Rodney P. Jones
Research Subjects
Rodney P. Jones has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Andrey Ponomarenko
Department of Biophysics, Informatics and Medical Instrumentation, Odessa National Medical University, Valikhovsky Lane 2, 65082 Odessa, Ukraine
7 shared publications Paul F. Greenfield
Biotechnology Unit, Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Queensland, St. Lucia, Qld., 4067, Australia
6 shared publications- Andrey Ponomarenko
Department of Biophysics, Informatics and Medical Instrumentation, Odessa National Medical University, Valikhovsky Lane 2, 65082 Odessa, Ukraine
2 shared publications Neeraj Beeknoo
2 shared publicationsD. Goldeck
Tuebingen Ageing & Tumor Immunology Group, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Tuebingen Medical School, Waldhoernlestr.22, D 72072 Tuebingen, Germany
1 shared publicationGeoffrey M. Gadd
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Dundee, Dundee, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Whole Hospital Bed Occupancy Explained: Why Do Countries Operate at Different Average Bed Occupancy and to Which Specific Context Does 85% Occupancy Apply?
Whole hospital bed occupancy is explained based on the size of the individual units/departments within each hospital. The weighted population density and the deaths per 1000 population combine to influence the size distribution of hospitals (WPD) within a country/region. This explains why different countries and regions operate at different average occupancy. It also explains why smaller hospitals must operate at lower average occupancy to avoid access block. Mixed specialty hospitals in the USA operate at around 76% (upper quartile 81%) occupancy at 1000 beds, 68% (75%) at 500, 55% (64%) at 100 and 32% (40%) at 20 beds, etc. However, single function/specialty hospitals tend to have an occupancy lying between the 0.1% to 3% lines of turn-away as calculated by the Erlang equation. The often-quoted figure of 85% occupancy is used as an approximate measure of daily busyness/workload and will occur most often in larger hospitals where most studies of this nature are conducted. For example, in 2025 some 12% of a sample (n = 107) of 500+ bed US hospitals operated above 85% annual average occupancy (midnight). Above this figure the workload becomes such that medication errors, falls, hospital acquired infection (HAI) and stress occur in increasing measures. Attribution of cause and effect is clouded because above 85% both busyness and delays to admission (access block) can often occur simultaneously. Acute bed occupancy in England follows a trajectory where the entire acute NHS could be at 100% occupancy by 2040. This is the result of serious failures in bed planning by successive governments over the past 30 years. Increasing numbers of same day stay admissions are causing underestimation of the real levels of bed occupancy. Hence, the apparent higher US bed occupancy in the 1960’s to 80’s (76.5 ± 1.7% vs 66.2 ± 0.2% since the 2000’s) may reflect something closer to real time bed occupancy in the earlier years. The situation and consequences in the USA for increasing post-pandemic occupancy can be explained in the above context with lessons to be learned from England.
- 18 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessWhole Hospital Bed Occupancy Explained: Why Do Countries Operate at Different Average Bed Occupancy and to Which Specific Context Does 85% Occupancy Apply?
Whole hospital bed occupancy is explained based on the size of the individual units/departments within each hospital. The weighted population density and the deaths per 1000 population combine to influence the size distribution of hospitals (WPD) within a country/region. This explains why different countries and regions operate at different average occupancy. It also explains why smaller hospitals must operate at lower average occupancy to avoid access block. Mixed specialty hospitals in the USA operate at around 76% (upper quartile 81%) occupancy at 1000 beds, 68% (75%) at 500, 55% (64%) at 100 and 32% (40%) at 20 beds, etc. However, single function/specialty hospitals tend to have an occupancy lying between the 0.1% to 3% lines of turn-away as calculated by the Erlang equation. The often-quoted figure of 85% occupancy is used as an approximate measure of daily busyness/workload and will occur most often in larger hospitals where most studies of this nature are conducted. For example, in 2025 some 12% of a sample (n = 107) of 500+ bed US hospitals operated above 85% annual average occupancy (midnight). Above this figure the workload becomes such that medication errors, falls, hospital acquired infection (HAI) and stress occur in increasing measures. Attribution of cause and effect is clouded because above 85% both busyness and delays to admission (access block) can often occur simultaneously. Acute bed occupancy in England follows a trajectory where the entire acute NHS could be at 100% occupancy by 2040. This is the result of serious failures in bed planning by successive governments over the past 30 years. Increasing numbers of same day stay admissions are causing underestimation of the real levels of bed occupancy. Hence, the apparent higher US bed occupancy in the 1960’s to 80’s (76.5 ± 1.7% vs 66.2 ± 0.2% since the 2000’s) may reflect something closer to real time bed occupancy in the earlier years. The situation and consequences in the USA for increasing post-pandemic occupancy can be explained in the above context with lessons to be learned from England.
