Timothy Simon Meese
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Timothy Simon Meese has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Daniel H. Baker
Affiliation Department of Psychology, University of York, York, United Kingdom
25 shared publications - Robert James Summers
School of Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham, UK
10 shared publications - Mark A. Georgeson
School of Life & Health Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham, UK
8 shared publications - Frans A. J. Verstraten
The University of Sydney
5 shared publications - Alex S. Baldwin
McGill Vision Research, Department of Ophthalmology & Visual Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada
4 shared publications Robert F. Hess
McGill Vision Research Unit, Department of Ophthalmology, McGill University, Montreal, Que., Canada
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- p. 1-18
Making a mark by designing from scratch: a swifter assessment scheme for essays, dissertations and data projects
As measures of independent critical thinking, coherence of thought, and academic ability, many undergraduate courses include final-year dissertations with written work in the region of 4,000 to 8,0...
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- p. 1-18
Open AccessMaking a mark by designing from scratch: a swifter assessment scheme for essays, dissertations and data projects
As measures of independent critical thinking, coherence of thought, and academic ability, many undergraduate courses include final-year dissertations with written work in the region of 4,000 to 8,0...
- 9 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (1) , 3-6
Introducing Philosophy Corner
- 9 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (1) , 3-6
Introducing Philosophy Corner
- 3 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (3) , 203-208
Phenomenology and philosophy for perceptionists: A renewed role in the face of AI
- 3 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (3) , 203-208
Phenomenology and philosophy for perceptionists: A renewed role in the face of AI
- Open Access
- 7 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (2) , 111-138
Visual expertise for aerial- and ground-views of houses: No evidence for mental rotation, but experts were more diligent than novices
Ordnance Survey (OS) remote sensing surveyors have extensive experience with aerial views of scenes and objects. Building on our previous work with this group, we investigated whether their expertise influenced performance on a same/different object recognition task involving houses. In an online study, these stimuli were shown from both familiar ground-level viewpoints and from what is for most people, unfamiliar aerial viewpoints. OS experts and novices compared achromatic, disparity-free images with aerial perspectives rotated around the clock against canonical ground-views; we measured response times (RTs) and sensitivities ( d’ ). In two ‘grounding’ tasks using rotated letters, we found conventional outcomes for both groups, validating the online approach. Experiment 1 (non-matching letters) yielded ceiling-level performance with no signs of mental rotation, consistent with a feature-based recognition strategy. In Experiment 2 (mirror reversed letters), both groups showed orientation-dependent performance, but experts exhibited a speed-accuracy trade-off, responding more cautiously than novices. In the main house task (Experiment 3), we found (a) the same speed-accuracy trade-off observed in Experiment 2, (b) substantially longer RTs overall, and (c) no evidence for mental rotation in either group, mirroring Experiment 1. Contrary to our earlier findings on aerial depth perception, expertise in remote sensing did not yield a distinctive recognition strategy for the experiments here. However, experts displayed more diligent tactics in Experiments 2 and 3. We suggest that all participants in Experiment 3 engaged in cognitively challenging feature comparisons across viewpoints, presumably supported by volumetric or surface-connected prototypes of houses as the basis for feature comparisons.
- 7 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (2) , 111-138
Open AccessVisual expertise for aerial- and ground-views of houses: No evidence for mental rotation, but experts were more diligent than novices
Ordnance Survey (OS) remote sensing surveyors have extensive experience with aerial views of scenes and objects. Building on our previous work with this group, we investigated whether their expertise influenced performance on a same/different object recognition task involving houses. In an online study, these stimuli were shown from both familiar ground-level viewpoints and from what is for most people, unfamiliar aerial viewpoints. OS experts and novices compared achromatic, disparity-free images with aerial perspectives rotated around the clock against canonical ground-views; we measured response times (RTs) and sensitivities ( d’ ). In two ‘grounding’ tasks using rotated letters, we found conventional outcomes for both groups, validating the online approach. Experiment 1 (non-matching letters) yielded ceiling-level performance with no signs of mental rotation, consistent with a feature-based recognition strategy. In Experiment 2 (mirror reversed letters), both groups showed orientation-dependent performance, but experts exhibited a speed-accuracy trade-off, responding more cautiously than novices. In the main house task (Experiment 3), we found (a) the same speed-accuracy trade-off observed in Experiment 2, (b) substantially longer RTs overall, and (c) no evidence for mental rotation in either group, mirroring Experiment 1. Contrary to our earlier findings on aerial depth perception, expertise in remote sensing did not yield a distinctive recognition strategy for the experiments here. However, experts displayed more diligent tactics in Experiments 2 and 3. We suggest that all participants in Experiment 3 engaged in cognitively challenging feature comparisons across viewpoints, presumably supported by volumetric or surface-connected prototypes of houses as the basis for feature comparisons.
