Kimberly M. Carlson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Recognitions
Kimberly M. Carlson has a total of 316 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Robert Heilmayr
University of California, Santa Barbara
10 shared publications - Paul C. West
Department of Applied Economics, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN, USA
6 shared publications - Gregory P. Asner
Center for Global Discovery and Conservation Science Arizona State University Hilo HI USA
5 shared publications - James S. Gerber
Institute on the Environment, University of Minnesota, Saint Paul, USA
5 shared publications - Rachael D. Garrett
Department of Geography and Conservation Research Institute, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
5 shared publications - David L. A. Gaveau
The TreeMap, France
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 July 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (29)
Zero-deforestation commitments in Indonesia's palm oil sector achieve high compliance but no additionality.
In response to public pressure, companies have increasingly adopted voluntary sustainable sourcing commitments. Yet, it often remains unclear whether such commitments lead only to the narrow goal of supplier compliance, or also to the broader goal of additionality, benefits beyond what would have occurred without commitments. A company's ability to influence its suppliers' behavior partly depends on the complexity of supply chains, yet data on supply chain linkages are limited, inhibiting causal evaluations. Here, we evaluate the compliance and additionality of zero-deforestation commitments (ZDCs) in the Indonesian palm oil sector, a major driver of tropical deforestation. We compiled a detailed dataset that integrates information about corporate ZDC implementation, supply chain linkages, and maps of palm-driven deforestation in Indonesia. We use this dataset to evaluate the causal impact of ZDCs on deforestation in oil palm concessions from 2018 to 2020 using difference-in-differences econometric methods. We find that concessions linked to companies with ZDCs had low deforestation (<1% per year from 2018 to 2020) and thus largely achieved compliance. Yet they experienced similar reductions in deforestation compared to concessions not covered by ZDCs, therefore showing no additionality. We attribute our finding of no additionality to broader changes in policy and economic conditions during the study period that may have reduced the remaining accessible forest and dampened market and regulatory incentives to clear forests for palm oil. Should these conditions change in the future, continued compliance with ZDCs could yield additional reductions in deforestation.
- 13 July 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (29)
Open AccessZero-deforestation commitments in Indonesia's palm oil sector achieve high compliance but no additionality.
In response to public pressure, companies have increasingly adopted voluntary sustainable sourcing commitments. Yet, it often remains unclear whether such commitments lead only to the narrow goal of supplier compliance, or also to the broader goal of additionality, benefits beyond what would have occurred without commitments. A company's ability to influence its suppliers' behavior partly depends on the complexity of supply chains, yet data on supply chain linkages are limited, inhibiting causal evaluations. Here, we evaluate the compliance and additionality of zero-deforestation commitments (ZDCs) in the Indonesian palm oil sector, a major driver of tropical deforestation. We compiled a detailed dataset that integrates information about corporate ZDC implementation, supply chain linkages, and maps of palm-driven deforestation in Indonesia. We use this dataset to evaluate the causal impact of ZDCs on deforestation in oil palm concessions from 2018 to 2020 using difference-in-differences econometric methods. We find that concessions linked to companies with ZDCs had low deforestation (<1% per year from 2018 to 2020) and thus largely achieved compliance. Yet they experienced similar reductions in deforestation compared to concessions not covered by ZDCs, therefore showing no additionality. We attribute our finding of no additionality to broader changes in policy and economic conditions during the study period that may have reduced the remaining accessible forest and dampened market and regulatory incentives to clear forests for palm oil. Should these conditions change in the future, continued compliance with ZDCs could yield additional reductions in deforestation.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (12) , 124019
Institutional dimensions of remote sensing capacity for tropical forest monitoring
Remote sensing technologies are central to tropical forest monitoring, yet the institutional mechanisms constraining their adoption and operationalization within responsible organizations remain poorly understood. Drawing on thirty-eight semi-structured interviews with actors across the remote sensing value chain in Latin America, Africa, and Southeast Asia, we examine how institutional arrangements shape remote sensing capacity within organizations directly engaged in tropical forest monitoring and management. We distinguish between operational frictions, the practical obstacles practitioners encounter in day-to-day remote sensing work, and the institutional conditions that generate and sustain them, organized across four capacity dimensions: dependable data access, technical expertise, organizational support and mandate clarity, and equitable user-provider relations. Our findings show that capacity constraints are not primarily technical but institutional: external data ownership and governance structures, organizational instability, weak mandates, and asymmetric power within the remote sensing value chain interact and compound to undermine capacity even where technical resources are nominally available. These dynamics are especially pronounced for subnational governments, Indigenous organizations, and civil society actors at the periphery of the value chain, who face severe barriers and are frequently on the frontlines of deforestation. Our results suggest that capacity building efforts are more likely to yield durable results when they engage directly with the institutional contexts in which remote sensing is embedded, rather than focusing primarily on individual frictions, such as data access or technical skill development.
