Robert D. Clark
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Robert D. Clark has a total of 236 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Steven Consiglio
TEL Technology Center, America, LLC
44 shared publications Gert J. Leusink
Tokyo Electron, Albany, NY, USA
20 shared publications- Kandabara Tapily
TEL Technology Center, America, LLC
18 shared publications Alain C. Diebold
College of Nanoscale Science and Engineering, University at Albany 1 , 257 Fuller Rd., Albany, New York 12203, USA
12 shared publicationsCory S Wajda
TEL Technology Center, America, LLC
10 shared publicationsCory S. Wajda
Tokyo Electron, Albany, NY, USA
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 19 May 2026
- Published by American Vacuum Society in Surface Science Spectra
- Vol. 33 (1)
Core-level high-resolution XPS spectra of trimethylsilyl-functionalized SiO2 surfaces
Trimethylsilyl-functionalization via N-(trimethylsilyl)dimethylamine (TMSDMA) vapor exposure is used by the semiconductor industry to selectively passivate SiO2 surfaces during area selective deposition. Although the effectiveness of this molecule at inhibiting deposition has been studied, there have been very few published journal articles that include XPS analysis of this passivated SiO2 surface. In addition, none of these studies provide high-resolution deconvolution of the XPS peaks associated with the adsorbed siloxyl groups. To help rectify this, XPS was used to analyze coupons cleaved from a TMSDMA-treated, 5 nm plasma-oxidized SiO2/Si(100) wafer. High-resolution, angle-resolved XPS spectra of the Si 2p, C 1s, and O 1s core regions were collected at an emission angle of 80° with respect to the surface normal. Initial attempts to analyze the functionalized surface revealed that the molecular films degrade rapidly during analysis. In order to mitigate degradation of the organic monolayer, single-scan measurement sets (Si 2p, C 1s, and then O 1s) were performed on 78 separate analysis spots, which limits the x-ray exposure time of the functional groups at each measurement spot to 3 min. The spectra were then averaged to produce the high-resolution narrow-energy core spectra of the Si 2p, C 1s, and O 1s regions. This analysis technique, in conjunction with the high surface sensitivity of the angle-resolved XPS measurements at an emission angle of 80°, has made it possible to identify the O–Si(CH3)3 and Si–CH3 chemical shifts within the Si 2p and C 1s regions, respectively.
- 19 May 2026
- Published by American Vacuum Society in Surface Science Spectra
- Vol. 33 (1)
Core-level high-resolution XPS spectra of trimethylsilyl-functionalized SiO2 surfaces
Trimethylsilyl-functionalization via N-(trimethylsilyl)dimethylamine (TMSDMA) vapor exposure is used by the semiconductor industry to selectively passivate SiO2 surfaces during area selective deposition. Although the effectiveness of this molecule at inhibiting deposition has been studied, there have been very few published journal articles that include XPS analysis of this passivated SiO2 surface. In addition, none of these studies provide high-resolution deconvolution of the XPS peaks associated with the adsorbed siloxyl groups. To help rectify this, XPS was used to analyze coupons cleaved from a TMSDMA-treated, 5 nm plasma-oxidized SiO2/Si(100) wafer. High-resolution, angle-resolved XPS spectra of the Si 2p, C 1s, and O 1s core regions were collected at an emission angle of 80° with respect to the surface normal. Initial attempts to analyze the functionalized surface revealed that the molecular films degrade rapidly during analysis. In order to mitigate degradation of the organic monolayer, single-scan measurement sets (Si 2p, C 1s, and then O 1s) were performed on 78 separate analysis spots, which limits the x-ray exposure time of the functional groups at each measurement spot to 3 min. The spectra were then averaged to produce the high-resolution narrow-energy core spectra of the Si 2p, C 1s, and O 1s regions. This analysis technique, in conjunction with the high surface sensitivity of the angle-resolved XPS measurements at an emission angle of 80°, has made it possible to identify the O–Si(CH3)3 and Si–CH3 chemical shifts within the Si 2p and C 1s regions, respectively.
- 24 November 2025
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2025-02 (17) , 1182
Time-Dependent Quantized Conductance Degradation in High-K Switching Devices Treated with H-Plasma
Resistive Random-Access Memory (RRAM) is widely recognized for its analog switching behavior, scalability, excellent endurance, and low power consumption [1,2]. These properties make RRAM devices promising candidate as a non-volatile memory for neuromorphic computing. The capability of RRAM devices to mimic synaptic weight modulation due to their multi-level cell characteristics makes them highly suited for artificial and spiking neural networks [3,4]. The most significant characteristics required for RRAM to be used for memory applications and learning systems are long-term retention and stable multilevel conductance states. That will ensure precise and repeatable programing behavior, while these characteristics are still in active research and a key challenge [2,5]. For neuromorphic applications, conductance drifting over time can significantly weaken inference accuracy and learning efficiency [4]. In our recent work [6], we found that ZrO 2 -based RRAM devices treated with hydrogen plasma can achieve low-power operation and enhanced quantized conductance, making them compatible for multi-level memory applications. The forming energy and quantization performance relay on where to insert the H-plasma and the thickness of the capping layer after the treatment. Several studies have shown that selecting the optimum pulse width and amplitude while programing the RRAM devices for analog switching impact the reliability of the devices. Carefully adjusted pulse conditions can improve endurance and reliability by stabilizing the conductive filament and reducing thermally driven defect migration [7]. In this work, we investigate the stability of the programmed conductance levels of ZrO 2 -based RRAM over extended periods. The devices that have been tested are deposited as ZrO 2 with H-plasma treatment for the switching layer, and TiN as both top and bottom electrodes. The devices were exposed to a train of SET pulses using identical pulse amplitudes but with varying programming pulse widths. Conductance (G) values were recorded immediately after programming and monitored over the extended periods. Results show that the devices programmed with shorter pulses (less than 10μs) exhibit a larger drop in conductance over time compared to those programmed with longer pulses. This could be due to the conductive filament strength, since the longer pulses will allow more oxygen vacancies to be generated inside the oxide [1] and that will stable the CF ,which will stabilize the programed conductance value. Optimizing the programed pulses plays a significant role and more experiments will be performed to confirm the trend between the stability of the programed conductance value and the pulse conditions. REFERENCES H.-S. P. Wong, H.-Y. Lee, S. Yu, Y.-S. Chen, Y. Wu, P.-S. Chen, B. Lee, F. T. Chen, and M.-J. Tsai, Proc. IEEE, 100, 1951–1970 (2012). R. Waser and M. Aono, Nat. Mater., 6, 833–840 (2007). I. Boybat, M. Le Gallo, S. R. Nandakumar, T. Moraitis, T. Parnell, T. Tuma, B. Rajendran, Y. Leblebici, A. Sebastian, and E. Eleftheriou, Nat. Commun., 9, 2514 (2018). M. Wang, S. Joshi, S. E. Savel’ev, R. Midya, H. Li, P. Lin, C. Li, S. P. Levitan, V. K. Narayanan, J. J. Yang, and Q. Xia, Nat. Electron., 1, 137–145 (2018). C. Y. Chen, L. Goux, A. Fantini, A. Redolfi, S. Clima, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 14.2.1 (2014). A. Zeinati, S. Montaño, H. Shih, D. Triyoso, and T. Gokmen, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 42, 063207 (2024). C. Y. Chen, L. Goux, A. Fantini, A. Redolfi, S. Clima, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 14.2.1 (2014). L. Goux, A. Fantini, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, S. Clima, G. S. Kar, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, VLSI Technology Symposium, 1–2 (2014).
