Bernhard S. A. Schuberth
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Bernhard S. A. Schuberth has a total of 60 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Christophe Zaroli
6 shared publications- Gabriel Robl
Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, LMU Munich, Germany
6 shared publications - Christine Thomas
Institut für Geophysik Universität Münster Münster Germany
5 shared publications Hans-Peter Bunge
Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, LMU Munich, Germany
5 shared publicationsIsabel Papanagnou
5 shared publications- Roman Freissler
Geophysics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München 1 Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences Theresienstr. 41, München 80333
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
TERRA-NG v1.0: Extreme-Scale, GPU-accelerated Mantle Convection
We present TERRA-NG, a portable, GPU-accelerated, matrix-free mantle-convection code. A single Kokkos C++ implementation runs at scale on NVIDIA, AMD, and Intel GPU supercomputers. TERRA-NG has a deliberately narrow design: built on a radially extruded mesh of spherical wedges, tailored to the spherical shell geometry, which enables domain-specific optimizations like single quadrature-point integral-evaluations, radial coordinate storage compression and radial shared-memory tiling. The corresponding low-order W1-iso-W2/W1 wedge-based Stokes--energy discretisation is verified against the Zhong et al.(2008) spherical-shell convection benchmark suite. We showcase TERRA-NG through strong- and weak-scaling on the JUWELS Booster (NVIDIA A100), MareNostrum 5 (NVIDIA H100), LUMI-G (AMD MI250X), Hunter (AMD MI300A APU), and SuperMUC-NG Phase 2 (Intel PVC) supercomputers. Coupled mantle convection simulations at ∼11 km and ∼5.6 km radial spacing (∼2.8 B and ∼22 B DoFs) can be run routinely on standard node partitions of all considered systems. Global ∼1 km-per-gridpoint mantle convection (∼1.4 T DoFs) is feasible on an extreme-scale allocation, and a sub-km hero-run at ∼0.7 km grid spacing scaling up to ∼11,000 GPUs of LUMI-G (∼11 T DoFs) shows the potential of the code on future, larger machines.
- 26 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
Open AccessTERRA-NG v1.0: Extreme-Scale, GPU-accelerated Mantle Convection
We present TERRA-NG, a portable, GPU-accelerated, matrix-free mantle-convection code. A single Kokkos C++ implementation runs at scale on NVIDIA, AMD, and Intel GPU supercomputers. TERRA-NG has a deliberately narrow design: built on a radially extruded mesh of spherical wedges, tailored to the spherical shell geometry, which enables domain-specific optimizations like single quadrature-point integral-evaluations, radial coordinate storage compression and radial shared-memory tiling. The corresponding low-order W1-iso-W2/W1 wedge-based Stokes--energy discretisation is verified against the Zhong et al.(2008) spherical-shell convection benchmark suite. We showcase TERRA-NG through strong- and weak-scaling on the JUWELS Booster (NVIDIA A100), MareNostrum 5 (NVIDIA H100), LUMI-G (AMD MI250X), Hunter (AMD MI300A APU), and SuperMUC-NG Phase 2 (Intel PVC) supercomputers. Coupled mantle convection simulations at ∼11 km and ∼5.6 km radial spacing (∼2.8 B and ∼22 B DoFs) can be run routinely on standard node partitions of all considered systems. Global ∼1 km-per-gridpoint mantle convection (∼1.4 T DoFs) is feasible on an extreme-scale allocation, and a sub-km hero-run at ∼0.7 km grid spacing scaling up to ∼11,000 GPUs of LUMI-G (∼11 T DoFs) shows the potential of the code on future, larger machines.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 246 (3)
Constraining mantle viscosity using dynamic topography, the geoid, and seismic heterogeneity from high-resolution mantle circulation models
Mantle viscosity remains one of the largest outstanding uncertainties in global geodynamics. Time-dependent mantle circulation models that assimilate tectonic histories (MCMs) provide a way to test viscosity by assessing their present-day predictions against observations. This approach allows for the influence of viscosity on mantle density structure to be accounted for, which is not possible using instantaneous modelling approaches. Here we present the first systematic test of lower mantle viscosity against dynamic topography, the geoid, and seismic heterogeneity using high-resolution MCMs. Model density structure depends strongly on the assumed viscosity profile, which in turn controls the fit to seismic heterogeneity. The fit to dynamic topography and the geoid is further influenced by the instantaneous transmission of stresses to the surface. These two effects can either reinforce or counteract each other at different depths, which must be considered when attempting to match dynamic topography and geoid amplitudes. MCMs typically overestimate dynamic topography amplitudes. We find that it is possible to reduce these amplitudes by lowering viscosity in the upper lower mantle (≈660-2000 km), though this comes at the expense of a reduced fit to the geoid and/or seismic heterogeneity. Our preferred viscosity profile provides an excellent fit to observed geoid amplitudes and the seismic heterogeneity of S40RTS. We also tested an alternate tectonic reconstruction with tomography-based refinements around the Pacific which improved the correlation with the observed geoid by ≈20%. Our results show that MCMs can now reach a level of resolution and realism sufficient for comparison to multiple independent data sets, opening the door to systematic assessment of uncertain parameters which govern convection in the mantle.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 246 (3)
Open AccessConstraining mantle viscosity using dynamic topography, the geoid, and seismic heterogeneity from high-resolution mantle circulation models
