Lounès Chikhi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Lounès Chikhi has a total of 563 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jordi Salmona
Centre de Recherche sur la Biodiversité et l’Environnement (CRBE), UMR5300 Université Toulouse, CNRS, IRD, Toulouse INP, Université Toulouse 3 Paul Sabatier (UT3), Toulouse, France
18 shared publications - Michael William Bruford
School of Biosciences, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom
15 shared publications - Olivier Mazet
Institut de Mathématiques de Toulouse, Université de Toulouse, Institut National des Sciences Appliquées , Toulouse 31077
15 shared publications - Gabriele Maria Sgarlata
Department of Evolution and Ecology University of California Davis California USA
12 shared publications Emmanuel Rasolondraibe
Département de Biologie Animale et Ecologie, Faculté des Sciences, Université de Mahajanga
11 shared publications- Vitor Sousa
Centre for Ecology, Evolution and Environmental Changes (cE3c) & CHANGE - Global Change and Sustainability Institute, Faculdade de Ciências da Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
11 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Exploring the only known case of sympatry in sportive lemurs: isolation by distance or speciation?
Among Madagascar primates, the sportive lemurs (family Lepilemuridae) have seen their species diversity increase from eight in 2005 to 26 in 2009 mostly by applying the phylogenetic species concept to DNA barcode data. Despite the genus being speciose, only one case of sympatry is known from northern Madagascar, where two sportive lemur species described based on low mtDNA divergence, Lepilemur ankaranensis and Lepilemur milanoii , were found to co-occur at the center of their joint distribution range. Here, to clarify the taxonomy of these two species and examine their sympatry, we apply an integrative taxonomic framework to genomic and morphological data from 84 individuals of L. ankaranensis and L. milanoii , encompassing their entire distribution range and the forest of Analafiana, beyond their southernmost limit. Using clustering, multivariate, and isolation by distance analyses, we find no evidence of a sympatric zone and show that despite clear genetic differentiation between regions, the genomic and morphological diversity of the L. ankaranensis - L. milanoii - Analafiana group is clinal and explained by geographic distance. These results clarify that L. milanoii is a junior synonym of L. ankaranensis and that the Analafiana forest population belongs to L. ankaranensis , extending its distribution. It further implies that the “sympatric” zone—the Andrafiamena forest—hosts conspecific individuals with slightly differentiated mtDNA backgrounds, rather than slightly differentiated sympatric species. Lastly, we re-evaluate the IUCN conservation metrics of L. ankaranensis , which continue to qualify as Endangered (EN) under the B1ab(i-v) criteria.
Open AccessExploring the only known case of sympatry in sportive lemurs: isolation by distance or speciation?
Among Madagascar primates, the sportive lemurs (family Lepilemuridae) have seen their species diversity increase from eight in 2005 to 26 in 2009 mostly by applying the phylogenetic species concept to DNA barcode data. Despite the genus being speciose, only one case of sympatry is known from northern Madagascar, where two sportive lemur species described based on low mtDNA divergence, Lepilemur ankaranensis and Lepilemur milanoii , were found to co-occur at the center of their joint distribution range. Here, to clarify the taxonomy of these two species and examine their sympatry, we apply an integrative taxonomic framework to genomic and morphological data from 84 individuals of L. ankaranensis and L. milanoii , encompassing their entire distribution range and the forest of Analafiana, beyond their southernmost limit. Using clustering, multivariate, and isolation by distance analyses, we find no evidence of a sympatric zone and show that despite clear genetic differentiation between regions, the genomic and morphological diversity of the L. ankaranensis - L. milanoii - Analafiana group is clinal and explained by geographic distance. These results clarify that L. milanoii is a junior synonym of L. ankaranensis and that the Analafiana forest population belongs to L. ankaranensis , extending its distribution. It further implies that the “sympatric” zone—the Andrafiamena forest—hosts conspecific individuals with slightly differentiated mtDNA backgrounds, rather than slightly differentiated sympatric species. Lastly, we re-evaluate the IUCN conservation metrics of L. ankaranensis , which continue to qualify as Endangered (EN) under the B1ab(i-v) criteria.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 35 (6) , e70299
Combining Population Genomics With Ancient DNA to Understand Island Colonisation History of the Madagascar Turtle Dove
