Ann Griffin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Ann Griffin has a total of 67 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Antonia Rich
UCL Research Department of Medical Education, UCL Medical School, University College London, London, UK
7 shared publications - Alex McKeown
A University of Oxford
4 shared publications - Chase Staras
Research Department of Medical Education, University College London, London, UK
4 shared publications - Lorraine M. Noble
UCL Medical School, University College London, London, UK
4 shared publications - Shaun Boustani
UCL Research Department of Medical Education, UCL Medical School, University College London, London, UK
4 shared publications - Gianpaolo Manalastas
UCL Medical School, University College London, London, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
How should doctors manage workplace interruptions? A qualitative study in UK hospital outpatient departments
Background: Interruptions are common in hospital outpatient departments (OPDs) and are linked to error. Many are clinically necessary, so the aim is to regulate them. Most interventions target the individual clinician. Little is known about how doctors manage interruptions in practice or what makes their strategies work. Methods: Qualitative study using focus groups and interviews with 42 doctors working in UK National Health Service OPDs (19 sessions, September to November 2025). Participants were purposively sampled by clinical experience and self-reported patient complexity. Data were analysed using Framework Analysis, informed by Cognitive Load Theory and Social Identity Theory. Results: We developed four themes. (1) Pre-emptive protection of attention . Doctors withdrew, signalled unavailability and set thresholds for interrupting. These depended on colleagues learning and sharing the norm, which staff rotation eroded. (2) Sharing the burden through team coordination . Designated roles and time-limited rotas moved interruptions to colleagues with capacity set aside for them and made interrupting legitimate. (3) Real-time cognitive repair . Doctors asked interrupters to wait while they secured the task, and rebuilt the consultation on return, sometimes with the patient’s help. Asking a colleague to wait depended on seniority or team membership; some trainees described difficulty doing this with senior colleagues. (4) Organisational recognition as the precondition for sustainable regulation . Where supervision was built into job plans, the interruptions it generated were expected and doctors held capacity in reserve for them. Advice, vetting and telephone queries were rarely counted as work. Conclusions: Each strategy served a cognitive purpose, and social and organisational conditions decided whether it was perceived to work. Interventions could make norms shared and roles explicit, count interruption work in job plans and keep routes open for junior staff to raise concerns. Evaluations should ask who is able to use them. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC: Interruptions are common in clinical work and can disrupt task completion, while most interventions focus on individual clinicians and have shown mixed effects. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: Doctors described strategies to protect attention, redistribute interruptions and repair disrupted tasks, but their use depended on shared norms, legitimate roles, social standing and organisational capacity. Some trainees described difficulty asking senior colleagues to wait, although trainee representation in this sample was limited. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY: Departments could agree urgency thresholds alongside clear routes for non-urgent requests, use time-limited roles for queries and recognise advice and supervision in workload planning. Evaluations should assess who can use these arrangements and whether staff can still escalate concerns.
Open AccessHow should doctors manage workplace interruptions? A qualitative study in UK hospital outpatient departments
Background: Interruptions are common in hospital outpatient departments (OPDs) and are linked to error. Many are clinically necessary, so the aim is to regulate them. Most interventions target the individual clinician. Little is known about how doctors manage interruptions in practice or what makes their strategies work. Methods: Qualitative study using focus groups and interviews with 42 doctors working in UK National Health Service OPDs (19 sessions, September to November 2025). Participants were purposively sampled by clinical experience and self-reported patient complexity. Data were analysed using Framework Analysis, informed by Cognitive Load Theory and Social Identity Theory. Results: We developed four themes. (1) Pre-emptive protection of attention . Doctors withdrew, signalled unavailability and set thresholds for interrupting. These depended on colleagues learning and sharing the norm, which staff rotation eroded. (2) Sharing the burden through team coordination . Designated roles and time-limited rotas moved interruptions to colleagues with capacity set aside for them and made interrupting legitimate. (3) Real-time cognitive repair . Doctors asked interrupters to wait while they secured the task, and rebuilt the consultation on return, sometimes with the patient’s help. Asking a colleague to wait depended on seniority or team membership; some trainees described difficulty doing this with senior colleagues. (4) Organisational recognition as the precondition for sustainable regulation . Where supervision was built into job plans, the interruptions it generated were expected and doctors held capacity in reserve for them. Advice, vetting and telephone queries were rarely counted as work. Conclusions: Each strategy served a cognitive purpose, and social and organisational conditions decided whether it was perceived to work. Interventions could make norms shared and roles explicit, count interruption work in job plans and keep routes open for junior staff to raise concerns. Evaluations should ask who is able to use them. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC: Interruptions are common in clinical work and can disrupt task completion, while most interventions focus on individual clinicians and have shown mixed effects. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: Doctors described strategies to protect attention, redistribute interruptions and repair disrupted tasks, but their use depended on shared norms, legitimate roles, social standing and organisational capacity. Some trainees described difficulty asking senior colleagues to wait, although trainee representation in this sample was limited. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY: Departments could agree urgency thresholds alongside clear routes for non-urgent requests, use time-limited roles for queries and recognise advice and supervision in workload planning. Evaluations should assess who can use these arrangements and whether staff can still escalate concerns.
