Jessica R. K. Forrest
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jessica R. K. Forrest has a total of 191 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
James D. Thomson
University of Toronto
7 shared publications- Evelyn F. Alecrim
Department of Biology University of Ottawa Ottawa Ontario Canada
3 shared publications - Risa D. Sargent
Faculty of Land and Food Systems University of British Columbia Vancouver British Columbia Canada
3 shared publications - Sébastien Rivest
University of Ottawa Department of Biology Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5, Canada
3 shared publications - Benjamin R. Lee
Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Section of Botany
2 shared publications - Brian D. Inouye
Department of Biological Science Florida State University Tallahassee Florida USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Insect Conservation and Diversity
Roadside pollinator populations and the negative impact of intensive roadside vegetation maintenance
Insect population declines are increasingly well documented, and pollinators are among these threatened taxa. However, modified roadside habitats may be suitable for supporting pollinator populations. This study used a landscape‐scale natural experiment to test how different roadside maintenance practices affect bees (Hymenoptera: Anthophila) and flower flies (Diptera: Syrphidae). Treatments studied were Low Intensity (≤2 mowing events per year and spot‐spraying/hand‐pulling of invasive plants) and Business As Usual (several mowing events per year and heavy use of herbicide). Pollinators were collected at 31 sites, 24 times each, over 2 years (372 site‐visits/year). We found that Business As Usual practices significantly reduced abundance and species richness of pollinators. However, community composition was similar across both treatments, indicating that roadsides support a fairly homogeneous pollinator community, regardless of management. To increase pollinator abundance in roadsides, we recommend that managers adopt practices similar to the Low Intensity management of our study.
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Insect Conservation and Diversity
Open AccessRoadside pollinator populations and the negative impact of intensive roadside vegetation maintenance
Insect population declines are increasingly well documented, and pollinators are among these threatened taxa. However, modified roadside habitats may be suitable for supporting pollinator populations. This study used a landscape‐scale natural experiment to test how different roadside maintenance practices affect bees (Hymenoptera: Anthophila) and flower flies (Diptera: Syrphidae). Treatments studied were Low Intensity (≤2 mowing events per year and spot‐spraying/hand‐pulling of invasive plants) and Business As Usual (several mowing events per year and heavy use of herbicide). Pollinators were collected at 31 sites, 24 times each, over 2 years (372 site‐visits/year). We found that Business As Usual practices significantly reduced abundance and species richness of pollinators. However, community composition was similar across both treatments, indicating that roadsides support a fairly homogeneous pollinator community, regardless of management. To increase pollinator abundance in roadsides, we recommend that managers adopt practices similar to the Low Intensity management of our study.
- Open Access
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Insect Conservation and Diversity
- Vol. 18 (6) , 1037-1052
Associations between soil characteristics and ground‐nesting bees on farms
Much of the world's agricultural production depends on pollination services provided by wild bees. At the same time, agriculture changes landscapes in ways that can alter bee habitat. However, little is known about the nesting habitat requirements of the many bee species that nest underground. Here, we asked which soil factors influence the abundance, diversity, and community composition of ground‐nesting bees in agroecosystems around Ottawa, Canada. We measured soil characteristics (texture, hardness, slope, and ground cover) and sampled bee communities at 131 plots on 35 farms over a 2‐year period. We identified the ground‐nesting bees to species. We collected 8661 ground‐nesting bees representing 100 species. Ground‐nesting bee abundance and species richness were higher with increased percentages of bare ground and sand, while Simpson's diversity was negatively associated with slope. The abundance of non‐ground‐nesting (cavity‐nesting) bees was not related to any measured soil properties, suggesting that the associations between soil variables and ground‐nesting bees reflect direct effects of soils on these bees, rather than indirect effects mediated by unmeasured variables. Only a small proportion of the variance in ground‐nesting bee community composition was explained by soil factors; however, sand percentage, slope, soil compaction, and bare ground were all significant predictors, reflecting the fact that relationships between soil predictors and ground‐nesting bee taxa were species‐specific. Compared to floral resources, soils have been neglected as components of bee habitat quality, but understanding the soil characteristics preferred by ground‐nesting bees can assist in efforts to protect this important group of pollinators.