Mantle viscosity remains one of the largest outstanding uncertainties in global geodynamics. Time-dependent mantle circulation models that assimilate tectonic histories (MCMs) provide a way to test viscosity by assessing their present-day predictions against observations. This approach allows for the influence of viscosity on mantle density structure to be accounted for, which is not possible using instantaneous modelling approaches. Here we present the first systematic test of lower mantle viscosity against dynamic topography, the geoid, and seismic heterogeneity using high-resolution MCMs. Model density structure depends strongly on the assumed viscosity profile, which in turn controls the fit to seismic heterogeneity. The fit to dynamic topography and the geoid is further influenced by the instantaneous transmission of stresses to the surface. These two effects can either reinforce or counteract each other at different depths, which must be considered when attempting to match dynamic topography and geoid amplitudes. MCMs typically overestimate dynamic topography amplitudes. We find that it is possible to reduce these amplitudes by lowering viscosity in the upper lower mantle (≈660-2000 km), though this comes at the expense of a reduced fit to the geoid and/or seismic heterogeneity. Our preferred viscosity profile provides an excellent fit to observed geoid amplitudes and the seismic heterogeneity of S40RTS. We also tested an alternate tectonic reconstruction with tomography-based refinements around the Pacific which improved the correlation with the observed geoid by ≈20%. Our results show that MCMs can now reach a level of resolution and realism sufficient for comparison to multiple independent data sets, opening the door to systematic assessment of uncertain parameters which govern convection in the mantle.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Mantle temperatures from global seismic models: Uncertainties and limitations
Many geophysical studies require knowledge on the present-day temperature distribution in Earth’s mantle, which can be estimated from seismic velocity perturbations imaged by tomography in combination with thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy. However, even in the case of (assumed) known chemical composition, both the seismic and the mineralogical information are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty. We investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the thermal state of the mantle from tomographic models in a synthetic closed-loop experiment and quantify the interplay of tomographically damped and blurred seismic heterogeneity in combination with different approximations for the mineralogical conversion from seismic velocities to temperature. Our results highlight that, given the limitations of tomography and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models deviate significantly from the true state. The average deviations from the reference model are on the order of 50–100 K in the upper mantle and can increase with depth to values of up to 200 K, depending on the resolving capabilities of the respective tomography. Furthermore, large systematic errors exist in the vicinity of phase transitions due to the associated mineralogical complexities. When used to constrain buoyancy forces in time-dependent geodynamic simulations, errors in the temperature field might grow non-linearly due to the chaotic nature of mantle flow. This could be particularly problematic in combination with advanced implementations of compressibility, in which densities are extracted from thermodynamic mineralogical models with temperature-dependent phase assemblages. Erroneous temperatures in this case might activate ‘wrong’ phase transitions and potentially flip the sign of the associated Clapeyron slopes, thereby considerably altering the model evolution. Overall, the strategy to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be selected carefully to minimize the influence of the collective set of uncertainties.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMantle temperatures from global seismic models: Uncertainties and limitations
Many geophysical studies require knowledge on the present-day temperature distribution in Earth’s mantle, which can be estimated from seismic velocity perturbations imaged by tomography in combination with thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy. However, even in the case of (assumed) known chemical composition, both the seismic and the mineralogical information are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty. We investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the thermal state of the mantle from tomographic models in a synthetic closed-loop experiment and quantify the interplay of tomographically damped and blurred seismic heterogeneity in combination with different approximations for the mineralogical conversion from seismic velocities to temperature. Our results highlight that, given the limitations of tomography and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models deviate significantly from the true state. The average deviations from the reference model are on the order of 50–100 K in the upper mantle and can increase with depth to values of up to 200 K, depending on the resolving capabilities of the respective tomography. Furthermore, large systematic errors exist in the vicinity of phase transitions due to the associated mineralogical complexities. When used to constrain buoyancy forces in time-dependent geodynamic simulations, errors in the temperature field might grow non-linearly due to the chaotic nature of mantle flow. This could be particularly problematic in combination with advanced implementations of compressibility, in which densities are extracted from thermodynamic mineralogical models with temperature-dependent phase assemblages. Erroneous temperatures in this case might activate ‘wrong’ phase transitions and potentially flip the sign of the associated Clapeyron slopes, thereby considerably altering the model evolution. Overall, the strategy to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be selected carefully to minimize the influence of the collective set of uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Constraining deep mantle thermal evolution by linking geodynamic modelling, absolute plate motions and normal mode seismology