- 18 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (12) , 124019
Open AccessInstitutional dimensions of remote sensing capacity for tropical forest monitoring
Remote sensing technologies are central to tropical forest monitoring, yet the institutional mechanisms constraining their adoption and operationalization within responsible organizations remain poorly understood. Drawing on thirty-eight semi-structured interviews with actors across the remote sensing value chain in Latin America, Africa, and Southeast Asia, we examine how institutional arrangements shape remote sensing capacity within organizations directly engaged in tropical forest monitoring and management. We distinguish between operational frictions, the practical obstacles practitioners encounter in day-to-day remote sensing work, and the institutional conditions that generate and sustain them, organized across four capacity dimensions: dependable data access, technical expertise, organizational support and mandate clarity, and equitable user-provider relations. Our findings show that capacity constraints are not primarily technical but institutional: external data ownership and governance structures, organizational instability, weak mandates, and asymmetric power within the remote sensing value chain interact and compound to undermine capacity even where technical resources are nominally available. These dynamics are especially pronounced for subnational governments, Indigenous organizations, and civil society actors at the periphery of the value chain, who face severe barriers and are frequently on the frontlines of deforestation. Our results suggest that capacity building efforts are more likely to yield durable results when they engage directly with the institutional contexts in which remote sensing is embedded, rather than focusing primarily on individual frictions, such as data access or technical skill development.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 16 (3) , 354-363
Spatially explicit global assessment of cropland greenhouse gas emissions circa 2020
Spatially explicit cropland greenhouse gas emission data are essential for identifying emission hotspots and guiding sustainable mitigation strategies. Here we develop high-resolution (5 arcmin) global maps of cropland emissions across 46 crop classes in 2020 by integrating sectoral datasets on synthetic fertilizer, manure, crop residue, in-field burning, rice cultivation and cultivated drained peatlands. Global croplands emitted 2.5 (95% CI 2.4–2.7) GtCO 2 e yr −1 , with drained peatlands (35%), rice paddies (35%) and synthetic fertilizer (23%) as the primary contributors. Four crops—rice, maize, oil palm and wheat—accounted for 67% of total emissions. Emission areal intensities averaged 2 MgCO 2 e ha − 1 globally, with higher intensities in Asia and Europe, where croplands also achieved high caloric productivity. Spatial correlations between emission intensity and production efficiency reveal geographic trade-offs between mitigation potential and food production. The resulting dataset establishes a unified global framework for a spatially explicit assessment of agricultural emissions and efficiency.
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 16 (3) , 354-363
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessSpatially explicit global assessment of cropland greenhouse gas emissions circa 2020
Spatially explicit cropland greenhouse gas emission data are essential for identifying emission hotspots and guiding sustainable mitigation strategies. Here we develop high-resolution (5 arcmin) global maps of cropland emissions across 46 crop classes in 2020 by integrating sectoral datasets on synthetic fertilizer, manure, crop residue, in-field burning, rice cultivation and cultivated drained peatlands. Global croplands emitted 2.5 (95% CI 2.4–2.7) GtCO 2 e yr −1 , with drained peatlands (35%), rice paddies (35%) and synthetic fertilizer (23%) as the primary contributors. Four crops—rice, maize, oil palm and wheat—accounted for 67% of total emissions. Emission areal intensities averaged 2 MgCO 2 e ha − 1 globally, with higher intensities in Asia and Europe, where croplands also achieved high caloric productivity. Spatial correlations between emission intensity and production efficiency reveal geographic trade-offs between mitigation potential and food production. The resulting dataset establishes a unified global framework for a spatially explicit assessment of agricultural emissions and efficiency.
