WCWerner Ceusters

Werner Ceusters

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Werner Ceusters has a total of 237 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Towards Representing Change in the BFO

    by Werner Ceusters, Alan Ruttenberg

    The Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) is an upper ontology that embraces both continuants and occurrents. Continuants can persist through time while undergoing changes through their participation in processes. Processes are held not to change as they are said to be changes. Yet, the BFO is silent about what sorts of changes might exist: history is the only type that is subsumed by process. Although representing and tracking instance data by means of the BFO’s time-indexed relations allows one to infer that some change must have happened in the portion of reality described by the data, change is not explicitly represented. When a change exists, there must be a change of something. However, when the color of that flower (a quality inhering in, but distinct from, that flower) instantiates red at one time, and brown at a later time, then that change, alone, is not a process under the current definitions and axioms of the BFO. This is because qualities can participate in a process p, but never by itself: p must have a material entity as participant. Furthermore, processes can only have other processes and process boundaries as parts; if the BFO would accept the change of qualities, or specifically dependent continuants in general, as occurrents, though not processes, then such change cannot be occurrent-part-of a process. In this paper we explore the basis of a theory, and the beginnings of an axiomatization thereof, as an extension to the BFO that recognizes change as a subtype of occurrent so that instances thereof happen-in processes and happen-to continuants whereby these continuants participate in the processes these changes happen-in. We anticipate re-expressing the ideas presented here as axioms expressed in terms of processes and participation in a future revision of the BFO-FOL axioms that currently prevent a tighter integration.


  • Open Access

    Semantic Difficulties in FHIR ‘Conditions’

    by Werner Ceusters, Michael Rabenberg

    One goal of the Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR) standard is to prevent semantic ambiguities when patient data are electronically exchanged. To assess whether the FHIR specifications live up to this expectation, we examined FHIR’s Condition resource thereby focusing on the resource elements ‘clinical status’ and ‘verification status’ when used in combination. We found that the definitions for these elements, as well as of several of their allowed values, suffer from the following semantic difficulties: the use of disjunctive descriptions, the presence of pseudo-synonyms lacking clear explanation of what distinctions FHIR has in mind, and insufficient discrimination between evidence and what such evidence would be about.


  • Open Access

    Fiat Surfaces in the Basic Formal Ontology

    by Michael Rabenberg, Werner Ceusters

    The Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) class continuant fiat boundary and its subclasses, including fiat surface, are not heavily axiomatized; they have elucidations, not definitions; and the meanings of these elucidations are poorly captured by the relevant BFO axioms. This paper is an effort to make progress in these respects for fiat surface. We identify a range of desiderata for a BFO-conformant view of fiat surface, argue that the GitHub does not satisfy them, argue that the view of fiat surfaces in Arp et al. (2015) does a better job, and supplement that view in ways that do a still better job. Our discussion allows us to, inter alia, present a number of axioms relevant to our topic worthy of consideration for inclusion in BFO or dependent ontologies in specific domains and for specific purposes.


  • Open Access

    Setting the Scene to Link SNOMED CT to Realism-Based Ontologies

    by Anuwat Pengput, Werner Ceusters

    In a proof of concept study, we assessed the feasibility of designing a first-order logic (FOL) framework capable of translating SNOMED CT's terminological view on patient data as referencing concepts, into the realism-based view of the Basic Formal Ontology and the Ontology for General Medical Science according to which patient data represent instances of types. Because within the subject domain of this study, SNOMED CT's terminological coverage was excellent, and its EL++ axioms can be automatically translated into FOL as well as the antecedent part of bridging axioms between SNOMED CT and realism-based ontologies, we conclude that this is an area of R&D that deserves further attention and that may lead to new ways of federating terminologies with ontologies.


  • Open Access

    Axiomatizing SNOMED CT Disorders: Should There Be Room for Interpretation?

