SLSheina Lew-Levy

Sheina Lew-Levy

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sheina Lew-Levy has a total of 250 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Source selection shapes the strength of cultural transmission pathways

    by Sherilyn Segura, Wouter van Den Bos, Andrea Gradassi, Esra Cemre Su de Groot, Lucia Hendrikse, Lieke Hofmans, Fleur Francien Adrienne Korzilius, Sheina Lew-Levy, Ana da Silva Pinho, Scarlett Slagter, et al.

    Human culture depends on people learning from one another. Cultural evolutionary theory distinguishes three transmission pathways: learning from parents (vertical), non-parental adults (oblique), and peers (horizontal), which differ in how rapidly information spreads within and across generations. During middle childhood, children's social worlds expand beyond the family, creating opportunities for all three pathways to operate simultaneously, yet their relative strength has rarely been compared directly. Using 1,262 dyads of 6-13 year-olds and their parents, we examined the relative strength of vertical, oblique, and horizontal transmission in two complementary behavioral experiments. Participants either received information from, or chose between, their own parent or child, an unrelated adult or child, and a peer while completing an estimation task. This design allowed us to separate two components of cultural transmission: whom people choose to learn from and how strongly they use information once it has been acquired. Vertical transmission emerged as the strongest pathway. This advantage was driven primarily by source selection, as children and parents overwhelmingly selected one another as information sources, with parents learning from their own child providing evidence for reverse vertical transmission. Once information had been acquired, however, information weighting differed little between vertical, oblique, and horizontal transmission. Instead, developmental differences dominated: social information use declined markedly across middle childhood and remained consistently higher in children than in parents. Together, these findings suggest that the relative strength of cultural transmission pathways is determined primarily by source selection rather than information weighting.

  • Open Access

    A Practical Guide to Cross-Cultural Research with eHRAF

    by Zachary H Garfield, Rohan Kapitány, Sheina Lew-Levy

    The electronic Human Relations Area Files (eHRAF) World Cultures database indexes primary ethnographic documents at the paragraph level, allowing researchers to assemble systematic samples of text on a wide range of topics and across diverse societies. Unlike some other cross-cultural databases, eHRAF does not provide precoded society-level variables. It provides source text from which researchers can construct variables, and as such offers researchers greater flexibility in their ability to operationalize variables. We present an eight-step workflow for building a coded cross-cultural dataset from eHRAF: 1) formulating a question suited to the ethnographic record; 2) selecting Outline of Cultural Materials codes and constructing a search; 3) defining the unit of analysis and data structure; 4) addressing research ethics and working within the terms of service; 5) assembling a database; 6) developing and piloting a coding scheme; 7) training coders and assessing reliability; and 8) analyzing nested data. Drawing on our published research and experience supervising student projects, we identify common challenges, offer practical guidelines, and provide a reporting checklist. The workflow is intended to make eHRAF-based research more accessible and prevalent within the fields of behavioral and cultural research, while facilitating a more systematic, transparent, and reproducible approach.

  • Open Access

    Developmental and social variation in spatial behavior among BaYaka hunter-gatherers

    by Sarah Pope-Caldwell, Lee Gettler, Adam Boyette, Yann R. Ouamba, Alyssa N. Crittenden, Sheina Lew-Levy

    Effectively choosing between exploring alternative strategies versus exploiting familiar ones is a keyaspect of adaptive behavior. Previous research suggests that exploration in early life gives way tomore targeted exploitation with age. Further, group composition can shape one’s propensity forexploration and exploitation. Yet, few studies have investigated how individual cognitivedevelopment and collective intelligence articulate to help resolve the explore-exploit dilemma in real-world contexts. Here, we investigated spatial behavior in BaYaka hunter-gatherer children and adultsfrom the Republic of the Congo. We used 337 foraging GPS tracks collected across 42 days toinvestigate how individual age and group composition (child-only, mixed-age, adult-only) predictedsix spatial behaviors during real-world foraging bouts. We found that children's foraging paths weremore sinuous—that is, most exploratory—when travelling with peers than with adults. In contrast,mixed-age groups travelled further and covered more unique ground than child-only groups. Wesuggest that this may be indicative of distinct learning goals across foraging social contexts. Wefurther propose that child-only exploration alongside more adult-like exploitation may operate ascomplementary components of an age-graded division of cognitive labor, with discoveries made bychildren during exploratory foraging informing adults' subsequent resource exploitation.

  • Open Access

    Playing at scale: a long-term population perspective on the relationship between play and innovation

    by Elena Miu, Marc Malmdorf Andersen, Iulia Badescu, Cedric Boeckx, Camilla Cenni, Jean Baptiste Leca, Sheina Lew-Levy, Elodie Lepaludier, Luseadra Joy McKerracher, Mathilde Vestergaard Meyer, et al.

