Donald P. Haider-Markel
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Donald P. Haider-Markel has a total of 74 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mark R. Joslyn
University of Kansas
14 shared publications Mark R. Joslyn
University of Kansas
12 shared publications- Jami Kathleen Taylor
Department of Political Science and Public Administration, University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, USA
11 shared publications - Andrew R. Flores
Mills College
8 shared publications Daniel C. Lewis
Siena College NY
6 shared publications- Daniel C. Lewis
Department of Political Science & International Relations, Siena College, Loudonville, NY, USA
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
- Vol. 8, 1607634
Play fair: the impact of issue framing on attitudes toward transgender youth participation in sports
Introduction: Policies restricting sports participation by transgender youth have spread across the United States. The Trump administration has also taken a variety of executive actions to ban participation by transgender athletes. Methods: Little research has examined how issue framing affects attitudes toward these policies. Some LGBT advocates recommend emphasizing egalitarian and loss-based arguments, as well as acknowledging discomfort regarding transgender youth. We investigate whether these strategies affect Americans’ attitudes on transgender participation in sports. Results: Using a survey sample of American adults, we find that egalitarian frames have a marginal effect on respondents’ attitudes.
- 8 April 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
- Vol. 8, 1607634
Open AccessPlay fair: the impact of issue framing on attitudes toward transgender youth participation in sports
Introduction: Policies restricting sports participation by transgender youth have spread across the United States. The Trump administration has also taken a variety of executive actions to ban participation by transgender athletes. Methods: Little research has examined how issue framing affects attitudes toward these policies. Some LGBT advocates recommend emphasizing egalitarian and loss-based arguments, as well as acknowledging discomfort regarding transgender youth. We investigate whether these strategies affect Americans’ attitudes on transgender participation in sports. Results: Using a survey sample of American adults, we find that egalitarian frames have a marginal effect on respondents’ attitudes.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 107 (3) , e70150
An Army for God: Gun Ownership, Christian Nationalism, and Support for Political Violence
Introduction: Recent trends suggest that the United States is experiencing right‐wing political violence with heightened influence of Christian nationalism in public dialogue. Method: Using original data from a nationally representative survey of American adults, we explore whether gun ownership and gun owner identifying Christian nationalists are more likely to support political violence. Results: Christian nationalists believe that their identity is under threat, increasing the desire for political violence. Meanwhile, the tools of violence are made salient through gun owners’ possession of firearms; and for those with a high gun owner identity, there is an inculcated culture of personal and community protection that should make them more likely to endorse extreme actions like violence. Finally, we find that gun ownership and gun owner identity amplify the effect of Christian nationalism on support for political violence. Conclusion: Our results point to Christian nationalism, gun ownership, and gun owner identity as accelerants to support for political violence.
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 107 (3) , e70150
Open AccessAn Army for God: Gun Ownership, Christian Nationalism, and Support for Political Violence
Introduction: Recent trends suggest that the United States is experiencing right‐wing political violence with heightened influence of Christian nationalism in public dialogue. Method: Using original data from a nationally representative survey of American adults, we explore whether gun ownership and gun owner identifying Christian nationalists are more likely to support political violence. Results: Christian nationalists believe that their identity is under threat, increasing the desire for political violence. Meanwhile, the tools of violence are made salient through gun owners’ possession of firearms; and for those with a high gun owner identity, there is an inculcated culture of personal and community protection that should make them more likely to endorse extreme actions like violence. Finally, we find that gun ownership and gun owner identity amplify the effect of Christian nationalism on support for political violence. Conclusion: Our results point to Christian nationalism, gun ownership, and gun owner identity as accelerants to support for political violence.
- 14 February 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in State Politics & Policy Quarterly
- Vol. 25 (2) , 237-259
Beyond Group Membership: New Way of Measuring Environmental Interest Group Strength in the American States
Interest groups are an important influence in the subnational policymaking process. Previously, environmental policy scholars measured the strength of environmental groups in the American policymaking subnational process by using proxies like state-level group membership in major nationwide environmental organizations (e.g., Sierra Club). Although these prior measures of group strength have face validity, recent scholarship suggests that the utilization of group financial resources is a better measure of the influence of interest groups in state-level models. We take this approach and provide a new way to measure state-level environmental interests by using aggregated financial information (income and assets) from Internal Revenue Service (IRS) data obtained via the National Center for Charitable Statistics (NCCS). This measure provides several advantages over previous approaches because it varies over time, is derived from easily accessible public data, includes a greater diversity of environmental organizations, and it is considered reliable by prior scholars. We demonstrate its empirical value by deploying our measure in a model of state policy adoption. We encourage researchers to further utilize this new measure in their analysis of environmental advocacy at the subnational level.