The frequency of geomagnetic field reversals varies on time scales of tens of millions of years, reflecting mantle-controlled changes in outer core flow that sustains the geodynamo. Accurate knowledge of lateral heat flow variations across the core–mantle boundary (CMB) and their evolution over geologic time is therefore fundamental to understanding the long-term geodynamo behaviour.Here, we aim at generating robust predictions of lower mantle thermal evolution based on compressible high-resolution mantle circulation models (MCM). By assimilating 410 million years of plate motion history, which coincides roughly with two mantle overturns, the time span of geologically-informed structure above the CMB covers the Cretaceous normal superchron and beyond. To estimate uncertainties in lower mantle thermal evolution, we will employ systematic variations of model parameters, with a focus on uncertainties in the underlying absolute plate motion reference frame. Appraisal of the MCMs will be performed by predicting seismic data that can be compared to observations. Long-period normal mode data are particularly suited in this context, as they provide global constraints. In addition, splitting functions show high sensitivity to variations in the absolute reference frame. The realistic histories of mantle thermal evolution and CMB heat flux that we aim for in this project can in future be linked to geodynamo models and thus be used to predict time-series of Earth's magnetic field behaviour.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessConstraining deep mantle thermal evolution by linking geodynamic modelling, absolute plate motions and normal mode seismology
The frequency of geomagnetic field reversals varies on time scales of tens of millions of years, reflecting mantle-controlled changes in outer core flow that sustains the geodynamo. Accurate knowledge of lateral heat flow variations across the core–mantle boundary (CMB) and their evolution over geologic time is therefore fundamental to understanding the long-term geodynamo behaviour.Here, we aim at generating robust predictions of lower mantle thermal evolution based on compressible high-resolution mantle circulation models (MCM). By assimilating 410 million years of plate motion history, which coincides roughly with two mantle overturns, the time span of geologically-informed structure above the CMB covers the Cretaceous normal superchron and beyond. To estimate uncertainties in lower mantle thermal evolution, we will employ systematic variations of model parameters, with a focus on uncertainties in the underlying absolute plate motion reference frame. Appraisal of the MCMs will be performed by predicting seismic data that can be compared to observations. Long-period normal mode data are particularly suited in this context, as they provide global constraints. In addition, splitting functions show high sensitivity to variations in the absolute reference frame. The realistic histories of mantle thermal evolution and CMB heat flux that we aim for in this project can in future be linked to geodynamo models and thus be used to predict time-series of Earth's magnetic field behaviour.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
On the role of tomographic resolution and uncertainty in reconstructing past mantle flow
Tomographic images play a crucial role in estimating the thermodynamic state of Earth's mantle, yet reliable quantification of their uncertainties is essential for drawing robust conclusions in geodynamics. In particular, reconstructions of past mantle flow that rely on tomographic inputs require a practical handling of the difference in spatial scales between predictions from fluid dynamics and the heterogeneities observable through seismology. This scale discrepancy can indeed already be addressed through so-called tomographic filtering as a post-processing step applied to standard forward models of mantle circulation. However, integrating such approaches technically into adjoint or inverse modeling frameworks—used in data-driven mantle flow reconstructions—remains to be thoroughly explored.Here, we perform a fully synthetic experiment to highlight the difficulties in quantitatively linking tomographic images with geodynamic models. Specifically, we employ the Subtractive Optimally Localized Averages (SOLA) method—a linear Backus–Gilbert-type inversion technique—to image a reference mantle circulation model. The SOLA inversions are based on finite-frequency traveltime residuals derived from full-waveform numerical seismograms computed for the geodynamic reference model.Drawing on the insights provided by this synthetic experiment, we propose a workflow for adjoint-based mantle flow reconstructions that aims to leverage the tools provided by the SOLA approach. For the tomographic component, this involves generating spatially optimized averaging kernels that characterize local resolution (i.e. the specific tomographic filter), along with rigorous uncertainty estimates for parameter averages obtained by the propagation of data errors (both being built-in features of SOLA). On the geodynamic side, one should first aim to incorporate measures of tomographic resolution directly into the misfit/cost function of the adjoint method. This step is critical because the adjoint model validation compares observed surface dynamic topography in time with its prediction from the reconstructed flow history, which is highly sensitive to the tomographic input. Once resolution-related biases are factored in, small model ensembles should make it possible to practically account for stochastic uncertainties, eventually yielding more robust constraints on mantle flow history. We suggest that the success of a specific misfit function and the realization of model ensembles can be assessed with dedicated synthetic closed-loop experiments, prior to their actual application.Overall, our results offer practical guidance towards a strategy that integrates the complete tomographic information, including resolution and uncertainty, into fully operational reconstructions of past mantle flow.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessOn the role of tomographic resolution and uncertainty in reconstructing past mantle flow
