Emmanuel Garbolino has a total of 345 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Prevailing European light regimes are mismatched with conditions for high plant diversity

    by Wanben Wu, Jens-Christian Svenning, Sean E. H. Pang, Jonathan Lenoir, Jürgen Dengler, Jesper Moeslund, Zvjezdana Stančić, Grzegorz Swacha, Koenraad Van Meerbeek, Idoia Biurrun, et al.

    Light is a key driver of plant performance and community assembly, yet whether contemporary landscapes provide the light regimes associated with high diversity remains unclear. Here, we integrate more than 650,000 vegetation plots, 14,835 species-specific light indicator values from Ecological Indicator Values for Europe, and Earth observation data to assess relationships between near-ground light regimes and plant diversity across Europe, using separate plot subsets for light modelling and biodiversity analyses. Full models incorporating light regimes increase cross-validated R² by 27.4–34.5% at the landscape scale, relative to models containing climatic, edaphic and sampling-effort covariates alone. Our results reveal a pronounced landscape-scale mismatch between prevailing light regimes and those associated with high predicted plant diversity in contemporary Europe. Across three Hill numbers, light-regime conditions associated with the highest predicted plant diversity occurred across only 5.4–8.3% of European natural and semi-natural areas, indicating that these high-diversity light conditions are uncommon in contemporary landscape, whereas prevailing regimes were generally darker and more homogeneous. These findings call for greater attention to light regimes in efforts to restore plant diversity across Europe, with a focus on restoring relatively open vegetation and spatially heterogeneous near-ground light environments.

  • Open Access

    Light regimes organize plant diversity across spatial scales

    by Wanben Wu, Jens-Christian Svenning, Sean E. H. Pang, Jonathan Lenoir, Jürgen Dengler, Jesper Erenskjold Moeslund, Zvjezdana Stančić, Grzegorz Swacha, Koenraad Van Meerbeek, Idoia Biurrun, et al.

    Light regulates ecological processes from organism performance to ecosystem functioning, yet its role in shaping plant diversity across spatial scales remains unresolved. Here, we combine > 650,000 vegetation plots, 14,835 species-specific light indicator values based on Ecological Indicator Values for Europe (EIVE), and Earth observation data to provide the first pan-European assessment of how light regimes near the ground shape plant diversity across scales. Incorporating light-regime metrics beyond macroclimatic and edaphic drivers improved predictions of plant diversity, with relative increases in explained variance of 3% and 27.4–34.5% at the local and landscape scale, respectively. Plant diversity peaked under intermediate-to-high light availability coupled with high spatial heterogeneity. Strikingly, at the landscape level, we identified a pronounced mismatch between the light regimes currently prevailing across Europe and those associated with high plant diversity. Together, these findings reveal light regime as a fundamental axis for plant biodiversity and suggest that widespread shifts towards very low light availability and reduced spatial heterogeneity may decrease plant diversity across Europe. Maintaining non-shaded or increasing spatial heterogeneity in light conditions near the ground could therefore help reduce this mismatch, expanding the extent of light regimes with high potential to support plant diversity.

  • Open Access

    Disturbance regimes drive widespread plant range disequilibrium in Europe alongside climate change

    by Sean E. H. Pang, Robert Buitenwerf, Oliver Baines, Svetlana Aćić, Markus Bernhardt-Römermann, Idoia Biurrun, Gianmaria Bonari, Hans Henrik Bruun, Chaeho Byun, Eduardo Chacón-Madrigal, et al.

