Robert M. Herd
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Robert M. Herd has a total of 55 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
P. F. Arthur
CNSW Department of Primary Industries, Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute, Menangle, NSW 2568, Australia
6 shared publicationsK. A. Donoghue
DNSW Department of Primary Industries, Agricultural Research Centre, Trangie, NSW 2823, Australia
4 shared publicationsR. S. Hegarty
CEnvironmental and Rural Science, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia
4 shared publicationsT. Bird-Gardiner
DNSW Department of Primary Industries, Agricultural Research Centre, Trangie, NSW 2823, Australia
3 shared publicationsV. H. Oddy
ANSW Department of Primary Industries, Livestock Industry Centre, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia
3 shared publications- Wayne S. Pitchford
Adelaide University
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 June 2024
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 64 (9)
Selection for growth rate at pasture in Angus cattle results in heavier cattle that eat more in the feedlot
Context: Selection for growth rate has received considerable attention in beef cattle but the evidence for an improvement in the efficiency of feed conversion is equivocal. Aim: To examine whether feed efficiency by beef cattle finished in a feedlot had been changed in response to divergence selection for growth rate. Methods: The Angus cattle used came from three lines of cattle selected for over five generations for fast growth rate to yearling age (High-line), slow growth (Low-line), or from an unselected Control-line. Over sequential years, a cohort of steers, then of heifers and then of steers, representative of the lines, were measured for feedlot performance, and carcase- and meat-quality traits. The animals were fed a high-energy feedlot ration and after an adjustment period they underwent a performance test of at least 70 days of duration. After slaughter, muscle samples were taken for subsequent measurement of the components of the endogenous calpain proteolytic enzyme system. Their carcasses underwent a standard chiller assessment and meat samples were taken after 1 day and 14 days (steers) or 17 days (heifers) for objective measurement of tenderness. Key results: Cattle from the High-line grew 48% faster (P < 0.05), and ate 48% more feed (P < 0.05) than did those from the Low-line, but had similar (P > 0.05) feed conversion ratio and residual feed intake. There were no differences between the High-line and Low-line in the visual meat-quality attributes of meat colour, fat colour and marbling, and no differences in the objective measurements of tenderness and connective-tissue toughness. There was no evidence of a selection response in the circulating concentrations of the metabolites and hormones measured, nor in the endogenous calpain proteolytic enzyme system in muscle. Conclusions: The superior growth demonstrated by the High-line cattle over the feedlot test was accompanied by a higher feed intake, with no evidence for an improvement in feed efficiency. Implications: Selection for growth rate is a powerful tool to alter animal performance but the beef industry needs to be cognisant of the proportional increase in feed requirement from breeding bigger animals.
- 18 June 2024
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 64 (9)
Open AccessSelection for growth rate at pasture in Angus cattle results in heavier cattle that eat more in the feedlot
Context: Selection for growth rate has received considerable attention in beef cattle but the evidence for an improvement in the efficiency of feed conversion is equivocal. Aim: To examine whether feed efficiency by beef cattle finished in a feedlot had been changed in response to divergence selection for growth rate. Methods: The Angus cattle used came from three lines of cattle selected for over five generations for fast growth rate to yearling age (High-line), slow growth (Low-line), or from an unselected Control-line. Over sequential years, a cohort of steers, then of heifers and then of steers, representative of the lines, were measured for feedlot performance, and carcase- and meat-quality traits. The animals were fed a high-energy feedlot ration and after an adjustment period they underwent a performance test of at least 70 days of duration. After slaughter, muscle samples were taken for subsequent measurement of the components of the endogenous calpain proteolytic enzyme system. Their carcasses underwent a standard chiller assessment and meat samples were taken after 1 day and 14 days (steers) or 17 days (heifers) for objective measurement of tenderness. Key results: Cattle from the High-line grew 48% faster (P < 0.05), and ate 48% more feed (P < 0.05) than did those from the Low-line, but had similar (P > 0.05) feed conversion ratio and residual feed intake. There were no differences between the High-line and Low-line in the visual meat-quality attributes of meat colour, fat colour and marbling, and no differences in the objective measurements of tenderness and connective-tissue toughness. There was no evidence of a selection response in the circulating concentrations of the metabolites and hormones measured, nor in the endogenous calpain proteolytic enzyme system in muscle. Conclusions: The superior growth demonstrated by the High-line cattle over the feedlot test was accompanied by a higher feed intake, with no evidence for an improvement in feed efficiency. Implications: Selection for growth rate is a powerful tool to alter animal performance but the beef industry needs to be cognisant of the proportional increase in feed requirement from breeding bigger animals.