- Open Access
- 25 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Globalizations
- Vol. 23 (2) , 237-261
Long-standing labour migration, new plantation enclosures, and social reproduction in Indonesian Borneo’s borderlands
- 25 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Globalizations
- Vol. 23 (2) , 237-261
Open AccessLong-standing labour migration, new plantation enclosures, and social reproduction in Indonesian Borneo’s borderlands
- Open Access
- 23 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Does Palm Oil Really Rule the Supermarket?—An Assessment of Three Western Supermarket Chains
The claim that 50% of supermarket products contain palm oil is widely cited and repeated to underscore the relevance of activist campaigns and sustainability efforts in the oil palm sector. Yet evidence supporting this claim has never been publicly available. We investigated the accuracy of this claim at three large supermarket chains across three countries, where adequate online product and ingredient data were available. We compiled and analysed ingredient lists from approximately 1,600 food products from three supermarkets in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Australia to evaluate the prevalence of palm and palm kernel oil, as well as other major vegetable oil crops. Across these supermarkets, palm and/or palm kernel oil were explicitly listed in 7.9% (95% CI [6.9%, 9.0%]) of products, whereas maize (19% [18%, 21%]), rapeseed (15% [13%, 16%]), and soya (14% [13%, 16%]) were more prevalent. Up to 40% (95% CI [37%, 43%]) of products at these supermarkets may contain palm oil through unspecified vegetable oils or oleochemicals, which were found in about 18% of all sampled products. This underscores a broader challenge: modern processed foods are part of complex global supply chains that rely on interchangeable commodities such as palm oil. While traceability mechanisms like those promoted by the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) aim to enhance upstream accountability, consumer-facing labelling transparency remains inadequate. We emphasise the need for clearer food labelling and broader systems-level impact assessments if consumers are to make fully informed choices to align with their values and goals.
- 23 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessDoes Palm Oil Really Rule the Supermarket?—An Assessment of Three Western Supermarket Chains
The claim that 50% of supermarket products contain palm oil is widely cited and repeated to underscore the relevance of activist campaigns and sustainability efforts in the oil palm sector. Yet evidence supporting this claim has never been publicly available. We investigated the accuracy of this claim at three large supermarket chains across three countries, where adequate online product and ingredient data were available. We compiled and analysed ingredient lists from approximately 1,600 food products from three supermarkets in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Australia to evaluate the prevalence of palm and palm kernel oil, as well as other major vegetable oil crops. Across these supermarkets, palm and/or palm kernel oil were explicitly listed in 7.9% (95% CI [6.9%, 9.0%]) of products, whereas maize (19% [18%, 21%]), rapeseed (15% [13%, 16%]), and soya (14% [13%, 16%]) were more prevalent. Up to 40% (95% CI [37%, 43%]) of products at these supermarkets may contain palm oil through unspecified vegetable oils or oleochemicals, which were found in about 18% of all sampled products. This underscores a broader challenge: modern processed foods are part of complex global supply chains that rely on interchangeable commodities such as palm oil. While traceability mechanisms like those promoted by the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) aim to enhance upstream accountability, consumer-facing labelling transparency remains inadequate. We emphasise the need for clearer food labelling and broader systems-level impact assessments if consumers are to make fully informed choices to align with their values and goals.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 6 (1) , 1-18
Uneven participation of independent and contract smallholders in certified palm oil mill markets in Indonesia
Sustainability requirements imposed on agricultural producers by downstream supply chain actors risk excluding smallholder farmers from upgraded markets. Here we investigated smallholder participation in sustainably certified palm oil mill markets in Indonesia. We developed and applied a conceptual model to estimate the importance of structural market access, smallholder capacity, and buyer/seller behavior in shaping mill smallholder sourcing. Smallholders who hold exclusive contracts with specific mills were overrepresented at certified mills. Independent smallholders unaffiliated with mills contributed one-third of regional oil palm production but 7% of certified mill supply. We found no evidence that independent smallholders exited markets after mill certification (“active” exclusion). Instead, only 36% of certified mills ever purchased from independent smallholders, and independent smallholder lands were less common around certified (29–38% of palm area) versus noncertified (41–42%) mills. To address such “passive” exclusion, supply chain governance programs should encourage participation of actors well-positioned to source from small-scale producers.
