Meghan Bruce Kumar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Meghan Bruce Kumar has a total of 153 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Miriam Taegtmeyer
Department of Clinical Sciences, Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, UK
7 shared publications - Joël Arthur Kiendrébéogo
University Joseph Ki-Zerbo
5 shared publications - Asha George
University of the Western Cape
4 shared publications - Edwine Barasa
Health Economics Research Unit (HERU), KEMRI-Wellcome Trust Research Programme Nairobi, Nairobi, Kenya
3 shared publications Issa Kaboré
Recherche pour la santé et le développement (RESADE)
3 shared publicationsJason J Madan
University of Warwick Warwick Medical School, Coventry, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Involvement and Engagement
- Vol. 12 (1) , 140
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) in methodological research: exploring challenges, tensions and learning from the perspectives of PPIE and researchers in the Realist Economic Evaluation Methods (REEM) study
Background: Methodological research is often abstract, heavily theoretical and jargon laden. Despite having significant implications for the users of health and social care services, it can be difficult to involve the public and patients in research that is oriented towards more academic ‘ways of knowing’. This article combines Public and Patient Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) and university researcher perspectives on their experiences working on a study that aimed to develop a new evaluation approach. Methods: Using a co-produced reflective case study design, four university researchers and three (representing a wider group of six) PPIE contributors reflected on their shared experiences of PPIE within the Realist Economic Evaluation Methods (REEM) methodological study. Reflections were gathered during a structured two-hour workshop, which identified three broad initial themes. These were explored in depth by academic/PPIE writing duos across two online follow-up meetings, producing collaborative written summaries. A fourth academic synthesised the summaries to ensure coherence and the final manuscript was examined and approved by the full team. Results: The challenges encountered during the study were organised into three broad themes: (1) Identifying appropriate PPIE contributors; (2) maintaining and sustaining engagement; and (3) determining when and how best to engage. Conclusion: We propose that PPIE in methodological health and social care research requires different considerations than PPIE in applied research, including actions to normalise uncertainty and be creative about modes of contribution as part of co-learning. We have articulated these as recommendations, with implications for funders/commissioners of research, university researchers and PPIE contributors alike.
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Involvement and Engagement
- Vol. 12 (1) , 140
Open AccessPatient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) in methodological research: exploring challenges, tensions and learning from the perspectives of PPIE and researchers in the Realist Economic Evaluation Methods (REEM) study
Background: Methodological research is often abstract, heavily theoretical and jargon laden. Despite having significant implications for the users of health and social care services, it can be difficult to involve the public and patients in research that is oriented towards more academic ‘ways of knowing’. This article combines Public and Patient Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) and university researcher perspectives on their experiences working on a study that aimed to develop a new evaluation approach. Methods: Using a co-produced reflective case study design, four university researchers and three (representing a wider group of six) PPIE contributors reflected on their shared experiences of PPIE within the Realist Economic Evaluation Methods (REEM) methodological study. Reflections were gathered during a structured two-hour workshop, which identified three broad initial themes. These were explored in depth by academic/PPIE writing duos across two online follow-up meetings, producing collaborative written summaries. A fourth academic synthesised the summaries to ensure coherence and the final manuscript was examined and approved by the full team. Results: The challenges encountered during the study were organised into three broad themes: (1) Identifying appropriate PPIE contributors; (2) maintaining and sustaining engagement; and (3) determining when and how best to engage. Conclusion: We propose that PPIE in methodological health and social care research requires different considerations than PPIE in applied research, including actions to normalise uncertainty and be creative about modes of contribution as part of co-learning. We have articulated these as recommendations, with implications for funders/commissioners of research, university researchers and PPIE contributors alike.
- Open Access
- 29 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Evaluation
- Vol. 32 (4) , 552-572
Developing initial programme theory for realist economic evaluation: A review of findings from three pilot studies
It is increasingly recognised that ‘big problems’ in health and social care require well-designed solutions and robust evaluation, including attention to costs as well as outcomes. This is especially important in the pervasive environment of resource scarcity. Decisions need to be made that consider not only whether and how an intervention works but also affordability and efficiency in different circumstances and populations. As researchers tackle these complex issues, interest in bringing together realist and economic evaluation is growing. Responding to this, we discuss how using programme theory within a novel realist economic evaluation approach can be used in articulating how interventions may (or may not) bring about cost-effective change. We identify what initial programme theory in realist economic evaluation might look like in practice, drawing on data from three pilot realist economic evaluation studies.