- Open Access
Who carries the cost of interruptions? A qualitative study of doctors in UK hospital outpatient departments
Background: Hospital outpatient departments (OPDs) deliver specialist care at scale, under close scrutiny over waiting times. Interruptions are common in this setting and are linked to error. Little is known about how they cause harm, for whom, and under what conditions. Methods: Qualitative study using focus groups and interviews with 42 doctors working in UK National Health Service OPDs (19 sessions, September to November 2025). Participants were purposively sampled by clinical experience and self-reported patient complexity. Data were analysed using the Framework Method, informed by Cognitive Load Theory and Social Identity Theory, with independent double coding of 10% of transcripts and participant validation. Results: We developed four themes. (1) Interruptions as a structural and increasingly ambiguous feature of clinical work . Interruptions were a normal part of clinical coordination, but new communication channels lacked shared norms about urgency, so each doctor had to judge what mattered. (2) The hidden cognitive cost of interruptions . The main cost came from returning to the interrupted task. This cost grew with complexity and was only partly offset by experience. (3) The social fabric of interruption burden . Transient teams weakened the norms that regulate interrupting, and approachability and hierarchy concentrated the burden on particular doctors. (4) The social amplification of cognitive burden . Understaffing multiplied cognitive costs. Doctors used familiarity and track record to decide which requests deserved attention, so concerns from junior or unfamiliar colleagues risked being discounted. Conclusions: Interruptions are structural, and their impact depends on cognitive and social conditions. Reducing interruption frequency alone may miss the main risk. Interventions should support task resumption, protect capacity at busy times, rebuild shared communication norms and take account of the receiver’s capacity when designing escalation. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC: Interruptions are common in clinical work and are linked to error, and laboratory studies place much of their cost in resuming the interrupted task. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: In UK hospital outpatient departments, doctors’ accounts were consistent with these known mechanisms and suggest two further ones. Unfamiliar teams add cognitive load because each request has to be judged on its content, and under pressure, concerns raised by junior or unfamiliar colleagues may be discounted by the person receiving them. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY: Interventions should support task resumption, set shared norms about urgency, protect doctors’ capacity at busy times and design escalation with the receiver’s capacity in mind.