- 30 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 6 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessUneven participation of independent and contract smallholders in certified palm oil mill markets in Indonesia
Sustainability requirements imposed on agricultural producers by downstream supply chain actors risk excluding smallholder farmers from upgraded markets. Here we investigated smallholder participation in sustainably certified palm oil mill markets in Indonesia. We developed and applied a conceptual model to estimate the importance of structural market access, smallholder capacity, and buyer/seller behavior in shaping mill smallholder sourcing. Smallholders who hold exclusive contracts with specific mills were overrepresented at certified mills. Independent smallholders unaffiliated with mills contributed one-third of regional oil palm production but 7% of certified mill supply. We found no evidence that independent smallholders exited markets after mill certification (“active” exclusion). Instead, only 36% of certified mills ever purchased from independent smallholders, and independent smallholder lands were less common around certified (29–38% of palm area) versus noncertified (41–42%) mills. To address such “passive” exclusion, supply chain governance programs should encourage participation of actors well-positioned to source from small-scale producers.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Sustainability and Transformation
- Vol. 4 (7) , e0000183
The impact of reading a synthesis report on perceptions of palm oil in the global conservation community
Tropical forest risk commodities including palm oil contribute to deforestation and biodiversity decline, making them a major focus of the international conservation community. Many in this community rely on scientific evidence to inform conservation decision-making, but the extent to which synthesized evidence influences perceptions across the diverse set of individuals that comprise the global conservation community remains unclear. We surveyed 470 conservation professionals living in 90 countries regarding their perceptions of palm oil, and evaluated the influence of reading a synthesis report on oil palm and biodiversity on these perceptions. We found that respondent perceptions of palm oil’s impacts on the environment tended to align with scientific evidence, with high agreement among respondents. We found less agreement regarding the effectiveness of biodiversity conservation interventions in the palm oil sector. Respondents often evaluated interventions whose effectiveness had not yet been assessed in the scientific literature. Reading the full synthesis report led to significantly less negative perceptions of palm oil production’s impacts on biodiversity and tropical rainforests but did not change perceptions of conservation intervention effectiveness. Given the substantial effort involved in developing synthesis reports about conservation, long-term studies exploring how these publications influence perceptions, knowledge, discourse, conservation decision-making, and conservation outcomes are needed. Palm oil supplies more than a third of global edible oil demand. Development of oil palm plantations drives tropical deforestation and biodiversity loss but contributes to economies of producing countries like Indonesia and Malaysia. Since the early 2000s, the global conservation community has debated the appropriate set of interventions to improve palm oil production sustainability. Yet, the views of this community – which influence conservation policy and practice – have been unknown. We analyzed a survey of hundreds of individuals affiliated with diverse conservation organizations across the world regarding their perceptions before and after they read a situation analysis on palm oil and biodiversity prepared by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). We found that while respondents agreed about the impacts of palm oil on the environment, they had more polarized views regarding the effectiveness of conservation policy interventions to address biodiversity loss in the palm oil sector. After reading the full IUCN report, respondents had significantly less negative assessments of the impacts of palm oil on biodiversity and tropical rainforests compared to a control group. Our findings advance understanding of how efforts to synthesize scientific evidence influence the views of decision-makers.
