Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Shih-Ning Then has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The Problem With ‘Gillick’

    by Sarah Martin, Shih‐Ning Then, Samuel Boyle

    Aim: To outline the law pertaining to adolescent consent in Australia in 2025. To address some of the ethical challenges relevant to this area. To provide some practical advice for clinicians.Audience: Emergency medicine physicians and trainees in Australia and New Zealand.

  • Open Access

    Determining the state of guidance on pediatric biobanking for researchers, HRECS, and families: Regulatory mapping of international guidance

    by Sinead Prince, Shih-Ning Then, Kerry-Ann O’gRady

    Biobanking—the storage of human biological samples, including tissue, blood, urine, and genetic data—raises many ethical, legal, and social issues, including confidentiality and privacy. Pediatric biobanking is more complicated, with difficulties arising because children lack capacity to consent and acquire this capacity upon maturity when the research is still ongoing. Yet given the limited availability of pediatric samples, the translational nature of biobanking presents a unique opportunity to share samples and produce clinically necessary information about pediatric development and diseases. Guidance on navigating these legal and ethical difficulties is needed for those involved in pediatric biobanking—including researchers, participants, and families, and those involved in biobank governance. This paper seeks to map the current regulatory framework governing pediatric biobanking to determine what guidance is currently offered. Regulatory mapping of current international and national guidelines on pediatric biobanking addressing the ethical, legal, and social nuances of pediatric biobanking was undertaken. This paper finds that international guidelines around biobanking are mostly for adults, and even when pediatric-specific, documents are non-binding, inconsistent, or only limited guidance is offered on a range of important issues specific to pediatric biobanks. Conclusion: This paper shows a need for consistent, comprehensive, and clear regulation on pediatric biobanking so that research can more quickly, efficiently, and ethically be translated to useful information and treatment in pediatric care. What is Known:• Pediatric biobanking presents new opportunities to conduct valuable translational research to benefit pediatric populations. However, the storage of pediatric biological samples raises many ethical, legal and social issues—in part because child participants may be considered to lack capacity to consent but can acquire this capacity upon maturity when the research is still ongoing. Pediatric biobanks must grapple with issues of consent, confidentiality and privacy, and long-term participation regarding child participants. What is New:• Regulatory guidance on these ethical, legal, and social issues is needed for researchers, participants, and families and those involved in biobank governance. This paper identifies nationally specific and international guidance on biobanking and summarizes the guidance provided in relation to these pediatric specific issues. It finds that most guidance is non-binding and inconsistent between guidance documents and may offer only limited guidance to stakeholders. A need for consistent, comprehensive, and clear regulation on pediatric biobanking is needed at an international level to enable research.


  • Open Access

    Delivering decision making support to people with cognitive disability—What more has been learned from pilot programmes in Australia and internationally from 2016 to 2021?

    by Shih‐Ning Then, Julia Duffy, Christine Bigby, Craig Sinclair, Ilan Wiesel, Terry Carney, Jacinta Douglas

    Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has been instrumental in driving the development of the concept and practice of supported decision making. An important feature has been the development of “supported decision making pilots.” This paper identifies, describes and analyses pilot programmes providing support for decision making for people with cognitive disabilities in Australia and internationally between 2016 and 2021. It finds that challenges included providing support for socially isolated people and adequately resourcing those programmes. However, most pilots reported positive outcomes for decision makers, adding to the evidence base for claims to be made about the positive impact of supported decision making on the lives of people with disabilities. The pilots demonstrate that, internationally, there is an emerging set of programmes that seek to promote supported decision making incrementally through developing focussed community awareness and practice. While still small‐scale, time‐limited and experimental, with different levels of rigour in practice and evaluation, they provide some foundation and a preliminary evidence base for larger interventions and reforms in the future.


