Alison K. Young
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Alison K. Young has a total of 61 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ken Rice
SUPA, Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh , The Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ
5 shared publications Adam Koval
SUPA, Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh , The Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ
3 shared publications- Matthew R. Bate
University of Exeter Department of Physics and Astronomy Stocker Road, Exeter EX4 4QL
3 shared publications - Richard A. Booth
University of Leeds
3 shared publications Tim J. Harries
School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Exeter, Exeter EX4 4QL, UK
3 shared publicationsChris F. Mowat
Univ Exeter, Sch Phys & Astron, Stocker Rd, Exeter EX4 4QL, Devon, England
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
A metallicity sweet spot for disc fragmentation and planet formation
Fragmentation of gravitationally unstable discs offers an alternate formation mechanism for gas giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits. Metallicity plays a key role in disc evolution from the onset of gravitational instability to the formation of planets. We aim to determine the effect of metallicity on disc fragmentation and on the properties of disc-instability planets. We model gravitationally unstable discs with varying metallicity ($0.01\mathrm{ -}10\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$) using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics code phantom. Our simulations reveal a ‘sweet spot’ for fragmentation at $0.3\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$, where cooling is most efficient, with fragmentation also happening less vigorously at higher and lower metallicities. However, further away from the sweet spot, fragmentation becomes more difficult and is eventually suppressed at extreme low and high metallicities ($0.01\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$ and $10\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$, respectively), where the disc cools inefficiently. Discs with metallicities close to the sweet spot form more planets per disc, faster, and with lower initial masses than fragmenting discs with higher or lower metallicities. Our results may explain the slight overabundance of wide-orbit giant planets observed around metal-poor stars; these planets may have formed via disc fragmentation.- 20 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
Open AccessA metallicity sweet spot for disc fragmentation and planet formation
Fragmentation of gravitationally unstable discs offers an alternate formation mechanism for gas giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits. Metallicity plays a key role in disc evolution from the onset of gravitational instability to the formation of planets. We aim to determine the effect of metallicity on disc fragmentation and on the properties of disc-instability planets. We model gravitationally unstable discs with varying metallicity ($0.01\mathrm{ -}10\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$) using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics code phantom. Our simulations reveal a ‘sweet spot’ for fragmentation at $0.3\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$, where cooling is most efficient, with fragmentation also happening less vigorously at higher and lower metallicities. However, further away from the sweet spot, fragmentation becomes more difficult and is eventually suppressed at extreme low and high metallicities ($0.01\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$ and $10\, \rm {Z_{\odot }}$, respectively), where the disc cools inefficiently. Discs with metallicities close to the sweet spot form more planets per disc, faster, and with lower initial masses than fragmenting discs with higher or lower metallicities. Our results may explain the slight overabundance of wide-orbit giant planets observed around metal-poor stars; these planets may have formed via disc fragmentation. - Open Access
- 14 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
Revisiting gravitational instability in protostellar discs with improved radiative cooling models
Young discs are expected to be significantly more massive than those observed at $\gt 1$ Myr, and it is at this earliest stage that planet formation likely begins. Such massive discs may be susceptible to the gravitational instability (GI); therefore, we need to determine the disc and stellar properties for which the GI is active to understand its role in early disc evolution and planet formation. Prior work has been limited by model assumptions and inaccuracies due to the complex nature of the thermodynamics of protostellar discs, so we now revisit this question using an improved method to approximate radiative cooling within hydrodynamics simulations. We have explored a wide parameter space, representative of young protostellar discs of 0.1 to 1 M$_\odot$ and include irradiation from the host star. The parameters for which discs form spirals and fragment were found to differ to those obtained from earlier simulations. The outer regions of discs with radii of 50 au may be susceptible to fragmentation, meaning that GI-driven planet formation is not restricted to only the most extended discs. The additional thermal support due to stellar irradiation increases the disc mass that remains stable against GI: discs may reach up to $\gtrsim 0.4$ M$_*$ without fragmenting, providing a considerable quantity of material for building planets. Large-scale spiral arms only developed for $M_*\lesssim$0.3 M$_\odot$, except in the most compact discs. Furthermore, the long-lived spiral structures that form tend to be flocculent and compact, indicating that large-scale spiral arms should not be considered a typical outcome of GI.- 14 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
Open AccessRevisiting gravitational instability in protostellar discs with improved radiative cooling models