- 1 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (1) , 7-10
An eye to AI, part II: Consciousness without qualia
- 1 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 55 (1) , 7-10
An eye to AI, part II: Consciousness without qualia
- 30 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (12) , 903-906
An eye to AI, part I: Understanding without consciousness
- 30 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (12) , 903-906
An eye to AI, part I: Understanding without consciousness
- 3 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (10) , 731-733
Are you a perception scientist?
- 3 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (10) , 731-733
Are you a perception scientist?
- Open Access
- 24 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (11) , 817-843
Performance and confusion effects for gist perception of scenes: An investigation of expertise, viewpoint and image categories
Human object recognition often exhibits viewpoint invariance. However, unfamiliar aerial viewpoints pose challenges because diagnostic features are often obscured. Here, we investigated the gist perception of scenes when viewed from above and at the ground level, comparing novices against remote sensing surveyors with expertise in aerial photogrammetry. In a randomly interleaved single-interval, 14-choice design, briefly presented target images were followed by a backward white-noise mask. The targets and choices were selected from seven natural and seven man-made categories. Performance across expertise and viewpoint was between 46.0% and 82.6% correct and confusions were sparsely distributed across the 728 (2 × 2 × 14 × 13) possibilities. Both groups performed better with ground views than with aerial views and different confusions were made across viewpoints, but experts outperformed novices only for aerial views, displaying no transfer of expertise to ground views. Where novices underperformed by comparison, this tended to involve mistaking natural for man-made scenes in aerial views. There was also an overall effect for categorisation to be better for the man-made categories than the natural categories. These, and a few other notable exceptions aside, the main result was that detailed sub-category patterns of successes and confusions were very similar across participant groups: the experimental effects related more to viewpoint than expertise. This contrasts with our recent finding for perception of 3D relief, where comparable groups of experts and novices used very different strategies. It seems that expertise in gist perception (for aerial images at least) is largely a matter of degree rather than kind.
- 24 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
- Vol. 54 (11) , 817-843
Open AccessPerformance and confusion effects for gist perception of scenes: An investigation of expertise, viewpoint and image categories
Human object recognition often exhibits viewpoint invariance. However, unfamiliar aerial viewpoints pose challenges because diagnostic features are often obscured. Here, we investigated the gist perception of scenes when viewed from above and at the ground level, comparing novices against remote sensing surveyors with expertise in aerial photogrammetry. In a randomly interleaved single-interval, 14-choice design, briefly presented target images were followed by a backward white-noise mask. The targets and choices were selected from seven natural and seven man-made categories. Performance across expertise and viewpoint was between 46.0% and 82.6% correct and confusions were sparsely distributed across the 728 (2 × 2 × 14 × 13) possibilities. Both groups performed better with ground views than with aerial views and different confusions were made across viewpoints, but experts outperformed novices only for aerial views, displaying no transfer of expertise to ground views. Where novices underperformed by comparison, this tended to involve mistaking natural for man-made scenes in aerial views. There was also an overall effect for categorisation to be better for the man-made categories than the natural categories. These, and a few other notable exceptions aside, the main result was that detailed sub-category patterns of successes and confusions were very similar across participant groups: the experimental effects related more to viewpoint than expertise. This contrasts with our recent finding for perception of 3D relief, where comparable groups of experts and novices used very different strategies. It seems that expertise in gist perception (for aerial images at least) is largely a matter of degree rather than kind.
- Open Access
Summation of contrast across the visual field: a common “fourth root” rule holds from the fovea to the periphery
A bstract: Increasing the area of grating-like stimuli reduces their contrast detection thresholds. Characterising the visual system’s summation rule this way provides insights into early visual architecture. Previous work in the fovea has found linear summation over short distances, consistent with integration within the receptive fields of early cortical neurons. Beyond this range, the benefit of stimulus area is reduced. Here, we investigated whether the same integration rule holds for stimulus elongations centred at different positions across the visual field. We did this for “tiger tail” strips of grating (growing orthogonally to the major axis of the early receptive fields) in the fovea, parafovea (3 deg), and periphery (10.5 deg). The interpretation of results from previous studies has been complicated by variation in local contrast sensitivity across the visual field. We addressed this here by using detailed maps of the inhomogeneity for each participant (their “witch hat”) to generate “compensated” stimuli where the local stimulus contrast was amplified by the reciprocal of their local sensitivity. Our results followed a common fourth-root summation rule for tiger-tails in the fovea, parafovea, and periphery. We explained this by a “noisy energy” model that combined: i) a “witch hat” sensitivity surface, ii) linear filtering by receptive fields, iii) square-law contrast transduction, and iv) an internal template to direct the observer’s attention to the spatial extent of the stimulus. Fitting this model with a single global sensitivity parameter accounted for foveal and parafoveal results (56 thresholds), with one further parameter needed to model the periphery (84 thresholds).
