Frank Köhler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Frank Köhler has a total of 310 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Francesco Criscione
Australian Museum Research Institute
18 shared publications - Isabel T. Hyman
Australian Museum, Sydney, Australia
11 shared publications Matthias Glaubrecht
Department of Malacozoology, Museum of Natural History, Leibniz Institute for Research in Evolution and Biodiversity at the Humboldt University Berlin, Invalidenstrasse 43, 10115, Berlin, Germany
7 shared publicationsVince Kessner
Australian Museum Research Institute Australian Museum Sydney NSW Australia
7 shared publications- Guoyi Zhang
University of New South Wales
5 shared publications - Michael Shea
Australian Museum Research Institute 1 William Street 2010 Sydney New South Wales Australia
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 208 (2)
Not just a pretty keel: interpreting diversity patterns of Calliotropidae (Vetigastropoda: Seguenzioidea) in Australian deep waters through integrative taxonomy
The vetigastropod family Calliotropidae is an important and yet poorly understood component of deep-water benthic communities. In this study, the group is investigated through an integrative approach for the first time, with the aim of resolving its systematics in the Australian deep sea. Analyses of concatenated mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences revealed the existence in the region of eight clades, treated as primary species hypotheses (PSHs). Following additional evaluation of shell and radular features, as well as examination of geographic and bathymetric ranges, these PSHs were converted to secondary species hypotheses (SSHs). Our data suggested that Calliotropis and Solaricida represent two well-differentiated genera. Solaricida, here removed from the synonymy of Calliotropis, is distinguished by having an epipodial cylinder. Three species are assigned to Solaricida, one of which is new (Solaricida vorago sp. nov.). In addition, five species of Calliotropis are recognized, one being new (Calliotropis montismarini sp. nov.). Bathybembix abyssorum is transferred to Calliotropis based on its close phylogenetic relationships with other species in this genus. Based on the evidence available, the most likely speciation mechanisms involved are evaluated in the attempt to explain the diversity patterns of calliotropids in Australian deep waters.
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 208 (2)
Not just a pretty keel: interpreting diversity patterns of Calliotropidae (Vetigastropoda: Seguenzioidea) in Australian deep waters through integrative taxonomy
The vetigastropod family Calliotropidae is an important and yet poorly understood component of deep-water benthic communities. In this study, the group is investigated through an integrative approach for the first time, with the aim of resolving its systematics in the Australian deep sea. Analyses of concatenated mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences revealed the existence in the region of eight clades, treated as primary species hypotheses (PSHs). Following additional evaluation of shell and radular features, as well as examination of geographic and bathymetric ranges, these PSHs were converted to secondary species hypotheses (SSHs). Our data suggested that Calliotropis and Solaricida represent two well-differentiated genera. Solaricida, here removed from the synonymy of Calliotropis, is distinguished by having an epipodial cylinder. Three species are assigned to Solaricida, one of which is new (Solaricida vorago sp. nov.). In addition, five species of Calliotropis are recognized, one being new (Calliotropis montismarini sp. nov.). Bathybembix abyssorum is transferred to Calliotropis based on its close phylogenetic relationships with other species in this genus. Based on the evidence available, the most likely speciation mechanisms involved are evaluated in the attempt to explain the diversity patterns of calliotropids in Australian deep waters.
