TSThomas Schultze

Thomas Schultze

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Thomas Schultze has a total of 205 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Distinct neural routes for evaluative and informational social influence

    by Sriranjani Manivasagam, Thomas Schultze, Anne Schacht, Anna Fischer

    Humans routinely revise their judgments based on input from others, yet how the brain mechanisms distinguish evaluative from informational social influence remains unclear. Using preregistered electroencephalography (EEG, N = 87) and the Judge-Advisor System, we identified distinct neurocognitive routes by which feedback and advice shape judgment revision. Participants made numerical estimates, received either feedback (“good”/“bad”) or advice (alternative estimates) of varying proximity to their own judgment, and then revised their response. Feedback engaged rapid evaluative monitoring: a feedback-related negativity (FRN, 200-300ms) that decreased with confidence, indicating reflexive performance assessment. Advice triggered delayed deliberate processing: late positive complex (LPC) onset latencies that slowed when confident individuals encountered discrepant advice, indicating effortful integration of external information. Both routes converged on the P300 (250-250ms),whose amplitudes increased with proximity, consistent with the reward value of social validation. These findings reveal a dual-route architecture: feedback determines whether to revise through rapid evaluative signals, while advice specifies how much to revise through sustained integrative processes. Confidence calibrates both routes, protecting against misleading feedback while intensifying deliberation over discrepant advice. This temporal dissociation clarifies how metacognitive and social processes coordinate adaptive judgment revision.


  • Open Access

    The benefit of collaboration: Disentangling the sources of synergy in group judgment

    by Matthias Lippold, Thomas Schultze, Stefan Schulz-Hardt

    Whereas recent research on the wisdom of the crowd effect questioned the importance of group interaction by showing that, in many cases, simple aggregations of independent judgments are already highly accurate, we present extensive meta-analytic evidence that interacting groups outperform such aggregations and, thereby, achieve synergy. In particular, we show that group judgments are more accurate than the average of a comparable number of individual judgments, and that group judgments can be as accurate as the judgments of the best individual member of the nominal groups (i.e., the person with the lowest judgment error). Additionally, our meta-analytic results substantiate two different mechanisms that lead to synergy in quantitative group judgment. On the one hand, group members can learn from each other and, thereby, increase their individual accuracy (G-I transfer). On the other hand, when controlling for G-I transfer, group members are also able to identify the more accurate judgments and assign more weight to them (differential weighting).

  • Open Access

    Learning Processes in the Judge–Advisor System: A Neglected Advantage of Advice Taking

    by Thomas Schultze, Alexander Stern, Stefan Schulz‐Hardt

    Previous research in the judge–advisor paradigm has focused on how judges utilize the wisdom of others by taking their advice and on the beneficial effect of receiving advice on judges' postadvice final judgments about the exact same problem. However, a completely different possibility of how judges might benefit from advice has been overlooked so far: Learning processes could improve the accuracy of judges' subsequent initial judgments from one problem to another problem on the same type of task as well. Hence, we test the assumption that advice can induce individual performance enhancements that differ as a function of the advisor's judgment accuracy. The results of three experiments support our hypothesis and indicate positive learning, particularly when participants receive high‐quality advice. Furthermore, we show that external information about the advisor's accuracy is not crucial for the occurrence of these individual performance enhancements. In general, our results suggest that advice can have a positive effect on judges' subsequent initial judgments.


  • Open Access

    The development of a task to study advice taking across nations and its application in a China-Germany comparison

    by Thomas Schultze, Zhijun Chen

    Advice taking is a crucial part of decision-making and has attracted the interest of scholars across the world. Laboratory research on advice taking has revealed several robust phenomena, such as sensitivity to advice quality or a tendency to underutilize advice. Despite extensive investigations in different countries, cultural differences in advice taking remain understudied. Knowing whether such cultural differences exist would not only be interesting from an academic standpoint but might also have consequences for multinational organizations and businesses. Here, we argue that prior laboratory research on cultural differences in advice taking is hindered by confounding factors, particularly the confound between participants’ cultural background and task difficulty. To draw a valid conclusion about cultural differences in advice taking, it is vital to develop a decision task devoid of this confound. Here, we develop such a judgment task and demonstrate that the core phenomena of advice taking manifest in a sample of German participants. We then use this task in a cross-national comparison of German and Chinese participants. While the core phenomena of advice taking consistently manifested in both samples, some differences emerged. Most notably, Chinese participants were more receptive of advice, even though they still underutilized it. This greater reliance on advice was driven by Chinese participants’ greater preference for averaging their own and the advisor’s judgments. We discuss how our findings extend current understanding of the nuanced interplay between cultural values and the dynamics of advice taking.

  • Open Access

    Using Large Language Models to Augment (Rather Than Replace) Human Feedback in Higher Education Improves Perceived Feedback Quality

    by Thomas Schultze, Varun Suresh Kumar, Gary John McKeown, Patrick Aaron O'COnnor, Magdalena Rychlowska, Kristina Sparemblek

    Formative feedback on assignments such as essays or theses is deemed necessary for students’ academic development in higher education. However, providing high quality feedback can be time-intensive and challenging, and students frequently report dissatisfaction with feedback quality. Here we explore a possible solution, namely using large language models (LLMs) to augment feedback provided by instructors. One potential obstacle to using LLM-augmented feedback is algorithm aversion, which might lead students to deprecate LLM-augmented feedback. Therefore, we examined students’ perceptions of human versus LLM-augmented feedback. In a pre-registered study, participants (N = 112) evaluated original human-generated versus LLM-augmented feedback on a previous assignment. Our results show evidence against algorithm aversion. Furthermore, participants rated the quality of LLM-augmented feedback substantially higher and strongly preferred it over the human-generated original. Our findings demonstrate the potential of LLMs to solve the persistent problem of low perceived feedback quality in higher education.