The Mascarene archipelago (Mauritius, Reunion and Rodrigues), characterised by first human arrival being recent, offers a unique setting to study species colonisation on a recent timescale, and contribution of past human interventions. Here we use a combination of modern and ancient DNA data as a case study to investigate the colonisation history of a species of concern in relation to conservation programmes—the Madagascar turtle dove ( Nesoenas picturata ) on Mauritius and Reunion. We generated a reference genome and re‐sequenced genomes from contemporary N. picturata populations, as well as genome‐wide data from relevant subfossils. A combination of model‐free inferences, site frequency spectrum (SFS) based demographic modelling, and analyses of population structure including that of subfossils indicate that N. picturata colonised both islands independently and naturally from Madagascar, long before human arrival. Summary statistics and SFS‐based modelling reveal large effective population sizes ( Ne ) and high genetic diversity in island populations, conflicting with historical accounts of human‐induced demographic collapse. Based on goodness‐of‐fit, genetic structure and diversity indices do not discriminate between two best‐fitting models, one of which posits large recent Ne and negligible translocation rates, while the other supports recent severe bottlenecks followed by high post‐human translocation from Madagascar. Nonetheless, linkage disequilibrium provides stronger evidence for the latter scenario, which may also explain high genetic diversity. Both modern and ancient DNA data sources independently support the classification of N. picturata as native to both islands. Our findings highlight the potential of resolving colonisation history on timescales that have often been too recent for resolution, using a combination of different data sources, and by validating demographic models with multiple summary statistics.
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 35 (6) , e70299
Open AccessCombining Population Genomics With Ancient DNA to Understand Island Colonisation History of the Madagascar Turtle Dove
The Mascarene archipelago (Mauritius, Reunion and Rodrigues), characterised by first human arrival being recent, offers a unique setting to study species colonisation on a recent timescale, and contribution of past human interventions. Here we use a combination of modern and ancient DNA data as a case study to investigate the colonisation history of a species of concern in relation to conservation programmes—the Madagascar turtle dove ( Nesoenas picturata ) on Mauritius and Reunion. We generated a reference genome and re‐sequenced genomes from contemporary N. picturata populations, as well as genome‐wide data from relevant subfossils. A combination of model‐free inferences, site frequency spectrum (SFS) based demographic modelling, and analyses of population structure including that of subfossils indicate that N. picturata colonised both islands independently and naturally from Madagascar, long before human arrival. Summary statistics and SFS‐based modelling reveal large effective population sizes ( Ne ) and high genetic diversity in island populations, conflicting with historical accounts of human‐induced demographic collapse. Based on goodness‐of‐fit, genetic structure and diversity indices do not discriminate between two best‐fitting models, one of which posits large recent Ne and negligible translocation rates, while the other supports recent severe bottlenecks followed by high post‐human translocation from Madagascar. Nonetheless, linkage disequilibrium provides stronger evidence for the latter scenario, which may also explain high genetic diversity. Both modern and ancient DNA data sources independently support the classification of N. picturata as native to both islands. Our findings highlight the potential of resolving colonisation history on timescales that have often been too recent for resolution, using a combination of different data sources, and by validating demographic models with multiple summary statistics.
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genetics
- Vol. 232 (4)
Extending the IICR to complex nonstationary structured models
Population genetic studies use genetic data to understand aspects of the evolutionary history of species. Here, we extend the piecewise-homogeneous structured coalescent framework to complex models where the parameters of the model, and thus the state space, change between periods of constant gene flow. To do this, we introduce glue matrices to map one state space to another, hence enabling the computation of the inverse instantaneous coalescence rate (IICR) using Q-matrices of different dimensions. This approach allows us to study structured models where the number of demes changes forward in time due to extinction or foundation of demes. Our analysis confirms that interpreting IICR curves as indicators of changes in Ne can be misleading and that a robust theoretical framework is required to ensure the correct interpretation of coalescent-based inferential methods. We show that there are cases where new deme foundations can generate an increase in the IICR (forward in time) hence producing an intuitive change where an increase in the IICR follows an increase in the size of the population. However, when we explore the impact of changes in migration rates, timing of deme creation or deletion, and sampling strategies on the IICR, we also identify several counter-intuitive results , where changes in the IICR and the total size of the population appear disconnected. For instance, we find that the IICR starts to decrease several generations before any change in the number of demes, effectively anticipating the upcoming change. By presenting examples of IICRs for various transitions and sampling scenarios, we emphasize the importance of a thorough understanding of the IICR as a foundation for accurate demographic inference.