Tomographic images play a crucial role in estimating the thermodynamic state of Earth's mantle, yet reliable quantification of their uncertainties is essential for drawing robust conclusions in geodynamics. In particular, reconstructions of past mantle flow that rely on tomographic inputs require a practical handling of the difference in spatial scales between predictions from fluid dynamics and the heterogeneities observable through seismology. This scale discrepancy can indeed already be addressed through so-called tomographic filtering as a post-processing step applied to standard forward models of mantle circulation. However, integrating such approaches technically into adjoint or inverse modeling frameworks—used in data-driven mantle flow reconstructions—remains to be thoroughly explored.Here, we perform a fully synthetic experiment to highlight the difficulties in quantitatively linking tomographic images with geodynamic models. Specifically, we employ the Subtractive Optimally Localized Averages (SOLA) method—a linear Backus–Gilbert-type inversion technique—to image a reference mantle circulation model. The SOLA inversions are based on finite-frequency traveltime residuals derived from full-waveform numerical seismograms computed for the geodynamic reference model.Drawing on the insights provided by this synthetic experiment, we propose a workflow for adjoint-based mantle flow reconstructions that aims to leverage the tools provided by the SOLA approach. For the tomographic component, this involves generating spatially optimized averaging kernels that characterize local resolution (i.e. the specific tomographic filter), along with rigorous uncertainty estimates for parameter averages obtained by the propagation of data errors (both being built-in features of SOLA). On the geodynamic side, one should first aim to incorporate measures of tomographic resolution directly into the misfit/cost function of the adjoint method. This step is critical because the adjoint model validation compares observed surface dynamic topography in time with its prediction from the reconstructed flow history, which is highly sensitive to the tomographic input. Once resolution-related biases are factored in, small model ensembles should make it possible to practically account for stochastic uncertainties, eventually yielding more robust constraints on mantle flow history. We suggest that the success of a specific misfit function and the realization of model ensembles can be assessed with dedicated synthetic closed-loop experiments, prior to their actual application.Overall, our results offer practical guidance towards a strategy that integrates the complete tomographic information, including resolution and uncertainty, into fully operational reconstructions of past mantle flow.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Matrix-free, robust linear solvers for realistic, large scale, high-contrast forward mantle convection simulations
In order to accurately capture the physics of mantle convection, nonlinear, compressible flow models and high resolution numerical simulations are required. The viscosity inside the Earth's mantle exhibits strong gradients and in general depends on the pressure, temperature and strain rate, leading to numerically challenging high-contrast problems. Since the parameters governing geophysical models for mantle convection are often fraught with uncertainties, a major goal is to solve inverse problems (usually facilitated via the adjoint method), which require computationally expensive feedback loops. These requirements put a significant emphasis on the development of robust, iterative solvers for the associated linear systems and a highly scalable, parallel implementation usable on distributed memory HPC systems. Additionally, the prohibitive memory requirements of matrix assembly necessitate a matrix-free approach in order to make high resolution models feasible.In this talk, we employ the finite element framework HyTeG that has successfully been applied to problems with 10^12 unknowns and consider two compressible forward mantle convection models, respectively with the truncated anelastic liquid approximation (TALA) and projected density approximation (PDA). The models feature high-contrast temperature-dependent viscosities together with realistic plate motion reconstructions as boundary conditions at Earth's surface. For the PDA model, we also consider the take-up and release of the latent heat that occurs at mineral phase boundaries by means of effective thermal expansivity and effective specific heat capacity stored on high-resolution lookup tables precomputed with a thermodynamics framework.For the TALA model, as presented in [Burkhart et al. 2026], we consider the quasi-stationary Stokes system coupled with a time dependent advection diffusion equation, solved in a Gauss-Seidel like alternating fashion as part of a semi implicit scheme. To handle the advection dominated energy conservation equation we use a novel operator splitting approach, combining the BDF2 method with a particle method, resulting in an overall second order time discretisation. Due to handling the compressibility term implicitly (in contrast to a frozen velocity approach) the Stokes system admits an asymmetrical generalised saddle point problem, which we solve by the application of an outer FMGRES solver loop combined with an Uzawa type block precondtioner. As part of the block preconditioner we use geometric multigrid approaches and a new kind of BFBT type Schur complement approximation.Due to the high contrast in thermal expansivity and specific heat capacity along mineral phase transitions, we discuss adaptations of this solving strategy for the PDA model and aim for a comparison with the entropy formulation introduced in [Dannberg et al. 2022].
