Julia Knopes
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Julia Knopes has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Ariel Cascio
Central Michigan University College of Medicine, Mt Pleasant, USA
1 shared publicationBarbara Warner
Department of Psychology, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, OH, USA
1 shared publication- Barbara Warner
Psychology Department, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, USA
1 shared publication - Edward E. McKee
Department of Foundational Sciences, College of Medicine, Central Michigan University, Mount Pleasant, Michigan, USA
1 shared publication - Laura Guidry-Grimes
Cleveland Clinic
1 shared publication M. Ariel Cascio
Center for Bioethics and Social Justice, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Medical Science Educator
- Vol. 36 (1) , 111-116
Team Switching in Peer-Based Learning Groups: Academic Performance and Medical Student Perspectives
This paper reports on academic outcomes and student perspectives on a 3-year medical education intervention study in which students were assigned to either work with the same “static” group for both team-based learning (TBL) and case-based learning (CBL) sessions, or work with a “hybrid” TBL group comprised of members from different CBL groups. Data included exam and quiz scores, surveys, and focus groups. There were no significant differences in exam scores. Differences in quiz scores were inconsistent. Survey respondents rated static groups better. Qualitative data revealed student ambivalence, which should be addressed when implementing team switching interventions.
- 7 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Medical Science Educator
- Vol. 36 (1) , 111-116
Open AccessTeam Switching in Peer-Based Learning Groups: Academic Performance and Medical Student Perspectives
This paper reports on academic outcomes and student perspectives on a 3-year medical education intervention study in which students were assigned to either work with the same “static” group for both team-based learning (TBL) and case-based learning (CBL) sessions, or work with a “hybrid” TBL group comprised of members from different CBL groups. Data included exam and quiz scores, surveys, and focus groups. There were no significant differences in exam scores. Differences in quiz scores were inconsistent. Survey respondents rated static groups better. Qualitative data revealed student ambivalence, which should be addressed when implementing team switching interventions.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in AJOB Neuroscience
- Vol. 16 (1) , 20-31
Mental Health Conditions Between Neurodiversity and the Medical Model
Scholarship in neuroethics and related disciplines has long reflected on the value of different conceptual models of disability and impairment. While this theoretical work is valuable, centering the voices of people with mental health conditions in neuroethics research can help us better understand how such models apply in everyday people's lives. Drawing on qualitative data from a study on mental health peer providers' lived experiences of recovery, this paper will demonstrate that peers borrow from both a neurodiversity framework and the medical model of disability, though their feelings toward the two models were often complex and ambivalent. These findings advance neuroethics by indicating that future research and clinical practice should take a nuanced approach to responding to the needs of people with mental health conditions and turn to peers as experts, honoring their values and recognizing both the promise and pitfalls of living with a mental health condition.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in AJOB Neuroscience
- Vol. 16 (1) , 20-31
Mental Health Conditions Between Neurodiversity and the Medical Model
Scholarship in neuroethics and related disciplines has long reflected on the value of different conceptual models of disability and impairment. While this theoretical work is valuable, centering the voices of people with mental health conditions in neuroethics research can help us better understand how such models apply in everyday people's lives. Drawing on qualitative data from a study on mental health peer providers' lived experiences of recovery, this paper will demonstrate that peers borrow from both a neurodiversity framework and the medical model of disability, though their feelings toward the two models were often complex and ambivalent. These findings advance neuroethics by indicating that future research and clinical practice should take a nuanced approach to responding to the needs of people with mental health conditions and turn to peers as experts, honoring their values and recognizing both the promise and pitfalls of living with a mental health condition.
- 1 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability & Society
- Vol. 40 (4) , 979-997
Chat windows and zoom bombers: virtual boundaries in mental health peer support
- 1 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability & Society
- Vol. 40 (4) , 979-997
Chat windows and zoom bombers: virtual boundaries in mental health peer support
- 11 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 34 (6) , 528-539
Intraprofessionalism and Peer-to-Peer Learning in American Medical Education
As previous research has observed, medical students and physicians alike confront vast amounts of knowledge in their education and practice, such that no one clinician can know everything there is to know about biomedicine. Even before clerkships, medical students learn to cope with this impossibility by prioritizing certain information based on its perceived utility for exams and clinical practice. Many factors can shape this process, including teamwork, wherein individual medical students rely on one another to address gaps in knowledge at the level of the group. This paper will draw on qualitative data from two allopathic medical schools in the American Midwest to demonstrate that peer-to-peer learning, a widely utilized pedagogical modality in North American medical schools, is amongst the earliest places where future physicians learn how to rely on their peers in the profession as they make choices about what to know and what not to know about biomedicine: cultivating a culture of “intraprofessionalism” between students with different knowledges and values, as they prepare to enter the same profession. The paper will also consider how differences in the student populations at two field sites impact intraprofessional development. Drawing on scholarship of peer-based learning strategies and the sociology and anthropology of medical education, the authors argue that peer-to-peer learning is a key site in the professional socialization of medical students toward the effective management of medical knowledge.
