Danya Bakhbakhi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Danya Bakhbakhi has a total of 191 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Christy Burden
Translational Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
19 shared publications- Anna Davies
Academic Women’s Health Unit, Translational Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
15 shared publications Abigail Fraser
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
13 shared publications- Abi Merriel
University of Liverpool, UK
11 shared publications Mary Lynch
Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
11 shared publicationsLaura Timlin
North Bristol NHS Trust, Bristol, United Kingdom
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (5) , e0347544
What outcomes are important to families with a lived experience of stillbirth? A qualitative study to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care
Objective: To identify outcomes that are important to families, to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research. Design: Qualitative interview study. Setting: A national study in the United Kingdom. Population: A diverse sample of parents with a personal history of stillbirth were interviewed. Methods: Data collection, coding and analysis were influenced by a modified Grounded Theory approach. Parents’ lived experiences of stillbirth were translated into outcomes for the purpose of developing a core outcome set. Results: Forty parents and family members were interviewed. Analysis identified 349 potential care outcomes, 303 (87%) of which have not been previously reported by stillbirth care studies. Outcomes were organised into four major care outcome themes: 1) Clinical 2) Mental health and wellbeing 3) Social and family 4) Future pregnancy and children. Short- and long-term outcomes related to the labour, birth, investigations to understand why a baby had died, stillbirth in a multiple pregnancy, postpartum, psychological and subsequent pregnancy care were reported. Outcomes infrequently measured in previous stillbirth care research yet discussed by most participants were social isolation, impact on occupation and need for mental health support. Parents spoke of the importance of counselling to help them understand their grief, however, the provision of this service was reported to be varied throughout the UK. Conclusion: A comprehensive outcome inventory has now been constructed, from which the final core outcome set will be determined. Future care should be developed and evaluated using outcomes that directly relate to the lived experiences of parents and families exposed to stillbirth.
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (5) , e0347544
Open AccessWhat outcomes are important to families with a lived experience of stillbirth? A qualitative study to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care
Objective: To identify outcomes that are important to families, to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research. Design: Qualitative interview study. Setting: A national study in the United Kingdom. Population: A diverse sample of parents with a personal history of stillbirth were interviewed. Methods: Data collection, coding and analysis were influenced by a modified Grounded Theory approach. Parents’ lived experiences of stillbirth were translated into outcomes for the purpose of developing a core outcome set. Results: Forty parents and family members were interviewed. Analysis identified 349 potential care outcomes, 303 (87%) of which have not been previously reported by stillbirth care studies. Outcomes were organised into four major care outcome themes: 1) Clinical 2) Mental health and wellbeing 3) Social and family 4) Future pregnancy and children. Short- and long-term outcomes related to the labour, birth, investigations to understand why a baby had died, stillbirth in a multiple pregnancy, postpartum, psychological and subsequent pregnancy care were reported. Outcomes infrequently measured in previous stillbirth care research yet discussed by most participants were social isolation, impact on occupation and need for mental health support. Parents spoke of the importance of counselling to help them understand their grief, however, the provision of this service was reported to be varied throughout the UK. Conclusion: A comprehensive outcome inventory has now been constructed, from which the final core outcome set will be determined. Future care should be developed and evaluated using outcomes that directly relate to the lived experiences of parents and families exposed to stillbirth.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Wiley
Luteal phase progesterone to prevent recurrent miscarriage and improve live birth: A systematic review
Objective: Preventing recurrent miscarriage is a top research priority, for which luteal phase progesterone is a potential treatment. A systematic review was conducted to investigate the available evidence on luteal phase progesterone supplementation to reduce miscarriage, increase live birth rate and improve pregnancy outcomes in women and birthing people with a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage. Evidence review: Pubmed, Cochrane Library, Ovid MEDLINE, Ovid EMBASE, CINAHL and ClinicalTrials.gov were systematically searched in 05/2025 to identify English-language, peer-reviewed, randomised-controlled trials and observational studies involving human participants published from the year 2000 onwards. This study adhered to PRISMA guidelines. Participants had a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage who were prescribed luteal phase progesterone or placebo/usual care. Primary outcomes were miscarriage and live birth. Additional outcomes were informed by the miscarriage prevention core outcome set. Two independent reviewers conducted screening and study selection. Our protocol was pre-registered (PROSPERO CRD:420250653486). Results: A systematic search yielded 6722 studies. None of the 47 articles that underwent full text review met eligibility criteria. Three observational studies were identified however, due to differences in population characteristics or study design, none were eligible for inclusion. This highlights a significant gap in evidence. Conclusion: No evidence was identified linking luteal phase progesterone treatment to a reduction in miscarriage or increase in live births in women and birthing people with a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage. A feasibility trial investigating treatment acceptability and adherence is proposed. This will subsequently support a definitive trial assessing clinical effectiveness, providing high quality evidence on luteal progesterone supplementation in recurrent miscarriage care.