- 24 November 2025
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2025-02 (17) , 1182
Time-Dependent Quantized Conductance Degradation in High-K Switching Devices Treated with H-Plasma
Resistive Random-Access Memory (RRAM) is widely recognized for its analog switching behavior, scalability, excellent endurance, and low power consumption [1,2]. These properties make RRAM devices promising candidate as a non-volatile memory for neuromorphic computing. The capability of RRAM devices to mimic synaptic weight modulation due to their multi-level cell characteristics makes them highly suited for artificial and spiking neural networks [3,4]. The most significant characteristics required for RRAM to be used for memory applications and learning systems are long-term retention and stable multilevel conductance states. That will ensure precise and repeatable programing behavior, while these characteristics are still in active research and a key challenge [2,5]. For neuromorphic applications, conductance drifting over time can significantly weaken inference accuracy and learning efficiency [4]. In our recent work [6], we found that ZrO 2 -based RRAM devices treated with hydrogen plasma can achieve low-power operation and enhanced quantized conductance, making them compatible for multi-level memory applications. The forming energy and quantization performance relay on where to insert the H-plasma and the thickness of the capping layer after the treatment. Several studies have shown that selecting the optimum pulse width and amplitude while programing the RRAM devices for analog switching impact the reliability of the devices. Carefully adjusted pulse conditions can improve endurance and reliability by stabilizing the conductive filament and reducing thermally driven defect migration [7]. In this work, we investigate the stability of the programmed conductance levels of ZrO 2 -based RRAM over extended periods. The devices that have been tested are deposited as ZrO 2 with H-plasma treatment for the switching layer, and TiN as both top and bottom electrodes. The devices were exposed to a train of SET pulses using identical pulse amplitudes but with varying programming pulse widths. Conductance (G) values were recorded immediately after programming and monitored over the extended periods. Results show that the devices programmed with shorter pulses (less than 10μs) exhibit a larger drop in conductance over time compared to those programmed with longer pulses. This could be due to the conductive filament strength, since the longer pulses will allow more oxygen vacancies to be generated inside the oxide [1] and that will stable the CF ,which will stabilize the programed conductance value. Optimizing the programed pulses plays a significant role and more experiments will be performed to confirm the trend between the stability of the programed conductance value and the pulse conditions. REFERENCES H.-S. P. Wong, H.-Y. Lee, S. Yu, Y.-S. Chen, Y. Wu, P.-S. Chen, B. Lee, F. T. Chen, and M.-J. Tsai, Proc. IEEE, 100, 1951–1970 (2012). R. Waser and M. Aono, Nat. Mater., 6, 833–840 (2007). I. Boybat, M. Le Gallo, S. R. Nandakumar, T. Moraitis, T. Parnell, T. Tuma, B. Rajendran, Y. Leblebici, A. Sebastian, and E. Eleftheriou, Nat. Commun., 9, 2514 (2018). M. Wang, S. Joshi, S. E. Savel’ev, R. Midya, H. Li, P. Lin, C. Li, S. P. Levitan, V. K. Narayanan, J. J. Yang, and Q. Xia, Nat. Electron., 1, 137–145 (2018). C. Y. Chen, L. Goux, A. Fantini, A. Redolfi, S. Clima, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 14.2.1 (2014). A. Zeinati, S. Montaño, H. Shih, D. Triyoso, and T. Gokmen, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 42, 063207 (2024). C. Y. Chen, L. Goux, A. Fantini, A. Redolfi, S. Clima, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 14.2.1 (2014). L. Goux, A. Fantini, R. Degraeve, Y. Y. Chen, S. Clima, G. S. Kar, G. Groeseneken, and M. Jurczak, VLSI Technology Symposium, 1–2 (2014).
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Materials for Electron Devices
- Vol. 2, 145-150
H-Plasma Treated ZrO 2 and HfO 2 RRAM Devices for Low Power In-Memory Computing
This work investigates the impact of hydrogen plasma-treated ZrO2 and HfO2 (midpoint of deposition) as the switching layer dielectrics in resistive random-access memory (RRAM) devices. Results show that devices incorporating treated ZrO2 require significantly lower initial forming power (0.46 nW) compared to those with treated HfO2 (3.8 nW). Both devices exhibit multi-level cell (MLC) behavior under two pulsed operation schemes: one with linearly increasing pulse widths and another with exponentially increasing pulse widths to enhance the separation between successive conductance states. Despite the structural similarities between ZrO2 and HfO2, the devices demonstrate distinct variation in electrical characteristics. To elucidate these differences, we compare their electron affinities and Gibbs free energies, examining how these material properties influence oxygen vacancy (Vo) generation an essential mechanism in RRAM switching. Endurance testing up to 4000 cycles indicates that treated HfO2 devices exhibit greater stability under electrical stress. Fitting analysis of the low resistance state (LRS) suggests that the treated HfO2 device support an Ohmic conduction mechanism, whereas the treated ZrO2 device is supporting space-charge-limited current (SCLC) behavior based on the log(I)-log(v) curves. Furthermore, TEM analysis of the fresh devices reveals a higher oxygen content and lower nitrogen concentration in treated ZrO2, which may account for its lower forming power.
