Clayton Ó Néill
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Clayton Ó Néill has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anne-Maree Farrell
Edinburgh Law School, University of Edinburgh, Old College South Bridge, Edinburgh EH8 9YL UK
2 shared publications - Mary Donnelly
School of Law, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland
2 shared publications - Mary-Elizabeth Tumelty
School of Law, University College Cork
2 shared publications - Andrea Mulligan
School of Law Trinity College Dublin Dublin Ireland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (4) , 352-364
Anonymity beyond the Courtroom: Abbasi and Another v. Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust; Haastrup v. King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15
The United Kingdom Supreme Court (UKSC) decision in Abbasi and another v Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust; Haastrup v King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15 is explored in this case commentary. The UKSC clarified the legal basis and duration of reporting restriction orders that protect clinicians’ anonymity in cases where disputes exist in relation to the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment of children. The commentary evaluates the manner in which the court treats the relationship between the court’s inherent jurisdiction, the Human Rights Act 1998 and the competing rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, notably Articles 8 (the right to respect for private and family life) and Article 10 (freedom of expression). It is now clear that continued anonymity must be based on established domestic causes of action and must normally be limited in time. However, it is contended that the UKSC has adopted an excessively formalistic approach to risk. By stressing that individualised evidence of harm must exist before anonymity can be extended, the UKSC’s approach does not sufficiently recognise the anticipatory and systemic risks that clinicians face, especially in an era of online harassment and social media. It is concluded in the commentary that, even though the UKSC has strengthened constitutional coherence and the principle of open justice, important questions about how the law ought to respond to foreseeable, collective harms in healthcare remain unresolved.
- 18 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (4) , 352-364
Open AccessAnonymity beyond the Courtroom: Abbasi and Another v. Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust; Haastrup v. King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15
The United Kingdom Supreme Court (UKSC) decision in Abbasi and another v Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust; Haastrup v King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15 is explored in this case commentary. The UKSC clarified the legal basis and duration of reporting restriction orders that protect clinicians’ anonymity in cases where disputes exist in relation to the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment of children. The commentary evaluates the manner in which the court treats the relationship between the court’s inherent jurisdiction, the Human Rights Act 1998 and the competing rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, notably Articles 8 (the right to respect for private and family life) and Article 10 (freedom of expression). It is now clear that continued anonymity must be based on established domestic causes of action and must normally be limited in time. However, it is contended that the UKSC has adopted an excessively formalistic approach to risk. By stressing that individualised evidence of harm must exist before anonymity can be extended, the UKSC’s approach does not sufficiently recognise the anticipatory and systemic risks that clinicians face, especially in an era of online harassment and social media. It is concluded in the commentary that, even though the UKSC has strengthened constitutional coherence and the principle of open justice, important questions about how the law ought to respond to foreseeable, collective harms in healthcare remain unresolved.
- Open Access
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 34 (3)
Welfare paternalism and the paradox of protection: towards a rights-based framework to mediate the deprivation of liberty of children
This article examines the acute ambiguity in the law governing the deprivation of liberty of children in England and Wales, where protective interventions often rely on judicial direction and on unclear statutory safeguards. It is argued that the current framework is reactive, welfare-driven, and lacking in procedural coherence. Drawing upon Fineman’s theory of vulnerability, Fraser’s parity of participation, and Lundy’s analysis of children’s agency in relation to the participatory guarantees of Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, the article reconceptualizes vulnerability and rejects the paternalistic protection ethos of the status quo. The article exposes structural gaps in the light of a shifting legal landscape. This backdrop includes the Supreme Court’s recent 2026 move away from the rigid, single-determinant tests for confinement towards contextual, multifactorial assessments. It proposes an original statutory architecture: the Children’s Liberty Protection Framework (CLPF) that establishes statutory mechanisms of advocacy, review, and oversight at Tribunal level. The CLPF transforms vulnerability from being a control-based condition into a procedural right to participate. As such, it offers a coherent legal pathway for reconciling the challenges posed by the right to liberty and the need to protect children within a supportive and responsive state.
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 34 (3)
Open AccessWelfare paternalism and the paradox of protection: towards a rights-based framework to mediate the deprivation of liberty of children
This article examines the acute ambiguity in the law governing the deprivation of liberty of children in England and Wales, where protective interventions often rely on judicial direction and on unclear statutory safeguards. It is argued that the current framework is reactive, welfare-driven, and lacking in procedural coherence. Drawing upon Fineman’s theory of vulnerability, Fraser’s parity of participation, and Lundy’s analysis of children’s agency in relation to the participatory guarantees of Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, the article reconceptualizes vulnerability and rejects the paternalistic protection ethos of the status quo. The article exposes structural gaps in the light of a shifting legal landscape. This backdrop includes the Supreme Court’s recent 2026 move away from the rigid, single-determinant tests for confinement towards contextual, multifactorial assessments. It proposes an original statutory architecture: the Children’s Liberty Protection Framework (CLPF) that establishes statutory mechanisms of advocacy, review, and oversight at Tribunal level. The CLPF transforms vulnerability from being a control-based condition into a procedural right to participate. As such, it offers a coherent legal pathway for reconciling the challenges posed by the right to liberty and the need to protect children within a supportive and responsive state.