- 22 August 2023
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 63 (15) , 1473-1482
Phenotypic and genetic relationships for feed intake, feed efficiency, body composition and cow milk yield measured postweaning and in mature beef cows
Context: Providing feed is the largest cost in beef production. Genetic variation exists in feed efficiency traits in young cattle but the genetic associations with feed efficiency traits in cows are poorly understood, but if strong and favourable, they might be used to improve feed efficiency of cows. Aim: To examine the phenotypic and genetic relationships among feed intake, feed efficiency, body composition and cow milk yield measured in young cattle and in cows. Methods: Data on 1783 young Angus, Hereford, Polled Hereford and Shorthorn bulls and heifers, and for 751 of the females as cows, were used to calculate the phenotypic and genetic relationships among feed efficiency traits, body composition and cow milk yield measured postweaning and in mature cows. The young cattle were tested for feed intake and feed efficiency at approximately 9 months of age and the females, after two calvings, were tested again as non-pregnant, non-lactating cows at approximately 4 years of age. Key results: At the postweaning test, the heritability estimates for feed intake, average daily gain, test weight, residual feed intake (RFI), feed conversion ratio, rump fat depth and eye-muscle area were 0.47, 0.32, 0.46, 0.42, 0.28, 0.47 and 0.20 respectively. Corresponding heritability estimates in the cow test were 0.27, 0.35, 0.74, 0.22, 0.30, 0.47 and 0.12. Heritability estimates for 400-day weight, cow 4-year weight and cow milk yield were 0.47, 0.62 and 0.15 respectively. Genetic correlations between traits measured postweaning and the same traits measured in the cow were moderate to high, and for the feed efficiency trait, RFI, was very high (0.95), close to unity. Conclusions: Inclusion of postweaning RFI as a selection criterion in beef cattle breeding can be expected to lead to improvement in cow feed efficiency. Implications: Most breeding decisions in beef cattle are based on traits measured early in life and for replacement heifers are made with an aim to improve their productivity and profitability as cows. The strong and favourable associations measured between postweaning RFI and cow RFI mean that feed efficiency measured in young cattle can be used as a selection trait to improve cow feed efficiency.
- 22 August 2023
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 63 (15) , 1473-1482
Phenotypic and genetic relationships for feed intake, feed efficiency, body composition and cow milk yield measured postweaning and in mature beef cows
Context: Providing feed is the largest cost in beef production. Genetic variation exists in feed efficiency traits in young cattle but the genetic associations with feed efficiency traits in cows are poorly understood, but if strong and favourable, they might be used to improve feed efficiency of cows. Aim: To examine the phenotypic and genetic relationships among feed intake, feed efficiency, body composition and cow milk yield measured in young cattle and in cows. Methods: Data on 1783 young Angus, Hereford, Polled Hereford and Shorthorn bulls and heifers, and for 751 of the females as cows, were used to calculate the phenotypic and genetic relationships among feed efficiency traits, body composition and cow milk yield measured postweaning and in mature cows. The young cattle were tested for feed intake and feed efficiency at approximately 9 months of age and the females, after two calvings, were tested again as non-pregnant, non-lactating cows at approximately 4 years of age. Key results: At the postweaning test, the heritability estimates for feed intake, average daily gain, test weight, residual feed intake (RFI), feed conversion ratio, rump fat depth and eye-muscle area were 0.47, 0.32, 0.46, 0.42, 0.28, 0.47 and 0.20 respectively. Corresponding heritability estimates in the cow test were 0.27, 0.35, 0.74, 0.22, 0.30, 0.47 and 0.12. Heritability estimates for 400-day weight, cow 4-year weight and cow milk yield were 0.47, 0.62 and 0.15 respectively. Genetic correlations between traits measured postweaning and the same traits measured in the cow were moderate to high, and for the feed efficiency trait, RFI, was very high (0.95), close to unity. Conclusions: Inclusion of postweaning RFI as a selection criterion in beef cattle breeding can be expected to lead to improvement in cow feed efficiency. Implications: Most breeding decisions in beef cattle are based on traits measured early in life and for replacement heifers are made with an aim to improve their productivity and profitability as cows. The strong and favourable associations measured between postweaning RFI and cow RFI mean that feed efficiency measured in young cattle can be used as a selection trait to improve cow feed efficiency.