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Materials for Electron Devices
- Vol. 2, 145-150
H-Plasma Treated ZrO 2 and HfO 2 RRAM Devices for Low Power In-Memory Computing
This work investigates the impact of hydrogen plasma-treated ZrO2 and HfO2 (midpoint of deposition) as the switching layer dielectrics in resistive random-access memory (RRAM) devices. Results show that devices incorporating treated ZrO2 require significantly lower initial forming power (0.46 nW) compared to those with treated HfO2 (3.8 nW). Both devices exhibit multi-level cell (MLC) behavior under two pulsed operation schemes: one with linearly increasing pulse widths and another with exponentially increasing pulse widths to enhance the separation between successive conductance states. Despite the structural similarities between ZrO2 and HfO2, the devices demonstrate distinct variation in electrical characteristics. To elucidate these differences, we compare their electron affinities and Gibbs free energies, examining how these material properties influence oxygen vacancy (Vo) generation an essential mechanism in RRAM switching. Endurance testing up to 4000 cycles indicates that treated HfO2 devices exhibit greater stability under electrical stress. Fitting analysis of the low resistance state (LRS) suggests that the treated HfO2 device support an Ohmic conduction mechanism, whereas the treated ZrO2 device is supporting space-charge-limited current (SCLC) behavior based on the log(I)-log(v) curves. Furthermore, TEM analysis of the fresh devices reveals a higher oxygen content and lower nitrogen concentration in treated ZrO2, which may account for its lower forming power.
- 11 July 2025
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2025-01 (63) , 3073
A Comparative Study of H-Plasma Treated ZrO2 and HfO2 RRAM Devices for Low Power in-Memory Computing
The floating gate flash memories are facing their physical and scaling limitation, highlighting the need of the resistive random-access memory (RRAM) as a promising solution for in-memory computing1. Transition metal oxide (TMOs) are utilized as switching layer for RRAM devices due to their low power consumption, high density integration capability, high switching speed (2-6. ZrO2 and HfO2 are two of the mature TMOs to be used as switching layer due to their high specific heat and thermal conductivity, low Gibbs free energy and high dielectric constant7,8. Despite all the promising properties of the RRAM devices there are still issues like power consumption during the initial forming of the conductive filament (CF), the stability and controllability of this CF during the MLC programing, the uniformity of the programable states and the window between each two states (ΔG). To conquer these challenges many techniques such as bilayer structure9, annealing atmosphere10, adding additional defects during deposition process by introducing H-plasma11, have been implemented. It has been reported that incorporation of H at the midpoint of HfO2 layer stabilize and increase the Vo formation which lower the initial forming power11. In addition, H-plasma creates new localized Vo clusters and forms stable HO defects as reported by Chen et al12. Thus, H makes filament formation more favorable since it lowers the forming voltage or even provide forming-free devices13. This work studies the effects of using hydrogen plasma-treated ZrO2 and HfO2 as oxide layers in resistive random-access memory devices. It was found that devices including treated ZrO2 consume significantly lower initial forming power (0.46 nW) compared to those with treated HfO2 (3.8 nW). Additionally, both devices exhibit multi-level cell (MLC) characteristics during pulsed operation. Despite the similarities between these oxides, they demonstrate distinct electrical behaviors when used in RRAM devices. To explain these differences, we compare their electron affinity and Gibbs free energy and analyze how these properties influence oxygen vacancy (Vo) generation, a critical feature in the performance of RRAM devices. REFERENCES Levisse, P. Royer, B. Giraud, J. P. Noel, M. Moreau, and J. M. Portal, IEEE/ACM Int. Symp. Nanoscale Archit. 2017, 55 (2017). Gong, M.J. Rasch, S.-C. Seo et al., IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), pp. 33-7(2022). Ismail, Z. Batool, K. Mahmood, A. M. Rana, B.-D. Yang, and S. Kim, Results Phys. 18, 103275 (2020). Waser, R. Dittmann, C. Staikov, and K. Szot, Adv. Mater. 21, 2632 (2009). Pan, S. Gao, C. Chen, C. Song, and F. Zeng, Mater. Sci. Eng. R Rep. 83, 1 (2014). J. Yang, D. B. Strukov, and D. R. Stewart, Nat. Nanotechnol. 8, 13 (2013). C. Hsu, J. K. Sun, C. C. Tsao, and P. Y. Chuang, Phys. B Condens. Matter 519, 21 (2017). Lanza, Materials (Basel) 7, 2155 (2014). Misra, P. Zhao, D. H. Triyoso, V. Kaushik, K. Tapily, R. D. Clark, S. Consiglio, T. Hakamata, C. S. Wajda, and G. J. Leusink, ECS J. Solid State Sci. Technol. 9, 053004 (2020). Yao, M. Ismail, A. Hao, S. K. Thatikonda, W. Huang, N. Qin, et al., RSC Adv. 9, 12615 (2019). Aseel Zeinati, Durga Misra, Dina H. Triyoso, Kandabara Tapily, Robert D. Clark, Sarah Lombardo, Cory S. Wajda, Gert J. Leusink, J of Vacuum Sc & Tech, B, vol. 42(6), 2024. Y. Chen, L. Goux, J. Swerts, M. Toeller, C. Adelmann, J. Kittl, M. Jurczak, G. Groeseneken, and D. J. Wouters, IEEE Electron Dev. Lett. 33, 483 (2012). Duncan, B. Magyari-Köpe, and Y. Nishi, Appl. Phys. Lett. 108, 043501 (2016).
