Samuel M. Bashevkin
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Samuel M. Bashevkin has a total of 81 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Brian Mahardja
Bureau of Reclamation Sacramento California USA
7 shared publications Delta Stewardship Council
7 shared publicationsCalifornia Department of Water Resources
6 shared publications- Rosemary Hartman
California Department of Water Resources, West Sacramento, USA
5 shared publications Steven G. Morgan
Bodega Marine Laboratory and Department of Environmental Science and Policy, University of California, Davis, 2099 Westshore Rd, PO Box 247, Bodega Bay, CA, 94923, USA
5 shared publicationsBrian Mahardja
Bureau of Reclamation 7 Lodi Fish and Wildlife Office United States
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 March 2025
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 23 (1)
Heatwaves and Rising Temperatures in the Upper San Francisco Estuary: Trends and Effects on Ecosystems and Humans
Rising temperature is one direct consequence of climate change, and temperature is a key controlling variable on biological processes from molecular to ecosystem scales. While rising average temperature is one of the most discussed aspects of climate change, extreme events such as heatwaves are also expected to increase in duration, intensity, and frequency. These changes will bring about effects that threaten the integrity of the upper San Francisco Estuary (estuary) ecosystem, the services they provide to humans, and the health of humans that reside in the region. In the estuary, warmer temperatures are expected to result in seasonal shifts to life-cycle timing, and to favor smaller-bodied individuals across most non-human taxa. Several native fish species will likely decline, while a considerable number of non-native and cosmopolitan species tolerant of high temperatures are predicted to be relatively unaffected by or even benefit from a warmer climate. For humans, high temperatures and heatwaves are associated with wide-ranging health effects, from direct effects such as dehydration and heat exhaustion, to indirect and adverse health outcomes such as lower birth weight, mental health problems, and violence. These health effects will be exacerbated by ecosystem changes, as a longer warm season will increase our exposure to vectors such as mosquitos, as well as to the toxins produced by harmful algal blooms. Climate change is a global issue that cannot be resolved effectively at a regional level; however, some actions can either be taken or further studied to potentially lessen the effects of rising temperatures for the estuary’s ecosystem and residents at a more localized level. Although decreasing global greenhouse gas emissions remains our best option to combat climate change and the resultant temperature increases, successful adaptation to warming and heatwaves will require actions at multiple scales.
- 20 March 2025
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 23 (1)
Open AccessHeatwaves and Rising Temperatures in the Upper San Francisco Estuary: Trends and Effects on Ecosystems and Humans
Rising temperature is one direct consequence of climate change, and temperature is a key controlling variable on biological processes from molecular to ecosystem scales. While rising average temperature is one of the most discussed aspects of climate change, extreme events such as heatwaves are also expected to increase in duration, intensity, and frequency. These changes will bring about effects that threaten the integrity of the upper San Francisco Estuary (estuary) ecosystem, the services they provide to humans, and the health of humans that reside in the region. In the estuary, warmer temperatures are expected to result in seasonal shifts to life-cycle timing, and to favor smaller-bodied individuals across most non-human taxa. Several native fish species will likely decline, while a considerable number of non-native and cosmopolitan species tolerant of high temperatures are predicted to be relatively unaffected by or even benefit from a warmer climate. For humans, high temperatures and heatwaves are associated with wide-ranging health effects, from direct effects such as dehydration and heat exhaustion, to indirect and adverse health outcomes such as lower birth weight, mental health problems, and violence. These health effects will be exacerbated by ecosystem changes, as a longer warm season will increase our exposure to vectors such as mosquitos, as well as to the toxins produced by harmful algal blooms. Climate change is a global issue that cannot be resolved effectively at a regional level; however, some actions can either be taken or further studied to potentially lessen the effects of rising temperatures for the estuary’s ecosystem and residents at a more localized level. Although decreasing global greenhouse gas emissions remains our best option to combat climate change and the resultant temperature increases, successful adaptation to warming and heatwaves will require actions at multiple scales.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2024
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 22 (1)
Years of Drought and Salt: Decreasing Flows Determine the Distribution of Zooplankton Resources in the San Francisco Estuary
The San Francisco Estuary (estuary) and the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta (the Delta) in California face significant challenges in managing water resources during extended droughts. Zooplankton are a vital trophic link between phytoplankton producers and higher-level consumers such as predatory zooplankton and fish. However, there is still much to be learned about what drives zooplankton abundance and how they respond to drastic changes in environmental conditions, such as droughts. We found that during drought years zooplankton abundance and distribution changes varied for examined taxa. Significant declines in the abundance of Daphnia spp. and the copepod Pseudodiaptomus forbesi occurred in the Suisun Marsh and Suisun Bay regions. In contrast, abundance of the non-native copepod Limnoithona tetraspina increased in Suisun Marsh and the South-Central Delta during those same drought conditions. Salinity is a strong determinant of the presence and abundance of the studied taxa, and we showed that changes in the distribution of salinity low outflow conditions were an important factor in the regional abundance of zooplankton. Because of the expected increase in the frequency and severity of regional droughts, understanding how these conditions affect zooplankton in the estuary will benefit scientists and resource managers who aim to improve conditions for native fishes.