- Open Access
- 11 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 53 (7) , e70294
Barriers or Bridges? The Role of Streams in Shaping the Genetic Structure of the Australian Land Snail Sauroconcha grayi (Gastropoda, Camaenidae)
Aim: Short‐range endemic (SRE) terrestrial invertebrates, such as land snails, are of significant conservation concern due to their limited dispersal abilities and high susceptibility to habitat fragmentation. A central debate in landscape genetics, the River Barrier Hypothesis, posits that river systems act as major obstacles to gene flow, yet empirical evidence remains mixed, with some studies suggesting rivers may instead facilitate movement. To test the River Barrier Hypothesis by evaluating whether river systems act as barriers to gene flow in a short‐range endemic land snail, and to assess how landscape heterogeneity shapes population genetic structure and divergence. Our study can inform efforts to conserve the genetic diversity of SRE. Location: Sydney Basin, Hawkesbury and Hunter Valley, New South Wales, Australia. Taxon: Ourimbah Forest Snail ( Sauroconcha grayi ), Camaenidae. Methods: This study utilizes genome‐wide restriction site‐associated DNA sequencing (RAD‐seq) to investigate the fine‐scale population structure of an endemic land snail in central eastern New South Wales and estimate migration rates across a heterogeneous landscape. We also tested whether the river influences the genetic connectivity across different heterogeneous topographies using isolation by distance and isolation by resistance. Results: Structure analyses of genome‐wide single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) identified three spatially distinct genetic clusters, which are delimited by major hydrological features, specifically the Hunter and Hawkesbury Rivers. Patterns of genetic differentiation were heterogeneous across the landscape, revealing variation that corresponded with underlying topographic context and hydrological configuration. We identified rugged terrain areas where rivers corresponded with marked genetic discontinuities, indicating their role as barriers to gene flow, and plain areas where these barrier effects were reduced or absent. Main Conclusions: The results conditionally support the River Barrier Hypothesis. Landscape heterogeneity, particularly interactions between topography and hydrology, plays a critical role in structuring genetic variation in short‐range endemic taxa. Conservation strategies for S. grayi in rugged terrain should prioritize networks of multiple small reserves to preserve geographically structured and genetically distinct lineages.
- 11 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 53 (7) , e70294
Open AccessBarriers or Bridges? The Role of Streams in Shaping the Genetic Structure of the Australian Land Snail Sauroconcha grayi (Gastropoda, Camaenidae)
Aim: Short‐range endemic (SRE) terrestrial invertebrates, such as land snails, are of significant conservation concern due to their limited dispersal abilities and high susceptibility to habitat fragmentation. A central debate in landscape genetics, the River Barrier Hypothesis, posits that river systems act as major obstacles to gene flow, yet empirical evidence remains mixed, with some studies suggesting rivers may instead facilitate movement. To test the River Barrier Hypothesis by evaluating whether river systems act as barriers to gene flow in a short‐range endemic land snail, and to assess how landscape heterogeneity shapes population genetic structure and divergence. Our study can inform efforts to conserve the genetic diversity of SRE. Location: Sydney Basin, Hawkesbury and Hunter Valley, New South Wales, Australia. Taxon: Ourimbah Forest Snail ( Sauroconcha grayi ), Camaenidae. Methods: This study utilizes genome‐wide restriction site‐associated DNA sequencing (RAD‐seq) to investigate the fine‐scale population structure of an endemic land snail in central eastern New South Wales and estimate migration rates across a heterogeneous landscape. We also tested whether the river influences the genetic connectivity across different heterogeneous topographies using isolation by distance and isolation by resistance. Results: Structure analyses of genome‐wide single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) identified three spatially distinct genetic clusters, which are delimited by major hydrological features, specifically the Hunter and Hawkesbury Rivers. Patterns of genetic differentiation were heterogeneous across the landscape, revealing variation that corresponded with underlying topographic context and hydrological configuration. We identified rugged terrain areas where rivers corresponded with marked genetic discontinuities, indicating their role as barriers to gene flow, and plain areas where these barrier effects were reduced or absent. Main Conclusions: The results conditionally support the River Barrier Hypothesis. Landscape heterogeneity, particularly interactions between topography and hydrology, plays a critical role in structuring genetic variation in short‐range endemic taxa. Conservation strategies for S. grayi in rugged terrain should prioritize networks of multiple small reserves to preserve geographically structured and genetically distinct lineages.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Australian Museum in Technical Reports of the Australian Museum, Online