Young discs are expected to be significantly more massive than those observed at $\gt 1$ Myr, and it is at this earliest stage that planet formation likely begins. Such massive discs may be susceptible to the gravitational instability (GI); therefore, we need to determine the disc and stellar properties for which the GI is active to understand its role in early disc evolution and planet formation. Prior work has been limited by model assumptions and inaccuracies due to the complex nature of the thermodynamics of protostellar discs, so we now revisit this question using an improved method to approximate radiative cooling within hydrodynamics simulations. We have explored a wide parameter space, representative of young protostellar discs of 0.1 to 1 M$_\odot$ and include irradiation from the host star. The parameters for which discs form spirals and fragment were found to differ to those obtained from earlier simulations. The outer regions of discs with radii of 50 au may be susceptible to fragmentation, meaning that GI-driven planet formation is not restricted to only the most extended discs. The additional thermal support due to stellar irradiation increases the disc mass that remains stable against GI: discs may reach up to $\gtrsim 0.4$ M$_*$ without fragmenting, providing a considerable quantity of material for building planets. Large-scale spiral arms only developed for $M_*\lesssim$0.3 M$_\odot$, except in the most compact discs. Furthermore, the long-lived spiral structures that form tend to be flocculent and compact, indicating that large-scale spiral arms should not be considered a typical outcome of GI. - Open Access
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
High-resolution simulations of disc tearing in the GW Orionis triple system
The disc around the pre-main-sequence triple star system GW Orionis is known from observations to be warped and broken. Theoretical modelling has produced conflicting results regarding the mechanism responsible for breaking the disc. Analytical predictions for the measured parameters of GW Ori suggest the disc is only marginally stable to tearing. We present new high-resolution simulations of GW Ori that replicate the wavelike regime expected in thick, low-turbulence protoplanetary discs for the first time to settle this question. Using the most optimistic values of misalignment and stellar mass ratio allowed by observational constraints, we find that the GW Ori disc can be torn by stellar torques alone, without need for an embedded planet. Even if the disc retains a smooth warp in simulations with similar parameters, it is likely that any small perturbation in the density or temperature structure could cause the disc to break. The new simulations rule out retrograde disc rotation relative to the stellar orbits and tentatively suggest the thicker (h/r = 0.04) disc better matches observations. Going forward, we should take care to ensure models of GW Ori and similar systems appropriately represent the propagation of warps. Additionally, analytical predictions are derived from idealized (and often massless) discs and it is useful to assess how each observed disc might deviate from those assumptions, especially in the context of a young and active star-forming neighbourhood.
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Open AccessHigh-resolution simulations of disc tearing in the GW Orionis triple system
The disc around the pre-main-sequence triple star system GW Orionis is known from observations to be warped and broken. Theoretical modelling has produced conflicting results regarding the mechanism responsible for breaking the disc. Analytical predictions for the measured parameters of GW Ori suggest the disc is only marginally stable to tearing. We present new high-resolution simulations of GW Ori that replicate the wavelike regime expected in thick, low-turbulence protoplanetary discs for the first time to settle this question. Using the most optimistic values of misalignment and stellar mass ratio allowed by observational constraints, we find that the GW Ori disc can be torn by stellar torques alone, without need for an embedded planet. Even if the disc retains a smooth warp in simulations with similar parameters, it is likely that any small perturbation in the density or temperature structure could cause the disc to break. The new simulations rule out retrograde disc rotation relative to the stellar orbits and tentatively suggest the thicker (h/r = 0.04) disc better matches observations. Going forward, we should take care to ensure models of GW Ori and similar systems appropriately represent the propagation of warps. Additionally, analytical predictions are derived from idealized (and often massless) discs and it is useful to assess how each observed disc might deviate from those assumptions, especially in the context of a young and active star-forming neighbourhood.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 539 (4) , 3421-3435
Dust density enhancements and the direct formation of planetary cores in gravitationally unstable discs
Planet formation via core accretion involves the growth of solids that can accumulate to form planetary cores. There are a number of barriers to the collisional growth of solids in protostellar discs, one of which is the drift, or metre, barrier. Solid particles experience a drag force that will tend to cause them to drift towards the central star in smooth, laminar discs, potentially removing particles before they grow large enough to decouple from the disc gas. Here we present 3D, shearing box simulations that explore the dynamical evolution of solids in a protostellar disc that is massive enough for the gravitational instability to manifest as spiral density waves. We expand on earlier work by considering a range of particle sizes and find that the spirals can still enhance the local solid density by more than an order of magnitude, potentially aiding grain growth. Furthermore, if solid particles have enough mass, and the particle size distribution extends to sufficiently large particle sizes, the solid component of the disc can undergo direct gravitational collapse to form bound clumps with masses typically between 1 and 10 M$_\oplus$. Thus, the concentration of dust in a self-gravitating disc could bypass the size barrier for collisional growth and directly form planetary cores early in the lifetime of the disc.