Open AccessWho carries the cost of interruptions? A qualitative study of doctors in UK hospital outpatient departments
Background: Hospital outpatient departments (OPDs) deliver specialist care at scale, under close scrutiny over waiting times. Interruptions are common in this setting and are linked to error. Little is known about how they cause harm, for whom, and under what conditions. Methods: Qualitative study using focus groups and interviews with 42 doctors working in UK National Health Service OPDs (19 sessions, September to November 2025). Participants were purposively sampled by clinical experience and self-reported patient complexity. Data were analysed using the Framework Method, informed by Cognitive Load Theory and Social Identity Theory, with independent double coding of 10% of transcripts and participant validation. Results: We developed four themes. (1) Interruptions as a structural and increasingly ambiguous feature of clinical work . Interruptions were a normal part of clinical coordination, but new communication channels lacked shared norms about urgency, so each doctor had to judge what mattered. (2) The hidden cognitive cost of interruptions . The main cost came from returning to the interrupted task. This cost grew with complexity and was only partly offset by experience. (3) The social fabric of interruption burden . Transient teams weakened the norms that regulate interrupting, and approachability and hierarchy concentrated the burden on particular doctors. (4) The social amplification of cognitive burden . Understaffing multiplied cognitive costs. Doctors used familiarity and track record to decide which requests deserved attention, so concerns from junior or unfamiliar colleagues risked being discounted. Conclusions: Interruptions are structural, and their impact depends on cognitive and social conditions. Reducing interruption frequency alone may miss the main risk. Interventions should support task resumption, protect capacity at busy times, rebuild shared communication norms and take account of the receiver’s capacity when designing escalation. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC: Interruptions are common in clinical work and are linked to error, and laboratory studies place much of their cost in resuming the interrupted task. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: In UK hospital outpatient departments, doctors’ accounts were consistent with these known mechanisms and suggest two further ones. Unfamiliar teams add cognitive load because each request has to be judged on its content, and under pressure, concerns raised by junior or unfamiliar colleagues may be discounted by the person receiving them. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY: Interventions should support task resumption, set shared norms about urgency, protect doctors’ capacity at busy times and design escalation with the receiver’s capacity in mind.
- Open Access
Understanding clinician engagement with electronic health records: a mixed-methods study of structured data entry using the Theory of Planned Behaviour
Background: Electronic health records (EHRs) are central to NHS clinical practice, and the value of the data they hold depends on clinicians entering structured data. Structured data entry (SDE) is nonetheless used inconsistently, and most evidence comes from US settings documenting barriers rather than the mechanisms interventions must target. This is, to our knowledge, the first study to apply the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) to SDE, to examine SDE behaviour among UK NHS doctors, and to apply corpus linguistics to clinicians’ free-text accounts of EHR use. Methods: A two-part mixed-methods study was conducted at a large NHS teaching hospital in central London using the Epic EHR. Study 1 was a cross-sectional survey of non-consultant grade doctors comprising the System Usability Scale (SUS), a purpose-designed TPB questionnaire, and two open-text questions analysed using corpus linguistics. Study 2 was an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) of semi-structured interviews with six resident doctors. Results: Eighty-three doctors responded; 65 completed the SUS and 49 the TPB questionnaire. Mean SUS score was 62.1 (95% CI 58.3-65.9), below the benchmark of 68 and equivalent to a grade of “D”. Structured features were used markedly less often than narrative notes. TPB constructs explained 56% of the variance in intention (F(3,45) = 18.95, p < .001); attitudes (p = .003) and subjective norms (p = .009) predicted intention independently, whereas perceived behavioural control did not (p = .14). Intention predicted self-reported use of problem lists, event-specific templates and standardised documents, but not narrative notes. Corpus analysis identified time pressure and interface friction as dominant barriers. IPA generated four themes: structured documentation as cognitive relief; as fragile collective infrastructure; as a practice clinicians are expected to perform but not enabled to learn; and as a format that can flatten clinical reasoning. Conclusions: Engagement with SDE is driven principally by attitudes and social norms rather than by perceived control, and the barriers clinicians describe arise from the intersection of interface design, training, team norms and institutional expectation. Interventions addressing usability alone are unlikely to succeed: sustained change requires team-level normative reinforcement, specialty-relevant training that explains both how and why, and systems that preserve space for clinical narrative.
