AKAndrey Innokentievich Krivoshapkin

Andrey Innokentievich Krivoshapkin

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Andrey Innokentievich Krivoshapkin has a total of 250 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Earliest evidence for invasive mitigation of dental caries by Neanderthals

    by Alisa V. Zubova, Lydia V. Zotkina, John W. Olsen, Alexander M. Kulkov, Vyacheslav G. Moiseyev, Anna A. Malyutina, Roman V. Davydov, Sergey V. Markin, Eugene A. Maksimovskiy, Pavel V. Chistyakov, et al.

    Neanderthal medical knowledge has long attracted scholarly interest. Evidence suggests they cared for sick, injured, and elderly group members, with possible use of medicinal plants. However, it remains uncertain whether such practices reflect deliberate medical strategies or instinctive self-medication akin to that observed in non-human primates. Here, we analyze and interpret traces of deliberate artificial manipulation of Chagyrskaya 64, a Neanderthal lower left second molar found in Chagyrskaya Cave (Altai Krai, Russia). The tooth exhibits a large human-generated concavity on the occlusal surface, created during the lifetime of the individual. Traceological and microtomographic analyses of the observed modifications, combined with experimental verification, reveal that the concavity in Chagyrskaya 64 is indicative of the earliest documented instance of caries treatment involving the drilling/rotating with a lithic perforator, ca. 59 ka. Evidence of two distinct types of manipulations requiring different tools, in addition to the drilling/rotating technique, necessitating complex finger movements, indicates that the Chagyrskaya Cave Neanderthals possessed the cognitive capacity to intuit the source of pain, comprehend the feasibility of its elimination, and deliberately select the most efficacious dental intervention. These patterns bring Neanderthal behavior closer to modern humans and differentiate that behavior from the instinctive actions of other primates.


  • Open Access

    Paleolandscape environments of Discontinuity in Paleolithic Cultural Ranges: The Example of Neanderthal Dispersal from Eastern Europe to the Altai

    by Kseniya A. Kolobova, Dmitrii V. Kobylkin, Viktor N. Bogdanov, Pavel V. Chistyakov, Ekaterina N. Bocharova, Daria V. Kozhevnikova, Vyacheslav G. Kotov, Mikhail M. Rumiantsev, Alena V. Kharevich, Andrey I. Krivoshapkin

    This article presents a comprehensive analysis of the paleogeographic and paleolandscape factors that determined the discontinuous and mosaic distribution of Paleolithic cultures, using the migration of Late Neanderthals – associated with the Micoquian industry – from Eastern Europe to the Altai as a case study. The research is motivated by the significant geographical gaps observed between sites of the same cultural tradition, raising questions about the accurate interpretation of the mechanisms behind the spread of cultural complexes – whether through the migration of human populations or the transfer of technology. The study employs methods of geoinformation modeling, including the creation and integration of thematic layers within a unified coordinate system (WGS-84). These layers encompass modern relief (SRTM), the distribution of Holocene peat deposits, and the location of archaeological sites. Through the synthesis of data from paleogeography, geomorphology, and archaeology, the paleoecological conditions along potential migration routes across the Volga-Ural interfluve and the West Siberian Plain are reconstructed. The results indicate that the formation of extensive gaps in the distribution of the Eastern Micoquian is a consequence of the cumulative impact of several catastrophic processes. These include: the radical transformation of the landscapes in the Caspian Lowland during the Khvalynian transgression and concomitant neotectonic movements; a series of Late Pleistocene megafloods (cataclysmic flooding), which destroyed sites in the river valleys of Western Siberia; and the widespread presence of powerful Holocene peatlands that mask ancient land surfaces. A critical factor reducing archaeological visibility was the acute shortage of high-quality lithic raw material, leading to the highly economical use of imported resources and a minimal number of artifacts at temporary sites. It is concluded that the absence of sites across a vast territory cannot serve as a definitive argument against the possibility of migration. The study underscores the necessity of considering the paleolandscape context and taphonomic processes when distinguishing between population migrations and the diffusion of technologies. This is a crucial prerequisite for reliable reconstruction of the peopling of Eurasia during the Paleolithic.