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMatrix-free, robust linear solvers for realistic, large scale, high-contrast forward mantle convection simulations
In order to accurately capture the physics of mantle convection, nonlinear, compressible flow models and high resolution numerical simulations are required. The viscosity inside the Earth's mantle exhibits strong gradients and in general depends on the pressure, temperature and strain rate, leading to numerically challenging high-contrast problems. Since the parameters governing geophysical models for mantle convection are often fraught with uncertainties, a major goal is to solve inverse problems (usually facilitated via the adjoint method), which require computationally expensive feedback loops. These requirements put a significant emphasis on the development of robust, iterative solvers for the associated linear systems and a highly scalable, parallel implementation usable on distributed memory HPC systems. Additionally, the prohibitive memory requirements of matrix assembly necessitate a matrix-free approach in order to make high resolution models feasible.In this talk, we employ the finite element framework HyTeG that has successfully been applied to problems with 10^12 unknowns and consider two compressible forward mantle convection models, respectively with the truncated anelastic liquid approximation (TALA) and projected density approximation (PDA). The models feature high-contrast temperature-dependent viscosities together with realistic plate motion reconstructions as boundary conditions at Earth's surface. For the PDA model, we also consider the take-up and release of the latent heat that occurs at mineral phase boundaries by means of effective thermal expansivity and effective specific heat capacity stored on high-resolution lookup tables precomputed with a thermodynamics framework.For the TALA model, as presented in [Burkhart et al. 2026], we consider the quasi-stationary Stokes system coupled with a time dependent advection diffusion equation, solved in a Gauss-Seidel like alternating fashion as part of a semi implicit scheme. To handle the advection dominated energy conservation equation we use a novel operator splitting approach, combining the BDF2 method with a particle method, resulting in an overall second order time discretisation. Due to handling the compressibility term implicitly (in contrast to a frozen velocity approach) the Stokes system admits an asymmetrical generalised saddle point problem, which we solve by the application of an outer FMGRES solver loop combined with an Uzawa type block precondtioner. As part of the block preconditioner we use geometric multigrid approaches and a new kind of BFBT type Schur complement approximation.Due to the high contrast in thermal expansivity and specific heat capacity along mineral phase transitions, we discuss adaptations of this solving strategy for the PDA model and aim for a comparison with the entropy formulation introduced in [Dannberg et al. 2022].
- Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
- Vol. 482 (2331)
Towards integrating tomographic resolution and uncertainty information into geodynamic mantle flow reconstructions
For reconstructing mantle flow back in geologic time, geodynamic inversions require input from seismology in the form of tomographic images. However, a practical representation of image uncertainty is needed for robust inferences. Addressing the scale discrepancy between fluid dynamic predictions and seismically visible heterogeneity is crucial, since the subsequent validation of mantle flow trajectories involves surface dynamic topography predictions that are highly sensitive to the tomographic input. Here, we conduct a synthetic experiment to illustrate the challenges in quantitatively integrating tomographic and geodynamic models, using a linear tomographic framework, the subtractive optimally localized averages (SOLA) method and a mantle circulation model (MCM) as reference. We propose a possible workflow for adjoint flow reconstructions that aims to leverage the capabilities of the SOLA method. This includes the construction of tomographic averaging kernels that can be spatially optimized and which define local resolution, together with model averages and their uncertainties. For the geodynamic adjoint framework, we suggest incorporating the SOLA estimates in the cost function and testing the implementation of specific tomographic realizations in closed-loop experiments. We stress that only after accounting for the effects of resolution, an ensemble approach for uncertainty quantification can provide meaningful constraints on the flow history.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
- Vol. 482 (2331)
Open AccessTowards integrating tomographic resolution and uncertainty information into geodynamic mantle flow reconstructions
For reconstructing mantle flow back in geologic time, geodynamic inversions require input from seismology in the form of tomographic images. However, a practical representation of image uncertainty is needed for robust inferences. Addressing the scale discrepancy between fluid dynamic predictions and seismically visible heterogeneity is crucial, since the subsequent validation of mantle flow trajectories involves surface dynamic topography predictions that are highly sensitive to the tomographic input. Here, we conduct a synthetic experiment to illustrate the challenges in quantitatively integrating tomographic and geodynamic models, using a linear tomographic framework, the subtractive optimally localized averages (SOLA) method and a mantle circulation model (MCM) as reference. We propose a possible workflow for adjoint flow reconstructions that aims to leverage the capabilities of the SOLA method. This includes the construction of tomographic averaging kernels that can be spatially optimized and which define local resolution, together with model averages and their uncertainties. For the geodynamic adjoint framework, we suggest incorporating the SOLA estimates in the cost function and testing the implementation of specific tomographic realizations in closed-loop experiments. We stress that only after accounting for the effects of resolution, an ensemble approach for uncertainty quantification can provide meaningful constraints on the flow history.
