Li Li
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Li Li has a total of 129 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Qiu‐Gang Zong
School of Earth and Space Sciences Peking University Beijing China
27 shared publications - Xu‐Zhi Zhou
School of Earth and Space Sciences Peking University Beijing China
22 shared publications - Chao Yue
Peking University
19 shared publications - Yoshiharu Omura
State Key Laboratory of Lunar and Planetary Sciences Macau University of Science and Technology Macau China
13 shared publications - Zhi-Yang Liu
Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie CNES‐CNRS‐Universite Toulouse III Paul Sabatier Toulouse France
13 shared publications - Robert Rankin
Department of Physics University of Alberta Edmonton AB Canada
11 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 53 (17)
Substorm Effects on Chorus Emissions Modulated by ULF Waves
Although cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions play a critical role in energy transfer in the magnetosphere, the influence of geomagnetic activity on the physical mechanisms involved remains unclear. In this study, we investigate this question by analyzing Van Allen Probes‐A observations of an event occurring on 25 July 2016. Ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves, chorus waves, and enhancements of electron fluxes with substorm‐induced energy‐dispersive characteristics were detected simultaneously during this event. Cross‐wavelet analysis suggests that the chorus intensity is modulated by ULF waves. The frequency of chorus elements decreases concurrently with substorm injections. We perform linear instability analysis to interpret the frequency drop. It is found that substorm‐injected electrons with energies of tens to ∼200 keV have reduced perpendicular anisotropy, thereby changing the energy range responsible for chorus growth and modifying the generation frequency. Our results enhance knowledge of cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions and their roles in auroral evolution during substorm processes.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 53 (17)
Open AccessSubstorm Effects on Chorus Emissions Modulated by ULF Waves
Although cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions play a critical role in energy transfer in the magnetosphere, the influence of geomagnetic activity on the physical mechanisms involved remains unclear. In this study, we investigate this question by analyzing Van Allen Probes‐A observations of an event occurring on 25 July 2016. Ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves, chorus waves, and enhancements of electron fluxes with substorm‐induced energy‐dispersive characteristics were detected simultaneously during this event. Cross‐wavelet analysis suggests that the chorus intensity is modulated by ULF waves. The frequency of chorus elements decreases concurrently with substorm injections. We perform linear instability analysis to interpret the frequency drop. It is found that substorm‐injected electrons with energies of tens to ∼200 keV have reduced perpendicular anisotropy, thereby changing the energy range responsible for chorus growth and modifying the generation frequency. Our results enhance knowledge of cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions and their roles in auroral evolution during substorm processes.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in AGU Advances
- Vol. 7 (4)
Bidirectional Energy Transfer via Simultaneous Wave‐Particle Resonances in Inhomogeneous Space Plasmas
Wave‐particle resonance is a key mechanism for energy transfer in collisionless plasmas with important implications for wave excitation and particle acceleration. Cyclotron resonance occurs when a particle's gyromotion synchronizes with the wave fields, with their interactions usually describable by quasilinear diffusion or nonlinear trapping. The nonlinear wave‐particle energy transfer is facilitated by background inhomogeneities such as magnetic field gradients and/or frequency sweeping. When wave amplitudes become large, the particle's gyromotion can be strongly perturbed, altering the classical cyclotron resonance condition and giving rise to a nonlinear process known as anomalous resonance or anomalous trapping. This mechanism has been explored in idealized, uniform settings; however, its behavior in realistic inhomogeneous environments remains poorly understood. Here, we present in situ evidence of simultaneous cyclotron and anomalous resonances between electromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) waves and charged particles in Earth's dayside magnetosphere. The local magnetic‐field gradient enables bidirectional wave‐particle energy transfer: high‐energy ions drive the waves through cyclotron resonance, while lower‐energy ions absorb energy from the same waves via anomalous resonance. We also identify signatures consistent with anomalous resonance of sub‐keV electrons, suggesting that efficient wave‐particle coupling may extend far below the classical cyclotron‐resonant energy. This interplay of resonances reveals an inhomogeneity‐driven pathway for energy redistribution across a broader energy range than previously recognized. These findings highlight the need to incorporate anomalous resonance into models of magnetospheric dynamics, especially in regions with strong inhomogeneities, and open new avenues for understanding energy transfer in complex plasma environments.
