Andreas Schulz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Andreas Schulz has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alois Buholzer2 shared publications
Johannes Voermanek
2 shared publications- Karolin Maskos2 shared publications
- Selin S. Oeksuez2 shared publications
Timo Leuders
University of Teacher Education Freiburg, Germany
2 shared publications- Andreas Obersteiner
Technical University of Munich, TUM School of Social Sciences and Technology, Department of Educational Sciences, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 182
Enhancing students’ mathematics achievement through teacher professional development on peer- and self-assessment: A randomized controlled trial
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 182
Open AccessEnhancing students’ mathematics achievement through teacher professional development on peer- and self-assessment: A randomized controlled trial
- Open Access
- 5 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 181
Enhancing primary teachers’ formative assessment literacy: Effects of a professional development program on peer and self-assessment
- 5 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 181
Open AccessEnhancing primary teachers’ formative assessment literacy: Effects of a professional development program on peer and self-assessment
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 57 (4) , 679-693
Formative Assessment in Mathematics Education: A Systematic Review
Formative assessment (FA) is a crucial factor influencing learning in schools. However, definitions of FA vary, and findings regarding the effectiveness of FA in mathematics education, specifically, are fragmentary. In this systematic review, we defined five FA components and integrated them into an overarching model. We identified 45 studies spanning the period 2015–2023 that investigated FA’s impact on cognitive and noncognitive learning in mathematics and yielded mixed results. Notably, computer-based assessments in interactive learning environments revealed particular promise. An analysis of the variations in study designs and characteristics provided insight into the factors that could contribute to the effectiveness of FA in progressing and promoting student learning, such as regular implementation over three months, content-specific learning intentions and measurement instruments, and randomized designs. An analysis of the reported moderator and mediator variables facilitated a more nuanced understanding of the effects of FA, highlighting its potential to support lower- to medium-performing students and those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, thus potentially contributing to educational equity. Based on our results, we recommend that future research should prioritize well-defined studies that investigate and describe FA in detail to comprehensively evaluate its potential in supporting mathematical education.
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 57 (4) , 679-693
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessFormative Assessment in Mathematics Education: A Systematic Review
Formative assessment (FA) is a crucial factor influencing learning in schools. However, definitions of FA vary, and findings regarding the effectiveness of FA in mathematics education, specifically, are fragmentary. In this systematic review, we defined five FA components and integrated them into an overarching model. We identified 45 studies spanning the period 2015–2023 that investigated FA’s impact on cognitive and noncognitive learning in mathematics and yielded mixed results. Notably, computer-based assessments in interactive learning environments revealed particular promise. An analysis of the variations in study designs and characteristics provided insight into the factors that could contribute to the effectiveness of FA in progressing and promoting student learning, such as regular implementation over three months, content-specific learning intentions and measurement instruments, and randomized designs. An analysis of the reported moderator and mediator variables facilitated a more nuanced understanding of the effects of FA, highlighting its potential to support lower- to medium-performing students and those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, thus potentially contributing to educational equity. Based on our results, we recommend that future research should prioritize well-defined studies that investigate and describe FA in detail to comprehensively evaluate its potential in supporting mathematical education.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers and Education Open
- Vol. 8
How do help-seeking and help-abuse affect learning achievement in an interactive learning environment?
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers and Education Open
- Vol. 8
Open AccessHow do help-seeking and help-abuse affect learning achievement in an interactive learning environment?
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal für Mathematik-Didaktik
- Vol. 45 (2) , 1-27
How Do Multiplicative and Relational Thinking Contribute to Multidigit Division?
Multiplicative thinking (MT), relational thinking (RT), and multidigit division are highly important for facilitating the transition from arithmetic to algebra in the middle grades. The present study analyzed the extent to which the contribution of MT to multidigit division was mediated by 472 fourth- and fifth-grade students’ RT and how their RT supported the use of multiple and clever shortcut strategies for multidigit division. The MT measurement instrument mapped the progression from additive to multiplicative thinking in two proficiency levels, and the RT measurement instrument operationalized the progression from understanding and using relationships between numbers to understanding and using relationships between terms in four proficiency levels. RT was a complete mediator of the impact of MT on multidigit division and had a particularly strong influence on the use of 10 × N patterns and advanced strategies, including shortcut strategies.