- Vol. 44, 1-8
Community-driven survey of land snails in three communal conservation areas in East Kwaio, Malaita, Solomon Islands
In collaboration with the Kwainaa’isi Cultural Centre and Baru Conservation Alliance, we undertook a survey of the land snails of East Kwaio, Malaita, Solomon Islands with emphasis on the species inventory of three communal conservation reserves. This report is based on three visits to the region in April 2019 and November 2023. We conducted collective visual searches at five main survey sites recording 35 species of land snails based on morphological examinations. We collected 186 sample vouchers that are deposited in the malacological collection of the Australian Museum as resource for on-going taxonomic research aimed at an enhanced documentation of the land snail fauna of Malaita. Considering an inevitable sampling bias, we conclude that the land snail faunas of all three conservation sites are rather similar and that collectively the three reserves contain a representative fraction of the overall land snail diversity in central Malaita. Therefore, the reserves fulfil their intended role of preserving Malaita’s land snail species for the future.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Australian Museum in Technical Reports of the Australian Museum, Online
- Vol. 44, 1-8
Community-driven survey of land snails in three communal conservation areas in East Kwaio, Malaita, Solomon Islands
In collaboration with the Kwainaa’isi Cultural Centre and Baru Conservation Alliance, we undertook a survey of the land snails of East Kwaio, Malaita, Solomon Islands with emphasis on the species inventory of three communal conservation reserves. This report is based on three visits to the region in April 2019 and November 2023. We conducted collective visual searches at five main survey sites recording 35 species of land snails based on morphological examinations. We collected 186 sample vouchers that are deposited in the malacological collection of the Australian Museum as resource for on-going taxonomic research aimed at an enhanced documentation of the land snail fauna of Malaita. Considering an inevitable sampling bias, we conclude that the land snail faunas of all three conservation sites are rather similar and that collectively the three reserves contain a representative fraction of the overall land snail diversity in central Malaita. Therefore, the reserves fulfil their intended role of preserving Malaita’s land snail species for the future.
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Molluscan Research
- Vol. 46 (2) , 112-121
Systematic relationships of Australian Pupilloidea based on analyses of nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Molluscan Research
- Vol. 46 (2) , 112-121
Systematic relationships of Australian Pupilloidea based on analyses of nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences
- Open Access
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Australian Museum in Technical Reports of the Australian Museum, Online
- Vol. 43, 1-7
Targeted surveys for two threatened, short-range endemic land snails in the southern MacDonnell Ranges, Northern Territory
The MacDonnell Ranges bioregion in the southern Northern Territory is a centre of land snail endemism in arid Australia, and a high proportion of species are listed as threatened under Northern Territory legislation. We sought to locate extant populations of two endemic and threatened land snails, each known only from a single location. We recorded the first live individuals of Tateropa aemula (Charopidae, Stylommatophora) at Penny Springs in Watarrka National Park since the type material was collected 131 years ago. We did not detect this species at other spring sites in this national park. We also located Divellomelon hillieri (Camaenidae, Stylommatophora) alive at one of two sites where it was previously recorded in Palm Valley, Finke Gorge National Park. The total area of occupancy at this site was ~0.6 hectares. Excluding wildfire from the habitat of both species through strategic fire breaks is a high priority, as well as removal of invasive buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris) at the D. hillieri site. We recommend that an updated conservation assessment is undertaken for T. aemula based on current knowledge of its distribution and threats. Further targeted survey should be undertaken for D. hillieri before undertaking a revised conservation assessment. We also report on other land snail species recorded during our surveys at both national parks.