- 14 February 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in State Politics & Policy Quarterly
- Vol. 25 (2) , 237-259
Beyond Group Membership: New Way of Measuring Environmental Interest Group Strength in the American States
Interest groups are an important influence in the subnational policymaking process. Previously, environmental policy scholars measured the strength of environmental groups in the American policymaking subnational process by using proxies like state-level group membership in major nationwide environmental organizations (e.g., Sierra Club). Although these prior measures of group strength have face validity, recent scholarship suggests that the utilization of group financial resources is a better measure of the influence of interest groups in state-level models. We take this approach and provide a new way to measure state-level environmental interests by using aggregated financial information (income and assets) from Internal Revenue Service (IRS) data obtained via the National Center for Charitable Statistics (NCCS). This measure provides several advantages over previous approaches because it varies over time, is derived from easily accessible public data, includes a greater diversity of environmental organizations, and it is considered reliable by prior scholars. We demonstrate its empirical value by deploying our measure in a model of state policy adoption. We encourage researchers to further utilize this new measure in their analysis of environmental advocacy at the subnational level.
- 5 June 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Politics and Religion
- Vol. 17 (2) , 183-202
A colorblind Christian country? How racial attitudes affect support for Christian nationalism and civil religion
Can racial primes influence support for public expressions of religion? While a growing body of research demonstrates correlations between racial attitudes and support for public religion among White Americans, experimental tests of subconscious connections between the two concepts have been lacking. We utilize a novel survey experiment to prime racial considerations, and we find that Black racial primes raise support for Christian nationalism and civil religion among White Americans, compared to White racial primes. Moreover, our analysis indicates that these effects are attributable to racial animus, namely the evaluation that Black Americans are not prototypical members of the national community. The findings suggest that the preference for a Christian/religious America and a White America are subconsciously interwoven for many White Americans, providing the first experimental evidence, to our knowledge, of this relationship.
- 5 June 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Politics and Religion
- Vol. 17 (2) , 183-202
A colorblind Christian country? How racial attitudes affect support for Christian nationalism and civil religion
Can racial primes influence support for public expressions of religion? While a growing body of research demonstrates correlations between racial attitudes and support for public religion among White Americans, experimental tests of subconscious connections between the two concepts have been lacking. We utilize a novel survey experiment to prime racial considerations, and we find that Black racial primes raise support for Christian nationalism and civil religion among White Americans, compared to White racial primes. Moreover, our analysis indicates that these effects are attributable to racial animus, namely the evaluation that Black Americans are not prototypical members of the national community. The findings suggest that the preference for a Christian/religious America and a White America are subconsciously interwoven for many White Americans, providing the first experimental evidence, to our knowledge, of this relationship.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Political Behavior
- Vol. 46 (4) , 2401-2426
Cultural Threat, Outgroup Discrimination, and Attitudes toward Transgender Rights
Scholars often highlight the roles that group threat and intergroup solidarity play in shaping attitudes toward outgroups. Competition among social groups, including over values and culture, can underlie negative attitudes toward outgroups. Meanwhile, perceptions of discrimination against outgroups can drive feelings of solidarity, sympathy, or empathy, which may foster more positive attitudes. These social identity concepts are often studied in the context of racial, ethnic, and religious prejudice, with less attention to how they apply to attitudes toward transgender and gender diverse people. Using a 2022 national survey, we assess how respondents’ perceptions of cultural threat from the LGBTQ community and perceptions of discrimination among a range of outgroups are related to attitudes about transgender rights policies, including access to public restrooms, participation in school sports, and medical transition care. We find that cultural threat is consistently associated with support for policies that restrict the rights of transgender people, but perceived outgroup discrimination tends not to show a significant relationship with these attitudes.
- 22 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Political Behavior
- Vol. 46 (4) , 2401-2426
Open AccessCultural Threat, Outgroup Discrimination, and Attitudes toward Transgender Rights
Scholars often highlight the roles that group threat and intergroup solidarity play in shaping attitudes toward outgroups. Competition among social groups, including over values and culture, can underlie negative attitudes toward outgroups. Meanwhile, perceptions of discrimination against outgroups can drive feelings of solidarity, sympathy, or empathy, which may foster more positive attitudes. These social identity concepts are often studied in the context of racial, ethnic, and religious prejudice, with less attention to how they apply to attitudes toward transgender and gender diverse people. Using a 2022 national survey, we assess how respondents’ perceptions of cultural threat from the LGBTQ community and perceptions of discrimination among a range of outgroups are related to attitudes about transgender rights policies, including access to public restrooms, participation in school sports, and medical transition care. We find that cultural threat is consistently associated with support for policies that restrict the rights of transgender people, but perceived outgroup discrimination tends not to show a significant relationship with these attitudes.