- 7 June 2023
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 63 (13) , 1272-1287
Selection for yearling growth rate in Angus cattle results in bigger cows that eat more
Context: Measurement of weight provides the basis of most performance-recording schemes for beef cattle around the world. The limitation of faster growth rate as a breeding objective, without considering changes in mature-cow weight, is the expected increase in cow size and, hence, feed requirements. Aims: To measure the correlated changes in feed intake and efficiency of cows, calves and the cow–calf unit following divergent selection for growth rate. Methods: The cows and their calves came from three lines of Angus cattle selected for either fast weight gain to yearling age (the High-line), slow weight gain (the Low-line), or from an unselected Control-line. Efficiency was evaluated over an annual production cycle. Individual cow weights and feed intakes, and calf growth and feed intake (including milk), were recorded. Milk production, milk composition and body composition were also measured so that correlated changes in efficiency of use of energy and nitrogen could be determined. Key results: The High-line cows were 18% (P < 0.05) heavier than the Low-line cows at the start and consumed 7% (P < 0.05) more feed than did the Low-line cows. Feed efficiency of the cow–calf unit was 12% higher (P < 0.05) in the High-line cows and calves than in the Low-line cows and calves. When compared on the basis of feed used relative to their weight and weight gain there was no difference (P > 0.05) between the selection lines. Divergent selection was accompanied by a change in body composition, with the High-line cows containing proportionally less protein and more fat in their bodies than did the Low-line cows. There was no evidence for change in the efficiency of feed energy use, but there was a 10% (P < 0.05) improvement in nitrogen efficiency of the cow–calf unit in the High-line compared with the Low-line. Conclusions: Divergent selection for weight gain led to a correlated change in cow size and cow feed requirements. Implications: This experiment supported the consensus among earlier reviews that there is little evidence that selection for growth rate or size, without moderating change in mature-cow weight, is associated with improved efficiency of feed energy use in maternal beef breeds.
- 7 June 2023
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 63 (13) , 1272-1287
Selection for yearling growth rate in Angus cattle results in bigger cows that eat more
Context: Measurement of weight provides the basis of most performance-recording schemes for beef cattle around the world. The limitation of faster growth rate as a breeding objective, without considering changes in mature-cow weight, is the expected increase in cow size and, hence, feed requirements. Aims: To measure the correlated changes in feed intake and efficiency of cows, calves and the cow–calf unit following divergent selection for growth rate. Methods: The cows and their calves came from three lines of Angus cattle selected for either fast weight gain to yearling age (the High-line), slow weight gain (the Low-line), or from an unselected Control-line. Efficiency was evaluated over an annual production cycle. Individual cow weights and feed intakes, and calf growth and feed intake (including milk), were recorded. Milk production, milk composition and body composition were also measured so that correlated changes in efficiency of use of energy and nitrogen could be determined. Key results: The High-line cows were 18% (P < 0.05) heavier than the Low-line cows at the start and consumed 7% (P < 0.05) more feed than did the Low-line cows. Feed efficiency of the cow–calf unit was 12% higher (P < 0.05) in the High-line cows and calves than in the Low-line cows and calves. When compared on the basis of feed used relative to their weight and weight gain there was no difference (P > 0.05) between the selection lines. Divergent selection was accompanied by a change in body composition, with the High-line cows containing proportionally less protein and more fat in their bodies than did the Low-line cows. There was no evidence for change in the efficiency of feed energy use, but there was a 10% (P < 0.05) improvement in nitrogen efficiency of the cow–calf unit in the High-line compared with the Low-line. Conclusions: Divergent selection for weight gain led to a correlated change in cow size and cow feed requirements. Implications: This experiment supported the consensus among earlier reviews that there is little evidence that selection for growth rate or size, without moderating change in mature-cow weight, is associated with improved efficiency of feed energy use in maternal beef breeds.
- 12 September 2022
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 62 (18) , 1749-1756
Associations of digestibility with phenotypic and genetic variation in methane production in Angus cattle
Context: Cattle and sheep emit methane, a potent greenhouse gas, as part of the fermentation process of feed digestion in their gut; however, the mechanisms explaining differences among animals in enteric methane production are not fully understood. Aim: To investigate whether variation among animals in their ability to digest their test ration was associated with phenotypic and genetic variation in methane production. Methods: The experiment used 135 Angus beef cattle measured for their phenotypic and genetic merit for methane production. The extent of digestion of the dry matter (DMD) in the test ration by individual cattle was determined using silica as a naturally present indigestible marker. Its concentration in feed consumed and faeces was determined using rapid portable X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, from which DMD was calculated. Key results: Higher daily methane-production rate (MPR), higher methane produced per unit of feed consumed (methane yield; MY) and higher methane produced than the predicted daily production (residual MPR; RMP) by animals was accompanied by higher DMD. Higher genetic merit for MPR was also accompanied by higher DMD, but DMD had no detectable association with genetic variation in the other two methane emission traits. The regression coefficients for change in MPR (g/day), MY (g/kg DMI), RMP (g/day) with change in DMD (%) were 2.6 ± 1.1 (s.e.; P < 0.05), 0.14 ± 0.07 (P < 0.1) and 0.68 ± 0.38 (P < 0.1) respectively. Conclusions: Differences among animals in their DMD were found and were associated with phenotypic variation in the three methane emission traits studied, and with genetic variation in daily methane production. The results support the caution that feeding and breeding interventions seeking to reduce methane emissions can also reduce the extent of digestion of feed by cattle. Implications: Feeding and breeding interventions that seek to reduce methane emissions may change rumen physiology and reduce the extent of digestion of feed by cattle, which may be undesirable.
