BHBenjamin Mako Hill

Benjamin Mako Hill

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Benjamin Mako Hill has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Beyond Productivity: AI, Community, and Sustainability in Open Source Software

    by Eli Min, Hana Frluckaj, Matthew Gaughan, Kaylea Champion, Kevin Crowston, Benjamin Mako Hill, James Howison

  • Open Access

    The Relational Origins of Rules in Online Communities

    by Charles Kiene, Sohyeon Hwang, Carl Colglazier, Nathan TeBlunthuis, Aaron Shaw, Benjamin Mako Hill

    Where do rules come from in online communities? This study investigates how and why online communities adopt and change their rules. We conducted a grounded theory-based analysis of 40 in-depth interviews with community leaders from subreddits, Fandom wikis, and Fediverse servers, and identified seven processes involved in the adoption of online community rules. Our findings reveal that, beyond operational reasons like regulating behavior and solving problems, rules are also adopted and changed for relational reasons, such as signaling or reinforcing community legitimacy and identity to other communities. While rule change was often prompted by challenges during community growth or decline, change also depended on volunteer leaders’ work capacity, the presence of member feedback mechanisms, and relational dynamics between leaders and members. Our findings extend prior theories from social computing and organizational research, illustrating how institutionalist and ecological explanations of the relational origins of rules complement operational accounts. Finally, we build on these explanations to offer a set of design propositions that reflect the relational aspects of rules and rulemaking across communities’ lifecycles.

  • Open Access

    Sanctioned by Others: Remediating Knowledge Exclusion on Wikipedia Through Design

    by Leah Ajmani, Moyan Zhou, Tanja Andic, Amber Berson, Isaac Johnson, Benjamin Mako Hill, Rebecca Maung, Sneha Narayan, Sarah Severson, Loren Terveen, et al.

    Knowledge-based institutions, such as libraries and archives, are ripe venues for knowledge gaps, defined as systemic disparities in content coverage or participation. The core problem is not that knowledge gaps exist, but that they often further disempower already marginalized communities. By reinforcing systemic inequity, knowledge gaps are matters of justice. In this paper, we draw on critical scholarship about knowledge exclusion and take a design lens to a pressing instantiation: knowledge gaps on Wikipedia. We present findings from a two-day Wikipedia expert workshop focused on how knowledge gaps manifest in editors’ interactions with platform policy. Our core contribution is an empirically grounded argument that a more inclusive Wikipedia is one in which editors can acquire the skills to invoke, bend, and even break the platform policies that dictate encyclopedic content. To make this argument, we synthesize author testimony into (1) a problem space articulating contributing factors and (2) a two-dimensional solution space where policy engagement can be at odds with policy adherence. To illustrate this inclusive Wikipedia future, we present speculative prototypes along the engagement-adherence matrix. Finally, we discuss the epistemic implications of our work, returning to formative philosophies on knowledge inclusion and justice.

  • Open Access

    Unintended Politics: Opinion Expression and Incivility in Incidental Political Discussion

    by Yibin Fan, Benjamin Mako Hill, Patricia Moy

    While substantial research has focused on how political talk can reinforce or undermine democratic norms, relatively little attention has been paid to the role of incidental political discussion in everyday, nonpolitical contexts. Embedded within contexts of shared, nonpartisan identities or preexisting social relationships, existing theory suggests that incidental political discussion will include less political opinion and uncivil expression than purposive political discussion. Analyses of nearly three thousand comments on mass shootings and gun control across both political and nonpolitical communities on Reddit show that, contrary to expectations, incidental political discussions are more likely than purposive political discussions to contain expressions of policy opinion. Additionally, the level of incivility does not differ between the two kinds of discussions.

  • Open Access

    Epistemic Infrastructure Under Attack: Conceptualizing the Capture and Destruction of Public Knowledge Institutions

    by Zarine Kharazian, Benjamin Mako Hill

    From organized disinformation campaigns on social media to politically motivatedattempts to take over publishers and platforms, the last decade has seen a proliferationof attacks on the epistemic infrastructure that people rely on to understand the world. Weargue that scholars, practitioners, and policymakers have struggled to respond effectively tothese threats in part because they lack systematic ways to understand the shifting nature ofwhat is under threat and how it is being attacked. Drawing on Elinor Ostrom’s classic workon commons governance, we develop a conceptual framework that conceptualizes epistemicinfrastructure as a shared resource system whose three interdependent components—knowledge, governance, and legitimacy—can each be attacked independently by motivatedactors through two distinct modes: capture and destruction. Applied to recent attacks onWikipedia, public broadcasters, and government data agencies, the framework reveals howattacks frequently target governance structures and institutional legitimacy rather than theknowledge outputs and information flows that existing approaches focus on, with implicationsfor how scholars and practitioners diagnose and respond to these threats.