- 29 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Evaluation
- Vol. 32 (4) , 552-572
Open AccessDeveloping initial programme theory for realist economic evaluation: A review of findings from three pilot studies
It is increasingly recognised that ‘big problems’ in health and social care require well-designed solutions and robust evaluation, including attention to costs as well as outcomes. This is especially important in the pervasive environment of resource scarcity. Decisions need to be made that consider not only whether and how an intervention works but also affordability and efficiency in different circumstances and populations. As researchers tackle these complex issues, interest in bringing together realist and economic evaluation is growing. Responding to this, we discuss how using programme theory within a novel realist economic evaluation approach can be used in articulating how interventions may (or may not) bring about cost-effective change. We identify what initial programme theory in realist economic evaluation might look like in practice, drawing on data from three pilot realist economic evaluation studies.
- Open Access
- 20 June 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Global Women's Health
- Vol. 6, 1492231
Measuring the positive potential value of birth in economic evaluation of perinatal interventions
Giving birth is a \me of both risk and possibility: what happens during childbirth can be life-changing and has life-long implica\ons for mother, baby and wider family. We call for a fundamental rethinking of economic evalua\on of perinatal health interven\ons that recognises this: one that centers birthing people's experiences and accounts for the posi\ve poten\al value of birth in their lives, acknowledging that birth is not an illness (1,2) from which the best possible outcome is a return to 'baseline'. This reframing, in line with the salutogenic model of birth (3) challenges the typically employed 'deficit model' approach focusing on measuring severe morbidi\es and mortality as the most important outcomes of perinatal health interven\ons (4)(5)(6)(7). We suggest instead an assessment of the poten\al well-being increase that would result from a posi\ve, empowered, family and person-centred birth experience alongside high-quality clinical care. In this commentary, we examine the well-being enhancing poten\al of a posi\ve birth experience and the jus\fica\on for health economists to include this in economic evalua\ons of perinatal health interven\ons.From this point, at the request of the Fron\ers in Global Women's Health Chief Editorial Team, we will refer to 'women' when discussing people giving birth. We acknowledge that not everyone giving birth iden\fies as a woman and that using this shorthand risks being read as ignoring trans and non-binary people.Economic evaluations in all health areas typically focus on mortality and (severe) morbidity as the key outcomes related to health and health-related quality of life (8)(9)(10). Focusing on these 'universal' outcomes allows economists and policy makers to compare across health areas and interventions. In the perinatal period, using these outcomes means newborn well-being outweighs the parent(s) because of their much larger potential number of life years to be gained. At the most basic, this drives a focus on both clinical quality of care and on newborn care as the focus of improvement with the highest potential return.Although a woman's outcomes might be outweighed by their infant's, if a simple cumulative total approach to economic evaluation were used, the distribution of these outcomes is also important. In the global community, the right to high-quality reproductive healthcare is acknowledged(11), though often unmet. Among outcomes to be considered for women giving birth, 99.2% survive childbirth and the postpartum period globally today, though there are still many unnecessary deaths. As the recent flagship WHO report states, from 2016-2020 three quarters of countries had stagnant or increasing maternal mortality rates (MMR), with a significant reduction in MMR in just 31 countries globally (12). As such, while tracking MMR remains critical to ensure sustained health impact, including in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), simply focusing on maternal mortality (Goal 3.1) is no longer a sensitive marker of the impact of maternal and perinatal health improvement interventions in many settings (13)(14)(15). Indeed, after decades of progress focused on maternal mortality, there is a recognition that childbirth can and should be evaluated beyond merely maternal or perinatal survival (16)(17)(18)(19).The literature suggests that experience of maternity services affects utilization and timeliness of care seeking for future reproductive health needs, including early ANC (to identify high-risk pregnancies), appropriate imaging, skilled birth attendance and indeed safe abortion care (20,21). As such, a poor experience for one person during one pregnancy can create a cascade of future decision-making for them and their neighbors/family/friends. By using approaches driven by quantitative, process-oriented metrics of clinical protocols that directly lead to observable mortality and morbidity outcomes, economists neglect or under-value patient experience aspects of quality of care (22), which are likely to be more context-specific yet are critical to family-centred care and longer-term mental and physical health (23,24).There is strong evidence on the long-lasting impact of birth experience (25,26) and potential long-term impacts on bonding and capacity of mother and baby to thrive and thus to contribute economic 'value' to society, beyond these intrinsically valuable capabilities (27).Existing measures and scales are inadequate to this task, though beginning to acknowledge it in different ways. To date, these efforts have primarily focused on outcomes measures, and patientreported outcome measures (PROMs) as a category can speak to some outcomes of birth experienceas differentiated from patient-reported experience measures, that might more directly engage with the process or experience of birth. There is very limited use of PROMs in maternity and childbirth as yet, though there is growing interest.