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessLuteal phase progesterone to prevent recurrent miscarriage and improve live birth: A systematic review
Objective: Preventing recurrent miscarriage is a top research priority, for which luteal phase progesterone is a potential treatment. A systematic review was conducted to investigate the available evidence on luteal phase progesterone supplementation to reduce miscarriage, increase live birth rate and improve pregnancy outcomes in women and birthing people with a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage. Evidence review: Pubmed, Cochrane Library, Ovid MEDLINE, Ovid EMBASE, CINAHL and ClinicalTrials.gov were systematically searched in 05/2025 to identify English-language, peer-reviewed, randomised-controlled trials and observational studies involving human participants published from the year 2000 onwards. This study adhered to PRISMA guidelines. Participants had a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage who were prescribed luteal phase progesterone or placebo/usual care. Primary outcomes were miscarriage and live birth. Additional outcomes were informed by the miscarriage prevention core outcome set. Two independent reviewers conducted screening and study selection. Our protocol was pre-registered (PROSPERO CRD:420250653486). Results: A systematic search yielded 6722 studies. None of the 47 articles that underwent full text review met eligibility criteria. Three observational studies were identified however, due to differences in population characteristics or study design, none were eligible for inclusion. This highlights a significant gap in evidence. Conclusion: No evidence was identified linking luteal phase progesterone treatment to a reduction in miscarriage or increase in live births in women and birthing people with a history of unexplained recurrent miscarriage. A feasibility trial investigating treatment acceptability and adherence is proposed. This will subsequently support a definitive trial assessing clinical effectiveness, providing high quality evidence on luteal progesterone supplementation in recurrent miscarriage care.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
- Vol. 133 (3) , 520-531
What Should Be Discussed When Considering a Vaginal Birth? A Delphi Consensus Study
Objective: Spontaneous vaginal births are often the presumed choice, representing 45% of UK births. However, information about benefits and risks is inconsistently given, impacting decision‐making and experience. A Core Information Set (CIS) is an agreed set of information points discussed prior to a decision. We aimed to develop a CIS for vaginal birth. Design: A Delphi study was used to create the CIS. Information points were identified from a literature search, patient leaflets, interviews, and a survey. These informed a two‐round Delphi survey, where stakeholders rated item importance. Items rated critically important by ≥ 80% of parents or professionals, and of limited importance by < 15%, progressed to consensus meetings, where 20 parents and professionals discussed retained items. The final CIS was populated with an engagement group ensuring accessibility. Setting: The study took place in the UK, with participants recruited online. Population: Pregnant and postnatal women, birth partners, healthcare professionals, medicolegal professionals, and representatives from relevant organizations. Main Outcome: A CIS for vaginal birth. Results: 77 information items were identified. In round 1 (631 participants) of the Delphi Survey, 84.5% were from the patient group and 15.5% from the professional group; in round 2 (228 participants), 74.3% were from the patient group and 25.7% from the professional group. 29 items met the criteria for consensus discussion. The final CIS includes 19 information points addressing: labour process, pain relief, labour complications, procedures or interventions during labour, experiences after birth, outcomes for the baby and labour environment. Conclusions: This CIS can facilitate discussions and support informed decision‐making about vaginal birth.
