SNSindile Amina Ngubane

Sindile Amina Ngubane

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sindile Amina Ngubane has a total of 53 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Equity-Oriented Governance of Student Support in Open and Distance Higher Education: A Systematic Review of Comparative Lessons from the United States and South Africa

    by Akinlolu Ademola Onaolapo, Johannes Nathi Zongozzi, Bunmi Isaiah Omodan, Slindile A. Ngubane

    Student support in open and distance e-learning (ODeL) higher education remains unevenly governed, particularly for historically disadvantaged, low-income, rural, and disabled students. This systematic review compares how governance structures shape equitable student support in the United States and South Africa, two systems marked by histories of racial segregation and apartheid and by persistent racial, socioeconomic, technological, and disability-related inequalities. Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, the review searched five databases and relevant policy repositories, screening 773 records and appraising 123 full-text reports. Twenty-one sources met the inclusion criteria, comprising 13 empirical studies and eight governance and policy documents published mainly between 2013 and 2025. Because the corpus was deliberately bounded to governance evidence from two national systems, the review is a focused comparative synthesis rather than an exhaustive account of distance education provision in either country. A thematic synthesis examined legislation, funding, disability provisions, quality assurance, and institutional accountability. Findings show that both countries articulate strong equity commitments but experience persistent implementation, monitoring, and accountability gaps, with the digital divide undermining support for rural and low-income learners. Contextual differences in funding models and regulatory design generate transferable lessons. The review proposes an equity-oriented governance framework that links foundational equity values, four governance pillars, and continuous monitoring to strengthen inclusive, accountable, and sustainable student support.

  • Open Access

    The Trend in Studies on Decoloniality, Artificial Intelligence and University Classrooms: A Systematic Review of African Higher Education Scholarship

    by Bunmi Isaiah Omodan, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    The convergence of decoloniality, artificial intelligence (AI), and university classroom practice has emerged as a pressing concern in African higher education. While decolonial movements such as Rhodes Must Fall and #FeesMustFall have reignited debates regarding epistemic justice within African universities, the rapid mainstreaming of generative AI has introduced new inquiries concerning whose knowledge is valued, which languages are acknowledged, and whose pedagogies are perpetuated through machine learning systems. This systematic review maps the trends in studies that engage with decoloniality, AI, and university classrooms, focusing specifically on African universities and African scholarship from 2010 to 2025. Adhering to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 guidelines, the review examined Scopus, Web of Science, African Journals Online, Sabinet, ERIC, and Google Scholar, supplemented by citation chasing. A total of twenty-five studies of varying types and peer-review status met the inclusion criteria. The findings indicate a marked acceleration in scholarly output following 2020, the emergence of three dominant thematic clusters (epistemic injustice and curriculum, algorithmic coloniality and data extractivism, and pedagogical adaptation of generative AI), and a significant concentration of research in South Africa, alongside emerging Pan-African scholarship on African-language AI. The review concludes that African scholarship is formulating a coherent decolonial AI research agenda; however, the scarcity of empirical evidence from classroom settings, the marginalisation of African languages within AI corpora, and uneven regional representation hinder the advancement of the field. Implications are discussed for institutional policy, curriculum design, and future research directions.

  • Include the Excluded via the Lens of the Open Distance E-Learning Programme

    by Oladayo Samsom Akinbile, Ruth Oluyemi Adekunle, Olufemi Timothy Adigun, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    This chapter revealed the on-going challenges faced by marginalized individuals at achieving education. Concerned about the state exclusion faced are individuals or communities systematically marginalised from formal education systems, the chapter noted the impact of governmental agencies at ensuring education for all learners, but also points out that potential deficiencies in the existing praxis in open and distance e-learning (ODeL). In view of the forestated, this intellectual piece leveraged on the principles of the constructivism theory to strategically present how ODeL can be used to bridge educational gaps faced by marginalized groups in the 21st century.

  • Advancing E-Health Intervention for Deaf People

    by Oluwaseun Timilehin Ojomo, Faisat Adekilekun Tijani, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    By developing specialized digital technologies, e-health interventions for the Deaf people are essential to closing gaps in healthcare access. These treatments help Deaf people and healthcare professionals communicate effectively by utilizing visual-based technologies such as accessible telehealth platforms, real-time captioning, and sign language video resources. For sign language users, mobile apps and web-based resources improve health literacy and facilitate improved chronic disease self-management. Inclusion and usability are guaranteed by the incorporation of artificial intelligence for automated sign language translation and culturally sensitive user interfaces. By lowering systemic barriers, fostering active patient engagement, and ensuring fair access to healthcare services, these developments empower Deaf people. E-health treatments promote better health outcomes and assist the deaf community in accessing healthcare in an increasingly digital environment by placing a high priority on accessibility and cultural competence.