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal für Mathematik-Didaktik
- Vol. 45 (2) , 1-27
Open AccessHow Do Multiplicative and Relational Thinking Contribute to Multidigit Division?
Multiplicative thinking (MT), relational thinking (RT), and multidigit division are highly important for facilitating the transition from arithmetic to algebra in the middle grades. The present study analyzed the extent to which the contribution of MT to multidigit division was mediated by 472 fourth- and fifth-grade students’ RT and how their RT supported the use of multiple and clever shortcut strategies for multidigit division. The MT measurement instrument mapped the progression from additive to multiplicative thinking in two proficiency levels, and the RT measurement instrument operationalized the progression from understanding and using relationships between numbers to understanding and using relationships between terms in four proficiency levels. RT was a complete mediator of the impact of MT on multidigit division and had a particularly strong influence on the use of 10 × N patterns and advanced strategies, including shortcut strategies.
- Open Access
- 22 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
- Vol. 27 (6) , 981-1008
Assessing student teachers’ procedural fluency and strategic competence in operating and mathematizing with natural and rational numbers
Procedural fluency and strategic competence in operating and mathematizing with natural and rational numbers are based on a flexible and meaningful use of mental models, strategies, and procedures. The study to be presented in this paper pursued the question as to which subdomains or tasks relating to procedural fluency and strategic competence at upper primary school level are particularly challenging for elementary school student teachers. The newly devised assessment instrument included mathematical problems from a wide variety of content domains such as numbers and operations with natural and rational numbers, place value, computational strategies, estimation, (inverse) proportion, combinatorics, mathematization, and word problems. A preceding theoretical task analysis ensured that the solution of the problems required adaptation of strategies and flexible reasoning about a procedure or a formula. In the assessment, each of the 15 tasks were presented to 280 first-semester student teachers. As the results of the analyses indicate, combinatorial problems and division problems with rational numbers proved to be particularly challenging for a large proportion of the participants. Supplemental qualitative analyses of solution pathways confirmed that the assessment tasks allowed for multiple solution pathways. The item difficulties could be explained by a lack of ability to link mental models, strategies, and procedures. The study makes a connection between theoretical and empirical research on educational standards and teacher education. It contributes to the international state of research about student teachers’ content knowledge by providing specific insights concerning procedural fluency and strategic competence.
- 22 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
- Vol. 27 (6) , 981-1008
Open AccessAssessing student teachers’ procedural fluency and strategic competence in operating and mathematizing with natural and rational numbers
Procedural fluency and strategic competence in operating and mathematizing with natural and rational numbers are based on a flexible and meaningful use of mental models, strategies, and procedures. The study to be presented in this paper pursued the question as to which subdomains or tasks relating to procedural fluency and strategic competence at upper primary school level are particularly challenging for elementary school student teachers. The newly devised assessment instrument included mathematical problems from a wide variety of content domains such as numbers and operations with natural and rational numbers, place value, computational strategies, estimation, (inverse) proportion, combinatorics, mathematization, and word problems. A preceding theoretical task analysis ensured that the solution of the problems required adaptation of strategies and flexible reasoning about a procedure or a formula. In the assessment, each of the 15 tasks were presented to 280 first-semester student teachers. As the results of the analyses indicate, combinatorial problems and division problems with rational numbers proved to be particularly challenging for a large proportion of the participants. Supplemental qualitative analyses of solution pathways confirmed that the assessment tasks allowed for multiple solution pathways. The item difficulties could be explained by a lack of ability to link mental models, strategies, and procedures. The study makes a connection between theoretical and empirical research on educational standards and teacher education. It contributes to the international state of research about student teachers’ content knowledge by providing specific insights concerning procedural fluency and strategic competence.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Scuola Universitaria Professionale Della Svizzera Italiana -D. Formazione E Apprendimento