- 1 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 539 (4) , 3421-3435
Open AccessDust density enhancements and the direct formation of planetary cores in gravitationally unstable discs
Planet formation via core accretion involves the growth of solids that can accumulate to form planetary cores. There are a number of barriers to the collisional growth of solids in protostellar discs, one of which is the drift, or metre, barrier. Solid particles experience a drag force that will tend to cause them to drift towards the central star in smooth, laminar discs, potentially removing particles before they grow large enough to decouple from the disc gas. Here we present 3D, shearing box simulations that explore the dynamical evolution of solids in a protostellar disc that is massive enough for the gravitational instability to manifest as spiral density waves. We expand on earlier work by considering a range of particle sizes and find that the spirals can still enhance the local solid density by more than an order of magnitude, potentially aiding grain growth. Furthermore, if solid particles have enough mass, and the particle size distribution extends to sufficiently large particle sizes, the solid component of the disc can undergo direct gravitational collapse to form bound clumps with masses typically between 1 and 10 M$_\oplus$. Thus, the concentration of dust in a self-gravitating disc could bypass the size barrier for collisional growth and directly form planetary cores early in the lifetime of the disc.
- Open Access
- 13 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 531 (1) , 1746-1755
Introducing two improved methods for approximating radiative cooling in hydrodynamical simulations of accretion discs
The evolution of many astrophysical systems depends strongly on the balance between heating and cooling, in particular star formation in giant molecular clouds and the evolution of young protostellar systems. Protostellar discs are susceptible to the gravitational instability, which can play a key role in their evolution and in planet formation. The strength of the instability depends on the rate at which the system loses thermal energy. To study the evolution of these systems, we require radiative cooling approximations because full radiative transfer is generally too expensive to be coupled to hydrodynamical models. Here, we present two new approximate methods for computing radiative cooling that make use of the polytropic cooling approximation. This approach invokes the assumption that each parcel of gas is located within a spherical pseudo-cloud, which can then be used to approximate the optical depth. The first method combines the methods introduced by Stamatellos et al. and Lombardi et al. to overcome the limitations of each method at low and high optical depths, respectively. The second method, the ‘modified Lombardi’ method, is specifically tailored for self-gravitating discs. This modifies the scale height estimate from the method of Lombardi et al. using the analytical scale height for a self-gravitating disc. We show that the modified Lombardi method provides an excellent approximation for the column density in a fragmenting disc, a regime in which the existing methods fail to recover the clumps and spiral structures. We therefore recommend this improved radiative cooling method for more realistic simulations of self-gravitating discs.
- 13 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 531 (1) , 1746-1755
Open AccessIntroducing two improved methods for approximating radiative cooling in hydrodynamical simulations of accretion discs
The evolution of many astrophysical systems depends strongly on the balance between heating and cooling, in particular star formation in giant molecular clouds and the evolution of young protostellar systems. Protostellar discs are susceptible to the gravitational instability, which can play a key role in their evolution and in planet formation. The strength of the instability depends on the rate at which the system loses thermal energy. To study the evolution of these systems, we require radiative cooling approximations because full radiative transfer is generally too expensive to be coupled to hydrodynamical models. Here, we present two new approximate methods for computing radiative cooling that make use of the polytropic cooling approximation. This approach invokes the assumption that each parcel of gas is located within a spherical pseudo-cloud, which can then be used to approximate the optical depth. The first method combines the methods introduced by Stamatellos et al. and Lombardi et al. to overcome the limitations of each method at low and high optical depths, respectively. The second method, the ‘modified Lombardi’ method, is specifically tailored for self-gravitating discs. This modifies the scale height estimate from the method of Lombardi et al. using the analytical scale height for a self-gravitating disc. We show that the modified Lombardi method provides an excellent approximation for the column density in a fragmenting disc, a regime in which the existing methods fail to recover the clumps and spiral structures. We therefore recommend this improved radiative cooling method for more realistic simulations of self-gravitating discs.
