Tobias Pamminger
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Tobias Pamminger has a total of 95 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Susanne Foitzik
Institute of Organismic and Molecular Evolution, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Germany
11 shared publications Matthias Bergtold
BASF SE, Speyererstrasse 2, 67117 Limburgerhof, Germany
8 shared publicationsRoland Becker
6 shared publicationsSophie Himmelreich
6 shared publicationsChristof W Schneider
Global Ecotoxicology, BASF SE, Limburgerhof, Germany
4 shared publications- William O. H. Hughes
University of Sussex
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Aquatic Toxicology
- Vol. 301, 107995
The zebrafish embryo as a potential 3R-compliant model to identify endocrine activity across estrogenic, androgenic and steroidogenic (EAS) modalities
- 28 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Aquatic Toxicology
- Vol. 301, 107995
Open AccessThe zebrafish embryo as a potential 3R-compliant model to identify endocrine activity across estrogenic, androgenic and steroidogenic (EAS) modalities
- 10 July 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 60 (28) , 19715-19717
Bias Is Blind to Virtue: Conflicts of Interest across All Sectors of Science
- 10 July 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 60 (28) , 19715-19717
Bias Is Blind to Virtue: Conflicts of Interest across All Sectors of Science
- Open Access
- 10 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 44 (8) , 2322-2330
Sublethal effects of plant protection products on bees: learnings from an abandoned meta-analysis
Chemical plant protection products are designed to manage pests, weeds, and diseases in a wide range of crop plants, ensuring stable yields. Although effective in limiting pest populations, they can come in contact with nontarget organisms, including bees. Such unintended exposure can result in lethal and sublethal effects, such as altering movement, learning, and feeding behavior. Although the existence of such effects is well documented in bees, there have only been a handful of attempts to quantitatively assess their occurrence across products and species. In this study, we attempted to fill this gap by performing a formal meta-analysis on the occurrence, strength, and potential dose dependency of sublethal effects in adult bees moving beyond a simple analysis of their existence. We found an extensive bias in the existing data in terms of product–species pairs tested, with the majority of studies focusing on insecticides targeting the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (e g., imidacloprid and clothianidin) in the honeybee. In addition, we found that a large proportion of the studies do not adequately report necessary methodological details and results to reliably extract the information needed to conduct a formal meta-analysis across chemical plant protection products and the different types of sublethal effects. We discuss the causes and consequences of these findings for studying sublethal effects in bees beyond demonstrating their existence and emphasize well-established recommendations to improve the reporting standards of such studies.
- 10 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 44 (8) , 2322-2330
Open AccessSublethal effects of plant protection products on bees: learnings from an abandoned meta-analysis
Chemical plant protection products are designed to manage pests, weeds, and diseases in a wide range of crop plants, ensuring stable yields. Although effective in limiting pest populations, they can come in contact with nontarget organisms, including bees. Such unintended exposure can result in lethal and sublethal effects, such as altering movement, learning, and feeding behavior. Although the existence of such effects is well documented in bees, there have only been a handful of attempts to quantitatively assess their occurrence across products and species. In this study, we attempted to fill this gap by performing a formal meta-analysis on the occurrence, strength, and potential dose dependency of sublethal effects in adult bees moving beyond a simple analysis of their existence. We found an extensive bias in the existing data in terms of product–species pairs tested, with the majority of studies focusing on insecticides targeting the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (e g., imidacloprid and clothianidin) in the honeybee. In addition, we found that a large proportion of the studies do not adequately report necessary methodological details and results to reliably extract the information needed to conduct a formal meta-analysis across chemical plant protection products and the different types of sublethal effects. We discuss the causes and consequences of these findings for studying sublethal effects in bees beyond demonstrating their existence and emphasize well-established recommendations to improve the reporting standards of such studies.