  • Open Access

    From Hanging Out to Figuring It Out: Socializing Online as a Pathway to Computational Thinking

    by Samantha Shorey, Benjamin Mako Hill, Samuel C. Woolley

    Although socializing is a powerful driver of youth engagement online, platforms struggle to leverage engagement to promote learning. We seek to understand this dynamic using a multi-stage analysis of over 14,000 comments on Scratch, an online platform designed to support learning about programming. First, we inductively develop the concept of "participatory debugging" -- a practice through which users learn through collaborative technical troubleshooting. Second, we use a content analysis to establish how common the practice is on Scratch. Third, we conduct a qualitative analysis of user activity over time and identify three factors that serve as social antecedents of participatory debugging: (1) sustained community, (2) identifiable problems, and (3) what we call "topic porousness" to describe conversations that are able to span multiple topics. We integrate these findings in a theoretical framework that highlights a productive tension between the desire to promote learning and the interest-driven sub-communities that drive user engagement in many new media environments.

  • Open Access

    Challenges in Restructuring Community-based Moderation

    by Chau Tran, Kejsi Take, Kaylea Champion, Benjamin Mako Hill, Rachel Greenstadt

    Content moderation practices and technologies need to change over time as requirements and community expectations shift. However, attempts to restructure the existing moderation practices can be difficult, especially for platforms that rely on their communities to moderate, because changes can transform the workflow and workload participants' reward systems. By examining the extensive archival discussions around a prepublication moderation technology on Wikipedia named Flagged Revisions, complemented by seven semi-structured interviews, we identify various challenges in restructuring community-based moderation practices. Thus, we find that while a new system might sound good in theory and perform well in terms of quantitative metrics, it may conflict with existing social norms. Furthermore, our findings underscore how the relationship between platforms and self-governed communities can hinder the ability to assess the performance of any new system and introduce considerable costs related to maintaining, overhauling, or scrapping any piece of infrastructure.


  • Open Access

    Life Histories of Taboo Knowledge Artifacts

    by Kaylea Champion, Benjamin Mako Hill

    Communicating about some vital topics---such as sexuality and health---is treated as taboo and subjected to censorship. How can we construct knowledge about these topics? Wikipedia is home to numerous high-quality knowledge artifacts about taboo topics like sexual organs and human reproduction. How did these artifacts come into being? How is their existence sustained? This mixed-methods comparative project builds on previous work on taboo topics in Wikipedia and draws from qualitative and quantitative approaches. We follow a sequential complementary design, developing a narrative articulation of the life of taboo articles, comparing them to nontaboo articles, and examining some of their quantifiable traits. We find that taboo knowledge artifacts develop through multiple successful collaboration styles and, unsurprisingly, that taboo subjects are the sites of conflict. We identify and describe six themes in the development of taboo knowledge artifacts. These artifacts need resilient leadership and engaged organizations to thrive under conditions of limited identifiability and disjointed sensemaking , while contributors simultaneously engage in emergent governance and imagining public audiences . Our observations have important implications for supporting public knowledge work on controversial subjects such as taboos and more generally.


  • Open Access

    Governance Capture in a Self-Governing Community: A Qualitative Comparison of the Croatian, Serbian, Bosnian, and Serbo-Croatian Wikipedias

    by Zarine Kharazian, Kate Starbird, Benjamin Mako Hill

    What types of governance arrangements make some self-governed online groups more vulnerable to disinformation campaigns? We present a qualitative comparative analysis of the Croatian and Serbian Wikipedia editions to answer this question. We do so because between at least 2011 and 2020, the Croatian language version of Wikipedia was taken over by a small group of administrators who introduced far-right bias and outright disinformation. Dissenting editorial voices were reverted, banned, and blocked. Although Serbian, Bosnian, and Serbo-Croatian Wikipedias share many linguistic and cultural features, and faced similar threats, they seem to have largely avoided this fate. Based on a grounded theory analysis of interviews with members of these communities and others in cross-functional platform-level roles, we propose that the convergence of three features---high perceived value as a target, limited early bureaucratic openness, and a preference for personalistic, informal forms of organization over formal ones---produced a window of opportunity for governance capture on Croatian Wikipedia. Our findings illustrate that online community governing infrastructures can play a crucial role in systematic disinformation campaigns and other influence operations.