Liam Guilfoyle
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Liam Guilfoyle has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sibel Erduran
University of Oxford
6 shared publications - Nigel Fancourt
University of Oxford
3 shared publications - Wonyong Park
University of Southampton
3 shared publications - Jessica Chan
Plymouth Institute of Education, University of Plymouth, Plymouth, UK
2 shared publications - Judith Hillier
Department of Education, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 shared publications - Alison Cullinane
University of Oxford
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 July 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 44 (2) , 490-509
Fostering student climate agency and future literacy: a case study of scenario-based teaching
- 24 July 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 44 (2) , 490-509
Open AccessFostering student climate agency and future literacy: a case study of scenario-based teaching
- Open Access
- 12 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 144
The role of research experiences in developing pre-service teachers’ epistemic beliefs
- 12 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 144
Open AccessThe role of research experiences in developing pre-service teachers’ epistemic beliefs
- 20 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 241-264
Broadening STEAM Education Through Cross-Curricular Collaboration: The Case of Argumentation in Science and Religious Education
- 20 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 241-264
Broadening STEAM Education Through Cross-Curricular Collaboration: The Case of Argumentation in Science and Religious Education
- 22 August 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 110-119
Multicomponent and cognitive interviewing
This chapter explores the use of multicomponent interviewing for researching beliefs. Multicomponent interviews combine multiple methods into a single interview protocol with the intention of exploring the construct under investigation from different perspectives. This is particularly useful when researching beliefs that are difficult to articulate, such as beliefs about the nature of knowledge and nature of knowing (i.e., epistemic beliefs). Cognitive interviewing, a method used to a gain more nuanced understanding of participants’ responses on questionnaires, can be used as one component in a multicomponent interview.
- 22 August 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 110-119
Multicomponent and cognitive interviewing
This chapter explores the use of multicomponent interviewing for researching beliefs. Multicomponent interviews combine multiple methods into a single interview protocol with the intention of exploring the construct under investigation from different perspectives. This is particularly useful when researching beliefs that are difficult to articulate, such as beliefs about the nature of knowledge and nature of knowing (i.e., epistemic beliefs). Cognitive interviewing, a method used to a gain more nuanced understanding of participants’ responses on questionnaires, can be used as one component in a multicomponent interview.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 44 (8) , 1251-1276
Secondary teachers’ instructional practices on argumentation in the context of science and religious education
Argumentation is widely recognised as a core practice of science, but the relation between argumentation in the teaching of science in contrast to the teaching of other school subjects has not been sufficiently addressed. In this study, we investigate science and religious education (RE) teachers’ instructional practices related to argumentation in lower secondary lessons in England. Through qualitative analysis of a pair of science and RE teachers’ instructional practices, we characterise how the teachers participating in a professional development project understand and teach argumentation. Data sources included questionnaires, lesson materials, classroom video recordings, and written teacher reflections. Findings suggest that both teachers recognised the value of argumentation in their subject, but some variations existed in the nuances of their views and particularly how different instructional strategies were utilised to achieve the lesson goals related to argumentation. The study highlights the teachers’ different understandings and enactments of argumentation as a disciplinary practice and an instructional objective in science and RE lessons. We call for further consideration of argumentation in different school subjects and how argumentation can enrich science teaching in interdisciplinary contexts.