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Insect Conservation and Diversity
- Vol. 18 (6) , 1037-1052
Open AccessAssociations between soil characteristics and ground‐nesting bees on farms
Much of the world's agricultural production depends on pollination services provided by wild bees. At the same time, agriculture changes landscapes in ways that can alter bee habitat. However, little is known about the nesting habitat requirements of the many bee species that nest underground. Here, we asked which soil factors influence the abundance, diversity, and community composition of ground‐nesting bees in agroecosystems around Ottawa, Canada. We measured soil characteristics (texture, hardness, slope, and ground cover) and sampled bee communities at 131 plots on 35 farms over a 2‐year period. We identified the ground‐nesting bees to species. We collected 8661 ground‐nesting bees representing 100 species. Ground‐nesting bee abundance and species richness were higher with increased percentages of bare ground and sand, while Simpson's diversity was negatively associated with slope. The abundance of non‐ground‐nesting (cavity‐nesting) bees was not related to any measured soil properties, suggesting that the associations between soil variables and ground‐nesting bees reflect direct effects of soils on these bees, rather than indirect effects mediated by unmeasured variables. Only a small proportion of the variance in ground‐nesting bee community composition was explained by soil factors; however, sand percentage, slope, soil compaction, and bare ground were all significant predictors, reflecting the fact that relationships between soil predictors and ground‐nesting bee taxa were species‐specific. Compared to floral resources, soils have been neglected as components of bee habitat quality, but understanding the soil characteristics preferred by ground‐nesting bees can assist in efforts to protect this important group of pollinators.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (6) , e70289
Up High, Hot and Dry: Individual Reproductive Output in Subalpine Bees Declines With Increasing Drought Severity
Wild bees play indispensable ecological roles in many ecosystems, yet declines in many species have been documented in recent years. These declines have been linked to numerous anthropogenic pressures, including climate change, which can influence bee populations directly (i.e., via physiological mechanisms) and indirectly (e.g., through changes to floral resource quantity and quality). Widespread changes in the distributions and abundances of many bee species have been linked to climate change at large spatial scales; yet, the local‐scale processes that generate these broad‐scale patterns are little known. Specifically, it is unclear how climate change influences the fitness of individual bees, despite the fact that broad‐scale patterns of decline must be driven by individual‐level processes. Our study examines the individual fitness responses (i.e., reproductive output) of five solitary bee species in the genus Osmia to variations in local climate variables in subalpine habitats. Over nine years, we tracked brood cell production in over 700 individual female bees, conducted repeated surveys of floral abundance (while taking into account the specific floral host taxa used by each bee species), and recorded local precipitation and temperature at seven sites. Our data revealed both direct and indirect (floral resource‐mediated) negative effects of drought: the total number of brood cells produced by nesting females decreased significantly in summers characterized by greater drought severity and high temperatures—a relationship‐driven partly by significant decreases in floral host‐plant availability in hotter and drier years. Our study highlights how the negative consequences of climate change for bee populations can manifest at the level of individuals and the role of floral resources in mediating these relationships. Overall, our results suggest that the increasingly warm and dry conditions forecasted for our study area will have net negative effects on the demographic success of these solitary bees.