- 19 March 2024
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 22 (1)
Open AccessYears of Drought and Salt: Decreasing Flows Determine the Distribution of Zooplankton Resources in the San Francisco Estuary
The San Francisco Estuary (estuary) and the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta (the Delta) in California face significant challenges in managing water resources during extended droughts. Zooplankton are a vital trophic link between phytoplankton producers and higher-level consumers such as predatory zooplankton and fish. However, there is still much to be learned about what drives zooplankton abundance and how they respond to drastic changes in environmental conditions, such as droughts. We found that during drought years zooplankton abundance and distribution changes varied for examined taxa. Significant declines in the abundance of Daphnia spp. and the copepod Pseudodiaptomus forbesi occurred in the Suisun Marsh and Suisun Bay regions. In contrast, abundance of the non-native copepod Limnoithona tetraspina increased in Suisun Marsh and the South-Central Delta during those same drought conditions. Salinity is a strong determinant of the presence and abundance of the studied taxa, and we showed that changes in the distribution of salinity low outflow conditions were an important factor in the regional abundance of zooplankton. Because of the expected increase in the frequency and severity of regional droughts, understanding how these conditions affect zooplankton in the estuary will benefit scientists and resource managers who aim to improve conditions for native fishes.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2024
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 22 (1)
The Anatomy of a Drought in the Upper San Francisco Estuary: Water Quality and Lower-Trophic Responses to Multi-Year Droughts Over a Long-Term Record (1975-2021)
Multi-year droughts are ever-present and transformational features of California’s Mediterranean climate and can fundamentally affect the water quality and the ecosystem responses of the San Francisco Estuary (estuary) and the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta). This study assessed data collected by long-term monitoring programs over the past 46 water years (1975-2021) to evaluate how water quality in the estuary changes during multi-year droughts. Data were aggregated by region (South-Central Delta, North Delta, Confluence, Suisun Bay, and Suisun Marsh) and season, then differences between multi-year Drought periods, multi-year Wet periods, and Neutral periods were compared using generalized linear models. We found that multi-year Drought periods altered multiple physical and chemical parameters in the estuary, increasing water temperature, salinity, water clarity, and nutrient levels. This trend was consistent across regions and seasons, with few exceptions. Increases in these parameters during Drought periods were likely caused by reduced Delta inflows that intensified in each successive dry year because of reduced precipitation and managed estuarine inflows and outflows. Drought periods did not substantially affect tidal velocities within the estuary, which remained mostly consistent across Wet and Drought periods. Trends in chlorophyll concentrations during Drought periods were more nuanced with higher concentrations occurring in the South-Central Delta region and during the winter and spring. Together, these results characterized drought in the estuary as warm, clear, high in nutrients, with patchy phytoplankton blooms (as indexed by chlorophyll), all of which have implications for higher trophic levels. Considering that droughts are expected to increase in frequency and intensity in California with climate change, understanding the effects of multi-year droughts on the water quality conditions of the estuary can help inform water management decisions.