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genetics
- Vol. 232 (4)
Extending the IICR to complex nonstationary structured models
Population genetic studies use genetic data to understand aspects of the evolutionary history of species. Here, we extend the piecewise-homogeneous structured coalescent framework to complex models where the parameters of the model, and thus the state space, change between periods of constant gene flow. To do this, we introduce glue matrices to map one state space to another, hence enabling the computation of the inverse instantaneous coalescence rate (IICR) using Q-matrices of different dimensions. This approach allows us to study structured models where the number of demes changes forward in time due to extinction or foundation of demes. Our analysis confirms that interpreting IICR curves as indicators of changes in Ne can be misleading and that a robust theoretical framework is required to ensure the correct interpretation of coalescent-based inferential methods. We show that there are cases where new deme foundations can generate an increase in the IICR (forward in time) hence producing an intuitive change where an increase in the IICR follows an increase in the size of the population. However, when we explore the impact of changes in migration rates, timing of deme creation or deletion, and sampling strategies on the IICR, we also identify several counter-intuitive results , where changes in the IICR and the total size of the population appear disconnected. For instance, we find that the IICR starts to decrease several generations before any change in the number of demes, effectively anticipating the upcoming change. By presenting examples of IICRs for various transitions and sampling scenarios, we emphasize the importance of a thorough understanding of the IICR as a foundation for accurate demographic inference.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Evolutionary Applications
- Vol. 18 (10)
Estimating the Effective Population Size Across Space and Time in the Critically Endangered Western Chimpanzee in Guinea‐Bissau: Challenges and Implications for Conservation Management
The western chimpanzee ( Pan troglodytes verus ) is a Critically Endangered taxon. In Guinea‐Bissau (GB), the subspecies is increasingly threatened, but there is a lack of understanding regarding the degree of genetic threat faced by populations. This hinders the development of targeted conservation strategies and the prioritization of efforts by national agencies. In this study, we use microsatellite data from four parks located in southern GB and five whole‐genome sequences to estimate the effective population size ( N e ) and infer the recent and ancient demographic history of populations using different methods. We also aim to integrate the different N e estimates to improve our understanding of the evolutionary history and current demography of this great ape and to discuss the strengths and limitations of each estimator and their complementarity in informing conservation decisions. Results from the PSMC method suggest a large ancestral N e , likely due to ancient structure over the whole subspecies distribution until approximately 10,000–15,000 years ago. After that, a change in connectivity, a real decrease in size, or a combination of both occurred, which reduced the then still large ancestral population to a smaller size (MSVAR: ~10,000 decreasing to 1,000–6,000 breeding individuals), possibly indicating a fragmentation into coastal and inland subpopulations. In the most recent past, contemporary N e is close to 500 (GONE: 395–583, NeEstimator: 107–549), suggesting a high risk of extinction. The populations located at the coastal parks may have been small or isolated for several generations and are at higher risk, whereas the ones located inland exhibit higher long‐term N e and can be considered a stronghold for chimpanzee conservation. Through combining different types of molecular markers and analytical methodologies, we tried to overcome the limitations of obtaining high‐quality DNA samples from wild threatened populations and estimated N e at different temporal and spatial scales, which is crucial information to make informed conservation decisions at local and regional scales.
