Anja Giudici
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Anja Giudici has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Thomas Ruoss
Swiss Federal University for Vocational Education and Training, Switzerland
3 shared publications Anna Pultar
Heriot Watt University, UK
1 shared publicationJane Gingrich
Department of Politics and International Relations University of Oxford Oxford UK
1 shared publication- Jane Gingrich
University of Oxford
1 shared publication - Sarah Van Ruyskensvelde
KU Leuven, Belgium
1 shared publication - Susannah Wright
Oxford Brookes University, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 25 (1) , 3-13
Contested identities in Europe: Historical insights into the construction of citizenship education from the bottom up
Citizens need to be educated. However, both understandings of citizenship and the education required to disseminate them are inherently contested. After presenting an analytical framework that allows for a conceptually grounded analysis of such contestation, this introduction draws on the papers included in the special issue to identify three axes that have structured the debate around citizenship education in modern Europe: the roles of the state, of place, and of conflict versus consensus. In conclusion, we present the papers included in this special issue and consider their value in both showcasing the diversity of understandings of citizenship in contemporary Europe, as well as the issues that this diversity raises for education research.
- 17 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 25 (1) , 3-13
Open AccessContested identities in Europe: Historical insights into the construction of citizenship education from the bottom up
Citizens need to be educated. However, both understandings of citizenship and the education required to disseminate them are inherently contested. After presenting an analytical framework that allows for a conceptually grounded analysis of such contestation, this introduction draws on the papers included in the special issue to identify three axes that have structured the debate around citizenship education in modern Europe: the roles of the state, of place, and of conflict versus consensus. In conclusion, we present the papers included in this special issue and consider their value in both showcasing the diversity of understandings of citizenship in contemporary Europe, as well as the issues that this diversity raises for education research.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Political Research
- Vol. 64 (3) , 1276-1303
Who polarises? Who targets? Parties’ educational speech over the long run
How do political parties speak about education? While struggles over education played a foundational role in structuring modern partisan cleavages, scholars debate the extent to which parties still adopt distinct rhetorical stances on education. Existing data, however, is limited to studying broad public support or opposition to educational expansion, restricting both our empirical knowledge of the politicisation of education and our ability to theorise parties’ incentives to speak publicly about it. This paper provides the first systematic examination of the post‐war evolution of partisan rhetoric about education in advanced democracies. We develop a novel dataset ( Education Politics Dataset EPD) based on hand‐coded manifesto speech of the largest centre‐left and centre‐right parties for 20 countries in Europe and beyond, from 1950 to the present. The EPD distinguishes nine educational issues, grouped under the three fundamental policy dimensions of distribution, governance and curricular content. We theorise that parties use educational speech both to signal competence to a broader electorate and to signal credibility to a narrower base. The result is three distinct patterns of speech: consensual, differentially salient and polarised. Where education policies cross‐cut existing cleavages, parties devote similar attention to issues and adopt similar stances, creating a consensual pattern. We find this pattern for issues of participation and quality in education. Where education policies are universal but offer specific benefits to a partisan base, we find patterns of differential salience: some parties devote more rhetorical attention to the issue than others, but parties adopt common stances. We find this pattern for questions of spending and access. Finally, where education policies align with broader political cleavages and provide targeted electoral benefits to partisan bases, parties adopt distinct public stances leading to more polarised rhetoric. We find this pattern for issues related to academic tracking and traditional curricular content. In developing the first multidimensional theorisation and measurement of partisan rhetoric on education, the paper provides insight into parties’ evolving approaches to an area increasingly crucial to electoral and social life.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Political Research
- Vol. 64 (3) , 1276-1303
Open AccessWho polarises? Who targets? Parties’ educational speech over the long run
How do political parties speak about education? While struggles over education played a foundational role in structuring modern partisan cleavages, scholars debate the extent to which parties still adopt distinct rhetorical stances on education. Existing data, however, is limited to studying broad public support or opposition to educational expansion, restricting both our empirical knowledge of the politicisation of education and our ability to theorise parties’ incentives to speak publicly about it. This paper provides the first systematic examination of the post‐war evolution of partisan rhetoric about education in advanced democracies. We develop a novel dataset ( Education Politics Dataset EPD) based on hand‐coded manifesto speech of the largest centre‐left and centre‐right parties for 20 countries in Europe and beyond, from 1950 to the present. The EPD distinguishes nine educational issues, grouped under the three fundamental policy dimensions of distribution, governance and curricular content. We theorise that parties use educational speech both to signal competence to a broader electorate and to signal credibility to a narrower base. The result is three distinct patterns of speech: consensual, differentially salient and polarised. Where education policies cross‐cut existing cleavages, parties devote similar attention to issues and adopt similar stances, creating a consensual pattern. We find this pattern for issues of participation and quality in education. Where education policies are universal but offer specific benefits to a partisan base, we find patterns of differential salience: some parties devote more rhetorical attention to the issue than others, but parties adopt common stances. We find this pattern for questions of spending and access. Finally, where education policies align with broader political cleavages and provide targeted electoral benefits to partisan bases, parties adopt distinct public stances leading to more polarised rhetoric. We find this pattern for issues related to academic tracking and traditional curricular content. In developing the first multidimensional theorisation and measurement of partisan rhetoric on education, the paper provides insight into parties’ evolving approaches to an area increasingly crucial to electoral and social life.