- 19 March 2024
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 22 (1)
Open AccessThe Anatomy of a Drought in the Upper San Francisco Estuary: Water Quality and Lower-Trophic Responses to Multi-Year Droughts Over a Long-Term Record (1975-2021)
Multi-year droughts are ever-present and transformational features of California’s Mediterranean climate and can fundamentally affect the water quality and the ecosystem responses of the San Francisco Estuary (estuary) and the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta). This study assessed data collected by long-term monitoring programs over the past 46 water years (1975-2021) to evaluate how water quality in the estuary changes during multi-year droughts. Data were aggregated by region (South-Central Delta, North Delta, Confluence, Suisun Bay, and Suisun Marsh) and season, then differences between multi-year Drought periods, multi-year Wet periods, and Neutral periods were compared using generalized linear models. We found that multi-year Drought periods altered multiple physical and chemical parameters in the estuary, increasing water temperature, salinity, water clarity, and nutrient levels. This trend was consistent across regions and seasons, with few exceptions. Increases in these parameters during Drought periods were likely caused by reduced Delta inflows that intensified in each successive dry year because of reduced precipitation and managed estuarine inflows and outflows. Drought periods did not substantially affect tidal velocities within the estuary, which remained mostly consistent across Wet and Drought periods. Trends in chlorophyll concentrations during Drought periods were more nuanced with higher concentrations occurring in the South-Central Delta region and during the winter and spring. Together, these results characterized drought in the estuary as warm, clear, high in nutrients, with patchy phytoplankton blooms (as indexed by chlorophyll), all of which have implications for higher trophic levels. Considering that droughts are expected to increase in frequency and intensity in California with climate change, understanding the effects of multi-year droughts on the water quality conditions of the estuary can help inform water management decisions.
- Open Access
Evaluating top‐down, bottom‐up, and environmental drivers of pelagic food web dynamics along an estuarine gradient
Identification of the key biotic and abiotic drivers within food webs is important for understanding species abundance changes in ecosystems, particularly across ecotones where there may be strong variation in interaction strengths. Using structural equation models (SEMs) and four decades of integrated data from the San Francisco Estuary, we investigated the relative effects of top‐down, bottom‐up, and environmental drivers on multiple trophic levels of the pelagic food web along an estuarine salinity gradient and at both annual and monthly temporal resolutions. We found that interactions varied across the estuarine gradient and that the detectability of different interactions depended on timescale. For example, for zooplankton and estuarine fishes, bottom‐up effects appeared to be stronger in the freshwater upstream regions, while top‐down effects were stronger in the brackish downstream regions. Some relationships (e.g., bottom‐up effects of phytoplankton on zooplankton) were seen primarily at annual timescales, whereas others (e.g., temperature effects) were only observed at monthly timescales. We also found that the net effect of environmental drivers was similar to or greater than bottom‐up and top‐down effects for all food web components. These findings can help identify which trophic levels or environmental factors could be targeted by management actions to have the greatest impact on estuarine forage fishes and the spatial and temporal scale at which responses might be observed. More broadly, this study highlights how environmental gradients can structure community interactions and how long‐term data sets can be leveraged to generate insights across multiple scales.
Open AccessEvaluating top‐down, bottom‐up, and environmental drivers of pelagic food web dynamics along an estuarine gradient
Identification of the key biotic and abiotic drivers within food webs is important for understanding species abundance changes in ecosystems, particularly across ecotones where there may be strong variation in interaction strengths. Using structural equation models (SEMs) and four decades of integrated data from the San Francisco Estuary, we investigated the relative effects of top‐down, bottom‐up, and environmental drivers on multiple trophic levels of the pelagic food web along an estuarine salinity gradient and at both annual and monthly temporal resolutions. We found that interactions varied across the estuarine gradient and that the detectability of different interactions depended on timescale. For example, for zooplankton and estuarine fishes, bottom‐up effects appeared to be stronger in the freshwater upstream regions, while top‐down effects were stronger in the brackish downstream regions. Some relationships (e.g., bottom‐up effects of phytoplankton on zooplankton) were seen primarily at annual timescales, whereas others (e.g., temperature effects) were only observed at monthly timescales. We also found that the net effect of environmental drivers was similar to or greater than bottom‐up and top‐down effects for all food web components. These findings can help identify which trophic levels or environmental factors could be targeted by management actions to have the greatest impact on estuarine forage fishes and the spatial and temporal scale at which responses might be observed. More broadly, this study highlights how environmental gradients can structure community interactions and how long‐term data sets can be leveraged to generate insights across multiple scales.
