ISIsabel M. Smallegange

Isabel M. Smallegange

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Isabel M. Smallegange has a total of 96 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Nutritional Stress Modulates Developmental Thresholds in a Male Dimorphic Mite

    by Isabel M. Smallegange

    Global warming can affect arthropods not only through direct thermal stress but also by altering nutritional conditions that shape development. For condition‐dependent alternative phenotypes, such environmental effects may change phenotype expression by shifting the distribution of individual condition, or by altering the developmental threshold at which individuals switch between phenotypes. I tested these alternatives in the bulb mite Rhizoglyphus robini , in which males develop into either fighters or scramblers depending on body size at a critical juvenile stage. Using isofemale lines reared on high‐quality yeast or low‐quality oats, I quantified male morph expression across body sizes and estimated diet‐specific switch points. Fighter expression was strongly condition‐dependent, with larger juveniles more likely to develop into fighters. However, the nutritional environment affected morph expression even after accounting for body size: males reared on oats were more likely to become fighters than same‐sized males reared on yeast. The size‐dependent relationship between body size and morph expression did not differ between diets, but the threshold for fighter expression shifted, with higher thresholds in yeast than in oats. The magnitude of this threshold shift also varied among isofemale lines. These results show that nutritional conditions influence morph expression not only by changing body size, but also by modifying the developmental threshold and its responsiveness across genetic backgrounds. Developmental thresholds may therefore represent environmentally responsive decision points through which arthropods buffer stress and generate variation relevant to adaptation under climate change.

  • Open Access

    From traits to trajectories: development, agency and a phenotypic gap in demography

    by Isabel M. Smallegange

    Demography links ecology and evolution by connecting population dynamics with variation in fitness and selection. Yet, most demographic models represent phenotypes as fixed traits and environments as static backdrops, overlooking the developmental processes through which phenotypes are constructed. This creates a phenotypic gap in demographic theory: a disconnect between how phenotypes arise through development and how they are represented in demographic models. A development-centric perspective can address this gap by incorporating agency—the capacity of organisms to regulate development, reallocate energy, and modify their environments through feedback—into demographic thinking. State-of-the-art demographic models, including Integral Projection Models (IPMs) and Dynamic Energy Budget (DEB) IPMs, capture phenotypic outcomes and aspects of physiological development, but they do not explicitly represent how agential, feedback-driven developmental processes shape phenotypes and selection. I argue that progress can be made by integrating DEB-based, individual-based models with agent-based and decision-theoretic approaches, such as Markov decision processes, which represent organisms as active developmental systems embedded in feedback-rich environments. Coupling these approaches with evolutionary tools from quantitative and population genetics would yield a unified, development-centric demography. Using examples of context-sensitive developmental trajectories and intraspecific phenotypic diversification, I show how development-centric approaches reveal how energy allocation, developmental plasticity, and feedback shape phenotypic variation and demographic dynamics. A development-centric demography reframes population dynamics as a science of self-directed change and provides a stronger foundation for understanding eco-evolutionary feedback and forecasting population resilience under environmental change.


  • Open Access

    From form to function: Morphology as a proxy for life history and population performance in fish

    by Victoria Dixon, Isabel M. Smallegange

    Life history strategies emerge from trade-offs between growth, survival and reproduction and are key predictors of how populations respond to environmental disturbances. However, estimating these strategies typically requires detailed demographic data, which are unavailable for many species. Because morphological traits govern whole-organism performance, selection on ecological performance can link morphology with life history strategies. Morphological traits can thus be practical proxies for life history strategies, offering a scalable approach for data-deficient populations. To test the hypothesis that morphological traits predict major life-history axes—and, by extension, population performance and resilience—via shared performance trade-offs, we parameterised dynamic energy budget integral projection models for 290 marine and freshwater fish species to quantify life history strategies and measured eight morphological traits from lateral-view photographs for each species. We used phylogenetically corrected principal component analysis to summarise life history strategies and morphological traits, and tested whether morphology predicts life history strategies, and whether either predicts population growth rate or demographic resilience. Lateral size morphology, comprising body elongation, relative eye size and oral gape position predicted generation turnover depending on water column position, and predicted reproductive output depending on clade. Generation turnover, reproductive output and lateral size morphology predicted population growth rate and resilience, but population growth rate and resilience were not directly aligned, challenging common assumptions in fisheries management that treat them as interchangeable. Our results support the hypothesis that morphologies linked to ecological performance scale up to shape demographic strategies, providing proof of concept that morphology can predict life-history strategies. They also highlight the potential to develop performance-based trait proxies for rapid, low-cost estimations of demographic vulnerability and recovery potential across data-poor fish populations—expanding the scope of life-history frameworks for fisheries management and conservation under increasing pressures from overfishing, habitat loss and climate change.