- 18 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
- Vol. 133 (3) , 520-531
Open AccessWhat Should Be Discussed When Considering a Vaginal Birth? A Delphi Consensus Study
Objective: Spontaneous vaginal births are often the presumed choice, representing 45% of UK births. However, information about benefits and risks is inconsistently given, impacting decision‐making and experience. A Core Information Set (CIS) is an agreed set of information points discussed prior to a decision. We aimed to develop a CIS for vaginal birth. Design: A Delphi study was used to create the CIS. Information points were identified from a literature search, patient leaflets, interviews, and a survey. These informed a two‐round Delphi survey, where stakeholders rated item importance. Items rated critically important by ≥ 80% of parents or professionals, and of limited importance by < 15%, progressed to consensus meetings, where 20 parents and professionals discussed retained items. The final CIS was populated with an engagement group ensuring accessibility. Setting: The study took place in the UK, with participants recruited online. Population: Pregnant and postnatal women, birth partners, healthcare professionals, medicolegal professionals, and representatives from relevant organizations. Main Outcome: A CIS for vaginal birth. Results: 77 information items were identified. In round 1 (631 participants) of the Delphi Survey, 84.5% were from the patient group and 15.5% from the professional group; in round 2 (228 participants), 74.3% were from the patient group and 25.7% from the professional group. 29 items met the criteria for consensus discussion. The final CIS includes 19 information points addressing: labour process, pain relief, labour complications, procedures or interventions during labour, experiences after birth, outcomes for the baby and labour environment. Conclusions: This CIS can facilitate discussions and support informed decision‐making about vaginal birth.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
- Vol. 132 (13) , 2149-2159
A Core Outcome Set for Stillbirth Care: An International Consensus Study
Objective: To develop a core outcome set for stillbirth care. Design: Consensus development study. Setting: International. Population: 542 participants from 29 countries, including 381 parents or family members who have experienced stillbirth, 192 care professionals and researchers (31 of which identified as both parent and professional). 95.6% of parents and 86.5% of professional stakeholders were from in high‐income countries. Methods: Modified Delphi method and consensus meetings. Results: Stakeholders agreed upon 8 core outcomes to measure in all stillbirth care studies; an additional 11 outcomes for specific interventions or care were also decided. Core outcomes for all stillbirth care studies were life‐threatening complications and maternal death, parents' experience of respectful and supportive care, grief, mental health and emotional wellbeing, isolation, stigma, impact on work, impact on relationship with immediate family. Outcomes for studies assessing interventions to understand the cause of stillbirth (investigations): cause of death identified and parents' understanding of the cause of death. Outcomes in studies assessing subsequent pregnancy after stillbirth: antenatal complications for mother, antenatal complications for baby, survival of baby, neonatal outcomes and attachment to baby. Outcomes for when a stillbirth occurs in a multiple pregnancy: survival of other baby/ies, preterm birth, pregnancy complications for baby/ies and neonatal outcomes. Conclusion: This core outcome set for stillbirth care can be used in future trials and systematic reviews to minimise outcome‐reporting bias, allow comparability of interventions in meta‐analyses and ultimately reduce research wastage.
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology
- Vol. 132 (13) , 2149-2159
Open AccessA Core Outcome Set for Stillbirth Care: An International Consensus Study
Objective: To develop a core outcome set for stillbirth care. Design: Consensus development study. Setting: International. Population: 542 participants from 29 countries, including 381 parents or family members who have experienced stillbirth, 192 care professionals and researchers (31 of which identified as both parent and professional). 95.6% of parents and 86.5% of professional stakeholders were from in high‐income countries. Methods: Modified Delphi method and consensus meetings. Results: Stakeholders agreed upon 8 core outcomes to measure in all stillbirth care studies; an additional 11 outcomes for specific interventions or care were also decided. Core outcomes for all stillbirth care studies were life‐threatening complications and maternal death, parents' experience of respectful and supportive care, grief, mental health and emotional wellbeing, isolation, stigma, impact on work, impact on relationship with immediate family. Outcomes for studies assessing interventions to understand the cause of stillbirth (investigations): cause of death identified and parents' understanding of the cause of death. Outcomes in studies assessing subsequent pregnancy after stillbirth: antenatal complications for mother, antenatal complications for baby, survival of baby, neonatal outcomes and attachment to baby. Outcomes for when a stillbirth occurs in a multiple pregnancy: survival of other baby/ies, preterm birth, pregnancy complications for baby/ies and neonatal outcomes. Conclusion: This core outcome set for stillbirth care can be used in future trials and systematic reviews to minimise outcome‐reporting bias, allow comparability of interventions in meta‐analyses and ultimately reduce research wastage.
