Kimberley J. Mathot
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Kimberley J. Mathot has a total of 142 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Niels Jeroen Dingemanse
Faculty of Biology, LMU Munich, Planegg-Martinsried, Germany
19 shared publications - Jan J. Wijmenga
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Alberta
7 shared publications - Elène Haave‐Audet
Department of Biological Sciences University of Alberta Edmonton Alberta Canada
6 shared publications - Josue David Arteaga-Torres
Konrad Lorenz Research Center for Behavior and Cognition, Core Facility of the University of Vienna, Grünau im Almtal, 4645 Austria
6 shared publications - Aaron W. Schrey
Georgia Southern University - Armstrong Campus
5 shared publications Bart Kempenaers
Department of Behavioural Ecology and Evolutionary Genetics, Max Planck Institute for Ornithology, Seewiesen, Germany
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Ecology & Evolution
The development of individuality: beyond nature and nurture
- 11 November 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Ecology & Evolution
The development of individuality: beyond nature and nurture
- Open Access
- 7 October 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (10)
Can optimal caching models predict changes in diurnal feeder use patterns in black-capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus )?
Many birds collect and store food for later use, a behaviour known as caching. Theoretical models predict that caching effort is concentrated in a single peak during the day, though the precise timing of that peak depends on multiple factors. We studied diurnal patterns of feeder used in a population of 50 individually marked black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) in late summer. We used total daily feeder visits (1 visit ≈ 1 sunflower seed) as a proxy for caching intensity because daily feeder visits (range 11–339 feeder visits per bird per day) often exceeded the required intake of about 45 sunflower seeds for chickadees at this time of year, consistent with a wide range of caching effort. Patterns of feeder use were always bimodal, and increases in hourly feeder visits occurred throughout the day with increased total daily feeder visits, however, the greatest relative increase in feeder visits was during midday. Post hoc analyses revealed that this population-level effect was driven by individual differences; some chickadees increased morning feeder visits with increasing total daily feeder visits, while others increased midday or end-of-day feeder visits. Future work should investigate drivers of these individual differences, including the role of interference competition.
- 7 October 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (10)
Open AccessCan optimal caching models predict changes in diurnal feeder use patterns in black-capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus )?
Many birds collect and store food for later use, a behaviour known as caching. Theoretical models predict that caching effort is concentrated in a single peak during the day, though the precise timing of that peak depends on multiple factors. We studied diurnal patterns of feeder used in a population of 50 individually marked black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) in late summer. We used total daily feeder visits (1 visit ≈ 1 sunflower seed) as a proxy for caching intensity because daily feeder visits (range 11–339 feeder visits per bird per day) often exceeded the required intake of about 45 sunflower seeds for chickadees at this time of year, consistent with a wide range of caching effort. Patterns of feeder use were always bimodal, and increases in hourly feeder visits occurred throughout the day with increased total daily feeder visits, however, the greatest relative increase in feeder visits was during midday. Post hoc analyses revealed that this population-level effect was driven by individual differences; some chickadees increased morning feeder visits with increasing total daily feeder visits, while others increased midday or end-of-day feeder visits. Future work should investigate drivers of these individual differences, including the role of interference competition.
- Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (7) , e73972
Female Black‐Capped Chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) Expand Foraging Both Temporally and Spatially to Mitigate Interference Competition
Group living provides many potential benefits but can also incur important costs via competition for access to resources. Even in the absence of resource depletion, interference competition can reduce access to resources, and interference competition is not expected to affect all group members equally. In groups with dominance hierarchies, dominant individuals have priority access to resources and are therefore expected to experience lower costs of interference competition compared to subordinate individuals. Here, we assessed the effect of manipulating the number of feeders available with ad libitum food, which we assumed would affect competition intensity, on total daily feeder visits in a marked population of 126 black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ). As predicted, we found strong evidence of interference competition: reducing feeder availability by 50% reduced average per capita daily visits to feeders in our population by circa 50%. Because chickadee flocks exhibit linear dominance hierarchies, with males being dominant over females, and at least in some populations, adults being dominant over immatures, we also investigated whether there was evidence for sex‐ and/or age‐related differences in the strength of interference competition. We found that reductions in total daily feeder visits under lower manipulated food availability were similar for all age‐sex categories, suggesting that females and immatures did not experience higher interference competition despite their subordinate status relative to males and adults. Post hoc analyses revealed that adult females expanded their foraging area, while immature females increased both the length of the foraging window and foraging area when the availability of feeders was reduced. We suggest that these results may indicate that females invest more to mitigate competition and manage unpredictable access to food due to their subordinate status.