- 10 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Evolutionary Applications
- Vol. 18 (10)
Open AccessEstimating the Effective Population Size Across Space and Time in the Critically Endangered Western Chimpanzee in Guinea‐Bissau: Challenges and Implications for Conservation Management
The western chimpanzee ( Pan troglodytes verus ) is a Critically Endangered taxon. In Guinea‐Bissau (GB), the subspecies is increasingly threatened, but there is a lack of understanding regarding the degree of genetic threat faced by populations. This hinders the development of targeted conservation strategies and the prioritization of efforts by national agencies. In this study, we use microsatellite data from four parks located in southern GB and five whole‐genome sequences to estimate the effective population size ( N e ) and infer the recent and ancient demographic history of populations using different methods. We also aim to integrate the different N e estimates to improve our understanding of the evolutionary history and current demography of this great ape and to discuss the strengths and limitations of each estimator and their complementarity in informing conservation decisions. Results from the PSMC method suggest a large ancestral N e , likely due to ancient structure over the whole subspecies distribution until approximately 10,000–15,000 years ago. After that, a change in connectivity, a real decrease in size, or a combination of both occurred, which reduced the then still large ancestral population to a smaller size (MSVAR: ~10,000 decreasing to 1,000–6,000 breeding individuals), possibly indicating a fragmentation into coastal and inland subpopulations. In the most recent past, contemporary N e is close to 500 (GONE: 395–583, NeEstimator: 107–549), suggesting a high risk of extinction. The populations located at the coastal parks may have been small or isolated for several generations and are at higher risk, whereas the ones located inland exhibit higher long‐term N e and can be considered a stronghold for chimpanzee conservation. Through combining different types of molecular markers and analytical methodologies, we tried to overcome the limitations of obtaining high‐quality DNA samples from wild threatened populations and estimated N e at different temporal and spatial scales, which is crucial information to make informed conservation decisions at local and regional scales.
- Open Access
- 28 July 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (31)
The effect of habitat loss and fragmentation on isolation by distance and divergence
Natural habitats have undergone drastic changes in quality, continuity, and extent during the Pleistocene, influencing the distribution of many species. More recently, human activities have converted continuous habitats into fragmented and isolated patches. Recent meta-analyses suggest that habitat loss and fragmentation (HL&F) have negatively impacted the genetic diversity of species but very few studies have analyzed the consequences of HL&F on the spatial distribution of genetic diversity and on isolation by distance (IBD) patterns (i.e., correlations between genetic and geographical distances) observed in many species. In this work, we use spatial simulations to investigate the speed at which IBD patterns generated in continuous habitats are lost in a context of HL&F. We characterized the behavior of IBD in the case of i) instantaneous HL&F, ii) gradual (two-steps) HL&F, and iii) range expansion followed by instantaneous HL&F. In addition, we show that a spatially explicit theoretical framework based on previous IBD theoretical results can be modified and applied to a toroidal stepping-stone model undergoing HL&F. Our results suggest that IBD patterns can be maintained for long periods of time after HL&F, thus pointing to the long-term persistence of signatures associated to past habitat connectivity in the genetic diversity of many species, even if they went through major and sometimes ancient fragmentation events. This suggests that some present-day fragmented species, who still exhibit significant IBD patterns, may have been partly disconnected for very long periods, on the order of tens of thousands of years for species with long generation time.
- 28 July 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (31)
Open AccessThe effect of habitat loss and fragmentation on isolation by distance and divergence
Natural habitats have undergone drastic changes in quality, continuity, and extent during the Pleistocene, influencing the distribution of many species. More recently, human activities have converted continuous habitats into fragmented and isolated patches. Recent meta-analyses suggest that habitat loss and fragmentation (HL&F) have negatively impacted the genetic diversity of species but very few studies have analyzed the consequences of HL&F on the spatial distribution of genetic diversity and on isolation by distance (IBD) patterns (i.e., correlations between genetic and geographical distances) observed in many species. In this work, we use spatial simulations to investigate the speed at which IBD patterns generated in continuous habitats are lost in a context of HL&F. We characterized the behavior of IBD in the case of i) instantaneous HL&F, ii) gradual (two-steps) HL&F, and iii) range expansion followed by instantaneous HL&F. In addition, we show that a spatially explicit theoretical framework based on previous IBD theoretical results can be modified and applied to a toroidal stepping-stone model undergoing HL&F. Our results suggest that IBD patterns can be maintained for long periods of time after HL&F, thus pointing to the long-term persistence of signatures associated to past habitat connectivity in the genetic diversity of many species, even if they went through major and sometimes ancient fragmentation events. This suggests that some present-day fragmented species, who still exhibit significant IBD patterns, may have been partly disconnected for very long periods, on the order of tens of thousands of years for species with long generation time.