    Species distributions often fail to match climatically suitable areas, resulting in range disequilibrium. Although recent studies have focused on mismatches arising from lags in biotic responses to climate change (for example, extinction and colonization lags), disturbance processes may also determine whether species occupy otherwise climatically suitable areas, for example, by altering vegetation structure and light regimes. Here we assess climate-change and disturbance-driven disequilibrium for 3,047 vascular plant species across Europe using species distribution models and >1.1 million vegetation plots. Almost all species (99%) show disturbance-driven disequilibrium, revealing mismatches that are strongly structured along disturbance gradients, consistent with alternative vegetation states. We identified disequilibrium associated with recent climate change in 52% of species, with ranges best predicted by climates 10–18 years before sampling and most pronounced among closed-canopy species, probably reflecting under-canopy microclimatic buffering. These findings demonstrate that climate change and disturbance jointly shape widespread disequilibrium in European plant distributions, with disturbance regimes strongly structuring the realization of climatic suitability across contemporary landscapes. Accounting for both disturbance regimes and temporal lags in climate response is therefore essential for improving biodiversity forecasts and guiding conservation strategies.


  • Open Access

    Plant adaptive strategies respond to environmental change across European grassland habitats

    by Xiao‐Peng Tan, Petr Pyšek, Milan Chytrý, Irena Axmanová, Jan Divíšek, Ilona Knollová, Svetlana Aćić, Idoia Biurrun, Hans Henrik Bruun, Jürgen Dengler, et al.

    Grassland ecosystems are facing rapid and ongoing change driven by intensified land‐use and accelerated climate change, highlighting the urgent need to understand their potential adaptation and response to environmental change. We analyzed data from 52 980 vegetation plots spanning all major grassland habitats in Europe (including alpine, rocky, sandy, saline, dry, mesic and wet grasslands). We quantified competitive (C), stress‐tolerant (S), and ruderal (R) strategies for 7858 plant species based on key functional traits and mapped the spatial patterns of C‐, S‐ and R‐strategies across European grasslands. Using random forest models, we evaluated the relative importance of environmental factors in shaping these patterns and explored potential changes in the distribution of C‐, S‐ and R‐strategies under future climate scenarios. We further investigated how these strategies and their environmental drivers vary across grassland habitats. Our results revealed a clear biogeographical gradient in the distribution of C‐, S‐ and R‐strategies from predominantly stress‐tolerant strategies in Mediterranean grasslands to greater representation of competitive and ruderal strategies in temperate regions. Climate and soil factors emerged as major drivers shaping these patterns at the continental scale. Projected responses to future climate change varied among regions: grasslands in the Atlantic and Continental regions were projected to decrease in C‐strategy and increase in both S‐ and R‐strategy representation, whereas grasslands in Arctic and boreal regions exhibited contrasting trends. Mediterranean grasslands were projected to undergo a transition from mainly R‐strategy toward S‐strategy species predominance. Furthermore, the strategy patterns and their key drivers differed among grassland habitats, with patterns largely reflecting habitat‐specific environmental constraints. This study demonstrates the utility of Grime's CSR framework for characterizing broad‐scale patterns of plant adaptive strategies across diverse grassland habitats. It highlights region‐ and habitat‐specific differences in potential responses to future climate change, with implications for targeted grassland management and restoration.


  • Open Access

    Ecological niches and biogeography of nitrogen‐fixing plants in Europe

    by N. Fahs, I. Axmanová, J.‐C. Svenning, T. Těšitelová, J. Padullés Cubino, I. Biurrun, J. A. Campos, J. Dengler, E. Garbolino, J. Těšitel

    Symbiotic nitrogen fixation by vascular plants represents a major pathway for nitrogen input in terrestrial ecosystems, fundamentally altering nutrient cycles and plant community dynamics. Nitrogen‐fixing plants comprise phylogenetically and physiologically distinct lineages whose ecological niches and responses to environmental gradients remain poorly resolved at continental scales. We investigated the geographic distribution and ecological responses of major nitrogen‐fixing lineages across Europe, focusing on legumes (inverted repeat lacking clade [IRLC], characterised by high symbiont regulation ability, and non‐IRLC) and actinorhizal genera. We analysed 707,673 vegetation plots (1970–2021) from the European Vegetation Archive to map lineage density at 30‐km resolution, assess habitat associations, model climatic drivers and evaluate distributions along environmental gradients using ecological indicator values. Non‐IRLC legumes predominated in Mediterranean scrublands and dry grasslands, whereas IRLC legumes extended into northern regions and mesic grasslands. Legumes were associated with high diurnal temperature range, high summer temperatures, low summer rainfall and low soil nitrogen and water availability—patterns pronounced in non‐IRLC legumes, but less distinct or even absent in IRLC legumes. Actinorhizal lineages showed disparate habitat associations and contrasting climatic responses, with temperature seasonality as the strongest predictor—positive for Alnus and Elaeagnaceae and negative for the other lineages. Our findings demonstrate fundamentally divergent ecological niches among European nitrogen‐fixing lineages, reflecting distinct evolutionary histories and physiological strategies. Enhanced symbiont regulation in IRLC legumes likely facilitates persistence where the benefits of nitrogen fixation are limited. Despite sharing a common adaptive trait, nitrogen‐fixing lineages have evolved different strategies to colonise various environments under diverse climatic conditions.