( 28) For example, the Birth Satisfaction Scale is a specific and important scale that we include in our ongoing assessment of existing measures for understanding birth experience. ( 29)However, we posit that satisfaction is an outcome and birth experience is a process, albeit one that is intrinsically valuable. In a systematic review of birth outcomes, the authors found an initial list of 135 positive outcomes and over ten times that amount of negative outcomes, supporting the claim that "…effectiveness of intrapartum interventions was measured against adverse outcomes rather than increases in measures of health and well-being". (3) To measure change and perhaps kick start further reductions, a different metric to evaluate progress against is needed -this means using these broader outcomes included in the calculation instead of focusing narrowly on death and disability, as well as including patient-reported aspects (30,31). What is currently under-explored are the links between experience and relevant capabilities -moving from the...
- 20 June 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Global Women's Health
- Vol. 6, 1492231
Open AccessMeasuring the positive potential value of birth in economic evaluation of perinatal interventions
Giving birth is a \me of both risk and possibility: what happens during childbirth can be life-changing and has life-long implica\ons for mother, baby and wider family. We call for a fundamental rethinking of economic evalua\on of perinatal health interven\ons that recognises this: one that centers birthing people's experiences and accounts for the posi\ve poten\al value of birth in their lives, acknowledging that birth is not an illness (1,2) from which the best possible outcome is a return to 'baseline'. This reframing, in line with the salutogenic model of birth (3) challenges the typically employed 'deficit model' approach focusing on measuring severe morbidi\es and mortality as the most important outcomes of perinatal health interven\ons (4)(5)(6)(7). We suggest instead an assessment of the poten\al well-being increase that would result from a posi\ve, empowered, family and person-centred birth experience alongside high-quality clinical care. In this commentary, we examine the well-being enhancing poten\al of a posi\ve birth experience and the jus\fica\on for health economists to include this in economic evalua\ons of perinatal health interven\ons.From this point, at the request of the Fron\ers in Global Women's Health Chief Editorial Team, we will refer to 'women' when discussing people giving birth. We acknowledge that not everyone giving birth iden\fies as a woman and that using this shorthand risks being read as ignoring trans and non-binary people.Economic evaluations in all health areas typically focus on mortality and (severe) morbidity as the key outcomes related to health and health-related quality of life (8)(9)(10). Focusing on these 'universal' outcomes allows economists and policy makers to compare across health areas and interventions. In the perinatal period, using these outcomes means newborn well-being outweighs the parent(s) because of their much larger potential number of life years to be gained. At the most basic, this drives a focus on both clinical quality of care and on newborn care as the focus of improvement with the highest potential return.Although a woman's outcomes might be outweighed by their infant's, if a simple cumulative total approach to economic evaluation were used, the distribution of these outcomes is also important. In the global community, the right to high-quality reproductive healthcare is acknowledged(11), though often unmet. Among outcomes to be considered for women giving birth, 99.2% survive childbirth and the postpartum period globally today, though there are still many unnecessary deaths. As the recent flagship WHO report states, from 2016-2020 three quarters of countries had stagnant or increasing maternal mortality rates (MMR), with a significant reduction in MMR in just 31 countries globally (12). As such, while tracking MMR remains critical to ensure sustained health impact, including in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), simply focusing on maternal mortality (Goal 3.1) is no longer a sensitive marker of the impact of maternal and perinatal health improvement interventions in many settings (13)(14)(15). Indeed, after decades of progress focused on maternal mortality, there is a recognition that childbirth can and should be evaluated beyond merely maternal or perinatal survival (16)(17)(18)(19).The literature suggests that experience of maternity services affects utilization and timeliness of care seeking for future reproductive health needs, including early ANC (to identify high-risk pregnancies), appropriate imaging, skilled birth attendance and indeed safe abortion care (20,21). As such, a poor experience for one person during one pregnancy can create a cascade of future decision-making for them and their neighbors/family/friends. By using approaches driven by quantitative, process-oriented metrics of clinical protocols that directly lead to observable mortality and morbidity outcomes, economists neglect or under-value patient experience aspects of quality of care (22), which are likely to be more context-specific yet are critical to family-centred care and longer-term mental and physical health (23,24).There is strong evidence on the long-lasting impact of birth experience (25,26) and potential long-term impacts on bonding and capacity of mother and baby to thrive and thus to contribute economic 'value' to society, beyond these intrinsically valuable capabilities (27).Existing measures and scales are inadequate to this task, though beginning to acknowledge it in different ways. To date, these efforts have primarily focused on outcomes measures, and patientreported outcome measures (PROMs) as a category can speak to some outcomes of birth experienceas differentiated from patient-reported experience measures, that might more directly engage with the process or experience of birth. There is very limited use of PROMs in maternity and childbirth as yet, though there is growing interest.