MBMargaret Brown

Margaret Brown

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Margaret Brown has a total of 38 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

    • 1 January 2023
      • Vol. 30  (1) , 155-165

    Can Doctors Be Compelled to Prolong the Life of a Dying Patient? The Ongoing Medical, Legal and Social Issues

    by Margaret Brown

    The law does not require health professionals to provide medical treatment that is of no benefit to the patient. Despite this, medical staff who are caring for patients at the end of their lives frequently experience pressure from the patients' families to prolong their lives. This article considers the Australian law relating to the right to demand treatment when a loved one is dying, and whether an increasing emphasis on shared decision-making has introduced uncertainty. It discusses factors that affect the application of the law, including widespread ignorance of the law, the difficulty of deciding whether a treatment is futile and the need to ration scarce health care resources. It also introduces the perspectives of three senior medical practitioners on disputes with families of dying patients. The article concludes that community education is needed on legal and medical issues at the end of life, including conversations about advance care directives.

  • Open Access

    The impact of language on the interpretation of resuscitation clinical care plans by doctors. A mixed methods study

    by Colette Dignam, Josephine Thomas, Margaret Brown, Campbell H. Thompson

    Resuscitation clinical care plans (resuscitation plans) are gradually replacing ‘Not for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation’ orders in the hospital setting. The 7-Step Pathway Resuscitation Plan and Alert form (7-Step form) is one example of a resuscitation plan. Treatment recommendations in resuscitation plans currently lack standardised language, creating potential for misinterpretation and patient harm. To explore how terminology used in resuscitation plans is interpreted and applied by clinicians. A mixed methods study surveyed 50 general medical doctors, who were required to interpret and apply a 7-Step form in three case vignettes and define seven key terms. Statistical analysis on multiple choice and thematic analysis on free-text responses was performed. Terminology was inconsistently interpreted and inconsistently applied, resulting in clinically significant differences in treatment choices. Three key themes influenced the application of a resuscitation plan: in-depth discussion, precise documentation and personal experience of the bedside deciding doctor. This study highlights persistent communication deficiencies in resuscitation plan documentation and how this may adversely affect patient care; findings unlikely to be unique to Australia or South Australia. Removing ambiguity by standardising and defining the terminology in resuscitation plans will improve bedside decision-making, while also supporting the rights of the patient to receive appropriate and desired care.


  • Changes in resuscitation and end‐of‐life documentation in older patients’ clinical case notes: A comparison of 2011 and 2017 practice

    by Colette Dignam, Margaret Brown, Campbell H Thompson

    Objective: To compare 2011 and 2017 documentation of resuscitation decisions in older patients, including the frequency and clarity of documentation.Methods: The clinical case notes of 130 patients aged 70 years and over were examined to identify how resuscitation decisions are discussed and documented at a major teaching hospital. Results were compared to 2011 data.Results: The proportion of patients with a documented order significantly increased, from 34 to 63%, with a concurrent increased number of patients identified as Not For Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (Not for CPR). The standardised documentation has also improved rates of documented discussion, legibility and identification of the involved doctor.Conclusion: The Resuscitation Plan 7‐Step Pathway has markedly improved the frequency of documented discussion, the rate of recorded Not For CPR status and clarity of documentation. There is scope for improvement as this policy is embraced across South Australia.


    • 1 February 2018
      • Vol. 25  (2) , 538-548

    The South Australian Advance Care Directives Act 2013: How Has the Decision-Making Paradigm Changed?

    by Margaret Brown

    This article analyses how the Advance Care Directives Act 2013 (SA) is changing the decision-making paradigm in health care and guardianship in South Australia. It examines the background to the legislation, the main areas that have been transformed by the Act and the amendments to associated legislation. The significant changes include an increased respect for autonomy and a presumption of decision-making capacity, a new paradigm of substitute decision-making, clarification of the decision-making hierarchy, and protections for medical practitioners who decline to give treatment that would have no benefit to a dying patient. Despite some difficulties implementing the new scheme, this article argues that the Act has introduced important changes and clarifications in the law that other States would do well to follow. When it is fully implemented, the Act will ensure that the wishes of patients are respected and that doctors can follow these wishes without fear of prosecution.