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (7) , e73972
Open AccessFemale Black‐Capped Chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) Expand Foraging Both Temporally and Spatially to Mitigate Interference Competition
Group living provides many potential benefits but can also incur important costs via competition for access to resources. Even in the absence of resource depletion, interference competition can reduce access to resources, and interference competition is not expected to affect all group members equally. In groups with dominance hierarchies, dominant individuals have priority access to resources and are therefore expected to experience lower costs of interference competition compared to subordinate individuals. Here, we assessed the effect of manipulating the number of feeders available with ad libitum food, which we assumed would affect competition intensity, on total daily feeder visits in a marked population of 126 black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ). As predicted, we found strong evidence of interference competition: reducing feeder availability by 50% reduced average per capita daily visits to feeders in our population by circa 50%. Because chickadee flocks exhibit linear dominance hierarchies, with males being dominant over females, and at least in some populations, adults being dominant over immatures, we also investigated whether there was evidence for sex‐ and/or age‐related differences in the strength of interference competition. We found that reductions in total daily feeder visits under lower manipulated food availability were similar for all age‐sex categories, suggesting that females and immatures did not experience higher interference competition despite their subordinate status relative to males and adults. Post hoc analyses revealed that adult females expanded their foraging area, while immature females increased both the length of the foraging window and foraging area when the availability of feeders was reduced. We suggest that these results may indicate that females invest more to mitigate competition and manage unpredictable access to food due to their subordinate status.
- Open Access
- 5 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (7) , e73946
Evidence of Small Changes in Daytime Body Temperature in Active Black‐Capped Chickadees in Response to Supplemental Food Availability
In winter, small birds may be able to reduce their energy expenditure by decreasing daytime body temperature ( T b ). While the use of reduced T b during the active‐phase is not well understood, one factor predicted to shape T b and heterothermy is food availability. We experimentally manipulated the presence of supplemental food at a bird feeder and monitored subcutaneous temperature ( T sub ) in 15 overwintering black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) during feeder visits to investigate whether food availability shapes daytime T sub . Chickadees had lower T sub when the ambient temperature was lower, and this effect was strongest when the feeder was empty. Diurnal patterns in T sub also varied as a function of food treatment; on days when the feeder was full, chickadees exhibited a mid‐afternoon peak in T sub , while on days when the feeder was empty, chickadees exhibited a mid‐morning minimum in T sub . Treatment‐related differences in diurnal T sub patterns and ambient temperature effects align with effects reported in earlier studies, though they are notably smaller in magnitude. We attribute the differences in effect sizes to the fact that our manipulations involved removal of supplemental food, rather than complete food deprivation, and that we measured T sub in active individuals. Although the observed effect sizes for T sub were small, this study is an important step toward understanding how access to a reliable food source during winter may shape energy management in small wintering birds. Future studies that obtain measures of T b outside of when individuals are actively foraging are needed to elucidate how food availability shapes the overall use of T b adjustments as an energy management strategy.