- 12 September 2022
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 62 (18) , 1749-1756
Associations of digestibility with phenotypic and genetic variation in methane production in Angus cattle
Context: Cattle and sheep emit methane, a potent greenhouse gas, as part of the fermentation process of feed digestion in their gut; however, the mechanisms explaining differences among animals in enteric methane production are not fully understood. Aim: To investigate whether variation among animals in their ability to digest their test ration was associated with phenotypic and genetic variation in methane production. Methods: The experiment used 135 Angus beef cattle measured for their phenotypic and genetic merit for methane production. The extent of digestion of the dry matter (DMD) in the test ration by individual cattle was determined using silica as a naturally present indigestible marker. Its concentration in feed consumed and faeces was determined using rapid portable X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, from which DMD was calculated. Key results: Higher daily methane-production rate (MPR), higher methane produced per unit of feed consumed (methane yield; MY) and higher methane produced than the predicted daily production (residual MPR; RMP) by animals was accompanied by higher DMD. Higher genetic merit for MPR was also accompanied by higher DMD, but DMD had no detectable association with genetic variation in the other two methane emission traits. The regression coefficients for change in MPR (g/day), MY (g/kg DMI), RMP (g/day) with change in DMD (%) were 2.6 ± 1.1 (s.e.; P < 0.05), 0.14 ± 0.07 (P < 0.1) and 0.68 ± 0.38 (P < 0.1) respectively. Conclusions: Differences among animals in their DMD were found and were associated with phenotypic variation in the three methane emission traits studied, and with genetic variation in daily methane production. The results support the caution that feeding and breeding interventions seeking to reduce methane emissions can also reduce the extent of digestion of feed by cattle. Implications: Feeding and breeding interventions that seek to reduce methane emissions may change rumen physiology and reduce the extent of digestion of feed by cattle, which may be undesirable.
- 11 May 2021
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 61 (13) , 1303-1314
Selection for lower residual feed intake in mice is accompanied by increased body fatness and lower activity but not lower metabolic rate
Context: Mice bred to be genetically different in feed efficiency were used in this experiment designed to help improve our knowledge of the biological basis of variation in feed efficiency between individual animals. Aims: This experiment used mice to explore the metabolic basis of genetic variation in feed efficiency in the growing animal. Methods: Mice bred to differ in residual feed intake (RFI) recorded over a postweaning test were used. After 11 generations of divergent selection, mice in groups were tested for RFI from 6 to 8, 8 to 10, and 10 to 12 weeks of age, and measured for traits describing the ability to digest feed, body composition, protein turnover, basal and resting metabolic rate, and level of activity. Key results: Compared with the low-RFI (high efficiency) line mice, high-RFI mice consumed 28% more feed per day over their RFI-test, were no heavier, were leaner (16% less total fat per unit of bodyweight), did not differ in the fractional synthesis rate of protein in skeletal muscle or in liver, and had similar basal metabolic rates at 33°C. On an energy basis, the selection lines did not differ in energy retained in body tissue gain, which represented only 1.8% of metabolisable energy intake. The remaining 98.2% was lost as heat. Of the processes measured contributing to the higher feed intake by the high-RFI mice, 47% of the extra feed consumed was lost in faeces and urine, activity was 84% higher and accounted for 24%, the cost of protein gain was 6% higher and accounted for 2%, and the energy cost of digesting and absorbing the extra feed consumed and basal heat production could have accounted for 11 and 15% each. Conclusions: Selection for low RFI (high efficiency) in mice was accompanied by an increase in body fat, an improvement in the process of digestion, a lower rate of protein turnover and a much lower level of activity. Selection did not result in major change in basal metabolic rate. Implications: This experiment with mice provided new information on the biological basis of genetic differences in feed efficiency. The experiment investigated the relative importance of major energy-consuming metabolic processes and was able to quantify the responses in protein turnover and level of activity, being responses in energy-consuming processes that have proven difficult to quantitatively demonstrate in large farm animals.