- 11 July 2025
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2025-01 (63) , 3073
A Comparative Study of H-Plasma Treated ZrO2 and HfO2 RRAM Devices for Low Power in-Memory Computing
The floating gate flash memories are facing their physical and scaling limitation, highlighting the need of the resistive random-access memory (RRAM) as a promising solution for in-memory computing1. Transition metal oxide (TMOs) are utilized as switching layer for RRAM devices due to their low power consumption, high density integration capability, high switching speed (2-6. ZrO2 and HfO2 are two of the mature TMOs to be used as switching layer due to their high specific heat and thermal conductivity, low Gibbs free energy and high dielectric constant7,8. Despite all the promising properties of the RRAM devices there are still issues like power consumption during the initial forming of the conductive filament (CF), the stability and controllability of this CF during the MLC programing, the uniformity of the programable states and the window between each two states (ΔG). To conquer these challenges many techniques such as bilayer structure9, annealing atmosphere10, adding additional defects during deposition process by introducing H-plasma11, have been implemented. It has been reported that incorporation of H at the midpoint of HfO2 layer stabilize and increase the Vo formation which lower the initial forming power11. In addition, H-plasma creates new localized Vo clusters and forms stable HO defects as reported by Chen et al12. Thus, H makes filament formation more favorable since it lowers the forming voltage or even provide forming-free devices13. This work studies the effects of using hydrogen plasma-treated ZrO2 and HfO2 as oxide layers in resistive random-access memory devices. It was found that devices including treated ZrO2 consume significantly lower initial forming power (0.46 nW) compared to those with treated HfO2 (3.8 nW). Additionally, both devices exhibit multi-level cell (MLC) characteristics during pulsed operation. Despite the similarities between these oxides, they demonstrate distinct electrical behaviors when used in RRAM devices. To explain these differences, we compare their electron affinity and Gibbs free energy and analyze how these properties influence oxygen vacancy (Vo) generation, a critical feature in the performance of RRAM devices. REFERENCES Levisse, P. Royer, B. Giraud, J. P. Noel, M. Moreau, and J. M. Portal, IEEE/ACM Int. Symp. Nanoscale Archit. 2017, 55 (2017). Gong, M.J. Rasch, S.-C. Seo et al., IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), pp. 33-7(2022). Ismail, Z. Batool, K. Mahmood, A. M. Rana, B.-D. Yang, and S. Kim, Results Phys. 18, 103275 (2020). Waser, R. Dittmann, C. Staikov, and K. Szot, Adv. Mater. 21, 2632 (2009). Pan, S. Gao, C. Chen, C. Song, and F. Zeng, Mater. Sci. Eng. R Rep. 83, 1 (2014). J. Yang, D. B. Strukov, and D. R. Stewart, Nat. Nanotechnol. 8, 13 (2013). C. Hsu, J. K. Sun, C. C. Tsao, and P. Y. Chuang, Phys. B Condens. Matter 519, 21 (2017). Lanza, Materials (Basel) 7, 2155 (2014). Misra, P. Zhao, D. H. Triyoso, V. Kaushik, K. Tapily, R. D. Clark, S. Consiglio, T. Hakamata, C. S. Wajda, and G. J. Leusink, ECS J. Solid State Sci. Technol. 9, 053004 (2020). Yao, M. Ismail, A. Hao, S. K. Thatikonda, W. Huang, N. Qin, et al., RSC Adv. 9, 12615 (2019). Aseel Zeinati, Durga Misra, Dina H. Triyoso, Kandabara Tapily, Robert D. Clark, Sarah Lombardo, Cory S. Wajda, Gert J. Leusink, J of Vacuum Sc & Tech, B, vol. 42(6), 2024. Y. Chen, L. Goux, J. Swerts, M. Toeller, C. Adelmann, J. Kittl, M. Jurczak, G. Groeseneken, and D. J. Wouters, IEEE Electron Dev. Lett. 33, 483 (2012). Duncan, B. Magyari-Köpe, and Y. Nishi, Appl. Phys. Lett. 108, 043501 (2016).
- 22 November 2024
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2024-02 (20) , 1813
(Invited) Investigation of Plasma Defect Engineering in ZrO2-Based RRAM Devices for Low Power in-Memory Computing
Resistive random-access memory (RRAM) is a promising candidate to be used for in-memory computing applications due to its low power consumption, high scalability, high density, significant endurance, good retention, and low cost [1-2]. The usage of zirconium dioxide (ZrO2) as the switching layer in RRAM stacks has garnered attention due to its high thermodynamic stability, simple structure, and CMOS process compatibility [3-5]. In addition, introducing a hydrogen (H) plasma treatment to the switching layer reduced the forming power since it improved the oxygen vacancies (Vo) and defects distribution near the top electrode (TE) and switching layer interface [6]. In this work, we investigated five ZrO2-based RRAM devices with titanium nitride (TiN) as top and bottom electrodes. Figure 1 shows the schematics for the devices that have been investigated in this work. Device-A that has stochiometric ZrO2 switching layer was compared with devices B, C, D, and E that have been treated with H-plasma. The treated devices vary by the insertion position of the plasma during the deposition of the oxide layer, optimized to reduce initial defect levels [7]. The oxide layer of device-B - 7nm of ZrO2 - was fully deposited, followed by the H-plasma. While device-C had the H-plasma at the midpoint of the 7nm oxide. Device-D oxide was deposited as 3.5nm ZrO2, followed by H-plasma followed by 4nm ZrO2 that has the interface with the TE. Device-E was deposited as 3.5nm ZrO2, followed by H-plasma, followed by 3nm ZrO2 that has the interface with the TE. We studied the leakage current of the devices to investigate the number of defects in the oxide layer since it plays a significant role in reducing the forming power, as previously reported [8]. While it is well-known that the devices with higher leakage current have more defects [9], devices from wafer-A (7nm stochiometric ZrO2) show the lowest leakage current. The devices were then formed with a DC voltage sweep and compliance current between 1nA-100mA and observed a trend between the leakage current (number of defects) and the forming power, device-A consumed the highest forming power (122mW) as expected due to fewer defects in the oxide layer, which matched with the leakage current measurements. The leakiest devices - device-C (TiN/3.5nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) and device-D (TiN/4nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) - consumed the lowest power while forming (0.46nW) and (0.24nW) respectively- which confirms that more defects inside the oxide layer support the electron transport and lead to reduction of the forming power [10]. While device-B (TiN/H-plasma/7nmZrO2/TiN) has higher leakage current and lower forming power (2.5nW) than device-E (TiN/3nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) that consumes (4.7nW) to form the conductive filament. A thinner layer can't passivate the defects, resulting in a uniform spread of Vo related defects throughout the dielectric thickness, which increases the forming voltage as observed in device-E (TiN/3nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN). A thicker cap layer, on the other hand, allows for reoxidation, and the migration of oxygen vacancies towards the top, ultimately reducing the forming voltage as observed in device-D (TiN/4nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) [7]. Since the devices are expected to be used in memory computing, a pulse operation was performed with amplitude variation to quantize the conductance states. Device-C and device-D show a good quantization, with no overlap between the states and low fluctuations for each state compared to device-B, which shows degraded fluctuations and overlap between the states due to reduced defect distribution near the interface with the TE [11]. REFERENCE: Waser, R. et al 2009 ECS Trans. 