- Open Access
- 8 April 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 241 (3) , 2003-2027
From seismic models to mantle temperatures: Uncertainties related to mineralogical complexities and limited tomographic resolution
SUMMARY: Many geophysical studies require knowledge on the present-day temperature distribution in Earth’s mantle. One example is geodynamic inverse models, which utilize data assimilation techniques to reconstruct mantle flow back in time. The thermal state of the mantle can be estimated from seismic velocity perturbations imaged by tomography with the help of thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy. Unique interpretations of the tomographically imaged seismic heterogeneity can either be obtained by incorporating additional data sets or requires assumptions on the chemical composition of the mantle. However, even in the case of (assumed) known chemical composition, both the seismic and the mineralogical information are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty.Here, we investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the thermal state of the mantle from tomographic models in a synthetic closed-loop experiment. The ‘true’ temperature distribution of the mantle is taken from a 3-D mantle circulation model with Earth-like convective vigour. We aim to recover this reference model after: (1) mineralogical mapping from the ‘true’ temperatures to seismic velocities, (2) application of a tomographic filter to mimic the effect of limited seismic resolution, and (3) mapping of the ‘imaged’ seismic velocities back to temperatures. We test and quantify the interplay of tomographically damped and blurred seismic heterogeneity in combination with different approximations for the mineralogical ‘inverse’ conversion from seismic velocities to temperature. Owing to imperfect knowledge of the parameters governing mineral anelasticity, we additionally investigate the effects of over- or underestimating the corresponding correction to the underlying mineralogical model. Our results highlight that, given the current limitations of seismic tomography and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models deviate significantly from the true state, even in the idealized case of known bulk chemical composition. The average deviations from the reference model are on the order of 50–100 K in the upper mantle and depending on the resolving capabilities of the respective tomography—can increase with depth throughout the lower mantle to values of up to 200 K close to the core–mantle boundary. Furthermore, large systematic errors exist in the vicinity of phase transitions due to the associated mineralogical complexities. When used to constrain buoyancy forces in time-dependent geodynamic simulations, errors in the temperature field might grow nonlinearly due to the chaotic nature of mantle flow. This could be particularly problematic in combination with advanced implementations of compressibility, in which densities are extracted from thermodynamic mineralogical models with temperature-dependent phase assemblages. Erroneous temperatures in this case might activate ‘wrong’ phase transitions and potentially flip the sign of the associated Clapeyron slopes, thereby considerably altering the model evolution. Additional testing is required to evaluate the behaviour of different compressibility formulations in geodynamic inverse problems. Overall, the strategy to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be selected carefully to minimize the influence of the collective set of uncertainties.
- 8 April 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 241 (3) , 2003-2027
Open AccessFrom seismic models to mantle temperatures: Uncertainties related to mineralogical complexities and limited tomographic resolution
SUMMARY: Many geophysical studies require knowledge on the present-day temperature distribution in Earth’s mantle. One example is geodynamic inverse models, which utilize data assimilation techniques to reconstruct mantle flow back in time. The thermal state of the mantle can be estimated from seismic velocity perturbations imaged by tomography with the help of thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy. Unique interpretations of the tomographically imaged seismic heterogeneity can either be obtained by incorporating additional data sets or requires assumptions on the chemical composition of the mantle. However, even in the case of (assumed) known chemical composition, both the seismic and the mineralogical information are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty.Here, we investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the thermal state of the mantle from tomographic models in a synthetic closed-loop experiment. The ‘true’ temperature distribution of the mantle is taken from a 3-D mantle circulation model with Earth-like convective vigour. We aim to recover this reference model after: (1) mineralogical mapping from the ‘true’ temperatures to seismic velocities, (2) application of a tomographic filter to mimic the effect of limited seismic resolution, and (3) mapping of the ‘imaged’ seismic velocities back to temperatures. We test and quantify the interplay of tomographically damped and blurred seismic heterogeneity in combination with different approximations for the mineralogical ‘inverse’ conversion from seismic velocities to temperature. Owing to imperfect knowledge of the parameters governing mineral anelasticity, we additionally investigate the effects of over- or underestimating the corresponding correction to the underlying mineralogical model. Our results highlight that, given the current limitations of seismic tomography and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models deviate significantly from the true state, even in the idealized case of known bulk chemical composition. The average deviations from the reference model are on the order of 50–100 K in the upper mantle and depending on the resolving capabilities of the respective tomography—can increase with depth throughout the lower mantle to values of up to 200 K close to the core–mantle boundary. Furthermore, large systematic errors exist in the vicinity of phase transitions due to the associated mineralogical complexities. When used to constrain buoyancy forces in time-dependent geodynamic simulations, errors in the temperature field might grow nonlinearly due to the chaotic nature of mantle flow. This could be particularly problematic in combination with advanced implementations of compressibility, in which densities are extracted from thermodynamic mineralogical models with temperature-dependent phase assemblages. Erroneous temperatures in this case might activate ‘wrong’ phase transitions and potentially flip the sign of the associated Clapeyron slopes, thereby considerably altering the model evolution. Additional testing is required to evaluate the behaviour of different compressibility formulations in geodynamic inverse problems. Overall, the strategy to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be selected carefully to minimize the influence of the collective set of uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Geodynamic-mineralogical predictions of mantle transition zone seismic structure