- 5 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (7) , e73946
Open AccessEvidence of Small Changes in Daytime Body Temperature in Active Black‐Capped Chickadees in Response to Supplemental Food Availability
In winter, small birds may be able to reduce their energy expenditure by decreasing daytime body temperature ( T b ). While the use of reduced T b during the active‐phase is not well understood, one factor predicted to shape T b and heterothermy is food availability. We experimentally manipulated the presence of supplemental food at a bird feeder and monitored subcutaneous temperature ( T sub ) in 15 overwintering black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) during feeder visits to investigate whether food availability shapes daytime T sub . Chickadees had lower T sub when the ambient temperature was lower, and this effect was strongest when the feeder was empty. Diurnal patterns in T sub also varied as a function of food treatment; on days when the feeder was full, chickadees exhibited a mid‐afternoon peak in T sub , while on days when the feeder was empty, chickadees exhibited a mid‐morning minimum in T sub . Treatment‐related differences in diurnal T sub patterns and ambient temperature effects align with effects reported in earlier studies, though they are notably smaller in magnitude. We attribute the differences in effect sizes to the fact that our manipulations involved removal of supplemental food, rather than complete food deprivation, and that we measured T sub in active individuals. Although the observed effect sizes for T sub were small, this study is an important step toward understanding how access to a reliable food source during winter may shape energy management in small wintering birds. Future studies that obtain measures of T b outside of when individuals are actively foraging are needed to elucidate how food availability shapes the overall use of T b adjustments as an energy management strategy.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Biological Reviews
- Vol. 101 (5) , 2337-2358
Trade‐offs in avian parental care: a review of theory and meta‐analysis of brood size manipulations
The selective forces shaping parental care have been studied for over 50 years. While theoretical and experimental work has yielded qualitative progress, the large body of empirical work testing predictions about parental investment based on life‐history trade‐offs has yet to be synthesized. We first provide an overview of the core life‐history theory exploring how selection might shape parental care. We then conduct a systematic review and meta‐analysis on studies that experimentally manipulated brood size in birds, a widely used experimental approach to manipulate parental investment. We extracted 313 estimates from 62 studies representing 31 species of birds from 19 different families and tested key predictions on trade‐offs in parental care derived from theory. Our analysis provides strong support for some predictions about life‐history trade‐offs in parental care, but weak or equivocal support for others. Specifically, we found that overall, avian parents respond to brood size manipulations as predicted by life‐history theory: they increased care in response to brood enlargement, and decreased care in response to brood reductions. Furthermore, for the same relative manipulation size, responses to brood reductions were greater than responses to brood enlargements. This finding is consistent with predictions derived from life‐history theory based on some types of non‐linear utility curves. However, many predictions derived from theory are not well supported by our comparative analysis. Species' life‐history traits such as clutch size (a measure of current reproduction), adult survival, and broods per year (two measures of future reproduction), explained little, if any, among‐species variation in response to brood size manipulations. Several factors may explain this. We highlight that brood size manipulations may affect more than just perception of the value of current reproduction, such as altering parents' perception of predation risk. Importantly, these unintended consequences could lead to asymmetric responses like those we observed. Other common experimental approaches – such as hormone manipulations, altering a partner's effort, and food supplementation – often affect multiple traits or fitness components simultaneously, or may involve cues that poorly match the evolved mechanisms guiding parental behaviour. Our review of both theory and experimental approaches suggests that there are multiple opportunities for more precise experiments. We offer several recommendations for effective designs. One is improved understanding of the biology underlying the functions relating to costs and benefits, with careful consideration of not only how the manipulation will affect only one of those, but also the mechanisms that might alter how parents perceive the manipulation. We also emphasize general principles, such as assessing alternative hypotheses and devising multiple independent tests. Armed with these recommendations, we believe there are new opportunities to increase the strength of inference achieved from studies aimed at understanding the trade‐offs affecting the evolution of parental care.
