Rebecca Kirk
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Rebecca Kirk has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Lisa Hutchinson
4 shared publications- Agata Morka
Public Library of Science (PLOS)
2 shared publications - Michael Ehrmann
Center of Medical Biotechnology, Faculty of Biology, University of Duisburg-Essen, Universitaetsstr. 2, 45141 Essen, Germany
2 shared publications - Tim Clausen
Research Institute of Molecular Pathology (IMP), Vienna Biocenter, Vienna, Austria
2 shared publications Bastian Schmidt
Research Institute of Molecular Pathology
1 shared publicationBoril Boyanov
Research Institute of Molecular Pathology
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 September 2025
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 2
Solving the “file drawer problem”: How researchers, institutions, publishers and funders can reduce publication bias
In 1979, psychologist Robert Rosenthal proposed that “journals are filled with the 5% of the studies that show Type I errors, while the file drawers are filled with the 95% of the studies that show nonsignificant results” (1). Despite being identified 45 years ago, the “file drawer problem” persists today. Failure to publish null and negative results has inflated reported efficacy in social sciences as well as translational and clinical medicine. This, in turn, leads to misleading or exaggerated effect sizes in meta-analyses, as well as a risk that future studies will be underpowered or based on irrelevant or insignificant findings. Why are researchers relegating their null and negative results to the file drawer? Investigators might be reluctant to submit work they think has a higher chance of being rejected. There is evidence from clinical medicine that reviewers are indeed more critical of manuscripts that report null results. Funding agencies and commercial interests can introduce bias into the types of research questions that are investigated and how these results are framed. Finally, the “publish or perish” culture endemic in academia has also been blamed for driving the preference for reporting positive or confirmatory results. Given the risk that publication bias poses to the advancement of knowledge, as well as the entrenched behaviours that drive it, what roles and responsibilities do researchers, institutions, funders and publishers have in addressing this problem? This workshop will bring experts from these fields together with participants to develop actionable recommendations for improving the dissemination of null and negative results and reducing publication bias. It aims to raise awareness of the persistent “file drawer problem” and its impact on scientific advancement, while exploring the roles and responsibilities of researchers, institutions, funders and publishers in addressing publication bias. Workshop structure: The workshop will begin with short presentations from various stakeholders—researchers, institutions, funders, and publishers—on their perspectives and initiatives addressing publication bias against null and negative results. Participants will then engage in role-playing exercises, collaborative strategy development, and group presentations, culminating in a synthesis session to identify shared challenges. The workshop will conclude with a focus on actionable next steps that participants can implement in their professional contexts. Target Audience: This workshop is designed for anyone committed to improving the dissemination of null and negative results. We hope that attendees from the stakeholder groups mentioned above will participate.
- 2 September 2025
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 2
Open AccessSolving the “file drawer problem”: How researchers, institutions, publishers and funders can reduce publication bias
In 1979, psychologist Robert Rosenthal proposed that “journals are filled with the 5% of the studies that show Type I errors, while the file drawers are filled with the 95% of the studies that show nonsignificant results” (1). Despite being identified 45 years ago, the “file drawer problem” persists today. Failure to publish null and negative results has inflated reported efficacy in social sciences as well as translational and clinical medicine. This, in turn, leads to misleading or exaggerated effect sizes in meta-analyses, as well as a risk that future studies will be underpowered or based on irrelevant or insignificant findings. Why are researchers relegating their null and negative results to the file drawer? Investigators might be reluctant to submit work they think has a higher chance of being rejected. There is evidence from clinical medicine that reviewers are indeed more critical of manuscripts that report null results. Funding agencies and commercial interests can introduce bias into the types of research questions that are investigated and how these results are framed. Finally, the “publish or perish” culture endemic in academia has also been blamed for driving the preference for reporting positive or confirmatory results. Given the risk that publication bias poses to the advancement of knowledge, as well as the entrenched behaviours that drive it, what roles and responsibilities do researchers, institutions, funders and publishers have in addressing this problem? This workshop will bring experts from these fields together with participants to develop actionable recommendations for improving the dissemination of null and negative results and reducing publication bias. It aims to raise awareness of the persistent “file drawer problem” and its impact on scientific advancement, while exploring the roles and responsibilities of researchers, institutions, funders and publishers in addressing publication bias. Workshop structure: The workshop will begin with short presentations from various stakeholders—researchers, institutions, funders, and publishers—on their perspectives and initiatives addressing publication bias against null and negative results. Participants will then engage in role-playing exercises, collaborative strategy development, and group presentations, culminating in a synthesis session to identify shared challenges. The workshop will conclude with a focus on actionable next steps that participants can implement in their professional contexts. Target Audience: This workshop is designed for anyone committed to improving the dissemination of null and negative results. We hope that attendees from the stakeholder groups mentioned above will participate.