- Open Access
Introducing two improved methods for approximating radiative cooling in hydrodynamical simulations of accretion discs
The evolution of many astrophysical systems depends strongly on the balance between heating and cooling, in particular star formation in giant molecular clouds and the evolution of young protostellar systems. Protostellar discs are susceptible to the gravitational instability, which can play a key role in their evolution and in planet formation. The strength of the instability depends on the rate at which the system loses thermal energy. To study the evolution of these systems, we require radiative cooling approximations because full radiative transfer is generally too expensive to be coupled to hydrodynamical models. Here we present two new approximate methods for computing radiative cooling that make use of the polytropic cooling approximation. This approach invokes the assumption that each parcel of gas is located within a spherical pseudo-cloud which can then be used to approximate the optical depth. The first method combines the methods introduced by Stamatellos et al. and Lombardi et al. to overcome the limitations of each method at low and high optical depths respectively. The second, the "Modified Lombardi" method, is specifically tailored for self-gravitating discs. This modifies the scale height estimate from the method of Lombardi et al. using the analytical scale height for a self-gravitating disc. We show that the Modified Lombardi method provides an excellent approximation for the column density in a fragmenting disc, a regime in which the existing methods fail to recover the clumps and spiral structures. We therefore recommend this improved radiative cooling method for more realistic simulations of self-gravitating discs.
Open AccessIntroducing two improved methods for approximating radiative cooling in hydrodynamical simulations of accretion discs
The evolution of many astrophysical systems depends strongly on the balance between heating and cooling, in particular star formation in giant molecular clouds and the evolution of young protostellar systems. Protostellar discs are susceptible to the gravitational instability, which can play a key role in their evolution and in planet formation. The strength of the instability depends on the rate at which the system loses thermal energy. To study the evolution of these systems, we require radiative cooling approximations because full radiative transfer is generally too expensive to be coupled to hydrodynamical models. Here we present two new approximate methods for computing radiative cooling that make use of the polytropic cooling approximation. This approach invokes the assumption that each parcel of gas is located within a spherical pseudo-cloud which can then be used to approximate the optical depth. The first method combines the methods introduced by Stamatellos et al. and Lombardi et al. to overcome the limitations of each method at low and high optical depths respectively. The second, the "Modified Lombardi" method, is specifically tailored for self-gravitating discs. This modifies the scale height estimate from the method of Lombardi et al. using the analytical scale height for a self-gravitating disc. We show that the Modified Lombardi method provides an excellent approximation for the column density in a fragmenting disc, a regime in which the existing methods fail to recover the clumps and spiral structures. We therefore recommend this improved radiative cooling method for more realistic simulations of self-gravitating discs.