- 12 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Biological Reviews
- Vol. 101 (5) , 2337-2358
Open AccessTrade‐offs in avian parental care: a review of theory and meta‐analysis of brood size manipulations
The selective forces shaping parental care have been studied for over 50 years. While theoretical and experimental work has yielded qualitative progress, the large body of empirical work testing predictions about parental investment based on life‐history trade‐offs has yet to be synthesized. We first provide an overview of the core life‐history theory exploring how selection might shape parental care. We then conduct a systematic review and meta‐analysis on studies that experimentally manipulated brood size in birds, a widely used experimental approach to manipulate parental investment. We extracted 313 estimates from 62 studies representing 31 species of birds from 19 different families and tested key predictions on trade‐offs in parental care derived from theory. Our analysis provides strong support for some predictions about life‐history trade‐offs in parental care, but weak or equivocal support for others. Specifically, we found that overall, avian parents respond to brood size manipulations as predicted by life‐history theory: they increased care in response to brood enlargement, and decreased care in response to brood reductions. Furthermore, for the same relative manipulation size, responses to brood reductions were greater than responses to brood enlargements. This finding is consistent with predictions derived from life‐history theory based on some types of non‐linear utility curves. However, many predictions derived from theory are not well supported by our comparative analysis. Species' life‐history traits such as clutch size (a measure of current reproduction), adult survival, and broods per year (two measures of future reproduction), explained little, if any, among‐species variation in response to brood size manipulations. Several factors may explain this. We highlight that brood size manipulations may affect more than just perception of the value of current reproduction, such as altering parents' perception of predation risk. Importantly, these unintended consequences could lead to asymmetric responses like those we observed. Other common experimental approaches – such as hormone manipulations, altering a partner's effort, and food supplementation – often affect multiple traits or fitness components simultaneously, or may involve cues that poorly match the evolved mechanisms guiding parental behaviour. Our review of both theory and experimental approaches suggests that there are multiple opportunities for more precise experiments. We offer several recommendations for effective designs. One is improved understanding of the biology underlying the functions relating to costs and benefits, with careful consideration of not only how the manipulation will affect only one of those, but also the mechanisms that might alter how parents perceive the manipulation. We also emphasize general principles, such as assessing alternative hypotheses and devising multiple independent tests. Armed with these recommendations, we believe there are new opportunities to increase the strength of inference achieved from studies aimed at understanding the trade‐offs affecting the evolution of parental care.
- Open Access
- 23 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Avian Biology
- Vol. 2025 (6)
Temperature predictability and introduction history affect the expression of genes regulating DNA methylation in a globally distributed songbird
Phenotypic plasticity is a major mechanism whereby organisms adjust their traits within‐generations to changes in environmental conditions. In the context of range expansions, plasticity is thought to be especially important, as plastic changes in traits can lead to rapid adaptation. One epigenetic process in particular, DNA methylation, enables organisms to adjust gene expression contingent on the environment, which suggests it may play a role in range expansions. At present, we know little about how methylation is regulated in wildlife, especially expression of the enzymes responsible for altering methyl marks on the genome. In this study, we compared expression of three epigenetic regulator genes (DNA methyltransferase 1, DNMT1; DNA methyltransferase 3, DNMT3; and one ten‐eleven translocation methylcytosine dioxygenase, TET2) in three tissues (gut, liver, and spleen) of house sparrows Passer domesticus from nine countries. Some countries are in the native range of the species (Israel, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, and Vietnam) whereas others are sites the species has colonized in the last 150 years (i.e. Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Senegal). In this exploratory study, we asked whether non‐native birds and/or birds from sites with comparatively unpredictable climates would express different levels of these genes. We found that all three genes were expressed more in sparrows from the native range and from areas with more stable temperatures. Expression of all three genes was also strongly correlated among‐locations and within‐individuals, but mean expression was quite different among tissues. Many factors (e.g. urbanization of the capture site, sex of the bird) did not significantly affect gene expression, but others surprisingly did (e.g. latitude). Our results suggest that these enzymes could be important in range expansions or geographic distribution generally, but more detailed investigations will be insightful.