Open AccessSummation of contrast across the visual field: a common “fourth root” rule holds from the fovea to the periphery
A bstract: Increasing the area of grating-like stimuli reduces their contrast detection thresholds. Characterising the visual system’s summation rule this way provides insights into early visual architecture. Previous work in the fovea has found linear summation over short distances, consistent with integration within the receptive fields of early cortical neurons. Beyond this range, the benefit of stimulus area is reduced. Here, we investigated whether the same integration rule holds for stimulus elongations centred at different positions across the visual field. We did this for “tiger tail” strips of grating (growing orthogonally to the major axis of the early receptive fields) in the fovea, parafovea (3 deg), and periphery (10.5 deg). The interpretation of results from previous studies has been complicated by variation in local contrast sensitivity across the visual field. We addressed this here by using detailed maps of the inhomogeneity for each participant (their “witch hat”) to generate “compensated” stimuli where the local stimulus contrast was amplified by the reciprocal of their local sensitivity. Our results followed a common fourth-root summation rule for tiger-tails in the fovea, parafovea, and periphery. We explained this by a “noisy energy” model that combined: i) a “witch hat” sensitivity surface, ii) linear filtering by receptive fields, iii) square-law contrast transduction, and iv) an internal template to direct the observer’s attention to the spatial extent of the stimulus. Fitting this model with a single global sensitivity parameter accounted for foveal and parafoveal results (56 thresholds), with one further parameter needed to model the periphery (84 thresholds).
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in I-Perception
- Vol. 16 (2)
Blodgett's (1919) “Ship camouflage” 105 years on: A misperception of dazzle perception revealed and redressed
During WWI, dazzle camouflage involved painting allied shipping with bold geometric patterns to disrupt the perceptions of enemy submariners. The first experiment to provide quantitative results on this (Blodgett, 1919; MIT Libraries , MA) used scale models and mechanical simulation, and reported enormous perceptual errors for their perceived direction of travel (up to ∼60°), possibly due to a “twist” effect from forced perspective. However, Blodgett's work did not meet modern standards and the organisation of his report complicates evaluation. Here, we produce (i) reformatted and (ii) heavily edited versions of the original report to improve readability, and (iii) provide a critical reappraisal of the work including (iv) a detailed reanalysis of Blodgett's data and (v) a new control experiment on edited images of the original stimuli. After addressing problems with Blodgett's analysis and control experiment, we found results indicating a twist of only about 7°, but a much larger “hysteresis” effect (∼19–23°) where perceived direction was drawn to the horizon regardless of dazzle. This effect combined both constructively and destructively with “twist”, depending on the direction of the target ship. These reappraised findings resolve an apparent conflict with the second quantitative experiment on dazzle ships conducted over a century later using computer displays online (Lovell et al., 2024; Royal Society Open Science ). We conclude that Blodgett's approach and data remain of interest today, but his conclusions substantially overestimated the effectiveness of dazzle camouflage in biasing the perceived directions of ships. However, other potential benefits of dazzle, including perceptual variance, await systematic investigation.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in I-Perception
- Vol. 16 (2)
Open AccessBlodgett's (1919) “Ship camouflage” 105 years on: A misperception of dazzle perception revealed and redressed
During WWI, dazzle camouflage involved painting allied shipping with bold geometric patterns to disrupt the perceptions of enemy submariners. The first experiment to provide quantitative results on this (Blodgett, 1919; MIT Libraries , MA) used scale models and mechanical simulation, and reported enormous perceptual errors for their perceived direction of travel (up to ∼60°), possibly due to a “twist” effect from forced perspective. However, Blodgett's work did not meet modern standards and the organisation of his report complicates evaluation. Here, we produce (i) reformatted and (ii) heavily edited versions of the original report to improve readability, and (iii) provide a critical reappraisal of the work including (iv) a detailed reanalysis of Blodgett's data and (v) a new control experiment on edited images of the original stimuli. After addressing problems with Blodgett's analysis and control experiment, we found results indicating a twist of only about 7°, but a much larger “hysteresis” effect (∼19–23°) where perceived direction was drawn to the horizon regardless of dazzle. This effect combined both constructively and destructively with “twist”, depending on the direction of the target ship. These reappraised findings resolve an apparent conflict with the second quantitative experiment on dazzle ships conducted over a century later using computer displays online (Lovell et al., 2024; Royal Society Open Science ). We conclude that Blodgett's approach and data remain of interest today, but his conclusions substantially overestimated the effectiveness of dazzle camouflage in biasing the perceived directions of ships. However, other potential benefits of dazzle, including perceptual variance, await systematic investigation.