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Australian Museum in Technical Reports of the Australian Museum, Online
- Vol. 43, 1-7
Open AccessTargeted surveys for two threatened, short-range endemic land snails in the southern MacDonnell Ranges, Northern Territory
The MacDonnell Ranges bioregion in the southern Northern Territory is a centre of land snail endemism in arid Australia, and a high proportion of species are listed as threatened under Northern Territory legislation. We sought to locate extant populations of two endemic and threatened land snails, each known only from a single location. We recorded the first live individuals of Tateropa aemula (Charopidae, Stylommatophora) at Penny Springs in Watarrka National Park since the type material was collected 131 years ago. We did not detect this species at other spring sites in this national park. We also located Divellomelon hillieri (Camaenidae, Stylommatophora) alive at one of two sites where it was previously recorded in Palm Valley, Finke Gorge National Park. The total area of occupancy at this site was ~0.6 hectares. Excluding wildfire from the habitat of both species through strategic fire breaks is a high priority, as well as removal of invasive buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris) at the D. hillieri site. We recommend that an updated conservation assessment is undertaken for T. aemula based on current knowledge of its distribution and threats. Further targeted survey should be undertaken for D. hillieri before undertaking a revised conservation assessment. We also report on other land snail species recorded during our surveys at both national parks.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 205 (4)
More than just a dot: the enigmatic ‘large’ Punctidae of Lord Howe Island (Gastropoda: Stylommatophora)
Punctidae are a family of mostly minute, poorly known land snails with a nearly worldwide distribution. Studies of Australian species are primarily shell-based. We herein revise one of two punctid radiations found on Lord Howe Island located in the Tasman Sea, which encompasses Australia’s largest punctid species. We comprehensively revise the taxonomy of this group, which encompasses three nominal genera, Dignamoconcha, Pernastela, and Charopella, using comparative morpho-anatomy and phylogenetic analyses of mitochondrial (COI, 16S) and nuclear (ITS2, ELAVI8) DNA revealing it to form a single radiation. We treat Pernastela and Charopella as junior synonyms of Dignamoconcha, demonstrate that ‘Pernastela’ gnoma is not a member of this radiation, and synonymize the species Pernastela howensis with Dignamoconcha charon and Charopella zela with Dignamoconcha wilkinsoni, respectively. Dignamoconcha as newly delimited contains three accepted species: D. dulcissima, D. charon, and D. wilkinsoni. In addition, our study shows that Scelidoropa is not a member of Cystopeltidae as previously thought, but is sister to (Charopidae + Punctidae). However, other species formerly assigned to Charopidae are found to be cystopeltids. Radular morphology has utility in identifying higher level groups, such as Punctidae and Scelidoropa, but cannot be used to distinguish between the Cystopeltidae and the Charopidae.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 205 (4)
More than just a dot: the enigmatic ‘large’ Punctidae of Lord Howe Island (Gastropoda: Stylommatophora)
Punctidae are a family of mostly minute, poorly known land snails with a nearly worldwide distribution. Studies of Australian species are primarily shell-based. We herein revise one of two punctid radiations found on Lord Howe Island located in the Tasman Sea, which encompasses Australia’s largest punctid species. We comprehensively revise the taxonomy of this group, which encompasses three nominal genera, Dignamoconcha, Pernastela, and Charopella, using comparative morpho-anatomy and phylogenetic analyses of mitochondrial (COI, 16S) and nuclear (ITS2, ELAVI8) DNA revealing it to form a single radiation. We treat Pernastela and Charopella as junior synonyms of Dignamoconcha, demonstrate that ‘Pernastela’ gnoma is not a member of this radiation, and synonymize the species Pernastela howensis with Dignamoconcha charon and Charopella zela with Dignamoconcha wilkinsoni, respectively. Dignamoconcha as newly delimited contains three accepted species: D. dulcissima, D. charon, and D. wilkinsoni. In addition, our study shows that Scelidoropa is not a member of Cystopeltidae as previously thought, but is sister to (Charopidae + Punctidae). However, other species formerly assigned to Charopidae are found to be cystopeltids. Radular morphology has utility in identifying higher level groups, such as Punctidae and Scelidoropa, but cannot be used to distinguish between the Cystopeltidae and the Charopidae.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 205 (4)