- Open Access
Women’s perspectives of decision-making for labour and birth: a qualitative antenatal-postnatal paired interview study
Objectives To understand and compare women’s antenatal and postnatal views on: (1) priorities for information provided about labour and delivery and (2) decision-making in labour and delivery. Design Qualitative interview study using repeat interviews at two time points: during pregnancy (≥13 weeks gestation); and after birth (≥6 weeks). Setting Large maternity hospital in the Southwest of England. Participants Pregnant women accessing antenatal care were purposively sampled and recruited antenatally by community midwives to ensure representation from different sociodemographic groups, with diverse experiences of low and high-risk care. Data collection Telephone interviews with a single researcher using a semistructured interview topic guide. Data analysis Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and qualitative thematic analysis was conducted using Braun and Clarke’s six-stage process. Results Twelve women participated (12 antenatal interviews; 10 follow-up postnatal interviews). Overall, women’s postnatal views were consistent with their antenatal views about what they wanted to know and the factors that influence decision-making. Three themes were generated. Theme 1 ‘Sources of information’ presents evidence of how women obtain and use information (sub-themes: ‘social influences’, ‘patient responsibility for information seeking’, ‘NHS vs non-NHS resources’). Theme 2 reports women’s views and experiences of ‘The influence of Healthcare Professionals in decision-making’ (sub-themes ‘patient and professional roles in decision-making’, ‘conflicting advice and preferences’, ‘taking authority in emergency decision-making’). The final theme, theme 3, ‘When, how, and what information women want’ shows women want time to process information (sub-themes ‘when: it’s definitely information and time’, ‘how: presentation of information’, ‘what: information required’). Cross-cutting all themes, we found an unmet need for information to be tailored to the individual. Conclusions Women understand decision-making during labour and birth is a dynamic process. Women can struggle with the volume, quality and timing of information available. In busy maternity settings, the challenge is to better equip women with the information they want, and health professionals with the information they need to provide for personalised care and shared decision-making. Antenatal interventions that warrant further research include decision aids, birth plans, and structured counselling using core information sets. Insights from both antenatal and postnatal perspectives will help inform their development.
Open AccessWomen’s perspectives of decision-making for labour and birth: a qualitative antenatal-postnatal paired interview study
Objectives To understand and compare women’s antenatal and postnatal views on: (1) priorities for information provided about labour and delivery and (2) decision-making in labour and delivery. Design Qualitative interview study using repeat interviews at two time points: during pregnancy (≥13 weeks gestation); and after birth (≥6 weeks). Setting Large maternity hospital in the Southwest of England. Participants Pregnant women accessing antenatal care were purposively sampled and recruited antenatally by community midwives to ensure representation from different sociodemographic groups, with diverse experiences of low and high-risk care. Data collection Telephone interviews with a single researcher using a semistructured interview topic guide. Data analysis Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and qualitative thematic analysis was conducted using Braun and Clarke’s six-stage process. Results Twelve women participated (12 antenatal interviews; 10 follow-up postnatal interviews). Overall, women’s postnatal views were consistent with their antenatal views about what they wanted to know and the factors that influence decision-making. Three themes were generated. Theme 1 ‘Sources of information’ presents evidence of how women obtain and use information (sub-themes: ‘social influences’, ‘patient responsibility for information seeking’, ‘NHS vs non-NHS resources’). Theme 2 reports women’s views and experiences of ‘The influence of Healthcare Professionals in decision-making’ (sub-themes ‘patient and professional roles in decision-making’, ‘conflicting advice and preferences’, ‘taking authority in emergency decision-making’). The final theme, theme 3, ‘When, how, and what information women want’ shows women want time to process information (sub-themes ‘when: it’s definitely information and time’, ‘how: presentation of information’, ‘what: information required’). Cross-cutting all themes, we found an unmet need for information to be tailored to the individual. Conclusions Women understand decision-making during labour and birth is a dynamic process. Women can struggle with the volume, quality and timing of information available. In busy maternity settings, the challenge is to better equip women with the information they want, and health professionals with the information they need to provide for personalised care and shared decision-making. Antenatal interventions that warrant further research include decision aids, birth plans, and structured counselling using core information sets. Insights from both antenatal and postnatal perspectives will help inform their development.