    The multifaceted relationship between play and innovation has long fascinated scholars across disciplines. Yet, we lack robust empirical evidence regarding the causal pathways that may connect these two behavioural concepts. While much work has revolved around how play might drive innovation in childhood, there has been little focus on how play might contribute to transformative societal innovation. Studies investigating play and innovation have taken a short-term synchronic perspective to innovation and have focused mainly on invention (i.e. the first instance of a novel behaviour), interested in how play might increase behavioural flexibility and problem-solving skills. Although these approaches cannot speak to population-level innovation (i.e. novel information that spreads across groups), evidence from such studies is often marshalled to support claims about the role of play for societal innovation dynamics over time. Here we propose that the link between play and population innovation has not been robustly demonstrated because of 1. a lack of precise specification of the causal pathways linking the two and 2. a mismatch between the scale on which play is measured and the scale on which population-level innovation operates. We narrow in on a specific kind of play (object play), a specific life history period (childhood), and a specific kind of innovation (population-level), and introduce a causal framework highlighting long-term processes to understand the state-of-the-art knowledge landscape and to guide future work. We synthesise three mechanistic pathways linking the children’s play and population-level innovation: exploration, development, and cultural evolution. We design formal causal diagrams that link children’s play and population-level innovation via the three mechanisms we identified, and consider potential confounds relevant to each. Our explicit long-term populational perspective on the link between play and innovation sheds light on productive means to move the field forward.

  • Open Access

    Youth physical activity in transitioning subsistence societies varies by biological maturity and market integration

    by Lee Gettler, Vidrige Kandza, Jessica K. Hlay, Haneul Jang, Rahul C. Oka, Francy Kiabiya Ntamboudila, Derlan Brenez Bihoundou Mouketou, Chelvin Destin Siassia Vindou, Evrahd Ngalekandza, Brel Koubemba, et al.

    Background: Physical activity patterns across childhood and adolescence help shape long-term health and contribute to the allocation of limited resources among growth, maintenance, and reproduction during maturation. The vast majority of data on youth physical activity comes from post/industrial societies. We know relatively little about youth physical activity in smaller-scale subsistence contexts where youth routinely contribute to production and household tasks under energetically demanding conditions. Methods: Using wearable technology, we measured moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) and sedentary behavior among BaYaka forager and Bantu fisher-farmer youth (N=206; obs. days=798) in the Congo Basin. These communities live under energetically-demanding conditions and varying degrees of early market integration. Results: Youth were highly physically active, averaging 4.07 hours of daily MVPA. Forager females had the highest routine MVPA, although foragers were more sedentary than farmers. Developmentally, youth who were more pubertally advanced engaged in a lower percentage of daily MVPA, and older youth were more sedentary. Youth residing in the most market-integrated village engaged in a lower percentage of daily MVPA compared to the least-integrated village. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that youth facultatively adjust their activity levels as they biologically mature and that physical activity is lower with incipient market integration. The routinely high levels of youth physical activity in these communities underscore the gap between subsistence lifestyles in energetically-demanding environments and physical activity in post/industrialized societies. From a global public health perspective, our findings highlight a crucial window during early economic transitions for public health interventions aimed at preventing physical inactivity and the chronic disease burden associated with lifestyle shifts.

  • Open Access

    No evidence for the age-based imitation bias in a culturally diverse sample

    by Sheina Lew-Levy, Jing Xu, Sarah Pope-Caldwell, Claire Sutherland, Francy Kiabiya Ntamboudila, Wouter van Den Bos, Kathleen H. Corriveau, Natalia Bezerra Dutra, Emma Flynn, Eoin O'SUllivan, et al.

    Humans possess learning biases that guide them to imitate individuals likely to hold adaptive information. One proposed bias—the age-based imitation bias—suggests that children preferentially imitate adults over peers because adults are presumed to have greater instrumental and conventional competence. Although supported by studies with young children from the post-industrialized west, this bias has not been examined across broader developmental ranges or diverse cultural contexts. Therefore, here we investigated adult versus peer imitation in 369 children aged 3–17 years from four communities: Congolese BaYaka, Congolese Bandongo, Scots, and Chinese Americans. Across instrumental and conventional tasks, we found no evidence that children preferentially imitated adults over peers. These null findings may reflect an existing publication bias in the social learning literature. They also raise the possibility that reported age-based effects may have been activated by the presence of other state- and model-based biases embedded within previous experiments.

  • Open Access

    The development of subsistence effort and skill among BaYaka foragers

    by Sheina Lew-Levy, Erik Ringen, Lucie Benoit, Yann R. Ouamba, Adam Boyette, Sarah Pope-Caldwell, Lee Gettler, Alyssa N. Crittenden