- 9 July 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in AGU Advances
- Vol. 7 (4)
Open AccessBidirectional Energy Transfer via Simultaneous Wave‐Particle Resonances in Inhomogeneous Space Plasmas
Wave‐particle resonance is a key mechanism for energy transfer in collisionless plasmas with important implications for wave excitation and particle acceleration. Cyclotron resonance occurs when a particle's gyromotion synchronizes with the wave fields, with their interactions usually describable by quasilinear diffusion or nonlinear trapping. The nonlinear wave‐particle energy transfer is facilitated by background inhomogeneities such as magnetic field gradients and/or frequency sweeping. When wave amplitudes become large, the particle's gyromotion can be strongly perturbed, altering the classical cyclotron resonance condition and giving rise to a nonlinear process known as anomalous resonance or anomalous trapping. This mechanism has been explored in idealized, uniform settings; however, its behavior in realistic inhomogeneous environments remains poorly understood. Here, we present in situ evidence of simultaneous cyclotron and anomalous resonances between electromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) waves and charged particles in Earth's dayside magnetosphere. The local magnetic‐field gradient enables bidirectional wave‐particle energy transfer: high‐energy ions drive the waves through cyclotron resonance, while lower‐energy ions absorb energy from the same waves via anomalous resonance. We also identify signatures consistent with anomalous resonance of sub‐keV electrons, suggesting that efficient wave‐particle coupling may extend far below the classical cyclotron‐resonant energy. This interplay of resonances reveals an inhomogeneity‐driven pathway for energy redistribution across a broader energy range than previously recognized. These findings highlight the need to incorporate anomalous resonance into models of magnetospheric dynamics, especially in regions with strong inhomogeneities, and open new avenues for understanding energy transfer in complex plasma environments.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 52 (20)
Auroral Asymmetry Associated With the South Atlantic Anomaly
The South Atlantic anomaly (SAA) exerts a weakening effect on magnetic field strength on Earth, however, little is known of its effect on the auroral spatial distribution and temporal evolution. Using Defense Meteorological Satellite Program/Special Sensor Ultraviolet Spectrographic Imager ultraviolet data spanning 2016–2023, we investigated the impact of the SAA on auroral asymmetries. The SAA amplified the inherent north–south hemispheric asymmetry by reducing the local south/north intensity ratios, modified the semiannual variations through a seasonally persistent suppression, and modulated the dawn–dusk asymmetries by attenuating the southern hemisphere intensity while enhancing the northern hemisphere dawnside intensity. The SAA‐induced auroral asymmetries persisted across geomagnetic conditions but became more distinguishable during active periods. Therefore, the SAA acts as a local perturbation and global modulator of auroral precipitation patterns. This work provides new insights into auroral behavior on Earth and can be extended to other planetary bodies with nondipolar or weak magnetic field configurations.
- 13 October 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 52 (20)
Open AccessAuroral Asymmetry Associated With the South Atlantic Anomaly
The South Atlantic anomaly (SAA) exerts a weakening effect on magnetic field strength on Earth, however, little is known of its effect on the auroral spatial distribution and temporal evolution. Using Defense Meteorological Satellite Program/Special Sensor Ultraviolet Spectrographic Imager ultraviolet data spanning 2016–2023, we investigated the impact of the SAA on auroral asymmetries. The SAA amplified the inherent north–south hemispheric asymmetry by reducing the local south/north intensity ratios, modified the semiannual variations through a seasonally persistent suppression, and modulated the dawn–dusk asymmetries by attenuating the southern hemisphere intensity while enhancing the northern hemisphere dawnside intensity. The SAA‐induced auroral asymmetries persisted across geomagnetic conditions but became more distinguishable during active periods. Therefore, the SAA acts as a local perturbation and global modulator of auroral precipitation patterns. This work provides new insights into auroral behavior on Earth and can be extended to other planetary bodies with nondipolar or weak magnetic field configurations.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 52 (10)
Cross‐Scale Interactions Between ULF Waves, VLF Waves, and Electrons
Wave‐particle interactions are essential for energy transport in the magnetosphere. In this study, we investigated an event during which electrons interact simultaneously with waves in different scales, using data from the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission. At the macroscale ( km), drift resonance between ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves and 70–300 keV electrons is observed. At the microscale ( km), lower‐band chorus waves and electron cyclotron harmonic (ECH) waves are alternately generated, showing signatures of modulation by ULF waves. We found that compressional ULF waves affect the temperature anisotropy of 1–10 keV electrons, thereby periodically exciting chorus waves. Through linear instability analysis, we propose that ULF waves modulate ECH wave emissions by regulating the gradient of electron phase space density at the edge of the loss cone. Our results enhance the understanding of cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions, highlighting their importance in magnetospheric dynamics.