- Open Access
Missing genomic resources for the next generation of environmental risk assessment
Environmental risk assessment traditionally relies on a wide range of in vivo testing to assess the potential hazard of chemicals in the environment. These tests are often time-consuming, costly and can cause test organisms’ suffering. Recent developments of reliable low-cost alternatives, both in vivo - and in silico -based, opened the door to reconsider current toxicity assessment. However, many of these new approach methodologies (NAMs) rely on high quality annotated genomes for surrogate species of the regulatory risk assessment. Currently, lacking genomic information slows the process of NAM development. Here, we present a phylogenetically resolved overview of missing genomic resources for surrogate species within regulatory ecotoxicological risk assessment. We call for an organized and systematic effort within the (regulatory) ecotoxicological community to provide these missing genomic resources. Further, we discuss the potential of a standardized genomic surrogate species landscape to enable a robust and non-animal reliant ecotoxicological risk assessment in the systems ecotoxicology era. Synopsis Statement: We identify missing genomic resources needed for the development and regulatory acceptance of new approach methodologies in environmental risk assessment.
Open AccessMissing genomic resources for the next generation of environmental risk assessment
Environmental risk assessment traditionally relies on a wide range of in vivo testing to assess the potential hazard of chemicals in the environment. These tests are often time-consuming, costly and can cause test organisms’ suffering. Recent developments of reliable low-cost alternatives, both in vivo - and in silico -based, opened the door to reconsider current toxicity assessment. However, many of these new approach methodologies (NAMs) rely on high quality annotated genomes for surrogate species of the regulatory risk assessment. Currently, lacking genomic information slows the process of NAM development. Here, we present a phylogenetically resolved overview of missing genomic resources for surrogate species within regulatory ecotoxicological risk assessment. We call for an organized and systematic effort within the (regulatory) ecotoxicological community to provide these missing genomic resources. Further, we discuss the potential of a standardized genomic surrogate species landscape to enable a robust and non-animal reliant ecotoxicological risk assessment in the systems ecotoxicology era. Synopsis Statement: We identify missing genomic resources needed for the development and regulatory acceptance of new approach methodologies in environmental risk assessment.
- 1 September 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1434-1436
shinyshval: A user-friendly Shiny implementation of the EFSA SHVAL tool for use in European pollinator risk assessment
- 1 September 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1434-1436
shinyshval: A user-friendly Shiny implementation of the EFSA SHVAL tool for use in European pollinator risk assessment
- Open Access
- 21 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1423-1433
Investigating the role of soil mesofauna abundance and biodiversity for organic matter breakdown in arable fields
Intact soil food webs are pivotal to maintain essential soil functions such as carbon recycling, sequestering and biomass production. While the functional role of micro- (e.g. bacteria and fungi) and macrofauna (e.g. earthworms) is comparatively well established, the importance of the mesofauna community (e.g. abundance and diversity of Acari and Collembola) in maintaining soil functionality is less clear. We investigated this question in a six-month field experiment in arable soil by actively manipulating mesofauna abundance and biodiversity through the application of two legacy insecticides (lindane and methamidophos) at sufficiently high doses to reduce mesofauna abundance (well above previously registered application rates; 2.5 and 7.5 kg a.s./ha for lindane, and 0.6 and 3 kg a.s./ha for methamidophos) and measure the impact, on organic matter degradation. Our results show that both insecticides had reduced Collembola and Acari abundances by up to 80% over the 6 months study duration. In addition, we observed less pronounced and more complex changes in mesofauna biodiversity over time. These included insecticide-dependent temporal fluctuations (both reduction and increase) for different estimates (indices) of local (alpha)-diversity over time and no lasting impact for most estimates after six months. Even at these exceptionally high field rates Collembola and Acari diversity was observed to generally recover by six months. In contrast, considering organic matter breakdown, we found no evidence for a treatment related effect. These results suggest that organic matter breakdown in arable soils is likely driven by other trophic levels (e.g. microorganisms or earthworms) with only a limited influence of the mesofauna community. We discuss these findings with regard to their implications for our current understanding of soil food web function and future European soil risk assessments.