( 28) For example, the Birth Satisfaction Scale is a specific and important scale that we include in our ongoing assessment of existing measures for understanding birth experience. ( 29)However, we posit that satisfaction is an outcome and birth experience is a process, albeit one that is intrinsically valuable. In a systematic review of birth outcomes, the authors found an initial list of 135 positive outcomes and over ten times that amount of negative outcomes, supporting the claim that "…effectiveness of intrapartum interventions was measured against adverse outcomes rather than increases in measures of health and well-being". (3) To measure change and perhaps kick start further reductions, a different metric to evaluate progress against is needed -this means using these broader outcomes included in the calculation instead of focusing narrowly on death and disability, as well as including patient-reported aspects (30,31). What is currently under-explored are the links between experience and relevant capabilities -moving from the...
- Open Access
- 16 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 18 (1) , 2476820
Unwrapping the Global Financing Facility: understanding implications for women’s children’s and adolescent’s health through layered policy analysis
The Global Financing Facility (GFF), launched in 2015, aims to catalyse funding for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health, and nutrition. Few independent assessments have evaluated its processes and impact. We conducted a multi-layered policy analysis of GFF documents - the Investment Cases (ICs) and the GFF-linked World Bank Project Appraisal Documents (PADs) - examining the content of GFF documents for 28 countries, comparing four tracer themes (maternal and newborn health, adolescent health, community health, and quality), and analysing the policy processes in four country studies (Burkina Faso, Mozambique, Tanzania, and Uganda). From 2015 to 2022, GFF-linked PADs reported US$ 14.5 billion of funding across 26 countries through 30 PADs, with GFF contributing 4% to this value. GFF investments primarily focused on service delivery, governance, and performance-based financing. Countries received more targeted investments for maternal and newborn health and adolescent health linked to their burden of these tracer themes. Attention to community health and quality varied. ICs were broader than PADs and more inclusive in their development. Local contexts shaped policy processes. GFF supported priority-setting and learning; however, translating priorities into resourced actions proved challenging. Power dynamics influenced country ownership, donor coordination and resource mobilisation. The GFF is a significant opportunity to advance health for vulnerable populations. Progress in transparency and data use is evident, but accountability gaps, power imbalances, and limited engagement with civil society and private sector hinder national ownership. Further research is needed to determine GFF's attribution to catalytic resource mobilization.
- 16 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 18 (1) , 2476820
Open AccessUnwrapping the Global Financing Facility: understanding implications for women’s children’s and adolescent’s health through layered policy analysis
The Global Financing Facility (GFF), launched in 2015, aims to catalyse funding for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health, and nutrition. Few independent assessments have evaluated its processes and impact. We conducted a multi-layered policy analysis of GFF documents - the Investment Cases (ICs) and the GFF-linked World Bank Project Appraisal Documents (PADs) - examining the content of GFF documents for 28 countries, comparing four tracer themes (maternal and newborn health, adolescent health, community health, and quality), and analysing the policy processes in four country studies (Burkina Faso, Mozambique, Tanzania, and Uganda). From 2015 to 2022, GFF-linked PADs reported US$ 14.5 billion of funding across 26 countries through 30 PADs, with GFF contributing 4% to this value. GFF investments primarily focused on service delivery, governance, and performance-based financing. Countries received more targeted investments for maternal and newborn health and adolescent health linked to their burden of these tracer themes. Attention to community health and quality varied. ICs were broader than PADs and more inclusive in their development. Local contexts shaped policy processes. GFF supported priority-setting and learning; however, translating priorities into resourced actions proved challenging. Power dynamics influenced country ownership, donor coordination and resource mobilisation. The GFF is a significant opportunity to advance health for vulnerable populations. Progress in transparency and data use is evident, but accountability gaps, power imbalances, and limited engagement with civil society and private sector hinder national ownership. Further research is needed to determine GFF's attribution to catalytic resource mobilization.
