Carolyn Whitzman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Carolyn Whitzman has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Billie Giles-Corti
RMIT University
5 shared publications - Melanie Davern
RMIT University Melbourne Victoria Australia
3 shared publications Dana Mizrachi
Faculty of Architecture, Building and Planning , University of Melbourne , Parkville , Australia
2 shared publications- Dominique Hes
The University of Melbourne
2 shared publications - Hannah Badland
RMIT University
2 shared publications - Karen Villanueva
RMIT University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 13 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Housing Policy
- Vol. 22 (2) , 278-298
Women’s housing: balancing scaling and caring in three Canadian cities
Canada has recently enshrined the right to housing in legislation and included a funding target directed towards women-led households. Women’s housing organisations are generally small and looking for ways to scale up while maintaining a care focus. This article describes potential impacts of these recent policy shifts, and how women’s housing perspectives and practices might move from the periphery to the centre of policy-making.
- 13 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Housing Policy
- Vol. 22 (2) , 278-298
Women’s housing: balancing scaling and caring in three Canadian cities
Canada has recently enshrined the right to housing in legislation and included a funding target directed towards women-led households. Women’s housing organisations are generally small and looking for ways to scale up while maintaining a care focus. This article describes potential impacts of these recent policy shifts, and how women’s housing perspectives and practices might move from the periphery to the centre of policy-making.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Queen's University Library in Canadian Planning and Policy / Aménagement et politique au Canada
- Vol. 2020, 1-19
Collaborative Governance for Affordable Housing in Toronto and Melbourne
Policy formation and implementation have largely shifted from a top-down government-led process, to a collaborative governance approach characterised by complex and opaque partnerships, weakly steered by the state. We use 36 interviews, undertaken in Toronto and Melbourne between 2015 and 2018, to assess procedural accountability in these two cities: the extent to which policy outputs developed through a partnership approach are fair, transparent, rational, and intentional. We find that both cities fail the basics of procedural accountability, and that there is little shared understanding amongst key partners – local and provincial/state policymakers, non-profit and private sector housing providers, and philanthropic and private sector finance providers – about the definition and missing quantum of affordable housing, let alone a sense of how to move forward.
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Queen's University Library in Canadian Planning and Policy / Aménagement et politique au Canada
- Vol. 2020, 1-19
Open AccessCollaborative Governance for Affordable Housing in Toronto and Melbourne
Policy formation and implementation have largely shifted from a top-down government-led process, to a collaborative governance approach characterised by complex and opaque partnerships, weakly steered by the state. We use 36 interviews, undertaken in Toronto and Melbourne between 2015 and 2018, to assess procedural accountability in these two cities: the extent to which policy outputs developed through a partnership approach are fair, transparent, rational, and intentional. We find that both cities fail the basics of procedural accountability, and that there is little shared understanding amongst key partners – local and provincial/state policymakers, non-profit and private sector housing providers, and philanthropic and private sector finance providers – about the definition and missing quantum of affordable housing, let alone a sense of how to move forward.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2020
- Published by Wiley in Tijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale Geografie
- Vol. 111 (3) , 434-450
The City Under COVID‐19: Podcasting As Digital Methodology
This critical commentary reflects on a rapidly mobilised international podcast project, in which 25 urban scholars from around the world provided audio recordings about their cities during COVID‐19. New digital tools are increasing the speeds, formats and breadth of the research and communication mediums available to researchers. Voice recorders on mobile phones and digital audio editing on laptops allows researchers to collaborate in new ways, and this podcast project pushed at the boundaries of what a research method and community might be. Many of those who provided short audio 'reports from the field' recorded on their mobile phones were struggling to make sense of their experience in their city during COVID‐19. The substantive sections of this commentary discuss the digital methodology opportunities that podcasting affords geographical scholarship. In this case the methodology includes the curated production of the podcast and critical reflection on the podcast process through collaborative writing. Then putting this methodology into action some limited reflections on cities under COVID‐19 lockdown and social distancing initiatives around the world are provided to demonstrate the utility and limitations of this method.