- Open Access
- 25 September 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 21 (3)
Long-Term Trends in Seasonality and Abundance of Three Key Zooplankters in the Upper San Francisco Estuary
Zooplankton provide critical food for threatened and endangered fish species in the San Francisco Estuary (estuary). Reduced food supply has been implicated in the Pelagic Organism Decline of the early 2000s, and further changes in zooplankton abundance, seasonality, and distribution may continue to threaten declining fishes. While we have a wealth of monitoring data, we know little about the abundance trends of many estuary zooplankton species. To fill these gaps, we reviewed past research and then examined trends in seasonality and abundance from 1972 to the present of three key but understudied zooplankton species (Bosmina longirostris, Acanthocyclops spp., and Acartiella sinensis) that play important roles in the estuary food web. We fit Bayesian generalized additive mixed models of each taxon’s relationship with salinity, seasonality, year, and geography on an integrated database of zooplankton monitoring in the upper estuary. We found marked changes in the seasonality and overall abundance of each study species. Bosmina longirostris no longer peaks in abundance in the fall months, Acanthocyclops spp. precipitously declined in all months and lost its strong relationship with salinity, and A. sinensis adult abundance has become more strongly related to salinity while juveniles have developed wider seasonal abundance peaks. Through these analyses, we have documented the relationship of each species with salinity and seasonality since the beginning of monitoring or their introduction, thus increasing our understanding of their ecology and importance in the estuary. These results can inform food-web models, be paired with fish data to model the contributions of these species toward fish abundance trends and be mirrored to elucidate other species’ trends in future studies.
- 25 September 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 21 (3)
Open AccessLong-Term Trends in Seasonality and Abundance of Three Key Zooplankters in the Upper San Francisco Estuary
Zooplankton provide critical food for threatened and endangered fish species in the San Francisco Estuary (estuary). Reduced food supply has been implicated in the Pelagic Organism Decline of the early 2000s, and further changes in zooplankton abundance, seasonality, and distribution may continue to threaten declining fishes. While we have a wealth of monitoring data, we know little about the abundance trends of many estuary zooplankton species. To fill these gaps, we reviewed past research and then examined trends in seasonality and abundance from 1972 to the present of three key but understudied zooplankton species (Bosmina longirostris, Acanthocyclops spp., and Acartiella sinensis) that play important roles in the estuary food web. We fit Bayesian generalized additive mixed models of each taxon’s relationship with salinity, seasonality, year, and geography on an integrated database of zooplankton monitoring in the upper estuary. We found marked changes in the seasonality and overall abundance of each study species. Bosmina longirostris no longer peaks in abundance in the fall months, Acanthocyclops spp. precipitously declined in all months and lost its strong relationship with salinity, and A. sinensis adult abundance has become more strongly related to salinity while juveniles have developed wider seasonal abundance peaks. Through these analyses, we have documented the relationship of each species with salinity and seasonality since the beginning of monitoring or their introduction, thus increasing our understanding of their ecology and importance in the estuary. These results can inform food-web models, be paired with fish data to model the contributions of these species toward fish abundance trends and be mirrored to elucidate other species’ trends in future studies.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (4)
Ecosystem Services and Disservices of Bay-Delta Primary Producers: How Plants and Algae Affect Ecosystems and Respond to Management of the Estuary and Its Watershed
The Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta (Delta) is a case-study of the Anthropocene “great accelerations,” with exponentially increasing temperatures and sea level over time, leading to rapid change in other ecosystem components. In nearly all these interconnected changes and across scales, primary producers play a major role, with diverse effects that mitigate or exacerbate rapid change induced by climate or other human-driven perturbations. Through this anthropocentric lens, primary producers can be viewed as performing numerous ecosystem services—which ultimately benefit humans—as well as ecosystem disservices, which have negative effects on human communities. For example, through carbon sequestration, wetlands can perform ecosystem services of mitigating warming at a global scale and combating relative sea-level rise at a local scale, while generating food that supports regional food webs and fisheries. On the other hand, invasive aquatic vegetation (IAV) can trap sediment before it reaches wetlands, exacerbating local subsidence and relative sea-level rise while incurring great costs to recreation, fishing, and agencies tasked with its control. Effectively managing these ecosystem services and disservices requires understanding of how they are