Open AccessUnderstanding clinician engagement with electronic health records: a mixed-methods study of structured data entry using the Theory of Planned Behaviour
Background: Electronic health records (EHRs) are central to NHS clinical practice, and the value of the data they hold depends on clinicians entering structured data. Structured data entry (SDE) is nonetheless used inconsistently, and most evidence comes from US settings documenting barriers rather than the mechanisms interventions must target. This is, to our knowledge, the first study to apply the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) to SDE, to examine SDE behaviour among UK NHS doctors, and to apply corpus linguistics to clinicians’ free-text accounts of EHR use. Methods: A two-part mixed-methods study was conducted at a large NHS teaching hospital in central London using the Epic EHR. Study 1 was a cross-sectional survey of non-consultant grade doctors comprising the System Usability Scale (SUS), a purpose-designed TPB questionnaire, and two open-text questions analysed using corpus linguistics. Study 2 was an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) of semi-structured interviews with six resident doctors. Results: Eighty-three doctors responded; 65 completed the SUS and 49 the TPB questionnaire. Mean SUS score was 62.1 (95% CI 58.3-65.9), below the benchmark of 68 and equivalent to a grade of “D”. Structured features were used markedly less often than narrative notes. TPB constructs explained 56% of the variance in intention (F(3,45) = 18.95, p < .001); attitudes (p = .003) and subjective norms (p = .009) predicted intention independently, whereas perceived behavioural control did not (p = .14). Intention predicted self-reported use of problem lists, event-specific templates and standardised documents, but not narrative notes. Corpus analysis identified time pressure and interface friction as dominant barriers. IPA generated four themes: structured documentation as cognitive relief; as fragile collective infrastructure; as a practice clinicians are expected to perform but not enabled to learn; and as a format that can flatten clinical reasoning. Conclusions: Engagement with SDE is driven principally by attitudes and social norms rather than by perceived control, and the barriers clinicians describe arise from the intersection of interface design, training, team norms and institutional expectation. Interventions addressing usability alone are unlikely to succeed: sustained change requires team-level normative reinforcement, specialty-relevant training that explains both how and why, and systems that preserve space for clinical narrative.
- Open Access
Doctors’ experiences of interruptions in UK secondary care outpatient clinics: a cross-sectional survey of prevalence, consequences and management strategies
Objectives: To examine the prevalence of interruptions during UK secondary care outpatient consultations, their association with clinician mental workload, and the strategies clinicians use to manage them. Design: Nationwide cross-sectional online survey. Setting: Secondary care outpatient clinics, United Kingdom. Participants: A sample of 465 UK secondary care doctors across a range of grades and specialties, recruited through a medical defence organisation’s network. Primary and secondary outcome measures: Mental workload (NASA Task Load Index, Raw-TLX); interruption frequency; perceived cognitive impact of interruptions; task resumption difficulty; perceived social effects on colleague interactions and team cohesion; and interruption-management strategy use. Results: 61.1% of clinicians reported being interrupted often or very often, and mean overall workload was high (Raw-TLX 66.2, SD 11.5). Interruption frequency, patient complexity and perceived cognitive impact were each associated with higher workload across multiple NASA-TLX subscales. In fully adjusted models, interruption frequency retained independent associations with overall workload (β = 1.79, p = 0.004) and temporal demand (β = 0.94, p < 0.001). Task resumption difficulty was associated with worse perceived performance (β = −0.59, p = 0.014), while perceiving interruptions as socially positive was associated with better performance (β = 0.75, p = 0.003) and lower frustration (β = −1.16, p < 0.001). Years of experience showed only small effects, and self-reported strategy use (38.7%) was not consistently associated with lower workload. Exploratory natural language processing of open-text descriptions identified three strategy clusters; cognitive offloading, anticipating and preparing, and blunt responses, with distinct emotional profiles. Conclusions: Interruptions were commonly reported during UK secondary care outpatient consultations and were associated with measurable cognitive and temporal burden. The perceived social framing of interruptions was independently associated with frustration and self-rated performance. Binary strategy use showed no consistent workload association, indicating a need for system-level approaches addressing interruption frequency, task resumption support and the social context of interruptions rather than reliance on individual coping. Strengths and limitations of this study: To our knowledge, this is the first national survey of interruptions in UK secondary care outpatient consultations, spanning a wide range of specialties, grades and career stages (0–52 years post-qualification). Mental workload was measured using the NASA Task Load Index, a validated multidimensional instrument, allowing workload to be decomposed into cognitive, temporal, physical and affective components. Open-text descriptions of interruption-management strategies were analysed using natural language processing, revealing heterogeneity in strategy type that binary coding alone would have obscured. The cross-sectional design precludes causal inference, and the direction of the association between perceived interruption frequency and workload cannot be established. Recruitment through a single medical defence organisation’s network, together with an indeterminate eligible denominator, means this was a convenience sample in which non-response bias cannot be excluded.