- Open Access
Qualitative study exploring the barriers and facilitators to low-dose aspirin adherence in pregnant women with placental dysfunction risk in the UK
Introduction Placental dysfunction is estimated to affect 10% of pregnancies and is associated with adverse perinatal outcomes. Low-dose aspirin (LDA) reduces placental dysfunction risk. However, adherence to LDA is suboptimal in pregnant women and may reduce its effectiveness. Objectives We aimed to explore the barriers and facilitators to LDA adherence in pregnant women with placental dysfunction risk. Design Qualitative semi-structured individual interviews were undertaken, and data were inductively thematically analysed. Setting A single NHS Trust in South West England, UK. Participants Pregnant women aged>18, recommended daily LDA for pregnancy indications. We purposively recruited those with a range of adherence patterns (non-adherent, suboptimally adherent, adherent). Results 15 women participated (93% white British, 73% university educated). Five were adherent (6–7 doses per week), five suboptimally adherent (4–5 doses per week) and five non-adherent (Conclusions We identified motivational and implementation-related barriers and facilitators to LDA adherence in a clinical sample of women with placental dysfunction risk. Women require more information to enhance understanding and inform their decision, and require support to establish effective habits. Theory-informed behaviour change techniques could address these barriers. Adherence barriers and facilitators should be explored in minority ethnicity and economically deprived women, and healthcare staff providing LDA-related care to inform optimally effective interventions.
Open AccessQualitative study exploring the barriers and facilitators to low-dose aspirin adherence in pregnant women with placental dysfunction risk in the UK
Introduction Placental dysfunction is estimated to affect 10% of pregnancies and is associated with adverse perinatal outcomes. Low-dose aspirin (LDA) reduces placental dysfunction risk. However, adherence to LDA is suboptimal in pregnant women and may reduce its effectiveness. Objectives We aimed to explore the barriers and facilitators to LDA adherence in pregnant women with placental dysfunction risk. Design Qualitative semi-structured individual interviews were undertaken, and data were inductively thematically analysed. Setting A single NHS Trust in South West England, UK. Participants Pregnant women aged>18, recommended daily LDA for pregnancy indications. We purposively recruited those with a range of adherence patterns (non-adherent, suboptimally adherent, adherent). Results 15 women participated (93% white British, 73% university educated). Five were adherent (6–7 doses per week), five suboptimally adherent (4–5 doses per week) and five non-adherent (Conclusions We identified motivational and implementation-related barriers and facilitators to LDA adherence in a clinical sample of women with placental dysfunction risk. Women require more information to enhance understanding and inform their decision, and require support to establish effective habits. Theory-informed behaviour change techniques could address these barriers. Adherence barriers and facilitators should be explored in minority ethnicity and economically deprived women, and healthcare staff providing LDA-related care to inform optimally effective interventions.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2025
- Published by Wiley
A core outcome set for stillbirth care: an international consensus study
Objective To develop a core outcome set for stillbirth care. Design Consensus development study. Setting International. Population 542 participants from 29 countries, including 381 parents or family members who have experienced stillbirth, 192 care professionals and researchers (31 of which identified as both parent and professional). Methods Modified Delphi method and Modified Nominal Group Technique. Results A long list of 108 potential outcomes was developed by combining outcomes reported in 240 stillbirth care studies with those derived from interviews of 40 parents and family members with lived experience of stillbirth. Following a two-round Delphi process with consensus meetings, stakeholders agreed upon 8 core outcomes to measure in all stillbirth care studies; an additional 11 outcomes for specific interventions or care were also decided. Core outcomes for all stillbirth care studies were life-threatening complications and maternal death, parents’ experience of respectful and supportive care, grief, mental health and emotional wellbeing, isolation, stigma, impact on work, impact on relationship with immediate family. Outcomes for