connected. For example, wetland restoration often creates opportunities for IAV, which may inhibit sediment deposition on the wetland and outcompete native species. As the Delta science community works toward a more integrative understanding of how different components of the Delta interact as a whole and across scales, the pervasive effects of the ecosystem services and disservices of primary producers serve as foundational knowledge. In this topically themed edition of State of Bay-Delta Science, we review these effects. Individual chapters focus on the historical ecology of the primary productivity of aquatic vegetation, the ecology and control of invasive aquatic vegetation, harmful algal blooms, carbon sequestration and subsidence reversal by wetlands, and remote sensing methods for quantifying the ecosystem services and disservices of Delta primary producers.
- 3 February 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (4)
Open AccessEcosystem Services and Disservices of Bay-Delta Primary Producers: How Plants and Algae Affect Ecosystems and Respond to Management of the Estuary and Its Watershed
The Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta (Delta) is a case-study of the Anthropocene “great accelerations,” with exponentially increasing temperatures and sea level over time, leading to rapid change in other ecosystem components. In nearly all these interconnected changes and across scales, primary producers play a major role, with diverse effects that mitigate or exacerbate rapid change induced by climate or other human-driven perturbations. Through this anthropocentric lens, primary producers can be viewed as performing numerous ecosystem services—which ultimately benefit humans—as well as ecosystem disservices, which have negative effects on human communities. For example, through carbon sequestration, wetlands can perform ecosystem services of mitigating warming at a global scale and combating relative sea-level rise at a local scale, while generating food that supports regional food webs and fisheries. On the other hand, invasive aquatic vegetation (IAV) can trap sediment before it reaches wetlands, exacerbating local subsidence and relative sea-level rise while incurring great costs to recreation, fishing, and agencies tasked with its control. Effectively managing these ecosystem services and disservices requires understanding of how they are connected. For example, wetland restoration often creates opportunities for IAV, which may inhibit sediment deposition on the wetland and outcompete native species. As the Delta science community works toward a more integrative understanding of how different components of the Delta interact as a whole and across scales, the pervasive effects of the ecosystem services and disservices of primary producers serve as foundational knowledge. In this topically themed edition of State of Bay-Delta Science, we review these effects. Individual chapters focus on the historical ecology of the primary productivity of aquatic vegetation, the ecology and control of invasive aquatic vegetation, harmful algal blooms, carbon sequestration and subsidence reversal by wetlands, and remote sensing methods for quantifying the ecosystem services and disservices of Delta primary producers.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Evaluating top-down, bottom-up, and environmental drivers of pelagic food web dynamics along an estuarine gradient
Identification of the key biotic and abiotic drivers within food webs is important for understanding species abundance changes in ecosystems, particularly across ecotones where there may be strong variation in interaction strengths. Using structural equation models and four decades of integrated data from the San Francisco Estuary, we investigated the relative effects of top-down, bottom-up, and environmental drivers on multiple trophic levels of the pelagic food web along an estuarine salinity gradient and at both annual and monthly temporal resolutions. For zooplankton and estuarine fishes, bottom-up effects appeared to be stronger in the freshwater upstream regions, while top-down effects were stronger in the brackish downstream regions. Interestingly, this contrasts with hypotheses that freshwater systems have stronger top-down effects than marine systems due to the more limited spatial range of their predators. The net effect of environmental drivers was similar to or greater than bottom-up and top-down effects for all food web components. Some relationships (e.g., bottom-up effects of phytoplankton on zooplankton) were seen primarily at annual timescales, whereas others (e.g., temperature effects) were only observed at monthly timescales. Overall, our results provide strong evidence that environmental gradients can structure the relative strengths of bottom-up, top-down, and environmental drivers within food webs. This advances our understanding of the influence of environmental drivers on species interactions, as well as the mechanisms behind variability in the relative strengths of bottom-up and top-down drivers among habitats and ecosystems. Furthermore, these findings can help identify which trophic levels or environmental factors could be targeted by management actions to have the greatest impact on estuarine forage fishes. This approach of leveraging long-term datasets to identify trophic interactions is applicable to a wide range of systems, including complex, dynamic systems along environmental gradients.