- 15 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 104 (6) , 1295-1308
Religious liberties or reading rainbows? The partisan implications of religious liberties frames in education attitudes
Objective: Many state legislatures have moved to restrict LGBT students’ rights, and the Supreme Court has veered toward greater protection of religious free exercise protection over LGBT nondiscrimination policies. Some studies have found that rights framings are associated with heightened affective and attitudinal polarization, while others have argued that rights framings lead to greater tolerance. Do religious liberties frames affect policy attitudes or group affect? And are some groups’ use of religious liberties frames more persuasive?Methods: We utilize data from a survey that experimentally varies candidate statements on inclusion of LGBT issues in schools using a religious liberties frame and by the group asserting religious liberties. We use the experiment to document the extent to which religious liberties framings shift support for restriction of LGBT rights in schools and affect toward religious and LGBT Americans.Results: Our analysis suggests there are few direct effects, but that responses to religious liberties frames reflect debates within the parties about morality, social group conflict, and civic nationalism.Conclusion: Our results add to the growing literature on religious liberty, and we argue that there is a need to understand why religious liberties frames produce effects in some circumstances but not in others.
- 15 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 104 (6) , 1295-1308
Religious liberties or reading rainbows? The partisan implications of religious liberties frames in education attitudes
Objective: Many state legislatures have moved to restrict LGBT students’ rights, and the Supreme Court has veered toward greater protection of religious free exercise protection over LGBT nondiscrimination policies. Some studies have found that rights framings are associated with heightened affective and attitudinal polarization, while others have argued that rights framings lead to greater tolerance. Do religious liberties frames affect policy attitudes or group affect? And are some groups’ use of religious liberties frames more persuasive?Methods: We utilize data from a survey that experimentally varies candidate statements on inclusion of LGBT issues in schools using a religious liberties frame and by the group asserting religious liberties. We use the experiment to document the extent to which religious liberties framings shift support for restriction of LGBT rights in schools and affect toward religious and LGBT Americans.Results: Our analysis suggests there are few direct effects, but that responses to religious liberties frames reflect debates within the parties about morality, social group conflict, and civic nationalism.Conclusion: Our results add to the growing literature on religious liberty, and we argue that there is a need to understand why religious liberties frames produce effects in some circumstances but not in others.
- 15 September 2022
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 51 (1) , 123-143
Taking perspective of the stories we tell about transgender rights: The narrative policy framework
Our project uses the narrative policy framework (NPF) to explore narrative effects on attitudes about transgender rights. The framework focuses on the stories that are told about public policy. As opposed to conceptualizing communications as informational, NPF suggests that getting lost in the story is primary for attitude change. We also incorporate a perspective taking exercise to examine its effects on individual attitudes. Using an experiment on 1784 American adults, we found that individuals who received the inclusive transgender policy narrative by either watching or reading the narrative held views more supportive of transgender rights, with the effect greater for watching than reading. Those who experienced greater narrative transportation, being more lost in the story, reported more supportive attitudes. We further find that those with traits that lead them to become more imaginatively involved in stories occasionally are more greatly affected by watching policy narratives than those who are less imaginatively involved. However, perspective taking did not influence attitudes and weakened the treatment effects of the narratives. Our findings suggest stories can affect policy attitudes and beliefs, which may be conceptually distinct from traditional framing‐based accounts and implies distinctive causal mechanisms that result in attitude change.
- 15 September 2022
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 51 (1) , 123-143
Taking perspective of the stories we tell about transgender rights: The narrative policy framework
Our project uses the narrative policy framework (NPF) to explore narrative effects on attitudes about transgender rights. The framework focuses on the stories that are told about public policy. As opposed to conceptualizing communications as informational, NPF suggests that getting lost in the story is primary for attitude change. We also incorporate a perspective taking exercise to examine its effects on individual attitudes. Using an experiment on 1784 American adults, we found that individuals who received the inclusive transgender policy narrative by either watching or reading the narrative held views more supportive of transgender rights, with the effect greater for watching than reading. Those who experienced greater narrative transportation, being more lost in the story, reported more supportive attitudes. We further find that those with traits that lead them to become more imaginatively involved in stories occasionally are more greatly affected by watching policy narratives than those who are less imaginatively involved. However, perspective taking did not influence attitudes and weakened the treatment effects of the narratives. Our findings suggest stories can affect policy attitudes and beliefs, which may be conceptually distinct from traditional framing‐based accounts and implies distinctive causal mechanisms that result in attitude change.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Graduate School of Public Administration, Seoul National University (GSPA) in Journal of Policy Studies
- Vol. 37 (2) , 27-42
Staying in Class: Representative Bureaucracy and Student Praise and Punishment
Our project investigates the impact of minority bureaucratic and political representation on the distribution of disciplinary measures in public schools, in contrast with its impact on gifted and talented class placement. It is motivated by the contrast in accumulating research on the consequences of minority bureaucratic representation between findings that minority teacher representation yields beneficial outcomes for minority students while minority representation on police forces does not yield beneficial outcomes for minority residents. Similarly, we note that public school teaching involves two kinds of organizational roles: one involving distribution of benefits (such as placement in gifted and talented programs) which is consistent with an educator role, while the other, involving the distribution of discipline, approximates a policing role, which could be less consistent with an educator role. In short, the educator role benefits the client and the policing role regulates the client. We theorize that (a) modeling the impact of greater minority representation on teaching staffs will yield contrasting results for these two roles, (b) that there will also be differences based on type of discipline at issue, and that (c) the role of minority representation on the school board must also be taken into account. We examine these issues by employing merged data from several data sources ranging from 2007 to 2010 for our analyses. Our results suggest that higher minority teacher representation does increase minority student placement in gifted programs, but does not significantly reduce punishment of minority students. Our analyses also suggest that future research needs to more fully incorporate contextual variables, such as school board representation and state policy. Scholars of representative bureaucracy should also consider the multiple organizational roles that many bureaucrats have.