- 19 May 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 44 (8) , 1251-1276
Open AccessSecondary teachers’ instructional practices on argumentation in the context of science and religious education
Argumentation is widely recognised as a core practice of science, but the relation between argumentation in the teaching of science in contrast to the teaching of other school subjects has not been sufficiently addressed. In this study, we investigate science and religious education (RE) teachers’ instructional practices related to argumentation in lower secondary lessons in England. Through qualitative analysis of a pair of science and RE teachers’ instructional practices, we characterise how the teachers participating in a professional development project understand and teach argumentation. Data sources included questionnaires, lesson materials, classroom video recordings, and written teacher reflections. Findings suggest that both teachers recognised the value of argumentation in their subject, but some variations existed in the nuances of their views and particularly how different instructional strategies were utilised to achieve the lesson goals related to argumentation. The study highlights the teachers’ different understandings and enactments of argumentation as a disciplinary practice and an instructional objective in science and RE lessons. We call for further consideration of argumentation in different school subjects and how argumentation can enrich science teaching in interdisciplinary contexts.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Technology
- Vol. 53 (3) , 558-576
Transforming a doctoral summer school to an online experience: A response to the COVID‐19 pandemic
For the last 28 years, one of the leading international science education organisations has regularly provided a week‐long summer school experience for doctoral students. In summer 2020, the COVID‐19 pandemic prevented international travel and close‐contact interactions between scholars. This required the transformation and relocation of learning interactions between mentors and doctoral students online through a virtual week‐long summer school. All doctoral participants, from across the five continents, were invited to reflectively comment on their educative experience after the online event. This paper consequently presents the perspectives of these science education PhD students who engaged with the transformed virtual summer school to consider how the range of varied online interactions maintained the learning opportunities for them and enabled their introduction to an established research community. The study indicates how the digital activities facilitated and maintained high‐quality learning exchanges through a varied array of intellectual activities involving both experienced and novice scholars. The findings demonstrate how successful academic outcomes can be achieved remotely while minimising international travel and significantly reducing financial outlay. This was achieved through creatively structuring a week‐long virtual experience and combining a series of synchronous and asynchronous learning opportunities for different groupings of participants within the international summer school community. Practitioner notes: What is already known about this topic Doctoral students often feel that studying for their research degree is a very solitary experience. Supporting doctoral students to discuss their research with peers and more experienced others can address the feelings of isolation. The pandemic restricting face‐to‐face interaction constrains how learning can unfold in online contexts. It is possible to provide doctoral support through online means, however, the exact nature of such is not clearly defined. What this paper adds Clear evidence that doctoral learning communities [involving university students and tutors] can be successfully developed through online virtual environments. That online working can afford and extend doctoral learning, develop beginning researcher identities and provide students the opportunity to become part of an international research community whatever their geographical setting and prior socio‐cultural experiences. Clarity about the nature of online activities that ensure an appropriate blend of the kind of synchronous and asynchronous interactions that effectively support virtual online doctoral learning. The Community of Practice COP theoretical framework can offer a useful way of looking at different dimensions of higher degree learning. Implications for practice and/or policy This paper provides advice for those who would like to develop their own virtual learning networks that bring together learners from universities and wider organisations to develop a community of learning. That an appropriate blend of synchronous and asynchronous interactions can mediate and support doctoral students, aiding them to effectively become more knowledgeable members of an international research community within a short space of time. That international virtual events can successfully achieve learning outcomes while also minimising overseas travel, significantly reducing financial expenditure and individual carbon footprints.
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Technology
- Vol. 53 (3) , 558-576
Open AccessTransforming a doctoral summer school to an online experience: A response to the COVID‐19 pandemic
For the last 28 years, one of the leading international science education organisations has regularly provided a week‐long summer school experience for doctoral students. In summer 2020, the COVID‐19 pandemic prevented international travel and close‐contact interactions between scholars. This required the transformation and relocation of learning interactions between mentors and doctoral students online through a virtual week‐long summer school. All doctoral participants, from across the five continents, were invited to reflectively comment on their educative experience after the online event. This paper consequently presents the perspectives of these science education PhD students who engaged with the transformed virtual summer school to consider how the range of varied online interactions maintained the learning opportunities for them and enabled their introduction to an established research community. The study indicates how the digital activities facilitated and maintained high‐quality learning exchanges through a varied array of intellectual activities involving both experienced and novice scholars. The findings demonstrate how successful academic outcomes can be achieved remotely while minimising international travel and significantly reducing financial outlay. This was achieved through creatively structuring a week‐long virtual experience and combining a series of synchronous and asynchronous learning opportunities for different groupings of participants within the international summer school community. Practitioner notes: What is already known about this topic Doctoral students often feel that studying for their research degree is a very solitary experience. Supporting doctoral students to discuss their research with peers and more experienced others can address the feelings of isolation. The pandemic restricting face‐to‐face interaction constrains how learning can unfold