Randolph Martin Nesse
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Randolph Martin Nesse has a total of 250 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
George C. Curtis
Department of Psychiatry and Mental Health Research Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
19 shared publicationsOliver G. Cameron
Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan Medical Center, Ann Arbor 48109-0722, USA
12 shared publications- Daniel Joseph Stein
University of Cape Town
9 shared publications James L. Abelson
9 shared publications- Bruce A. Thyer
Florida State University
7 shared publications - Eiko I. Fried
Department of Clinical Psychology, Leiden University, Leiden, Netherlands
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 March 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 4 (4) , pgaf086
Explanations for failures in designed and evolved systems
Engineers have long studied the origins of design features that make machines prone to failure, but biologists have only recently begun investigating why organisms have traits that make them susceptible to disease. This article compares explanations for vulnerability to failure in machines with explanations for traits that make bodies vulnerable to disease. Some global explanations are relevant for both: design deficiencies, corrupted plans, assembly variations, incorrect operating environment, and trade-offs. These similarities suggest that a common framework for failure analysis could be valuable. However, a closer look at each of the 10 global categories reveals fundamental differences: machines are built to match an ideal blueprint, while species have no perfect genome or form. Design trade-offs in machines involve balancing multiple factors such as performance, robustness, and costs, while biological trade-offs maximize only gene transmission, often at the expense of health and lifespan. Detailed consideration of these and other differences reveals how the metaphor of body as a designed machine fosters tacit creationism that misrepresents the nature of organically complex systems.
- 27 March 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 4 (4) , pgaf086
Open AccessExplanations for failures in designed and evolved systems
Engineers have long studied the origins of design features that make machines prone to failure, but biologists have only recently begun investigating why organisms have traits that make them susceptible to disease. This article compares explanations for vulnerability to failure in machines with explanations for traits that make bodies vulnerable to disease. Some global explanations are relevant for both: design deficiencies, corrupted plans, assembly variations, incorrect operating environment, and trade-offs. These similarities suggest that a common framework for failure analysis could be valuable. However, a closer look at each of the 10 global categories reveals fundamental differences: machines are built to match an ideal blueprint, while species have no perfect genome or form. Design trade-offs in machines involve balancing multiple factors such as performance, robustness, and costs, while biological trade-offs maximize only gene transmission, often at the expense of health and lifespan. Detailed consideration of these and other differences reveals how the metaphor of body as a designed machine fosters tacit creationism that misrepresents the nature of organically complex systems.
- Open Access
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 61 (5) , e70028
Tacit Creationism Encourages Oversimplified Views of Functions and Dysfunctions
Notions of function and dysfunction are fundamental for neuroscience, psychology and psychiatry but remain contentious. We propose that some of these controversies arise from ‘tacit creationism’, which disavows a designer but nonetheless views bodies and brain‐minds as if they are products of conscious planning with discrete parts that serve specific functions. Many philosophers agree that ‘failure to perform a normal function’ is fundamental to the concepts of physical disease and mental disorder. However, unlike machines and computers, no blueprint defines a single normal phenotype for bodies and brain‐minds. Instead, varying genes interact with one another and environments to create individuals who vary in ways that give advantages and disadvantages that depend on the environment. Many clinically relevant variations influence the gain in control systems for adaptive responses such as anxiety and low mood, making it difficult to draw a bright line between normal and excessive activation of distressing emotions in a particular context. Literal interpretations of the metaphor of body as machine or brain‐mind as computer encourage essentializing normality and pathology—expecting functions to be as specific as those for parts of machine and dysfunctions to involve discrete anatomo‐physiological or molecular defects corresponding to broken parts. Rejecting tacit creationism, and accepting the messy reality of organic complexity, the fuzzy boundaries of disorders and the multiple difference‐makers that contribute to pathogenesis offers a better way forward for neuroscience, psychology and psychiatry.