- 11 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (6) , e70289
Open AccessUp High, Hot and Dry: Individual Reproductive Output in Subalpine Bees Declines With Increasing Drought Severity
Wild bees play indispensable ecological roles in many ecosystems, yet declines in many species have been documented in recent years. These declines have been linked to numerous anthropogenic pressures, including climate change, which can influence bee populations directly (i.e., via physiological mechanisms) and indirectly (e.g., through changes to floral resource quantity and quality). Widespread changes in the distributions and abundances of many bee species have been linked to climate change at large spatial scales; yet, the local‐scale processes that generate these broad‐scale patterns are little known. Specifically, it is unclear how climate change influences the fitness of individual bees, despite the fact that broad‐scale patterns of decline must be driven by individual‐level processes. Our study examines the individual fitness responses (i.e., reproductive output) of five solitary bee species in the genus Osmia to variations in local climate variables in subalpine habitats. Over nine years, we tracked brood cell production in over 700 individual female bees, conducted repeated surveys of floral abundance (while taking into account the specific floral host taxa used by each bee species), and recorded local precipitation and temperature at seven sites. Our data revealed both direct and indirect (floral resource‐mediated) negative effects of drought: the total number of brood cells produced by nesting females decreased significantly in summers characterized by greater drought severity and high temperatures—a relationship‐driven partly by significant decreases in floral host‐plant availability in hotter and drier years. Our study highlights how the negative consequences of climate change for bee populations can manifest at the level of individuals and the role of floral resources in mediating these relationships. Overall, our results suggest that the increasingly warm and dry conditions forecasted for our study area will have net negative effects on the demographic success of these solitary bees.
- Open Access
Fitness costs and benefits of a non‐native floral resource for subalpine solitary bees
Organisms inhabiting seasonal environments must fit their life cycle into a limited time window while also synchronizing periods of resource consumption with timing of resource availability. Introduced non‐native species, which often differ in phenology from natives, can alter and expand the seasonal window of resource availability for native consumers, providing potential fitness benefits. However, if these non‐native resources are nutritionally unsuitable for native consumers, their presence could elicit foraging behaviour that proves maladaptive – i.e. they could act as an ecological trap. Here, we used multi‐year field observations and a laboratory experiment to investigate the impacts of a common non‐native plant species on two components of fitness in three solitary bee species (all specialist consumers of pollen from the plant family Asteraceae) native to the Colorado Rocky Mountains. First, we tested whether individual bees that collect pollen from the non‐native common dandelion Taraxacum officinale produce more offspring than those that do not, thanks to the unusually early flowering phenology of the non‐native. Second, we compared survival of bee larvae experimentally reared on Taraxacum pollen to that of larvae reared on native Asteraceae pollen. Bees that used at least some non‐native Taraxacum pollen produced more potentially viable offspring, but larval survival was significantly reduced for bee larvae experimentally fed provisions dominated by Taraxacum pollen. Therefore, survival costs may negate the potential fitness benefits of early nesting, indicating that non‐native floral resource use may act as an ecological trap for native bees. Using a series of simple simulations informed by our results, we explore the fitness effects of non‐native floral resource use, demonstrating that the net cost or benefit depends on how bees respond to resource shortages. Our results highlight the importance of considering organisms' full life cycles when evaluating the fitness consequences of resource availability and species introductions.
Open AccessFitness costs and benefits of a non‐native floral resource for subalpine solitary bees