studies assessing interventions to understand the cause of stillbirth (investigations): cause of death identified and parents’ understanding of cause of death. Outcomes in studies assessing subsequent pregnancy after stillbirth: antenatal complications for mother, antenatal complications for baby, survival of baby, neonatal outcomes and attachment to baby. Outcomes for when a stillbirth occurs in a multiple pregnancy: Survival of other baby/ies, preterm birth, pregnancy complications for baby/ies and neonatal outcomes. Conclusion This core outcome set for stillbirth care should now be used in future trials and systematic reviews to ensure that outcomes considered important by a range of stakeholders are addressed, and to minimise outcome reporting bias.
- 21 February 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessA core outcome set for stillbirth care: an international consensus study
Objective To develop a core outcome set for stillbirth care. Design Consensus development study. Setting International. Population 542 participants from 29 countries, including 381 parents or family members who have experienced stillbirth, 192 care professionals and researchers (31 of which identified as both parent and professional). Methods Modified Delphi method and Modified Nominal Group Technique. Results A long list of 108 potential outcomes was developed by combining outcomes reported in 240 stillbirth care studies with those derived from interviews of 40 parents and family members with lived experience of stillbirth. Following a two-round Delphi process with consensus meetings, stakeholders agreed upon 8 core outcomes to measure in all stillbirth care studies; an additional 11 outcomes for specific interventions or care were also decided. Core outcomes for all stillbirth care studies were life-threatening complications and maternal death, parents’ experience of respectful and supportive care, grief, mental health and emotional wellbeing, isolation, stigma, impact on work, impact on relationship with immediate family. Outcomes for studies assessing interventions to understand the cause of stillbirth (investigations): cause of death identified and parents’ understanding of cause of death. Outcomes in studies assessing subsequent pregnancy after stillbirth: antenatal complications for mother, antenatal complications for baby, survival of baby, neonatal outcomes and attachment to baby. Outcomes for when a stillbirth occurs in a multiple pregnancy: Survival of other baby/ies, preterm birth, pregnancy complications for baby/ies and neonatal outcomes. Conclusion This core outcome set for stillbirth care should now be used in future trials and systematic reviews to ensure that outcomes considered important by a range of stakeholders are addressed, and to minimise outcome reporting bias.
- Open Access
- 7 February 2025
- Published by Wiley
What should be discussed when considering a vaginal birth? : A Delphi Study to develop a Core Information Set for vaginal birth.
Objective Spontaneous vaginal births are often the presumed choice and represent 45% of UK births. However, information is inconsistently given about benefits and risks. This impacts decision-making and experience. A Core Information Set (CIS) is an agreed set of information points discussed prior to a decision. We aimed to develop a CIS for vaginal birth. Design Information points were identified from a literature search, patient information leaflets, interviews, and a survey. These informed a two-round Delphi survey, where stakeholders voted on the importance of items for inclusion. Items supported by >80% of participants were discussed by 28 parents and professionals at consensus meetings. The final CIS was populated with an engagement group ensuring accessibility. Setting The study took place in the UK, with participants recruited online. Population Pregnant and postnatal women, birth partners, healthcare professionals, medico-legal professionals and people working for interested/relevant organisations. Main outcome A CIS for vaginal birth. Results 77 information items were identified. In round 1 (631 participants) of the Delphi Survey, 84.5% were from the patient group and 15.5% from the professional group; in round 2 (228 participants), 74.3% were from the patient group and 25.7% from the professional group. 28 items met the criteria for consensus discussion. The final CIS includes 19 information points addressing: labour process, pain relief, labour complications, procedures or interventions during labour, experiences after birth, outcomes for the baby and environment during labour. Conclusions This CIS can be used to facilitate discussions and support informed decision-making about vaginal birth.