- Open Access
- 27 May 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 23 (6) , 711
Capacity Planning for Small Hospitals and Departments Illustrated Using Maternity and Paediatrics Departments: Roles for Weighted Population Density, Seasonality and Size, Myths Around Length of Stay and Factors Influencing Costs and Funding
The Erlang B equation is directly applicable to smaller hospital departments such as maternity and paediatrics departments. The bed occupancy margin is directly linked to size and not ‘efficiency’. A figure of 0.1% turn-away has been recommended as a planning target, i.e., only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found. Two bed calculators are provided which can be used for paediatric, obstetric, maternity, midwife-led, birthing wards and neonatal/paediatric critical care capacity. The negative effects of turn-away are likely to be context specific, hence, critical care > theatres > birthing unit > maternity unit. The uncertainty regarding future births is discussed along with the variable nature of seasonality in births. For paediatrics, much of bed demand is also influenced by the trend in births. Weighted population density (WPD) is associated with the size distribution of hospitals/units within countries and regions. This influences the average cost per birth/admission. The USA has a low WPD and a significant problem with small hospitals/departments. Only 10% of countries have WPD higher than England. Some countries choose to operate with even more hospitals than needed and this acts to elevate costs. Suggestions are made for a pragmatic approach to bed planning, especially where a dispersed population dictates a need for small hospitals, and hence, issues regarding size and costs. For maternity/paediatrics admissions (and other relatively short-stay admissions) the majority of overhead/indirect costs and most staffing costs should be apportioned based on admissions, and not LOS. Apportionment based on LOS creates the spurious illusion that LOS is the major cost driver and that reducing LOS will immediately save costs. Below 20 beds, Poisson statistical variation plus environment-induced randomness in daily arrivals imply that staff costs may become increasingly fixed irrespective of LOS. Around >30 beds, it looks possible to save costs by reducing LOS. Allocating total organizational costs to individual units and then to patients is less precise than realized and can be done in different ways, which all heavily rely on the steady-state assumption. When bed availability is the bottleneck, then reducing LOS may increase throughput per bed and increase income; however, is this for the benefit of the patient or for the benefit of the organization, and does it lead to higher unanticipated total costs including patient harm? The older economy-of-scale literature has been demonstrated to be flawed, with a recent focus on economy of scale at the department level being entirely consistent with the application of the Erlang B equation. A list of nine catastrophic pitfalls is given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external experts.
- 27 May 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 23 (6) , 711
Open AccessCapacity Planning for Small Hospitals and Departments Illustrated Using Maternity and Paediatrics Departments: Roles for Weighted Population Density, Seasonality and Size, Myths Around Length of Stay and Factors Influencing Costs and Funding
The Erlang B equation is directly applicable to smaller hospital departments such as maternity and paediatrics departments. The bed occupancy margin is directly linked to size and not ‘efficiency’. A figure of 0.1% turn-away has been recommended as a planning target, i.e., only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found. Two bed calculators are provided which can be used for paediatric, obstetric, maternity, midwife-led, birthing wards and neonatal/paediatric critical care capacity. The negative effects of turn-away are likely to be context specific, hence, critical care > theatres > birthing unit > maternity unit. The uncertainty regarding future births is discussed along with the variable nature of seasonality in births. For paediatrics, much of bed demand is also influenced by the trend in births. Weighted population density (WPD) is associated with the size distribution of hospitals/units within countries and regions. This influences the average cost per birth/admission. The USA has a low WPD and a significant problem with small hospitals/departments. Only 10% of countries have WPD higher than England. Some countries choose to operate with even more hospitals than needed and this acts to elevate costs. Suggestions are made for a pragmatic approach to bed planning, especially where a dispersed population dictates a need for small hospitals, and hence, issues regarding size and costs. For maternity/paediatrics admissions (and other relatively short-stay admissions) the majority of overhead/indirect costs and most staffing costs should be apportioned based on admissions, and not LOS. Apportionment based on LOS creates the spurious illusion that LOS is the major cost driver and that reducing LOS will immediately save costs. Below 20 beds, Poisson statistical variation plus environment-induced randomness in daily arrivals imply that staff costs may become increasingly fixed irrespective of LOS. Around >30 beds, it looks possible to save costs by reducing LOS. Allocating total organizational costs to individual units and then to patients is less precise than realized and can be done in different ways, which all heavily rely on the steady-state assumption. When bed availability is the bottleneck, then reducing LOS may increase throughput per bed and increase income; however, is this for the benefit of the patient or for the benefit of the organization, and does it lead to higher unanticipated total costs including patient harm? The older economy-of-scale literature has been demonstrated to be flawed, with a recent focus on economy of scale at the department level being entirely consistent with the application of the Erlang B equation. A list of nine catastrophic pitfalls is given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external experts.