  • Decision-making About Premortem Interventions for Donation: Navigating Legal and Ethical Complexities

    by Shih-Ning Then, Dominique E. Martin, Andrew McGee, Dale MBBS Gardiner, Nadia Llb El Moslemani

    Premortem interventions (PMIs) for organ donation play a vital role in preserving opportunities for deceased donation or increasing the chances of successful transplantation of donor organs. Although ethical considerations relating to use of particular PMIs have been well explored, the ethical and legal aspects of decision-making about the use of PMIs have received comparatively little attention. In many countries, there is significant uncertainty regarding whether PMIs are lawful or, if they are, who can authorize them. Furthermore, emphasis on consideration of therapeutic goals in substitute decision-making frameworks may discourage consideration of donation goals. In this article, we examine the fundamental questions of who should have the authority to make decisions about the use of PMIs on behalf of a potential donor and how such decisions should be made. We draw on international examples of legal reform that have sought to clarify the legal position in relation to administering PMIs and identify potential elements of an effective regulatory model for PMIs. In doing so, we argue that reforms are needed in many countries to provide legal certainty for clinicians who are responsible for supporting decision-making about PMIs and to ensure that the goals and preferences of potential donors are accorded due consideration in the decision-making process.


  • Open Access

    Moving from Support for Decision-making to Substitute Decision-making: Legal Frameworks and Perspectives of Supporters of Adults with Intellectual Disabilities

    by Shih-Ning Then, Terry Carney, Christine Bigby, Ilan Wiesel, Elizabeth Smith, Jacinta Douglas

    The United Nations Convention on Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) has significantly changed the way our society views models of decision-making for adults with cognitive impairment. The formerly-accepted substitute decision-making models – where a person can legally make decisions for an individual, often guided by the ‘best interests’ principle – are considered less desirable than supported decision-making which prioritises an individual’s ‘will, preferences and rights’. However, disciplinary differences in understandings about what these concepts entail and how they should look in policy, legal and practice frameworks persist. For many, supported decision-making is experienced through informal support for decision-making through close family, and in the absence of a legal appointment. What this support looks like and whether it can help achieve the aim of greater participation by people with intellectual disability is still being empirically examined. In addition, the circumstances when that support moves into informal substitute decision-making is largely unexplored. It is also unclear whether the reasons for such a shift mirror the legal requirements for the appointment of a formal substitute decision-maker under Australian law. This paper uses a subset of qualitative data from interviews with parents who act as supporters to adults who have an intellectual disability. The overall aim of the study was to explore the impact of training in applying a practice framework (the La Trobe Support for Decision Making Practice Framework) about effective support for decision-making. We show that promising development is reported from the impact of capacity-building training for supporters, with evidence that the decision-making capabilities of adults with intellectual disabilities can be seen to shift over a period of time and training informal supporters can be effective in moving the dial as to when a supporter finds it necessary to step in and make a substitute decision. However, we also demonstrate that considerations of ‘risk’ and future opportunities for the supported adult are nuanced factors taken into account by supporters who shifted into a substitute decision-maker role and this is not well accounted for in our legal frameworks.


  • Open Access

    “I used to call him a non-decision-maker - I never do that anymore”: parental reflections about training to support decision-making of their adult offspring with intellectual disabilities

    by Christine Bigby, Jacinta Douglas, Elizabeth Smith, Terry Carney, Shih-Ning Then, Ilan Wiesel

    A rights perspective proposes supported decision-making as an alternative to substitute decision-making. However, evidence about supported decision-making practice is limited. Our aim was to build ...


  • Open Access

    Parental strategies that support adults with intellectual disabilities to explore decision preferences, constraints and consequences

    by Christine Bigby, Jacinta Douglas, Elizabeth Smith, Terry Carney, Shih-Ning Then, Ilan Wiesel

    Supporting participation in decision making is complex, dynamic and multifactorial. The aim of this study was to understand more about the difficulties parents of adults with intellectual disabilit...


  • Open Access

    Paternalism to empowerment: all in the eye of the beholder?

    by Terry Carney, Christine Bigby, Shih-Ning Then, Elizabeth Smith, Ilan Wiesel, Jacinta Douglas

    This article reports findings from the first set of qualitative data from a study aimed to further understand practices of decision support for people with cognitive disabilities and assess the impact of training supporters in an evidence-based practice framework. It poses questions about whether, using the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) as the benchmark, it is possible to identify purchase points for assessing the degree of shift from paternalism towards empowerment of the supported person. The study findings suggest that this is a highly difficult, nuanced and subjective task offering little on which to hang objectivity. Instead, we suggest CRPD realisation of the will, preferences and rights of the person supported may better be realised through training of supporters designed to enable greater participation by persons supported and greater reflection and deliberation on wise and effective ways of providing such support by supporters.