- 7 February 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessWhat should be discussed when considering a vaginal birth? : A Delphi Study to develop a Core Information Set for vaginal birth.
Objective Spontaneous vaginal births are often the presumed choice and represent 45% of UK births. However, information is inconsistently given about benefits and risks. This impacts decision-making and experience. A Core Information Set (CIS) is an agreed set of information points discussed prior to a decision. We aimed to develop a CIS for vaginal birth. Design Information points were identified from a literature search, patient information leaflets, interviews, and a survey. These informed a two-round Delphi survey, where stakeholders voted on the importance of items for inclusion. Items supported by >80% of participants were discussed by 28 parents and professionals at consensus meetings. The final CIS was populated with an engagement group ensuring accessibility. Setting The study took place in the UK, with participants recruited online. Population Pregnant and postnatal women, birth partners, healthcare professionals, medico-legal professionals and people working for interested/relevant organisations. Main outcome A CIS for vaginal birth. Results 77 information items were identified. In round 1 (631 participants) of the Delphi Survey, 84.5% were from the patient group and 15.5% from the professional group; in round 2 (228 participants), 74.3% were from the patient group and 25.7% from the professional group. 28 items met the criteria for consensus discussion. The final CIS includes 19 information points addressing: labour process, pain relief, labour complications, procedures or interventions during labour, experiences after birth, outcomes for the baby and environment during labour. Conclusions This CIS can be used to facilitate discussions and support informed decision-making about vaginal birth.
- Open Access
Developing a core outcome set for assessing interventions and care for parents after neonatal death in high-income countries (iCHOOSE Neonatal study): protocol for a mixed-methods study
Introduction: Neonatal death exerts long-lasting impact on parents’ mental health, finances and relationships, and the wider family. There is national and international momentum to evaluate interventions to support parents after the death of a baby. Core Outcome Sets (COSs) provide a minimum set of outcomes, agreed by stakeholders to be important, which should be evaluated in all studies to support evidence syntheses and identification of the most effective interventions. We aim to develop a COS for assessing interventions and care after neonatal death in high-income countries, to support future evidence syntheses and enable the identification of effective interventions and care for parents. Methods and analysis: We will develop the COS in six phases. A parent involvement group and stakeholder steering committee have been established and have informed each planned phase: (1) systematic review of quantitative studies evaluating care and interventions provided after neonatal death, to describe interventions, outcomes and outcome measurement tools used to assess intervention effectiveness; (2) qualitative interviews with parents who have experienced neonatal death to identify outcomes important and relevant to them; (3) think-aloud interviews with stakeholders (bereaved parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders) to develop and refine an online survey; (4) real-time online international Delphi survey with bereaved parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders to shortlist outcomes for consideration in the COS; (5) adapted nominal group online consensus meetings with parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders to agree final COS and (6) identification of a preliminary set of measurement tools. Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval has been granted for all activities to be undertaken by the University of Bristol Health Sciences Faculty Research Ethics Committee (reference: 15121). We will disseminate the findings via peer-reviewed publications and relevant academic and professional conferences. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42020151365.