- p. 496-502
Wie und mit welchem Erfolg dividieren angehende Primarlehrpersonen natürliche Zahlen, gemischte Brüche und Dezimalzahlen? Eine fokussierte Analyse mathematischen Wissens von Studienanfängern mit Folgerungen für die Ausbildung
Das Dividieren mit mehrstelligen Zahlen sowie das Verständnis und Operieren mit rationalen Zahlen ist für Schüler:innen herausfordernd und stellt zudem wichtige Grundlagen für ein erfolgreiches Weiterlernen in der Domäne Mathematik dar. Um Schüler:innen angemessen zu fördern, müssen Lehrpersonen selbst in der Lage sein, die zu bearbeitenden Probleme auf flexible, verstehensbasierte und kreative Weise zu lösen. Daher fokussiert die hier vorgestellte Studie auf mathematisches Wissen angehender Primarschullehrpersonen zur Division mit natürlichen und rationalen Zahlen. Zunächst wurde theoretisch analysiert, worauf Schwierigkeiten im Verständnis und in der prozeduralen Geläufigkeit zur Division zurückzuführen sein können. Darauf aufbauend wurden entsprechende Testaufgaben entwickelt und in Erhebungen mit angehenden Primarschullehrpersonen im ersten und dritten Semester eingesetzt. Die Befunde verdeutlichen, dass bei einem nennenswerten Anteil der Studierenden zum Studienbeginn sowie im dritten Semester Lücken im Verständnis und in der prozeduralen Geläufigkeit zur Division mit natürlichen und rationalen Zahlen bestehen. Die Befunde werden hinsichtlich ihrer Konsequenzen für die Gestaltung der fachdidaktischen Ausbildung angehender Primarschullehrpersonen und vor dem Hintergrund begrenzt zur Verfügung stehender Ausbildungszeit interpretiert und diskutiert.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Scuola Universitaria Professionale Della Svizzera Italiana -D. Formazione E Apprendimento
- p. 496-502
Open AccessWie und mit welchem Erfolg dividieren angehende Primarlehrpersonen natürliche Zahlen, gemischte Brüche und Dezimalzahlen? Eine fokussierte Analyse mathematischen Wissens von Studienanfängern mit Folgerungen für die Ausbildung
Das Dividieren mit mehrstelligen Zahlen sowie das Verständnis und Operieren mit rationalen Zahlen ist für Schüler:innen herausfordernd und stellt zudem wichtige Grundlagen für ein erfolgreiches Weiterlernen in der Domäne Mathematik dar. Um Schüler:innen angemessen zu fördern, müssen Lehrpersonen selbst in der Lage sein, die zu bearbeitenden Probleme auf flexible, verstehensbasierte und kreative Weise zu lösen. Daher fokussiert die hier vorgestellte Studie auf mathematisches Wissen angehender Primarschullehrpersonen zur Division mit natürlichen und rationalen Zahlen. Zunächst wurde theoretisch analysiert, worauf Schwierigkeiten im Verständnis und in der prozeduralen Geläufigkeit zur Division zurückzuführen sein können. Darauf aufbauend wurden entsprechende Testaufgaben entwickelt und in Erhebungen mit angehenden Primarschullehrpersonen im ersten und dritten Semester eingesetzt. Die Befunde verdeutlichen, dass bei einem nennenswerten Anteil der Studierenden zum Studienbeginn sowie im dritten Semester Lücken im Verständnis und in der prozeduralen Geläufigkeit zur Division mit natürlichen und rationalen Zahlen bestehen. Die Befunde werden hinsichtlich ihrer Konsequenzen für die Gestaltung der fachdidaktischen Ausbildung angehender Primarschullehrpersonen und vor dem Hintergrund begrenzt zur Verfügung stehender Ausbildungszeit interpretiert und diskutiert.
- 7 February 2019
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment
- Vol. 38 (4) , 426-444
The Use of a Diagnostic Competence Model About Children’s Operation Sense for Criterion-Referenced Individual Feedback in a Large-Scale Formative Assessment
We provide evidence of validity for a newly developed diagnostic competence model of operation sense, by both (a) describing the theoretically substantiated development of the competence model in close association with its use within a large-scale formative assessment and (b) providing empirical evidence for the theoretically described cognitive levels of competences. The competence model describes students’ operation sense on four distinct levels. On each level, the model elaborates on the characteristics of tasks that students on this level are able to answer correctly. Moreover, the model explains this by referring to two kinds of cognitive processes that are supposed to be necessary to respond to these kinds of tasks successfully. In a validation study, about 85% of the variance in the item difficulties was explained by the four, a priori allocated, levels of operation sense. We discuss the relevance of the validation of the diagnostic competence model for the provision of criterion-referenced feedback in a large-scale formative assessment, including suggestions for teachers’ subsequent support activities, and the contributions of the model to the state of research about operation sense.
