Mario Gliozzi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Mario Gliozzi has a total of 97 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nathan J. Secrest
U.S. Naval Observatory
11 shared publications - Shobita Satyapal
George Mason University
8 shared publications - Claudio Ricci
Department of Astronomy, University of Geneva
7 shared publications - Ryan W. Pfeifle
X-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Code 662, Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA
7 shared publications - Laura Blecha
University of Florida
6 shared publications - Barry Rothberg
Department of Physics and Astronomy, George Mason University, 4400 University Drive, MSN 3F3, Fairfax, VA 22030, USA
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1005 (1) , 40
A Compton Reverberation Model for the Production of X-Ray Time Lags from Coupled Bursts in Black Hole Accretion Disks
X-ray Fourier time lags detected from accreting black holes in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) provide important glimpses into the high-energy processes occurring near the event horizon. For many narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxies, the lag–frequency distribution displays multiple sign changes, indicating several transitions between hard and soft time lags. We develop a new Compton reverberation model that can reproduce the observed time lag distributions for multiple NLS1 galaxies, based on the Compton reprocessing of iron K and L seed photons that are injected in two coupled bursts occurring at different radii in the disk. The variability is driven by transient high-energy emission generated by the Compton upscattering in the hot corona of soft thermal photons produced in the cool outer region of the accretion disk. The two bursts of K and L seed photons are linked by a pressure wave that propagates outward and deposits its energy near the standing shock at the outer boundary of the hot inner region, triggering the second burst. The new model is based on a Fourier-transformed, vertically averaged radiation transport equation. We use our new model to analyze and interpret the observational time lag data for the NLS1 galaxies 1H 0707−495, Ark 564, NGC 4051, and Mrk 766. We demonstrate that the incorporation of a second seed photon burst allows our model to accurately reproduce the time lag data for several AGNs that display complex time lag patterns, including multiple sign changes. We also discuss the physical scenario for connecting the two coupled bursts.
- 23 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1005 (1) , 40
Open AccessA Compton Reverberation Model for the Production of X-Ray Time Lags from Coupled Bursts in Black Hole Accretion Disks
X-ray Fourier time lags detected from accreting black holes in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) provide important glimpses into the high-energy processes occurring near the event horizon. For many narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxies, the lag–frequency distribution displays multiple sign changes, indicating several transitions between hard and soft time lags. We develop a new Compton reverberation model that can reproduce the observed time lag distributions for multiple NLS1 galaxies, based on the Compton reprocessing of iron K and L seed photons that are injected in two coupled bursts occurring at different radii in the disk. The variability is driven by transient high-energy emission generated by the Compton upscattering in the hot corona of soft thermal photons produced in the cool outer region of the accretion disk. The two bursts of K and L seed photons are linked by a pressure wave that propagates outward and deposits its energy near the standing shock at the outer boundary of the hot inner region, triggering the second burst. The new model is based on a Fourier-transformed, vertically averaged radiation transport equation. We use our new model to analyze and interpret the observational time lag data for the NLS1 galaxies 1H 0707−495, Ark 564, NGC 4051, and Mrk 766. We demonstrate that the incorporation of a second seed photon burst allows our model to accurately reproduce the time lag data for several AGNs that display complex time lag patterns, including multiple sign changes. We also discuss the physical scenario for connecting the two coupled bursts.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 699, A202
Measuring monster black hole masses: Maybe mighty, maybe merely massive
Context. Accurate black hole mass (MBH) measurements in high-redshift galaxies are difficult yet crucial to constrain the growth of supermassive BHs, and to discriminate between competing BH seed models. Recent studies claimed the detection of massive BHs in very distant AGN, implying extreme conditions. However, these estimates are usually obtained by extrapolating indirect methods that are calibrated for moderately accreting, low-luminosity AGN in the local universe. Aims. We want to assess the reliability of the single epoch method (SE) in the distant universe. Methods. We computed the MBH values for a sample of hyperluminous distant quasars (the X-WISSH sample) and a sample of highly accreting AGN (X-HESS) using the X-ray scaling method. Results. We first verified that the X-ray scaling method yields reliable MBH values also for distant highly accreting objects. Then, we carried out a systematic comparison with the SE method and found that these two indirect methods are fully consistent over a broad range of luminosities, intrinsic absorption, and accretion rates. The only discrepancies were associated with AGN that are substantially absorbed (underestimated by the SE method) and AGN accreting well above the Eddington limit (overestimated by the SE method). The latter result casts some doubts on the claim of overmassive BHs in highly accreting AGN in the early universe. Our study also reveals that one of the frequently used AGN catalogs consistently underestimates MBH by a factor of 2.5. Although this factor is on the order of the uncertainty associated with the SE method, we demonstrated that using these underestimated values can result in potentially misleading conclusions. Specifically, for this AGN sample we confirmed strong positive correlations for Γ versus λEdd, for the X-ray bolometric correction versus λEdd, and for Γ versus the soft excess strength, at odds with the conclusions inferred using underestimated MBH values.