- Open Access
- 24 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 25 (1) , 126-145
Shaping illiberal citizenries: Far-right justifications of educational structures
Educational structures do not only have pedagogical implications; by defining and ranking categories of teaching and learning, and by assigning individuals to these categories, they also contribute to shaping the identity and stratification of citizenries. It is this latter dimension that is often mobilised in the political debate on structures. Existing literature in sociology and politics shows that the main parties in post-World War II Europe have typically invoked liberal citizenship norms based on solidarity, autonomy and pluralism in this debate to appeal to both domestic electorates and international audiences. But what about those who disagree with liberal and egalitarian understandings of citizenship? This paper examines one such movement: the post-1945 Western European far right. Applying rigorous content analysis to an extensive original database of archival documents, we show that extreme and radical right parties and intellectual organisations largely advocate highly stratified education systems and justify this preference with social-order based citizenship norms – but we also find rhetorical variation. While existing theories of liberal-democratic education politics can serve to understand some of this variation, more specific theorising may be needed for educational research to develop a finer-grained understanding of the rhetorical and positional choices of actors who reject liberal-democratic principles.
- 24 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 25 (1) , 126-145
Open AccessShaping illiberal citizenries: Far-right justifications of educational structures
Educational structures do not only have pedagogical implications; by defining and ranking categories of teaching and learning, and by assigning individuals to these categories, they also contribute to shaping the identity and stratification of citizenries. It is this latter dimension that is often mobilised in the political debate on structures. Existing literature in sociology and politics shows that the main parties in post-World War II Europe have typically invoked liberal citizenship norms based on solidarity, autonomy and pluralism in this debate to appeal to both domestic electorates and international audiences. But what about those who disagree with liberal and egalitarian understandings of citizenship? This paper examines one such movement: the post-1945 Western European far right. Applying rigorous content analysis to an extensive original database of archival documents, we show that extreme and radical right parties and intellectual organisations largely advocate highly stratified education systems and justify this preference with social-order based citizenship norms – but we also find rhetorical variation. While existing theories of liberal-democratic education politics can serve to understand some of this variation, more specific theorising may be needed for educational research to develop a finer-grained understanding of the rhetorical and positional choices of actors who reject liberal-democratic principles.
- 23 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 507-525
Nationalism and the Curriculum: Analytical and Methodological Considerations
- 23 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 507-525
Nationalism and the Curriculum: Analytical and Methodological Considerations
- 9 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-19
Nationalism and the Curriculum: Analytical and Methodological Considerations
- 9 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-19
Nationalism and the Curriculum: Analytical and Methodological Considerations
- Open Access
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Social Policy & Administration
- Vol. 57 (2) , 172-188
Education as a tool of social equality?
Do political parties approach education with different social policy aims? We argue that while parties have adopted a common language of equality as an aim of education, they draw on different conceptions of it linked to diverging social projects. To make this argument, we first normatively distinguish education as a tool for creating equal opportunity, equal outcomes, and representational diversity. We then draw on an original dataset coding the educational content in the political manifestos of the largest center‐left and center‐right party across 19 Western democracies from 1950 to present. The analysis shows that left parties emphasise more equality of outcome than rightwing parties and pay less attention to equality of opportunity, and that they associate equality‐related aims more extensively with promises of resources. These findings suggest that there remain critical differences in parties' understanding of education as a tool of social policy.