- Open Access
- 24 May 2025
- Published by Pivot Science Publications Corporation in Human Population Genetics and Genomics
- Vol. 5 (2)
On the Demographic History of Chimpanzees and Some Consequences of Integrating Population Structure in Chimpanzees and Other Great Apes
Reconstructing the evolutionary history of great apes is of particular importance for our understanding of the demographic history of humans. The reason for this is that modern humans and their hominin ancestors evolved in Africa and thus shared the continent with the ancestors of chimpanzees and gorillas. Common chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) are our closest relatives with bonobos (Pan paniscus) and most of what we know about their evolutionary history comes from genetic and genomic studies. Most evolutionary studies of common chimpanzees have assumed that the four currently recognised subspecies can be modelled using simple tree models where each subspecies is panmictic and represented by one branch of the evolutionary tree. In addition, one recent genetic study claimed to have detected admixture between bonobos and chimpanzees. However, several studies have identified the existence of significant population structure with evidence of isolation-by-distance (IBD) patterns, both within and between subspecies. This suggests that demographic models integrating population structure may be necessary to improve our understanding of their evolutionary history. Here we propose to use n-island models within each subspecies to infer a demographic history integrating population structure and changes in connectivity (i.e., gene flow). For each subspecies, we use SNIF (Structured non-stationary inference framework), a method developed to infer a piecewise stationary n-island model using PSMC (Pairwise sequentially Markovian coalescent) curves as summary statistics. We then propose a general model integrating the four subspecies as metapopulations within a phylogenetic tree. We find that this model correctly predicts estimates of within subspecies genetic diversity and differentiation, but overestimates genetic differentiation between subspecies as a consequence of the tree structure. We argue that spatial models integrating gene flow between subspecies should improve the prediction of between subspecies differentiation and generate the observed IBD patterns. We also simulated data under a simple spatially structured model for bonobos and chimpanzees (without admixture) and found that it generates potentially spurious signals of admixture between the two species that have been reported and could thus be spurious. This may have implications for our understanding of the evolutionary history of the Homo genus.
- 24 May 2025
- Published by Pivot Science Publications Corporation in Human Population Genetics and Genomics
- Vol. 5 (2)
Open AccessOn the Demographic History of Chimpanzees and Some Consequences of Integrating Population Structure in Chimpanzees and Other Great Apes
Reconstructing the evolutionary history of great apes is of particular importance for our understanding of the demographic history of humans. The reason for this is that modern humans and their hominin ancestors evolved in Africa and thus shared the continent with the ancestors of chimpanzees and gorillas. Common chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) are our closest relatives with bonobos (Pan paniscus) and most of what we know about their evolutionary history comes from genetic and genomic studies. Most evolutionary studies of common chimpanzees have assumed that the four currently recognised subspecies can be modelled using simple tree models where each subspecies is panmictic and represented by one branch of the evolutionary tree. In addition, one recent genetic study claimed to have detected admixture between bonobos and chimpanzees. However, several studies have identified the existence of significant population structure with evidence of isolation-by-distance (IBD) patterns, both within and between subspecies. This suggests that demographic models integrating population structure may be necessary to improve our understanding of their evolutionary history. Here we propose to use n-island models within each subspecies to infer a demographic history integrating population structure and changes in connectivity (i.e., gene flow). For each subspecies, we use SNIF (Structured non-stationary inference framework), a method developed to infer a piecewise stationary n-island model using PSMC (Pairwise sequentially Markovian coalescent) curves as summary statistics. We then propose a general model integrating the four subspecies as metapopulations within a phylogenetic tree. We find that this model correctly predicts estimates of within subspecies genetic diversity and differentiation, but overestimates genetic differentiation between subspecies as a consequence of the tree structure. We argue that spatial models integrating gene flow between subspecies should improve the prediction of between subspecies differentiation and generate the observed IBD patterns. We also simulated data under a simple spatially structured model for bonobos and chimpanzees (without admixture) and found that it generates potentially spurious signals of admixture between the two species that have been reported and could thus be spurious. This may have implications for our understanding of the evolutionary history of the Homo genus.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Monographs
- Vol. 95 (2)
Advancing transdisciplinary research on Madagascar's grassy biomes to support resilience in ecosystems and livelihoods
Grassy biomes (savanna and grasslands) are globally extensive and host a unique biodiversity that is of central importance to human livelihoods. We focus here on the island of Madagascar—a microcosm of the global tropics, covered in 80% grassy biomes—to illustrate how transdisciplinary approaches to research can clarify ecosystem dynamics, from evolutionary history to human land use. Research on Madagascar's human‐environment interactions has sparked debates about the role of past and current land use in shaping grassy biomes (e.g., pastoralism, cultivation, fire use). These debates echo those in other regions globally, and highlight obstacles to understanding and supporting both ecosystem and livelihood resilience. Like many tropical biodiversity hotspots, Madagascar faces converging challenges that can be aided by transdisciplinary research, including food and health insecurity, economic inequities, biodiversity loss, climate change, land conversion, and limited resource access. We present a framework to guide transdisciplinary research centered on improved understanding and management of grassy biomes on Madagascar by: (1) establishing a globally common terminology; (2) summarizing data contributions and scientific knowledge gaps relating to Madagascar's grassy biomes; (3) identifying priority research questions for Madagascar with applicability in other regions; and (4) highlighting transdisciplinary, inclusive approaches to research that can co‐benefit people and the ecosystems with which they interact.