  • Filling the Gap: The Middle Palaeolithic of Kulbulak in the Context of the Extended Chronology of the Obi-Rakhmat Variant

    by Kseniya Kolobova, Andrey Krivoshapkin, Galina Pavlenok, Konstantin Pavlenok

    This paper presents the results of a techno-typological and statistical analysis of assemblages from key Middle Palaeolithic layers (12.1, 12.3, 17) at the Kulbulak site. The study aims to determine their position within the Obi-Rakhmatian and to elucidate the nature of its long-term developmental trajectory. Based on the study of 8,790 artifacts and the application of non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS), a detailed comparison was conducted between the Kulbulak assemblages (layers 12.1, 12.3, 17) and both chronologically earlier (Kulbulak layers 23–24) and later (Obi-Rakhmat layers 17–21) industries. The results demonstrate that the assemblages from the middle part of the Kulbulak sequence (~89–120 ka) fall within the single variability range of the Obi-Rakhmat variant across all key parameters (debitage structure, core types, and tool composition). They thereby fill a significant chronological gap between its earliest (~200–180 ka) and latest (~85–40 ka) phases. It is shown that, despite variability influenced by raw material and possibly functional factors, the Obi-Rakhmatian is characterized by a remarkable stability in its core techno-typological characteristics from the late Middle through the end of Middle- first half of the Upper Pleistocene, exhibiting no evidence of directed linear development.


  • Mobility of Steppe Bisons (Bison priscus) as a Possible Trigger of the Neanderthal Transcontinental Migration

    by K. A. Kolobova, A. S. Koliasnikova, A. I. Krivoshapkin

    This article discusses one of the possible causes of the transcontinental migration of the late European Neanderthals who left the Micoquian industries into the Altai at the end of MIS 4 (ca. 57–71 ka BP). It is shown that traditional explanations of ancient hominin migrations, which are usually linked to climatic changes with periodic stadials and following the herds of large and medium-sized herbivores, cannot fully account for all aspects of the process. Two sets of data are analyzed: Neanderthal mobility during cold phases and mobility of steppe bison (Bison priscus)—the main hunting resource of the Micoquian groups in Europe, Crimea, Caucasus, and Altai, associated with the expansion of available pasturelands. Synchrony was detected between the maximum expansion of the range of steppe bison and population size of the Late Pleistocene and MIS 4 when a transcontinental steppe belt emerged. Two scenarios connecting these processes are proposed: Neanderthals directly following the migrating bison herds, or sequential colonization of territories with the stable hunting base. Limitations of the hypothesis are discussed, including the lack of direct isotopic data on Altai bison migrations and absence of synchronous archaeological sites at the intermediate points along the route.

  • Open Access

    Inner Asian Agropastoralism Within the Mongol Empire: Multi‐Proxy Investigations at Sel'Ungur Cave, Kyrgyzstan

    by G. Brancaleoni, S. V. Shnaider, M. Blinnikov, K. Boxleitner, S. M. Mentzer, V. Alekseitseva, S. V. Zhilich, T. Chargynov, S. Alisher Kyzy, E. V. Parkhomchuk, et al.

    Agropastoralism has been a widespread subsistence strategy in Central Asia from prehistory to the present. While significant research has aimed at understanding past agropastoral communities in the region, reconstructing a generalized economic model remains challenging due to the complex topographic and ecological conditions, as well as its social and political variability. It is likely that subsistence strategies were flexible and adapted to local conditions. Most of what we know about these communities comes from burial sites, with comparatively less information derived from temporary encampments or occupation contexts. Caves and rockshelters have been readily used by pastoralists for millennia. In this study, we present the results of a multi‐proxy study of a Holocene sequence from one of the most archeologically significant cave sites in Central Asia: the Sel'Ungur Cave of Kyrgyzstan. We combined chronometric dating with phytolith, carpological, and fecal‐spherulite concentration analyses, as well as micromorphological, micro‐XRF, and micro‐FTIR studies. The deposits are primarily composed of charred materials and ash, forming the fumier facies. Micromorphological and micro‐analytical methods have enabled us to identify penning activities and periodic burning as the dominant site formation processes. High‐temperature burning destroyed diagnostic features necessary for more precise identification of herd animals. Notably, “vitrified” dung fragments were observed and inferred through micromorphology and micro‐XRF. Through phytolith and archaeobotanical analyses, we were able to infer that livestock mainly grazed locally. The low abundance of domesticated plants—wheat, millet, and barley—as well as fruit seeds, such as grape, pistachio, and walnut, points toward the use of these as a supplement to the herder's diet. The presence of local and allochthonous domesticated plant species alongside evidence for herding suggests the implementation of a mixed economic strategy, likely combining transhumance and agropastoralism. Chronological analysis of the fumier deposits indicates that Sel'Ungur Cave was used as a pen between the 12th and 15th centuries.