- 21 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1423-1433
Open AccessInvestigating the role of soil mesofauna abundance and biodiversity for organic matter breakdown in arable fields
Intact soil food webs are pivotal to maintain essential soil functions such as carbon recycling, sequestering and biomass production. While the functional role of micro- (e.g. bacteria and fungi) and macrofauna (e.g. earthworms) is comparatively well established, the importance of the mesofauna community (e.g. abundance and diversity of Acari and Collembola) in maintaining soil functionality is less clear. We investigated this question in a six-month field experiment in arable soil by actively manipulating mesofauna abundance and biodiversity through the application of two legacy insecticides (lindane and methamidophos) at sufficiently high doses to reduce mesofauna abundance (well above previously registered application rates; 2.5 and 7.5 kg a.s./ha for lindane, and 0.6 and 3 kg a.s./ha for methamidophos) and measure the impact, on organic matter degradation. Our results show that both insecticides had reduced Collembola and Acari abundances by up to 80% over the 6 months study duration. In addition, we observed less pronounced and more complex changes in mesofauna biodiversity over time. These included insecticide-dependent temporal fluctuations (both reduction and increase) for different estimates (indices) of local (alpha)-diversity over time and no lasting impact for most estimates after six months. Even at these exceptionally high field rates Collembola and Acari diversity was observed to generally recover by six months. In contrast, considering organic matter breakdown, we found no evidence for a treatment related effect. These results suggest that organic matter breakdown in arable soils is likely driven by other trophic levels (e.g. microorganisms or earthworms) with only a limited influence of the mesofauna community. We discuss these findings with regard to their implications for our current understanding of soil food web function and future European soil risk assessments.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1399-1413
Holistic evaluation of long-term earthworm field studies with a fungicide
Plant protection products to be placed on the market in the European Union need to meet rigorous safety criteria including the testing of lumbricid earthworms, the functionally most important soil organism group in Central European agricultural ecosystems. To address uncertainties and investigate the potential long-term in-crop effects of the fungicide Cantus® containing 50% boscalid as an active substance, a series of standardized earthworm field studies with an overall duration of 5 years per study program was carried out in four German agricultural fields under realistic crop rotation conditions. A two-step approach was chosen to analyze the potential overall long-term effects on earthworms in agricultural fields: (i) an assessment of the earthworm abundance development in the course of the four study programs in relation to the determined actual content of boscalid in soil and (ii) an effect size meta-analysis of earthworm abundance 1 year after treatment for each consecutive year and study program. Measured boscalid concentrations in the soil after multiple applications were well above the maximum boscalid residues observed in agricultural soils across Central Europe. There were isolated statistically significant reductions of earthworm abundance for some species and groups at some time points during the studies, but no consistent relationship to the Cantus® treatments was observed. These results were supported by the meta-analysis, indicating no adverse effects on earthworm populations. Therefore, fluctuations of abundance reflect the natural variation of the populations rather than a concentration-related response. Based on this comprehensive analysis, we conclude that there is no application rate-related effect of the 5-year use of Cantus® on the development of the earthworm communities. The four study programs, paired with a comprehensive evaluation, directly address the concerns about the potential long-term effects of boscalid on earthworms in the field and suggest that multiyear applications do not adversely affect earthworm populations. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2022;18:1399–1413. © 2021 ECT Oekotoxikologie GmbH and BASF SE. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC). KEY POINTS A series of standardized earthworm field studies with the fungicide Cantus® containing 50% boscalid as active substance and with an overall duration of 5 years per study program was carried out in four German agricultural fields under realistic crop rotation conditions. The development of earthworm abundance in the course of the four study programs in relation to the determined actual content of boscalid in soil was assessed and an effect size meta-analysis of earthworm abundance one year after treatment for each consecutive year and study program was performed. Measured boscalid concentrations in soil after multiple applications were well above the maximum boscalid residues observed in agricultural soils across Central Europe. The four study programs, paired with a comprehensive evaluation, directly address the concerns about potential long-term effects of boscalid on earthworms in the field and suggest that multiyear applications do not adversely affect earthworm populations.