- 16 December 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessEvaluating top-down, bottom-up, and environmental drivers of pelagic food web dynamics along an estuarine gradient
Identification of the key biotic and abiotic drivers within food webs is important for understanding species abundance changes in ecosystems, particularly across ecotones where there may be strong variation in interaction strengths. Using structural equation models and four decades of integrated data from the San Francisco Estuary, we investigated the relative effects of top-down, bottom-up, and environmental drivers on multiple trophic levels of the pelagic food web along an estuarine salinity gradient and at both annual and monthly temporal resolutions. For zooplankton and estuarine fishes, bottom-up effects appeared to be stronger in the freshwater upstream regions, while top-down effects were stronger in the brackish downstream regions. Interestingly, this contrasts with hypotheses that freshwater systems have stronger top-down effects than marine systems due to the more limited spatial range of their predators. The net effect of environmental drivers was similar to or greater than bottom-up and top-down effects for all food web components. Some relationships (e.g., bottom-up effects of phytoplankton on zooplankton) were seen primarily at annual timescales, whereas others (e.g., temperature effects) were only observed at monthly timescales. Overall, our results provide strong evidence that environmental gradients can structure the relative strengths of bottom-up, top-down, and environmental drivers within food webs. This advances our understanding of the influence of environmental drivers on species interactions, as well as the mechanisms behind variability in the relative strengths of bottom-up and top-down drivers among habitats and ecosystems. Furthermore, these findings can help identify which trophic levels or environmental factors could be targeted by management actions to have the greatest impact on estuarine forage fishes. This approach of leveraging long-term datasets to identify trophic interactions is applicable to a wide range of systems, including complex, dynamic systems along environmental gradients.
- Open Access
- 14 October 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (3)
A Framework for Evaluating the Effects of Reduced Spatial or Temporal Monitoring Effort
Monitoring in the San Francisco Estuary (estuary) has fluctuated in sampling effort over time with changes to resources, objectives, and unforeseen events. I designed an approach to evaluate how reduced sampling would alter our ability to describe the status and trends of key species. This approach can evaluate the sensitivity of the estuary monitoring program to disruptions in sampling, and whether sampling effort could be reduced without compromising the information provided by these surveys. I simulated reduced sampling on top of the historical data record (1985–2018) by selectively removing data and evaluating the effect on model inference. The same model structure is fit to the full data set and several reduced data sets that represent simulations of reduced sampling effort. I then compared model predictions from reduced models to those from the full model to evaluate how reduced sampling may have affected our ability to detect key patterns in the data. In a case study, I applied this approach to Sacramento Splittail abundance trends from the Bay Study and the Suisun Marsh Fish Study otter trawls. Sampling reductions of 10% and 20% had fairly low impacts on the overlap of reduced model predictions with those from the full model. These results demonstrate the utility of my approach, but they are not generalizable beyond our ability to detect trends in Splittail abundance from Bay Study and Suisun Marsh Fish Study otter trawl data. A thorough analysis should run these simulations on multiple species and multiple parameters (e.g., abundance, distribution, length). By simulating sampling reductions on top of historical conditions, this approach could evaluate differential effects in varying environmental or historical conditions (e.g., droughts, species declines, invasions). In addition, this approach can easily be extended to other functional groups (e.g., zooplankton, phytoplankton) as well as physical parameters (e.g., temperature, salinity, Secchi depth).