Open AccessDoctors’ experiences of interruptions in UK secondary care outpatient clinics: a cross-sectional survey of prevalence, consequences and management strategies
Objectives: To examine the prevalence of interruptions during UK secondary care outpatient consultations, their association with clinician mental workload, and the strategies clinicians use to manage them. Design: Nationwide cross-sectional online survey. Setting: Secondary care outpatient clinics, United Kingdom. Participants: A sample of 465 UK secondary care doctors across a range of grades and specialties, recruited through a medical defence organisation’s network. Primary and secondary outcome measures: Mental workload (NASA Task Load Index, Raw-TLX); interruption frequency; perceived cognitive impact of interruptions; task resumption difficulty; perceived social effects on colleague interactions and team cohesion; and interruption-management strategy use. Results: 61.1% of clinicians reported being interrupted often or very often, and mean overall workload was high (Raw-TLX 66.2, SD 11.5). Interruption frequency, patient complexity and perceived cognitive impact were each associated with higher workload across multiple NASA-TLX subscales. In fully adjusted models, interruption frequency retained independent associations with overall workload (β = 1.79, p = 0.004) and temporal demand (β = 0.94, p < 0.001). Task resumption difficulty was associated with worse perceived performance (β = −0.59, p = 0.014), while perceiving interruptions as socially positive was associated with better performance (β = 0.75, p = 0.003) and lower frustration (β = −1.16, p < 0.001). Years of experience showed only small effects, and self-reported strategy use (38.7%) was not consistently associated with lower workload. Exploratory natural language processing of open-text descriptions identified three strategy clusters; cognitive offloading, anticipating and preparing, and blunt responses, with distinct emotional profiles. Conclusions: Interruptions were commonly reported during UK secondary care outpatient consultations and were associated with measurable cognitive and temporal burden. The perceived social framing of interruptions was independently associated with frustration and self-rated performance. Binary strategy use showed no consistent workload association, indicating a need for system-level approaches addressing interruption frequency, task resumption support and the social context of interruptions rather than reliance on individual coping. Strengths and limitations of this study: To our knowledge, this is the first national survey of interruptions in UK secondary care outpatient consultations, spanning a wide range of specialties, grades and career stages (0–52 years post-qualification). Mental workload was measured using the NASA Task Load Index, a validated multidimensional instrument, allowing workload to be decomposed into cognitive, temporal, physical and affective components. Open-text descriptions of interruption-management strategies were analysed using natural language processing, revealing heterogeneity in strategy type that binary coding alone would have obscured. The cross-sectional design precludes causal inference, and the direction of the association between perceived interruption frequency and workload cannot be established. Recruitment through a single medical defence organisation’s network, together with an indeterminate eligible denominator, means this was a convenience sample in which non-response bias cannot be excluded.
- Open Access
What works in educational interventions for teams caring for children and young people admitted to general acute paediatric wards for mental health? A systematic review
Objective: To systematically review educational interventions for staff working on acute paediatric wards aimed at improving the care of children and young people (CYP) admitted for mental health support. Design: We conducted a systematic search of PubMed, ERIC, PsychInfo, and Web of Science from 2000 to September 2025 using terms related to healthcare professionals, training/education, mental health , and children/young people . PRISMA guidelines were followed. Interventions were classified using the Kirkpatrick model and the Behavioural Change Technique Taxonomy (BCT v1) to identify mechanisms underpinning effective change. Results: We found nine studies met inclusion criteria, across a range of teaching methodologies, and settings. Most interventions were designed and applied for nurses. Overall quality of evidence was poor. Although no single intervention could be recommended, analysis identified potentially useful components tailored to different learner needs, mapped through the Kirkpatrick and BCT frameworks. A notable gap was a lack of co-design with CYP and carers with lived experience and the absence of strategies to engage ambivalent or reluctant learners who might not attend educational interventions voluntarily. Conclusions: Existing educational interventions contain elements that may support behavioural and practice change among staff caring for CYP with mental health needs. However, future research should prioritise high-quality, framework-based evaluations developed through co-design with CYP and carers. Interventions should also address how to engage learners who may be reluctant to participate in training for this area of clinical practice.