- 22 May 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 52 (10)
Open AccessCross‐Scale Interactions Between ULF Waves, VLF Waves, and Electrons
Wave‐particle interactions are essential for energy transport in the magnetosphere. In this study, we investigated an event during which electrons interact simultaneously with waves in different scales, using data from the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission. At the macroscale ( km), drift resonance between ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves and 70–300 keV electrons is observed. At the microscale ( km), lower‐band chorus waves and electron cyclotron harmonic (ECH) waves are alternately generated, showing signatures of modulation by ULF waves. We found that compressional ULF waves affect the temperature anisotropy of 1–10 keV electrons, thereby periodically exciting chorus waves. Through linear instability analysis, we propose that ULF waves modulate ECH wave emissions by regulating the gradient of electron phase space density at the edge of the loss cone. Our results enhance the understanding of cross‐scale wave‐particle interactions, highlighting their importance in magnetospheric dynamics.
- Open Access
- 7 February 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (6) , eadr8227
Direct observations of cross-scale wave-particle energy transfer in space plasmas
The collisionless plasmas in space and astrophysical environments are intrinsically multiscale in nature, behaving as conducting fluids at macroscales and kinetically at microscales comparable to ion and/or electron gyroradii. A fundamental question in understanding the plasma dynamics is how energy is transported and dissipated across scales. Here, we present spacecraft measurements in the terrestrial foreshock, a region upstream of the bow shock where the solar wind population coexists with the reflected ions. In this region, the fluid-scale, ultralow-frequency waves resonate with the reflected ions to modify the velocity distributions, which in turn cause the growth of the ion-scale, magnetosonic-whistler waves. The latter waves then resonate with the electrons, and the accelerated electrons contribute to the excitation of electron-scale, high-frequency whistler waves. These observations demonstrate that the chain of wave-particle resonances is an efficient mechanism for cross-scale energy transfer, which could redistribute the kinetic energy and accelerate the particles upstream of the shocks.
- 7 February 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (6) , eadr8227
Open AccessDirect observations of cross-scale wave-particle energy transfer in space plasmas
The collisionless plasmas in space and astrophysical environments are intrinsically multiscale in nature, behaving as conducting fluids at macroscales and kinetically at microscales comparable to ion and/or electron gyroradii. A fundamental question in understanding the plasma dynamics is how energy is transported and dissipated across scales. Here, we present spacecraft measurements in the terrestrial foreshock, a region upstream of the bow shock where the solar wind population coexists with the reflected ions. In this region, the fluid-scale, ultralow-frequency waves resonate with the reflected ions to modify the velocity distributions, which in turn cause the growth of the ion-scale, magnetosonic-whistler waves. The latter waves then resonate with the electrons, and the accelerated electrons contribute to the excitation of electron-scale, high-frequency whistler waves. These observations demonstrate that the chain of wave-particle resonances is an efficient mechanism for cross-scale energy transfer, which could redistribute the kinetic energy and accelerate the particles upstream of the shocks.
- 21 November 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (11)
The Excitation of Second Harmonic Poloidal ULF Waves Through Drift‐Bounce Resonance With Protons in the Magnetic Dip
The drift‐bounce resonance between ultralow‐frequency (ULF) waves and charged particles is an efficient way to transfer energy. In this study, we report the excitation of ULF waves through drift‐bounce resonance with protons in the magnetic dip for the first time. On 4 September 2015, Van Allen probe B observed ULF signals with a frequency of ∼10 mHz inside the magnetic dip during substorms at the dusk side. The ULF waves are further diagnosed as second harmonic poloidal waves. The 54–67 keV protons in the magnetic dip exhibit oscillations with the same period as ULF waves, providing evidence for drift‐bounce resonance. Through finite Larmor radius effects, we determined that the ULF waves propagate eastward with an azimuthal wave number in the range of 237–277. The ULF waves are excited with free energy related to the enhanced proton phase space density in the magnetic dip.
- 21 November 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (11)
The Excitation of Second Harmonic Poloidal ULF Waves Through Drift‐Bounce Resonance With Protons in the Magnetic Dip
The drift‐bounce resonance between ultralow‐frequency (ULF) waves and charged particles is an efficient way to transfer energy. In this study, we report the excitation of ULF waves through drift‐bounce resonance with protons in the magnetic dip for the first time. On 4 September 2015, Van Allen probe B observed ULF signals with a frequency of ∼10 mHz inside the magnetic dip during substorms at the dusk side. The ULF waves are further diagnosed as second harmonic poloidal waves. The 54–67 keV protons in the magnetic dip exhibit oscillations with the same period as ULF waves, providing evidence for drift‐bounce resonance. Through finite Larmor radius effects, we determined that the ULF waves propagate eastward with an azimuthal wave number in the range of 237–277. The ULF waves are excited with free energy related to the enhanced proton phase space density in the magnetic dip.