21(1) ,2632–2663 Chen, Y. S. et al 2009 IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting pp.105-108 Sun, B. et al 2009 Appl. 105:61630 Lin, C.-C. et al 2016 AIP Adv 6:35103 Lin, C.-L. et al 2016 AIP Adv 6:35103 Patel, Y. et al 2021 ECS Trans. 104, 3 Consiglio, S. et al 2021 ECS Trans. 102, 19 Young-Fisher et al 2013 IEEE Electron Device Letters, vol. 34, no. 6 Maleeswaran, P. et al 2013 Appl. Phys. 113, 184504 Bersuker, G. et al 2011 Solid-State Electron. vols. 65–66, pp. 146–150 Kim, B. et al 2022 Applied Surface Science 593 Figure 1
- 22 November 2024
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2024-02 (20) , 1813
(Invited) Investigation of Plasma Defect Engineering in ZrO2-Based RRAM Devices for Low Power in-Memory Computing
Resistive random-access memory (RRAM) is a promising candidate to be used for in-memory computing applications due to its low power consumption, high scalability, high density, significant endurance, good retention, and low cost [1-2]. The usage of zirconium dioxide (ZrO2) as the switching layer in RRAM stacks has garnered attention due to its high thermodynamic stability, simple structure, and CMOS process compatibility [3-5]. In addition, introducing a hydrogen (H) plasma treatment to the switching layer reduced the forming power since it improved the oxygen vacancies (Vo) and defects distribution near the top electrode (TE) and switching layer interface [6]. In this work, we investigated five ZrO2-based RRAM devices with titanium nitride (TiN) as top and bottom electrodes. Figure 1 shows the schematics for the devices that have been investigated in this work. Device-A that has stochiometric ZrO2 switching layer was compared with devices B, C, D, and E that have been treated with H-plasma. The treated devices vary by the insertion position of the plasma during the deposition of the oxide layer, optimized to reduce initial defect levels [7]. The oxide layer of device-B - 7nm of ZrO2 - was fully deposited, followed by the H-plasma. While device-C had the H-plasma at the midpoint of the 7nm oxide. Device-D oxide was deposited as 3.5nm ZrO2, followed by H-plasma followed by 4nm ZrO2 that has the interface with the TE. Device-E was deposited as 3.5nm ZrO2, followed by H-plasma, followed by 3nm ZrO2 that has the interface with the TE. We studied the leakage current of the devices to investigate the number of defects in the oxide layer since it plays a significant role in reducing the forming power, as previously reported [8]. While it is well-known that the devices with higher leakage current have more defects [9], devices from wafer-A (7nm stochiometric ZrO2) show the lowest leakage current. The devices were then formed with a DC voltage sweep and compliance current between 1nA-100mA and observed a trend between the leakage current (number of defects) and the forming power, device-A consumed the highest forming power (122mW) as expected due to fewer defects in the oxide layer, which matched with the leakage current measurements. The leakiest devices - device-C (TiN/3.5nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) and device-D (TiN/4nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) - consumed the lowest power while forming (0.46nW) and (0.24nW) respectively- which confirms that more defects inside the oxide layer support the electron transport and lead to reduction of the forming power [10]. While device-B (TiN/H-plasma/7nmZrO2/TiN) has higher leakage current and lower forming power (2.5nW) than device-E (TiN/3nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) that consumes (4.7nW) to form the conductive filament. A thinner layer can't passivate the defects, resulting in a uniform spread of Vo related defects throughout the dielectric thickness, which increases the forming voltage as observed in device-E (TiN/3nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN). A thicker cap layer, on the other hand, allows for reoxidation, and the migration of oxygen vacancies towards the top, ultimately reducing the forming voltage as observed in device-D (TiN/4nmZrO2/H-plasma/3.5nmZrO2/TiN) [7]. Since the devices are expected to be used in memory computing, a pulse operation was performed with amplitude variation to quantize the conductance states. Device-C and device-D show a good quantization, with no overlap between the states and low fluctuations for each state compared to device-B, which shows degraded fluctuations and overlap between the states due to reduced defect distribution near the interface with the TE [11]. REFERENCE: Waser, R. et al 2009 ECS Trans. 21(1) ,2632–2663 Chen, Y. S. et al 2009 IEEE Int. Electron Devices Meeting pp.105-108 Sun, B. et al 2009 Appl. 105:61630 Lin, C.-C. et al 2016 AIP Adv 6:35103 Lin, C.-L. et al 2016 AIP Adv 6:35103 Patel, Y. et al 2021 ECS Trans. 104, 3 Consiglio, S. et al 2021 ECS Trans. 102, 19 Young-Fisher et al 2013 IEEE Electron Device Letters, vol. 34, no. 6 Maleeswaran, P. et al 2013 Appl. Phys. 113, 184504 Bersuker, G. et al 2011 Solid-State Electron. vols. 65–66, pp. 146–150 Kim, B. et al 2022 Applied Surface Science 593 Figure 1
- 15 November 2024
- Published by American Vacuum Society in Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B
- Vol. 42 (6)
Engineering of ZrO2-based RRAM devices for low power in-memory computing
This work evaluates the impact of applying hydrogen plasma (H-plasma) either after the deposition of the ZrO2 layer or as an intermediate step during the deposition on the performance of resistive random-access memory devices. Devices treated with H-plasma exhibited lower power consumption during the forming process and a higher Ron/Roff ratio over 50 cycles of SET and RESET pulses compared to untreated devices. The position of the plasma treatment significantly influenced the device's performance. We measured the leakage current, which correlates well with the forming process. Devices with higher leakage current required less power during the forming process. It was observed that a thicker capping layer following plasma insertion reduced forming power and improved the conductance quantization for multilevel cell characteristics.