    by Werner Ceusters, Anuwat Pengput

    SNOMED CT is a large concept-based terminology designed according to epistemic, semantic and pragmatic principles relevant to clinicians. Its goal is structured clinical reporting in electronic healthcare records (EHRs). The Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) is an ontology designed on the basis of types claimed to exist in reality based on a domain-independent ontological theory. Its goal is faithful representation of reality within that theory. The Ontology for General Medical Science (OGMS) extends the BFO by providing definitions for types relevant within the clinical domain. Combining SNOMED CT with the ontological rigor of BFO and OGMS might improve clinical reporting by, f.i., preventing data entry mistakes and inconsistencies, and make EHRs more comparable. To that end, we are developing a logical framework capable of exploiting what SNOMED CT offers terminologically and realism-based ontologies such as the BFO and the OGMS ontologically by means of bridging axioms compatible with the BFO, and expressed in the same CLIF-dialect as used in its axiomatization in first order logic. In this paper, we report on our attempts to detect in the combinations of binary relations that are used in the definition of SNOMED CT’s definitions of disorder concepts patterns which might at least partially automate the construction of such axioms. Our findings suggest that this partial automation is indeed possible, but to a smaller extent than we had hoped for. We compare our approach with a recent proposal that seeks to bring SNOMED CT and BFO closer together by reinterpreting SNOMED CT disorders as clinical occurrents. The proposal has its merit in providing a realist underpinning for that part of SNOMED CT’s concept model in terms of the BFO, but is not discriminatory enough for an automatic translation into OGMS. Key problem is the lack of face validity of SNOMED CT disorder terms as compared to the formal definitions they are given and this in absence of textual definitions.


    • 1 January 2023
      • Vol. 3603, 25-35
    Open Access

    An Extendible Realism-Based Ontology for Kinship

    by Michael Rabenberg, Anuwat Pengput, Werner Ceusters

    Adequately representing kinship relations is crucial for a variety of medical and biomedical applications. Several kinship ontologies have been proposed but none of them have been designed thus far in line with the Basic Formal Ontology. In this paper, we propose a novel kinship ontology that exhibits the following characteristics: (1) it is fully axiomatized in First Order Logic following the rules governing predicate formation as proposed in BFO2020-FOL, (2) it is modularized in 6 separate files written in the Common Logic Interface Format (CLIF) each one of which can be imported based on specific needs, (3) it provides bridging axioms to and from SNOMED CT, and (4) it contains an extra module with axioms which would not be literally true when phrased naively but are crafted in such a way that they highlight the unusual kinship relations they represent and can be used to generate alerts on possible data entry mistakes. We describe design considerations and challenges encountered.

  • Open Access

    The place of Referent Tracking in Biomedical Informatics

    by Werner Ceusters

    Terminological systems, including coding and classification systems, are used in electronic medical record systems to facilitate the interpretation of structured data by providing terms and codes with a relatively precise meaning. When a clinician selects a term or code from such system and enters it in the medical record of a patient, then, from an ontological perspective and as a consequence of how ter-minological systems are currently integrated in electronic medical record systems, an assertion has been made to the effect that the patient exhibits, or exhibited, some phenomenon of type T. It is however left unspecified which phenomenon in particular is of the designated type T. In other words: such records contain explic-it references, i.e. the terms or codes, but the referents of these references are not explicitly identified! Because referents can be referenced in many different ways, types used as references can be about many referents, and referents may change so they become of a different type, data analytics application which rely on types only are prone to drawing erroneous conclusions. Referent Tracking is a method-ology for data management which allows assertions only to be made with explicit reference to the referents they are about. This chapter offers an introduction to the principles upon which the methodology rests and how these principles can be applied to improve the quality of the problem list in medical records.


  • Open Access

    Expanding Evolutionary Terminology Auditing with Historic Formal and Linguistic Intensions: A Case Study in SNOMED CT

    by Ceusters Werner, Mullin Sarah

    A method is described to use SNOMED CT's history mechanism as a means to compute how the formal and linguistic intensions of its concepts change over versions. As a result of this, it is demonstrated that the intended principle of concept permanence is not always adhered to. It is shown that the evolution of formal intensions can be monitored fully automatically and that the proposed procedure includes a method to suggest missing subsumers in a concept's transitive closure set by identifying mistakes that have been made in the past. Changes in linguistic intensions were found to be much more labor-intensive to identify. It is suggested that this could be improved if the history mechanism would come with more detailed motivations for change than the current and insufficiently used annotation to the effect that a fully specified name 'fails to comply with the current editorial guidance'.


  • Open Access

    Caveats for the Use of the Active Problem List as Ground Truth for Decision Support

    by Ceusters Werner, Blaisure Jonathan

    Diagnoses recorded on the problem list are increasingly being used for decision support applications. To obtain insight in the adequacy of the clinical user interface to capture what the clinician has in mind, and to reconstruct the clinical reality of the patient, we analyzed in the database of an EHR system the transactions that resulted from managing the problem list. Our findings indicate (1) that caution is required when using the evolution of the problem list for determining comorbidity or ongoing disease, and (2) that similarities or differences in problem list annotation sequences do not always correspond with similarities resp. differences in disease courses. It is to be investigated whether automatically identifiable subsets of problem list evolution patterns exist from which ground truth reliably can be inferred or whether clinicians need more education in how problem list user interfaces should be used to avoid erroneous interpretations by clinical decision support applications.