- 11 May 2021
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 61 (13) , 1303-1314
Selection for lower residual feed intake in mice is accompanied by increased body fatness and lower activity but not lower metabolic rate
Context: Mice bred to be genetically different in feed efficiency were used in this experiment designed to help improve our knowledge of the biological basis of variation in feed efficiency between individual animals. Aims: This experiment used mice to explore the metabolic basis of genetic variation in feed efficiency in the growing animal. Methods: Mice bred to differ in residual feed intake (RFI) recorded over a postweaning test were used. After 11 generations of divergent selection, mice in groups were tested for RFI from 6 to 8, 8 to 10, and 10 to 12 weeks of age, and measured for traits describing the ability to digest feed, body composition, protein turnover, basal and resting metabolic rate, and level of activity. Key results: Compared with the low-RFI (high efficiency) line mice, high-RFI mice consumed 28% more feed per day over their RFI-test, were no heavier, were leaner (16% less total fat per unit of bodyweight), did not differ in the fractional synthesis rate of protein in skeletal muscle or in liver, and had similar basal metabolic rates at 33°C. On an energy basis, the selection lines did not differ in energy retained in body tissue gain, which represented only 1.8% of metabolisable energy intake. The remaining 98.2% was lost as heat. Of the processes measured contributing to the higher feed intake by the high-RFI mice, 47% of the extra feed consumed was lost in faeces and urine, activity was 84% higher and accounted for 24%, the cost of protein gain was 6% higher and accounted for 2%, and the energy cost of digesting and absorbing the extra feed consumed and basal heat production could have accounted for 11 and 15% each. Conclusions: Selection for low RFI (high efficiency) in mice was accompanied by an increase in body fat, an improvement in the process of digestion, a lower rate of protein turnover and a much lower level of activity. Selection did not result in major change in basal metabolic rate. Implications: This experiment with mice provided new information on the biological basis of genetic differences in feed efficiency. The experiment investigated the relative importance of major energy-consuming metabolic processes and was able to quantify the responses in protein turnover and level of activity, being responses in energy-consuming processes that have proven difficult to quantitatively demonstrate in large farm animals.
- 4 November 2020
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 61 (4) , 381-389
Predicting metabolisable energy intake by free-ranging cattle using multiple short-term breath samples and applied to a pasture case-study
Context: Research into improving feed efficiency by ruminant animals grazing pastures has historically been restrained by an inability to measure feed intake by large numbers of individual animals. Recent advances in portable breath measurement technology could be useful for this purpose but methodologies need to be developed. Aims: To evaluate predictive models for metabolisable energy intake (MEI) by free-ranging cattle using multiple short-term breath samples and then apply these to predict MEI by free-ranging cattle in a historic grazing experiment with cattle genetically divergent for residual feed intake (feed efficiency). Methods: Predictive models for MEI were developed using bodyweight (BW) data, and carbon dioxide production rate (CPR) and methane production rate (MPR) from multiple short-term breath measurements, from an experiment with long-fed Angus steers on a grain-based diet, and an experiment with short-fed Angus heifers on a roughage diet. Heat production was calculated using CPR and MPR. Energy retained (ER) in body tissue gain by steers was calculated from BW, ADG, initial and final subcutaneous fat depths, and for both groups using feeding-standards equations. Key results: Metabolic mid-test BW (MBW) explained 49 and 47% of the variation in MEI in the steer and heifer experiment, respectively, and for the steers adding ADG and then subcutaneous fat gain resulted in the models accounting for 60 and then 65% of the variation in MEI. In the steer experiment, MBW with CPR explained 57% of the variation in MEI, and including MPR did not account for any additional variation. In the heifer experiment, MBW with CPR explained 50%, and with MPR accounted for 52% of the variation in MEI. Heat production plus ER explained 60, 35 and 85% of the variation in MEI in the steer and the heifer experiments, and in the pooled data from both experiments, respectively. Conclusions: Multiple short-term breath measurements, together simple BW data, can be used to predict MEI by free-ranging cattle in studies in which animals do not have feed-intake or ADG recorded. Implications: This methodology can be used for research into improving feed efficiency by farm animals grazing pastures.
- 4 November 2020
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 61 (4) , 381-389
Predicting metabolisable energy intake by free-ranging cattle using multiple short-term breath samples and applied to a pasture case-study
Context: Research into improving feed efficiency by ruminant animals grazing pastures has historically been restrained by an inability to measure feed intake by large numbers of individual animals. Recent advances in portable breath measurement technology could be useful for this purpose but methodologies need to be developed. Aims: To evaluate predictive models for metabolisable energy intake (MEI) by free-ranging cattle using multiple short-term breath samples and then apply these to predict MEI by free-ranging cattle in a historic grazing experiment with cattle genetically divergent for residual feed intake (feed efficiency). Methods: Predictive models for MEI were developed using bodyweight (BW) data, and carbon dioxide production rate (CPR) and methane production rate (MPR) from multiple short-term breath measurements, from an experiment with long-fed Angus steers on a grain-based diet, and an experiment with short-fed Angus heifers on a roughage diet. Heat production was calculated using CPR and MPR. Energy retained (ER) in body tissue gain by steers was calculated from BW, ADG, initial and final subcutaneous fat depths, and for both groups using feeding-standards equations. Key results: Metabolic mid-test BW (MBW) explained 49 and 47% of the variation in MEI in the steer and heifer experiment, respectively, and for the steers adding ADG and then subcutaneous fat gain resulted in the models accounting for 60 and then 65% of the variation in MEI. In the steer experiment, MBW with CPR explained 57% of the variation in MEI, and including MPR did not account for any additional variation. In the heifer experiment, MBW with CPR explained 50%, and with MPR accounted for 52% of the variation in MEI. Heat production plus ER explained 60, 35 and 85% of the variation in MEI in the steer and the heifer experiments, and in the pooled data from both experiments, respectively. Conclusions: Multiple short-term breath measurements, together simple BW data, can be used to predict MEI by free-ranging cattle in studies in which animals do not have feed-intake or ADG recorded. Implications: This methodology can be used for research into improving feed efficiency by farm animals grazing pastures.
