KSKyle W. Shertzer

Kyle W. Shertzer

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Kyle W. Shertzer has a total of 137 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Evaluating the potential benefits of close-kin mark-recapture data for integrated stock assessment of Southeast U.S. Atlantic red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus)

    by Paul S. McLaughlin, Matthew D. Damiano, Paul B. Conn, Kyle W. Shertzer, Matthew T. Vincent

    A growing body of evidence suggests that close-kin mark-recapture (CKMR) data can improve parameter estimation when integrated into fisheries stock assessment models. We conducted a simulation study using a Southeast U.S. Atlantic (SEUSA) red snapper stock assessment model augmented with CKMR data to evaluate potential improvements in estimation performance relative to a traditional assessment model that does not utilize CKMR information. Across simulated scenarios, incorporation of CKMR data resulted in substantial improvements in the accuracy and precision of spawning stock biomass estimates and, to a lesser extent, natural mortality estimates. Additionally, reductions in root mean squared error were observed for several other commonly evaluated stock assessment metrics. These results demonstrate the potential for CKMR data to improve parameter estimation within integrated stock assessment frameworks and suggest that inclusion of CKMR data may be justified in future SEUSA red snapper stock assessments.

  • Maturity, spawning seasonality, and sex ratios of U.S. Atlantic Blueline Tilefish

    by Jonathan G Low, David M Wyanski, Nikolai Klibansky, William Henley, Kyle W Shertzer, Joseph Cimino, Kevin R Spanik, Michael A Schmidtke, Chad C Wong, Yan Jiao

    Objective: Blueline Tilefish Caulolatilus microps have a relatively brief history of exploitation in United States Atlantic waters. A stock assessment in 2017 indicated that age-structured models, although preferred over age-aggregated models, should not be used without reliable maturity estimates and age data for Blueline Tilefish. However, there have been only four immature Blueline Tilefish collected to date. Therefore, we collaborated with the charter boat sector of the recreational fishery to target small (<400 mm total length), potentially immature Blueline Tilefish to better estimate sexual maturity. In addition, we combined known data sets on age and reproduction from fish that were sampled from the southeastern U.S. Atlantic (SEUS) and U.S. mid-Atlantic (USMA) regions to determine the overall spawning season, sex ratios, and sexual maturity of Blueline Tilefish. Methods: Gonad histology was used to microscopically identify sexes and reproductive phases to determine the spawning season and sex ratios. Generalized additive models were used to analyze gonad weight–whole weight and gonad weight–month relationships. Length and age at maturity were estimated using logit, probit, and Gompertz models. Maturity was defined in four ways, based on different histological thresholds of oocyte stages, to separate fish that are expected to spawn (mature; n = 1,532) from those that will not spawn (immature; n = 9). Results: Sex ratios were female skewed in both regions and deviated significantly from 1:1 in the USMA. Gonad weight increased with whole weight in both regions. Female spawning peaks were identified as May–June and August–September for the SEUS and USMA, respectively, but USMA sample sizes remained low in most months. Despite targeted sampling, sample size remained low for immature fish (n = 9 total) as well as for fish from suspected nonspawning months. The Gompertz model for length at maturity and logit model for age at maturity in maturity scenario 4, whereby females in early development with cortical alveolar oocytes present were considered to be immature and females in vitellogenesis were scored as mature, were considered the best fit models for maturity ogives. These models estimated length and age at 50% maturity to be 337 mm total length and 3.1 years, respectively. Conclusions: Through a collaborative analysis of multiple data sets, it was possible to determine the spawning season, sex ratios, and sexual maturity of Blueline Tilefish in the SEUS and the USMA. Targeted sampling remains the only known method to acquire immature fish needed for better sexual maturity estimates, so we suggest that collaborative relationships with industry be maintained.


  • Open Access

    Applying mark-resight, count, and telemetry data to estimate effective sampling area and fish density with stationary underwater cameras

    by Viviane Zulian, Krishna Pacifici, Nathan M. Bacheler, Jeffrey A. Buckel, William F. Patterson, Brian J. Reich, Kyle W. Shertzer, Nathan J. Hostetter

    Accurate estimates of abundance and density for geographically open populations must account for the effective sampling area (ESA) of sampling gears. We describe a Marked N-Mixture model to estimate ESA and density (number of individuals/unit area) from repeated counts of unmarked and marked individuals, integrating mark-resight, camera counts, and telemetry data of red snapper ( Lutjanus campechanus) at a 1.6 km2 reef off North Carolina, USA. Cameras recorded observations of unmarked and marked individuals, whereas telemetry data indicated the number of tagged fish present on the reef. We estimated density (95 individuals/km2, 95%CI: 58–149), ESA (which was lower when current direction was towards the camera), detection probability (0.06, 95%CI: 0.03–0.09), and covariate relationships. Simulation studies under different scenarios of data quality and space use identified positive bias in density estimates from N-mixture models due to fish movement. In contrast, the Marked N-Mixture model returned unbiased estimates of density, ESA, and detection parameters, and appears to be a more robust method for modeling density given the data available for this analysis. This approach can be applied to other populations where count and telemetry data overlap in space and time.