- 9 July 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 699, A202
Open AccessMeasuring monster black hole masses: Maybe mighty, maybe merely massive
Context. Accurate black hole mass (MBH) measurements in high-redshift galaxies are difficult yet crucial to constrain the growth of supermassive BHs, and to discriminate between competing BH seed models. Recent studies claimed the detection of massive BHs in very distant AGN, implying extreme conditions. However, these estimates are usually obtained by extrapolating indirect methods that are calibrated for moderately accreting, low-luminosity AGN in the local universe. Aims. We want to assess the reliability of the single epoch method (SE) in the distant universe. Methods. We computed the MBH values for a sample of hyperluminous distant quasars (the X-WISSH sample) and a sample of highly accreting AGN (X-HESS) using the X-ray scaling method. Results. We first verified that the X-ray scaling method yields reliable MBH values also for distant highly accreting objects. Then, we carried out a systematic comparison with the SE method and found that these two indirect methods are fully consistent over a broad range of luminosities, intrinsic absorption, and accretion rates. The only discrepancies were associated with AGN that are substantially absorbed (underestimated by the SE method) and AGN accreting well above the Eddington limit (overestimated by the SE method). The latter result casts some doubts on the claim of overmassive BHs in highly accreting AGN in the early universe. Our study also reveals that one of the frequently used AGN catalogs consistently underestimates MBH by a factor of 2.5. Although this factor is on the order of the uncertainty associated with the SE method, we demonstrated that using these underestimated values can result in potentially misleading conclusions. Specifically, for this AGN sample we confirmed strong positive correlations for Γ versus λEdd, for the X-ray bolometric correction versus λEdd, and for Γ versus the soft excess strength, at odds with the conclusions inferred using underestimated MBH values.
- Open Access
- 24 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 961 (2) , 178
Exploring X-Ray Properties of Low-metallicity Dwarf Galaxies
One of the primary outstanding questions in extragalactic astronomy is the formation and early evolution of the supermassive black holes that are seen in nearly every massive galaxy. Low-metallicity dwarf galaxies may offer the most representative local analogs to pristine early galaxies, making them a vital tool in probing black hole seed models through the study of the intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs) possibly hosted therein; though these dwarf galaxies, and the IMBHs they may host, are typically not as well-studied in this context as their higher-metallicity and higher-mass counterparts. In this paper, we explore the X-ray properties of a sample of 37 low-metallicity dwarf galaxies using archival XMM observations, and we compare the properties of this population against a representative sample of higher-metallicity counterparts. We report the detection of 10 sources with 0.3–10 keV luminosity in excess of 1040 erg s−1 within the low-metallicity sample, which we highlight for followup as potential IMBH candidates. Finally, we discuss the differing multiwavelength scaling relations (e.g., L X–L W2, L X–star formation rate) between the two galaxy populations, as well as the sample’s L X as a function of metallicity.