- Open Access
- 29 April 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 51 (1) , 1-13
Methods and consequences of including reduction in greenhouse gas emission in beef cattle multiple-trait selection
Societal pressures exist to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from farm animals, especially in beef cattle. Both total GHG and GHG emissions per unit of product decrease as productivity increases. Limitations of previous studies on GHG emissions are that they generally describe feed intake inadequately, assess the consequences of selection on particular traits only, or examine consequences for only part of the production chain. Here, we examine GHG emissions for the whole production chain, with the estimated cost of carbon included as an extra cost on traits in the breeding objective of the production system. We examined an example beef production system where economic merit was measured from weaning to slaughter. The estimated cost of the carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2-e) associated with feed intake change is included in the economic values calculated for the breeding objective traits and comes in addition to the cost of the feed associated with trait change. GHG emission effects on the production system are accumulated over the breeding objective traits, and the reduction in GHG emissions is evaluated, for different carbon prices, both for the individual animal and the production system. Multiple-trait selection in beef cattle can reduce total GHG and GHG emissions per unit of product while increasing economic performance if the cost of feed in the breeding objective is high. When carbon price was $10, $20, $30 and $40/ton CO2-e, selection decreased total GHG emissions by 1.1, 1.6, 2.1 and 2.6% per generation, respectively. When the cost of feed for the breeding objective was low, selection reduced total GHG emissions only if carbon price was high (~ $80/ton CO2-e). Ignoring the costs of GHG emissions when feed cost was low substantially increased emissions (e.g. 4.4% per generation or ~ 8.8% in 10 years). The ability to reduce GHG emissions in beef cattle depends on the cost of feed in the breeding objective of the production system. Multiple-trait selection will reduce emissions, while improving economic performance, if the cost of feed in the breeding objective is high. If it is low, greater growth will be favoured, leading to an increase in GHG emissions that may be undesirable.
- 29 April 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 51 (1) , 1-13
Open AccessMethods and consequences of including reduction in greenhouse gas emission in beef cattle multiple-trait selection
Societal pressures exist to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from farm animals, especially in beef cattle. Both total GHG and GHG emissions per unit of product decrease as productivity increases. Limitations of previous studies on GHG emissions are that they generally describe feed intake inadequately, assess the consequences of selection on particular traits only, or examine consequences for only part of the production chain. Here, we examine GHG emissions for the whole production chain, with the estimated cost of carbon included as an extra cost on traits in the breeding objective of the production system. We examined an example beef production system where economic merit was measured from weaning to slaughter. The estimated cost of the carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2-e) associated with feed intake change is included in the economic values calculated for the breeding objective traits and comes in addition to the cost of the feed associated with trait change. GHG emission effects on the production system are accumulated over the breeding objective traits, and the reduction in GHG emissions is evaluated, for different carbon prices, both for the individual animal and the production system. Multiple-trait selection in beef cattle can reduce total GHG and GHG emissions per unit of product while increasing economic performance if the cost of feed in the breeding objective is high. When carbon price was $10, $20, $30 and $40/ton CO2-e, selection decreased total GHG emissions by 1.1, 1.6, 2.1 and 2.6% per generation, respectively. When the cost of feed for the breeding objective was low, selection reduced total GHG emissions only if carbon price was high (~ $80/ton CO2-e). Ignoring the costs of GHG emissions when feed cost was low substantially increased emissions (e.g. 4.4% per generation or ~ 8.8% in 10 years). The ability to reduce GHG emissions in beef cattle depends on the cost of feed in the breeding objective of the production system. Multiple-trait selection will reduce emissions, while improving economic performance, if the cost of feed in the breeding objective is high. If it is low, greater growth will be favoured, leading to an increase in GHG emissions that may be undesirable.