- Open Access
- 6 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Cost and Capacity Issues in Small Hospital Departments, Difficulties in Estimating Future Demand, the Impact of Seasonality, and the Cost Reduction (If Any) from Reducing Length of Stay
Queuing theory and the Erlang equation are directly applicable to small hospital departments such as maternity and pediatrics. Bed capacity tables can be easily generated linking annual births/admissions to the required available beds, using expected births/admissions and length of stay (LOS). Two bed calculators are provided. For example, in maternity the total bed days includes any admissions during pregnancy and after birth, i.e., excluding the time spent in the birthing unit. It is emphasized that bed days must be calculated using real time length of stay as opposed to the usual midnight figure. The bed occupancy margin is directly linked to size and not ‘efficiency’. Based on the Erlang B equation which links available beds, occupied beds and turn-away, a figure of 0.1% turn-away has been chosen as the minimum acceptable number of beds, i.e., only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found. Two bed calculators are provided which can be used for obstetric, maternity, midwife-led, birthing wards and neonatal unit bed capacity. Specific issues relating to neonatal critical care bed capacity are highlighted. The negative effects of turn-away are likely to be context specific, hence, critical care > theatres > birthing unit > maternity unit. The far greater uncertainty regarding future births is discussed along with the variable nature of seasonality in births. For pediatrics much of bed demand is also influenced by the trend in births. Suggestions are made for a pragmatic approach to bed planning. Evidence is presented which suggests that for maternity (and other relative short stay admissions) the majority of overhead/indirect costs and most staffing costs should be apportioned based on admissions, and not LOS. Apportionment based on LOS creates the spurious illusion that LOS is the major cost driver and that reducing LOS will immediately save costs. Several lines of evidence point to the minimum cost per patient in maternity (antenatal + postnatal) lying greater than 30 beds (plus associated labor/birthing beds), and the minimum economic size around 12 beds. Around 30 beds probably mark the point where it is possible to make small cost savings by reducing LOS. Allocating total organizational costs to individual units and then to patients is far less precise than is realized and can be done in different ways which all heavily rely on the steady-state assumption. The real world of daily arrivals, case mix and clinical severity is never in steady state. Below 20 to 30 beds Poisson statistical plus environment induced randomness in daily arrivals imply that staff costs become increasingly fixed irrespective of LOS. When bed availability is the bottleneck then reducing LOS may increase throughput per bed and increase income, however, is this for the benefit of the patient or for the benefit of the organization, and does it lead to higher unanticipated total costs including patient harm? Finally, a list of nine ‘never do this’ catastrophic pitfalls are given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external ‘experts’.
- 6 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessCost and Capacity Issues in Small Hospital Departments, Difficulties in Estimating Future Demand, the Impact of Seasonality, and the Cost Reduction (If Any) from Reducing Length of Stay
Queuing theory and the Erlang equation are directly applicable to small hospital departments such as maternity and pediatrics. Bed capacity tables can be easily generated linking annual births/admissions to the required available beds, using expected births/admissions and length of stay (LOS). Two bed calculators are provided. For example, in maternity the total bed days includes any admissions during pregnancy and after birth, i.e., excluding the time spent in the birthing unit. It is emphasized that bed days must be calculated using real time length of stay as opposed to the usual midnight figure. The bed occupancy margin is directly linked to size and not ‘efficiency’. Based on the Erlang B equation which links available beds, occupied beds and turn-away, a figure of 0.1% turn-away has been chosen as the minimum acceptable number of beds, i.e., only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found. Two bed calculators are provided which can be used for obstetric, maternity, midwife-led, birthing wards and neonatal unit bed capacity. Specific issues relating to neonatal critical care bed capacity are highlighted. The negative effects of turn-away are likely to be context specific, hence, critical care > theatres > birthing unit > maternity unit. The far greater uncertainty regarding future births is discussed along with the variable nature of seasonality in births. For pediatrics much of bed demand is also influenced by the trend in births. Suggestions are made for a pragmatic approach to bed planning. Evidence is presented which suggests that for maternity (and other relative short stay admissions) the majority of overhead/indirect costs and most staffing costs should be apportioned based on admissions, and not LOS. Apportionment based on LOS creates the spurious illusion that LOS is the major cost driver and that reducing LOS will immediately save costs. Several lines of evidence point to the minimum