Organisms inhabiting seasonal environments must fit their life cycle into a limited time window while also synchronizing periods of resource consumption with timing of resource availability. Introduced non‐native species, which often differ in phenology from natives, can alter and expand the seasonal window of resource availability for native consumers, providing potential fitness benefits. However, if these non‐native resources are nutritionally unsuitable for native consumers, their presence could elicit foraging behaviour that proves maladaptive – i.e. they could act as an ecological trap. Here, we used multi‐year field observations and a laboratory experiment to investigate the impacts of a common non‐native plant species on two components of fitness in three solitary bee species (all specialist consumers of pollen from the plant family Asteraceae) native to the Colorado Rocky Mountains. First, we tested whether individual bees that collect pollen from the non‐native common dandelion Taraxacum officinale produce more offspring than those that do not, thanks to the unusually early flowering phenology of the non‐native. Second, we compared survival of bee larvae experimentally reared on Taraxacum pollen to that of larvae reared on native Asteraceae pollen. Bees that used at least some non‐native Taraxacum pollen produced more potentially viable offspring, but larval survival was significantly reduced for bee larvae experimentally fed provisions dominated by Taraxacum pollen. Therefore, survival costs may negate the potential fitness benefits of early nesting, indicating that non‐native floral resource use may act as an ecological trap for native bees. Using a series of simple simulations informed by our results, we explore the fitness effects of non‐native floral resource use, demonstrating that the net cost or benefit depends on how bees respond to resource shortages. Our results highlight the importance of considering organisms' full life cycles when evaluating the fitness consequences of resource availability and species introductions.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (1) , e70006
Land Use Change Consistently Reduces α‐ But Not β‐ and γ‐Diversity of Bees
Land use change threatens global biodiversity and compromises ecosystem functions, including pollination and food production. Reduced taxonomic α‐diversity is often reported under land use change, yet the impacts could be different at larger spatial scales (i.e., γ‐diversity), either due to reduced β‐diversity amplifying diversity loss or increased β‐diversity dampening diversity loss. Additionally, studies often focus on taxonomic diversity, while other important biodiversity components, including phylogenetic diversity, can exhibit differential responses. Here, we evaluated how agricultural and urban land use alters the taxonomic and phylogenetic α‐, β‐, and γ‐diversity of an important pollinator taxon—bees. Using a multicontinental dataset of 3117 bee assemblages from 157 studies, we found that taxonomic α‐diversity was reduced by 16%–18% in both agricultural and urban habitats relative to natural habitats. Phylogenetic α‐diversity was decreased by 11%–12% in agricultural and urban habitats. Compared with natural habitats, taxonomic and phylogenetic β‐diversity increased by 11% and 6% in urban habitats, respectively, but exhibited no systematic change in agricultural habitats. We detected a 22% decline in taxonomic γ‐diversity and a 17% decline in phylogenetic γ‐diversity in agricultural habitats, but γ‐diversity of urban habitats was not significantly different from natural habitats. These findings highlight the threat of agricultural expansions to large‐scale bee diversity due to systematic γ‐diversity decline. In addition, while both urbanization and agriculture lead to consistent declines in α‐diversity, their impacts on β‐ or γ‐diversity vary, highlighting the need to study the effects of land use change at multiple scales.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (1) , e70006
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessLand Use Change Consistently Reduces α‐ But Not β‐ and γ‐Diversity of Bees
Land use change threatens global biodiversity and compromises ecosystem functions, including pollination and food production. Reduced taxonomic α‐diversity is often reported under land use change, yet the impacts could be different at larger spatial scales (i.e., γ‐diversity), either due to reduced β‐diversity amplifying diversity loss or increased β‐diversity dampening diversity loss. Additionally, studies often focus on taxonomic diversity, while other important biodiversity components, including phylogenetic diversity, can exhibit differential responses. Here, we evaluated how agricultural and urban land use alters the taxonomic and phylogenetic α‐, β‐, and γ‐diversity of an important pollinator taxon—bees. Using a multicontinental dataset of 3117 bee assemblages from 157 studies, we found that taxonomic α‐diversity was reduced by 16%–18% in both agricultural and urban habitats relative to natural habitats. Phylogenetic α‐diversity was decreased by 11%–12% in agricultural and urban habitats. Compared with natural habitats, taxonomic and phylogenetic β‐diversity increased by 11% and 6% in urban habitats, respectively, but exhibited no systematic change in agricultural habitats. We detected a 22% decline in taxonomic γ‐diversity and a 17% decline in phylogenetic γ‐diversity in agricultural habitats, but γ‐diversity of urban habitats was not significantly different from natural habitats. These findings highlight the threat of agricultural expansions to large‐scale bee diversity due to systematic γ‐diversity decline. In addition, while both urbanization and agriculture lead to consistent declines in α‐diversity, their impacts on β‐ or γ‐diversity vary, highlighting the need to study the effects of land use change at multiple scales.