- 21 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 579-601
Supporting Research and Education Stakeholders in Meeting the Sustainable Development Goals Through the HESI SDG Publishers Compact Fellows
- 21 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 579-601
Supporting Research and Education Stakeholders in Meeting the Sustainable Development Goals Through the HESI SDG Publishers Compact Fellows
- Open Access
- 16 September 2024
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Painting the Mona Lisa?
Would Leonardo da Vinci have shared the precise methods behind his masterpieces? Would he guide us step by step through his process to recreate the enigmatic smile of the Mona Lisa? While art often celebrates the elusive and irreplicable touch of genius, contemporary science expects and relies on reproducibility to maintain trust and rigor. More than a decade has passed since the reproducibility crisis was first diagnosed, yet progress in addressing this issue has been gradual and unevenly distributed (Korbmacher, M. et al, 2023). Researchers are increasingly required to produce detailed data management plans and to ensure that their data is findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable (FAIR). However, questions often overlooked in the quest for FAIR data include: Where do the data come from, and how were they generated (Weissgerber, T. et al, 2024)? Detailed methods reporting enhances the value of shared data and makes replication of results more efficient, reducing research waste while also fostering a more equitable research culture, ensuring that up-to-date methods are available to all (LaFlamme, M, 2024). Workshop objectives This workshop will explore how stakeholders within the research science ecosystem can advance reproducibility by encouraging the uptake of methods and protocols sharing. Drawing on a recent set of recommendations from the European Commission's Joint Research Centre, we will spark a meaningful dialogue around translating these recommendations into practice across the scientific community (European Commission et al, 2024). By engaging participants in problem-solving and role-playing exercises, we will consider dilemmas and tradeoffs that may stand in the way of a more responsible, reproducible research culture. Workshop Structure Role-Playing Group Activities: Participants will be divided into groups, each presented with a real-life scenario related to methods and protocols sharing. Participants will assume different roles, such as a researcher, a department head, a librarian, or a funder. Within their respective groups, participants will: Discuss potential strategies to advance reproducibility within their assigned roles. Identify challenges (e.g., incentives and/or disincentives) and propose practical action plans to address them. Develop tools and communication strategies tailored to their stakeholder group. Group Presentations: Each group will present their scenario and proposed actions, explaining how they developed their approach. Synthesis: The workshop will conclude with a collaborative session where participants will discuss common challenges surfaced by the scenarios and collectively identify the most effective approaches to overcome them. Participants will be encouraged to state practical, tangible steps they will take after the workshop to promote methods and protocols sharing in their organizations. Target Audience: This workshop is designed for anyone who is committed to advancing reproducibility in scientific research. We hope that attendees from the stakeholder groups mentioned above will participate.
- 16 September 2024
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Open AccessPainting the Mona Lisa?