- 15 November 2024
- Published by American Vacuum Society in Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B
- Vol. 42 (6)
Engineering of ZrO2-based RRAM devices for low power in-memory computing
This work evaluates the impact of applying hydrogen plasma (H-plasma) either after the deposition of the ZrO2 layer or as an intermediate step during the deposition on the performance of resistive random-access memory devices. Devices treated with H-plasma exhibited lower power consumption during the forming process and a higher Ron/Roff ratio over 50 cycles of SET and RESET pulses compared to untreated devices. The position of the plasma treatment significantly influenced the device's performance. We measured the leakage current, which correlates well with the forming process. Devices with higher leakage current required less power during the forming process. It was observed that a thicker capping layer following plasma insertion reduced forming power and improved the conductance quantization for multilevel cell characteristics.
- 9 August 2024
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2024-01 (57) , 3009
Engineering High-K Switching Devices for in-Memory Computing
Selecting and processing of appropriate stack materials for HfO2-based RRAM devices significantly influences the distribution of defects and oxygen vacancies (Vo) within the switching layer, thereby playing an important role in their switching behavior (1). Controlling this distribution to have more oxygen vacancies near the top electrode (TE) while reducing them near the bottom electrode (BE) results in reduced switching power and enhanced multilevel cell characteristics (MLC) of RRAM devices (2) and that makes them as promising options for in-memory computing. Since RRAM devices fabricated as metal-insulator-metal stack, exploring the impact of each layer remains an active area of research. In this work, we compared different devices by varying the materials of each layer. The first comparison is by varying the oxide layer with same TE (Ru) and BE (TiN) by (i) using stoichiometric HfO2 and (ii) employing HfO2 treated with hydrogen plasma at the midpoint. The device treated with hydrogen plasma consumed nanowatts power compared to the stoichiometric device that consumed hundreds of microwatts to be switched. The introduction of hydrogen plasma treatment at the midpoint of the HfO2layer redirects more Vo towards the TE, explaining the reduction in the switching power (1). While applying pulse SET operation, the hydrogen plasma-treated device exhibited excellent conductance quantization, whereas the stoichiometric device quickly saturated and remaining stuck in a low-resistance state (LRS) due to a lack of Vo (3). Introducing a bilayer Al2O3/HfO2 dielectric significantly decreased switching power consumption to a few microwatts range compared to the stoichiometric device. This reduction is attributed to the rapid formation of Vo within the Al2O3 layer, subsequently stimulating Vo formation within the HfO2layer (4). However, the hydrogen plasma-treated device still maintains the lowest power consumption. Further investigation involved in changing the TE material, Ru and TiN to understand the impact of the TE, given its working function and interface barriers significantly affect the distribution of Vonear the TE. The device using Ru as the TE switched with a 3nA compliance current (1). Introducing nitrogen plasma treatment to the bottom electrode of the TiN device improved its switching behavior due to the reduction Vo near the BE because of formation of the Hf-N bond and led to increase the Vo near the TE (5). This enhancement was marked by a reduction in switching power to picowatts and stabilization of the conductive filament within the oxide. This device demonstrated improved conductance quantization. REFERENCES Patel, Y.; Misra, D.; Triyoso, D.; Clark, R.; Tapily, K.; Consiglio, S.; Wajda, C.; and Leusink, G., "RRAM devices with plasma treated hfo2 with Ru as top electrode for in-memory computing hardware," ECS Transactions, 104(3), p. 35, 2021, DOI: 10.1149/10403.0035ecst. Wong, H.-S. P.; Lee, H. Y.; Yu, Sh.; Chen,Y.; Wu, Y.; Chen, P. Ch.; Lee, B.; Chen, F.T.; Tsai, M. G., "Metal–Oxide RRAM," Proceedings of the IEEE, 2012, DOI: 10.1109/JPROC.2012.2190369. Zeinati, A., Misra, D., Triyoso, D.H., Clark, R.D., Tapily, K., Consiglio, S., Wajda, C.S., Leusink, G.J. "Process Optimization to Reduce Power in hfo2-Based RRAM Devices for in-Memory Computing," ECS Meeting Abstracts, vol. MA2022-02, 806 (2022). Doi: 10.1149/MA2022-0215806mtgabs Misra, D.; Zhao, P.; Triyoso, D.; Clark, R.; Tapily, K.; Consiglio, S.; Wajda, C.; Leusink, G., "Dielectrics and Metal Stack Engineering for Multilevel Resistive Random-Access Memory," ECS Journal of Solid-State Science and Technology, 9, 05300, 2020. DOI: 10.1149/2162-8777/ab9dc5. Wang, M.-H.; Chang, T.-Ch.; Shih, Ch.-Ch., "Performance improvement after nitridation treatment in hfo2-based resistance random-access memory," Applied Physics Express, 2018. DOI: 10.7567/APEX.11.084101.