- Open Access
- 16 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 51 (20)
Electromagnetic Landau Resonance: Nonlinear Dynamics and Harmonic Generation
In situ particle observations provide useful information for determining the significance of nonlinearity in wave‐particle interactions. Here, we examine an electromagnetic Landau resonance event observed by the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission near the dayside magnetopause along this line of thought. During this event, protons with energy 748 eV and pitch angle are observed to resonate with electromagnetic‐ion‐cyclotron waves. Detailed data analysis reveals the existence of a second harmonic signal in proton modulation. Using an observation‐based test particle simulation, this signal is explained as a low‐resolution manifestation of phase space rolled‐up structures, which themselves are not observable due to limited instrument resolution. The presence of these rolled‐up structures suggests that the waves induce significant displacement of the protons in phase space, consequently confirming the nonlinear nature of the observed interaction. Based on the observations, we further discuss the possibility of the nonlinear electromagnetic Landau resonance generating second harmonic waves.
- 16 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 51 (20)
Open AccessElectromagnetic Landau Resonance: Nonlinear Dynamics and Harmonic Generation
In situ particle observations provide useful information for determining the significance of nonlinearity in wave‐particle interactions. Here, we examine an electromagnetic Landau resonance event observed by the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission near the dayside magnetopause along this line of thought. During this event, protons with energy 748 eV and pitch angle are observed to resonate with electromagnetic‐ion‐cyclotron waves. Detailed data analysis reveals the existence of a second harmonic signal in proton modulation. Using an observation‐based test particle simulation, this signal is explained as a low‐resolution manifestation of phase space rolled‐up structures, which themselves are not observable due to limited instrument resolution. The presence of these rolled‐up structures suggests that the waves induce significant displacement of the protons in phase space, consequently confirming the nonlinear nature of the observed interaction. Based on the observations, we further discuss the possibility of the nonlinear electromagnetic Landau resonance generating second harmonic waves.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 51 (20)
Bow Shock Ripples and Their Modulation of Whistler Wave Packets: MMS Observations
The terrestrial bow shock is the boundary where supersonic solar wind slows down abruptly near the magnetopause. The shock front geometry could be modulated by surface waves to form rippled structures, which impact the acceleration process of the solar wind particles. However, the rippled structures are hard to be identified unambiguously due to the similar signatures in single‐spacecraft observations between rippled shocks and reforming shocks. Here, we utilize the four‐spacecraft observations from the MMS mission to investigate an event of quasi‐perpendicular bow shock crossing. The periodic oscillations of shock normal directions and normal velocities support the scenario of surface wave propagation in the tangential direction. We also reconstruct the shock profile along the normal direction, and its monotonic shape further excludes the occurrence of shock reformation. These ripples are found to modulate the reflected ions and whistler wave packets, which adds to the complexity of the bow shock plasma environments.
- 11 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 51 (20)
Open AccessBow Shock Ripples and Their Modulation of Whistler Wave Packets: MMS Observations
The terrestrial bow shock is the boundary where supersonic solar wind slows down abruptly near the magnetopause. The shock front geometry could be modulated by surface waves to form rippled structures, which impact the acceleration process of the solar wind particles. However, the rippled structures are hard to be identified unambiguously due to the similar signatures in single‐spacecraft observations between rippled shocks and reforming shocks. Here, we utilize the four‐spacecraft observations from the MMS mission to investigate an event of quasi‐perpendicular bow shock crossing. The periodic oscillations of shock normal directions and normal velocities support the scenario of surface wave propagation in the tangential direction. We also reconstruct the shock profile along the normal direction, and its monotonic shape further excludes the occurrence of shock reformation. These ripples are found to modulate the reflected ions and whistler wave packets, which adds to the complexity of the bow shock plasma environments.