Open AccessWhat works in educational interventions for teams caring for children and young people admitted to general acute paediatric wards for mental health? A systematic review
Objective: To systematically review educational interventions for staff working on acute paediatric wards aimed at improving the care of children and young people (CYP) admitted for mental health support. Design: We conducted a systematic search of PubMed, ERIC, PsychInfo, and Web of Science from 2000 to September 2025 using terms related to healthcare professionals, training/education, mental health , and children/young people . PRISMA guidelines were followed. Interventions were classified using the Kirkpatrick model and the Behavioural Change Technique Taxonomy (BCT v1) to identify mechanisms underpinning effective change. Results: We found nine studies met inclusion criteria, across a range of teaching methodologies, and settings. Most interventions were designed and applied for nurses. Overall quality of evidence was poor. Although no single intervention could be recommended, analysis identified potentially useful components tailored to different learner needs, mapped through the Kirkpatrick and BCT frameworks. A notable gap was a lack of co-design with CYP and carers with lived experience and the absence of strategies to engage ambivalent or reluctant learners who might not attend educational interventions voluntarily. Conclusions: Existing educational interventions contain elements that may support behavioural and practice change among staff caring for CYP with mental health needs. However, future research should prioritise high-quality, framework-based evaluations developed through co-design with CYP and carers. Interventions should also address how to engage learners who may be reluctant to participate in training for this area of clinical practice.
- Open Access
Poly-skilling and advanced practice roles in perioperative care: protocol for a realist synthesis of evidence
Introduction An ageing population and a workforce crisis have triggered an ambitious UK strategy for sustained delivery of healthcare. In perioperative care (the management of patients from contemplation of surgery until full recovery), it is recognised that interventions are needed to place the workforce on a more sustainable footing through cross-functionality and skill-shifting, namely with advanced practice roles. However, despite some reports and reviews in the literature, it is unclear how skills development efforts may potentially support workforce transformation for an effective and resilient perioperative care workforce. Thus, drawing causal inferences for policy-making that is both evidence based and rooted in theory is challenging. A scoping review, reported within this protocol, confirmed that ‘poly-skilling’ and ‘advanced practice roles’ are critical to this workforce transformation, but the mechanisms through which interventions in this area may work are not understood. A synthesis of evidence is, therefore, proposed in this protocol, to understand what works for whom and under what circumstances, in relation to poly-skilling and advanced practice roles in workforce transformation for sustained healthcare delivery. Methods and analysis This protocol sets out the plan to undertake a realist synthesis of the related literature, with theory elicitation (step 1), search for empirical evidence (step 2), selection and appraisal of evidence (step 3) and programme theory refinement (step 4). Exploratory reviews of the literature and key informants’ inputs will produce initial hypotheses as to what it is about interventions in poly-skilling and advanced practice roles that work and why. Data from the literature will then be collected based on relevance, rigour and richness. The iterative analysis and synthesis of these data will produce causal links between contexts, mechanisms and outcomes. The results will inform a realist evaluation, to be undertaken as part of doctoral research, to better understand the mechanisms that support workforce transformation through poly-skilling and advanced practice roles. Ethics and dissemination As a review of previously published literature, the evidence synthesis proposed in this protocol does not require formal ethical approval. Recommended ethical considerations regarding the involvement of key informants, who are not study participants but a consultative group, are presented in this protocol. A formal ethics approval will be sought ahead of the later empirical stage of the research. The results of the realist synthesis proposed in this protocol will be fed back to the local National Health Service organisation and Integrated Care Board and disseminated to the research community via presentations at conferences and a peer-reviewed journal article. PROSPERO registration number CRD42024512164.