Would Leonardo da Vinci have shared the precise methods behind his masterpieces? Would he guide us step by step through his process to recreate the enigmatic smile of the Mona Lisa? While art often celebrates the elusive and irreplicable touch of genius, contemporary science expects and relies on reproducibility to maintain trust and rigor. More than a decade has passed since the reproducibility crisis was first diagnosed, yet progress in addressing this issue has been gradual and unevenly distributed (Korbmacher, M. et al, 2023). Researchers are increasingly required to produce detailed data management plans and to ensure that their data is findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable (FAIR). However, questions often overlooked in the quest for FAIR data include: Where do the data come from, and how were they generated (Weissgerber, T. et al, 2024)? Detailed methods reporting enhances the value of shared data and makes replication of results more efficient, reducing research waste while also fostering a more equitable research culture, ensuring that up-to-date methods are available to all (LaFlamme, M, 2024). Workshop objectives This workshop will explore how stakeholders within the research science ecosystem can advance reproducibility by encouraging the uptake of methods and protocols sharing. Drawing on a recent set of recommendations from the European Commission's Joint Research Centre, we will spark a meaningful dialogue around translating these recommendations into practice across the scientific community (European Commission et al, 2024). By engaging participants in problem-solving and role-playing exercises, we will consider dilemmas and tradeoffs that may stand in the way of a more responsible, reproducible research culture. Workshop Structure Role-Playing Group Activities: Participants will be divided into groups, each presented with a real-life scenario related to methods and protocols sharing. Participants will assume different roles, such as a researcher, a department head, a librarian, or a funder. Within their respective groups, participants will: Discuss potential strategies to advance reproducibility within their assigned roles. Identify challenges (e.g., incentives and/or disincentives) and propose practical action plans to address them. Develop tools and communication strategies tailored to their stakeholder group. Group Presentations: Each group will present their scenario and proposed actions, explaining how they developed their approach. Synthesis: The workshop will conclude with a collaborative session where participants will discuss common challenges surfaced by the scenarios and collectively identify the most effective approaches to overcome them. Participants will be encouraged to state practical, tangible steps they will take after the workshop to promote methods and protocols sharing in their organizations. Target Audience: This workshop is designed for anyone who is committed to advancing reproducibility in scientific research. We hope that attendees from the stakeholder groups mentioned above will participate.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2024
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Openness and Transparency in Peer Review
Peer review is recognized as a fundamental part of the scholarly communication ecosystem. With the current push for increased transparency and openness in science, new ways of organizing and documenting the peer review process are emerging. Some argue that the traditional practice of ‘double blind’ peer review favours already privileged scholars from well-esteemed institutions in North America and Europe. Mechanisms preventing less privileged groups, including scholars from low- and middle-income countries in the global south, from publishing their papers in high impact journals should be combatted. One way of levelling the field, it is argued, is to promote various forms of open peer review. Another push for openness and transparency stems from debates regarding reform of research assessment. Peer review is a fundamental contribution to research that should be appreciated when evaluating the CV of a researcher. More streamlined ways of documenting peer review will be welcomed by such reformists. Finally, cases of misconduct, such as peer reviewers asking for citation of their own papers for the sole reason of boosting their number of citations, will be easier to detect if the identity of the reviewer is revealed along with the published paper. The session will begin with four lightning talks (6–7 minutes each), in which representatives of PREreview, eLife, Reviewer Credits, and PLOS share their experiences with different ways of promoting and facilitating more transparency in peer review. After the lightning talks, there will be a panel discussion chaired by Roald A. Øien, full professor of Special Education and Developmental Psychology at UiT and adjunct assistant professor at the Child Study Center at Yale University’s School of Medicine. Øien is part of the editorial team for the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders and teaches peer review to early career researchers. Watch the panel on this video recording. Vanessa Fairhurst, Head of Community, PREreview: “Why we need greater equity and transparency in peer review.” Naushin Thomson, Senior Production Assistant, eLife:“Learnings from a publishing model focussed on preprint review and curation.” Sven Fund, Managing Director, Reviewer Credits:“Ensuring Peer Review is a Force for Good in Open Science.” Rebecca Kirk, Associate Editorial Director, PLOS:“Open Science in Practice: The Evolution and Impact of Published Peer Review History.”