    Why humans have such long childhoods is an evolutionary puzzle. Childhood may represent a developmental period for the acquisition of cognitive and physical skills needed to exploit the complex hunted and gathered resources typical of our species’ subsistence niche. Childhood may also be an extended period for cooperating with kin, and by extension, reaping inclusive fitness benefits. Studies in contemporary hunter-gatherer communities show that subsistence proficiency peaks in adulthood. Yet, there is considerable inter-individual variation in food returns, with some children efficiently collecting specific resources from a young age, and others exceeding their daily caloric needs. To understand why some children are more productive than others, here we investigate the association between subsistence effort and skill development among Congo Basin BaYaka foragers. BaYaka rely on hunting, gathering, fishing, and small-scale horticulture for subsistence. We measured subsistence effort and food production over a six-week period in a forest camp with 52 residents aged 0 to 70 years. We analyzed these data using a Bayesian latent hierarchical model. We found that 50% of subsistence skill was achieved by age 15. Both subsistence skill and effort peaked in adulthood. Further, we found a negative age-adjusted correlation between effort and skill, suggesting that lower-skilled individuals participated in subsistence more frequently. Overall, our findings show that children can meaningfully reduce day-to-day dependence on adults, which over evolutionary time, may have helped offset the cost of extended human childhood.

  • Toward an integrated study of peer cultures

    by Sheina Lew-Levy, Dorsa Amir

    In our target article, we proposed that children are not merely recipients of adult culture but actively produce and maintain their own peer cultures, which may help communities navigate rare yet pivotal episodes of social and ecological change. Commentaries from across the social and biological sciences expanded this framework, situating peer cultures within developmental, evolutionary, and comparative contexts. They emphasized the diversity of peer cultures, the communicative systems and transmission mechanisms that sustain them, and introduced new approaches for identifying them – from formal evolutionary models to research in non-human species and the archaeological record. In this response, we synthesize and build on these contributions by addressing questions about the scope and influence of peer cultures within the broader processes of cultural evolution and by outlining future directions for a more unified, cross-disciplinary science of peer cultures.


  • Open Access

    Parental perspectives on children’s social learning in four cultures

    by Jing Xu, Lara Wood, Claire Sutherland, Sarah Pope-Caldwell, Olivier Mboumba, Armel Elenga Ondaye, Grace Revenant Ngoma, Roger Ndenguele, Francy Kiabiya Ntamboudila, Sheina Lew-Levy

    Social learning is key to the accumulation and transmission of cultural knowledge that underpins human evolutionary success. Cultural context is critical for understanding the content, mechanisms, and pathways through which social learning occurs. Although parents constitute an important part of children’s social environment, parental perspectives on children’s social learning across cultures are understudied. Here, we worked with BaYaka and Bandongo living in the Republic of the Congo, Scots living in Tayside, United Kingdom, and Chinese Americans living in the Greater Seattle Area, United States, representing considerable diversity across ecological, economic, social, and cultural dimensions. 303 parents/guardians answered free-list and open-ended questions regarding what and how children should learn from peers and adults. Across cultures, parents consistently reported that children should learn from adults via mechanisms like imitation and teaching, but with peers via collaboration. In terms of learning content, BaYaka and Bandongo parents more often reported that children should learn tasks, whereas Scottish and Chinese American parents focused on qualities and values. Overall, parental reports reveal cross-cultural regularities in normative social learning mechanisms, while systematic differences in content highlight the importance of accounting for cultural context when studying the interaction between how, what, and from whom children learn.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    The social learning and development of intra- and inter-ethnic sharing norms in the Congo Basin

    by Sheina Lew-Levy, Luke Maurits, Adam H. Boyette, Kate Ellis-Davies, Daniel Haun, Wilson Vieira, Ardain Dzabatou, Bienvenue Mbongo, Francy Kiabiya Ntamboudila, Roger Ndenguele, et al.

    Compared to other species, the extent of human cooperation is unparalleled. Such cooperation is coordinated between community members via social norms. Developmental research has demonstrated that very young children are sensitive to social norms, and that social norms are internalized by middle childhood. Most research on social norm acquisition has focused on norms that modulate intra-group cooperation. Yet around the world, multi-ethnic communities also cooperate, and this cooperation is often shaped by distinct inter-group social norms. In the present study, we investigated whether intra-ethnic and inter-ethnic social norm acquisition follows the same, or distinct, developmental trajectories. Specifically, we worked with BaYaka foragers and Bandongo fisher-farmers who inhabit multi-ethnic villages in the Republic of the Congo. In these villages, inter-ethnic cooperation is regulated by sharing norms. Based on our ethnographic knowledge of the participating communities, we predicted that children’s intra-ethnic sharing choices would match those of adults at an earlier age than their inter-ethnic sharing choices. To test this prediction, children (5–17 years) and adults (17 + years) participated in a modified Dictator Game to investigate the developmental trajectories of children’s intra- and inter-ethnic sharing choices. Contrary to our prediction, both intra- and inter-ethnic sharing norms were acquired in middle childhood. Interviews with adult participants suggested that intra- and inter-ethnic sharing norms are acquired from multiple sources, including parents and peers. Further, Bandongo adults primarily reported learning sharing norms via Instruction, whereas BaYaka adults primarily reported learning via Observation/Imitation. These cross-cultural differences may reflect variation in norm complexity. Together, these findings suggest that when social contexts regularly expose children to out-group collaboration, inter-ethnic norms are acquired at similar timelines to intra-ethnic ones, as part of children’s broader cooperative repertoire.