- 30 August 2017
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 58 (1) , 20-32
Genesis, design and methods of the Beef CRC Maternal Productivity Project
Australian seedstock cattle breeders have expressed concerns that while there has been genetic improvement in feedlot and abattoir performance of cows, it could have led to a decline in maternal productivity, especially under variable nutritional conditions. This paper describes a substantial project with two components designed to address these issues. The first sub-project was to monitor bodyweight and composition of 7760 young Angus and Hereford cows as they experience variable physiological states (pregnancy and lactation) and seasons. This was conducted on large numbers in seedstock herds. The second sub-project was to monitor more regularly bodyweight, body composition, and calf rearing performance of 500 Angus cows that are genetically divergent for either fat or residual feed intake at two research centres. This also included two levels of nutrition and recording of weekly feed intake of small groups of cows for at least three parities to allow reporting of genotype × nutrition effects on maternal productivity and efficiency. Results from the project are reported in a series of papers with each one having a defined focus.
- 30 August 2017
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 58 (1) , 20-32
Genesis, design and methods of the Beef CRC Maternal Productivity Project
Australian seedstock cattle breeders have expressed concerns that while there has been genetic improvement in feedlot and abattoir performance of cows, it could have led to a decline in maternal productivity, especially under variable nutritional conditions. This paper describes a substantial project with two components designed to address these issues. The first sub-project was to monitor bodyweight and composition of 7760 young Angus and Hereford cows as they experience variable physiological states (pregnancy and lactation) and seasons. This was conducted on large numbers in seedstock herds. The second sub-project was to monitor more regularly bodyweight, body composition, and calf rearing performance of 500 Angus cows that are genetically divergent for either fat or residual feed intake at two research centres. This also included two levels of nutrition and recording of weekly feed intake of small groups of cows for at least three parities to allow reporting of genotype × nutrition effects on maternal productivity and efficiency. Results from the project are reported in a series of papers with each one having a defined focus.
- 5 April 2016
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 58 (6) , 1006-1010
Effect of measurement duration in respiration chambers on methane traits of beef cattle
Records on 1043 young Angus heifer and bull progeny from 73 sires, measured for methane production in respiration chambers, were used to evaluate the accuracy of a 1-day measurement relative to 2-day measurement duration. The traits assessed were dry matter intake (DMI, kg/day), methane-production rate (MPR, g/day), methane yield (MY, MPR per unit DMI) and four residual methane (RMP, g/day) traits. The RMP traits were computed as actual MPR minus expected MPR, where the expected MPR were calculated from three widely used equations. The expected MPR for the fourth RMP trait was computed by regressing MPR on DMI, using the data from the study. Variance components, heritability, phenotypic and genetic correlations, and the efficiency of selection using 1-day compared with 2-day measurement were used as assessment criteria. The environmental variance for the 2-day measurement was slightly lower than that of the 1-day measurement for all the traits studied, indicating that the addition of an extra day of data was effective in reducing the amount of unexplained variation in each trait. However, these minor reductions did not have a major impact on accuracy; hence, very high phenotypic (rp of 0.91–0.99) and genetic (rg of 0.99 for each trait) correlations were obtained between the two measurement durations. The very high genetic correlation between the two durations of measurement indicated that, at the genetic level, the 1-day duration is measuring the same trait as the 2-day measurement duration. Any enteric-methane emission-abatement strategy that seeks to reduce MPR per se, may have a detrimental impact on ruminant productivity through a correlated reduction in feed intake; hence, MY and the RMP traits are likely to be the traits of interest for genetic improvement. Efficiency of selection for MY and the RMP traits ranged from 0.96 to 0.99, which implies that there would be less than 5% loss in efficiency by adopting a 1-day relative to a 2-day methane-measurement duration. While the throughput of the respiration-chamber facility can be increased by adopting a 1-day measurement duration, additional resources, such as holding pens, would be required to take advantage of the extra day.
- 5 April 2016
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 58 (6) , 1006-1010
Effect of measurement duration in respiration chambers on methane traits of beef cattle
Records on 1043 young Angus heifer and bull progeny from 73 sires, measured for methane production in respiration chambers, were used to evaluate the accuracy of a 1-day measurement relative to 2-day measurement duration. The traits assessed were dry matter intake (DMI, kg/day), methane-production rate (MPR, g/day), methane yield (MY, MPR per unit DMI) and four residual methane (RMP, g/day) traits. The RMP traits were computed as actual MPR minus expected MPR, where the expected MPR were calculated from three widely used equations. The expected MPR for the fourth RMP trait was computed by regressing MPR on DMI, using the data from the study. Variance components, heritability, phenotypic and genetic correlations, and the efficiency of selection using 1-day compared with 2-day measurement were used as assessment criteria. The environmental variance for the 2-day measurement was slightly lower than that of the 1-day measurement for all the traits studied, indicating that the addition of an extra day of data was effective in reducing the amount of unexplained variation in each trait. However, these minor reductions did not have a major impact on accuracy; hence, very high phenotypic (rp of 0.91–0.99) and genetic (rg of 0.99 for each trait) correlations were obtained between the two measurement durations. The very high genetic correlation between the two durations of measurement indicated that, at the genetic level, the 1-day duration is measuring the same trait as the 2-day measurement duration. Any enteric-methane emission-abatement strategy that seeks to reduce MPR per se, may have a detrimental impact on ruminant productivity through a correlated reduction in feed intake; hence, MY and the RMP traits are likely to be the traits of interest for genetic improvement. Efficiency of selection for MY and the RMP traits ranged from 0.96 to 0.99, which implies that there would be less than 5% loss in efficiency by adopting a 1-day relative to a 2-day methane-measurement duration. While the throughput of the respiration-chamber facility can be increased by adopting a 1-day measurement duration, additional resources, such as holding pens, would be required to take advantage of the extra day.