- 11 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 34 (6) , 528-539
Intraprofessionalism and Peer-to-Peer Learning in American Medical Education
As previous research has observed, medical students and physicians alike confront vast amounts of knowledge in their education and practice, such that no one clinician can know everything there is to know about biomedicine. Even before clerkships, medical students learn to cope with this impossibility by prioritizing certain information based on its perceived utility for exams and clinical practice. Many factors can shape this process, including teamwork, wherein individual medical students rely on one another to address gaps in knowledge at the level of the group. This paper will draw on qualitative data from two allopathic medical schools in the American Midwest to demonstrate that peer-to-peer learning, a widely utilized pedagogical modality in North American medical schools, is amongst the earliest places where future physicians learn how to rely on their peers in the profession as they make choices about what to know and what not to know about biomedicine: cultivating a culture of “intraprofessionalism” between students with different knowledges and values, as they prepare to enter the same profession. The paper will also consider how differences in the student populations at two field sites impact intraprofessional development. Drawing on scholarship of peer-based learning strategies and the sociology and anthropology of medical education, the authors argue that peer-to-peer learning is a key site in the professional socialization of medical students toward the effective management of medical knowledge.
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation and Mental Health
- Vol. 12 (1) , 41-52
Boundary Flexibilities in Mental Health Peer Support: The Peer Perspective
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation and Mental Health
- Vol. 12 (1) , 41-52
Boundary Flexibilities in Mental Health Peer Support: The Peer Perspective
- 3 October 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Community Mental Health Journal
- Vol. 60 (2) , 208-214
Reframing Mental Health Ethics
Mental health ethics has been classically focused on ethical concepts and problems in clinical mental health spaces. Psychiatric and psychotherapeutic ethics are main threads of analysis in this subfield of bioethics. However, ethical issues emerge around mental health and illness both within and beyond clinical settings. In particular, ethical quandaries arise in employment, education, family caregiving, and incarceration of people with mental health conditions outside of the clinical setting. Likewise, ethics are an important consideration within alternative care systems where mentally ill people seek support beyond biomedicine, psychotherapy, and case management. In this article, we argue that our understanding of “mental health ethics” should expand to be more inclusive of value questions and conflicts that arise in all areas of the lives of people with mental health conditions, rather than focusing more narrowly on how clinical practitioners and researchers should best respond to ethical quandaries in the delivery of mental healthcare. Community mental health is an ideal space in which to think about such ethical issues, as scholars and practitioners in the field strive to meet not only medical needs but the broader social needs of people with mental health conditions. We begin by providing an overview of psychiatric and psychotherapeutic ethics, and then describe broader applications of ethics in the lives of people experiencing mental illness. We encourage community mental health practitioners and researchers to reconceptualize disciplinary boundaries to consider the vast scope of ethical issues related to mental health in and out of the clinic.
- 3 October 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Community Mental Health Journal
- Vol. 60 (2) , 208-214
Reframing Mental Health Ethics
Mental health ethics has been classically focused on ethical concepts and problems in clinical mental health spaces. Psychiatric and psychotherapeutic ethics are main threads of analysis in this subfield of bioethics. However, ethical issues emerge around mental health and illness both within and beyond clinical settings. In particular, ethical quandaries arise in employment, education, family caregiving, and incarceration of people with mental health conditions outside of the clinical setting. Likewise, ethics are an important consideration within alternative care systems where mentally ill people seek support beyond biomedicine, psychotherapy, and case management. In this article, we argue that our understanding of “mental health ethics” should expand to be more inclusive of value questions and conflicts that arise in all areas of the lives of people with mental health conditions, rather than focusing more narrowly on how clinical practitioners and researchers should best respond to ethical quandaries in the delivery of mental healthcare. Community mental health is an ideal space in which to think about such ethical issues, as scholars and practitioners in the field strive to meet not only medical needs but the broader social needs of people with mental health conditions. We begin by providing an overview of psychiatric and psychotherapeutic ethics, and then describe broader applications of ethics in the lives of people experiencing mental illness. We encourage community mental health practitioners and researchers to reconceptualize disciplinary boundaries to consider the vast scope of ethical issues related to mental health in and out of the clinic.