- 7 February 2019
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment
- Vol. 38 (4) , 426-444
The Use of a Diagnostic Competence Model About Children’s Operation Sense for Criterion-Referenced Individual Feedback in a Large-Scale Formative Assessment
We provide evidence of validity for a newly developed diagnostic competence model of operation sense, by both (a) describing the theoretically substantiated development of the competence model in close association with its use within a large-scale formative assessment and (b) providing empirical evidence for the theoretically described cognitive levels of competences. The competence model describes students’ operation sense on four distinct levels. On each level, the model elaborates on the characteristics of tasks that students on this level are able to answer correctly. Moreover, the model explains this by referring to two kinds of cognitive processes that are supposed to be necessary to respond to these kinds of tasks successfully. In a validation study, about 85% of the variance in the item difficulties was explained by the four, a priori allocated, levels of operation sense. We discuss the relevance of the validation of the diagnostic competence model for the provision of criterion-referenced feedback in a large-scale formative assessment, including suggestions for teachers’ subsequent support activities, and the contributions of the model to the state of research about operation sense.
- 20 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mathematical Thinking and Learning
- Vol. 20 (2) , 108-141
Relational Reasoning about Numbers and Operations – Foundation for Calculation Strategy Use in Multi-Digit Multiplication and Division
Theoretical analysis of whole number-based calculation strategies and digit-based algorithms for multi-digit multiplication and division reveals that strategy use includes two kinds of reasoning: reasoning about the relations between numbers and reasoning about the relations between operations. In contrast, algorithms aim to reduce the necessary reasoning processes. In a sample of 221 German fourth graders, both kinds of relational reasoning were operationalized, as well as the use of strategies and algorithms in multiplication and division. The multi-dimensionality of the constructs and their discriminant validity were confirmed by a confirmatory factor analysis. The theoretically proposed, unidirectional relations between the constructs were investigated using a structural equation model: Abilities in reasoning about relations between numbers had a significant positive impact on strategy use in multiplication and division. Abilities in reasoning about relations between operations influenced strategy use in multiplication only. The use of algorithms in multiplication and division was exclusively affected by abilities in reasoning about relations between numbers, and not by abilities about relations between operations. Moreover, a negative effect of the use of digit-based algorithms on the use of whole number-based strategies was identified. Finally, the results of the theoretical and empirical analysis were integrated into a synthesis of existing models about calculation strategy use and development.
- 20 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mathematical Thinking and Learning
- Vol. 20 (2) , 108-141
Relational Reasoning about Numbers and Operations – Foundation for Calculation Strategy Use in Multi-Digit Multiplication and Division
Theoretical analysis of whole number-based calculation strategies and digit-based algorithms for multi-digit multiplication and division reveals that strategy use includes two kinds of reasoning: reasoning about the relations between numbers and reasoning about the relations between operations. In contrast, algorithms aim to reduce the necessary reasoning processes. In a sample of 221 German fourth graders, both kinds of relational reasoning were operationalized, as well as the use of strategies and algorithms in multiplication and division. The multi-dimensionality of the constructs and their discriminant validity were confirmed by a confirmatory factor analysis. The theoretically proposed, unidirectional relations between the constructs were investigated using a structural equation model: Abilities in reasoning about relations between numbers had a significant positive impact on strategy use in multiplication and division. Abilities in reasoning about relations between operations influenced strategy use in multiplication only. The use of algorithms in multiplication and division was exclusively affected by abilities in reasoning about relations between numbers, and not by abilities about relations between operations. Moreover, a negative effect of the use of digit-based algorithms on the use of whole number-based strategies was identified. Finally, the results of the theoretical and empirical analysis were integrated into a synthesis of existing models about calculation strategy use and development.