in online contexts. It is possible to provide doctoral support through online means, however, the exact nature of such is not clearly defined. What this paper adds Clear evidence that doctoral learning communities [involving university students and tutors] can be successfully developed through online virtual environments. That online working can afford and extend doctoral learning, develop beginning researcher identities and provide students the opportunity to become part of an international research community whatever their geographical setting and prior socio‐cultural experiences. Clarity about the nature of online activities that ensure an appropriate blend of the kind of synchronous and asynchronous interactions that effectively support virtual online doctoral learning. The Community of Practice COP theoretical framework can offer a useful way of looking at different dimensions of higher degree learning. Implications for practice and/or policy This paper provides advice for those who would like to develop their own virtual learning networks that bring together learners from universities and wider organisations to develop a community of learning. That an appropriate blend of synchronous and asynchronous interactions can mediate and support doctoral students, aiding them to effectively become more knowledgeable members of an international research community within a short space of time. That international virtual events can successfully achieve learning outcomes while also minimising overseas travel, significantly reducing financial expenditure and individual carbon footprints.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Religious Education
- Vol. 70 (1) , 1-23
Interdisciplinary perspective-taking within argumentation: students’ strategies across science and religious education
The importance of developing students’ argumentation skills is well established across the curriculum: students should grasp how claims are made and supported in different disciplines. One challenge is to follow and thereby agree with or critique the arguments of others, which requires perspective-taking, in tracing these other reasons and reasoning. This challenge is increased when disciplines construct argumentation and perspective-taking differently. Here, we consider the role of perspective-taking in argumentation within and between science education and pluralistic religious education, where the former aims at the justification of scientific claims and the latter at both an empathetic understanding of different religions and worldviews, and personal reasoning. We interpretively analyze student data to identify salient features of students’ strategies to perspective-taking within argumentation. Data from 324 pupils across nine schools are explored in relation to students’ challenges in perspective-taking, strategies for perspective-taking within argumentation, and the use of perspective-taking to construct personal argumentation. The analysis shows some barriers to perspective-taking within argumentation, the range of students’ perspective-taking strategies within argumentation, and how personal argumentation could hermeneutically build upon perspective-taking strategies. The importance and implications of perspective-taking within argumentation across the curriculum are considered highlighting challenges in the etic/emic shift, both within the individual subject as well as across them, and some reflections on how this provides a fresh pedagogical perspective on the science/religions debate are made. To end, we conclude with the wider challenges for disciplines and perspective-taking across schooling and university.
- 23 December 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Religious Education
- Vol. 70 (1) , 1-23
Open AccessInterdisciplinary perspective-taking within argumentation: students’ strategies across science and religious education
The importance of developing students’ argumentation skills is well established across the curriculum: students should grasp how claims are made and supported in different disciplines. One challenge is to follow and thereby agree with or critique the arguments of others, which requires perspective-taking, in tracing these other reasons and reasoning. This challenge is increased when disciplines construct argumentation and perspective-taking differently. Here, we consider the role of perspective-taking in argumentation within and between science education and pluralistic religious education, where the former aims at the justification of scientific claims and the latter at both an empathetic understanding of different religions and worldviews, and personal reasoning. We interpretively analyze student data to identify salient features of students’ strategies to perspective-taking within argumentation. Data from 324 pupils across nine schools are explored in relation to students’ challenges in perspective-taking, strategies for perspective-taking within argumentation, and the use of perspective-taking to construct personal argumentation. The analysis shows some barriers to perspective-taking within argumentation, the range of students’ perspective-taking strategies within argumentation, and how personal argumentation could hermeneutically build upon perspective-taking strategies. The importance and implications of perspective-taking within argumentation across the curriculum are considered highlighting challenges in the etic/emic shift, both within the individual subject as well as across them, and some reflections on how this provides a fresh pedagogical perspective on the science/religions debate are made. To end, we conclude with the wider challenges for disciplines and perspective-taking across schooling and university.
- Open Access
- 2 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 43 (18) , 2974-2995
Recalibrating the evolution versus creationism debate for student learning: towards students’ evaluation of evidence in an argumentation task
There is substantial body of literature in science education focusing on students’ understanding of the theory of evolution by natural selection. However, despite decades of research on the evolution versus creationism debate there is still widespread concern that particular misconceptions about evolution persist. The study aimed to recalibrate the evolution versus creationism debate by engaging students in an argumentation task where students can interpret evidence and reasons for why either position is justified or not, and on what basis. A card sort activity used to investigate the students’ use of evidence and reasons. A sample of 77 students with an average age of 13 participated in the study in England in the context of a funded research project. The findings pointed to challenges and opportunities in teaching and learning of evolution through an argumentation task where alternative perspectives are drawn from both science and religious education. Furthermore, they illustrated how argumentation tasks can potentially provide a context for students to explore cross-subject topics. Research about the immersion of students in tasks that support their argumentation can generate understanding of students’ reasoning, and ultimately such research may lead to the design of lesson resources to support students’ engagement in science.