- 24 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 961 (2) , 178
Open AccessExploring X-Ray Properties of Low-metallicity Dwarf Galaxies
One of the primary outstanding questions in extragalactic astronomy is the formation and early evolution of the supermassive black holes that are seen in nearly every massive galaxy. Low-metallicity dwarf galaxies may offer the most representative local analogs to pristine early galaxies, making them a vital tool in probing black hole seed models through the study of the intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs) possibly hosted therein; though these dwarf galaxies, and the IMBHs they may host, are typically not as well-studied in this context as their higher-metallicity and higher-mass counterparts. In this paper, we explore the X-ray properties of a sample of 37 low-metallicity dwarf galaxies using archival XMM observations, and we compare the properties of this population against a representative sample of higher-metallicity counterparts. We report the detection of 10 sources with 0.3–10 keV luminosity in excess of 1040 erg s−1 within the low-metallicity sample, which we highlight for followup as potential IMBH candidates. Finally, we discuss the differing multiwavelength scaling relations (e.g., L X–L W2, L X–star formation rate) between the two galaxy populations, as well as the sample’s L X as a function of metallicity.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 961 (1) , 109
FRAMEx. V. Radio Spectral Shape at Central Subparsec Region of Active Galactic Nuclei
We present results from the Very Long Baseline Array multifrequency (1.6, 4.4, 8.6, and 22 GHz), high-sensitivity (∼25 μJy beam−1), subparsec-scale (42 erg s−1, out to a distance of 40 Mpc. All 12 of the sources presented here were detected in the C (4.4 GHz) and X (8.6 GHz) bands, 75% in the L band (1.6 GHz), and 50% in the K band (22 GHz). Most sources showed compact, resolved/slightly resolved, central subparsec-scale radio morphology, except for a few with extended outflow-like features. A couple of sources have an additional component that may indicate the presence of a dual-core, single or double-sided jet or a more intricate feature, such as radio emission resulting from interaction with the nearby interstellar medium. The spectral slopes are mostly gigahertz-peaked or curved, with a few showing steep, flat, or inverted spectra. We found that at the subparsec scale, the gigahertz-peaked spectra belong to the low-accreting, radio-loud AGNs, with a tendency to produce strong outflows, possibly small-scale jets, and/or have a coronal origin. In contrast, flat/inverted spectra suggest compact radio emission from the central regions of highly accreting AGNs, possibly associated with radio-quiet AGNs producing winds/shocks or nuclear star formation in the vicinity of black holes.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 961 (1) , 109
Open AccessFRAMEx. V. Radio Spectral Shape at Central Subparsec Region of Active Galactic Nuclei
We present results from the Very Long Baseline Array multifrequency (1.6, 4.4, 8.6, and 22 GHz), high-sensitivity (∼25 μJy beam−1), subparsec-scale (42 erg s−1, out to a distance of 40 Mpc. All 12 of the sources presented here were detected in the C (4.4 GHz) and X (8.6 GHz) bands, 75% in the L band (1.6 GHz), and 50% in the K band (22 GHz). Most sources showed compact, resolved/slightly resolved, central subparsec-scale radio morphology, except for a few with extended outflow-like features. A couple of sources have an additional component that may indicate the presence of a dual-core, single or double-sided jet or a more intricate feature, such as radio emission resulting from interaction with the nearby interstellar medium. The spectral slopes are mostly gigahertz-peaked or curved, with a few showing steep, flat, or inverted spectra. We found that at the subparsec scale, the gigahertz-peaked spectra belong to the low-accreting, radio-loud AGNs, with a tendency to produce strong outflows, possibly small-scale jets, and/or have a coronal origin. In contrast, flat/inverted spectra suggest compact radio emission from the central regions of highly accreting AGNs, possibly associated with radio-quiet AGNs producing winds/shocks or nuclear star formation in the vicinity of black holes.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 528 (2) , 3417-3432
Comparing indirect methods for black hole masses in AGN: the good, the bad, and the ugly
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected sample of AGN to compare the reliability of some commonly used indirect methods, emphasising those that can be applied to obscured AGN. Based on a subsample of AGN with MBH determined via dynamical methods, our study suggests that X-ray based techniques, such as the scaling method and the one based on the variability measured through the excess variance, are in good agreement with the dynamical methods. On the other hand, the M − σ⋆ correlation based on inactive galaxies tends to systematically overestimate MBH, regardless of the level of obscuration. We provide a correcting factor that produces an acceptable agreement with dynamical values and can be used to quickly correct the MBH computed with this method. We also derive an alternative M − σ⋆ correlation based on this unbiased sample of AGN with a slope considerably shallower than the ones obtained using inactive galaxies, suggesting that the latter may not be appropriate to compute the MBH in AGN. Finally, we find that no quick fix can be applied to correct the MBH obtained from the fundamental plane of black hole activity, casting doubts on the reliability of this method.