A main objective in geodynamics is to create models that provide quantitative information to other Earth science disciplines. In order to assess the validity of the underlying assumptions and chosen input parameters related to different geodynamic hypotheses, it is crucial to test these models against observations. In this, thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy represent an essential tool. On the one hand, they enable the linking of temperature fields from mantle circulation models (MCMs) to seismic observations. On the other hand, they provide critical information on material behaviour in response to changing temperature and pressure conditions that occur over time within such mantle convection simulations. Some of the most interesting aspects in this context relate to mineral phase transitions and associated dynamic effects on mantle flow.The mantle transition zone (TZ) in particular is expected to influence vertical mass flow between upper and lower mantle as it hosts a complex set of mineral phase transitions as well as an increase in viscosity with depth. Still, neither its seismic structure nor the associated dynamic effects have conclusively been constrained. The seismic discontinuities at around 410 and 660 km depth (‘410’ and ‘660’) have classically been related to phase transitions between olivine polymorphs, the pressure of which is modulated by lateral temperature variations. The resulting topography of these discontinuities is seismically visible and can thus potentially provide insight on temperature and phase composition at depth. Besides the olivine phase changes, the disassociation of garnet may additionally impact the 660 at higher temperatures. However, the volume of material affected by this garnet transition and its dynamic implications have not yet been quantified.Here, we present hypothetical realizations of TZ seismic structure and major discontinuities based on the 3-D temperature field of a published MCM for a range of relevant mineralogies, including pyrolite and mechanical mixtures (MM). Systematic analysis of these models provides a framework for dynamically informed interpretations of seismic observations and gives insights into the potential dynamic behaviour of the TZ. Using our geodynamic-mineralogical approach we can identify which phase transitions induce specific topographic features of 410 and 660 and quantify their relative impact. Areal proportions of the garnet transition at the 660 are ∼3 and ∼1 per cent for pyrolite and MM, respectively. This proportion could be significantly higher (up to ∼39 per cent) in a hotter mantle for pyrolite, but remains low (< 2 per cent) for MM. In pyrolite, both slabs and plumes are found to depress the 660 —with average deflections of 14 and 6 km, respectively— due to the influence of garnet at high temperatures indicating its complex dynamic effects on mantle upwellings. Pronounced differences in model characteristics for pyrolite and MM, particularly their relative garnet proportions and associated topography features, could serve to discriminate between the two scenarios in Earth.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessGeodynamic-mineralogical predictions of mantle transition zone seismic structure
A main objective in geodynamics is to create models that provide quantitative information to other Earth science disciplines. In order to assess the validity of the underlying assumptions and chosen input parameters related to different geodynamic hypotheses, it is crucial to test these models against observations. In this, thermodynamic models of mantle mineralogy represent an essential tool. On the one hand, they enable the linking of temperature fields from mantle circulation models (MCMs) to seismic observations. On the other hand, they provide critical information on material behaviour in response to changing temperature and pressure conditions that occur over time within such mantle convection simulations. Some of the most interesting aspects in this context relate to mineral phase transitions and associated dynamic effects on mantle flow.The mantle transition zone (TZ) in particular is expected to influence vertical mass flow between upper and lower mantle as it hosts a complex set of mineral phase transitions as well as an increase in viscosity with depth. Still, neither its seismic structure nor the associated dynamic effects have conclusively been constrained. The seismic discontinuities at around 410 and 660 km depth (‘410’ and ‘660’) have classically been related to phase transitions between olivine polymorphs, the pressure of which is modulated by lateral temperature variations. The resulting topography of these discontinuities is seismically visible and can thus potentially provide insight on temperature and phase composition at depth. Besides the olivine phase changes, the disassociation of garnet may additionally impact the 660 at higher temperatures. However, the volume of material affected by this garnet transition and its dynamic implications have not yet been quantified.Here, we present hypothetical realizations of TZ seismic structure and major discontinuities based on the 3-D temperature field of a published MCM for a range of relevant mineralogies, including pyrolite and mechanical mixtures (MM). Systematic analysis of these models provides a framework for dynamically informed interpretations of seismic observations and gives insights into the potential dynamic behaviour of the TZ. Using our geodynamic-mineralogical approach we can identify which phase transitions induce specific topographic features of 410 and 660 and quantify their relative impact. Areal proportions of the garnet transition at the 660 are ∼3 and ∼1 per cent for pyrolite and MM, respectively. This proportion could be significantly higher (up to ∼39 per cent) in a hotter mantle for pyrolite, but remains low (< 2 per cent) for MM. In pyrolite, both slabs and plumes are found to depress the 660 —with average deflections of 14 and 6 km, respectively— due to the influence of garnet at high temperatures indicating its complex dynamic effects on mantle upwellings. Pronounced differences in model characteristics for pyrolite and MM, particularly their relative garnet proportions and associated topography features, could serve to discriminate between the two scenarios in Earth.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Deriving mantle temperatures from global seismic models: A quantitative analysis in the light of uncertain mineralogy and limited tomographic resolution