- 2 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 43 (18) , 2974-2995
Open AccessRecalibrating the evolution versus creationism debate for student learning: towards students’ evaluation of evidence in an argumentation task
There is substantial body of literature in science education focusing on students’ understanding of the theory of evolution by natural selection. However, despite decades of research on the evolution versus creationism debate there is still widespread concern that particular misconceptions about evolution persist. The study aimed to recalibrate the evolution versus creationism debate by engaging students in an argumentation task where students can interpret evidence and reasons for why either position is justified or not, and on what basis. A card sort activity used to investigate the students’ use of evidence and reasons. A sample of 77 students with an average age of 13 participated in the study in England in the context of a funded research project. The findings pointed to challenges and opportunities in teaching and learning of evolution through an argumentation task where alternative perspectives are drawn from both science and religious education. Furthermore, they illustrated how argumentation tasks can potentially provide a context for students to explore cross-subject topics. Research about the immersion of students in tasks that support their argumentation can generate understanding of students’ reasoning, and ultimately such research may lead to the design of lesson resources to support students’ engagement in science.
- Open Access
- 29 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 41 (2) , 759-776
Students’ argumentation in the contexts of science, religious education, and interdisciplinary science-religious education scenarios
Background: Argumentation, that is the coordination of evidence and reasons to support claims, is an important skill for democratic society, developing subject-specific literacies, and can be embedded in multiple school subjects. While argumentation has been extensively researched in science education, interdisciplinary argumentation is less explored, particularly between subjects where collaboration is not the norm, such as science and religious education (RE). Yet everyday issues often involve considering information from multiple sources, such as scientific information or ethical, moral, or religious perspectives. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to better understand students’ abilities in argumentation within and across the school subjects of science and RE to inform research and practice of interdisciplinary argumentation. Sample: The participants of this study were 457 students, aged between 11 and 14 years, from 10 secondary schools in England. Following data cleaning, 394 student responses were analysed. Design and Methods: Students completed simultaneous written assessments for argumentation in three tasks which are situated within three different subject contexts: (1) science (2) RE, and (3) an interdisciplinary context which involved argumentation from science and RE. Results: In each of the three contexts, high proportions of students achieve all available marks for identifying claims and evidence. These proportions drop when constructing the link between claim and evidence (warrant) and constructing an evaluative argument. Higher performances were generally noted in the context of science and that students experience particular challenges in argumentation in the RE scenario. Conclusions: This study contributes to our understanding of the challenges and successes of students’ argumentation within and across the subjects of science and RE. Implications for both research and practice are discussed.
- 29 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 41 (2) , 759-776
Open AccessStudents’ argumentation in the contexts of science, religious education, and interdisciplinary science-religious education scenarios
Background: Argumentation, that is the coordination of evidence and reasons to support claims, is an important skill for democratic society, developing subject-specific literacies, and can be embedded in multiple school subjects. While argumentation has been extensively researched in science education, interdisciplinary argumentation is less explored, particularly between subjects where collaboration is not the norm, such as science and religious education (RE). Yet everyday issues often involve considering information from multiple sources, such as scientific information or ethical, moral, or religious perspectives. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to better understand students’ abilities in argumentation within and across the school subjects of science and RE to inform research and practice of interdisciplinary argumentation. Sample: The participants of this study were 457 students, aged between 11 and 14 years, from 10 secondary schools in England. Following data cleaning, 394 student responses were analysed. Design and Methods: Students completed simultaneous written assessments for argumentation in three tasks which are situated within three different subject contexts: (1) science (2) RE, and (3) an interdisciplinary context which involved argumentation from science and RE. Results: In each of the three contexts, high proportions of students achieve all available marks for identifying claims and evidence. These proportions drop when constructing the link between claim and evidence (warrant) and constructing an evaluative argument. Higher performances were generally noted in the context of science and that students experience particular challenges in argumentation in the RE scenario. Conclusions: This study contributes to our understanding of the challenges and successes of students’ argumentation within and across the subjects of science and RE. Implications for both research and practice are discussed.