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 61 (5) , e70028
Open AccessTacit Creationism Encourages Oversimplified Views of Functions and Dysfunctions
Notions of function and dysfunction are fundamental for neuroscience, psychology and psychiatry but remain contentious. We propose that some of these controversies arise from ‘tacit creationism’, which disavows a designer but nonetheless views bodies and brain‐minds as if they are products of conscious planning with discrete parts that serve specific functions. Many philosophers agree that ‘failure to perform a normal function’ is fundamental to the concepts of physical disease and mental disorder. However, unlike machines and computers, no blueprint defines a single normal phenotype for bodies and brain‐minds. Instead, varying genes interact with one another and environments to create individuals who vary in ways that give advantages and disadvantages that depend on the environment. Many clinically relevant variations influence the gain in control systems for adaptive responses such as anxiety and low mood, making it difficult to draw a bright line between normal and excessive activation of distressing emotions in a particular context. Literal interpretations of the metaphor of body as machine or brain‐mind as computer encourage essentializing normality and pathology—expecting functions to be as specific as those for parts of machine and dysfunctions to involve discrete anatomo‐physiological or molecular defects corresponding to broken parts. Rejecting tacit creationism, and accepting the messy reality of organic complexity, the fuzzy boundaries of disorders and the multiple difference‐makers that contribute to pathogenesis offers a better way forward for neuroscience, psychology and psychiatry.
- 5 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 443-483
Evolutionary Psychiatry
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health
- Vol. 11 (1) , 353-362
The EvMed Assessment
Universities throughout the United States increasingly offer undergraduate courses in Evolutionary Medicine (EvMed), which creates a need for pedagogical resources. Several resources offer course content (e.g., textbooks) and a previous study identified EvMed core principles to help instructors set learning goals. However, assessment tools are not yet available. In this study, we address this need by developing an assessment that measures students’ ability to apply EvMed core principles to various health-related scenarios. The EvMed Assessment (EMA) consists of questions containing a short description of a health-related scenario followed by several likely/unlikely items. We evaluated the assessment’s validity and reliability using a variety of qualitative (expert reviews, student interviews) and quantitative (Cronbach’s α, Classical Test Theory) methods. We iteratively revised the assessment through several rounds of validation. We then administered the assessment to undergraduates in EvMed and Evolution courses at multiple institutions. We used results from the pilot to create the EMA final draft. After conducting quantitative validation, we deleted items that failed to meet performance criteria and revised items that exhibited borderline performance. The final version of the EMA consists of six core questions containing 25 items, and five supplemental questions containing 20 items. The EMA is a pedagogical tool supported by a wide range of validation evidence. Instructors can use it as a pre/post measure of student learning in an EvMed course to inform curriculum revision, or as a test bank to draw upon when developing in-class assessments, quizzes, or exams.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health
- Vol. 11 (1) , 353-362
Open AccessThe EvMed Assessment
Universities throughout the United States increasingly offer undergraduate courses in Evolutionary Medicine (EvMed), which creates a need for pedagogical resources. Several resources offer course content (e.g., textbooks) and a previous study identified EvMed core principles to help instructors set learning goals. However, assessment tools are not yet available. In this study, we address this need by developing an assessment that measures students’ ability to apply EvMed core principles to various health-related scenarios. The EvMed Assessment (EMA) consists of questions containing a short description of a health-related scenario followed by several likely/unlikely items. We evaluated the assessment’s validity and reliability using a variety of qualitative (expert reviews, student interviews) and quantitative (Cronbach’s α, Classical Test Theory) methods. We iteratively revised the assessment through several rounds of validation. We then administered the assessment to undergraduates in EvMed and Evolution courses at multiple institutions. We used results from the pilot to create the EMA final draft. After conducting quantitative validation, we deleted items that failed to meet performance criteria and revised items that exhibited borderline performance. The final version of the EMA consists of six core questions containing 25 items, and five supplemental questions containing 20 items. The EMA is a pedagogical tool supported by a wide range of validation evidence. Instructors can use it as a pre/post measure of student learning in an EvMed course to inform curriculum revision, or as a test bank to draw upon when developing in-class assessments, quizzes, or exams.