cost per patient in maternity (antenatal + postnatal) lying greater than 30 beds (plus associated labor/birthing beds), and the minimum economic size around 12 beds. Around 30 beds probably mark the point where it is possible to make small cost savings by reducing LOS. Allocating total organizational costs to individual units and then to patients is far less precise than is realized and can be done in different ways which all heavily rely on the steady-state assumption. The real world of daily arrivals, case mix and clinical severity is never in steady state. Below 20 to 30 beds Poisson statistical plus environment induced randomness in daily arrivals imply that staff costs become increasingly fixed irrespective of LOS. When bed availability is the bottleneck then reducing LOS may increase throughput per bed and increase income, however, is this for the benefit of the patient or for the benefit of the organization, and does it lead to higher unanticipated total costs including patient harm? Finally, a list of nine ‘never do this’ catastrophic pitfalls are given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external ‘experts’.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Wiley
More than 100 English maternity units are likely to have too few beds as births rise through to 2035
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessMore than 100 English maternity units are likely to have too few beds as births rise through to 2035
- Open Access
- 26 November 2025
- Published by Wiley
How many beds are needed in maternity units handling different numbers of births
Queuing theory and the Erlang equation are directly applicable to maternity capacity planning and tables can be easily generated linking annual births to the required available beds, with allowance for the total bed days per birth. The total bed days includes any admissions during pregnancy plus during birth (but excluding the time spent in the birthing unit). A figure of 0.1% turn-away has been chosen as the minimum acceptable number of beds, i.e. only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessHow many beds are needed in maternity units handling different numbers of births
Queuing theory and the Erlang equation are directly applicable to maternity capacity planning and tables can be easily generated linking annual births to the required available beds, with allowance for the total bed days per birth. The total bed days includes any admissions during pregnancy plus during birth (but excluding the time spent in the birthing unit). A figure of 0.1% turn-away has been chosen as the minimum acceptable number of beds, i.e. only 1 in a thousand admissions suffer a delay before a bed can be found.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Key Principles for Pediatric/Neonatal Inpatient Capacity Planning in the Face of Uncertain and Volatile Future Demand, Effect of Department Size on Costs, and How to Discern If Sources of Advice Have Genuine Expertise
Pediatric/neonatal bed demand unsurprisingly depend on the trend in local births. Periods of higher births generate a capacity shock, where length of stay (LOS) is reduced, sometimes by premature discharge or transfer to another hospital, to squeeze arriving patients into existing bed capacity. Similar capacity shocks occur during the autumn/winter/spring period when volatile levels of circulating pathogens, allergens, and air quality exacerbate common pediatric conditions. In England, 30% of 1,285 pediatric ICD-10 (3-digit) diagnoses have very high year-to-year volatility in admissions, while diagnoses with >3-times higher volatility than Poisson variation account for 54% of pediatric admissions. Such enormous volatility implies that the average length of stay (LOS) plays an almost trivial role in capacity planning. It is proposed that the Wuhan and Alpha strains of COVID-19 acted to reduce pediatric demand via pathogen interference – one example of how 3000 species of known human pathogens can interact with overall health in complex ways. Simple methods are presented to: 1. Construct scenarios for future births, 2. Construct a profile of daily (volatile) bed demand across the year, and 3. Calculate the surge capacity required to cope with a worst year. The Erlang equation is used to determine the optimum average bed occupancy rate for unhindered access to a bed, which depends on the size of the unit. For example, a 10-bed unit must function at only 31% average occupancy for unhindered access. Diminishing average occupancy as size reduces explains why smaller Pediatrics units cost more to run, and how this may influence the funding for smaller units in less populated rural and remote areas. The optimum size is above 30 beds, with 10 beds the likely minimum for an effective unit. Despite having a very high number of specialist children’s hospitals, the USA only manages to rank 55th in the world for childhood mortality – higher than Russia and Romania. With 47% of pediatric units in the USA having <10 beds, this could be described as a very expensive form of chaos. It is suggested that the numerous small units in the USA are unable to deal with anything other than the simplest admissions and form a vast hidden queue to (delayed) admission via transfer to a larger unit. Suggestions are given for lowering pediatric costs in the USA by improving the economy of scale. Finally, a list of nine ‘never do this’ catastrophic pitfalls are given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external ‘experts’.