Open AccessPoly-skilling and advanced practice roles in perioperative care: protocol for a realist synthesis of evidence
Introduction An ageing population and a workforce crisis have triggered an ambitious UK strategy for sustained delivery of healthcare. In perioperative care (the management of patients from contemplation of surgery until full recovery), it is recognised that interventions are needed to place the workforce on a more sustainable footing through cross-functionality and skill-shifting, namely with advanced practice roles. However, despite some reports and reviews in the literature, it is unclear how skills development efforts may potentially support workforce transformation for an effective and resilient perioperative care workforce. Thus, drawing causal inferences for policy-making that is both evidence based and rooted in theory is challenging. A scoping review, reported within this protocol, confirmed that ‘poly-skilling’ and ‘advanced practice roles’ are critical to this workforce transformation, but the mechanisms through which interventions in this area may work are not understood. A synthesis of evidence is, therefore, proposed in this protocol, to understand what works for whom and under what circumstances, in relation to poly-skilling and advanced practice roles in workforce transformation for sustained healthcare delivery. Methods and analysis This protocol sets out the plan to undertake a realist synthesis of the related literature, with theory elicitation (step 1), search for empirical evidence (step 2), selection and appraisal of evidence (step 3) and programme theory refinement (step 4). Exploratory reviews of the literature and key informants’ inputs will produce initial hypotheses as to what it is about interventions in poly-skilling and advanced practice roles that work and why. Data from the literature will then be collected based on relevance, rigour and richness. The iterative analysis and synthesis of these data will produce causal links between contexts, mechanisms and outcomes. The results will inform a realist evaluation, to be undertaken as part of doctoral research, to better understand the mechanisms that support workforce transformation through poly-skilling and advanced practice roles. Ethics and dissemination As a review of previously published literature, the evidence synthesis proposed in this protocol does not require formal ethical approval. Recommended ethical considerations regarding the involvement of key informants, who are not study participants but a consultative group, are presented in this protocol. A formal ethics approval will be sought ahead of the later empirical stage of the research. The results of the realist synthesis proposed in this protocol will be fed back to the local National Health Service organisation and Integrated Care Board and disseminated to the research community via presentations at conferences and a peer-reviewed journal article. PROSPERO registration number CRD42024512164.
- Open Access
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Education for Primary Care
- Vol. 34 (4) , 220-227
A realist evaluation of a London general practitioner trainer course
Clinicians with teaching and training roles should be adequately trained and assessed. However, some debate exists as to what the nature of this training should be. Historically, a postgraduate certificate in education was a pre-requisite to becoming a GP trainer but this is changing with growing concern that such a pre-requisite might act as a deterrent to potential GP trainers. This research examines the impact of a scheme designed to provide an alternative, more practical and focused, pathway to becoming a GP trainer. We interviewed 26 course participants and stakeholders of the London GP Training Course (LGPTC), observed teaching sessions, and analysed course materials. We asked what elements of the course were and weren't effective, for whom, and under what circumstances. Here, we present a summary of our main findings - that GP trainers want to know practically, not theoretically, how to be a trainer; formative assessment boosts trainees' confidence in their own skills and abilities; short, practical GP training courses can help enhance the numbers of GP trainers; important questions remain about the role and value of educational theory in education faculty development.
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Education for Primary Care
- Vol. 34 (4) , 220-227
Open AccessA realist evaluation of a London general practitioner trainer course
Clinicians with teaching and training roles should be adequately trained and assessed. However, some debate exists as to what the nature of this training should be. Historically, a postgraduate certificate in education was a pre-requisite to becoming a GP trainer but this is changing with growing concern that such a pre-requisite might act as a deterrent to potential GP trainers. This research examines the impact of a scheme designed to provide an alternative, more practical and focused, pathway to becoming a GP trainer. We interviewed 26 course participants and stakeholders of the London GP Training Course (LGPTC), observed teaching sessions, and analysed course materials. We asked what elements of the course were and weren't effective, for whom, and under what circumstances. Here, we present a summary of our main findings - that GP trainers want to know practically, not theoretically, how to be a trainer; formative assessment boosts trainees' confidence in their own skills and abilities; short, practical GP training courses can help enhance the numbers of GP trainers; important questions remain about the role and value of educational theory in education faculty development.