- 23 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Avian Biology
- Vol. 2025 (6)
Open AccessTemperature predictability and introduction history affect the expression of genes regulating DNA methylation in a globally distributed songbird
Phenotypic plasticity is a major mechanism whereby organisms adjust their traits within‐generations to changes in environmental conditions. In the context of range expansions, plasticity is thought to be especially important, as plastic changes in traits can lead to rapid adaptation. One epigenetic process in particular, DNA methylation, enables organisms to adjust gene expression contingent on the environment, which suggests it may play a role in range expansions. At present, we know little about how methylation is regulated in wildlife, especially expression of the enzymes responsible for altering methyl marks on the genome. In this study, we compared expression of three epigenetic regulator genes (DNA methyltransferase 1, DNMT1; DNA methyltransferase 3, DNMT3; and one ten‐eleven translocation methylcytosine dioxygenase, TET2) in three tissues (gut, liver, and spleen) of house sparrows Passer domesticus from nine countries. Some countries are in the native range of the species (Israel, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, and Vietnam) whereas others are sites the species has colonized in the last 150 years (i.e. Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Senegal). In this exploratory study, we asked whether non‐native birds and/or birds from sites with comparatively unpredictable climates would express different levels of these genes. We found that all three genes were expressed more in sparrows from the native range and from areas with more stable temperatures. Expression of all three genes was also strongly correlated among‐locations and within‐individuals, but mean expression was quite different among tissues. Many factors (e.g. urbanization of the capture site, sex of the bird) did not significantly affect gene expression, but others surprisingly did (e.g. latitude). Our results suggest that these enzymes could be important in range expansions or geographic distribution generally, but more detailed investigations will be insightful.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 229
An experimental test of seasonal and social influences on caching in black-capped chickadees, Poecile atricapillus
- 11 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 229
Open AccessAn experimental test of seasonal and social influences on caching in black-capped chickadees, Poecile atricapillus
- Open Access
- 17 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (8)
Individual Antipredator Responses Are Positively Correlated Across Cue Types in Free‐Living Black‐Capped Chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus )
Prey animals must accurately assess predation risk within their environment. To gather information about this risk, prey animals may personally sample the environment (“personal information”) or observe the behavior of congeners (“social information”). Personal information is thought to be more accurate and reliable but may also require more time and energy to acquire. On the other hand, social information, such as alarm calls, tends to be less costly to obtain but may also be less reliable if congeners assess risk differently from one another, or if the information quickly becomes outdated. Theoretical models predict that individuals will differ in how they value personal versus social information. We used previously collected data from a marked population of black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) to test this prediction. Chickadees were exposed to three different predator cue types: a predator mount (personal information), conspecific mobbing calls (social information), and a combination of both (personal + social information) near feeders established on their territory. We recorded the time it took a chickadee to visit a feeder following cue exposure (i.e., latency to resume feeding) to evaluate individual differences in response to predator cues. Contrary to our prediction, we found no evidence that individuals differed in how they valued personal versus social information about predation risk. Instead, our results suggest that responses to predator cues are state‐dependent, with some individuals consistently responding more strongly than others, regardless of cue type. We also found that when chickadees were exposed to a combination of social and personal predator cues, they exhibited higher among‐individual variation in latency to resume feeding than when they were exposed to social or personal cues alone. We discuss how individual differences in cue integration (i.e., cue redundancy/equivalence, enhancement, and antagonism) may account for this finding.
- 17 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (8)
Open AccessIndividual Antipredator Responses Are Positively Correlated Across Cue Types in Free‐Living Black‐Capped Chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus )
Prey animals must accurately assess predation risk within their environment. To gather information about this risk, prey animals may personally sample the environment (“personal information”) or observe the behavior of congeners (“social information”). Personal information is thought to be more accurate and reliable but may also require more time and energy to acquire. On the other hand, social information, such as alarm calls, tends to be less costly to obtain but may also be less reliable if congeners assess risk differently from one another, or if the information quickly becomes outdated. Theoretical models predict that individuals will differ in how they value personal versus social information. We used previously collected data from a marked population of black‐capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) to test this prediction. Chickadees were exposed to three different predator cue types: a predator mount (personal information), conspecific mobbing calls (social information), and a combination of both (personal + social information) near feeders established on their territory. We recorded the time it took a chickadee to visit a feeder following cue exposure (i.e., latency to resume feeding) to evaluate individual differences in response to predator cues. Contrary to our prediction, we found no evidence that individuals differed in how they valued personal versus social information about predation risk. Instead, our results suggest that responses to predator cues are state‐dependent, with some individuals consistently responding more strongly than others, regardless of cue type. We also found that when chickadees were exposed to a combination of social and personal predator cues, they exhibited higher among‐individual variation in latency to resume feeding than when they were exposed to social or personal cues alone. We discuss how individual differences in cue integration (i.e., cue redundancy/equivalence, enhancement, and antagonism) may account for this finding.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2025
- Published by Wiley
Sex-Specific Enemy Amplification, Not Release, in Introduced House Sparrows
Biological invasions disrupt ecosystems, economies, and disease transmission pathways, yet the mechanisms underlying invasion success remain debated. The Enemy Release Hypothesis (ERH) posits that non-native host populations thrive due to reduced pathogen pressure. While widely tested in plants and in vector-borne diseases, ERH remains understudied for enteric pathogens, which have generalist host ranges and are transmitted via faecal-oral and environmental routes. We examined the prevalence of two enteric bacteria, avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) and Salmonella enterica, in native and non-native house sparrows (Passer domesticus) from eight global populations (n = 200). We tested whether population status, sex, and urbanization influenced infection risk and examined effects on condition. Contrary to ERH, pathogen prevalence was not lower in non-native populations. Instead, we detected sex-specific amplification of infections: females from non-native populations had significantly higher odds of APEC infection than native females. Urbanization also disproportionately increased infection risk in females, highlighting sex-specific vulnerability. Infection had no measurable impact on condition, suggesting house sparrows may tolerate enteric infections, although differential mortality cannot be ruled out. These findings challenge the generality of ERH and suggest that successful invaders like house sparrows may persist by tolerating, rather than avoiding, pathogen exposure.