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 112 (6) , 1184-1199
Phenological mismatch between trees and wildflowers: Reconciling divergent findings in two recent analyses
Recent evidence suggests that community science and herbarium datasets yield similar estimates of species' phenological sensitivities to temperature. Despite this, two recent studies by Alecrim et al. (2023) and Miller et al. (2022) found very different results when using different data sources (community science and herbarium specimens, respectively) to investigate whether warming threatens wildflowers with phenological mismatch in relation to shading by deciduous trees. Here, we investigated whether differences between the two studies' results could be reconciled by testing four hypotheses related to model design, species, spatiotemporal data extent and phenophase. Hybrid model structures brought results from the two datasets closer together but did not fully reconcile the differences between the studies. Neither the species nor the phenophase selected for analysis seemed to be responsible for differences in results. Cropping the datasets to match spatial and temporal extents appeared to reconcile most differences but only at the cost of much higher uncertainty associated with reduced sample size. Synthesis: Our analysis suggests that although species‐level estimates of phenological sensitivity may be similar between community science and herbarium datasets, inherent differences in the types and extent of data may lead to contradictory inference about complex biotic interactions. We conclude that, until community science data repositories expand to match the range of climate conditions present in herbarium collections or until herbarium collections match the spatial extent and temporal frequency of community science repositories, ecological studies should ideally be evaluated using both datasets to test the possibility of biased results from either.
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 112 (6) , 1184-1199
Phenological mismatch between trees and wildflowers: Reconciling divergent findings in two recent analyses
Recent evidence suggests that community science and herbarium datasets yield similar estimates of species' phenological sensitivities to temperature. Despite this, two recent studies by Alecrim et al. (2023) and Miller et al. (2022) found very different results when using different data sources (community science and herbarium specimens, respectively) to investigate whether warming threatens wildflowers with phenological mismatch in relation to shading by deciduous trees. Here, we investigated whether differences between the two studies' results could be reconciled by testing four hypotheses related to model design, species, spatiotemporal data extent and phenophase. Hybrid model structures brought results from the two datasets closer together but did not fully reconcile the differences between the studies. Neither the species nor the phenophase selected for analysis seemed to be responsible for differences in results. Cropping the datasets to match spatial and temporal extents appeared to reconcile most differences but only at the cost of much higher uncertainty associated with reduced sample size. Synthesis: Our analysis suggests that although species‐level estimates of phenological sensitivity may be similar between community science and herbarium datasets, inherent differences in the types and extent of data may lead to contradictory inference about complex biotic interactions. We conclude that, until community science data repositories expand to match the range of climate conditions present in herbarium collections or until herbarium collections match the spatial extent and temporal frequency of community science repositories, ecological studies should ideally be evaluated using both datasets to test the possibility of biased results from either.
- 24 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Arthropod-Plant Interactions
- Vol. 18 (3) , 417-424
Impacts of Asteraceae pollen spines on bumble bee survival and larval growth
- 24 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Arthropod-Plant Interactions
- Vol. 18 (3) , 417-424
Impacts of Asteraceae pollen spines on bumble bee survival and larval growth
- Open Access
- 10 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 61 (3) , 442-451
Supplemental nesting habitat increases bee abundance in apple orchards
Identifying the resources that limit bee populations is essential for both bee conservation and pollination management in agroecosystems. Land‐use change typically leads to decreased habitat availability for wild pollinators, including loss of nesting habitat, which is an essential but often‐overlooked resource for wild bees. Cavity‐nesting bees, such as many Osmia spp. (Hymenoptera: Megachilidae), occupy holes in wood or reeds to build their nests; due to their nesting habits, they are frequently scarce in agricultural settings. Nevertheless, under the right circumstances, these bees can be ideal pollinators of apple and other orchard crops. Artificial nesting structures (‘bee hotels’ or ‘trap‐nests’) are often used to study cavity‐nesting bees and have been proposed as tools for bee conservation. To evaluate the effects of additional nesting habitat on the local abundance of pollinators, we selected 24 sites in apple orchards in eastern Canada in 2021 and 2022. Each site comprised two study plots: one in which we installed artificial nesting structures for cavity‐nesting bees, and one without added nesting habitat (control). Pollinator surveys were conducted in both plot types to measure pollinator visits to apple blossoms and, after apple bloom, to flowers in the undergrowth and/or in shrubs. Numbers and size of developing fruit were also recorded. Both Osmia bees and overall pollinator numbers were significantly higher in the treatment with trap‐nests (respectively, 33% and 22% higher during the 2021 growing season, and 113% and 30% higher during apple bloom across the 2 years of the study); however, there was no consistent difference in apple size or fruit set between the two treatments. Thus, trap‐nests locally increased the numbers of cavity‐nesting bees as well as total pollinator numbers, but they had little effect on apple yield, likely because apple production was not pollinator limited in the years of this study. Synthesis and applications. These findings suggest that bee populations in apple orchards can be limited by nesting resources such that addition of constructed nesting habitat could be an effective means of increasing pollinator numbers in orchards, and potentially, supporting bee conservation.