- Open Access
- 20 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-11
A national qualitative investigation of the impact of service change on doctors’ training during Covid-19
Background: The Covid-19 crisis sparked service reconfigurations in healthcare systems worldwide. With postgraduate medical education sitting within these systems, service reconfigurations substantially impact trainees and their training environment. This study aims to provide an in-depth qualitative understanding of the impact of service reconfiguration on doctors’ training during the pandemic, identifying opportunities for the future as well as factors that pose risks to education and training and how these might be mitigated. Methods: Qualitative parallel multi-centre case studies examined three Trusts/Health Boards in two countries in the United Kingdom. Data were collected from online focus groups and interviews with trainees and supervisors using semi-structured interview guides (September to December 2020). A socio-cultural model of workplace learning, the expansive-restrictive continuum, informed data gathering, analysis of focus groups and coding. Results: Sixty-six doctors participated, representing 25 specialties/subspecialties. Thirty-four participants were male, 26 were supervisors, 17 were specialty trainees and 23 were foundation doctors. Four themes described the impact of pandemic-related service reconfigurations on training: (1) Development of skills and job design, (2) Supervision and assessments, (3) Teamwork and communication, and (4) Workload and wellbeing. Service changes were found to both facilitate and hinder education and training, varying across sites, specialties, and trainees’ grades. Trainees’ jobs were redesigned extensively, and many trainees were redeployed to specialties requiring extra workforce during the pandemic. Conclusions: The rapid and unplanned service reconfigurations during the pandemic caused unique challenges and opportunities to doctors’ training. This impaired trainees’ development in their specialty of interest, but also presented new opportunities such as cross-boundary working and networking.
- 20 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-11
Open AccessA national qualitative investigation of the impact of service change on doctors’ training during Covid-19
Background: The Covid-19 crisis sparked service reconfigurations in healthcare systems worldwide. With postgraduate medical education sitting within these systems, service reconfigurations substantially impact trainees and their training environment. This study aims to provide an in-depth qualitative understanding of the impact of service reconfiguration on doctors’ training during the pandemic, identifying opportunities for the future as well as factors that pose risks to education and training and how these might be mitigated. Methods: Qualitative parallel multi-centre case studies examined three Trusts/Health Boards in two countries in the United Kingdom. Data were collected from online focus groups and interviews with trainees and supervisors using semi-structured interview guides (September to December 2020). A socio-cultural model of workplace learning, the expansive-restrictive continuum, informed data gathering, analysis of focus groups and coding. Results: Sixty-six doctors participated, representing 25 specialties/subspecialties. Thirty-four participants were male, 26 were supervisors, 17 were specialty trainees and 23 were foundation doctors. Four themes described the impact of pandemic-related service reconfigurations on training: (1) Development of skills and job design, (2) Supervision and assessments, (3) Teamwork and communication, and (4) Workload and wellbeing. Service changes were found to both facilitate and hinder education and training, varying across sites, specialties, and trainees’ grades. Trainees’ jobs were redesigned extensively, and many trainees were redeployed to specialties requiring extra workforce during the pandemic. Conclusions: The rapid and unplanned service reconfigurations during the pandemic caused unique challenges and opportunities to doctors’ training. This impaired trainees’ development in their specialty of interest, but also presented new opportunities such as cross-boundary working and networking.
- 14 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 57 (1) , 21-22
The state of science. When I say … quality
In the latest instalment of "When I Say..." Griffin and Konfli suggest we re‐examine words commonly associated with quality in medical education because exploring their inherent ambiguity can aid our re‐thinking and create new practices.
- 14 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 57 (1) , 21-22
The state of science. When I say … quality
In the latest instalment of "When I Say..." Griffin and Konfli suggest we re‐examine words commonly associated with quality in medical education because exploring their inherent ambiguity can aid our re‐thinking and create new practices.