  • Open Access

    Female leadership for inclusion, social justice, and intersectionality in educational spaces

    by Doniwen Pietersen, Sindile Ngubane, Thulile Shandu

    The study aims to examine female leadership and intersectionality in educational settings. The gatekeepers, who include male leadership, institutional cultures, and other women’s advancement facilitators, must recognise that ignoring the value and embodiment of women in educational leadership roles could result in loss of knowledge, a low level of awareness of how systems are changing, and a risk of educational institutions being forced to support antiquated practices. The methodology employed in this study is based on a qualitative and phenomenological approach that critically investigates the experiences and leadership challenges of women in leadership spaces. Fifteen women were interviewed from various education spheres and departments to understand their resilience, determination, and innovative practices comprehensively. Female leadership is crucial for educational success, especially when it challenges social justice. Social justice in schools is rooted in privilege and power, recognising and accepting differences for inclusion and equitable power distribution for empowerment. Firstly, understanding the foundation of social justice is essential to addressing women’s issues in educational spaces. There should be an emphasis on access for women, creating awareness of the causes of inequality, the capacity to direct interests, and taking control and action to reduce structural inequality. Secondly, opportunities for empowerment should be created amongst women and for women. The last recommendation pertains to challenging indigenous institutional cultures to increase the number of women in educational leadership spaces and give them the power to be decision-makers, leading to responsibilities and rights curtailing the right gatekeepers to stop women’s freedoms in educational spaces. So, empowerment moves between empowerment and development outcomes for women, ultimately leading to unintended results that will also be realised in women’s empowerment in educational leadership spaces. This paper is underpinned by critical theory to challenge the social justice idea of women’s empowerment in educational spaces in relation to women and their advancement in leadership positions. Our contribution focuses on women challenging the power and control over decisions and resources in educational leadership spaces, with particular focus on how women may use empowerment as a tool to encourage one another in oppressive spaces, while also developing themselves from an empowerment perspective in order to bring value to their embodiment in the aforementioned spaces.


  • Open Access

    Students’ readiness for the posthuman workforce in a rurally located university in South Africa

    by Bunmi Isaiah Omodan, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    The rapid advancement of digital tools, artificial intelligence, and global connectivity is reshaping workforce expectations, rendering it crucial to understand how students in rural and historically disadvantaged universities are preparing for such changes. These students often encounter compounded barriers, including inadequate digital infrastructure, outdated learning tools, limited exposure to emerging technologies, and scarce opportunities for practical collaboration, all of which impede their acquisition of the skills and competencies necessary to thrive in a posthuman environment. Guided by the Technological Acceptance Model and further interpreted through Van Dijk’s Digital Divide Model and Sen’s Capability Approach within a transformative paradigm employing participatory action research as a design. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 15 fourth-year rural university students selected through convenience sampling, and the data were analysed thematically. The findings reveal that poor connectivity, limited access to modern learning tools, reduced exposure to advanced technologies, and inadequate opportunities for practical application collectively hinder students’ preparedness for technology-driven work environments. Despite these challenges, students exhibit resilience, adaptability, and problem-solving potential—qualities that are valuable for the evolving workforce. The study concludes that targeted interventions to improve infrastructure, enhance access to digital tools, provide structured exposure to emerging technologies, and strengthen digital literacy programmes are essential to bridging the preparedness gap and enabling rural students to thrive in the posthuman workforce. Consequently, this article contributes to the literature by elucidating the digital readiness gaps experienced by rural students and proposes interventions to bridge infrastructural, technological, and literacy barriers to facilitate equitable participation in the workforce.

  • Open Access

    A phenomenological investigation into the role of a university degree in the reintegration of ex-offenders into the labour market

    by Mbongiseni Mdakane, Bongani Nkambule, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    Literature on social reintegration underscores that persistent societal attitudes contribute to the exclusion of job seekers who have a criminal record. In South Africa, this topic is still comparatively understudied as opposed to the developed world which has an abundance of literature addressing an extensive range of perspectives on it. This qualitative interpretive phenomenological study rooted in a social constructivist paradigm explored university-educated ex-offenders’ lived experiences of reintegration into the professional clusters of the South African labour market. Goffman’s social stigma theory (SST) was used as a theoretical framework. Purposive and snowball sampling techniques were applied to select six participants. The thematically arranged findings of the participants’ sense-making of the labour market reintegration experiences revealed that prospective employers perceived job seekers with a criminal record as “suspicious, untrustworthy and risky to employ.” The findings also showed that stigmatization and marginalization engendered feelings of rejection, worthlessness and frustration. Desperation also contributed to the participants accepting employment opportunities that are not commensurate with their qualifications concealing their criminal record from prospective employers or venturing into small-scale entrepreneurship (albeit with limited prospects for growth due to business registration and funding red tape).The study also found that when participants assessed the magnitude of the obstacles that affected their previous job-seeking attempts, they recognised that even their university degrees were insufficient to fully utilise their chances of reintegrating into the professional clusters of the South African labour market. The study proposed several recommendations in response to these findings.

  • Open Access

    Challenges and Opportunities for Females in Educational Leadership: Perspectives from Departmental Heads in South African Schools

    by Buhle Stella Nhlumayo, Sindile Amina Ngubane

    Current research on educational leadership indicates that women in various school management levels face numerous challenges in fulfilling their duties. Departmental heads, occupying the third tier in school leadership hierarchies, often experience significant difficulties in their role as curriculum managers. This paper presents findings from a broader Women in Research-funded project titled Women in Leadership and Management, which examined the challenges faced by departmental heads in relation to their gender identity. Grounded in role congruity theory and utilizing phenomenology as the research approach, data were gathered from four departmental heads across selected schools in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Thematic analysis revealed several persistent challenges: neglect from senior leadership, limited support from various stakeholders, excessive workloads resulting in low morale, and ambiguity regarding their leadership responsibilities. These issues suggest systemic gaps in leadership structures that fail to provide the necessary guidance and resources for departmental heads. The study underscores the importance of establishing clear role definitions and expectations, informed by policy and consistently implemented by school management teams. Furthermore, it highlights the need for targeted support systems to empower female departmental heads, enabling them to thrive and contribute meaningfully within their leadership roles.


  • Resilience, Determination, and Innovation in Women’s Educational Leadership

    by Sindile Amina Ngubane, Mncedisi Christian Maphalala, Thulile Pearl Shandu-Phetla