- 23 December 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 528 (2) , 3417-3432
Open AccessComparing indirect methods for black hole masses in AGN: the good, the bad, and the ugly
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected sample of AGN to compare the reliability of some commonly used indirect methods, emphasising those that can be applied to obscured AGN. Based on a subsample of AGN with MBH determined via dynamical methods, our study suggests that X-ray based techniques, such as the scaling method and the one based on the variability measured through the excess variance, are in good agreement with the dynamical methods. On the other hand, the M − σ⋆ correlation based on inactive galaxies tends to systematically overestimate MBH, regardless of the level of obscuration. We provide a correcting factor that produces an acceptable agreement with dynamical values and can be used to quickly correct the MBH computed with this method. We also derive an alternative M − σ⋆ correlation based on this unbiased sample of AGN with a slope considerably shallower than the ones obtained using inactive galaxies, suggesting that the latter may not be appropriate to compute the MBH in AGN. Finally, we find that no quick fix can be applied to correct the MBH obtained from the fundamental plane of black hole activity, casting doubts on the reliability of this method.
- Open Access
Comparing indirect methods for black hole masses in AGN: the good, the bad, and the ugly
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected sample of AGN to compare the reliability of some commonly used indirect methods, emphasising those that can be applied to obscured AGN. Based on a subsample of AGN with MBH determined via dynamical methods, our study suggests that X-ray based techniques, such as the scaling method and the one based on the variability measured through the excess variance, are in good agreement with the dynamical methods. On the other hand, the M-sigma correlation based on inactive galaxies tends to systematically overestimate MBH, regardless of the level of obscuration. We provide a correcting factor that produces an acceptable agreement with dynamical values and can be used to quickly correct the MBH computed with this method. We also derive an alternative M-sigma correlation based on this unbiased sample of AGN with a slope considerably shallower than the ones obtained using inactive galaxies, suggesting that the latter correlation may not be appropriate to compute the MBH in AGN. Finally, we find that no quick fix can be applied to correct the MBH obtained from the fundamental plane of black hole activity, casting doubts on the reliability of this method.
Open AccessComparing indirect methods for black hole masses in AGN: the good, the bad, and the ugly
The black hole mass MBH is crucial in constraining the growth of supermassive BHs within their host galaxies. Since direct measurements of MBH with dynamical methods are restricted to a limited number of nearly quiescent nearby galaxies and a small minority of active galactic nuclei (AGN), we must rely on indirect methods. In this work, we utilize an unbiased, volume-limited, hard X-ray selected sample of AGN to compare the reliability of some commonly used indirect methods, emphasising those that can be applied to obscured AGN. Based on a subsample of AGN with MBH determined via dynamical methods, our study suggests that X-ray based techniques, such as the scaling method and the one based on the variability measured through the excess variance, are in good agreement with the dynamical methods. On the other hand, the M-sigma correlation based on inactive galaxies tends to systematically overestimate MBH, regardless of the level of obscuration. We provide a correcting factor that produces an acceptable agreement with dynamical values and can be used to quickly correct the MBH computed with this method. We also derive an alternative M-sigma correlation based on this unbiased sample of AGN with a slope considerably shallower than the ones obtained using inactive galaxies, suggesting that the latter correlation may not be appropriate to compute the MBH in AGN. Finally, we find that no quick fix can be applied to correct the MBH obtained from the fundamental plane of black hole activity, casting doubts on the reliability of this method.