- Open Access
- 14 December 2021
- Published by AOSIS in South African Journal of Psychiatry
- Vol. 27, 2
Review of Problems of Living: Perspectives from Philosophy, Psychiatry and Cognitive-Affective Science
The South African Journal of Psychiatry publishes topical content in psychiatry for clinical practice and academic pursuits, including work in the subspecialty areas of psychiatry.
- 14 December 2021
- Published by AOSIS in South African Journal of Psychiatry
- Vol. 27, 2
Open AccessReview of Problems of Living: Perspectives from Philosophy, Psychiatry and Cognitive-Affective Science
The South African Journal of Psychiatry publishes topical content in psychiatry for clinical practice and academic pursuits, including work in the subspecialty areas of psychiatry.
- 1 October 2019
- Published by University of California Press in The American Biology Teacher
- Vol. 81 (8) , 533
Evolutionary Medicine – A Great Way to Teach Biology
- 1 October 2019
- Published by University of California Press in The American Biology Teacher
- Vol. 81 (8) , 533
Evolutionary Medicine – A Great Way to Teach Biology
- Open Access
- 23 September 2019
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 374 (1785) , 20190288
An evolutionary medicine perspective on pain and its disorders
Enormous progress in understanding the mechanisms that mediate pain can be augmented by an evolutionary medicine perspective on how the capacity for pain gives selective advantages, the trade-offs that shaped the mechanisms, and evolutionary explanations for the system's vulnerability to excessive and chronic pain. Syndromes of deficient pain document tragically the utility of pain to motivate escape from and avoidance of situations causing tissue damage. Much apparently excessive pain is actually normal because the cost of more pain is often vastly less than the cost of too little pain (the smoke detector principle). Vulnerability to pathological pain may be explained in part because natural selection has shaped mechanisms that respond adaptively to repeated tissue damage by decreasing the pain threshold and increasing pain salience. The other half of an evolutionary approach describes the phylogeny of pain mechanisms; the apparent independence of different kinds of pain is of special interest. Painful mental states such as anxiety, guilt and low mood may have evolved from physical pain precursors. Preliminary evidence for this is found in anatomic and genetic data. Such insights from evolutionary medicine may help in understanding vulnerability to chronic pain. This article is part of the Theo Murphy meeting issue ‘Evolution of mechanisms and behaviour important for pain’.
- 23 September 2019
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 374 (1785) , 20190288
Open AccessAn evolutionary medicine perspective on pain and its disorders
Enormous progress in understanding the mechanisms that mediate pain can be augmented by an evolutionary medicine perspective on how the capacity for pain gives selective advantages, the trade-offs that shaped the mechanisms, and evolutionary explanations for the system's vulnerability to excessive and chronic pain. Syndromes of deficient pain document tragically the utility of pain to motivate escape from and avoidance of situations causing tissue damage. Much apparently excessive pain is actually normal because the cost of more pain is often vastly less than the cost of too little pain (the smoke detector principle). Vulnerability to pathological pain may be explained in part because natural selection has shaped mechanisms that respond adaptively to repeated tissue damage by decreasing the pain threshold and increasing pain salience. The other half of an evolutionary approach describes the phylogeny of pain mechanisms; the apparent independence of different kinds of pain is of special interest. Painful mental states such as anxiety, guilt and low mood may have evolved from physical pain precursors. Preliminary evidence for this is found in anatomic and genetic data. Such insights from evolutionary medicine may help in understanding vulnerability to chronic pain. This article is part of the Theo Murphy meeting issue ‘Evolution of mechanisms and behaviour important for pain’.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Dialogues in clinical neuroscience
- Vol. 21 (2) , 167-175
How evolutionary psychiatry can advance psychopharmacology
The prevailing paradigm for psychopharmacology focuses on understanding brain mechanisms as the key to finding new medications and improving clinical outcomes, but frustration with slow progress has inspired many pleas for new approaches. Evolutionary psychiatry brings in an additional basic science that poses new questions about why natural selection left us vulnerable to so many mental disorders, and new insights about how drugs work. The integration of neuroscience with evolutionary psychiatry is synergistic, going beyond reductionism to provide a model like the one used by the rest of medicine. It recognizes negative emotions as symptoms, that are, like pain and cough, useful defenses whose presence should initiate a search for causes. An integrative evolutionary approach explains why agents that block useful aversive responses are usually safe, and how to anticipate when they may cause harm. More generally, an evolutionary framework suggests novel practical strategies for finding and testing new drugs. .