  • Open Access

    Linking the causes and consequences of phenotypic plasticity

    by Isabel M. Smallegange, Natalie Pilakouta

    Phenotypic plasticity is a foundational concept in ecology and evolution, yet its definitions and applications vary widely across disciplines. In this Special Feature, we synthesise contributions that link the causes and consequences of plasticity across biological scales, taxa and environmental contexts. Topics include methodological advances for quantifying plasticity, the role of trait coordination in shaping plastic responses and the developmental mechanisms underlying anticipatory and mitigating plasticity. Several papers examine transgenerational effects and the distinction between developmental plasticity and phenotypic flexibility. Collectively, these studies highlight the need for integrative frameworks that connect ecological, developmental and evolutionary processes. We conclude by identifying three key themes that emerge across the Special Feature: (1) integrative frameworks that connect ecological, developmental and evolutionary processes; (2) developmental mechanisms such as anticipatory and mitigating plasticity, epigenetic regulation and heterokairy; and (3) trait coordination, highlighting how integrated traits constrain or facilitate plastic responses. These themes can be addressed in plasticity research through cross‐disciplinary collaboration, comparative studies and experimental designs that disentangle generative and selective processes. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.


  • Open Access

    Changing Feeding Levels Reveal Plasticity in Elasmobranch Life History Strategies

    by Sol Lucas, Per Berggren, Ellen Barrowclift, Isabel M. Smallegange

    Life history strategies are shaped by phylogeny, environmental conditions and individual energy budgets, and have implications for conservation biology. We summarised life history traits of 151 elasmobranch species into life history strategies for two contrasting feeding levels, representing two different environments, in a principal components analysis. Two axes, reproductive output and generation turnover, structure elasmobranch life history strategies. Species' positions in this life history space were not fixed but shifted to higher reproductive output when feeding level increased. We also found that both axes predicted population performance, but that population growth rate does not necessarily inform on a species' demographic resilience. Finally, neither axis predicted IUCN conservation status. Our analyses reveal plasticity in species life history strategies and warn against extrapolating the life history strategy framework from one environment to another when predicting a species' response to (climate) change, perturbations, and (over)exploitation.


  • Open Access

    Population Performance and Resilience in Polychaetes as Environmental Indicators of Estuarine Ecosystems

    by Isabel M. Smallegange, Lukas H.A. Edwards, Amy Attle

    Understanding how estuarine populations respond to environmental changes is crucial for estuarine ecosystem management. Life history theory, particularly the fast-slow and parity continuums, offers a framework to predict population performance and resilience. However, applying these continuums to estuarine, environmental indicator species like spionida polychaetes remain underexplored. We investigated the applicability of the fast-slow and parity continuums as trait-based indicators of performance and resilience in seven estuarine polychaete species (Axiothella serrata, Boccardia proboscidea, Dimorphilus gyrociliatus—formerly Dinophilus gyrociliatus, Ophryotrocha labronica, Polydora cornuta, Pygospio elegans, and Streblospio benedicti). Using a Dynamic Energy Budget Integral Projection Model (DEB-IPM), we quantified eight life history traits across different feeding levels, reflecting environmental quality. Principal component analysis revealed that life history variation in polychaetes can be decomposed into two primary continuums: adult performance and growth. Species with higher adult performance exhibited increased population growth rates, while resilience was influenced by the interaction between adult performance and growth. Interestingly, these two continuums identified in estuarine polychaetes diverge from the traditionally recognised fast-slow and parity continuums. This divergence is likely because, in our framework, life history variation was driven by differences in environmental quality rather than resource allocation as in the fast-slow parity framework. Since polychaete presence and abundance are often used as indicators of environmental quality, our approach can therefore enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of environmental assessments for estuarine ecosystems. More generally, these findings highlight the importance of considering context-specific continuums and mechanistic models in life history analyses to better predict population responses to environmental changes.


  • Open Access

    To What Extent Can Life History Strategies Inform Reptile Conservation Planning?

    by Emily A. Stevenson, Sol Lucas, Philip J. K. McGowan, Isabel M. Smallegange, Louise Mair

    Global policy aims to prevent species extinctions; to support these aims, conservation planners must effectively target interventions to reduce the extinction risk of species. However, there is often a lack of knowledge on the magnitude and direction of species responses to interventions and, in turn, the extent to which a species extinction risk is reduced. If we can use a species' life history strategies to predict their responses to interventions, this offers a promising approach to better understand species extinction risks and conservation potential. Here we apply Dynamic Energy Budget Integral Projection Models to 23 reptile species to investigate whether their derived life history traits can be summarised into a life history strategy framework using principal component analysis, and whether species' positions along these axes predict their population growth rate, demographic resilience, sensitivity to perturbations and extinction risk. We found that species' positions on reproductive and pace of life axes predicted reptile population growth rate and demographic resilience but not sensitivity to perturbations or extinction risk. Our findings show that reptile life history strategies can inform our understanding of reptile species conservation potential and could be applied to influence management decisions such as establishing monitoring timelines.