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Sustainability and Transformation
- Vol. 4 (7) , e0000183
Open AccessThe impact of reading a synthesis report on perceptions of palm oil in the global conservation community
Tropical forest risk commodities including palm oil contribute to deforestation and biodiversity decline, making them a major focus of the international conservation community. Many in this community rely on scientific evidence to inform conservation decision-making, but the extent to which synthesized evidence influences perceptions across the diverse set of individuals that comprise the global conservation community remains unclear. We surveyed 470 conservation professionals living in 90 countries regarding their perceptions of palm oil, and evaluated the influence of reading a synthesis report on oil palm and biodiversity on these perceptions. We found that respondent perceptions of palm oil’s impacts on the environment tended to align with scientific evidence, with high agreement among respondents. We found less agreement regarding the effectiveness of biodiversity conservation interventions in the palm oil sector. Respondents often evaluated interventions whose effectiveness had not yet been assessed in the scientific literature. Reading the full synthesis report led to significantly less negative perceptions of palm oil production’s impacts on biodiversity and tropical rainforests but did not change perceptions of conservation intervention effectiveness. Given the substantial effort involved in developing synthesis reports about conservation, long-term studies exploring how these publications influence perceptions, knowledge, discourse, conservation decision-making, and conservation outcomes are needed. Palm oil supplies more than a third of global edible oil demand. Development of oil palm plantations drives tropical deforestation and biodiversity loss but contributes to economies of producing countries like Indonesia and Malaysia. Since the early 2000s, the global conservation community has debated the appropriate set of interventions to improve palm oil production sustainability. Yet, the views of this community – which influence conservation policy and practice – have been unknown. We analyzed a survey of hundreds of individuals affiliated with diverse conservation organizations across the world regarding their perceptions before and after they read a situation analysis on palm oil and biodiversity prepared by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). We found that while respondents agreed about the impacts of palm oil on the environment, they had more polarized views regarding the effectiveness of conservation policy interventions to address biodiversity loss in the palm oil sector. After reading the full IUCN report, respondents had significantly less negative assessments of the impacts of palm oil on biodiversity and tropical rainforests compared to a control group. Our findings advance understanding of how efforts to synthesize scientific evidence influence the views of decision-makers.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2024
- Published by University of California Press in Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene
- Vol. 12 (1)
Smallholder participation in zero-deforestation supply chain initiatives in the Indonesian palm oil sector: Challenges, opportunities, and limitations
As actors in tropical agricultural commodity supply chains implement commitments to end deforestation, they risk exacerbating social inequities by excluding smallholder farmers, who are important producers of many tropical commodity crops. Here, we explore the potential for independent oil palm smallholders in Indonesia to participate in zero-deforestation supply chains. We find that these smallholders are underrepresented in the share of zero-deforestation compliant oil palm production. We then synthesize perspectives from key actors in the oil palm industry including smallholders and their representatives, palm oil producing and consulting companies, nongovernmental organizations, and academic researchers. Based on these perspectives, we find that challenges to smallholder supply chain participation include limitations in knowledge (e.g., smallholders may not know the location of protected forests), institutional issues (e.g., absence of trust between oil palm growing companies and smallholder farmers), and financial constraints (e.g., the opportunity cost of not clearing forest). To address these shortcomings, we encourage oil palm growing and milling companies to take the lead on incentivizing, supporting, and facilitating smallholder participation in zero-deforestation initiatives. Specifically, these companies could build and use their technical and political resources to identify and map all forests in their entire supply shed and ensure small producers have land rights that enable participation in zero-deforestation supply chains. These policy levers would need to be combined with economic incentives such as access to improved inputs or price premia for their products. However, we caution that smallholder integration into existing zero-deforestation supply chains alone is unlikely to result in significant additional forest conservation at scale in Indonesia due to selection bias, leakage, and existing land tenure norms. Community-led and jurisdictional or landscape-scale supply chain initiatives that acknowledge multi-commodity production are more likely to provide equitable and just avenues for Indonesian smallholder farmers to steward forest resources.