- Open Access
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences
- Vol. 10, 1288730
Insights into the first and second hydrostatic core stages from numerical simulations
The theory of how low mass stars form from the collapse of a dense molecular cloud core has been well-established for decades. Thanks to significant progress in computing and numerical modelling, more physical models have been developed and a wider parameter space explored to understand the early stages of star formation more fully. In this review, I describe the expected physical properties of the first and second core stages and how the inclusion of different physics affects those predicted characteristics. I provide an overview of chemical models and synthetic observations, looking towards the positive identification of the first core in nature, which remains elusive. However, there are a few likely candidate first cores, which are listed, and I briefly discuss the recent progress in characterising the youngest protostellar sources. Chemistry will be instrumental in the firm identification of the first core so we require robust theoretical predictions of the chemical evolution of protostellar cores, especially of the first and second core outflows. Looking ahead, simulations can shed light on how the protostellar collapse phase shapes the evolution of the protostellar disc. Simulations of dust evolution during protostellar core collapse show there is significant enhancement in grain size and abundance towards the centre of the core. Chemical models show that the warm, dense conditions of the first core drive chemical evolution. There is a wide scope for further study of the role that the first and second core stages play in determining the structure and composition of the protostellar disc and envelope and, of course, the eventual influence on the formation of planets.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences
- Vol. 10, 1288730
Open AccessInsights into the first and second hydrostatic core stages from numerical simulations
The theory of how low mass stars form from the collapse of a dense molecular cloud core has been well-established for decades. Thanks to significant progress in computing and numerical modelling, more physical models have been developed and a wider parameter space explored to understand the early stages of star formation more fully. In this review, I describe the expected physical properties of the first and second core stages and how the inclusion of different physics affects those predicted characteristics. I provide an overview of chemical models and synthetic observations, looking towards the positive identification of the first core in nature, which remains elusive. However, there are a few likely candidate first cores, which are listed, and I briefly discuss the recent progress in characterising the youngest protostellar sources. Chemistry will be instrumental in the firm identification of the first core so we require robust theoretical predictions of the chemical evolution of protostellar cores, especially of the first and second core outflows. Looking ahead, simulations can shed light on how the protostellar collapse phase shapes the evolution of the protostellar disc. Simulations of dust evolution during protostellar core collapse show there is significant enhancement in grain size and abundance towards the centre of the core. Chemical models show that the warm, dense conditions of the first core drive chemical evolution. There is a wide scope for further study of the role that the first and second core stages play in determining the structure and composition of the protostellar disc and envelope and, of course, the eventual influence on the formation of planets.
- Open Access
Insights into the first and second hydrostatic core stages from numerical simulations
The theory of how low mass stars form from the collapse of a dense molecular cloud core has been well-established for decades. Thanks to significant progress in computing and numerical modelling, more physical models have been developed and a wider parameter space explored to understand the early stages of star formation more fully. In this review, I describe the expected physical properties of the first and second core stages and how the inclusion of different physics affects those predicted characteristics. I provide an overview of chemical models and synthetic observations, looking towards the positive identification of the first core in nature, which remains elusive. However, there are a few likely candidate first cores, which are listed, and I briefly discuss the recent progress in characterising the youngest protostellar sources. Chemistry will be instrumental in the firm identification of the first core so we require robust theoretical predictions of the chemical evolution of protostellar cores, especially of the first and second core outflows. Looking ahead, simulations can shed light on how the protostellar collapse phase shapes the evolution of the protostellar disc. Simulations of dust evolution during protostellar core collapse show there is significant enhancement in grain size and abundance towards the centre of the core. Chemical models show that the warm, dense conditions of the first core drive chemical evolution. There is a wide scope for further study of the role that the first and second core stages play in determining the structure and composition of the protostellar disc and envelope and, of course, the eventual influence on the formation of planets.
Open AccessInsights into the first and second hydrostatic core stages from numerical simulations
The theory of how low mass stars form from the collapse of a dense molecular cloud core has been well-established for decades. Thanks to significant progress in computing and numerical modelling, more physical models have been developed and a wider parameter space explored to understand the early stages of star formation more fully. In this review, I describe the expected physical properties of the first and second core stages and how the inclusion of different physics affects those predicted characteristics. I provide an overview of chemical models and synthetic observations, looking towards the positive identification of the first core in nature, which remains elusive. However, there are a few likely candidate first cores, which are listed, and I briefly discuss the recent progress in characterising the youngest protostellar sources. Chemistry will be instrumental in the firm identification of the first core so we require robust theoretical predictions of the chemical evolution of protostellar cores, especially of the first and second core outflows. Looking ahead, simulations can shed light on how the protostellar collapse phase shapes the evolution of the protostellar disc. Simulations of dust evolution during protostellar core collapse show there is significant enhancement in grain size and abundance towards the centre of the core. Chemical models show that the warm, dense conditions of the first core drive chemical evolution. There is a wide scope for further study of the role that the first and second core stages play in determining the structure and composition of the protostellar disc and envelope and, of course, the eventual influence on the formation of planets.