- 7 July 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessKey Principles for Pediatric/Neonatal Inpatient Capacity Planning in the Face of Uncertain and Volatile Future Demand, Effect of Department Size on Costs, and How to Discern If Sources of Advice Have Genuine Expertise
Pediatric/neonatal bed demand unsurprisingly depend on the trend in local births. Periods of higher births generate a capacity shock, where length of stay (LOS) is reduced, sometimes by premature discharge or transfer to another hospital, to squeeze arriving patients into existing bed capacity. Similar capacity shocks occur during the autumn/winter/spring period when volatile levels of circulating pathogens, allergens, and air quality exacerbate common pediatric conditions. In England, 30% of 1,285 pediatric ICD-10 (3-digit) diagnoses have very high year-to-year volatility in admissions, while diagnoses with >3-times higher volatility than Poisson variation account for 54% of pediatric admissions. Such enormous volatility implies that the average length of stay (LOS) plays an almost trivial role in capacity planning. It is proposed that the Wuhan and Alpha strains of COVID-19 acted to reduce pediatric demand via pathogen interference – one example of how 3000 species of known human pathogens can interact with overall health in complex ways. Simple methods are presented to: 1. Construct scenarios for future births, 2. Construct a profile of daily (volatile) bed demand across the year, and 3. Calculate the surge capacity required to cope with a worst year. The Erlang equation is used to determine the optimum average bed occupancy rate for unhindered access to a bed, which depends on the size of the unit. For example, a 10-bed unit must function at only 31% average occupancy for unhindered access. Diminishing average occupancy as size reduces explains why smaller Pediatrics units cost more to run, and how this may influence the funding for smaller units in less populated rural and remote areas. The optimum size is above 30 beds, with 10 beds the likely minimum for an effective unit. Despite having a very high number of specialist children’s hospitals, the USA only manages to rank 55th in the world for childhood mortality – higher than Russia and Romania. With 47% of pediatric units in the USA having <10 beds, this could be described as a very expensive form of chaos. It is suggested that the numerous small units in the USA are unable to deal with anything other than the simplest admissions and form a vast hidden queue to (delayed) admission via transfer to a larger unit. Suggestions are given for lowering pediatric costs in the USA by improving the economy of scale. Finally, a list of nine ‘never do this’ catastrophic pitfalls are given for doctors to identify dubious capacity advice from managers and external ‘experts’.
- Open Access
- 10 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 22 (1) , 87
Capacity Planning (Capital, Staff and Costs) of Inpatient Maternity Services: Pitfalls for the Unwary
This study investigates the process of planning for future inpatient resources (beds, staff and costs) for maternity (pregnancy and childbirth) services. The process of planning is approached from a patient-centered philosophy; hence, how do we discharge a suitably rested healthy mother who is fully capable of caring for the newborn baby back into the community? This demonstrates some of the difficulties in predicting future births and investigates trends in the average length of stay. While it is relatively easy to document longer-term (past) trends in births and the conditions relating to pregnancy and birth, it is exceedingly difficult to predict the future nature of such trends. The issue of optimum average bed occupancy is addressed via the Erlang B equation which links number of beds, average bed occupancy and turn-away. Turn-away is the proportion of times that there is not an immediately available bed for the next arriving inpatient. Data for maternity units show extreme and unexplained variation in turn-away. Economy of scale implied by queuing theory (and the implied role of population density) explains why many well intended community-based schemes fail to gain traction. The paper also addresses some of the erroneous ideas around the dogma that reducing length of stay ‘saves’ money. Maternity departments are encouraged to understand how their costs are calculated to avoid the trap where it is suggested by others that in reducing the length of stay, they will reduce costs and increase ‘efficiency’. Indeed, up to 60% of calculated maternity ‘costs’ are apportioned from (shared) hospital overheads from supporting departments such as finance, personnel, buildings and grounds, IT, information, etc., along with depreciation charges on the hospital-wide buildings and equipment. These costs, known as ‘the fixed costs dilemma’, are totally beyond the control of the maternity department and will vary by hospital depending on how these costs are apportioned to the maternity unit. Premature discharge, one of the unfortunate outcomes of turn-away, is demonstrated to shift maternity costs into the pediatric and neonatal departments as ‘boomerang babies’, and then require the cost of avoidable inpatient care. Examples are given from the English NHS of how misdirected government policy can create unforeseen problems.