- 9 June 2020
- Published by Wiley in Tijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale Geografie
- Vol. 111 (3) , 434-450
Open AccessThe City Under COVID‐19: Podcasting As Digital Methodology
This critical commentary reflects on a rapidly mobilised international podcast project, in which 25 urban scholars from around the world provided audio recordings about their cities during COVID‐19. New digital tools are increasing the speeds, formats and breadth of the research and communication mediums available to researchers. Voice recorders on mobile phones and digital audio editing on laptops allows researchers to collaborate in new ways, and this podcast project pushed at the boundaries of what a research method and community might be. Many of those who provided short audio 'reports from the field' recorded on their mobile phones were struggling to make sense of their experience in their city during COVID‐19. The substantive sections of this commentary discuss the digital methodology opportunities that podcasting affords geographical scholarship. In this case the methodology includes the curated production of the podcast and critical reflection on the podcast process through collaborative writing. Then putting this methodology into action some limited reflections on cities under COVID‐19 lockdown and social distancing initiatives around the world are provided to demonstrate the utility and limitations of this method.
- 2 January 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Housing Policy
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-22
How intersectoral policy networks shape affordable housing outcomes
Affordable housing policy is increasingly formulated and delivered through complex policy networks comprised of state, not-for-profit and for-profit actors. While these arrangements may generate new ideas and create space for more democratic decision-making, international case studies have shown that the devolution of policy responsibility has resulted in increasingly marketised housing solutions and reduced support for low income households. Policy network literature presents a valuable lens for analysing the degree to which state and non-state actors are capable of and willing to shape policy discourses and outcomes. This paper presents a new conceptual framework and typology for interpreting policy networks, identifying integrated vertical governance, advocacy coalitions and agenda setting and shared understandings as central to housing policy and outcomes. Drawing on 54 interviews conducted with members of affordable housing policy networks in Melbourne, Toronto, Vancouver, and Portland, the paper also provides a longitudinal, comparative analysis of policy networks in these cities. We provide insights into the implications of ‘hollowed out’ governance structures characterised by limited internal capacity and steering power. We also comment on the relative success of each city’s network in advocating for increased affordable housing outcomes.
- 2 January 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Housing Policy
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-22
How intersectoral policy networks shape affordable housing outcomes
Affordable housing policy is increasingly formulated and delivered through complex policy networks comprised of state, not-for-profit and for-profit actors. While these arrangements may generate new ideas and create space for more democratic decision-making, international case studies have shown that the devolution of policy responsibility has resulted in increasingly marketised housing solutions and reduced support for low income households. Policy network literature presents a valuable lens for analysing the degree to which state and non-state actors are capable of and willing to shape policy discourses and outcomes. This paper presents a new conceptual framework and typology for interpreting policy networks, identifying integrated vertical governance, advocacy coalitions and agenda setting and shared understandings as central to housing policy and outcomes. Drawing on 54 interviews conducted with members of affordable housing policy networks in Melbourne, Toronto, Vancouver, and Portland, the paper also provides a longitudinal, comparative analysis of policy networks in these cities. We provide insights into the implications of ‘hollowed out’ governance structures characterised by limited internal capacity and steering power. We also comment on the relative success of each city’s network in advocating for increased affordable housing outcomes.
- 3 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Housing Studies
- Vol. 35 (5) , 771-794
Housing need assessments in San Francisco, Vancouver, and Melbourne: normative science or neoliberal alchemy?
Governments in much of the Global North have responded to dramatic increases in house prices and rents by setting supply-side targets for new housing in regional and local plans, based on calculations of need. We apply social constructionism to assess widely divergent needs assessments underlying housing strategies in San Francisco, US; Vancouver, Canada; and Melbourne, Australia. In San Francisco, authorities use an approach required by the state government that ignores overcrowding and other ‘invisible’ criteria. In Vancouver, authorities have taken an ambitious approach that goes beyond a minimum quantum of affordable housing to discuss limits to market production. In Melbourne, the state government has chosen to ignore its own commissioned needs assessment to de-prioritize concerns around affordable housing shortages. We conclude by recommending that planners apply greater rigor in housing needs assessments, that can inform public debates around more equitable housing policy.