- Open Access
- 26 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (4) , 302-329
Who am I? Self-Fulfilment and the Persisting Evolving Self: Decision-Making and Ireland’s Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015
The article proposes a framework for understanding personhood in the context of cognitive decline, called the persisting evolving self, emphasising selfhood and continuity. It uses the new Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 (ADMCA) in Ireland as a vehicle through which this way of conceptualising the self, and the rights assigned to it, can be assessed. The case study of ‘Martha’, who has dementia, is used to highlight the development of the law in Ireland from the Ward of Court system to the support-based tiered mechanisms inherent in the Act. It contends that the ADMCA involves a powerful and empowering paradigm shift from best interests standards to a rights-based approach. This new approach is based on the concepts of autonomy, support and will and preferences. The article evaluates the ADMCA through the vista of Alan Gewirth’s Principle of Generic Consistency (PGC). Furthermore, the practical realities of the Act’s tiered support mechanisms are balanced with people’s lived experiences of diminishing capacities, as understood within the PGC’s concept of agency. The persisting evolving self builds upon and reconceptualises the Gewirthian concept of ‘self-fulfilment’.
- 26 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (4) , 302-329
Open AccessWho am I? Self-Fulfilment and the Persisting Evolving Self: Decision-Making and Ireland’s Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015
The article proposes a framework for understanding personhood in the context of cognitive decline, called the persisting evolving self, emphasising selfhood and continuity. It uses the new Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 (ADMCA) in Ireland as a vehicle through which this way of conceptualising the self, and the rights assigned to it, can be assessed. The case study of ‘Martha’, who has dementia, is used to highlight the development of the law in Ireland from the Ward of Court system to the support-based tiered mechanisms inherent in the Act. It contends that the ADMCA involves a powerful and empowering paradigm shift from best interests standards to a rights-based approach. This new approach is based on the concepts of autonomy, support and will and preferences. The article evaluates the ADMCA through the vista of Alan Gewirth’s Principle of Generic Consistency (PGC). Furthermore, the practical realities of the Act’s tiered support mechanisms are balanced with people’s lived experiences of diminishing capacities, as understood within the PGC’s concept of agency. The persisting evolving self builds upon and reconceptualises the Gewirthian concept of ‘self-fulfilment’.
- Open Access
- 6 February 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (2) , 175-180
Book review: Adult Social Care Law and Policy: Lessons from the Pandemic Adult Social Care Law and Policy: Lessons from the Pandemic, McHaleJean VNoszlopyLaura (Bristol, Bristol University Press, 2025), 364 pp., £27.99, ISBN 9781529229868.
- 6 February 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (2) , 175-180
Open AccessBook review: Adult Social Care Law and Policy: Lessons from the Pandemic Adult Social Care Law and Policy: Lessons from the Pandemic, McHaleJean VNoszlopyLaura (Bristol, Bristol University Press, 2025), 364 pp., £27.99, ISBN 9781529229868.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2023
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 74 (AD1) , 1-21
Promoting solidarity in contested political spaces and public health emergencies: examining Covid-19 vaccination on the island of Ireland
This article examines to what extent solidarity can be promoted in contested political spaces as part of mounting an effective response to public health emergencies. It examines the Covid-19 vaccination programmes in Ireland and Northern Ireland and identifies challenges in promoting solidarity in the island of Ireland. In these circumstances, it is suggested that a promising way forward in promoting solidaristic practices would encompass working from a baseline of shared health values, drawing upon (cross-border) institutional and jurisdictional support structures. Accordingly, building on a model set out by Prainsack and Buyx, we propose a tripartite solidarity framework which is not tiered or hierarchical in approach. Instead, it comprises three dimensions – jurisdictional, institutional and interpersonal – with shared health values operating as a centrifugal force.
