidant PD was negatively associated with both self-sacrificing and adaptive styles. Non-completion of treatment was predicted by low ODF scores and high maladaptive defence style scores at baseline. ODF improved significantly over time in treatment and was predicted by strong antisocial and weak schizotypal PD pathologies. Conclusions Defence style, as measured by the DSQ, appears to have the potential to inform assessment and measure change in this group of offenders. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.