- 1 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Monographs
- Vol. 95 (2)
Open AccessAdvancing transdisciplinary research on Madagascar's grassy biomes to support resilience in ecosystems and livelihoods
Grassy biomes (savanna and grasslands) are globally extensive and host a unique biodiversity that is of central importance to human livelihoods. We focus here on the island of Madagascar—a microcosm of the global tropics, covered in 80% grassy biomes—to illustrate how transdisciplinary approaches to research can clarify ecosystem dynamics, from evolutionary history to human land use. Research on Madagascar's human‐environment interactions has sparked debates about the role of past and current land use in shaping grassy biomes (e.g., pastoralism, cultivation, fire use). These debates echo those in other regions globally, and highlight obstacles to understanding and supporting both ecosystem and livelihood resilience. Like many tropical biodiversity hotspots, Madagascar faces converging challenges that can be aided by transdisciplinary research, including food and health insecurity, economic inequities, biodiversity loss, climate change, land conversion, and limited resource access. We present a framework to guide transdisciplinary research centered on improved understanding and management of grassy biomes on Madagascar by: (1) establishing a globally common terminology; (2) summarizing data contributions and scientific knowledge gaps relating to Madagascar's grassy biomes; (3) identifying priority research questions for Madagascar with applicability in other regions; and (4) highlighting transdisciplinary, inclusive approaches to research that can co‐benefit people and the ecosystems with which they interact.
- 22 March 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Theoretical Population Biology
- Vol. 163, 50-61
Exact calculation of the expected SFS in structured populations
- 22 March 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Theoretical Population Biology
- Vol. 163, 50-61
Exact calculation of the expected SFS in structured populations
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 9 (2) , 225-236
Ignoring population structure in hominin evolutionary models can lead to the inference of spurious admixture events
Genomic and ancient DNA data have revolutionized palaeoanthropology and our vision of human evolution, with indisputable landmarks like the sequencing of Neanderthal and Denisovan genomes. Yet, using genetic data to identify, date and quantify evolutionary events—such as ancient bottlenecks or admixture—is not straightforward, as inferences may depend on model assumptions. In the last two decades, the idea that Neanderthals and members of the Homo sapiens lineage interbred has gained momentum. From the status of unlikely theory, it has reached consensus among human evolutionary biologists. This theory is mainly supported by statistical approaches that depend on demographic models minimizing or ignoring population structure, despite its widespread occurrence and the fact that, when ignored, population structure can lead to the inference of spurious demographic events. We simulated genomic data under a structured and admixture-free model of human evolution, and found that all the tested admixture approaches identified long Neanderthal fragments in our simulated genomes and an admixture event that never took place. We also observed that several published admixture models failed to predict important empirical diversity or admixture statistics, and that we could identify several scenarios from our structured model that better predicted these statistics jointly. Using a simulated time series of ancient DNA, the structured scenarios could also predict the trajectory of the empirical D statistics. Our results suggest that models accounting for population structure are fundamental to improve our understanding of human evolution, and that admixture between Neanderthals and H. sapiens needs to be re-evaluated in the light of structured models. Beyond the Neanderthal case, we argue that ancient hybridization events, which are increasingly documented in many species, including with other hominins, may also benefit from such re-evaluation.