  • Open Access

    Arrow heads at Obi-Rakhmat (Uzbekistan) 80 ka ago?

    by Hugues Plisson, Alena V. Kharevich, Vladimir M. Kharevich, Pavel V. Chistiakov, Lydia V. Zotkina, Malvina Baumann, Eric Pubert, Ksenya A. Kolobova, Farhod A. Maksudov, Andrei I. Krivoshapkin

    Lithic weapon points occasionally found in Middle Palaeolithic Neanderthal sites are large and do not differ in size, shape or type from those used in other activities such as butchering or plant gathering. The presence in a same assemblage of various types of projectile armatures, some of which are microlithic and designed for this purpose, has only been documented in Modern Humans sites. Recent studies indicate that light projectile points, which would become a key element in Upper Palaeolithic lithic industries, were already present in its formative stages. However, they remain marginal in debates regarding the Middle to Upper Paleolithic transition. We present the initial findings of a traceological search for weapon heads in the oldest layers of the Obi-Rakhmat rock shelter in Uzbekistan, dating back around 80 ka. The lithic industry of this settlement is forming part of the Levantine Early Middle Paleolithic continuity but with several innovative traits. This site, located in the western foothills of the Tian Shan Mountains, northeastern Uzbekistan, has yielded throughout 10 meters of Pleistocene deposits covering 40,000 years a lithic industry characterized by the systematic production of blades (regular thick narrow blades from unipolar and bipolar sub-prismatic and narrow-faced cores, thin and wide blades from flat-faced Levallois-like cores) along with shorter pieces from convergent or centripetal Levallois cores, and bladelets from burin-cores and other small cores. Three types of projectile armature are identified over a selection of 20: retouched points, bladelets and more particularly unretouched triangular micropoints which had previously gone unoticed due to their fragmentary state. According to the fundamental principles of hunting weapon design these micropoints are too narrow for having been fitted to anything other than arrow-like shafts. They resemble the armatures described in a pioneer settlement by Sapiens in the Rhône Valley, France, 25,000 years later.


  • Open Access

    Arrow heads at Obi-Rakhmat (Uzbekistan) 80 ka ago

    by Hugues Plisson, Alëna V. Kharevich, Vladimir M. Kharevich, Pavel V. Chistiakov, Lydia V. Zotkina, Malvina Baumann, Eric Pubert, Ksenya A. Kolobova, Andrei I. Krivoshapkin

    When they are occasionally found in Middle Palaeolithic Neanderthal settlements, lithic weapons heads are large and do not differ in size, shaping or type from those used for activities other than hunting, such as plant gathering or butchery. The presence in a same assemblage of various types of armatures, some of which are microlithic and designed for this purpose, has only been documented in Modern Humans sites. Recent studies show that light projectile points, which were to become the structuring element of Upper Palaeolithic lithic industries, were already present in its formative stages. However, they remain marginal in debates regarding the Middle to Upper Paleolithic transition. We present here the first results of a search for weapon heads in the oldest layers of the Obi-Rakhmat rock shelter, at around 80 ka. This site, located in the western foothills of the Tian Shan Mountains, northeastern Uzbekistan, has yielded a blade-based lithic industry which is forming part of the continuity of the Levantine Early Middle Paleolithic but with several innovative traits. The assemblage is based on a systematic blade production (regular thick narrow blades from unipolar and bipolar sub-prismatic and narrow-faced cores, thin and wide blades from flat-faced Levallois-like cores) along with shorter pieces from convergent or centripetal Levallois cores, and bladelets from burin-cores and other small cores. Three types of projectile armature are identified from their impact marks: retouched points, bladelets and raw micropoints which were so far unseen due to their fragmentary state. The micropoints are too narrow for having been fitted to anything other than arrow shafts. They are similar to the armatures described in a pioneer settlement by Sapiens in the Rhône Valley, France, 25,000 years later.


  • Blank Production in the Middle Paleolithic Industry of Obi-Rakhmat Rockshelter: Assemblages from Layers 20-21