- 16 May 2024
- Published by University of California Press in Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene
- Vol. 12 (1)
Open AccessSmallholder participation in zero-deforestation supply chain initiatives in the Indonesian palm oil sector: Challenges, opportunities, and limitations
As actors in tropical agricultural commodity supply chains implement commitments to end deforestation, they risk exacerbating social inequities by excluding smallholder farmers, who are important producers of many tropical commodity crops. Here, we explore the potential for independent oil palm smallholders in Indonesia to participate in zero-deforestation supply chains. We find that these smallholders are underrepresented in the share of zero-deforestation compliant oil palm production. We then synthesize perspectives from key actors in the oil palm industry including smallholders and their representatives, palm oil producing and consulting companies, nongovernmental organizations, and academic researchers. Based on these perspectives, we find that challenges to smallholder supply chain participation include limitations in knowledge (e.g., smallholders may not know the location of protected forests), institutional issues (e.g., absence of trust between oil palm growing companies and smallholder farmers), and financial constraints (e.g., the opportunity cost of not clearing forest). To address these shortcomings, we encourage oil palm growing and milling companies to take the lead on incentivizing, supporting, and facilitating smallholder participation in zero-deforestation initiatives. Specifically, these companies could build and use their technical and political resources to identify and map all forests in their entire supply shed and ensure small producers have land rights that enable participation in zero-deforestation supply chains. These policy levers would need to be combined with economic incentives such as access to improved inputs or price premia for their products. However, we caution that smallholder integration into existing zero-deforestation supply chains alone is unlikely to result in significant additional forest conservation at scale in Indonesia due to selection bias, leakage, and existing land tenure norms. Community-led and jurisdictional or landscape-scale supply chain initiatives that acknowledge multi-commodity production are more likely to provide equitable and just avenues for Indonesian smallholder farmers to steward forest resources.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 19 (4) , 044054
How well does the implementation of corporate zero-deforestation commitments in Indonesia align with aims to halt deforestation and include smallholders?
In response to growing scrutiny surrounding commodity-driven deforestation, companies have introduced zero-deforestation commitments (ZDCs) with ambitious environmental and social targets. However, such initiatives may not effectively reduce deforestation if they are not aligned with the spatial extent of remaining forests at risk. They may also fail to avert socio-economic risks if ZDCs do not consider smallholder farmers’ needs. We assess the spatial and functional fit of ZDCs by mapping commodity-driven deforestation and socio-economic risks, and comparing them to the spatial coverage and implementation of ZDCs in the Indonesian palm oil sector. Our study finds that companies’ ZDCs often underperform in four areas: traceability, compliance support for high-risk palm oil mills, transparency, and smallholder inclusion. In 2020, only one-third of companies sourcing from their own mills, and just 6% of those sourcing from external suppliers, achieved full traceability to plantations. Comparing the reach of ZDCs adopted by downstream buyers with those adopted by mill owners located further upstream, we find that high-quality ZDCs from buyers covered 62% of forests at risk, while mill owners’ ZDCs only covered 23% of forests at risk within the mill supply base. In Kalimantan and Papua, the current and future deforestation frontiers, the forests most at risk of conversion were predominantly covered by weak ZDCs lacking in policy comprehensiveness and implementation. Additionally, we find that only 46% of independent smallholder oil palm plots are in mill supply sheds whose owners offer programs and support for independent smallholders, indicating that smallholder inclusion is a significant challenge for ZDC companies. These results highlight the lack of spatial and functional alignment between supply chain policies and their local context as a significant gap in ZDC implementation and a challenge that the EU Deforestation Regulation will face.
- 28 March 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 19 (4) , 044054
Open AccessHow well does the implementation of corporate zero-deforestation commitments in Indonesia align with aims to halt deforestation and include smallholders?