  • Open Access

    Spawning Potential Ratio Can Provide Reference Points for Fishery Management That Are Robust to Environmental Variability

    by Kyle W. Shertzer, Matthew D. Damiano, Erik H. Williams

    Biological reference points are key quantities provided by stock assessments and used in fishery management for evaluating fishery status and setting future catch levels. For many fisheries worldwide, biological reference points are based on the spawning potential ratio (SPR), which measures per-recruit reproductive output as a function of the fishing rate relative to that when fishing is absent. SPR depends on the biological characteristics of the stock, which in turn can be influenced by the environment. A fishing rate based on SPR is often used as a proxy for the fishing rate that provides maximum sustainable yield. Here, we evaluate variability in the fishing rate (F40) that provides an SPR of 40%, a commonly used limit reference point, given plausible variability in biological characteristics. Using eight case-study species from marine waters off the southeast United States, we consider both simple random variability and directional variability, both of which might result from climate change. We test the sensitivity of F40 to various life-history traits and compute distributions of F40, given the expected variability in those traits. Based on those distributions, we evaluate the probabilities of overfishing given a target fishing rate (here, 75%F40) that is based on prevailing conditions without considering future variability in F40, consistent with common, current practice. Analyses also considered an SPR of 30% and 50% to evaluate the generality of conclusions. Results support that SPR-reference points are generally robust to plausible levels of variability in life-history traits that might be induced by environmental nonstationarity and that associated target fishing rates can provide meaningful buffers to prevent overfishing.


  • Fishery management strategies for Red Snapper in the southeastern U.S. Atlantic: A spatial population model to compare approaches

    by Kyle Shertzer, Scott Crosson, Erik Williams, Jie Cao, Rick DeVictor, Chris Dumas, Geneviève Nesslage

    Objective Red Snapper Lutjanus campechanus is an iconic species in the southeast U.S. Atlantic Ocean, sought by both commercial and recreational fleets. Five stock assessments over the past quarter century have shown Red Snapper to be experiencing overfishing. Highly restricted landings since 2010 have been insufficient to end overfishing because fishing effort is not species specific but rather applies generally to a complex of reef-associated species. Consequently, Red Snapper are discarded as bycatch when regulations prohibit their retention, and many of the discarded fish die from hook injury, barotrauma, or depredation. Methods Here we developed a spatial population model of Red Snapper and the multispecies fishery that captures them in the southeast U.S. Atlantic. We then simulated and compared 25 different management measures that fall broadly into the categories of gear modifications, discard mortality mitigation, size limits, spatial approaches, or temporal approaches. Criteria for comparison address the management goals of decreasing dead discards, rebuilding the age structure, and increasing landings and spawning biomass. Result We found that the most effective measures reduced fishing effort, either temporally or spatially, and that benefits could largely be obtained by focusing on the recreational fleet. Discard mortality mitigation (e.g., through use of descender devices) displayed a wide range in effectiveness depending on plausible levels of mortality reduction, but it addressed all management goals and in practice could be paired with other measures. A measure with restricted recreational effort combined with full retention of all fish caught showed the greatest potential to simultaneously rebuild the stock, increase landings, and eliminate dead discards. Conclusion To end overfishing of Red Snapper as required by law, resource managers should reconsider the policy of unrestricted effort of the private recreational fleet to this multispecies fishery. The benefits of restricted effort would include increased catch rates, larger landed fish, and fewer dead discards.