- 9 August 2024
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2024-01 (57) , 3009
Engineering High-K Switching Devices for in-Memory Computing
Selecting and processing of appropriate stack materials for HfO2-based RRAM devices significantly influences the distribution of defects and oxygen vacancies (Vo) within the switching layer, thereby playing an important role in their switching behavior (1). Controlling this distribution to have more oxygen vacancies near the top electrode (TE) while reducing them near the bottom electrode (BE) results in reduced switching power and enhanced multilevel cell characteristics (MLC) of RRAM devices (2) and that makes them as promising options for in-memory computing. Since RRAM devices fabricated as metal-insulator-metal stack, exploring the impact of each layer remains an active area of research. In this work, we compared different devices by varying the materials of each layer. The first comparison is by varying the oxide layer with same TE (Ru) and BE (TiN) by (i) using stoichiometric HfO2 and (ii) employing HfO2 treated with hydrogen plasma at the midpoint. The device treated with hydrogen plasma consumed nanowatts power compared to the stoichiometric device that consumed hundreds of microwatts to be switched. The introduction of hydrogen plasma treatment at the midpoint of the HfO2layer redirects more Vo towards the TE, explaining the reduction in the switching power (1). While applying pulse SET operation, the hydrogen plasma-treated device exhibited excellent conductance quantization, whereas the stoichiometric device quickly saturated and remaining stuck in a low-resistance state (LRS) due to a lack of Vo (3). Introducing a bilayer Al2O3/HfO2 dielectric significantly decreased switching power consumption to a few microwatts range compared to the stoichiometric device. This reduction is attributed to the rapid formation of Vo within the Al2O3 layer, subsequently stimulating Vo formation within the HfO2layer (4). However, the hydrogen plasma-treated device still maintains the lowest power consumption. Further investigation involved in changing the TE material, Ru and TiN to understand the impact of the TE, given its working function and interface barriers significantly affect the distribution of Vonear the TE. The device using Ru as the TE switched with a 3nA compliance current (1). Introducing nitrogen plasma treatment to the bottom electrode of the TiN device improved its switching behavior due to the reduction Vo near the BE because of formation of the Hf-N bond and led to increase the Vo near the TE (5). This enhancement was marked by a reduction in switching power to picowatts and stabilization of the conductive filament within the oxide. This device demonstrated improved conductance quantization. REFERENCES Patel, Y.; Misra, D.; Triyoso, D.; Clark, R.; Tapily, K.; Consiglio, S.; Wajda, C.; and Leusink, G., "RRAM devices with plasma treated hfo2 with Ru as top electrode for in-memory computing hardware," ECS Transactions, 104(3), p. 35, 2021, DOI: 10.1149/10403.0035ecst. Wong, H.-S. P.; Lee, H. Y.; Yu, Sh.; Chen,Y.; Wu, Y.; Chen, P. Ch.; Lee, B.; Chen, F.T.; Tsai, M. G., "Metal–Oxide RRAM," Proceedings of the IEEE, 2012, DOI: 10.1109/JPROC.2012.2190369. Zeinati, A., Misra, D., Triyoso, D.H., Clark, R.D., Tapily, K., Consiglio, S., Wajda, C.S., Leusink, G.J. "Process Optimization to Reduce Power in hfo2-Based RRAM Devices for in-Memory Computing," ECS Meeting Abstracts, vol. MA2022-02, 806 (2022). Doi: 10.1149/MA2022-0215806mtgabs Misra, D.; Zhao, P.; Triyoso, D.; Clark, R.; Tapily, K.; Consiglio, S.; Wajda, C.; Leusink, G., "Dielectrics and Metal Stack Engineering for Multilevel Resistive Random-Access Memory," ECS Journal of Solid-State Science and Technology, 9, 05300, 2020. DOI: 10.1149/2162-8777/ab9dc5. Wang, M.-H.; Chang, T.-Ch.; Shih, Ch.-Ch., "Performance improvement after nitridation treatment in hfo2-based resistance random-access memory," Applied Physics Express, 2018. DOI: 10.7567/APEX.11.084101.
- 9 October 2022
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2022-02 (15) , 806
Process Optimization to Reduce Power in HfO2-Based Rram Devices for in-Memory Computing
Recently, HfO2-based resistive random-access memory (RRAM) devices have shown promise as candidates for in-memory computing applications. By engineering the distribution of defects or oxygen vacancies, the switching dielectric can potentially enable low power switching and multi-conductance levels. A higher concentration of oxygen vacancies closer to the top electrode a two-terminal RRAM device with a HfO2/Al2O3 bilayer structure reduces switching energy (1). Introducing excess oxygen vacancies near the top electrode through a hydrogen plasma treatment with a Ru as top electrode reduces the switching power of the device (2). In this work we study the pulsed SET operation of different HfO2-based RRAM devices for their possible uses as multi-level cells. We have compared two different RRAM devices with HfO2-based dielectrics. Device-A is prepared with hydrogen plasma treatment at mid-point of HfO2 deposition (10nm Ti/50nmTiN/3nm HfO2(plasma treatment) 3nm HfO2/5nm Ru/5nm ALD TiN/ 50nm PVD TiN). Whereas Device-B constitutes a HfO2/Al2O3 bilayer structure (10nm Ti/50nmTiN/7nm HfO2/1nm Al2O3/5nm Ru/5nm ALD TiN/50nm PVD TiN). Both the devices have Ru as the top metal. Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 show the conductance modulation obtained by applying successive pulse sequences (80 pulses) with increasing the pulse width tp (from 4 𝜇s to 10 ms) every 20 pulses where the pulse height, Vp, remained fixed at 2V during the experiment. A read pulse with voltage Vr=0.1V and pulse width tr=1ms is applied immediately after each pulse. The forming compliance current in Device-A is seven time lower than Device-B. Both devices clearly show promising behavior of multi-level conductance. Figure 1
- 9 October 2022
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2022-02 (15) , 806
Process Optimization to Reduce Power in HfO2-Based Rram Devices for in-Memory Computing
Recently, HfO2-based resistive random-access memory (RRAM) devices have shown promise as candidates for in-memory computing applications. By engineering the distribution of defects or oxygen vacancies, the switching dielectric can potentially enable low power switching and multi-conductance levels. A higher concentration of oxygen vacancies closer to the top electrode a two-terminal RRAM device with a HfO2/Al2O3 bilayer structure reduces switching energy (1). Introducing excess oxygen vacancies near the top electrode through a hydrogen plasma treatment with a Ru as top electrode reduces the switching power of the device (2). In this work we study the pulsed SET operation of different HfO2-based RRAM devices for their possible uses as multi-level cells. We have compared two different RRAM devices with HfO2-based dielectrics. Device-A is prepared with hydrogen plasma treatment at mid-point of HfO2 deposition (10nm Ti/50nmTiN/3nm HfO2(plasma treatment) 3nm HfO2/5nm Ru/5nm ALD TiN/ 50nm PVD TiN). Whereas Device-B constitutes a HfO2/Al2O3 bilayer structure (10nm Ti/50nmTiN/7nm HfO2/1nm Al2O3/5nm Ru/5nm ALD TiN/50nm PVD TiN). Both the devices have Ru as the top metal. Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 show the conductance modulation obtained by applying successive pulse sequences (80 pulses) with increasing the pulse width tp (from 4 𝜇s to 10 ms) every 20 pulses where the pulse height, Vp, remained fixed at 2V during the experiment. A read pulse with voltage Vr=0.1V and pulse width tr=1ms is applied immediately after each pulse. The forming compliance current in Device-A is seven time lower than Device-B. Both devices clearly show promising behavior of multi-level conductance. Figure 1
- Open Access
- 9 March 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-8
Antiferroelectric negative capacitance from a structural phase transition in zirconia
Crystalline materials with broken inversion symmetry can exhibit a spontaneous electric polarization, which originates from a microscopic electric dipole moment. Long-range polar or anti-polar order of such permanent dipoles gives rise to ferroelectricity or antiferroelectricity, respectively. However, the recently discovered antiferroelectrics of fluorite structure (HfO2 and ZrO2) are different: A non-polar phase transforms into a polar phase by spontaneous inversion symmetry breaking upon the application of an electric field. Here, we show that this structural transition in antiferroelectric ZrO2 gives rise to a negative capacitance, which is promising for overcoming the fundamental limits of energy efficiency in electronics. Our findings provide insight into the thermodynamically forbidden region of the antiferroelectric transition in ZrO2 and extend the concept of negative capacitance beyond ferroelectricity. This shows that negative capacitance is a more general phenomenon than previously thought and can be expected in a much broader range of materials exhibiting structural phase transitions.