- 16 December 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1399-1413
Open AccessHolistic evaluation of long-term earthworm field studies with a fungicide
Plant protection products to be placed on the market in the European Union need to meet rigorous safety criteria including the testing of lumbricid earthworms, the functionally most important soil organism group in Central European agricultural ecosystems. To address uncertainties and investigate the potential long-term in-crop effects of the fungicide Cantus® containing 50% boscalid as an active substance, a series of standardized earthworm field studies with an overall duration of 5 years per study program was carried out in four German agricultural fields under realistic crop rotation conditions. A two-step approach was chosen to analyze the potential overall long-term effects on earthworms in agricultural fields: (i) an assessment of the earthworm abundance development in the course of the four study programs in relation to the determined actual content of boscalid in soil and (ii) an effect size meta-analysis of earthworm abundance 1 year after treatment for each consecutive year and study program. Measured boscalid concentrations in the soil after multiple applications were well above the maximum boscalid residues observed in agricultural soils across Central Europe. There were isolated statistically significant reductions of earthworm abundance for some species and groups at some time points during the studies, but no consistent relationship to the Cantus® treatments was observed. These results were supported by the meta-analysis, indicating no adverse effects on earthworm populations. Therefore, fluctuations of abundance reflect the natural variation of the populations rather than a concentration-related response. Based on this comprehensive analysis, we conclude that there is no application rate-related effect of the 5-year use of Cantus® on the development of the earthworm communities. The four study programs, paired with a comprehensive evaluation, directly address the concerns about the potential long-term effects of boscalid on earthworms in the field and suggest that multiyear applications do not adversely affect earthworm populations. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2022;18:1399–1413. © 2021 ECT Oekotoxikologie GmbH and BASF SE. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC). KEY POINTS A series of standardized earthworm field studies with the fungicide Cantus® containing 50% boscalid as active substance and with an overall duration of 5 years per study program was carried out in four German agricultural fields under realistic crop rotation conditions. The development of earthworm abundance in the course of the four study programs in relation to the determined actual content of boscalid in soil was assessed and an effect size meta-analysis of earthworm abundance one year after treatment for each consecutive year and study program was performed. Measured boscalid concentrations in soil after multiple applications were well above the maximum boscalid residues observed in agricultural soils across Central Europe. The four study programs, paired with a comprehensive evaluation, directly address the concerns about potential long-term effects of boscalid on earthworms in the field and suggest that multiyear applications do not adversely affect earthworm populations.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (2) , 308-313
Establishing realistic exposure estimates of solitary bee larvae via pollen for use in risk assessment
Bees foraging in agricultural habitats can be exposed to plant protection products. To limit the risk of adverse events, a robust risk assessment is needed, which requires reliable estimates for the expected exposure. The exposure pathways to developing solitary bees in particular are not well described and, in the currently proposed form, rely on limited information. To build a scaling model predicting the amount of protein developing solitary bees need based on adult body weight, we used published data on the volume of pollen solitary bees provide for their offspring. This model was tested against and ultimately updated with additional literature data on bee weight and protein content of emerged bees. We rescaled this model, based on the known pollen protein content of bee-visited flowers, to predict the expected amount of pollen a generalist solitary bee would likely provide based on its adult body weight, and tested these predictions in the field. We found overall agreement between the models' predictions and the measured values in the field, but additional data are needed to confirm these initial results. Our study suggests that scaling models in the bee risk assessment could complement existing risk assessment approaches and facilitate the further development of accurate risk characterization for solitary bees; ultimately the models will help to protect them during their foraging activity in agricultural settings. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2022;18:308–313. © 2021 The Authors. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC). KEY POINTS This paper provides estimates for protein and pollen provisions for solitary bee larvae. The predictions are supported by Osmia bicornis pollen collection under field and semifield conditions.
- 1 July 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 18 (2) , 308-313
Open AccessEstablishing realistic exposure estimates of solitary bee larvae via pollen for use in risk assessment
Bees foraging in agricultural habitats can be exposed to plant protection products. To limit the risk of adverse events, a robust risk assessment is needed, which requires reliable estimates for the expected exposure. The exposure pathways to developing solitary bees in particular are not well described and, in the currently proposed form, rely on limited information. To build a scaling model predicting the amount of protein developing solitary bees need based on adult body weight, we used published data on the volume of pollen solitary bees provide for their offspring. This model was tested against and ultimately updated with additional literature data on bee weight and protein content of emerged bees. We rescaled this model, based on the known pollen protein content of bee-visited flowers, to predict the expected amount of pollen a generalist solitary bee would likely provide based on its adult body weight, and tested these predictions in the field. We found overall agreement between the models' predictions and the measured values in the field, but additional data are needed to confirm these initial results. Our study suggests that scaling models in the bee risk assessment could complement existing risk assessment approaches and facilitate the further development of accurate risk characterization for solitary bees; ultimately the models will help to protect them during their foraging activity in agricultural settings. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2022;18:308–313. © 2021 The Authors. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC). KEY POINTS This paper provides estimates for protein and pollen provisions for solitary bee larvae. The predictions are supported by Osmia bicornis pollen collection under field and semifield conditions.