- 14 October 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (3)
Open AccessA Framework for Evaluating the Effects of Reduced Spatial or Temporal Monitoring Effort
Monitoring in the San Francisco Estuary (estuary) has fluctuated in sampling effort over time with changes to resources, objectives, and unforeseen events. I designed an approach to evaluate how reduced sampling would alter our ability to describe the status and trends of key species. This approach can evaluate the sensitivity of the estuary monitoring program to disruptions in sampling, and whether sampling effort could be reduced without compromising the information provided by these surveys. I simulated reduced sampling on top of the historical data record (1985–2018) by selectively removing data and evaluating the effect on model inference. The same model structure is fit to the full data set and several reduced data sets that represent simulations of reduced sampling effort. I then compared model predictions from reduced models to those from the full model to evaluate how reduced sampling may have affected our ability to detect key patterns in the data. In a case study, I applied this approach to Sacramento Splittail abundance trends from the Bay Study and the Suisun Marsh Fish Study otter trawls. Sampling reductions of 10% and 20% had fairly low impacts on the overlap of reduced model predictions with those from the full model. These results demonstrate the utility of my approach, but they are not generalizable beyond our ability to detect trends in Splittail abundance from Bay Study and Suisun Marsh Fish Study otter trawl data. A thorough analysis should run these simulations on multiple species and multiple parameters (e.g., abundance, distribution, length). By simulating sampling reductions on top of historical conditions, this approach could evaluate differential effects in varying environmental or historical conditions (e.g., droughts, species declines, invasions). In addition, this approach can easily be extended to other functional groups (e.g., zooplankton, phytoplankton) as well as physical parameters (e.g., temperature, salinity, Secchi depth).
- Open Access
- 2 June 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Hydrobiologia
- Vol. 849 (13) , 2895-2918
Escape from the heat: thermal stratification in a well-mixed estuary and implications for fish species facing a changing climate
Climate change may cause organisms to seek thermal refuge from rising temperatures, either by shifting their ranges or seeking microrefugia within their existing ranges. We evaluate the potential for thermal stratification to provide refuge for two fish species in the San Francisco Estuary (Estuary): Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytschaWalbaum, 1792) and Delta Smelt (Hypomesus transpacificusMcAllister, 1963). We compiled water temperature data from multiple monitoring programs to evaluate spatial, daily, hourly, intra-annual, and inter-annual trends in stratification using generalized additive models. We used our models to predict the locations and periods of time that the bottom of the water column could function as thermal refuge for salmon and smelt. Periods in which the bottom was cooler than surface primarily occurred during the peak of summer and during the afternoons, with more prominent stratification during warmer years. Although the Estuary is often exceedingly warm for fish species and well-mixed overall, we identified potential thermal refugia in a long and deep terminal channel for Delta Smelt, and in the periods bordering summer for Chinook Salmon. Thermal stratification may increase as the climate warms, and pockets of cooler water at depth, though limited, may become more important for at-risk fishes in the future.