Mantle convection is driven by buoyancy forces in Earth’s interior. The resulting radial stresses generate vertical deflections of the surface, leaving traces in the geological record. Utilizing new data assimilation techniques, geodynamic inverse models of mantle flow can provide theoretical estimates of these surface processes, which can be tested against geological observations. These inverse models are emerging as powerful tools, providing the potential for tighter constraints on the relevant physical parameters governing mantle flow.The geodynamic inversions mentioned above require an estimate of the present-day thermal state of the mantle, which can be derived from seismic observations. Using thermodynamically self-consistent models of mantle mineralogy, it is possible to convert the seismic structure imaged by global tomographic models to temperature. However, both seismic and mineralogical models are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty. In addition, owing to the complexity of the mineralogical models, the relation between temperature and seismic velocities is highly non-linear and not strictly bijective: In the presence of phase transitions, different temperatures can result in the same seismic velocity, making the conversion from seismic heterogeneity to thermal structure non-unique.We investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the present-day thermal state of the mantle based on tomographic models in the case of isochemical convection. The temperature distribution from a 3-D mantle circulation model with earth-like convective vigour serves as the “true” temperature field. Using a closed-loop experiment, we aim to recover this initial model after: 1) mineralogical mapping from the “true” temperatures to seismic velocities, 2) application of a tomographic filter to mimic the effect of limited tomographic resolution, and 3) mapping of the “imaged” seismic velocities back to temperatures. We test and quantify the interplay of smoothed seismic structure due to tomographic filtering with different approximations for the conversion from seismic to thermal structure. Additionally, owing to imperfect knowledge of the parameters governing mineral anelasticity, we test the effects of changes to the anelastic correction applied in the mineralogical mapping. The observed mismatch between the recovered and initial temperature field is dominated by the effect of tomographic filtering, with a depth-dependent average error of up to 200 K. Additionally, we observe systematic large errors in the vicinity of phase transitions. Our results highlight that, given the current limitations of tomographic models and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models will deviate significantly from the true state, even under the assumption of purely thermally driven mantle flow. Strategies to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be carefully selected to minimize additional uncertainties.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessDeriving mantle temperatures from global seismic models: A quantitative analysis in the light of uncertain mineralogy and limited tomographic resolution
Mantle convection is driven by buoyancy forces in Earth’s interior. The resulting radial stresses generate vertical deflections of the surface, leaving traces in the geological record. Utilizing new data assimilation techniques, geodynamic inverse models of mantle flow can provide theoretical estimates of these surface processes, which can be tested against geological observations. These inverse models are emerging as powerful tools, providing the potential for tighter constraints on the relevant physical parameters governing mantle flow.The geodynamic inversions mentioned above require an estimate of the present-day thermal state of the mantle, which can be derived from seismic observations. Using thermodynamically self-consistent models of mantle mineralogy, it is possible to convert the seismic structure imaged by global tomographic models to temperature. However, both seismic and mineralogical models are significantly affected by inherent limitations and different sources of uncertainty. In addition, owing to the complexity of the mineralogical models, the relation between temperature and seismic velocities is highly non-linear and not strictly bijective: In the presence of phase transitions, different temperatures can result in the same seismic velocity, making the conversion from seismic heterogeneity to thermal structure non-unique.We investigate the theoretical ability to estimate the present-day thermal state of the mantle based on tomographic models in the case of isochemical convection. The temperature distribution from a 3-D mantle circulation model with earth-like convective vigour serves as the “true” temperature field. Using a closed-loop experiment, we aim to recover this initial model after: 1) mineralogical mapping from the “true” temperatures to seismic velocities, 2) application of a tomographic filter to mimic the effect of limited tomographic resolution, and 3) mapping of the “imaged” seismic velocities back to temperatures. We test and quantify the interplay of smoothed seismic structure due to tomographic filtering with different approximations for the conversion from seismic to thermal structure. Additionally, owing to imperfect knowledge of the parameters governing mineral anelasticity, we test the effects of changes to the anelastic correction applied in the mineralogical mapping. The observed mismatch between the recovered and initial temperature field is dominated by the effect of tomographic filtering, with a depth-dependent average error of up to 200 K. Additionally, we observe systematic large errors in the vicinity of phase transitions. Our results highlight that, given the current limitations of tomographic models and the incomplete knowledge of mantle mineralogy, magnitudes and spatial scales of a temperature field obtained from global seismic models will deviate significantly from the true state, even under the assumption of purely thermally driven mantle flow. Strategies to estimate the present-day thermodynamic state of the mantle must be carefully selected to minimize additional uncertainties.