  • Open Access

    The role of developmental plasticity in eco‐phenotypic population dynamics

    by Lukas H. A. Edwards, Isabel M. Smallegange

    Individual variation in development can strongly impact population density via its impact on demography. When this variation in development is caused by developmental plasticity, the resulting effects on population density are characterised as ‘eco‐phenotypic dynamics’ If plasticity in turn is sensitive to variation in population density, ‘eco‐phenotypic feedbacks’ can arise. When individual development is density‐dependent due to resource limitation, we expect eco‐phenotypic feedbacks between development rate and population density to be widespread. Yet, exactly how plasticity in development rates, termed ‘heterokairy’ interacts with population density to influence eco‐phenotypic dynamics is unclear. Here, we provide conceptual and empirical starting points to assess the role of heterokairy in eco‐phenotypic population dynamics. We present a conceptual framework to identify how heterokairy impacts, and is impacted by, population density. This framework is validated using existing empirical evidence, focusing on polyphenisms that comprise alternate phenotypes that differ in development rate: ‘heterokairic polyphenisms’. We find that heterokairic polyphenisms typically comprise fast developing (‘minor’) and slow developing (‘major’) phenotypes that are prevalent among ectotherms. How heterokairy shapes eco‐phenotypic feedbacks depends on whether minors (or majors) are mostly expressed at low (or high) density, or vice versa. Minor‐at‐low‐density systems, such as those found in salamanders, aphids and nematodes, reflect classic life history predictions that growing, low density, populations favour short development times, whilst high‐density populations favour slower development. Alternatively, minor‐at‐high‐density systems allow resource‐stressed juveniles, most common at high‐densities, to still mature but as minors by reducing developmental and metabolic costs. We propose such opposing responses to density can prompt different eco‐phenotypic dynamics and feedbacks. Our work highlights the crucial role that development plays in phenotype construction, and the consequences it can have for (meta)population dynamics and phenotype evolution. We call for a shift away from a focus on developmental outcomes in adulthood to the developmental processes that construct phenotypes. Ultimately, this can lead to a more mechanistic, and thus predictive, approach to understanding the adaptive role of alternative paces of development within ecological and evolutionary contexts. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.


  • Open Access

    Developmental Plasticity and the Evolutionary Rescue of a Colonizing Mite

    by Kathryn A. Stewart, Isabel M. Smallegange

    Plasticity, especially in small newly founded populations, can expose genetic variation to selection during the evolutionary rescue of populations, allowing individuals to achieve a phenotype with which they can survive. However, developmental plasticity can also enable organisms to accommodate perturbations, generating new phenotypic variation. We explored whether, at the start of a colonization event, phenotype dynamics follow a “selective” process in which plasticity fuels evolutionary rescue or whether they are due to developmental plasticity in a “generative” process. We investigated this using the bulb mite Rhizoglyphus robini, which expresses a facultative, juvenile dispersal phenotype (deutonymph) under unfavorable conditions and shows alternative adult male phenotypes: competitive fighters or benign scramblers that are expressed to mitigate food stress and which have higher levels of genetic heterozygosity than fighters. Mimicking colonization dynamics, we founded small, medium and large populations from deutonymphs on low or high food to test if scramblers were expressed earliest postcolonization within (i) the smallest founder populations to alleviate inbreeding (selective hypothesis), or (ii) the largest founder populations as a direct consequence of food stress is highest due to higher food competition (generative hypothesis). In line with the generative hypothesis under both food environments, scramblers were expressed at the earliest in the largest founder populations, which also tended to show the lowest growth at the start of the experiment and had the lowest ultimate population size. Our findings highlight the necessity to seek explanations of how developmental pathways likely influence evolutionary rescue patterns, starting with how resource limitation (stress) shapes adaptive responses during colonization.


  • Open Access

    A development-centric perspective on pace-of-life syndromes

    by Isabel M Smallegange, Anja Guenther

    Organism responses to environmental change require coordinated changes across correlated traits, so-called syndromes. For example, animals differ in their “pace-of-life syndrome” (POLS); suites of correlated life-history, behavioral and physiological traits. But standard “gene-centric” evolutionary theory cannot explain why POLSs exist because it assumes that the expression of phenotypic traits of animals is determined by genotype-specified reaction norms; it ignores that developmental processes can bias the direction of evolution so that phenotypes no longer match genotype-by-environment interactions. Here we apply a development-centric perspective to derive new POLS hypotheses that can resolve the conflict that current POLS predictions fail to explain which species/populations are resilient to environmental change.