- Open Access
- 29 December 2024
- Published by Nova Southeastern University in The Qualitative Report
- Vol. 29 (10) , 2826-2847
Collaborative Creative Inquiry: An Arts-Informed Approach to Transdisciplinary Research
This paper presents Collaborative Creative Inquiry (CCI) as innovative arts-informed approach to transdisciplinary research. Moving away from conventional qualitative research paradigms, we adopt a reflexive stance to introduce CCI as a process that challenges static narratives and fosters inclusivity within the research process. Through critical introspection, we describe an iterative five-step CCI approach, elucidating its unique process and methodological underpinnings. Drawing upon vivid personal illustrations, we offer vignettes to illustrate the application of CCI in practice and showcase opportunities for collaborative knowledge generation with co-creation. We conclude by reflecting on insights we gained through our CCI process and inviting others to join us in exploring the ways this approach can be applied across disciplines.
- 29 December 2024
- Published by Nova Southeastern University in The Qualitative Report
- Vol. 29 (10) , 2826-2847
Open AccessCollaborative Creative Inquiry: An Arts-Informed Approach to Transdisciplinary Research
This paper presents Collaborative Creative Inquiry (CCI) as innovative arts-informed approach to transdisciplinary research. Moving away from conventional qualitative research paradigms, we adopt a reflexive stance to introduce CCI as a process that challenges static narratives and fosters inclusivity within the research process. Through critical introspection, we describe an iterative five-step CCI approach, elucidating its unique process and methodological underpinnings. Drawing upon vivid personal illustrations, we offer vignettes to illustrate the application of CCI in practice and showcase opportunities for collaborative knowledge generation with co-creation. We conclude by reflecting on insights we gained through our CCI process and inviting others to join us in exploring the ways this approach can be applied across disciplines.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2406486
Examining priorities and investments made through the Global Financing Facility for maternal and newborn health: a sub-analysis on quality
Improving quality of care could avert most of the 4.5 million maternal and neonatal deaths and stillbirths that occur each year. The Global Financing Facility (GFF) aims to catalyse the national scale-up of maternal and newborn health (MNH) interventions through focused investments. Achieving impact and value for money requires high, equitable coverage and high quality of interventions. This study examines whether the rhetoric of increasing coverage together with quality has informed investment strategies in MNH through a secondary analysis of 25 GFF documents from 11 African countries. The analysis shows that the country GFF-related documents incorporate some MNH-related quality of care components; however, there is a lack of clarity in what is meant by quality and the absence of core MNH quality of care components as identified by the World Health Organization’s MNH quality framework, especially experience of care and newborn care. Many of the Investment Cases have a more diagonal focus on MNH service delivery considering the clinical dimensions of quality, while the investments described in the Project Appraisal Documents are primarily on horizontal structural aspects of the health system strengthening environment. The GFF is at the forefront of investing in MNH globally and provides an important opportunity to explicitly link health systems investments and quality interventions within the MNH continuum of care for optimal impact.
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2406486
Open AccessExamining priorities and investments made through the Global Financing Facility for maternal and newborn health: a sub-analysis on quality
Improving quality of care could avert most of the 4.5 million maternal and neonatal deaths and stillbirths that occur each year. The Global Financing Facility (GFF) aims to catalyse the national scale-up of maternal and newborn health (MNH) interventions through focused investments. Achieving impact and value for money requires high, equitable coverage and high quality of interventions. This study examines whether the rhetoric of increasing coverage together with quality has informed investment strategies in MNH through a secondary analysis of 25 GFF documents from 11 African countries. The analysis shows that the country GFF-related documents incorporate some MNH-related quality of care components; however, there is a lack of clarity in what is meant by quality and the absence of core MNH quality of care components as identified by the World Health Organization’s MNH quality framework, especially experience of care and newborn care. Many of the Investment Cases have a more diagonal focus on MNH service delivery considering the clinical dimensions of quality, while the investments described in the Project Appraisal Documents are primarily on horizontal structural aspects of the health system strengthening environment. The GFF is at the forefront of investing in MNH globally and provides an important opportunity to explicitly link health systems investments and quality interventions within the MNH continuum of care for optimal impact.