- 10 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 61 (3) , 442-451
Open AccessSupplemental nesting habitat increases bee abundance in apple orchards
Identifying the resources that limit bee populations is essential for both bee conservation and pollination management in agroecosystems. Land‐use change typically leads to decreased habitat availability for wild pollinators, including loss of nesting habitat, which is an essential but often‐overlooked resource for wild bees. Cavity‐nesting bees, such as many Osmia spp. (Hymenoptera: Megachilidae), occupy holes in wood or reeds to build their nests; due to their nesting habits, they are frequently scarce in agricultural settings. Nevertheless, under the right circumstances, these bees can be ideal pollinators of apple and other orchard crops. Artificial nesting structures (‘bee hotels’ or ‘trap‐nests’) are often used to study cavity‐nesting bees and have been proposed as tools for bee conservation. To evaluate the effects of additional nesting habitat on the local abundance of pollinators, we selected 24 sites in apple orchards in eastern Canada in 2021 and 2022. Each site comprised two study plots: one in which we installed artificial nesting structures for cavity‐nesting bees, and one without added nesting habitat (control). Pollinator surveys were conducted in both plot types to measure pollinator visits to apple blossoms and, after apple bloom, to flowers in the undergrowth and/or in shrubs. Numbers and size of developing fruit were also recorded. Both Osmia bees and overall pollinator numbers were significantly higher in the treatment with trap‐nests (respectively, 33% and 22% higher during the 2021 growing season, and 113% and 30% higher during apple bloom across the 2 years of the study); however, there was no consistent difference in apple size or fruit set between the two treatments. Thus, trap‐nests locally increased the numbers of cavity‐nesting bees as well as total pollinator numbers, but they had little effect on apple yield, likely because apple production was not pollinator limited in the years of this study. Synthesis and applications. These findings suggest that bee populations in apple orchards can be limited by nesting resources such that addition of constructed nesting habitat could be an effective means of increasing pollinator numbers in orchards, and potentially, supporting bee conservation.
- Open Access
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 111 (10) , 2257-2268
Warmer springs increase potential for temporal reproductive isolation among habitat patches in subalpine flowering plants
Flowering phenology can vary considerably even at fine spatial scales, potentially leading to temporal reproductive isolation among habitat patches. Climate change could alter flowering synchrony, and hence temporal isolation, if plants in different microhabitats vary in their phenological response to climate change. Despite the importance of temporal isolation in determining patterns of gene flow, and hence population genetic structure and local adaptation, little is known about how changes in climate affect temporal isolation within populations. Here, we use flowering phenology and floral abundance data of 50 subalpine plant species over 44 years to test whether temporal isolation between habitat patches is affected by spring temperature. For each species and year, we analysed temporal separation in peak flowering and flowering overlap between habitat patches separated by 5–950 m. Across our study species, warmer springs were associated with more temporal differentiation in flowering peaks among habitat patches, and less flowering overlap, increasing potential for temporal isolation within populations. Synthesis. By reducing opportunities for mating among plants in nearby habitat patches, our results suggest that warmer springs may reduce opportunities for gene flow within populations, and, consequently, the capacity of plant populations to adapt to environmental changes.