- 9 March 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessAntiferroelectric negative capacitance from a structural phase transition in zirconia
Crystalline materials with broken inversion symmetry can exhibit a spontaneous electric polarization, which originates from a microscopic electric dipole moment. Long-range polar or anti-polar order of such permanent dipoles gives rise to ferroelectricity or antiferroelectricity, respectively. However, the recently discovered antiferroelectrics of fluorite structure (HfO2 and ZrO2) are different: A non-polar phase transforms into a polar phase by spontaneous inversion symmetry breaking upon the application of an electric field. Here, we show that this structural transition in antiferroelectric ZrO2 gives rise to a negative capacitance, which is promising for overcoming the fundamental limits of energy efficiency in electronics. Our findings provide insight into the thermodynamically forbidden region of the antiferroelectric transition in ZrO2 and extend the concept of negative capacitance beyond ferroelectricity. This shows that negative capacitance is a more general phenomenon than previously thought and can be expected in a much broader range of materials exhibiting structural phase transitions.
- 24 January 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices
- Vol. 69 (3) , 1568-1574
Efficiency of Ferroelectric Field-Effect Transistors: An Experimental Study
While the theoretical maximum of the memory window $Δ V_{t}$ in a ferroelectric field-effect transistor (FEFET) is $2E_Ct_F$ , $E_C$ and $t_F$ being coercive field and FE thickness, respectively, experimentally $Δ V_{t}$ is observed to be much less than that, even in the case of complete polarization switching in the ferroelectric layer. This occurs because trapped charges in the gate oxide stack partially or completely screen the ferroelectric polarization, only a fraction of which gets ``electrostatically'' reflected in the semiconductor channel. In this article, we provide a generalized experimental framework to quantify the efficiency of practical FEFETs in converting the switched ferroelectric polarization into the memory window. To that end, we propose three efficiency metrics: 1) switched ferroelectric polarization $Δ P_F$ to memory window conversion ratio, $η_{MW}=Δ V_{t}/Δ P_F$ ; 2) switched ferroelectric polarization to the semiconductor charge ( $Δ Q_S$ ) conversion efficiency or the charge conversion efficiency $η_{c}=Δ Q_s/Δ P_F$ ; and 3) the ratio of memory window to the width of polarization versus gate voltage hysteresis characteristics ( $Δ V_P$ ) or the voltage conversation efficiency $η_V=Δ V_{t}/Δ V_P$ . We measure and compare these efficiency metrics in n-type and p-type FEFETs, fabricated in different facilities by different groups. In all the cases, we find that the maximum values of memory window efficiency $(η_{MW})_{max}$ , charge conversion efficiency $(η_{c}$ ) $_{max}$ , and voltage conversion efficiency ( $η_{V}$ ) $_{max}$ are in the range: 2.5-5.5 Vm²/C, 4%-10%, and 5%-20%, respectively.- 24 January 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices
- Vol. 69 (3) , 1568-1574
Efficiency of Ferroelectric Field-Effect Transistors: An Experimental Study
While the theoretical maximum of the memory window $Δ V_{t}$ in a ferroelectric field-effect transistor (FEFET) is $2E_Ct_F$ , $E_C$ and $t_F$ being coercive field and FE thickness, respectively, experimentally $Δ V_{t}$ is observed to be much less than that, even in the case of complete polarization switching in the ferroelectric layer. This occurs because trapped charges in the gate oxide stack partially or completely screen the ferroelectric polarization, only a fraction of which gets ``electrostatically'' reflected in the semiconductor channel. In this article, we provide a generalized experimental framework to quantify the efficiency of practical FEFETs in converting the switched ferroelectric polarization into the memory window. To that end, we propose three efficiency metrics: 1) switched ferroelectric polarization $Δ P_F$ to memory window conversion ratio, $η_{MW}=Δ V_{t}/Δ P_F$ ; 2) switched ferroelectric polarization to the semiconductor charge ( $Δ Q_S$ ) conversion efficiency or the charge conversion efficiency $η_{c}=Δ Q_s/Δ P_F$ ; and 3) the ratio of memory window to the width of polarization versus gate voltage hysteresis characteristics ( $Δ V_P$ ) or the voltage conversation efficiency $η_V=Δ V_{t}/Δ V_P$ . We measure and compare these efficiency metrics in n-type and p-type FEFETs, fabricated in different facilities by different groups. In all the cases, we find that the maximum values of memory window efficiency $(η_{MW})_{max}$ , charge conversion efficiency $(η_{c}$ ) $_{max}$ , and voltage conversion efficiency ( $η_{V}$ ) $_{max}$ are in the range: 2.5-5.5 Vm²/C, 4%-10%, and 5%-20%, respectively.