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 9 (2) , 225-236
Ignoring population structure in hominin evolutionary models can lead to the inference of spurious admixture events
Genomic and ancient DNA data have revolutionized palaeoanthropology and our vision of human evolution, with indisputable landmarks like the sequencing of Neanderthal and Denisovan genomes. Yet, using genetic data to identify, date and quantify evolutionary events—such as ancient bottlenecks or admixture—is not straightforward, as inferences may depend on model assumptions. In the last two decades, the idea that Neanderthals and members of the Homo sapiens lineage interbred has gained momentum. From the status of unlikely theory, it has reached consensus among human evolutionary biologists. This theory is mainly supported by statistical approaches that depend on demographic models minimizing or ignoring population structure, despite its widespread occurrence and the fact that, when ignored, population structure can lead to the inference of spurious demographic events. We simulated genomic data under a structured and admixture-free model of human evolution, and found that all the tested admixture approaches identified long Neanderthal fragments in our simulated genomes and an admixture event that never took place. We also observed that several published admixture models failed to predict important empirical diversity or admixture statistics, and that we could identify several scenarios from our structured model that better predicted these statistics jointly. Using a simulated time series of ancient DNA, the structured scenarios could also predict the trajectory of the empirical D statistics. Our results suggest that models accounting for population structure are fundamental to improve our understanding of human evolution, and that admixture between Neanderthals and H. sapiens needs to be re-evaluated in the light of structured models. Beyond the Neanderthal case, we argue that ancient hybridization events, which are increasingly documented in many species, including with other hominins, may also benefit from such re-evaluation.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 34 (1) , e17597
Species‐Specific Traits Shape Genetic Diversity During an Expansion–Contraction Cycle and Bias Demographic History Reconstruction
Species ranges are dynamic, experiencing expansions, contractions or shifts in response to habitat changes driven by extrinsic factors such as climate change or human activities. While existing research examines the genetic consequences of spatial processes, few studies integrate species‐specific traits to analyse how habitat changes affect co‐existing species. In this study, we address this gap by investigating how genetic diversity patterns vary among species with different traits (such as generation length, population density and dispersal) experiencing similar habitat changes. Using spatial simulations and a simpler panmictic population model, we investigate the temporal genetic diversity in refugium populations undergoing range expansion of their habitat, followed by stationary and contraction periods. By varying habitat contraction speed and species traits, we identified three distinct temporal dynamics of genetic diversity during contraction: (i) a decrease in genetic diversity, (ii) an initial increase followed by a decrease and (iii) a continuous increase throughout the contraction period. We show that genetic diversity trajectories during population decline can be predicted by comparing sampled population diversity to equilibrium values expected under expanded and contracted habitat ranges. Our study also challenges the belief that high genetic diversity in a refugium population is due to a recent and rapid habitat loss. Instead, we found contrasting effects of contraction speed on genetic diversity depending on the interaction between species‐specific traits and the dynamics of habitat change. Finally, using simulated genetic data, we found that demographic histories inferred from effective population size estimates may vary across species, even when they experience similar habitat changes.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 34 (1) , e17597
Species‐Specific Traits Shape Genetic Diversity During an Expansion–Contraction Cycle and Bias Demographic History Reconstruction
Species ranges are dynamic, experiencing expansions, contractions or shifts in response to habitat changes driven by extrinsic factors such as climate change or human activities. While existing research examines the genetic consequences of spatial processes, few studies integrate species‐specific traits to analyse how habitat changes affect co‐existing species. In this study, we address this gap by investigating how genetic diversity patterns vary among species with different traits (such as generation length, population density and dispersal) experiencing similar habitat changes. Using spatial simulations and a simpler panmictic population model, we investigate the temporal genetic diversity in refugium populations undergoing range expansion of their habitat, followed by stationary and contraction periods. By varying habitat contraction speed and species traits, we identified three distinct temporal dynamics of genetic diversity during contraction: (i) a decrease in genetic diversity, (ii) an initial increase followed by a decrease and (iii) a continuous increase throughout the contraction period. We show that genetic diversity trajectories during population decline can be predicted by comparing sampled population diversity to equilibrium values expected under expanded and contracted habitat ranges. Our study also challenges the belief that high genetic diversity in a refugium population is due to a recent and rapid habitat loss. Instead, we found contrasting effects of contraction speed on genetic diversity depending on the interaction between species‐specific traits and the dynamics of habitat change. Finally, using simulated genetic data, we found that demographic histories inferred from effective population size estimates may vary across species, even when they experience similar habitat changes.