When discrete characters are wanting: continuous character integration under the phylospecies concept informs the revision of the Australian land snail Thersites (Eupulmonata, Camaenidae)
Species that are predominantly characterized by continuous instead of discrete morphological characters pose a challenge to species delimitation. Under the phylospecies concept, species are delimited by apomorphies, which are difficult to establish when characters are not discrete. In the present study, we address these challenges in the Australian land snail genus Thersites (family Camaenidae), where accepted species exhibit a scarcity of discrete distinguishing characters and differ in a limited range of continuous characters according to prior taxonomic studies. We integrate analyses of genome-scale molecular data with evaluations of several continuous, qualitative, and discrete morphological characters derived from landmarks to delineate species by identifying apomorphies. We found that dimensions of shell and genitals overlapped considerably among the currently accepted species. These overlaps may indicate morphospace saturation, which may affect species delineation through the gen-morph species concept. Statistical methods, such as Dunn’s test, failed to consistently delineate monophyletic taxa. Additionally, we could not derive apomorphies from discretized landmarks for the prevalence of outlier specimens. However, applying the Kruskal–Wallis test at certain nodes of the tree revealed significant differences in some continuous characters. We propose that these inferred differences represent apomorphies of taxonomic lineages. Ultimately, we suggest based on our findings that of the four currently accepted species, two should be synonymized. To maintain monophyly of taxa, we synonymize Thersites mitchellae with Thersites novaehollandiae and Thersites darlingtoni with Thersites richmondiana. Distinct character states of the umbilicus support the existence of two independent lineages: one with an open (T. sp1 + T. sp2) and one with a closed umbilicus (T. novaehollandiae + T. richmondiana). Overall, the Kruskal–Wallis tests support four distinct species, T. novaehollandiae and T. richmondiana plus two newly described species, Thersites kaputarensis sp. nov. and Thersites coolahensis sp. nov.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Vol. 205 (4)
Open AccessWhen discrete characters are wanting: continuous character integration under the phylospecies concept informs the revision of the Australian land snail Thersites (Eupulmonata, Camaenidae)
Species that are predominantly characterized by continuous instead of discrete morphological characters pose a challenge to species delimitation. Under the phylospecies concept, species are delimited by apomorphies, which are difficult to establish when characters are not discrete. In the present study, we address these challenges in the Australian land snail genus Thersites (family Camaenidae), where accepted species exhibit a scarcity of discrete distinguishing characters and differ in a limited range of continuous characters according to prior taxonomic studies. We integrate analyses of genome-scale molecular data with evaluations of several continuous, qualitative, and discrete morphological characters derived from landmarks to delineate species by identifying apomorphies. We found that dimensions of shell and genitals overlapped considerably among the currently accepted species. These overlaps may indicate morphospace saturation, which may affect species delineation through the gen-morph species concept. Statistical methods, such as Dunn’s test, failed to consistently delineate monophyletic taxa. Additionally, we could not derive apomorphies from discretized landmarks for the prevalence of outlier specimens. However, applying the Kruskal–Wallis test at certain nodes of the tree revealed significant differences in some continuous characters. We propose that these inferred differences represent apomorphies of taxonomic lineages. Ultimately, we suggest based on our findings that of the four currently accepted species, two should be synonymized. To maintain monophyly of taxa, we synonymize Thersites mitchellae with Thersites novaehollandiae and Thersites darlingtoni with Thersites richmondiana. Distinct character states of the umbilicus support the existence of two independent lineages: one with an open (T. sp1 + T. sp2) and one with a closed umbilicus (T. novaehollandiae + T. richmondiana). Overall, the Kruskal–Wallis tests support four distinct species, T. novaehollandiae and T. richmondiana plus two newly described species, Thersites kaputarensis sp. nov. and Thersites coolahensis sp. nov.