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2407680
How does community health feature in Global Financing Facility planning documents to support reproductive, maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health and nutrition (RMNAH-N)? insights from six francophone West African countries
Community health is key for improving Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child, and Adolescent Health and Nutrition (RMNCAH-N). However, how community health supports integrated RMNCAH-N service delivery in francophone West Africa is under-researched. We examined how six francophone West African countries (Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Guinea, Mali, Niger, and Senegal) support community health through the Global Financing Facility for Women, Children and Adolescents (GFF). We conducted a content analysis on Investment Cases and Project Appraisal Documents from selected countries, and set out the scope of the analysis and the key search terms. We applied an iterative hybrid inductive-deductive approach to identify themes for data coding and extraction. The extracted data were compared within and across countries and further grouped into meaningful categories. In country documents, there is a commitment to community health, with significant attention paid to various cadres of community health workers (CHWs) who undertake a range of preventive, promotive and curative roles across RMNCAH-N spectrum. While CHWs renumeration is mentioned, it varies considerably. Most community health indicators focus on CHWs' deliverables, with few related to governance and civil registration. Challenges in implementing community health include poor leadership and governance and resource shortages resulting in low CHWs performance and service utilization. While some countries invest significantly in training CHWs, structural reforms and broader community engagement are lacking. There is an opportunity to better prioritize and streamline community health interventions, including integrating them into health system planning and budgeting, to fully harness their potential to improve RMNCAH-N.
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2407680
Open AccessHow does community health feature in Global Financing Facility planning documents to support reproductive, maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health and nutrition (RMNAH-N)? insights from six francophone West African countries
Community health is key for improving Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child, and Adolescent Health and Nutrition (RMNCAH-N). However, how community health supports integrated RMNCAH-N service delivery in francophone West Africa is under-researched. We examined how six francophone West African countries (Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Guinea, Mali, Niger, and Senegal) support community health through the Global Financing Facility for Women, Children and Adolescents (GFF). We conducted a content analysis on Investment Cases and Project Appraisal Documents from selected countries, and set out the scope of the analysis and the key search terms. We applied an iterative hybrid inductive-deductive approach to identify themes for data coding and extraction. The extracted data were compared within and across countries and further grouped into meaningful categories. In country documents, there is a commitment to community health, with significant attention paid to various cadres of community health workers (CHWs) who undertake a range of preventive, promotive and curative roles across RMNCAH-N spectrum. While CHWs renumeration is mentioned, it varies considerably. Most community health indicators focus on CHWs' deliverables, with few related to governance and civil registration. Challenges in implementing community health include poor leadership and governance and resource shortages resulting in low CHWs performance and service utilization. While some countries invest significantly in training CHWs, structural reforms and broader community engagement are lacking. There is an opportunity to better prioritize and streamline community health interventions, including integrating them into health system planning and budgeting, to fully harness their potential to improve RMNCAH-N.
- Open Access
- 5 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2329369
Global Financing Facility investments for vulnerable populations: content analysis regarding maternal and newborn health and stillbirths in 11 African countries, 2015 to 2019
The Global Financing Facility (GFF) was launched in 2015 to catalyse increased domestic and external financing for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, adolescent health, and nutrition. Half of the deaths along this continuum are neonatal deaths, stillbirths or maternal deaths; yet these topics receive the least aid financing across the continuum. To conduct a policy content analysis of maternal and newborn health (MNH), including stillbirths, in GFF country planning documents, and assess the mortality burden related to the investment. Content analysis was conducted on 24 GFF policy documents, investment cases and project appraisal documents (PADs), from 11 African countries. We used a systematic data extraction approach and applied a framework for analysis considering mindset, measures, and money for MNH interventions and mentions of mortality outcomes. We compared PAD investments to MNH-related deaths by country. For these 11 countries, USD$1,894 million of new funds were allocated through the PADs, including USD$303 million (16%) from GFF. All documents had strong content on MNH, with particular focus on pregnancy and childbirth interventions. The investment cases commonly included comprehensive results frameworks, and PADs generally had less technical content and fewer indicators. Mortality outcomes were mentioned, especially for maternal. Stillbirths were rarely included as targets. Countries had differing approaches to funding descriptions. PAD allocations are commensurate with the burden. The GFF country plans present a promising start in addressing MNH. Emphasising links between investments and burden, explicitly including stillbirth, and highlighting high-impact packages, as appropriate, could potentially increase impact.