- Open Access
- 28 August 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 954 (2) , 116
NuSTAR Observations of Four Mid-IR–Selected Dual AGN Candidates in Galaxy Mergers
Mergers of galaxies are a ubiquitous phenomenon in the universe and represent a natural consequence of the “bottom-up” mass accumulation and galaxy evolution cosmological paradigm. It is generally accepted that the peak of active galactic nucleus (AGN) accretion activity occurs at nuclear separations of ≲10 kpc for major mergers. Here we present new NuSTAR and XMM-Newton observations for a subsample of mid-IR preselected dual AGN candidates in an effort to better constrain the column densities along the line of sight (LOS) for each system. Only one dual AGN candidate, J0841+0101, is detected as a single, unresolved source in the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR imaging, while the remaining three dual AGN candidates, J0122+0100, J1221+1137, and J1306+0735, are not detected with NuSTAR; if these nondetections are due to obscuration alone, these systems are consistent with being absorbed by column densities of log(N H/cm−2) ≥ 24.9, 24.6, and 24.3, which are roughly consistent with previously inferred column densities in these merging systems. In the case of J0841+0101, the analysis of the 0.3–30 keV spectra reveal an LOS column density of N H ≳ 1024 cm−2, significantly larger than the column densities previously reported for this system and demonstrating the importance of the higher signal-to-noise ratio XMM-Newton spectra and access to the >10 keV energies via NuSTAR. Though it is unclear if J0841+0101 truly hosts a dual AGN, these results are in agreement with the high obscuring columns expected in AGNs in late-stage mergers.
- 28 August 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 954 (2) , 116
Open AccessNuSTAR Observations of Four Mid-IR–Selected Dual AGN Candidates in Galaxy Mergers
Mergers of galaxies are a ubiquitous phenomenon in the universe and represent a natural consequence of the “bottom-up” mass accumulation and galaxy evolution cosmological paradigm. It is generally accepted that the peak of active galactic nucleus (AGN) accretion activity occurs at nuclear separations of ≲10 kpc for major mergers. Here we present new NuSTAR and XMM-Newton observations for a subsample of mid-IR preselected dual AGN candidates in an effort to better constrain the column densities along the line of sight (LOS) for each system. Only one dual AGN candidate, J0841+0101, is detected as a single, unresolved source in the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR imaging, while the remaining three dual AGN candidates, J0122+0100, J1221+1137, and J1306+0735, are not detected with NuSTAR; if these nondetections are due to obscuration alone, these systems are consistent with being absorbed by column densities of log(N H/cm−2) ≥ 24.9, 24.6, and 24.3, which are roughly consistent with previously inferred column densities in these merging systems. In the case of J0841+0101, the analysis of the 0.3–30 keV spectra reveal an LOS column density of N H ≳ 1024 cm−2, significantly larger than the column densities previously reported for this system and demonstrating the importance of the higher signal-to-noise ratio XMM-Newton spectra and access to the >10 keV energies via NuSTAR. Though it is unclear if J0841+0101 truly hosts a dual AGN, these results are in agreement with the high obscuring columns expected in AGNs in late-stage mergers.