- 17 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (12)
Aridification Shaped the Diversification of Bothriembryon Land Snails in a Global Biodiversity Hotspot
Aim: Resolving the spatio‐temporal diversification patterns and systematic relationships of endemic Australian land snails against the backdrop of Neogene aridification through analyses of a combined nuclear and mitochondrial DNA sequence dataset. Location: Western Australia. Taxon: Mollusca, Stylommatophora, Bothriembryontidae, Bothriembryon. Methods: We employed Bayesian Inference and Maximum Likelihood to reconstruct the phylogenetic relationships in a group of Australian land snails using mitochondrial (COI, 16S) and nuclear (ANT) DNA sequences. Divergence times have been estimated by employing optimised molecular clocks using BEAST2, and RelTime in MEGA12. Speciation and net‐diversification rates have been modelled using revBayes to visualise diversification dynamics in lineage‐through‐time (LTT) plots. We employed automated species delimitation methods ASAP and bPTP to estimate taxonomic diversity. Results: Our final sequence dataset contained 1052 new DNA sequences from 374 individuals, representing 97% of all accepted species plus 26 putatively new species based on morphology and distribution. Recognizing almost three times as many candidate species, both DNA‐based species delimitation methods have excessively inflated diversity estimates, casting doubt on the usefulness of these methods in groups with marked phylogeographic structure. Nine well‐supported principal clades were recovered. Fossil‐calibrated chronograms revealed an early bifurcation of Bothriembryon followed by an accumulation of lineages over time. LTT plots revealed a relative flattening of the speciation curve from 15 to 10 Ma on. However, we also detected a steep increase in intraspecific lineage diversification during the last approx. 1 Ma. The modeled speciation and net diversification rates have continuously declined over the last 25 Ma, while extinction rates have remained relatively steady until about 5 Ma, when they also started to climb. Main Conclusions: Declining diversification rates during much of the Neogene, followed by increasing extinction rates, coincided with increasing aridity throughout Western Australia. A more recent increase in lineage diversification rates, driven by intraspecific differentiation, coincides with the rise of mesic conditions since the end of the Pleistocene. Both trends imply that through influencing extinction and diversification rates, historical climate change has likely contributed to shaping the current distribution patterns in Bothriembryon land snails that are characterised by fragmentation. Moreover, by uncovering many undescribed taxa, including multiple short‐range endemics, this study highlights the importance of continued conservation efforts in this globally important biodiversity hotspot. Key habitats, such as lithorefugia, in an otherwise harsh and exposed landscape are important strongholds for Bothriembryon to weather the impact of aridification.
- 17 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (12)
Aridification Shaped the Diversification of Bothriembryon Land Snails in a Global Biodiversity Hotspot
Aim: Resolving the spatio‐temporal diversification patterns and systematic relationships of endemic Australian land snails against the backdrop of Neogene aridification through analyses of a combined nuclear and mitochondrial DNA sequence dataset. Location: Western Australia. Taxon: Mollusca, Stylommatophora, Bothriembryontidae, Bothriembryon. Methods: We employed Bayesian Inference and Maximum Likelihood to reconstruct the phylogenetic relationships in a group of Australian land snails using mitochondrial (COI, 16S) and nuclear (ANT) DNA sequences. Divergence times have been estimated by employing optimised molecular clocks using BEAST2, and RelTime in MEGA12. Speciation and net‐diversification rates have been modelled using revBayes to visualise diversification dynamics in lineage‐through‐time (LTT) plots. We employed automated species delimitation methods ASAP and bPTP to estimate taxonomic diversity. Results: Our final sequence dataset contained 1052 new DNA sequences from 374 individuals, representing 97% of all accepted species plus 26 putatively new species based on morphology and distribution. Recognizing almost three times as many candidate species, both DNA‐based species delimitation methods have excessively inflated diversity estimates, casting doubt on the usefulness of these methods in groups with marked phylogeographic structure. Nine well‐supported principal clades were recovered. Fossil‐calibrated chronograms revealed an early bifurcation of Bothriembryon followed by an accumulation of lineages over time. LTT plots revealed a relative flattening of the speciation curve from 15 to 10 Ma on. However, we also detected a steep increase in intraspecific lineage diversification during the last approx. 1 Ma. The modeled speciation and net diversification rates have continuously declined over the last 25 Ma, while extinction rates have remained relatively steady until about 5 Ma, when they also started to climb. Main Conclusions: Declining diversification rates during much of the Neogene, followed by increasing extinction rates, coincided with increasing aridity throughout Western Australia. A more recent increase in lineage diversification rates, driven by intraspecific differentiation, coincides with the rise of mesic conditions since the end of the Pleistocene. Both trends imply that through influencing extinction and diversification rates, historical climate change has likely contributed to shaping the current distribution patterns in Bothriembryon land snails that are characterised by fragmentation. Moreover, by uncovering many undescribed taxa, including multiple short‐range endemics, this study highlights the importance of continued conservation efforts in this globally important biodiversity hotspot. Key habitats, such as lithorefugia, in an otherwise harsh and exposed landscape are important strongholds for Bothriembryon to weather the impact of aridification.