  • Source–sink recruitment of red snapper: Connectivity between the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean

    by Mandy Karnauskas, Kyle W. Shertzer, Claire B. Paris, Nicholas A. Farmer, Theodore S. Switzer, Susan K. Lowerre‐Barbieri, G. Todd Kellison, Ruoying He, Ana C. Vaz

    Geopolitical fishery management boundaries are often misaligned with the ecological population structure of marine species, which presents challenges for assessment and management of these species. Red snapper, Lutjanus campechanus, is an iconic and heavily exploited species in both the US Gulf of Mexico and off the southeastern US Atlantic coast and is managed separately in the two jurisdictions. It is hypothesized that the Atlantic red snapper stock is sustained partially by larval subsidies from the Gulf of Mexico. Here we use a biophysical modeling approach to simulate recruitment of red snapper across the entire Southeastern US region, and quantify rates of larval exchange across management jurisdictions. The biophysical framework simulates realistic red snapper behaviors and traits with respect to spatial distribution and timing of spawning, larval vertical migration and pelagic larval duration, and settlement habitat. Our results suggest that areas of the West Florida Shelf south of Tampa Bay are important sources of larvae for the Atlantic population, supplying as much as one third of the recruitment during some years. Yet, contributions of Gulf‐spawned red snapper to the Atlantic stock are highly dynamic given large variability in spatial and temporal patterns of red snapper recovery in each region. As such, effective management of the Gulf of Mexico red snapper stock, particularly the spawning population in southwest Florida, may have important consequences for the sustainable harvest of red snapper off the Atlantic coast.


  • Open Access

    Modeling Discards in Stock Assessments: Red Grouper Epinephelus morio in the U.S. Gulf of Mexico

    by Kyle W. Shertzer, Erik H. Williams, Skyler R. Sagarese

    To be as accurate as possible, stock assessments should account for discard mortality in fisheries if it occurs. Three common approaches to modeling discards in assessments are to lump dead discards with landings, treat dead discards as their own fleet, or link them conversely with landings through use of a retention function. The first approach (lumping) implicitly assumes that the selectivity of landings applies also to discards. In many cases, that assumption is false, for example, if discards comprise smaller fish than do landings. The latter two approaches avoid the assumption by modeling discards explicitly with their own selectivity pattern. Here, we examine these approaches to modeling discards. Using a simulation study, we demonstrate that the two approaches to modeling discards explicitly can provide identical results under both static and time-varying conditions. Then, using a stock assessment case study of red grouper Epinephelus morio in the U.S. Gulf of Mexico, we demonstrate that in practice the approaches to modeling discards can provide different outcomes, with implications for the resultant management advice. We conclude by comparing and contrasting the different approaches, calling for more research to elucidate which approach is most suitable under various sources of error typically encountered in discard data.


  • Open Access

    Discard Mortality of Red Snapper Released with Descender Devices in the U.S. South Atlantic

    by Brendan J. Runde, Nathan M. Bacheler, Kyle W. Shertzer, Paul J. Rudershausen, Beverly Sauls, Jeffrey A. Buckel


  • Open Access

    Spatio‐temporal dynamics of the threatened elkhorn coral Acropora palmata: Implications for conservation

    by Yi‐Hsiu Chen, Kyle W. Shertzer, T. Shay Viehman

    Aim: Species distribution models (SDMs) can be useful for predicting spatial dynamics. For species vulnerable to climate change, much attention has focused on predicting the future range of occurrence. However, predicted range changes provide little information about the potential impacts on population structure. Here, we develop and apply an SDM approach that incorporates population demography of a threatened coral species (U.S. Endangered Species Act) and aim to provide guidance for conservation efforts. We additionally use projected climate change scenarios to predict the potential future range of occurrence and spatial population structure.Location: U.S. Virgin Islands, United States.Methods: We applied process‐based dynamic range models to jointly model the spatio‐temporal population dynamics and spatial habitat suitability of the threatened elkhorn coral Acropora palmata in the U.S. Virgin Islands. The approach integrates information from multiple data sources under a hierarchical Bayesian framework. The models connect two components: (1) a niche model that correlates environmental predictors with demographic rates and (2) a size‐structured population model that describes local population dynamics and dispersal.Results: The model predicts that, under scenarios of elevated sea surface temperature and significant wave height, (a) A. palmata will occur at only a small proportion of its potential habitat (water depth ≤ 20 m) and (b) population structure of the colony will shift from larger towards smaller size classes.Main conclusions: For A. palmata, restricted geographic range and smaller colony sizes, as predicted by the models, would limit future population success. In general, the inclusion of demographic structure into a population range model provides critical information for conservation or restoration efforts in the context of climate change.


  • Paulik revisited: Statistical framework and estimation performance of multistage recruitment functions

    by Elizabeth N. Brooks, James T. Thorson, Kyle W. Shertzer, Richard D.M. Nash, Jon K.T. Brodziak, Kelli F. Johnson, Nikolai Klibansky, Brian K. Wells, Jonathan White