  • Do judges prefer advisors with dependent or independent errors? Investigating judges’ advice selection and advice weighting.

    by Stefan Schulz-Hardt, Stella K. Wanzel, Johannes Rollwage, Christian Treffenstädt, Thomas Schultze

    Advice stemming from sources with errors that are dependent on each other is usually less accurate than advice provided by sources with independent errors, while simultaneously exhibiting greater consensus. We investigate whether or not individuals express a preference for advice with dependent errors by choosing it over advice with independent errors and by weighting it more strongly. We test for this preference both in a situation where error interdependence does not negatively affect advice accuracy as well as in a situation where advice with dependent errors is less accurate than advice with independent errors. In a series of six studies, we show that, when being given the opportunity to choose between the two types of advice, participants only prefer advice with dependent errors if this is not detrimental for accuracy. However, when being sequentially provided with both types of advice, they generally weight advice with dependent errors more than advice with independent errors, even if the latter is more accurate. This effect is mainly driven by the fact that advice with dependent errors exhibits greater consensus, leading participants' initial estimates to lie outside the range of the advisors' judgments more frequently.


  • Does change of responsibility reduce escalating commitment? A replication and theoretical extension.

    by Thomas Schultze, Stefan Schulz-Hardt

    Reassigning responsibility is the most prominent and best-replicated intervention against escalating commitment (i.e., the failure to withdraw from losing courses of action). This intervention is considered effective because it reduces reinvestments after negative feedback in decision scenarios with a single reinvestment decision. However, we argue that any intervention against escalating commitment should fulfill two additional criteria. The first is temporal stability, that is, the beneficial effects of the intervention need to persist beyond a single reinvestment decision. The second is specific effectiveness, that is, the intervention should reduce commitment only if the project continues to fail after an initial setback (structural failure) but not if it recovers and is ultimately profitable (temporary failure). To subject reassignment of responsibility to this critical test of effectiveness, we introduce a modification of the escalation paradigm that allows testing for temporal stability and differentiates between structural and temporary failure. In the first of two experiments, we did not find evidence of temporal stability. Experiment 2 found persistent short-term effects of responsibility reassignment, but these effects were unspecific, reducing commitment to both losing and ultimately successful courses of action. Our findings question the usefulness of responsibility reassignment as an effective intervention against escalating commitment. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).


  • A test of synergy in dynamic system control tasks.

    by Thomas Schultze, Sylvana Drewes, Stefan Schulz-Hardt

    Individual performance in controlling complex dynamic systems such as managing production in a company or keeping ecosystems in balance is often suboptimal. In this article, we provide the first unequivocal test of whether groups are superior to individuals when controlling dynamic systems. In addition, we test to what extent performance advantages of groups are simply the result of statistically aggregating a larger number of individual opinions and to what extent they represent true synergy attributable to within-group interaction. In 3 experiments, we compared the system control performance of interacting real groups with that of equally sized nominal groups and with individuals. We provide evidence that groups indeed perform better than individuals in dynamic system control tasks. Furthermore, in comparing real groups with nominal groups, we show that, although the majority of real groups' performance advantage stems from statistical aggregation, there is also evidence of true synergy. Finally, we identify the mechanism by which groups achieve synergy, namely group-to-individual transfer. Discussion allows group members to exchange critical information about the system, leading to an improved individual capability to control the system, which, in turn, improves group performance. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).


  • G-I transfer in multicue judgment tasks: Discussion improves group members’ knowledge about target relations.

    by Matthias Lippold, Stefan Schulz-Hardt, Thomas Schultze

    One benefit of working in groups is that group members can learn from each other how to perform the task, a phenomenon called group-to-individual transfer (G-I transfer). In the context of quantitative judgments, G-I transfer means that group members improve their individual accuracy as a consequence of exchanging task-relevant information. This improved individual accuracy allows groups to outperform the average of a comparable number of individuals, that is, G-I transfer leads to synergy. While there is mounting evidence that group members benefit from G-I transfer in quantitative judgment tasks, we still know rather little about what exactly group members learn from each other during this transfer. Here, we build on the distinction between metric knowledge (knowing what constitutes a plausible range of values) and mapping knowledge (knowing the relative magnitude of the targets) to gain further insights into the nature of G-I transfer. Whereas previous research found evidence that G-I transfer improves group members' metric knowledge, there is, so far, no evidence that group discussion also improves mapping knowledge. Using a multicue judgment task, we tested whether group members would benefit from G-I-transfer and, if so, whether this G-I transfer would manifest in the form of improved mapping knowledge. The results of two experiments suggest that this is the case. Participants who worked in real interacting groups outperformed participants who worked individually, and this increase in accuracy was accompanied not only by improved metric but also by increased mapping knowledge. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).