- 10 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 22 (1) , 87
Open AccessCapacity Planning (Capital, Staff and Costs) of Inpatient Maternity Services: Pitfalls for the Unwary
This study investigates the process of planning for future inpatient resources (beds, staff and costs) for maternity (pregnancy and childbirth) services. The process of planning is approached from a patient-centered philosophy; hence, how do we discharge a suitably rested healthy mother who is fully capable of caring for the newborn baby back into the community? This demonstrates some of the difficulties in predicting future births and investigates trends in the average length of stay. While it is relatively easy to document longer-term (past) trends in births and the conditions relating to pregnancy and birth, it is exceedingly difficult to predict the future nature of such trends. The issue of optimum average bed occupancy is addressed via the Erlang B equation which links number of beds, average bed occupancy and turn-away. Turn-away is the proportion of times that there is not an immediately available bed for the next arriving inpatient. Data for maternity units show extreme and unexplained variation in turn-away. Economy of scale implied by queuing theory (and the implied role of population density) explains why many well intended community-based schemes fail to gain traction. The paper also addresses some of the erroneous ideas around the dogma that reducing length of stay ‘saves’ money. Maternity departments are encouraged to understand how their costs are calculated to avoid the trap where it is suggested by others that in reducing the length of stay, they will reduce costs and increase ‘efficiency’. Indeed, up to 60% of calculated maternity ‘costs’ are apportioned from (shared) hospital overheads from supporting departments such as finance, personnel, buildings and grounds, IT, information, etc., along with depreciation charges on the hospital-wide buildings and equipment. These costs, known as ‘the fixed costs dilemma’, are totally beyond the control of the maternity department and will vary by hospital depending on how these costs are apportioned to the maternity unit. Premature discharge, one of the unfortunate outcomes of turn-away, is demonstrated to shift maternity costs into the pediatric and neonatal departments as ‘boomerang babies’, and then require the cost of avoidable inpatient care. Examples are given from the English NHS of how misdirected government policy can create unforeseen problems.
- Open Access
- 7 November 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Capacity Planning (Capital, Staff and Costs) of Inpatient Maternity Services: Pitfalls for the Unwary
This study investigates the process of planning for future inpatient resources (beds, staff and costs) for maternity (pregnancy and childbirth) services. The process of planning is approached from a patient centered philosophy; hence, how do we discharge a suitably rested healthy mother who is fully capable of caring for the newborn baby back into the community. It demonstrates some of the difficulties in predicting future births and investigates trends in the average length of stay. While it is relatively easy to document longer-term (past) trends in births and the conditions relating to pregnancy and birth, it is exceedingly difficult to predict the future nature of such trends. The issue of optimum average bed occupancy is addressed via the Erlang B equation which links number of beds, average bed occupancy and turn-away. Turn-away is the proportion of times that there is not an immediately available bed for the next arriving inpatient. Economy of scale implied by queuing theory (and the implied role of population density) explains why many well intended community-based schemes fail to gain traction. The paper also addresses some of the erroneous ideas around the dogma that reducing length of stay ‘saves’ money. Maternity departments are encouraged to understand how their costs are calculated to avoid the trap where it is suggested by others that in reducing the length of stay, they will reduce costs and increase ‘efficiency’. Indeed, up to 60% of calculated maternity ‘costs’ are apportioned hospital overheads from supporting departments such as finance, personnel, buildings and grounds, IT, information, etc., along with depreciation charges on the hospital-wide buildings and equipment. These costs, “the fixed costs dilemma”, are totally beyond the control of the maternity department and will vary by hospital depending on how these costs are apportioned to the maternity unit. Premature discharge, one of the unfortunate outcomes of turn-away, is demonstrated to shift maternity costs into the pediatric and neonatal departments as ‘boomerang babies’ then require the cost of avoidable inpatient care. Examples are given from the English NHS of how misdirected government policy can create unforeseen problems.
- 7 November 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessCapacity Planning (Capital, Staff and Costs) of Inpatient Maternity Services: Pitfalls for the Unwary
This study investigates the process of planning for future inpatient resources (beds, staff and costs) for maternity (pregnancy and childbirth) services. The process of planning is approached from a patient centered philosophy; hence, how do we discharge a suitably rested healthy mother who is fully capable of caring for the newborn baby back into the community. It demonstrates some of the difficulties in predicting future births and investigates trends in the average length of stay. While it is relatively easy to document longer-term (past) trends in births and the conditions relating to pregnancy and birth, it is exceedingly difficult to predict the future nature of such trends. The issue of optimum average bed occupancy is addressed via the Erlang B equation which links number of beds, average bed occupancy and turn-away. Turn-away is the proportion of times that there is not an immediately available bed for the next arriving inpatient. Economy of scale implied by queuing theory (and the implied role of population density) explains why many well intended community-based schemes fail to gain traction. The paper also addresses some of the erroneous ideas around the dogma that reducing length of stay ‘saves’ money. Maternity departments are encouraged to understand how their costs are calculated to avoid the trap where it is suggested by others that in reducing the length of stay, they will reduce costs and increase ‘efficiency’. Indeed, up to 60% of calculated maternity ‘costs’ are apportioned hospital overheads from supporting departments such as finance, personnel, buildings and grounds, IT, information, etc., along with depreciation charges on the hospital-wide buildings and equipment. These costs, “the fixed costs dilemma”, are totally beyond the control of the maternity department and will vary by hospital depending on how these costs are apportioned to the maternity unit. Premature discharge, one of the unfortunate outcomes of turn-away, is demonstrated to shift maternity costs into the pediatric and neonatal departments as ‘boomerang babies’ then require the cost of avoidable inpatient care. Examples are given from the English NHS of how misdirected government policy can create unforeseen problems.