- 30 June 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Dialogues in clinical neuroscience
- Vol. 21 (2) , 167-175
Open AccessHow evolutionary psychiatry can advance psychopharmacology
The prevailing paradigm for psychopharmacology focuses on understanding brain mechanisms as the key to finding new medications and improving clinical outcomes, but frustration with slow progress has inspired many pleas for new approaches. Evolutionary psychiatry brings in an additional basic science that poses new questions about why natural selection left us vulnerable to so many mental disorders, and new insights about how drugs work. The integration of neuroscience with evolutionary psychiatry is synergistic, going beyond reductionism to provide a model like the one used by the rest of medicine. It recognizes negative emotions as symptoms, that are, like pain and cough, useful defenses whose presence should initiate a search for causes. An integrative evolutionary approach explains why agents that block useful aversive responses are usually safe, and how to anticipate when they may cause harm. More generally, an evolutionary framework suggests novel practical strategies for finding and testing new drugs. .
- Open Access
- 1 January 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health
- Vol. 2019 (1) , 82-92
The state of evolutionary medicine in undergraduate education
Undergraduate courses that include evolutionary medicine (EM) are increasingly available, but quantified data about such courses are lacking. In this article, we describe relevant course offerings by institution and department type, in conjunction with information on the backgrounds and experiences of associated instructors. We searched course catalogs from 196 American universities to find courses that include EM, and sent a survey to 101 EM instructors to ask about their backgrounds and teaching experiences. Research-focused universities (R1) were much more likely to offer at least one course that covers evolutionary applications to health and disease than universities that granted only bachelor’s or master’s degrees. A survey course on EM was offered in 56% of 116 R1 universities, but only 2% of the 80 non-R1 universities we searched. Most EM instructors have backgrounds in anthropology or biology; each instructor’s area of expertise provides clues as to how continued growth of EM may occur differently by discipline. Undergraduates are most likely to learn about EM in research-intensive universities from an anthropological or biological perspective. Responses from anthropology and biology instructors, including whom they share course materials with, highlight that courses may differ depending on the discipline in which they are taught. Recognition of evolution’s relevance to understanding health and disease is growing, but documentation of coverage in undergraduate education is lacking. This study explores where evolutionary medicine (EM) content is taught across 196 undergraduate institutions and how 53 instructors describe their experiences teaching EM.
- 1 January 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health
- Vol. 2019 (1) , 82-92
Open AccessThe state of evolutionary medicine in undergraduate education
Undergraduate courses that include evolutionary medicine (EM) are increasingly available, but quantified data about such courses are lacking. In this article, we describe relevant course offerings by institution and department type, in conjunction with information on the backgrounds and experiences of associated instructors. We searched course catalogs from 196 American universities to find courses that include EM, and sent a survey to 101 EM instructors to ask about their backgrounds and teaching experiences. Research-focused universities (R1) were much more likely to offer at least one course that covers evolutionary applications to health and disease than universities that granted only bachelor’s or master’s degrees. A survey course on EM was offered in 56% of 116 R1 universities, but only 2% of the 80 non-R1 universities we searched. Most EM instructors have backgrounds in anthropology or biology; each instructor’s area of expertise provides clues as to how continued growth of EM may occur differently by discipline. Undergraduates are most likely to learn about EM in research-intensive universities from an anthropological or biological perspective. Responses from anthropology and biology instructors, including whom they share course materials with, highlight that courses may differ depending on the discipline in which they are taught. Recognition of evolution’s relevance to understanding health and disease is growing, but documentation of coverage in undergraduate education is lacking. This study explores where evolutionary medicine (EM) content is taught across 196 undergraduate institutions and how 53 instructors describe their experiences teaching EM.