- 16 September 2024
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Open AccessOpenness and Transparency in Peer Review
Peer review is recognized as a fundamental part of the scholarly communication ecosystem. With the current push for increased transparency and openness in science, new ways of organizing and documenting the peer review process are emerging. Some argue that the traditional practice of ‘double blind’ peer review favours already privileged scholars from well-esteemed institutions in North America and Europe. Mechanisms preventing less privileged groups, including scholars from low- and middle-income countries in the global south, from publishing their papers in high impact journals should be combatted. One way of levelling the field, it is argued, is to promote various forms of open peer review. Another push for openness and transparency stems from debates regarding reform of research assessment. Peer review is a fundamental contribution to research that should be appreciated when evaluating the CV of a researcher. More streamlined ways of documenting peer review will be welcomed by such reformists. Finally, cases of misconduct, such as peer reviewers asking for citation of their own papers for the sole reason of boosting their number of citations, will be easier to detect if the identity of the reviewer is revealed along with the published paper. The session will begin with four lightning talks (6–7 minutes each), in which representatives of PREreview, eLife, Reviewer Credits, and PLOS share their experiences with different ways of promoting and facilitating more transparency in peer review. After the lightning talks, there will be a panel discussion chaired by Roald A. Øien, full professor of Special Education and Developmental Psychology at UiT and adjunct assistant professor at the Child Study Center at Yale University’s School of Medicine. Øien is part of the editorial team for the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders and teaches peer review to early career researchers. Watch the panel on this video recording. Vanessa Fairhurst, Head of Community, PREreview: “Why we need greater equity and transparency in peer review.” Naushin Thomson, Senior Production Assistant, eLife:“Learnings from a publishing model focussed on preprint review and curation.” Sven Fund, Managing Director, Reviewer Credits:“Ensuring Peer Review is a Force for Good in Open Science.” Rebecca Kirk, Associate Editorial Director, PLOS:“Open Science in Practice: The Evolution and Impact of Published Peer Review History.”
- Open Access
- 25 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in Learned Publishing
- Vol. 36 (1) , 37-41
Equitable representation in awards and recognition in scholarly publishing: Current challenges and the path ahead
Key points: Awards are an important mechanism of recognition that can signify inclusivity or exclusivity and impact careers. More women were selected by publishing organizations for awards overall yet appeared underrecognized in a predominantly women‐employed workforce. Award programs showed a preference for US‐based awardees despite the global representation of individuals' localities. To build equity in awards programs, organizations are encouraged to appoint diverse committees, promote transparency and publicize awards in historically excluded communities.
- 25 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in Learned Publishing
- Vol. 36 (1) , 37-41
Open AccessEquitable representation in awards and recognition in scholarly publishing: Current challenges and the path ahead
Key points: Awards are an important mechanism of recognition that can signify inclusivity or exclusivity and impact careers. More women were selected by publishing organizations for awards overall yet appeared underrecognized in a predominantly women‐employed workforce. Award programs showed a preference for US‐based awardees despite the global representation of individuals' localities. To build equity in awards programs, organizations are encouraged to appoint diverse committees, promote transparency and publicize awards in historically excluded communities.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2021
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 17 (3) , e1008867
Collaborating with our community to increase code sharing
- 30 March 2021
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 17 (3) , e1008867
Open AccessCollaborating with our community to increase code sharing
- Open Access
- 13 February 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in npj Breast Cancer
- Vol. 5 (1) , 1-2
Supporting data sharing
- 13 February 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in npj Breast Cancer
- Vol. 5 (1) , 1-2
Open AccessSupporting data sharing
- 10 September 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Cancer
- Vol. 15 (10) , 574-575
Conscious uncoupling
- 10 September 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Cancer
- Vol. 15 (10) , 574-575
Conscious uncoupling
- 17 December 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Nephrology
- Vol. 10 (2) , 63
Negative feedback loop reveals novel potential therapy
- 17 December 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Nephrology
- Vol. 10 (2) , 63
Negative feedback loop reveals novel potential therapy
- 10 December 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Nephrology
- Vol. 10 (2) , 64
Causative genes identified in rare renal ciliopathies
- 10 December 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Nephrology
- Vol. 10 (2) , 64
Causative genes identified in rare renal ciliopathies