- 12 May 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessSex-Specific Enemy Amplification, Not Release, in Introduced House Sparrows
Biological invasions disrupt ecosystems, economies, and disease transmission pathways, yet the mechanisms underlying invasion success remain debated. The Enemy Release Hypothesis (ERH) posits that non-native host populations thrive due to reduced pathogen pressure. While widely tested in plants and in vector-borne diseases, ERH remains understudied for enteric pathogens, which have generalist host ranges and are transmitted via faecal-oral and environmental routes. We examined the prevalence of two enteric bacteria, avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) and Salmonella enterica, in native and non-native house sparrows (Passer domesticus) from eight global populations (n = 200). We tested whether population status, sex, and urbanization influenced infection risk and examined effects on condition. Contrary to ERH, pathogen prevalence was not lower in non-native populations. Instead, we detected sex-specific amplification of infections: females from non-native populations had significantly higher odds of APEC infection than native females. Urbanization also disproportionately increased infection risk in females, highlighting sex-specific vulnerability. Infection had no measurable impact on condition, suggesting house sparrows may tolerate enteric infections, although differential mortality cannot be ruled out. These findings challenge the generality of ERH and suggest that successful invaders like house sparrows may persist by tolerating, rather than avoiding, pathogen exposure.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (4) , 250180
Social information use increases with decreasing winter temperature in a passerine bird
Foragers can gain knowledge of profitable foraging opportunities either by sampling the environment directly (asocial information) or from congeners (social information). The relative benefit of using social information over asocial information is context-specific, and social information use is expected to be particularly beneficial when the costs of acquiring asocial information are high, for example, due to high risk of starvation if asocial information fails. We investigated the plasticity of social information use in an overwintering population of black-capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) as they rediscovered an intermittently available food source. Lower temperatures impose energetic costs that increase the risk of starvation in chickadees; therefore, lower temperatures are predicted to favour higher use of social information. To test this prediction, we evaluated chickadees’ reliance on social information during foraging as ambient temperatures ranged from −11.0°C to 5.5°C. We evaluated the relative strength of reliance on social and asocial information using network-based diffusion analysis. We found increased reliance on social information transmission with decreasing temperature. Reversible plasticity of social information use may be an important mechanism to cope with low ambient temperatures, a seasonal challenge experienced by many animals.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (4) , 250180
Open AccessSocial information use increases with decreasing winter temperature in a passerine bird
Foragers can gain knowledge of profitable foraging opportunities either by sampling the environment directly (asocial information) or from congeners (social information). The relative benefit of using social information over asocial information is context-specific, and social information use is expected to be particularly beneficial when the costs of acquiring asocial information are high, for example, due to high risk of starvation if asocial information fails. We investigated the plasticity of social information use in an overwintering population of black-capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) as they rediscovered an intermittently available food source. Lower temperatures impose energetic costs that increase the risk of starvation in chickadees; therefore, lower temperatures are predicted to favour higher use of social information. To test this prediction, we evaluated chickadees’ reliance on social information during foraging as ambient temperatures ranged from −11.0°C to 5.5°C. We evaluated the relative strength of reliance on social and asocial information using network-based diffusion analysis. We found increased reliance on social information transmission with decreasing temperature. Reversible plasticity of social information use may be an important mechanism to cope with low ambient temperatures, a seasonal challenge experienced by many animals.