- Open Access
NuSTAR Observations of Four Mid-IR Selected Dual AGN Candidates in Galaxy Mergers
Mergers of galaxies are a ubiquitous phenomenon in the Universe and represent a natural consequence of the ``bottom-up'' mass accumulation and galaxy evolution cosmological paradigm. It is generally accepted that the peak of AGN accretion activity occurs at nuclear separations of $\lesssim10$ kpc for major mergers. Here we present new NuSTAR and XMM-Newton observations for a subsample of mid-IR preselected dual AGN candidates in an effort to better constrain the column densities along the line-of-sight for each system. Only one dual AGN candidate, J0841+0101, is detected as a single, unresolved source in the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR imaging, while the remaining three dual AGN candidates, J0122+0100, J1221+1137, and J1306+0735, are not detected with NuSTAR; if these non-detections are due to obscuration alone, these systems are consistent with being absorbed by column densities of log($N_{\rm{H}}/\rm{cm}^{-2}$) $\geq$ 24.9, 24.8, and 24.6, which are roughly consistent with previously inferred column densities in these merging systems. In the case of J0841+0101, the analysis of the 0.3-30 keV spectra reveal a line-of-sight column density of $N_{\rm{H}}\gtrsim10^{24}$ cm$^{-2}$, significantly larger than the column densities previously reported for this system and demonstrating the importance of the higher signal-to-noise XMM-Newton spectra and access to the $>10$ keV energies via NuSTAR. Though it is unclear if J0841+0101 truly hosts a dual AGN, these results are in agreement with the high obscuring columns expected in AGNs in late-stage mergers.Open AccessNuSTAR Observations of Four Mid-IR Selected Dual AGN Candidates in Galaxy Mergers
Mergers of galaxies are a ubiquitous phenomenon in the Universe and represent a natural consequence of the ``bottom-up'' mass accumulation and galaxy evolution cosmological paradigm. It is generally accepted that the peak of AGN accretion activity occurs at nuclear separations of $\lesssim10$ kpc for major mergers. Here we present new NuSTAR and XMM-Newton observations for a subsample of mid-IR preselected dual AGN candidates in an effort to better constrain the column densities along the line-of-sight for each system. Only one dual AGN candidate, J0841+0101, is detected as a single, unresolved source in the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR imaging, while the remaining three dual AGN candidates, J0122+0100, J1221+1137, and J1306+0735, are not detected with NuSTAR; if these non-detections are due to obscuration alone, these systems are consistent with being absorbed by column densities of log($N_{\rm{H}}/\rm{cm}^{-2}$) $\geq$ 24.9, 24.8, and 24.6, which are roughly consistent with previously inferred column densities in these merging systems. In the case of J0841+0101, the analysis of the 0.3-30 keV spectra reveal a line-of-sight column density of $N_{\rm{H}}\gtrsim10^{24}$ cm$^{-2}$, significantly larger than the column densities previously reported for this system and demonstrating the importance of the higher signal-to-noise XMM-Newton spectra and access to the $>10$ keV energies via NuSTAR. Though it is unclear if J0841+0101 truly hosts a dual AGN, these results are in agreement with the high obscuring columns expected in AGNs in late-stage mergers. - 10 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 521 (2) , 2897-2910
Assessing indirect methods to determine black hole masses using NGC 4151
Accurately determining the black hole mass (MBH) in active galactic nuclei (AGN) is crucial to constraining their properties and to studying their evolution. While direct methods yield reliable measurements of MBH in unobscured type 1 AGN, where the dynamics of stellar or gas components can be directly observed, only indirect methods can be applied to the vast majority of heavily absorbed type 2 AGN, which represent most of the AGN population. Since it is difficult to evaluate the accuracy and precision of these indirect methods, we utilize the nearby X-ray bright Seyfert galaxy NGC 4151, whose MBH has been tightly constrained with several independent direct methods, as a laboratory to assess the reliability of three indirect methods that have been applied to obscured AGN. All three, the X-ray scaling method, the fundamental plane of black hole activity, and the M–σ correlation, yield MBH values consistent with those inferred from direct methods and can therefore be considered accurate. However, only the X-ray scaling method and the M–σ correlation are precise because the substantial scatter in the fundamental plane of BH activity allows only for crude estimates. Of the four M–σ correlations we used, only the one from Kormendy and Ho yields a value consistent with the dynamical estimates. This study suggests that the best approach to estimating the black hole mass in systems where direct dynamical methods cannot be applied is to utilize a combination of indirect methods, taking into account their different ranges of applicability.