- 3 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Housing Studies
- Vol. 35 (5) , 771-794
Housing need assessments in San Francisco, Vancouver, and Melbourne: normative science or neoliberal alchemy?
Governments in much of the Global North have responded to dramatic increases in house prices and rents by setting supply-side targets for new housing in regional and local plans, based on calculations of need. We apply social constructionism to assess widely divergent needs assessments underlying housing strategies in San Francisco, US; Vancouver, Canada; and Melbourne, Australia. In San Francisco, authorities use an approach required by the state government that ignores overcrowding and other ‘invisible’ criteria. In Vancouver, authorities have taken an ambitious approach that goes beyond a minimum quantum of affordable housing to discuss limits to market production. In Melbourne, the state government has chosen to ignore its own commissioned needs assessment to de-prioritize concerns around affordable housing shortages. We conclude by recommending that planners apply greater rigor in housing needs assessments, that can inform public debates around more equitable housing policy.
- 2 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Children's Geographies
- Vol. 18 (3) , 253-268
Children’s independent mobility: the role of school-based social capital
Research has documented the decline in children’s independent mobility (CIM) globally. CIM is a measure of the level of a child’s freedom to move about his or her local neighbourhood without direct adult supervision. This paper explores the effectiveness of three intervention programmes to change travel behaviours of children to and from school in 26 Catholic primary schools in a range of urban and regional settings in Victoria, Australia. Using pre and post intervention surveys with 1600 students and parents, and interviews with school principals, we measured the influence of a range of individual, social, and built environment factors on the effectiveness of these intervention programmes. The degree of social connectedness of the school and the individual was found to have the most impact on the effectiveness of the intervention programmes to change behaviours, while the interventions themselves were not greatly effective without being embedded in a supportive school culture.
- 2 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Children's Geographies
- Vol. 18 (3) , 253-268
Children’s independent mobility: the role of school-based social capital
Research has documented the decline in children’s independent mobility (CIM) globally. CIM is a measure of the level of a child’s freedom to move about his or her local neighbourhood without direct adult supervision. This paper explores the effectiveness of three intervention programmes to change travel behaviours of children to and from school in 26 Catholic primary schools in a range of urban and regional settings in Victoria, Australia. Using pre and post intervention surveys with 1600 students and parents, and interviews with school principals, we measured the influence of a range of individual, social, and built environment factors on the effectiveness of these intervention programmes. The degree of social connectedness of the school and the individual was found to have the most impact on the effectiveness of the intervention programmes to change behaviours, while the interventions themselves were not greatly effective without being embedded in a supportive school culture.
- 24 December 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Urban Policy and Research
- Vol. 37 (2) , 170-184
Private Developers and the Public Good: Can a Socially Constructed Market Deliver Quality Affordable Housing for Australian Cities?
Australian government housing policy relies on the private housing industry contributing to the supply of affordable and social housing in cities. However, the diminishing availability of suitable housing for many households raises the question of whether the private housing industry is interested in, or capable of, catering for this market segment. Engagement would require both inducements and regulation, partnerships with government and non-profit actors, and an alignment of attitudes regarding the need and responsibility for providing dwellings in housing sub-markets. This paper explores perceptions and strategies of actors regarding the role for the industry in the context of Melbourne.
- 24 December 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Urban Policy and Research
- Vol. 37 (2) , 170-184
Private Developers and the Public Good: Can a Socially Constructed Market Deliver Quality Affordable Housing for Australian Cities?
Australian government housing policy relies on the private housing industry contributing to the supply of affordable and social housing in cities. However, the diminishing availability of suitable housing for many households raises the question of whether the private housing industry is interested in, or capable of, catering for this market segment. Engagement would require both inducements and regulation, partnerships with government and non-profit actors, and an alignment of attitudes regarding the need and responsibility for providing dwellings in housing sub-markets. This paper explores perceptions and strategies of actors regarding the role for the industry in the context of Melbourne.