- Open Access
When discrete characters are wanting: Continuous character integration under the phylospecies concept informs the revision of the Australian land snail Thersites (Eupulmonata, Camaenidae)
Species that are predominantly characterized by continuous instead of discrete morphological characters pose a challenge to species delimitation. Under the phylospecies concept, species are delimited by apomorphies, which are difficult to establish when characters are not discrete. In the present study, we address these challenges in the Australian land snail genus Thersites (family Camaenidae), where accepted species exhibit a scarcity of discrete distinguishing characters and differ in a limited range of continuous characters according to prior taxonomic studies. We integrate analyses of genome-scale molecular data with evaluations of several continuous, qualitative, and discrete morphological characters derived from landmarks to delineate species by identifying apomorphies. We found that dimensions of shell and genitals overlapped considerably among the currently accepted species. These overlaps may indicate morphospace saturation, which may affect species delineation through the gen-morph species concept. Statistical methods, such as Dunn’s test, failed to consistently delineate monophyletic taxa. Additionally, we could not derive apomorphies from discretized landmarks for the prevalence of outlier specimens. However, applying the Kruskal-Wallis test at certain nodes of the tree revealed significant differences in some continuous characters. We propose that these inferred differences represent apomorphies of taxonomic lineages. Ultimately, we suggest based on our findings that of the four currently accepted species, two should be synonymized. To maintain monophyly of taxa, we synonymize Thersites mitchellae with T. novaehollandiae and T. darlingtoni with T. richmondiana . Distinct character states of the umbilicus support the existence of two independent lineages: One with an open ( T . sp1 + T . sp2) and one with a closed umbilicus ( T. novaehollandiae + T. richmondiana ). Overall, the Kruskal-Wallis tests support four distinct species, T. novaehollandiae and T. richmondiana plus two newly described species.
Open AccessWhen discrete characters are wanting: Continuous character integration under the phylospecies concept informs the revision of the Australian land snail Thersites (Eupulmonata, Camaenidae)
Species that are predominantly characterized by continuous instead of discrete morphological characters pose a challenge to species delimitation. Under the phylospecies concept, species are delimited by apomorphies, which are difficult to establish when characters are not discrete. In the present study, we address these challenges in the Australian land snail genus Thersites (family Camaenidae), where accepted species exhibit a scarcity of discrete distinguishing characters and differ in a limited range of continuous characters according to prior taxonomic studies. We integrate analyses of genome-scale molecular data with evaluations of several continuous, qualitative, and discrete morphological characters derived from landmarks to delineate species by identifying apomorphies. We found that dimensions of shell and genitals overlapped considerably among the currently accepted species. These overlaps may indicate morphospace saturation, which may affect species delineation through the gen-morph species concept. Statistical methods, such as Dunn’s test, failed to consistently delineate monophyletic taxa. Additionally, we could not derive apomorphies from discretized landmarks for the prevalence of outlier specimens. However, applying the Kruskal-Wallis test at certain nodes of the tree revealed significant differences in some continuous characters. We propose that these inferred differences represent apomorphies of taxonomic lineages. Ultimately, we suggest based on our findings that of the four currently accepted species, two should be synonymized. To maintain monophyly of taxa, we synonymize Thersites mitchellae with T. novaehollandiae and T. darlingtoni with T. richmondiana . Distinct character states of the umbilicus support the existence of two independent lineages: One with an open ( T . sp1 + T . sp2) and one with a closed umbilicus ( T. novaehollandiae + T. richmondiana ). Overall, the Kruskal-Wallis tests support four distinct species, T. novaehollandiae and T. richmondiana plus two newly described species.