- 5 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2329369
Open AccessGlobal Financing Facility investments for vulnerable populations: content analysis regarding maternal and newborn health and stillbirths in 11 African countries, 2015 to 2019
The Global Financing Facility (GFF) was launched in 2015 to catalyse increased domestic and external financing for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, adolescent health, and nutrition. Half of the deaths along this continuum are neonatal deaths, stillbirths or maternal deaths; yet these topics receive the least aid financing across the continuum. To conduct a policy content analysis of maternal and newborn health (MNH), including stillbirths, in GFF country planning documents, and assess the mortality burden related to the investment. Content analysis was conducted on 24 GFF policy documents, investment cases and project appraisal documents (PADs), from 11 African countries. We used a systematic data extraction approach and applied a framework for analysis considering mindset, measures, and money for MNH interventions and mentions of mortality outcomes. We compared PAD investments to MNH-related deaths by country. For these 11 countries, USD$1,894 million of new funds were allocated through the PADs, including USD$303 million (16%) from GFF. All documents had strong content on MNH, with particular focus on pregnancy and childbirth interventions. The investment cases commonly included comprehensive results frameworks, and PADs generally had less technical content and fewer indicators. Mortality outcomes were mentioned, especially for maternal. Stillbirths were rarely included as targets. Countries had differing approaches to funding descriptions. PAD allocations are commensurate with the burden. The GFF country plans present a promising start in addressing MNH. Emphasising links between investments and burden, explicitly including stillbirth, and highlighting high-impact packages, as appropriate, could potentially increase impact.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2360702
Form and functioning: contextualising the start of the Global Financing Facility policy processes in Burkina Faso
Burkina Faso joined the Global Financing Facility for Women, Children and Adolescents (GFF) in 2017 to address persistent gaps in funding for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health and nutrition (RMNCAH-N). Few empirical papers deal with how global funding mechanisms, and specifically GFF, support resource mobilisation for health nationally. This study describes the policy processes of developing the GFF planning documents (the Investment Case and Project Appraisal Document) in Burkina Faso. We conducted an exploratory qualitative policy analysis. Data collection included document review (N = 74) and in-depth semi-structured interviews (N = 23). Data were analysed based on the components of the health policy triangle. There was strong national political support to RMNCAH-N interventions, and the process of drawing up the investment case (IC) and the project appraisal document was inclusive and multi-sectoral. Despite high-level policy commitments, subsequent implementation of the World Bank project, including the GFF contribution, was perceived by respondents as challenging, even after the project restructuring process occurred. These challenges were due to ongoing policy fragmentation for RMNCAH-N, navigation of differing procedures and perspectives between stakeholders in the setting up of the work, overcoming misunderstandings about the nature of the GFF, and weak institutional anchoring of the IC. Insecurity and political instability also contributed to observed delays and difficulties in implementing the commitments agreed upon. To tackle these issues, transformational and distributive leaderships should be promoted and made effective. Few studies have examined national policy processes linked to the GFF or other global health initiatives. This kind of research is needed to better understand the range of challenges in aligning donor and national priorities encountered across diverse health systems contexts. This study may stimulate others to ensure that the GFF and other global health initiatives respond to local needs and policy environments for better implementation.