Open AccessDeveloping a core outcome set for assessing interventions and care for parents after neonatal death in high-income countries (iCHOOSE Neonatal study): protocol for a mixed-methods study
Introduction: Neonatal death exerts long-lasting impact on parents’ mental health, finances and relationships, and the wider family. There is national and international momentum to evaluate interventions to support parents after the death of a baby. Core Outcome Sets (COSs) provide a minimum set of outcomes, agreed by stakeholders to be important, which should be evaluated in all studies to support evidence syntheses and identification of the most effective interventions. We aim to develop a COS for assessing interventions and care after neonatal death in high-income countries, to support future evidence syntheses and enable the identification of effective interventions and care for parents. Methods and analysis: We will develop the COS in six phases. A parent involvement group and stakeholder steering committee have been established and have informed each planned phase: (1) systematic review of quantitative studies evaluating care and interventions provided after neonatal death, to describe interventions, outcomes and outcome measurement tools used to assess intervention effectiveness; (2) qualitative interviews with parents who have experienced neonatal death to identify outcomes important and relevant to them; (3) think-aloud interviews with stakeholders (bereaved parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders) to develop and refine an online survey; (4) real-time online international Delphi survey with bereaved parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders to shortlist outcomes for consideration in the COS; (5) adapted nominal group online consensus meetings with parents, healthcare professionals and other stakeholders to agree final COS and (6) identification of a preliminary set of measurement tools. Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval has been granted for all activities to be undertaken by the University of Bristol Health Sciences Faculty Research Ethics Committee (reference: 15121). We will disseminate the findings via peer-reviewed publications and relevant academic and professional conferences. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42020151365.
- Open Access
- 29 August 2024
- Published by Wiley
What outcomes are important to families with a lived experience of stillbirth? A qualitative study to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research
Objective To identify outcomes that are important to families, to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research. Design Qualitative interview study. Setting A national study in the United Kingdom. Population A diverse sample of parents with a personal history of stillbirth were interviewed. Methods Data collection, coding and analysis were influenced by a modified Grounded Theory approach. Parents’ lived experiences of stillbirth were translated into outcomes for the purpose of developing a core outcome set. Results Forty parents and family members were interviewed. Analysis identified 343 potential care outcomes, 298 (87%) of which have not been previously reported by stillbirth care studies. Outcomes were organised into four major care outcome themes: 1) Clinical 2) Mental health and wellbeing 3) Social and family 4) Future pregnancy and children. Short- and long-term outcomes related to the labour, birth, investigations to understand why a baby had died, stillbirth in a multiple pregnancy, postpartum, psychological and subsequent pregnancy care were reported. Outcomes infrequently measured in previous stillbirth care research yet discussed by most participants were social isolation, impact on occupation and need for mental health support. Parents spoke of the importance of counselling to help them understand their grief, however, the provision of this service was reported to be varied throughout the UK. Conclusion A comprehensive outcome inventory has now been constructed, from which the final core outcome set will be determined. Future care should be developed and evaluated using outcomes that directly relate to the lived experiences of parents and families exposed to stillbirth.
- 29 August 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessWhat outcomes are important to families with a lived experience of stillbirth? A qualitative study to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research
Objective To identify outcomes that are important to families, to inform the development of a core outcome set for stillbirth care research. Design Qualitative interview study. Setting A national study in the United Kingdom. Population A diverse sample of parents with a personal history of stillbirth were interviewed. Methods Data collection, coding and analysis were influenced by a modified Grounded Theory approach. Parents’ lived experiences of stillbirth were translated into outcomes for the purpose of developing a core outcome set. Results Forty parents and family members were interviewed. Analysis identified 343 potential care outcomes, 298 (87%) of which have not been previously reported by stillbirth care studies. Outcomes were organised into four major care outcome themes: 1) Clinical 2) Mental health and wellbeing 3) Social and family 4) Future pregnancy and children. Short- and long-term outcomes related to the labour, birth, investigations to understand why a baby had died, stillbirth in a multiple pregnancy, postpartum, psychological and subsequent pregnancy care were reported. Outcomes infrequently measured in previous stillbirth care research yet discussed by most participants were social isolation, impact on occupation and need for mental health support. Parents spoke of the importance of counselling to help them understand their grief, however, the provision of this service was reported to be varied throughout the UK. Conclusion A comprehensive outcome inventory has now been constructed, from which the final core outcome set will be determined. Future care should be developed and evaluated using outcomes that directly relate to the lived experiences of parents and families exposed to stillbirth.