- Open Access
- 6 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 21 (8) , 1035
A New Approach for Understanding International Hospital Bed Numbers and Application to Local Area Bed Demand and Capacity Planning
Three models/methods are given to understand the extreme international variation in available and occupied hospital bed numbers. These models/methods all rely on readily available data. In the first, occupied beds (rather than available beds) are used to measure the expressed demand for hospital beds. The expressed occupied bed demand for three countries was in the order Australia > England > USA. Next, the age-standardized mortality rate (ASMR) has dual functions. Less developed countries/regions have low access to healthcare, which results in high ASMR, or a negative slope between ASMR versus available/occupied beds. In the more developed countries, high ASMR can also be used to measure the ‘need’ for healthcare (including occupied beds), a positive slope among various social (wealth/lifestyle) groups, which will include Indigenous peoples. In England, a 100-unit increase in ASMR (European Standard population) leads to a 15.3–30.7 (feasible range) unit increase in occupied beds per 1000 deaths. Higher ASMR shows why the Australian states of the Northern Territory and Tasmania have an intrinsic higher bed demand. The USA has a high relative ASMR (for a developed/wealthy country) because healthcare is not universal in the widest sense. Lastly, a method for benchmarking the whole hospital’s average bed occupancy which enables them to run at optimum efficiency and safety. English hospitals operate at highly disruptive and unsafe levels of bed occupancy, manifesting as high ‘turn-away’. Turn-away implies bed unavailability for the next arriving patient. In the case of occupied beds, the slope of the relationship between occupied beds per 1000 deaths and deaths per 1000 population shows a power law function. Scatter around the trend line arising from year-to-year fluctuations in occupied beds per 1000 deaths, ASMR, deaths per 1000 population, changes in the number of persons hidden in the elective, outpatient and diagnostic waiting lists, and local area variation in births affecting maternity, neonatal, and pediatric bed demand. Additional variation will arise from differences in the level of local funding for social care, especially elderly care. The problems associated with crafting effective bed planning are illustrated using the English NHS as an example.
- 6 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 21 (8) , 1035
Open AccessA New Approach for Understanding International Hospital Bed Numbers and Application to Local Area Bed Demand and Capacity Planning
Three models/methods are given to understand the extreme international variation in available and occupied hospital bed numbers. These models/methods all rely on readily available data. In the first, occupied beds (rather than available beds) are used to measure the expressed demand for hospital beds. The expressed occupied bed demand for three countries was in the order Australia > England > USA. Next, the age-standardized mortality rate (ASMR) has dual functions. Less developed countries/regions have low access to healthcare, which results in high ASMR, or a negative slope between ASMR versus available/occupied beds. In the more developed countries, high ASMR can also be used to measure the ‘need’ for healthcare (including occupied beds), a positive slope among various social (wealth/lifestyle) groups, which will include Indigenous peoples. In England, a 100-unit increase in ASMR (European Standard population) leads to a 15.3–30.7 (feasible range) unit increase in occupied beds per 1000 deaths. Higher ASMR shows why the Australian states of the Northern Territory and Tasmania have an intrinsic higher bed demand. The USA has a high relative ASMR (for a developed/wealthy country) because healthcare is not universal in the widest sense. Lastly, a method for benchmarking the whole hospital’s average bed occupancy which enables them to run at optimum efficiency and safety. English hospitals operate at highly disruptive and unsafe levels of bed occupancy, manifesting as high ‘turn-away’. Turn-away implies bed unavailability for the next arriving patient. In the case of occupied beds, the slope of the relationship between occupied beds per 1000 deaths and deaths per 1000 population shows a power law function. Scatter around the trend line arising from year-to-year fluctuations in occupied beds per 1000 deaths, ASMR, deaths per 1000 population, changes in the number of persons hidden in the elective, outpatient and diagnostic waiting lists, and local area variation in births affecting maternity, neonatal, and pediatric bed demand. Additional variation will arise from differences in the level of local funding for social care, especially elderly care. The problems associated with crafting effective bed planning are illustrated using the English NHS as an example.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
A New Approach for Understanding International Hospital Bed Numbers and Application to Local Area Bed Demand and Capacity Planning