- Open Access
On the impact of reference selection on variant calling in phylogenomics: How to avoid systematic error in target-enrichment studies of non-model organisms
Target-enrichment methods are widely used in phylogenomic studies aiming to reconstruct the relationships among diverse groups of organisms. When building phylogenomic datasets from short sequencer reads, software pipelines need to accurately align short sequencer reads to the target and identify the genetic variation in homologous DNA sequences. Variant calling, a crucial step in this process, is known to be error-prone in a phylogenetic analysis framework as it requires a conspecific reference as a template. To avoid problems relating to reference choice, existing target-enrichment pipelines often skip variant calling entirely using work-arounds. This study investigates the effect of reference genome selection on the reliability of variant calling and assesses the consequences of reference genome choice on phylogenomic analyses downstream. Employing an empirical exon capture sequence dataset, we examine how variant detection is influenced by reference genome choice. We reconstructed and analysed phylogenomic sequence datasets from short sequencer reads, which includes steps of quality control, read mapping, variant calling, multiple sequence alignment and phylogenetic analysis. We assembled the same exon capture dataset by using four different references for variant calling. These references were (1) a distantly related species, (2) a single ingroup sample, (3) a composite of all ingroup samples, and (4) a self-derived reference for each sample. We found that reference choice significantly impacted the variant detection and that these differences in variant detection influenced the phylogenetic reconstructions downstream. Comparing multiple sequence alignments and phylogenetic trees produced using different references revealed that employing a sample-specific self-reference for variant calling maximizes the accuracy of the variant detection process. Based on this finding, we recommend incorporating self-referenced variant calling in the assembly of phylogenomic datasets to ensure robustness and reproducibility, especially for datasets characterized by low read coverage.
Open AccessOn the impact of reference selection on variant calling in phylogenomics: How to avoid systematic error in target-enrichment studies of non-model organisms
Target-enrichment methods are widely used in phylogenomic studies aiming to reconstruct the relationships among diverse groups of organisms. When building phylogenomic datasets from short sequencer reads, software pipelines need to accurately align short sequencer reads to the target and identify the genetic variation in homologous DNA sequences. Variant calling, a crucial step in this process, is known to be error-prone in a phylogenetic analysis framework as it requires a conspecific reference as a template. To avoid problems relating to reference choice, existing target-enrichment pipelines often skip variant calling entirely using work-arounds. This study investigates the effect of reference genome selection on the reliability of variant calling and assesses the consequences of reference genome choice on phylogenomic analyses downstream. Employing an empirical exon capture sequence dataset, we examine how variant detection is influenced by reference genome choice. We reconstructed and analysed phylogenomic sequence datasets from short sequencer reads, which includes steps of quality control, read mapping, variant calling, multiple sequence alignment and phylogenetic analysis. We assembled the same exon capture dataset by using four different references for variant calling. These references were (1) a distantly related species, (2) a single ingroup sample, (3) a composite of all ingroup samples, and (4) a self-derived reference for each sample. We found that reference choice significantly impacted the variant detection and that these differences in variant detection influenced the phylogenetic reconstructions downstream. Comparing multiple sequence alignments and phylogenetic trees produced using different references revealed that employing a sample-specific self-reference for variant calling maximizes the accuracy of the variant detection process. Based on this finding, we recommend incorporating self-referenced variant calling in the assembly of phylogenomic datasets to ensure robustness and reproducibility, especially for datasets characterized by low read coverage.