ASArthur Quentin Summerfield

Arthur Quentin Summerfield

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Arthur Quentin Summerfield has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Using Rasch Analysis to Assess and Improve the Measurement Properties of a Questionnaire With Few Items: The York Binaural Hearing-Related Quality of Life (YBHRQL) Questionnaire

    by A. Quentin Summerfield, Pádraig T. Kitterick

    Objectives: The York Binaural Hearing-Related Quality of Life questionnaire is a condition-specific preference-based instrument sensitive to advantages of binaural over monaural hearing. Respondents use 5-point scales to report the difficulty experienced with three dimensions of listening that are easier or more successful when hearing is binaural: understanding speech in spatially separated noise, localizing sources of sound in azimuth, and the associated effort and fatigue. Previously, a preference value was estimated for each combination of dimension and level so that a value of binaural utility could be assigned to a respondent to inform analyses of cost effectiveness. The present objective was to determine whether the questionnaire conforms with the Rasch model sufficiently well for estimates of the binaural abilities of respondents to be obtained on an interval scale to inform parametric analyses of clinical effectiveness. Design: Data were obtained from unilateral cochlear implantees (N = 418; 209 ≤62 years; 209 ≥63 years) and members of the public (N = 325; 207 ≤62 years; 118 ≥63 years). A subset of implantees (N = 118) responded at test and retest. Responses were fitted to the partial credit model using the Extended Rasch Modeling package. Conformity with the model was evaluated in six ways: the ordering of response categories (Monotonicity) was assessed with plots of response probability against ability; differential item functioning (DIF) was assessed by analyses of variance of standardized response residuals; alignment of participants’ abilities with item difficulties (Targeting) was assessed with person-item maps; fit to the model (Fit) was assessed by comparing the means and variabilities of observed and expected responses, and by comparing observed values with analyses of simulated datasets; the hypothesis that item difficulties and participants’ abilities were measured on a single underlying scale (Unidimensionality) was assessed with principal components analyses of standardized response residuals. Results: Values of fit statistics were toward the lower end of the acceptable range. Comparisons with analyses of simulated datasets showed that low values were primarily the result of the structural limitation of including only three items. Modal values of the probabilities of response categories were ordered monotonically, but some response thresholds were disordered because of under-use of one category. Pooling categories to correct disordered thresholds resulted in estimates of ability that were less discriminatory of differences within and between groups, and showed less reproducibility between test and retest, than did the original estimates. Neither source-related DIF nor gender-related DIF arose. Uniform age-related DIF arose for the speech-in-noise item and could be managed by resolving the item. The resulting estimates of ability and difficulty were well targeted and unidimensional. Conclusions: The York Binaural Hearing-Related Quality of Life questionnaire, with three items each with five response categories, conforms with the Rasch model sufficiently well to yield practically useful measures of the abilities of participants. The trait measured by the questionnaire aligns with the ability to benefit from binaural hearing. More discriminatory measurement of this ability would be achieved with more items. Nonetheless, the questionnaire possesses the virtue that responses to the same three questions can be scored in different ways to inform parametric analyses of both cost-effectiveness and clinical effectiveness.


  • Development and Critical Evaluation of a Condition-Specific Preference-Based Measure Sensitive to Binaural Hearing in Adults: The York Binaural Hearing–Related Quality-of-Life System

    by A. Quentin Summerfield, Pádraig T. Kitterick, Adele M. Goman

    Objectives: The widely-used generic preference-based measures of health-related quality of life—the EuroQol Descriptive System (EQ-5D) and the Health Utilities Index (HUI3)—are limited in their response to technologies that improve hearing. The EQ-5D lacks construct validity for hearing, while the HUI3 is restricted by a ceiling effect and by using speech reception as the only evidence of the ability to hear. Consequently, neither measure consistently registers benefits from binaural hearing, such as those from bilateral versus unilateral cochlear implantation. The objectives were to test whether informants value binaural hearing, to develop a condition-specific preference-based measure sensitive to binaural hearing, to assess the psychometric properties of the new instrument, and to determine whether it meets requirements for informing judgments of cost-effectiveness: does it measure greater gains than do the generic preference-based measures, while avoiding exaggerating losses, and displaying sensitivity to side effects? Design: Three levels of function, ranging from no difficulty to great difficulty, were defined on each of three dimensions where listening is easier or more successful when hearing is binaural rather than monaural: perception of speech in spatially separated noise, localization of sounds, and effort and fatigue. Informants (N = 203) valued the 27 combinations of levels and dimensions in a time trade-off task with a 10-year time frame to provide a value of binaural-related quality of life (“binaural utility”) for each combination. A questionnaire was compiled to allow respondents to report their level of function on each dimension so that a value of binaural utility could be assigned to them. The questionnaire and the age-standardized valuations constitute The York Binaural Hearing–Related Quality-of-Life System (YBHRQL). Adult users of unilateral implants (N = 8), bilateral implants (N = 11), or bimodal aiding (N = 9) undertook performance tests of spatial listening and completed the HUI3, EQ-5D, and Speech, Spatial, and Qualities of Hearing (SSQ) questionnaires. They completed the YBHRQL questionnaire 24 and 38 mo later. Results: Despite long intervals between measurements, the YBHRQL demonstrated desirable psychometric properties: good construct validity evidenced by significant correlations with performance measures and the SSQ index; a greater ability than the EQ-5D or HUI3 to distinguish unilateral, bimodal, and bilateral listening; and good reproducibility. The YBHRQL did not exaggerate losses of utility but was insensitive to a potential side effect of implantation (pain/discomfort). It measured a gain in utility from bilateral compared with unilateral implantation (median = 0.11, interquartile range, 0.03 to 0.16) that was greater than the gain measured by the EQ-5D (0.00, 0.00 to 0.00) but not the HUI3 (0.00, 0.00 to 0.17). Conclusions: The YBHRQL summarizes the contribution of binaural hearing to quality of life by combining the functional status of a listener with the preferences of independent informants. It would be an efficient clinical outcome measure. In addition, if used alongside the EQ-5D or HUI3, it would provide evidence which could beneficially modulate confidence in the cost-effectiveness of interventions. Further research on its sensitivity to side effects, and on the size of the gains in utility which it measures, is needed to determine whether it could stand alone to inform resource-allocation decisions.