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Graduate School of Public Administration, Seoul National University (GSPA) in Journal of Policy Studies
- Vol. 37 (2) , 27-42
Open AccessStaying in Class: Representative Bureaucracy and Student Praise and Punishment
Our project investigates the impact of minority bureaucratic and political representation on the distribution of disciplinary measures in public schools, in contrast with its impact on gifted and talented class placement. It is motivated by the contrast in accumulating research on the consequences of minority bureaucratic representation between findings that minority teacher representation yields beneficial outcomes for minority students while minority representation on police forces does not yield beneficial outcomes for minority residents. Similarly, we note that public school teaching involves two kinds of organizational roles: one involving distribution of benefits (such as placement in gifted and talented programs) which is consistent with an educator role, while the other, involving the distribution of discipline, approximates a policing role, which could be less consistent with an educator role. In short, the educator role benefits the client and the policing role regulates the client. We theorize that (a) modeling the impact of greater minority representation on teaching staffs will yield contrasting results for these two roles, (b) that there will also be differences based on type of discipline at issue, and that (c) the role of minority representation on the school board must also be taken into account. We examine these issues by employing merged data from several data sources ranging from 2007 to 2010 for our analyses. Our results suggest that higher minority teacher representation does increase minority student placement in gifted programs, but does not significantly reduce punishment of minority students. Our analyses also suggest that future research needs to more fully incorporate contextual variables, such as school board representation and state policy. Scholars of representative bureaucracy should also consider the multiple organizational roles that many bureaucrats have.
- 23 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 103 (6) , 1359-1370
Voting on gun rights: Mapping the electoral scope of the pro‐gun constituency in America
- 23 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Social Science Quarterly
- Vol. 103 (6) , 1359-1370
Voting on gun rights: Mapping the electoral scope of the pro‐gun constituency in America
- 11 February 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociological Perspectives
- Vol. 65 (1) , 119-132
Gun Ownership, Threat, and Gun Attitudes in an Experiment
Researchers have considered the role of perceived threat and fear of crime in shaping attitudes about gun regulation. We contribute to this literature by examining whether gun owners, who tend to oppose gun regulations, moderate their gun views when exposed to a gun-related threat. We argue that although exposure to threat can increase the desire to be armed, gun owners primed with a threat may soften their views on gun regulation relative to non-gun owners. We employ an experiment embedded within a nationally representative survey to test our hypotheses. Our analysis of the data from our survey supports the notion that gun owners generally oppose gun regulations, but exposure to a gun-related threat moderates their opposition to gun regulations. We discuss the limitations of our study and conclude with a discussion of the implications of these results for understanding public support for gun regulation in America.
- 11 February 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociological Perspectives
- Vol. 65 (1) , 119-132
Gun Ownership, Threat, and Gun Attitudes in an Experiment
Researchers have considered the role of perceived threat and fear of crime in shaping attitudes about gun regulation. We contribute to this literature by examining whether gun owners, who tend to oppose gun regulations, moderate their gun views when exposed to a gun-related threat. We argue that although exposure to threat can increase the desire to be armed, gun owners primed with a threat may soften their views on gun regulation relative to non-gun owners. We employ an experiment embedded within a nationally representative survey to test our hypotheses. Our analysis of the data from our survey supports the notion that gun owners generally oppose gun regulations, but exposure to a gun-related threat moderates their opposition to gun regulations. We discuss the limitations of our study and conclude with a discussion of the implications of these results for understanding public support for gun regulation in America.