- 30 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry
- Vol. 48 (3) , 401-419
Beyond Competence: Efficiency in American Biomedicine
“Competence” is a longstanding value of American biomedicine. One underidentified corollary of competence is efficiency: at once a manifestation of competence, a challenge to competence, and a virtue in its own right. We will explore the social construction of efficiency in US undergraduate medical education through an analysis of its sociocultural and technological landscapes. We present qualitative data from two allopathic medical school field sites in the Midwestern United States, where medical students’ careful selection of certain learning resources and overall perspectives on the curriculum underscore their focus on efficiency and pragmatic approaches to knowledge. In the discussion, we consider the ethical implications of physician efficiency, as well as future trajectories for the study of efficiency in the medical social sciences, bioethics, and medical education. We posit that efficiency is at the theoretical heart of US medical practice and education: a finding that has wide-reaching implications for how researchers conceptualize the enterprise of biomedicine across cultural contexts and interpret the lived experiences of physicians, medical students, and other clinicians.
- 30 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry
- Vol. 48 (3) , 401-419
Beyond Competence: Efficiency in American Biomedicine
“Competence” is a longstanding value of American biomedicine. One underidentified corollary of competence is efficiency: at once a manifestation of competence, a challenge to competence, and a virtue in its own right. We will explore the social construction of efficiency in US undergraduate medical education through an analysis of its sociocultural and technological landscapes. We present qualitative data from two allopathic medical school field sites in the Midwestern United States, where medical students’ careful selection of certain learning resources and overall perspectives on the curriculum underscore their focus on efficiency and pragmatic approaches to knowledge. In the discussion, we consider the ethical implications of physician efficiency, as well as future trajectories for the study of efficiency in the medical social sciences, bioethics, and medical education. We posit that efficiency is at the theoretical heart of US medical practice and education: a finding that has wide-reaching implications for how researchers conceptualize the enterprise of biomedicine across cultural contexts and interpret the lived experiences of physicians, medical students, and other clinicians.
- 12 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Anthropology & Medicine
- Vol. 28 (4) , 429-444
Six hours to study: temporality and ignorance in medical education
Individual scientists, clinicians, and other experts cannot have absolute knowledge of all of the theories, methods, models, and findings in their field of practice. Rather, these individuals make choices about the kind of information that will be most meaningful and impactful in their work, while choosing – or being compelled to choose – what knowledge to overlook or ignore: a process identified as sufficient knowledge. In biomedicine, medical students are socialized to deliberately decide what information matters most; so, too, do practicing physicians openly acknowledge that they make choices around knowledge in daily practice. Within this process, time is a critical factor that mediates epistemological decision-making. In other words, how does time bound or restrict what forms and depth of medical knowledge that physicians and future physicians prioritize? When would someone intentionally limit time in order to constrain the amount and types of information he, she, or they acquire? To answer these questions, this study draws upon interviews and participant observation conducted with students at a medical school in the American Midwest. This article seeks to answer the aforementioned questions and to provide a new framework for, and expand discussions of, agnotology in the anthropology of medicine.