    by A.V. Kharevich, K.A. Kolobova, A.G. Mukhammadiev, A.I. Krivoshapkin

    The authors focus on the analysis of primary reduction strategy in the Middle Paleolithic industry of layers 20–21 at ObiRakhmat Rockshelter (Uzbekistan) and the comparative analysis of Obi-Rakhmat with the industries of the Early Middle Paleolithic of the Levant. The topic is currently popular due the growing interest in Central Asia as a key region for studying the dispersal of hominins and the spread of various cultural traditions. The research is based on an attribute analysis of 97 cores and truncatedfaceted pieces and address reconstructions of the used reduction strategies. A combination of the Levallois techniques (including point cores and nuclei of recurrent centripetal flaking) and laminar technologies (flat, subprismatic, and narrow-faced cores) alongside bladelet production has been identified. A predominance of blades among the identifiable blanks has been noted, as well as a developed production of bladelets, represented by diverse core types. These include single- and double-platform flat, volumetric, and narrow-faced cores, as well as specific cores-on-flakes for bladelet production. The results demonstrate significant technological diversity of primary knapping in the Obi-Rakhmat industry. The conducted comparative analysis has shown that despite the lack of terminological uniformity, the basic principles of primary knapping in the Obi-Rakhmat industry bear significant resemblance to the techno-complexes of the Early Middle Paleolithic of the Levant (220–150 ka BP). The similarity is manifested in the simultaneous use of Levallois and laminar (volumetric) reduction techniques aimed at removing pointed and elongated blanks. The main difference is the greater amount of centripetal recurrent Levallois cores and the more intensive and diverse bladelet flaking in the Obi-Rakhmat industry. Considering the structure of primary knapping in the techno-complexes of Central Asia and the Levant, the industry of Obi-Rakhmat Grotto reveals greater cultural links with the Early Middle Paleolithic of the Middle East than with the local Initial Upper Paleolithic.

  • Survey for New Stone Age Sites in Southern Uzbekistan in 2025

    by A.V. Kharevich, A.G. Mukhammadiev, V.M. Kharevich, G.A. Mukhtarov, Z.O. Rakhmanov, D.O. Sodikova, R.KH. Suleymanov, A.I. Krivoshapkin

    The article presents the results of archaeological survey work carried out in 2025 in southern Uzbekistan, in the Kashkadarya Region, near the city of Guzar. The research was conducted jointly by the National Center of Archaeology of Uzbekistan and the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography of SB RAS, continuing the survey initiated in 2023. Field investigations were conducted on the northwestern slopes of the southwestern spurs of the Gissar Range—a little-studied area located between desert regions and mountain valleys. The surveys identified new Stone Age archaeological sites: the Botobulak-1–6 cluster and the stratified site of Chuchukbulak. The Botobulak surface-material localities are associated with springs and temporary watercourses; the collected assemblages include Levallois, radial, and prismatic cores, flakes, and blades, demonstrating the technological diversity of lithic reduction. The morphological characteristics of the artifacts indicate the presence of both Middle and Upper Paleolithic traditions in the region. Chuchukbulak is the multilayered stratified Stone Age site. The archaeological material from several layers displays distinct Neolithic features, including microcores of wedge-shaped and subprismatic morphology, as well as microblades produced mainly by pressure flaking. The site’s location in close proximity to raw material outcrops accounts for the presence of items corresponding to the earliest stages of core reduction, providing an opportunity to reconstruct the complete sequence of the lithic production process. The obtained data significantly expand current understanding of human occupation in the southwestern foothills of the Gissar Range during the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene. The newly discovered sites document human presence in a previously poorly explored area of Central Asia and open new prospects for future research aimed at refining the stratigraphy, chronology, and cultural attribution of the identified industries, as well as reconstructing ancient migration routes and models of human adaptation to the natural environment.

  • Elongated Retouched Points from the Middle Paleolithic Complexes of Obi-Rakhmat Grotto: Morphology and Cultural Attribution

    by A.V. Kharevich, A.I. Krivoshapkin, G.A. Mukhtarov, K.A. Kolobova

    This article discusses the technological and morphological variability of stone points from the Obi-Rakhmat variant of the Middle Paleolithic in Central Asia. Special attention is given to the category of convergent tools, as sets of elongated retouched points often serve as markers in the context of Middle Paleolithic laminar industries, which are typically associated with early manifestations of anatomically modern humans. The study of their morphological and technological variability is therefore crucial for the cultural interpretation of these Middle Paleolithic laminar industries. The earliest laminar industry in the Middle Paleolithic of the eastern part of Central Asia is associated with the Obi-Rakhmat Grotto and the Obi-Rakhmat industrial variant, which is characterized by a combination of developed Levallois and laminar flaking technologies. These complexes have numerous parallels with the Middle Paleolithic laminar industries of the Middle East. An important feature of these industries is the presence of diverse retouched points and a significant proportion of elongated pointed flakes among the tool blanks. The study of the retouched points from ObiRakhmat Grotto has demonstrated that the assemblage contains all major point types distinguished in the Early Middle Paleolithic of the Levant. Moreover, a similarity was recorded in the production of these tools along with similar metric parameters within separate typological categories. In addition to similarities, the studied collection has its own features associated with advanced small laminar flaking which is nearly absent from the Levant complexes. In addition to elongated retouched points, Obi-Rakhmat demonstrates shortened forms also produced on laminar blanks, although of a smaller size, which correspond to the Levantine types in terms of the production method. The study herein provides us with new information about the tool production processes in the Obi-Rakhmat tradition and sheds some light on possible cultural/technological connections with the complexes of adjacent and distant territories.