In response to growing scrutiny surrounding commodity-driven deforestation, companies have introduced zero-deforestation commitments (ZDCs) with ambitious environmental and social targets. However, such initiatives may not effectively reduce deforestation if they are not aligned with the spatial extent of remaining forests at risk. They may also fail to avert socio-economic risks if ZDCs do not consider smallholder farmers’ needs. We assess the spatial and functional fit of ZDCs by mapping commodity-driven deforestation and socio-economic risks, and comparing them to the spatial coverage and implementation of ZDCs in the Indonesian palm oil sector. Our study finds that companies’ ZDCs often underperform in four areas: traceability, compliance support for high-risk palm oil mills, transparency, and smallholder inclusion. In 2020, only one-third of companies sourcing from their own mills, and just 6% of those sourcing from external suppliers, achieved full traceability to plantations. Comparing the reach of ZDCs adopted by downstream buyers with those adopted by mill owners located further upstream, we find that high-quality ZDCs from buyers covered 62% of forests at risk, while mill owners’ ZDCs only covered 23% of forests at risk within the mill supply base. In Kalimantan and Papua, the current and future deforestation frontiers, the forests most at risk of conversion were predominantly covered by weak ZDCs lacking in policy comprehensiveness and implementation. Additionally, we find that only 46% of independent smallholder oil palm plots are in mill supply sheds whose owners offer programs and support for independent smallholders, indicating that smallholder inclusion is a significant challenge for ZDC companies. These results highlight the lack of spatial and functional alignment between supply chain policies and their local context as a significant gap in ZDC implementation and a challenge that the EU Deforestation Regulation will face.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 17 (11) , 114003
Gaps in adoption and implementation limit the current and potential effectiveness of zero-deforestation supply chain policies for soy
Tropical deforestation continues despite global efforts to curb forest loss. Corporate zero-deforestation supply chain commitments (ZDCs) have the potential to address this deforestation, especially if strong state-led forest governance is absent. Yet, because ZDC adoption is limited to particular locations and supply chains, these commitments may fall short at reducing regional deforestation and protecting biodiverse ecosystems. Here, we leverage timeseries of spatially explicit corporate commodity sourcing data and ZDCs to assess the current and potential effect of ZDCs within soybean supply chains on forest loss and biodiversity. We focus on the Brazilian Amazon, where the first ZDC (soy moratorium (SoyM)) was implemented, and the Cerrado, where companies have adopted but not implemented ZDCs. We found that in the Amazon, SoyM signatories that controlled the market caused a 57% reduction in direct deforestation for soy from 2006 to 2015. In the Cerrado, if companies had implemented their ZDCs with the same relative effectiveness as in the Amazon, deforestation for soy could have been reduced by 46%. Thus, ZDC implementation in the Cerrado via stringent monitoring and enforcement could contribute substantially to forest and habitat conservation. Yet, incomplete ZDC adoption leaves >50% of soy-suitable forests and the biodiversity that they harbor outside the reach of ZDCs. To protect these forests, it is vital to incentivize more companies—including smaller, less publicly exposed traders—to make and implement ZDCs, while also promoting forest governance through public policy.
- 28 October 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 17 (11) , 114003
Open AccessGaps in adoption and implementation limit the current and potential effectiveness of zero-deforestation supply chain policies for soy
Tropical deforestation continues despite global efforts to curb forest loss. Corporate zero-deforestation supply chain commitments (ZDCs) have the potential to address this deforestation, especially if strong state-led forest governance is absent. Yet, because ZDC adoption is limited to particular locations and supply chains, these commitments may fall short at reducing regional deforestation and protecting biodiverse ecosystems. Here, we leverage timeseries of spatially explicit corporate commodity sourcing data and ZDCs to assess the current and potential effect of ZDCs within soybean supply chains on forest loss and biodiversity. We focus on the Brazilian Amazon, where the first ZDC (soy moratorium (SoyM)) was implemented, and the Cerrado, where companies have adopted but not implemented ZDCs. We found that in the Amazon, SoyM signatories that controlled the market caused a 57% reduction in direct deforestation for soy from 2006 to 2015. In the Cerrado, if companies had implemented their ZDCs with the same relative effectiveness as in the Amazon, deforestation for soy could have been reduced by 46%. Thus, ZDC implementation in the Cerrado via stringent monitoring and enforcement could contribute substantially to forest and habitat conservation. Yet, incomplete ZDC adoption leaves >50% of soy-suitable forests and the biodiversity that they harbor outside the reach of ZDCs. To protect these forests, it is vital to incentivize more companies—including smaller, less publicly exposed traders—to make and implement ZDCs, while also promoting forest governance through public policy.