  • Open Access

    Habitat-specific trends in taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic diversity in European plant communities over a century

    by Stephan Kambach, Ute Jandt, Alicia Teresa Rosario Acosta, Jose Manuel Álvarez-Martínez, Irena Axmanová, Manuele Bazzichetto, Erwin Bergmeier, Markus Bernhardt-Römermann, Idoia Biurrun, Gianmaria Bonari, et al.

    Despite widespread concern over global biodiversity loss, the balance between gains and losses within local plant communities remains contentious, largely due to a scarcity of integrative, long-term and large-scale analyses across different habitats and multiple facets of biodiversity. Here, we analyse 57,390 vegetation-plot time series of vascular plants across Europe to quantify the average and habitat-specific trends in taxonomic, functional, phylogenetic, and gamma diversity, alongside with changes in threatened Red List, non-native, and specialist versus generalist species. We find that, over the last 100 years, plant communities gained on average 0.7% in vegetation cover and 0.2% in species number per year, associated with gains in functional and phylogenetic diversity, non-native, Red List, and generalist species. Diversity changes are most pronounced in mire and wetland communities. Differences among habitat types and habitat-change trajectory (stable, successional, disturbed), together with the most recent observation year, explain 2.1%–36.6% of the variation in diversity trends. Habitat-specific gamma diversity showed no general trends and only increased in stable grasslands and successional sparsely vegetated habitats. By integrating habitat types and change trajectories, we reconcile some of the conflicting narratives on local biodiversity change in favour of a more nuanced understanding of the observed variation in local biodiversity change.


  • Open Access

    Sixty years of plant community change in Europe indicate a shift toward nutrient-richer and denser vegetation

    by Gabriele Midolo, Adam Thomas Clark, Milan Chytrý, Franz Essl, Stefan Dullinger, Ute Jandt, Helge Bruelheide, Jürgen Dengler, Irena Axmanová, Svetlana Aćić, et al.

    Anthropogenic impacts are reshaping plant biodiversity patterns, yet how community-composition shifts track environmental change at large spatial and temporal scales remains unclear. Here, we quantified trends in community-mean plant ecological indicator values (light, temperature, soil moisture, soil nitrogen, and soil reaction) across European vegetation between 1960 and 2020. We used spatiotemporal interpolation based on 644,524 plots and analyzed 18,345 time series encompassing diverse habitats. We found a clear shift in community composition over the past six decades with a steep increase in nitrogen-demanding species across all main habitat types, accompanied by a moderate increase in shade-tolerant species. Forest communities shifted toward species associated with higher soil pH, while wetland communities showed a decline in moisture-dependent species over time. Conversely, temperature indicator values were largely stable, except for recent thermophilization in alpine habitats. Our results indicate a widespread trend toward denser vegetation driven by eutrophication and changes in management practices.


  • Open Access

    Six Decades of Losses and Gains in Alpha Diversity of European Plant Communities

    by Gabriele Midolo, Adam Thomas Clark, Milan Chytrý, Franz Essl, Stefan Dullinger, Ute Jandt, Helge Bruelheide, Olivier Argagnon, Idoia Biurrun, Alessandro Chiarucci, et al.