- 12 May 2023
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 74 (AD1) , 1-21
Open AccessPromoting solidarity in contested political spaces and public health emergencies: examining Covid-19 vaccination on the island of Ireland
This article examines to what extent solidarity can be promoted in contested political spaces as part of mounting an effective response to public health emergencies. It examines the Covid-19 vaccination programmes in Ireland and Northern Ireland and identifies challenges in promoting solidarity in the island of Ireland. In these circumstances, it is suggested that a promising way forward in promoting solidaristic practices would encompass working from a baseline of shared health values, drawing upon (cross-border) institutional and jurisdictional support structures. Accordingly, building on a model set out by Prainsack and Buyx, we propose a tripartite solidarity framework which is not tiered or hierarchical in approach. Instead, it comprises three dimensions – jurisdictional, institutional and interpersonal – with shared health values operating as a centrifugal force.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Project MUSE in Irish Studies in International Affairs
- Vol. 34 (2) , 285-329
Health Law: Convergence and Divergence on the Island of Ireland
This article considers how health law operates on the island of Ireland, including some of its key issues: (1) capacity, (2) abortion and (3) clinical negligence. The healthcare and political context in both jurisdictions is discussed, as well as cross-border initiatives and arrangements. In relation to capacity, the article points to new legislation that has been introduced in the two jurisdictions and considers how it reflects (or does not reflect) the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Parallels and divergences of legislative change in respect of abortion are analysed, including approaches to process and implementation of change. The law on clinical negligence is critiqued in relation to standard of care, breach of duty, causation and quantum of damages and civil procedure. The article identifies convergences and divergences in terms of administration/procedure, legislation and context, but highlights a shared movement towards more human rights-oriented change and reform.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Project MUSE in Irish Studies in International Affairs
- Vol. 34 (2) , 285-329
Open AccessHealth Law: Convergence and Divergence on the Island of Ireland
This article considers how health law operates on the island of Ireland, including some of its key issues: (1) capacity, (2) abortion and (3) clinical negligence. The healthcare and political context in both jurisdictions is discussed, as well as cross-border initiatives and arrangements. In relation to capacity, the article points to new legislation that has been introduced in the two jurisdictions and considers how it reflects (or does not reflect) the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Parallels and divergences of legislative change in respect of abortion are analysed, including approaches to process and implementation of change. The law on clinical negligence is critiqued in relation to standard of care, breach of duty, causation and quantum of damages and civil procedure. The article identifies convergences and divergences in terms of administration/procedure, legislation and context, but highlights a shared movement towards more human rights-oriented change and reform.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 31 (1) , 25-46
‘THIS IS NO COUNTRY FOR OLD (WO)MEN’? AN EXAMINATION OF THE APPROACH TAKEN TO CARE HOME RESIDENTS DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
This article discusses the human rights of residents in care homes in England who were affected by restrictions that were imposed during the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic in order to safeguard health and life at a time of public health emergency. It focuses on the potentially adversarial relationship between the need to protect the health of these residents and the possible adverse interferences with their human rights in the initial phase of the pandemic. The scope and application of these rights to the healthcare context is not straightforward due to the exigencies of the pandemic. Consideration is given to whether their rights, as protected by the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) are vindicated or breached by the actions taken in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. The article questions whether the restrictions that were applied were justified, given the limitations that exist within some ECHR Articles. It deliberates upon what can be done to ensure that relevant bodies and care homes, themselves, are better enabled to respond to a public health emergency in an individualistic, rights-based manner, based upon both principlism and pragmatism.
- 21 July 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 31 (1) , 25-46
Open Access‘THIS IS NO COUNTRY FOR OLD (WO)MEN’? AN EXAMINATION OF THE APPROACH TAKEN TO CARE HOME RESIDENTS DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
This article discusses the human rights of residents in care homes in England who were affected by restrictions that were imposed during the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic in order to safeguard health and life at a time of public health emergency. It focuses on the potentially adversarial relationship between the need to protect the health of these residents and the possible adverse interferences with their human rights in the initial phase of the pandemic. The scope and application of these rights to the healthcare context is not straightforward due to the exigencies of the pandemic. Consideration is given to whether their rights, as protected by the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) are vindicated or breached by the actions taken in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. The article questions whether the restrictions that were applied were justified, given the limitations that exist within some ECHR Articles. It deliberates upon what can be done to ensure that relevant bodies and care homes, themselves, are better enabled to respond to a public health emergency in an individualistic, rights-based manner, based upon both principlism and pragmatism.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2022
- Published by Brill in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. 29 (2) , 240-259
COVID-19 Vaccination and Legal Preparedness: Lessons from Ireland
Ireland has been a leader in the COVID-19 vaccine rollout in the EU, with almost 80% of the eligible population (aged over 5 years) fully vaccinated at the time of writing. The success of the vaccine rollout in this jurisdiction notwithstanding, the legal frameworks supporting the rollout had significant lacunas. Two aspects in particular highlighted a lack of legal preparedness: the inadequacy of the legal framework for consent and the absence of a vaccine injury redress scheme. This paper explores these components of the COVID-19 vaccine rollout through the lens of legal preparedness. Whilst most often discussed in the context of command and control measures such as social distancing requirements and regional lockdowns, this paper argues for an expanded understanding of what it means to be legally prepared, highlighting the importance of the preparedness of domestic legal frameworks.
- 4 March 2022
- Published by Brill in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. 29 (2) , 240-259
Open AccessCOVID-19 Vaccination and Legal Preparedness: Lessons from Ireland
Ireland has been a leader in the COVID-19 vaccine rollout in the EU, with almost 80% of the eligible population (aged over 5 years) fully vaccinated at the time of writing. The success of the vaccine rollout in this jurisdiction notwithstanding, the legal frameworks supporting the rollout had significant lacunas. Two aspects in particular highlighted a lack of legal preparedness: the inadequacy of the legal framework for consent and the absence of a vaccine injury redress scheme. This paper explores these components of the COVID-19 vaccine rollout through the lens of legal preparedness. Whilst most often discussed in the context of command and control measures such as social distancing requirements and regional lockdowns, this paper argues for an expanded understanding of what it means to be legally prepared, highlighting the importance of the preparedness of domestic legal frameworks.
- Open Access
- 18 January 2021
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 71 (4) , 695-698
Book review
- 18 January 2021
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 71 (4) , 695-698
Open AccessBook review