- 3 December 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Planning Education and Research
- Vol. 42 (3) , 305-313
Rights Talk, Needs Talk and Money Talk in Affordable Housing Partnerships
There has been increased global activism supporting the right to housing. But in neoliberal governance regimes in wealthy cities of North America and Australia, belief in that right as an effective advocacy tool is weak. This paper focuses on the responses of 30 key affordable housing actors in four cities – Vancouver, Toronto, Portland and Melbourne, the majority of whom reject using the “right to housing” in their organizational work. Fraser’s framework of “rights talk,” “needs talk,” and “interests talk” provide the basis for considering alternative rationales for affordable housing advocacy.
- 3 December 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Planning Education and Research
- Vol. 42 (3) , 305-313
Rights Talk, Needs Talk and Money Talk in Affordable Housing Partnerships
There has been increased global activism supporting the right to housing. But in neoliberal governance regimes in wealthy cities of North America and Australia, belief in that right as an effective advocacy tool is weak. This paper focuses on the responses of 30 key affordable housing actors in four cities – Vancouver, Toronto, Portland and Melbourne, the majority of whom reject using the “right to housing” in their organizational work. Fraser’s framework of “rights talk,” “needs talk,” and “interests talk” provide the basis for considering alternative rationales for affordable housing advocacy.
- 8 December 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Planning Theory & Practice
- Vol. 19 (2) , 180-197
Health-Promoting Spatial Planning: Approaches for Strengthening Urban Policy Integration
Improving urban population health requires integrated spatial planning to create liveable communities, with affordable housing and daily living destinations accessible via walking, cycling and/or public transport. Integration must occur horizontally across transport, housing, employment, education and social infrastructure sectors, and vertically between levels of government. While horizontal integrated planning is a common urban policy aspiration, there is a lack of clarity on how it can be attained. Using a case study of Melbourne, Australia, this paper draws on interviews with state government policymakers and policy content analysis, to explore barriers and enablers of horizontal integrated planning for health. Key requirements for integrated planning are outlined, to assist policymakers in creating healthy, liveable communities.
- 8 December 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Planning Theory & Practice
- Vol. 19 (2) , 180-197
Health-Promoting Spatial Planning: Approaches for Strengthening Urban Policy Integration
Improving urban population health requires integrated spatial planning to create liveable communities, with affordable housing and daily living destinations accessible via walking, cycling and/or public transport. Integration must occur horizontally across transport, housing, employment, education and social infrastructure sectors, and vertically between levels of government. While horizontal integrated planning is a common urban policy aspiration, there is a lack of clarity on how it can be attained. Using a case study of Melbourne, Australia, this paper draws on interviews with state government policymakers and policy content analysis, to explore barriers and enablers of horizontal integrated planning for health. Key requirements for integrated planning are outlined, to assist policymakers in creating healthy, liveable communities.
- 5 October 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Urban Policy and Research
- Vol. 37 (1) , 1-12
The National Disability Insurance Scheme in an Urban Context: Opportunities and Challenges for Australian Cities
The NDIS will directly affect the lives of close to half a million people with a disability as well as significantly wider impacts on Australian cities. This review paper examines the urban policy and practice context for the NDIS, focusing specifically on housing, employment, governance, mainstream services (particularly health and education) and multiculturalism. Although the current Australian urban condition is hardly ideal for the implementation of such an ambitious scheme, the funding provided by the NDIS, coupled with appropriate adjustments to mainstream urban policy, can make important contributions to the social, cultural and economic thriving of Australian cities.
- 5 October 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Urban Policy and Research
- Vol. 37 (1) , 1-12
The National Disability Insurance Scheme in an Urban Context: Opportunities and Challenges for Australian Cities
The NDIS will directly affect the lives of close to half a million people with a disability as well as significantly wider impacts on Australian cities. This review paper examines the urban policy and practice context for the NDIS, focusing specifically on housing, employment, governance, mainstream services (particularly health and education) and multiculturalism. Although the current Australian urban condition is hardly ideal for the implementation of such an ambitious scheme, the funding provided by the NDIS, coupled with appropriate adjustments to mainstream urban policy, can make important contributions to the social, cultural and economic thriving of Australian cities.