- 24 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Global Health Action
- Vol. 17 (1) , 2360702
Open AccessForm and functioning: contextualising the start of the Global Financing Facility policy processes in Burkina Faso
Burkina Faso joined the Global Financing Facility for Women, Children and Adolescents (GFF) in 2017 to address persistent gaps in funding for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health and nutrition (RMNCAH-N). Few empirical papers deal with how global funding mechanisms, and specifically GFF, support resource mobilisation for health nationally. This study describes the policy processes of developing the GFF planning documents (the Investment Case and Project Appraisal Document) in Burkina Faso. We conducted an exploratory qualitative policy analysis. Data collection included document review (N = 74) and in-depth semi-structured interviews (N = 23). Data were analysed based on the components of the health policy triangle. There was strong national political support to RMNCAH-N interventions, and the process of drawing up the investment case (IC) and the project appraisal document was inclusive and multi-sectoral. Despite high-level policy commitments, subsequent implementation of the World Bank project, including the GFF contribution, was perceived by respondents as challenging, even after the project restructuring process occurred. These challenges were due to ongoing policy fragmentation for RMNCAH-N, navigation of differing procedures and perspectives between stakeholders in the setting up of the work, overcoming misunderstandings about the nature of the GFF, and weak institutional anchoring of the IC. Insecurity and political instability also contributed to observed delays and difficulties in implementing the commitments agreed upon. To tackle these issues, transformational and distributive leaderships should be promoted and made effective. Few studies have examined national policy processes linked to the GFF or other global health initiatives. This kind of research is needed to better understand the range of challenges in aligning donor and national priorities encountered across diverse health systems contexts. This study may stimulate others to ensure that the GFF and other global health initiatives respond to local needs and policy environments for better implementation.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Open Digital Health
- Vol. 2, oqae037
Task sharing for increasing access to obstetric ultrasonography: a formative qualitative study of nurse-led scanning with telemedicine review in Kenya
The informal settlements of Nairobi have higher neonatal and infant mortality rates than the average for Nairobi. Universal access to important diagnostics like ultrasonography is poor and inequitable due to the high cost of devices and limited availability of skilled sonographers. Recent advances of mobile ultrasound probes connected to smartphones, with or without artificial intelligence support, have improved access to devices; but skills to perform and interpret scans continue to be limited. The SonoMobile intervention involved training nurse-midwives to conduct point-of-care obstetric ultrasound scans in antenatal care clinics in urban informal settlements. Scan data and images were shared, using telemedicine technology, with remote sonographers, who reviewed scan images and data, and provided reports. This study of 61 respondents from diverse stakeholder groups describes the acceptability, utility and considerations for sustainability of nurse-led, point-of-care obstetric ultrasonography with telemedicine review. Perceived value of nurse-led obstetric ultrasonography includes improving access and affordability of obstetric ultrasonography services, timely identification and referral of high-risk pregnancies, and improving awareness of appropriate antenatal care among underserved populations. The relative affordability of SonoMobile was described as a critical enabler for a business model targeting low- and middle-income segments of the population, and for increasing quality and equity of antenatal care coverage. Areas highlighted for improvement include strengthening supervision of nurse trainees, broadening the scope of nurse training and development of clear regulatory guidelines for nurse-led obstetric ultrasonography. The study highlights the complex task shifting required to provide universal access to a life-saving technology in a low- and middle-income country health system.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Open Digital Health
- Vol. 2, oqae037
Open AccessTask sharing for increasing access to obstetric ultrasonography: a formative qualitative study of nurse-led scanning with telemedicine review in Kenya
The informal settlements of Nairobi have higher neonatal and infant mortality rates than the average for Nairobi. Universal access to important diagnostics like ultrasonography is poor and inequitable due to the high cost of devices and limited availability of skilled sonographers. Recent advances of mobile ultrasound probes connected to smartphones, with or without artificial intelligence support, have improved access to devices; but skills to perform and interpret scans continue to be limited. The SonoMobile intervention involved training nurse-midwives to conduct point-of-care obstetric ultrasound scans in antenatal care clinics in urban informal settlements. Scan data and images were shared, using telemedicine technology, with remote sonographers, who reviewed scan images and data, and provided reports. This study of 61 respondents from diverse stakeholder groups describes the acceptability, utility and considerations for sustainability of nurse-led, point-of-care obstetric ultrasonography with telemedicine review. Perceived value of nurse-led obstetric ultrasonography includes improving access and affordability of obstetric ultrasonography services, timely identification and referral of high-risk pregnancies, and improving awareness of appropriate antenatal care among underserved populations. The relative affordability of SonoMobile was described as a critical enabler for a business model targeting low- and middle-income segments of the population, and for increasing quality and equity of antenatal care coverage. Areas highlighted for improvement include strengthening supervision of nurse trainees, broadening the scope of nurse training and development of clear regulatory guidelines for nurse-led obstetric ultrasonography. The study highlights the complex task shifting required to provide universal access to a life-saving technology in a low- and middle-income country health system.