- 18 August 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 525 (2) , 2616-2631
On the conditions for warping and breaking protoplanetary discs
Recent observations demonstrate that misalignments and other out-of-plane structures are common in protoplanetary discs. Many of these have been linked to a central host binary with an orbit that is inclined with respect to the disc. We present simulations of misaligned circumbinary discs with a range of parameters to gain a better understanding of the link between those parameters and the disc morphology in the wave-like regime of warp propagation that is appropriate to protoplanetary discs. The simulations confirm that disc tearing is possible in protoplanetary discs as long as the mass ratio, μ, and disc-binary inclination angle, i, are not too small. For the simulations presented here this corresponds to μ > 0.1 and i ≳ 40○. For highly eccentric binaries, tearing can occur for discs with smaller misalignment. Existing theoretical predictions provide an estimate of the radial extent of the disc in which we can expect breaking to occur. However, there does not seem to be a simple relationship between the disc properties and the radius within the circumbinary disc at which the breaks appear, and furthermore the radius at which the disc breaks can change as a function of time in each case. We discuss the implications of our results for interpreting observations and suggest some considerations for modelling misaligned discs in the future.
- 18 August 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 525 (2) , 2616-2631
On the conditions for warping and breaking protoplanetary discs
Recent observations demonstrate that misalignments and other out-of-plane structures are common in protoplanetary discs. Many of these have been linked to a central host binary with an orbit that is inclined with respect to the disc. We present simulations of misaligned circumbinary discs with a range of parameters to gain a better understanding of the link between those parameters and the disc morphology in the wave-like regime of warp propagation that is appropriate to protoplanetary discs. The simulations confirm that disc tearing is possible in protoplanetary discs as long as the mass ratio, μ, and disc-binary inclination angle, i, are not too small. For the simulations presented here this corresponds to μ > 0.1 and i ≳ 40○. For highly eccentric binaries, tearing can occur for discs with smaller misalignment. Existing theoretical predictions provide an estimate of the radial extent of the disc in which we can expect breaking to occur. However, there does not seem to be a simple relationship between the disc properties and the radius within the circumbinary disc at which the breaks appear, and furthermore the radius at which the disc breaks can change as a function of time in each case. We discuss the implications of our results for interpreting observations and suggest some considerations for modelling misaligned discs in the future.
- Open Access
On the conditions for warping and breaking protoplanetary discs
Recent observations demonstrate that misalignments and other out-of-plane structures are common in protoplanetary discs. Many of these have been linked to a central host binary with an orbit that is inclined with respect to the disc. We present simulations of misaligned circumbinary discs with a range of parameters to gain a better understanding of the link between those parameters and the disc morphology in the wave-like regime of warp propagation that is appropriate to protoplanetary discs. The simulations confirm that disc tearing is possible in protoplanetary discs as long as the mass ratio, $μ$, and disc-binary inclination angle, $i$, are not too small. For the simulations presented here this corresponds to $μ> 0.1$ and $i \gtrsim 40^\circ$. For highly eccentric binaries, tearing can occur for discs with smaller misalignment. Existing theoretical predictions provide an estimate of the radial extent of the disc in which we can expect breaking to occur. However, there does not seem to be a simple relationship between the disc properties and the radius within the circumbinary disc at which the breaks appear, and furthermore the radius at which the disc breaks can change as a function of time in each case. We discuss the implications of our results for interpreting observations and suggest some considerations for modelling misaligned discs in the future.Open AccessOn the conditions for warping and breaking protoplanetary discs
Recent observations demonstrate that misalignments and other out-of-plane structures are common in protoplanetary discs. Many of these have been linked to a central host binary with an orbit that is inclined with respect to the disc. We present simulations of misaligned circumbinary discs with a range of parameters to gain a better understanding of the link between those parameters and the disc morphology in the wave-like regime of warp propagation that is appropriate to protoplanetary discs. The simulations confirm that disc tearing is possible in protoplanetary discs as long as the mass ratio, $μ$, and disc-binary inclination angle, $i$, are not too small. For the simulations presented here this corresponds to $μ> 0.1$ and $i \gtrsim 40^\circ$. For highly eccentric binaries, tearing can occur for discs with smaller misalignment. Existing theoretical predictions provide an estimate of the radial extent of the disc in which we can expect breaking to occur. However, there does not seem to be a simple relationship between the disc properties and the radius within the circumbinary disc at which the breaks appear, and furthermore the radius at which the disc breaks can change as a function of time in each case. We discuss the implications of our results for interpreting observations and suggest some considerations for modelling misaligned discs in the future.