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Social Policy & Administration
- Vol. 57 (2) , 172-188
Open AccessEducation as a tool of social equality?
Do political parties approach education with different social policy aims? We argue that while parties have adopted a common language of equality as an aim of education, they draw on different conceptions of it linked to diverging social projects. To make this argument, we first normatively distinguish education as a tool for creating equal opportunity, equal outcomes, and representational diversity. We then draw on an original dataset coding the educational content in the political manifestos of the largest center‐left and center‐right party across 19 Western democracies from 1950 to present. The analysis shows that left parties emphasise more equality of outcome than rightwing parties and pay less attention to equality of opportunity, and that they associate equality‐related aims more extensively with promises of resources. These findings suggest that there remain critical differences in parties' understanding of education as a tool of social policy.
- 2 September 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Paedagogica Historica
- Vol. 56 (5) , 569-571
Educating the Volksgemeinschaft: authoritarian ideals and school reforms in Europe's fascist era
In recent years, the scholarly treatment of fascism has changed. Older studies tended to focus on single regimes (generally, Italy, Germany, or Spain), treating each of them as a self-contained uni...
- 2 September 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Paedagogica Historica
- Vol. 56 (5) , 569-571
Educating the Volksgemeinschaft: authoritarian ideals and school reforms in Europe's fascist era
In recent years, the scholarly treatment of fascism has changed. Older studies tended to focus on single regimes (generally, Italy, Germany, or Spain), treating each of them as a self-contained uni...
- Open Access
- 19 August 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 20 (2) , 121-142
Seeds of authoritarian opposition: Far-right education politics in post-war Europe
Since the 1980s, right-wing extremism, radicalism, and populism have emerged as transformative forces in European politics. This unexpected resurgence has triggered an interdisciplinary scholarly effort to refine our understanding of the far right. Educationalists, however, have largely been absent from this endeavour, leaving us unable to theorise and address the potential effects of the far right’s political and cultural growth on European education. This article aims to provide an empirically based conceptional groundwork for educational research on the far right. Drawing on archival research and content analysis of programmatic material produced by diverse and influential far-right organisations in France, (West) Germany, and Italy, I show that the post-war European far right disposes of the two essential features of a social movement: an action-oriented frame that reduces educational reforms to a common contentious theme, and a dense organisational network. The latter engages in institutional and contentious politics, as well as education. Theoretically, these findings suggest that, in the realm of education, the far right ought to be conceptualised as a social movement that seeks to influence education policy, and represents itself an educational actor. Addressing the far right’s multifaceted educational engagement thus requires a combined effort across European education research.
- 19 August 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 20 (2) , 121-142
Open AccessSeeds of authoritarian opposition: Far-right education politics in post-war Europe
Since the 1980s, right-wing extremism, radicalism, and populism have emerged as transformative forces in European politics. This unexpected resurgence has triggered an interdisciplinary scholarly effort to refine our understanding of the far right. Educationalists, however, have largely been absent from this endeavour, leaving us unable to theorise and address the potential effects of the far right’s political and cultural growth on European education. This article aims to provide an empirically based conceptional groundwork for educational research on the far right. Drawing on archival research and content analysis of programmatic material produced by diverse and influential far-right organisations in France, (West) Germany, and Italy, I show that the post-war European far right disposes of the two essential features of a social movement: an action-oriented frame that reduces educational reforms to a common contentious theme, and a dense organisational network. The latter engages in institutional and contentious politics, as well as education. Theoretically, these findings suggest that, in the realm of education, the far right ought to be conceptualised as a social movement that seeks to influence education policy, and represents itself an educational actor. Addressing the far right’s multifaceted educational engagement thus requires a combined effort across European education research.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Education Policy
- Vol. 36 (6) , 801-821
Teacher politics bottom-up: theorising the impact of micro-politics on policy generation
Education policy is generally understood as a multi-layered process, consisting of diverse interconnected phases. Studies of these interconnections typically ask whether and how the generation of official policy from the top-down affects micro-politics, i.e. how teachers experience and execute their work. The assumption that policy is influenced in the reverse direction is widely held, but has seldom been studied empirically. Little is known, therefore, about how this dynamic operates. This study delineates mechanisms that link teachers’ micro-politics to the macro-politics of policy generation. Analytically, it combines concepts from the literature on teacher involvement in macro- and micro-politics in order to develop a framework bridging the two. Empirically, it harnesses the theoretical potential of Swiss language education policy, tracing the process of reforms through which teachers, though formally excluded from policy-making, were able to influence the choice of languages included in official curricula. The analysis identifies three mechanisms through which they exerted influence: voicing experience, subversive enactment, and open resistance. None of these are dependent upon higher levels of teacher unionisation or particular institutions of governance. These findings highlight the importance of engaging with the processual dimension of politics to advance our theories of educational policy.