A new model for international bed numbers is applied to local area populations for English Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) where the Age Standardized Mortality Rate (ASMR) is used as a measure of population health and hence for total occupied hospital bed demand (elective plus emergency admission types, including acute, rehabilitation, mental health, and maternity), rather than simple bed availability. A 100-unit increase in ASMR (European Standard population) leads to a 15.3 – 30.7 (feasible range) unit increase in occupied beds per 1,000 deaths. ASMR shows why the Australian states of the Northern Territory and Tasmania have an intrinsic higher bed demand than the other states – although in both cases the bed planning methodologies failed to indicate this need and both states show a large bed deficit. Due to the high volatility in bed demand the average bed demand for 2019 was determined by a linear trend using data for 2014/15 to 2019/20 — as the pre-COVID-19 baseline. The slope of the relationship between occupied beds per 1,000 deaths and deaths per 1,000 population shows a power law function. As is to be expected there is scatter around the trend line which will partly arise from uncertainty in the expected occupied beds in 2019, fluctuations in both ASMR and deaths per 1,000 population from one year to another, changes in the number of persons on the elective, outpatient and diagnostic waiting lists, and local area variation in births and consequently upon maternity, neonatal and pediatric bed demand. Additional variation in bed demand will arise from differences in the level of funding for social care, especially elderly care, and to a lesser extent upon patients using private health care, and charitable hospices for palliative care. However, after including the change in bed demand arising from ASMR the model is sufficiently accurate to identify gross differences in bed demand as a prelude to further investigation. The model requires further extension to cover specialty-level demand, and perhaps segregation between elective and emergency types of inpatient demand. A method for benchmarking the whole hospital’s average bed occupancy is given which enables them to run at optimum efficiency and safety. Using this method English hospitals can be shown to operate at highly disruptive and unsafe levels of bed occupancy leading to deleterious ‘turn-away’. Turn-away implies bed unavailability for the next arriving patient. The problems associated with crafting effective bed planning are illustrated using the English NHS as an example.
- 22 May 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessA New Approach for Understanding International Hospital Bed Numbers and Application to Local Area Bed Demand and Capacity Planning
A new model for international bed numbers is applied to local area populations for English Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) where the Age Standardized Mortality Rate (ASMR) is used as a measure of population health and hence for total occupied hospital bed demand (elective plus emergency admission types, including acute, rehabilitation, mental health, and maternity), rather than simple bed availability. A 100-unit increase in ASMR (European Standard population) leads to a 15.3 – 30.7 (feasible range) unit increase in occupied beds per 1,000 deaths. ASMR shows why the Australian states of the Northern Territory and Tasmania have an intrinsic higher bed demand than the other states – although in both cases the bed planning methodologies failed to indicate this need and both states show a large bed deficit. Due to the high volatility in bed demand the average bed demand for 2019 was determined by a linear trend using data for 2014/15 to 2019/20 — as the pre-COVID-19 baseline. The slope of the relationship between occupied beds per 1,000 deaths and deaths per 1,000 population shows a power law function. As is to be expected there is scatter around the trend line which will partly arise from uncertainty in the expected occupied beds in 2019, fluctuations in both ASMR and deaths per 1,000 population from one year to another, changes in the number of persons on the elective, outpatient and diagnostic waiting lists, and local area variation in births and consequently upon maternity, neonatal and pediatric bed demand. Additional variation in bed demand will arise from differences in the level of funding for social care, especially elderly care, and to a lesser extent upon patients using private health care, and charitable hospices for palliative care. However, after including the change in bed demand arising from ASMR the model is sufficiently accurate to identify gross differences in bed demand as a prelude to further investigation. The model requires further extension to cover specialty-level demand, and perhaps segregation between elective and emergency types of inpatient demand. A method for benchmarking the whole hospital’s average bed occupancy is given which enables them to run at optimum efficiency and safety. Using this method English hospitals can be shown to operate at highly disruptive and unsafe levels of bed occupancy leading to deleterious ‘turn-away’. Turn-away implies bed unavailability for the next arriving patient. The problems associated with crafting effective bed planning are illustrated using the English NHS as an example.