  • Advance care directives are an important part of good healthcare

    by Margaret Brown, Christine Drummond


  • A patient-centred model of care incorporating a palliative approach: A framework to meet the needs of people with advanced COPD?

    by Gregory B. Crawford, Teresa A. Burgess, Mary Young, Mary A. Brooksbank, Margaret Brown

    BACKGROUND: Current models of care for people with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) have been demonstrated to be inadequate, particularly in areas such as advance care planning, symptom control and psychosocial and spiritual care. AIM: This paper aims to explore how a model of patient-centred care can incorporate a palliative approach to form a practical and useful framework for care that meets the needs of people with advanced COPD. DISCUSSION: There is increasing recognition of the need to provide active disease management at the same time as supportive care for people with chronic disease. A palliative approach can incorporate these two care imperatives but a number of barriers often make implementation problematic. A patient-centred care approach can help to address these barriers and is increasingly being seen as an appropriate framework for all healthcare service provision. Significant changes are required to health systems and service provision for this model of care to be implemented; specialist palliative care services can take a leading role in change management. CONCLUSION: Patient-centred care provides an appropriate framework for the development of a model of care for advanced COPD. It allows for a need-based approach to service provision, rather than the current prognosis-based system and brings patient and carer needs and concerns to the forefront of care.Crawford, Gregory B.; Burgess, Teresa A.; Young, Mary; Brooksbank, Mary A.; Brown, Margare


  • Best-practice care for people with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: the potential role of a chronic obstructive pulmonary disease care co-ordinator

    by Teresa Burgess, Mary Young, Gregory B. Crawford, Mary A. Brooksbank, Margaret Brown

    Objective: To explore service availability and accessibility for people with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and their carers and strategies for improvement, including the potential role of a COPD care co-ordinator in ensuring best-practice care in the Australian context. Methods: This qualitative study used focus groups and interviews with health professionals, carers and consumers to explore gaps and restrictions in services, barriers to access and the functioning of services. Data were analysed deductively. Results: Key themes arising from the data included difficulties around access to care, lack of continuity of care, poor care co-ordination, the need for active disease management as well as supportive care, and poor communication. A COPD care co-ordinator was suggested as an effective strategy for ensuring best-practice care. Conclusions: People with advanced COPD often have difficulty navigating the acute, primary and community care systems to deal with the multiple services that they may require. Lack of communication between health professionals and services is frequently a significant issue. A COPD care co-ordinator, encompassing advanced nursing skills, could ensure that care is centred on the needs of the person and their carer and that they receive continuing, appropriate and accessible care as they approach the end of their life. What is known about the topic?: The importance of care co-ordination as a quality care indicator in chronic disease is growing, and the care co-ordinator role as a facilitator of quality care is increasingly being recognised in the UK and US. There is currently little information in the Australian context about how a COPD care co-ordinator role could be implemented, where it could be situated and the level of skill required. What does this paper add?: This paper explores the specific issues in developing a COPD care co-ordinator role and provides a detailed model of care for the introduction of care co-ordinators into the Australian setting. What are the implications for practitioners?: The proposed COPD care co-ordinator role has the potential to improve quality, continuing care for people with advanced COPD. It could facilitate the linkage of multidisciplinary teams across acute, primary and community care settings and promote timely and effective communication. The role would provide a clear point of contact for all practitioners and the opportunity for nurses to develop an advanced practice role in COPD care co-ordination, combining a palliative care approach with a chronic disease management framework.


    • 1 December 2012
      • Vol. 20  (2) , 400-9

    The experience of patients with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and advance care-planning: A South Australian perspective.

    by Margaret Brown, Mary A Brooksbank, Teresa A Burgess, Mary Young, Gregory B Crawford

    Advance care-planning conversations with people who have chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are important because of the severity of the disease and the unpredictable timing of death. Advance care-planning is a process involving conversations about future wishes, including end-of-life care and the appointment of a substitute decision-maker. This qualitative research explored issues relating to end-of-life decisions with 15 individuals and their carers living in the community who had severe COPD. Findings indicated that, although patients and carers would welcome the opportunity to discuss end-of-life decisions, almost no conversation about care-planning had been initiated by health professionals with any of the participants. It also demonstrated that professional support is required to assist with advance care-planning and the completion of the legal advance directive documents.


  • Should resuscitation replace good communication in the care of elderly patients?

    by Campbell H Thompson, Margaret Brown

    To the Editor: There are challenging ethical, legal and clinical issues associated with resuscitation and end-of-life care for older people. When an elderly patient with comorbidities and limited independence deteriorates, and is unable to participate in decision making, is it good medical practice to subject that person to invasive and traumatic resuscitation when the survival rate is less than 3.4%?1 Currently, many older patients will be ...