- 5 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (10)
A Statistical Examination of Interactions Between 1‐Hz Whistler Waves and Ions in the Earth's Foreshock
The 1 Hz whistler wave precursors attached to shock‐like structures are often observed in the foreshock. Using observations from the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission, we investigate the interactions between 1 Hz waves and ions. Incoming solar wind ions do not cyclotron‐resonate with the wave, since typically the wave is right‐handed in their frame. We demonstrate that solar wind ions commonly exhibit 180° gyro‐phase bunching from the wave magnetic field, understanding it with a reconciled linear theory and non‐linear trapping theory for non‐cyclotron‐resonant modulations. Along the longitudinal direction, solar wind ions experience Landau resonance, exhibiting either modulations at small wave potentials or trapping in phase‐space holes at large potentials. The results also improve our understanding of foreshock structure evolution and 1 Hz wave excitation. Shock‐like structures start with having incoming solar wind and remotely reflected ions from further downstream. The ion‐scale 1 Hz waves can already appear during this stage. The excitation may be due to shock‐like dispersive radiation or kinetic instabilities resonant with these remotely reflected ions. Ions reflected by local shock‐like structures occur later, so they are not always necessary for generating 1 Hz waves. The wave leads to ion reflection further upstream, which may cause reformation of shock‐like structures. In one event, locally reflected ions exhibit non‐cyclotron‐resonant modulation in the early stage, and later approach the anomalous cyclotron resonant condition with gyro‐phases ∼270°. The latter is possibly due to nonlinear trapping in regions with an upstream‐pointing magnetic field gradient, linked to reformation. Some additional special features, such as frequency dispersions, are observed, encouraging further investigations.
- 5 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (10)
A Statistical Examination of Interactions Between 1‐Hz Whistler Waves and Ions in the Earth's Foreshock
The 1 Hz whistler wave precursors attached to shock‐like structures are often observed in the foreshock. Using observations from the Magnetospheric Multiscale mission, we investigate the interactions between 1 Hz waves and ions. Incoming solar wind ions do not cyclotron‐resonate with the wave, since typically the wave is right‐handed in their frame. We demonstrate that solar wind ions commonly exhibit 180° gyro‐phase bunching from the wave magnetic field, understanding it with a reconciled linear theory and non‐linear trapping theory for non‐cyclotron‐resonant modulations. Along the longitudinal direction, solar wind ions experience Landau resonance, exhibiting either modulations at small wave potentials or trapping in phase‐space holes at large potentials. The results also improve our understanding of foreshock structure evolution and 1 Hz wave excitation. Shock‐like structures start with having incoming solar wind and remotely reflected ions from further downstream. The ion‐scale 1 Hz waves can already appear during this stage. The excitation may be due to shock‐like dispersive radiation or kinetic instabilities resonant with these remotely reflected ions. Ions reflected by local shock‐like structures occur later, so they are not always necessary for generating 1 Hz waves. The wave leads to ion reflection further upstream, which may cause reformation of shock‐like structures. In one event, locally reflected ions exhibit non‐cyclotron‐resonant modulation in the early stage, and later approach the anomalous cyclotron resonant condition with gyro‐phases ∼270°. The latter is possibly due to nonlinear trapping in regions with an upstream‐pointing magnetic field gradient, linked to reformation. Some additional special features, such as frequency dispersions, are observed, encouraging further investigations.
- 17 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (8)
Nonlinear Drift‐Bounce Resonance Between Charged Particles and Ultralow Frequency Waves
Ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves contribute significantly to the dynamic evolution of Earth's magnetosphere by accelerating and transporting charged particles within a wide energy range. A substantial excitation mechanism of these waves is their drift‐bounce resonant interactions with magnetospheric particles. Here, we extend the conventional drift‐bounce resonance theory to formulate the nonlinear particle trapping in the ULF wave‐carried potential well, which can be approximately described by a pendulum equation. We also predict the observable signatures of the nonlinear drift‐bounce resonance, and compare them with spacecraft observations. We further discuss potential drivers of the pendulum including the convection electric field and the magnetospheric dayside compression, which lead to additional particle acceleration or deceleration depending on magnetic longitude. These drivers indicate preferred regions for nonlinear ULF wave growth, which are consistent with previous statistical studies.
- 17 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
- Vol. 129 (8)
Nonlinear Drift‐Bounce Resonance Between Charged Particles and Ultralow Frequency Waves
Ultra‐low frequency (ULF) waves contribute significantly to the dynamic evolution of Earth's magnetosphere by accelerating and transporting charged particles within a wide energy range. A substantial excitation mechanism of these waves is their drift‐bounce resonant interactions with magnetospheric particles. Here, we extend the conventional drift‐bounce resonance theory to formulate the nonlinear particle trapping in the ULF wave‐carried potential well, which can be approximately described by a pendulum equation. We also predict the observable signatures of the nonlinear drift‐bounce resonance, and compare them with spacecraft observations. We further discuss potential drivers of the pendulum including the convection electric field and the magnetospheric dayside compression, which lead to additional particle acceleration or deceleration depending on magnetic longitude. These drivers indicate preferred regions for nonlinear ULF wave growth, which are consistent with previous statistical studies.