  • Open Access

    Sensitivity of EQ-5D-3L, HUI2, HUI3, and SF-6D to changes in speech reception and tinnitus associated with cochlear implantation

    by the UK Cochlear Implant Study Group, A. Q. Summerfield, G. R. Barton

    There is concern that some generic preference-based measures (GPMs) of health-related quality of life may be insensitive to interventions that improve hearing. Establishing where sensitivity arises could contribute to the design of improved measures. Accordingly, we compared the sensitivity of four widely used GPMs to a clinically effective treatment—cochlear implantation—which restores material degrees of hearing to adults with little or no functional hearing.


  • Open Access

    Physiological Evidence for a Midline Spatial Channel in Human Auditory Cortex

    by Paul M. Briley, Adele M. Goman, A. Quentin Summerfield

    Studies with humans and other mammals have provided support for a two-channel representation of horizontal (“azimuthal”) space in the auditory system. In this representation, location-sensitive neurons contribute activity to one of two broadly tuned channels whose responses are compared to derive an estimate of sound-source location. One channel is maximally responsive to sounds towards the left and the other to sounds towards the right. However, recent psychophysical studies of humans, and physiological studies of other mammals, point to the presence of an additional channel, maximally responsive to the midline. In this study, we used electroencephalography to seek physiological evidence for such a midline channel in humans. We measured neural responses to probe stimuli presented from straight ahead (0 °) or towards the right (+30 ° or +90 °). Probes were preceded by adapter stimuli to temporarily suppress channel activity. Adapters came from 0 ° or alternated between left and right (−30 ° and +30 ° or −90 ° and +90 °). For the +90 ° probe, to which the right-tuned channel would respond most strongly, both accounts predict greatest adaptation when the adapters are at ±90 °. For the 0 ° probe, the two-channel account predicts greatest adaptation from the ±90 ° adapters, while the three-channel account predicts greatest adaptation when the adapters are at 0 ° because these adapters stimulate the midline-tuned channel which responds most strongly to the 0 ° probe. The results were consistent with the three-channel account. In addition, a computational implementation of the three-channel account fitted the probe response sizes well, explaining 93 % of the variance about the mean, whereas a two-channel implementation produced a poor fit and explained only 61 % of the variance.


  • Evidence for Opponent Process Analysis of Sound Source Location in Humans

    by Paul M. Briley, Pádraig T. Kitterick, A. Quentin Summerfield

    Research with barn owls suggested that sound source location is represented topographically in the brain by an array of neurons each tuned to a narrow range of locations. However, research with small-headed mammals has offered an alternative view in which location is represented by the balance of activity in two opponent channels broadly tuned to the left and right auditory space. Both channels may be present in each auditory cortex, although the channel representing contralateral space may be dominant. Recent studies have suggested that opponent channel coding of space may also apply in humans, although these studies have used a restricted set of spatial cues or probed a restricted set of spatial locations, and there have been contradictory reports as to the relative dominance of the ipsilateral and contralateral channels in each cortex. The current study used electroencephalography (EEG) in conjunction with sound field stimulus presentation to address these issues and to inform the development of an explicit computational model of human sound source localization. Neural responses were compatible with the opponent channel account of sound source localization and with contralateral channel dominance in the left, but not the right, auditory cortex. A computational opponent channel model reproduced every important aspect of the EEG data and allowed inferences about the width of tuning in the spatial channels. Moreover, the model predicted the oft-reported decrease in spatial acuity measured psychophysically with increasing reference azimuth. Predictions of spatial acuity closely matched those measured psychophysically by previous authors.


  • The Developmental Trajectory of Spatial Listening Skills in Normal-Hearing Children

    by Rosemary Elizabeth Susan Lovett, Pádraig Thomas Kitterick, Shan Huang, Arthur Quentin Summerfield

    PurposeTo establish the age at which children can complete tests of spatial listening and to measure the normative relationship between age and performance. MethodFifty-six normal-hearing children, ages 1.5–7.9 years, attempted tests of the ability to discriminate a sound source on the left from one on the right, to localize a source, to track moving sources, and to perceive speech in noise. ResultsTests of left–right discrimination, movement tracking, and speech perception were completed by ≥75% of children older than 3 years. Children showed adult levels of performance from age 1.5 years (movement tracking), 3 years (left–right discrimination), and 6 years (localization and speech in noise). Spatial release from masking—calculated as the difference in speech reception thresholds between conditions with spatially coincident and spatially separate speech and noise—remained constant at 5 dB from age 3 years. Data from a separate study demonstrate the age at which children with cochlear implants can complete the same tests. Assessments of left–right discrimination, movement tracking, and speech perception were completed by ≥75% of children who are older than 5 years and who wear cochlear implants. ConclusionThese data can guide the selection of tests for future studies and inform the interpretation of results from clinical populations.