- 9 February 2016
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 56 (3) , 213-217
Repeatability of methane emission measurements in Australian beef cattle
Records on 175 young Angus heifer and bull progeny from 46 sires, measured for methane production in respiration chambers, were used to evaluate the repeatability of methane measurement over short- and long-term periods. The traits assessed were dry matter intake (DMI), methane production rate (MPR), methane yield (MPR per unit DMI), and four residual methane (RMP) traits. The RMP traits were computed as actual MPR minus expected MPR, where the expected MPR for the first three RMP traits were calculated from three different published and widely used equations. The expected MPR for the fourth was computed by regressing MPR on DMI, using the data from the study. Animals underwent an initial (first) methane measurement test for 48 h, and one repeat methane measurement test up to 450 days after the first test. Repeat tests were classified into four different time periods: tested across consecutive days; re-tested within 60 days of first test; re-tested 61–120 days after first test; and re-tested 121–450 days after first test. Repeatabilities were calculated for all traits across all time periods, and phenotypic correlations for the same trait measured over time were obtained from bivariate analyses. Methane traits from tests conducted over consecutive days were highly repeatable (0.75–0.94) and highly phenotypically correlated (0.85–0.95). Repeatabilities from tests conducted within 60 days of the first test were moderate to high (0.59–0.91), whereas phenotypic correlations were, in general, moderate (0.30–0.44), with the exception of MPR (0.78). Results for both longer-term time periods (61–120 days and 121–450 days after the first test) were very similar, with low estimates of repeatabilities (0.16–0.27) and phenotypic correlations (0.12–0.27). Correlations between sire progeny means from the first and repeat methane test were moderate (0.46–0.77) for all traits except RMPR (0.19). Results from this study indicate that methane traits from tests conducted either on consecutive days or within a short-term time frame afterward (~60 days) are highly repeatable and highly phenotypically correlated. However, methane tests conducted over longer-term time frames are substantially, but consistently, less repeatable and are lowly phenotypically correlated, which indicates that multiple measures may be required to accurately record methane traits over the life time of an animal.
- 9 February 2016
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Animal Production Science
- Vol. 56 (3) , 213-217
Repeatability of methane emission measurements in Australian beef cattle
Records on 175 young Angus heifer and bull progeny from 46 sires, measured for methane production in respiration chambers, were used to evaluate the repeatability of methane measurement over short- and long-term periods. The traits assessed were dry matter intake (DMI), methane production rate (MPR), methane yield (MPR per unit DMI), and four residual methane (RMP) traits. The RMP traits were computed as actual MPR minus expected MPR, where the expected MPR for the first three RMP traits were calculated from three different published and widely used equations. The expected MPR for the fourth was computed by regressing MPR on DMI, using the data from the study. Animals underwent an initial (first) methane measurement test for 48 h, and one repeat methane measurement test up to 450 days after the first test. Repeat tests were classified into four different time periods: tested across consecutive days; re-tested within 60 days of first test; re-tested 61–120 days after first test; and re-tested 121–450 days after first test. Repeatabilities were calculated for all traits across all time periods, and phenotypic correlations for the same trait measured over time were obtained from bivariate analyses. Methane traits from tests conducted over consecutive days were highly repeatable (0.75–0.94) and highly phenotypically correlated (0.85–0.95). Repeatabilities from tests conducted within 60 days of the first test were moderate to high (0.59–0.91), whereas phenotypic correlations were, in general, moderate (0.30–0.44), with the exception of MPR (0.78). Results for both longer-term time periods (61–120 days and 121–450 days after the first test) were very similar, with low estimates of repeatabilities (0.16–0.27) and phenotypic correlations (0.12–0.27). Correlations between sire progeny means from the first and repeat methane test were moderate (0.46–0.77) for all traits except RMPR (0.19). Results from this study indicate that methane traits from tests conducted either on consecutive days or within a short-term time frame afterward (~60 days) are highly repeatable and highly phenotypically correlated. However, methane tests conducted over longer-term time frames are substantially, but consistently, less repeatable and are lowly phenotypically correlated, which indicates that multiple measures may be required to accurately record methane traits over the life time of an animal.