    Biodiversity change forecasts rely on long‐term time series, but such data are often scarce in space and time. Here, we interpolated spatiotemporal changes in species richness using a new method based on machine learning that does not require temporal replication at sites. Using 698,692 one‐time sampled vegetation plots, we estimated trends in vascular plant alpha diversity across Europe and validated our approach against 22,852 independent time series. We found an overall near‐zero net change in species richness between 1960 and 2020. However, species richness generally declined from 1960 to 1980 and increased from 2000 to 2020 across habitats. Declines were most pronounced in forests, but trends varied across habitats and regions, with overall increases at higher latitudes and elevations, and declines or stable trends elsewhere. Our findings demonstrate how data without temporal replication can be used to reveal context‐dependent biodiversity dynamics, underscoring their importance for conservation and management.


  • Open Access

    Representativeness of the Natura 2000 network for preserving plant biodiversity in the European Union

    by Michele Di Musciano, Piero Zannini, Riccardo Testolin, Francesco Maria Sabatini, Diletta Santovito, Borja Jiménez‐Alfaro, Florian Jansen, Milan Chytrý, Lorenzo Ricci, Emiliano Agrillo, et al.

    The Natura 2000 (N2K) network of protected areas is one of the main tools for area‐based conservation in the European Union (EU), yet its role in preserving plant biodiversity requires better understanding. We examined data kept in the European Vegetation Archive from over 1.2 million vegetation plots and obtained over 14.2 million plant species occurrences. To test the N2K network's representativeness of plant species gamma diversity, we compared the number and percentage of native and conservation priority species in‐ and outside the N2K network throughout the EU and for individual countries, biogeographical regions, and combinations thereof. We then determined whether N2K sites hosted more species than sites outside the network with the species–area relationship. Overall, almost 90% of the native vascular plant species occurred at least once in the N2K network. Yet, significant variation exists across countries and biogeographical regions—from 0% of species in the Boreal region of Lithuania, to 98% in the Alpine region of Croatia—indicating that local N2K sites are not equally representative of the regional gamma diversity. Nonetheless, the N2K network contains more species than land outside the network when area is taken into account. The planned expansion of the N2K network, as mandated by the European Biodiversity Strategy for 2030, should prioritize areas with currently underrepresented elements of the EU vascular flora.


  • Open Access

    Parasitic plants in Europe: ecological niches and spatial patterns

    by N. Fahs, I. Axmanová, J.‐C. Svenning, J. Padullés Cubino, I. Biurrun, S. Boch, J. A. Campos, A. Čarni, J. Dengler, E. Garbolino, et al.

    Parasitic plants inhabit a wide range of ecosystems worldwide, where they may have critical roles as “ecosystem engineers”. We examined the ecology of parasitic plants in Europe. We aimed to identify habitat preferences, spatial distribution, and environmental drivers of parasitic plant functional types: euphytoid hemiparasites, obligate root parasites, and parasitic vines, and assess individual species' ecological niches. We analysed 244 parasitic plant species in a dataset of 819,452 vegetation plots across European natural vegetation. We used a boosted regression tree model to assess the effects of macro‐climate, topography, and habitat descriptors (open, wet, saline) on the distribution of parasitic plant functional types. We analysed their distribution along the gradients of ecological indicator values. Finally, we determined the niches of individual species along all the environmental gradients. Parasitic plants occur across Europe and in nearly all habitats. Euphytoid hemiparasites (173 species) are most abundant in colder environments with moderate to high precipitation and low precipitation seasonality. In contrast, obligate root parasites (52 species) and parasitic vines (12 species) are primarily associated with warm‐temperate to Mediterranean dry climates. All three functional types prefer nutrient‐poor to moderately rich conditions. Some species diverge from the trend of their functional type. The spatial distribution and niches of parasitic plant functional types correspond to their fundamental physiological properties, including mode of resource acquisition and level of photosynthesis. Euphytoid hemiparasites are likely to be negatively affected by climate warming, while obligate root parasites and parasitic vines might benefit from future warmer and drier climates.