- Open Access
How much pollen do solitary bee larvae consume? : Or establishing realistic exposure estimates of solitary bee larvae via pollen for the use in risk assessment
Bees foraging in agricultural habitats can be exposed to plant protection products. In order to limit the risk of adverse events to occur a robust risk assessment is needed, which requires reliable estimates for the expected exposure. Especially the exposure pathways to developing solitary bees are not well described and in the currently proposed form rely on limited information. To address this topic, we used a published data set on the volume of pollen solitary bees provide for their larvae to build two scaling models predicting the amount of protein and pollen developing solitary bees need based on adult body weight. We test our models using both literature and experimental data, which both support the validity of the presented models. Using scaling models in the bee risk assessment could complement existing risk assessment approaches, facilitate the further development of accurate risk characterization for solitary bees and ultimately will help to protect them during their foraging activity in agricultural settings.
Open AccessHow much pollen do solitary bee larvae consume? : Or establishing realistic exposure estimates of solitary bee larvae via pollen for the use in risk assessment
Bees foraging in agricultural habitats can be exposed to plant protection products. In order to limit the risk of adverse events to occur a robust risk assessment is needed, which requires reliable estimates for the expected exposure. Especially the exposure pathways to developing solitary bees are not well described and in the currently proposed form rely on limited information. To address this topic, we used a published data set on the volume of pollen solitary bees provide for their larvae to build two scaling models predicting the amount of protein and pollen developing solitary bees need based on adult body weight. We test our models using both literature and experimental data, which both support the validity of the presented models. Using scaling models in the bee risk assessment could complement existing risk assessment approaches, facilitate the further development of accurate risk characterization for solitary bees and ultimately will help to protect them during their foraging activity in agricultural settings.
- 22 March 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 40 (7) , 2042-2050
Extrapolating Acute Contact Bee Sensitivity to Insecticides Based on Body Weight Using a Phylogenetically Informed Interspecies Scaling Framework
Plant protection products, including insecticides, are important for global food production, but can have adverse effects on non‐target organisms including bees. Historically, research investigating such effects has focused mainly on the honeybee (Apis mellifera), while less information is available for non‐Apis bees. Consequently, a comprehensive hazard (sensitivity) assessment for the majority of bees is lacking, which in turn hinders accurate risk characterization and consequently bee protection. Interspecies sensitivity extrapolation based on body weight might be a way to improve the situation, but in the past such approaches did often ignore the phylogenetic background of species used, which in turn potentially reduces the robustness of such results. Published acute contact sensitivity data (LD50/bee) of bees to insecticides, their body weight and phylogenetic background were used to build interspecies scaling models (ISMs) to predict bee sensitivity based on their weight. The results indicate that 1) bee body weight is a predictor of acute contact bee sensitivity to a range of insecticides and 2) highlights that phylogeny (non‐independence of datapoints) needs to be considered in cross species analysis, although it not always confounds the observed effects.
- 22 March 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 40 (7) , 2042-2050
Extrapolating Acute Contact Bee Sensitivity to Insecticides Based on Body Weight Using a Phylogenetically Informed Interspecies Scaling Framework
Plant protection products, including insecticides, are important for global food production, but can have adverse effects on non‐target organisms including bees. Historically, research investigating such effects has focused mainly on the honeybee (Apis mellifera), while less information is available for non‐Apis bees. Consequently, a comprehensive hazard (sensitivity) assessment for the majority of bees is lacking, which in turn hinders accurate risk characterization and consequently bee protection. Interspecies sensitivity extrapolation based on body weight might be a way to improve the situation, but in the past such approaches did often ignore the phylogenetic background of species used, which in turn potentially reduces the robustness of such results. Published acute contact sensitivity data (LD50/bee) of bees to insecticides, their body weight and phylogenetic background were used to build interspecies scaling models (ISMs) to predict bee sensitivity based on their weight. The results indicate that 1) bee body weight is a predictor of acute contact bee sensitivity to a range of insecticides and 2) highlights that phylogeny (non‐independence of datapoints) needs to be considered in cross species analysis, although it not always confounds the observed effects.