- 12 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Anthropology & Medicine
- Vol. 28 (4) , 429-444
Six hours to study: temporality and ignorance in medical education
Individual scientists, clinicians, and other experts cannot have absolute knowledge of all of the theories, methods, models, and findings in their field of practice. Rather, these individuals make choices about the kind of information that will be most meaningful and impactful in their work, while choosing – or being compelled to choose – what knowledge to overlook or ignore: a process identified as sufficient knowledge. In biomedicine, medical students are socialized to deliberately decide what information matters most; so, too, do practicing physicians openly acknowledge that they make choices around knowledge in daily practice. Within this process, time is a critical factor that mediates epistemological decision-making. In other words, how does time bound or restrict what forms and depth of medical knowledge that physicians and future physicians prioritize? When would someone intentionally limit time in order to constrain the amount and types of information he, she, or they acquire? To answer these questions, this study draws upon interviews and participant observation conducted with students at a medical school in the American Midwest. This article seeks to answer the aforementioned questions and to provide a new framework for, and expand discussions of, agnotology in the anthropology of medicine.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Project MUSE in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
- Vol. 63 (3) , 444-457
When Physicians Don’t Know
Given the boundless amount of scientific information, clinical skills, and interventional techniques present in biomedicine today, it is impossible for individual physicians and clinicians to have absolute medical knowledge. Further, ambiguity in the interpretation and treatment of illness can lead to significant uncertainty. Despite the inevitability of not knowing in biomedicine, however, there is relatively little academic discussion about how physicians are socialized to address ignorance, how clinicians experience gaps in knowledge as practitioners, or the various forms that not knowing takes in professional health-care practice and education. This article seeks to invigorate new discussions on the role of ignorance and “non-knowledge” in biomedical practice and training. The article critically examines the predominant focus on medical knowledge in the sociological literature and presents a new anthropological framework for the relationship between knowing and not knowing in medicine, called “sufficient knowledge.” The author posits that future social and humanistic examinations of biomedicine should seriously consider the ways that physicians navigate ignorance, uncertainty, and not knowing, and that scientists, clinicians, social scientists, and ethicists all have valuable disciplinary perspectives to bring to the conversation around medical ignorance.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Project MUSE in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
- Vol. 63 (3) , 444-457
When Physicians Don’t Know
Given the boundless amount of scientific information, clinical skills, and interventional techniques present in biomedicine today, it is impossible for individual physicians and clinicians to have absolute medical knowledge. Further, ambiguity in the interpretation and treatment of illness can lead to significant uncertainty. Despite the inevitability of not knowing in biomedicine, however, there is relatively little academic discussion about how physicians are socialized to address ignorance, how clinicians experience gaps in knowledge as practitioners, or the various forms that not knowing takes in professional health-care practice and education. This article seeks to invigorate new discussions on the role of ignorance and “non-knowledge” in biomedical practice and training. The article critically examines the predominant focus on medical knowledge in the sociological literature and presents a new anthropological framework for the relationship between knowing and not knowing in medicine, called “sufficient knowledge.” The author posits that future social and humanistic examinations of biomedicine should seriously consider the ways that physicians navigate ignorance, uncertainty, and not knowing, and that scientists, clinicians, social scientists, and ethicists all have valuable disciplinary perspectives to bring to the conversation around medical ignorance.
- 23 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Anthropology
- Vol. 39 (3) , 255-268
Yields and Rabbit Holes: Medical Students’ Typologies of Sufficient Knowledge
Given the vastness of bioscientific knowledge and regular changes in evidence and protocol, how do individual clinicians make decisions about what to know and what to ignore? In this article I identify a process termed “sufficient knowledge:” the prioritizing of medical knowledge perceived as most important, while ignoring information that is not deemed essential or applicable. Drawing on 14 months of ethnographic fieldwork at an allopathic medical school in the American Midwest, I describe three typologies of sufficient knowledge that medical students devised to distinguish what to know and what to ignore or deemphasize: high yield knowledge, low yield knowledge and “rabbit holes.” I aim here to contribute to a growing topical and theoretical discussion of ignorance by social scientists, especially to generate a more balanced picture of physician training and practice beyond depictions of knowledge and expertise.
- 23 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Anthropology
- Vol. 39 (3) , 255-268
Yields and Rabbit Holes: Medical Students’ Typologies of Sufficient Knowledge
Given the vastness of bioscientific knowledge and regular changes in evidence and protocol, how do individual clinicians make decisions about what to know and what to ignore? In this article I identify a process termed “sufficient knowledge:” the prioritizing of medical knowledge perceived as most important, while ignoring information that is not deemed essential or applicable. Drawing on 14 months of ethnographic fieldwork at an allopathic medical school in the American Midwest, I describe three typologies of sufficient knowledge that medical students devised to distinguish what to know and what to ignore or deemphasize: high yield knowledge, low yield knowledge and “rabbit holes.” I aim here to contribute to a growing topical and theoretical discussion of ignorance by social scientists, especially to generate a more balanced picture of physician training and practice beyond depictions of knowledge and expertise.