- 10 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 521 (2) , 2897-2910
Assessing indirect methods to determine black hole masses using NGC 4151
Accurately determining the black hole mass (MBH) in active galactic nuclei (AGN) is crucial to constraining their properties and to studying their evolution. While direct methods yield reliable measurements of MBH in unobscured type 1 AGN, where the dynamics of stellar or gas components can be directly observed, only indirect methods can be applied to the vast majority of heavily absorbed type 2 AGN, which represent most of the AGN population. Since it is difficult to evaluate the accuracy and precision of these indirect methods, we utilize the nearby X-ray bright Seyfert galaxy NGC 4151, whose MBH has been tightly constrained with several independent direct methods, as a laboratory to assess the reliability of three indirect methods that have been applied to obscured AGN. All three, the X-ray scaling method, the fundamental plane of black hole activity, and the M–σ correlation, yield MBH values consistent with those inferred from direct methods and can therefore be considered accurate. However, only the X-ray scaling method and the M–σ correlation are precise because the substantial scatter in the fundamental plane of BH activity allows only for crude estimates. Of the four M–σ correlations we used, only the one from Kormendy and Ho yields a value consistent with the dynamical estimates. This study suggests that the best approach to estimating the black hole mass in systems where direct dynamical methods cannot be applied is to utilize a combination of indirect methods, taking into account their different ranges of applicability.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 943 (2) , 109
NuSTAR Observes Two Bulgeless Galaxies: No Hard X-Ray AGN Detected in NGC 4178 or J0851+3926
The discovery over the last several decades of low- and moderate-luminosity active galactic nuclei (AGNs) in disk-dominated galaxies—which show no “classical” bulges—suggests that secular mechanisms represent an important growth pathway for supermassive black holes in these systems. We present new follow-up NuSTAR observations of the optically elusive AGNs in two bulgeless galaxies, NGC 4178 and J0851+3926. Galaxy NGC 4178 was originally reported as hosting an AGN based on the detection of [Ne v] mid-infrared emission detected by Spitzer, and based on Chandra X-ray imaging, it has since been argued to host either a heavily obscured AGN or a supernova remnant. Galaxy J0851+3926 was originally identified as an AGN based on its Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer mid-IR colors, and follow-up near-infrared spectroscopy previously revealed a hidden broad-line region, offering compelling evidence for an optically elusive AGN. Neither AGN is detected within the new NuSTAR imaging, and we derive upper limits on the hard X-ray 10–24 keV fluxes of −14 and 24.2 and 24.1, respectively. The nature of the nuclear activity in NGC 4178 remains inconclusive; it is plausible that the [Ne v] traces a period of higher activity in the past, but that the AGN is relatively quiescent now. The nondetection in J0851+3926 and multiwavelength properties are consistent with the AGN being heavily obscured.
- 31 January 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 943 (2) , 109
Open AccessNuSTAR Observes Two Bulgeless Galaxies: No Hard X-Ray AGN Detected in NGC 4178 or J0851+3926
The discovery over the last several decades of low- and moderate-luminosity active galactic nuclei (AGNs) in disk-dominated galaxies—which show no “classical” bulges—suggests that secular mechanisms represent an important growth pathway for supermassive black holes in these systems. We present new follow-up NuSTAR observations of the optically elusive AGNs in two bulgeless galaxies, NGC 4178 and J0851+3926. Galaxy NGC 4178 was originally reported as hosting an AGN based on the detection of [Ne v] mid-infrared emission detected by Spitzer, and based on Chandra X-ray imaging, it has since been argued to host either a heavily obscured AGN or a supernova remnant. Galaxy J0851+3926 was originally identified as an AGN based on its Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer mid-IR colors, and follow-up near-infrared spectroscopy previously revealed a hidden broad-line region, offering compelling evidence for an optically elusive AGN. Neither AGN is detected within the new NuSTAR imaging, and we derive upper limits on the hard X-ray 10–24 keV fluxes of −14 and 24.2 and 24.1, respectively. The nature of the nuclear activity in NGC 4178 remains inconclusive; it is plausible that the [Ne v] traces a period of higher activity in the past, but that the AGN is relatively quiescent now. The nondetection in J0851+3926 and multiwavelength properties are consistent with the AGN being heavily obscured.