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 111 (10) , 2257-2268
Open AccessWarmer springs increase potential for temporal reproductive isolation among habitat patches in subalpine flowering plants
Flowering phenology can vary considerably even at fine spatial scales, potentially leading to temporal reproductive isolation among habitat patches. Climate change could alter flowering synchrony, and hence temporal isolation, if plants in different microhabitats vary in their phenological response to climate change. Despite the importance of temporal isolation in determining patterns of gene flow, and hence population genetic structure and local adaptation, little is known about how changes in climate affect temporal isolation within populations. Here, we use flowering phenology and floral abundance data of 50 subalpine plant species over 44 years to test whether temporal isolation between habitat patches is affected by spring temperature. For each species and year, we analysed temporal separation in peak flowering and flowering overlap between habitat patches separated by 5–950 m. Across our study species, warmer springs were associated with more temporal differentiation in flowering peaks among habitat patches, and less flowering overlap, increasing potential for temporal isolation within populations. Synthesis. By reducing opportunities for mating among plants in nearby habitat patches, our results suggest that warmer springs may reduce opportunities for gene flow within populations, and, consequently, the capacity of plant populations to adapt to environmental changes.
- Open Access
Phenological mismatch between trees and wildflowers: Reconciling divergent findings in two recent analyses
Recent evidence suggests that community science and herbarium datasets yield similar estimates of species’ phenological sensitivities to temperature. Despite this, two recent studies by Alecrim et al. (2023) and Miller et al. (2022) found contradictory results when investigating an identical ecological mechanism (phenological mismatch of wildflower flowering and of shading by deciduous trees; “phenological escape”) with separate datasets. Here, we investigated whether differences between the two studies’ results could be reconciled by testing four hypotheses related to model design, species selection, spatiotemporal data extent, and phenophase selection. Hybrid model structures brought results from the two datasets closer together but did not fully reconcile the differences between the studies. Cropping the datasets to match spatial and temporal extents appeared to reconcile most differences but only at the cost of much higher uncertainty associated with reduced sample size. Neither species selection nor phenophase selection seemed to be responsible for differences in results. Synthesis: Our analysis suggests that although species-level estimates of phenological sensitivity may be similar between crowd-sourced and herbarium datasets, inherent differences in the types and extent of data may lead to contradictory inference about complex biotic interactions. We conclude that, until community science data repositories grow to match the range of climate conditions present in herbarium collections or until herbarium collections grow to match the spatial extent and temporal frequency of community science repositories, ecological studies should ideally be evaluated using both datasets to test the possibility of biased results from either.
Open AccessPhenological mismatch between trees and wildflowers: Reconciling divergent findings in two recent analyses
Recent evidence suggests that community science and herbarium datasets yield similar estimates of species’ phenological sensitivities to temperature. Despite this, two recent studies by Alecrim et al. (2023) and Miller et al. (2022) found contradictory results when investigating an identical ecological mechanism (phenological mismatch of wildflower flowering and of shading by deciduous trees; “phenological escape”) with separate datasets. Here, we investigated whether differences between the two studies’ results could be reconciled by testing four hypotheses related to model design, species selection, spatiotemporal data extent, and phenophase selection. Hybrid model structures brought results from the two datasets closer together but did not fully reconcile the differences between the studies. Cropping the datasets to match spatial and temporal extents appeared to reconcile most differences but only at the cost of much higher uncertainty associated with reduced sample size. Neither species selection nor phenophase selection seemed to be responsible for differences in results. Synthesis: Our analysis suggests that although species-level estimates of phenological sensitivity may be similar between crowd-sourced and herbarium datasets, inherent differences in the types and extent of data may lead to contradictory inference about complex biotic interactions. We conclude that, until community science data repositories grow to match the range of climate conditions present in herbarium collections or until herbarium collections grow to match the spatial extent and temporal frequency of community science repositories, ecological studies should ideally be evaluated using both datasets to test the possibility of biased results from either.