- 2 June 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Hydrobiologia
- Vol. 849 (13) , 2895-2918
Open AccessEscape from the heat: thermal stratification in a well-mixed estuary and implications for fish species facing a changing climate
Climate change may cause organisms to seek thermal refuge from rising temperatures, either by shifting their ranges or seeking microrefugia within their existing ranges. We evaluate the potential for thermal stratification to provide refuge for two fish species in the San Francisco Estuary (Estuary): Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytschaWalbaum, 1792) and Delta Smelt (Hypomesus transpacificusMcAllister, 1963). We compiled water temperature data from multiple monitoring programs to evaluate spatial, daily, hourly, intra-annual, and inter-annual trends in stratification using generalized additive models. We used our models to predict the locations and periods of time that the bottom of the water column could function as thermal refuge for salmon and smelt. Periods in which the bottom was cooler than surface primarily occurred during the peak of summer and during the afternoons, with more prominent stratification during warmer years. Although the Estuary is often exceedingly warm for fish species and well-mixed overall, we identified potential thermal refugia in a long and deep terminal channel for Delta Smelt, and in the periods bordering summer for Chinook Salmon. Thermal stratification may increase as the climate warms, and pockets of cooler water at depth, though limited, may become more important for at-risk fishes in the future.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (1)
Relative Bias in Catch Among Long-Term Fish Monitoring Surveys Within the San Francisco Estuary
Fish monitoring gears rarely capture all available fish, an inherent bias in monitoring programs referred to as catchability. Catchability is a source of bias that can be affected by numerous aspects of gear deployment (e.g., deployment speed, mesh size, and avoidance behavior). Thus, care must be taken when multiple surveys—especially those using different sampling methods—are combined to answer spatio-temporal questions about population and community dynamics. We assessed relative catchability differences among four long-term fish monitoring surveys from the San Francisco Estuary: the Bay Study Otter Trawl (BSOT), the Bay Study Midwater Trawl (BSMT), the Fall Midwater Trawl (FMWT), and the Suisun Marsh Otter Trawl (SMOT). We used generalized additive models with a spatio-temporal smoother and survey as a fixed effect to predict gear-specific estimates of catch for 45 different fish species within large and small size classes. We used estimates of the fixed effect coefficients for each survey (e.g., BSOT) relative to the reference gear (FMWT) to develop relative measures of catchability among taxa, surveys, and fish-size classes, termed the catch-ratio. We found higher relative catchability of 27%, 22%, and 57% of fish species in large size classes from the FMWT than in the BSMT, BSOT, or SMOT, respectively. In the small size class, relative catchability was higher in the FMWT than the BSMT, BSOT, or SMOT for 50%, 18%, and 25% of fish species, respectively. As expected, relative catchability of demersal species was higher in the otter trawls (BSOT, SMOT) while relative catchability of pelagic species was higher in the midwater trawls (FMWT, BSMT). Our results demonstrate that catchability is a source of bias among monitoring efforts within the San Francisco Estuary, and assuming equal catchability among surveys, species, and size classes could result in significant bias when describing spatio-temporal patterns in catch if ignored.
- 17 March 2022
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science
- Vol. 20 (1)
Open AccessRelative Bias in Catch Among Long-Term Fish Monitoring Surveys Within the San Francisco Estuary
Fish monitoring gears rarely capture all available fish, an inherent bias in monitoring programs referred to as catchability. Catchability is a source of bias that can be affected by numerous aspects of gear deployment (e.g., deployment speed, mesh size, and avoidance behavior). Thus, care must be taken when multiple surveys—especially those using different sampling methods—are combined to answer spatio-temporal questions about population and community dynamics. We assessed relative catchability differences among four long-term fish monitoring surveys from the San Francisco Estuary: the Bay Study Otter Trawl (BSOT), the Bay Study Midwater Trawl (BSMT), the Fall Midwater Trawl (FMWT), and the Suisun Marsh Otter Trawl (SMOT). We used generalized additive models with a spatio-temporal smoother and survey as a fixed effect to predict gear-specific estimates of catch for 45 different fish species within large and small size classes. We used estimates of the fixed effect coefficients for each survey (e.g., BSOT) relative to the reference gear (FMWT) to develop relative measures of catchability among taxa, surveys, and fish-size classes, termed the catch-ratio. We found higher relative catchability of 27%, 22%, and 57% of fish species in large size classes from the FMWT than in the BSMT, BSOT, or SMOT, respectively. In the small size class, relative catchability was higher in the FMWT than the BSMT, BSOT, or SMOT for 50%, 18%, and 25% of fish species, respectively. As expected, relative catchability of demersal species was higher in the otter trawls (BSOT, SMOT) while relative catchability of pelagic species was higher in the midwater trawls (FMWT, BSMT). Our results demonstrate that catchability is a source of bias among monitoring efforts within the San Francisco Estuary, and assuming equal catchability among surveys, species, and size classes could result in significant bias when describing spatio-temporal patterns in catch if ignored.