- 21 February 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Education Policy
- Vol. 36 (6) , 801-821
Open AccessTeacher politics bottom-up: theorising the impact of micro-politics on policy generation
Education policy is generally understood as a multi-layered process, consisting of diverse interconnected phases. Studies of these interconnections typically ask whether and how the generation of official policy from the top-down affects micro-politics, i.e. how teachers experience and execute their work. The assumption that policy is influenced in the reverse direction is widely held, but has seldom been studied empirically. Little is known, therefore, about how this dynamic operates. This study delineates mechanisms that link teachers’ micro-politics to the macro-politics of policy generation. Analytically, it combines concepts from the literature on teacher involvement in macro- and micro-politics in order to develop a framework bridging the two. Empirically, it harnesses the theoretical potential of Swiss language education policy, tracing the process of reforms through which teachers, though formally excluded from policy-making, were able to influence the choice of languages included in official curricula. The analysis identifies three mechanisms through which they exerted influence: voicing experience, subversive enactment, and open resistance. None of these are dependent upon higher levels of teacher unionisation or particular institutions of governance. These findings highlight the importance of engaging with the processual dimension of politics to advance our theories of educational policy.
- 23 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Paedagogica Historica
- Vol. 56 (5) , 605-623
How to educate an authoritarian society: conflicting views on school reform for a fascist society in interwar Switzerland
Despite its image as an antifascist stronghold, interwar-Switzerland hosted several fascist movements. So far, research has not remarked upon the extraordinarily strong involvement of educators in these groups. Exploiting Switzerland’s particular situation in this period, this paper aims to shed new light on the relationship between authoritarian politics and education. To this end, we analyse the educational writings by activists of the main Swiss fascist organisation Nationale Front (NF), between 1933 and 1938, asking what role they attributed schooling in bringing their societal vision about, as well as which reforms they proposed for schooling to conform to this role. We argue that Swiss interwar-fascists considered schooling a conservative institution that could not contribute to producing an authoritarian revolution, but had to be reformed thereafter. However, despite sharing a unified vision of the future fascist Volksgemeinschaft, NF activists did not agree on what kind of schools were needed to educate it. Swiss fascists never even came close to attaining the position of power needed to execute their ideas, and thus were never burdened by practical or institutional difficulties of government. Consequently, these results suggest that, despite its totalitarian aspiration, interwar European authoritarianism did not come with a clear educational vision.
- 23 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Paedagogica Historica
- Vol. 56 (5) , 605-623
How to educate an authoritarian society: conflicting views on school reform for a fascist society in interwar Switzerland
Despite its image as an antifascist stronghold, interwar-Switzerland hosted several fascist movements. So far, research has not remarked upon the extraordinarily strong involvement of educators in these groups. Exploiting Switzerland’s particular situation in this period, this paper aims to shed new light on the relationship between authoritarian politics and education. To this end, we analyse the educational writings by activists of the main Swiss fascist organisation Nationale Front (NF), between 1933 and 1938, asking what role they attributed schooling in bringing their societal vision about, as well as which reforms they proposed for schooling to conform to this role. We argue that Swiss interwar-fascists considered schooling a conservative institution that could not contribute to producing an authoritarian revolution, but had to be reformed thereafter. However, despite sharing a unified vision of the future fascist Volksgemeinschaft, NF activists did not agree on what kind of schools were needed to educate it. Swiss fascists never even came close to attaining the position of power needed to execute their ideas, and thus were never burdened by practical or institutional difficulties of government. Consequently, these results suggest that, despite its totalitarian aspiration, interwar European authoritarianism did not come with a clear educational vision.