Karen M. Stegers-Jager
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Karen M. Stegers-Jager has a total of 69 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Axel P N Themmen
Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam, Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
9 shared publications- Andrea M. Woltman
Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam, Erasmus MC University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Rotterdam, the Netherlands
8 shared publications - Marise Ph. Born
Department of Psychology, Education and Child Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
7 shared publications - Suzanne Fikrat-Wevers
Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam, Erasmus MC, University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
5 shared publications - Walter. W. Van Den Broek
Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam, Erasmus MC University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Rotterdam, the Netherlands
5 shared publications - Chantal E. E. van Andel
Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam Erasmus MC Rotterdam the Netherlands
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
Beyond a single ideal: An appreciative inquiry into students' perspectives on workplace‐based assessment during clerkships
Introduction: Workplace‐based assessments (WBAs) are central to evaluating clinical performance in clerkships, yet their design and implementation remain challenging. One major challenge is that WBAs inevitably rely on subjective human judgement. However, little is known about how undergraduate students perceive subjectivity in assessment and what they consider trustworthy assessment practices. We therefore explored undergraduate medical students' perceptions of WBAs during clerkships, using a strengths‐based approach to envision an ideal WBA system. Methods: We organised six focus groups ( N = 24) guided by Appreciative Inquiry. Focus group discussions focused on memorable assessment experiences, underlying values, desired changes and visions of an ideal system. We used Reflexive Thematic Analysis within a constructionist paradigm through iterative coding, thematic mapping, analytic memos and team discussions to ensure rigour and reflexivity. Results: Three themes represent foundational conditions for an ideal WBA system: (1) Being seen , acknowledging students as individuals through personalised feedback; (2) Growth , conceptualising WBAs as a longitudinal process supporting learning and career exploration; and (3) Feeling safe , emphasising a meaningful dialogue and a culture of trust. A fourth theme, Balancing ideals , captured the inherent tensions between competing ideals. Importantly, students perceived assessment as trustworthy not when subjectivity was eliminated but when it was considered accountable and conducive to fair outcomes. Discussion: Our findings suggest that trustworthy WBA systems are best understood as sets of deliberate compromises, negotiated in ongoing dialogue with students and assessors, rather than one‐size‐fits‐all frameworks. By adopting a strengths‐based approach, this study reframes familiar assessment concepts as conditions for enabling trust, rather than as solutions to deficits. These findings advance our understanding of how to embed subjectivity into WBAs in a trustworthy manner and offer a student‐informed approach for strengthening WBAs design in undergraduate medical education.
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
Open AccessBeyond a single ideal: An appreciative inquiry into students' perspectives on workplace‐based assessment during clerkships
Introduction: Workplace‐based assessments (WBAs) are central to evaluating clinical performance in clerkships, yet their design and implementation remain challenging. One major challenge is that WBAs inevitably rely on subjective human judgement. However, little is known about how undergraduate students perceive subjectivity in assessment and what they consider trustworthy assessment practices. We therefore explored undergraduate medical students' perceptions of WBAs during clerkships, using a strengths‐based approach to envision an ideal WBA system. Methods: We organised six focus groups ( N = 24) guided by Appreciative Inquiry. Focus group discussions focused on memorable assessment experiences, underlying values, desired changes and visions of an ideal system. We used Reflexive Thematic Analysis within a constructionist paradigm through iterative coding, thematic mapping, analytic memos and team discussions to ensure rigour and reflexivity. Results: Three themes represent foundational conditions for an ideal WBA system: (1) Being seen , acknowledging students as individuals through personalised feedback; (2) Growth , conceptualising WBAs as a longitudinal process supporting learning and career exploration; and (3) Feeling safe , emphasising a meaningful dialogue and a culture of trust. A fourth theme, Balancing ideals , captured the inherent tensions between competing ideals. Importantly, students perceived assessment as trustworthy not when subjectivity was eliminated but when it was considered accountable and conducive to fair outcomes. Discussion: Our findings suggest that trustworthy WBA systems are best understood as sets of deliberate compromises, negotiated in ongoing dialogue with students and assessors, rather than one‐size‐fits‐all frameworks. By adopting a strengths‐based approach, this study reframes familiar assessment concepts as conditions for enabling trust, rather than as solutions to deficits. These findings advance our understanding of how to embed subjectivity into WBAs in a trustworthy manner and offer a student‐informed approach for strengthening WBAs design in undergraduate medical education.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 17 (6) , 698-700
Extend or Fast-Track Medical Training Based on Competencies Acquired Through Personal Illness?
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 17 (6) , 698-700
Extend or Fast-Track Medical Training Based on Competencies Acquired Through Personal Illness?
- Open Access
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 14 (1) , 991-1002
Adjustment of Assessors’ First Impressions Differs by Student Ethnicity
Introduction: Ethnic minority medical students often receive lower grades than their majority counterparts, especially in workplace-based assessments. To unravel this phenomenon of “differential attainment”, we explore assessor bias focusing on how first impressions of students from ethnic minority groups may be adjusted differently compared to majority students when their performance changes. Methods: In an online experiment with an incomplete block design we created near-identical videos showcasing varying performances of medical students during history-taking. Eighty-one physicians were randomly assigned to watch four different videos each, two with ascending performances (poor start, good ending) and two with descending performances (good start, poor ending), featuring one ethnic minority actress (Turkish or Moroccan origin) and one ethnic majority actress (Dutch origin) as students. We evaluated ethnicity-related differences in first impression ratings (after 60 seconds), final ratings (after 5 minutes), and rating changes. Results: No significant differences in first impression ratings were found between ethnic groups. Ethnic minority students received higher final ratings than ethnic majority students for ascending performances, but only when rated by residents and not specialists. Finally, rating changes between first impressions and final ratings were larger for ethnic minority than ethnic majority students, for both ascending and descending performances. Discussion: Our results do not show evidence of assessor bias in first impressions being an explanation for ethnicity-related differential attainment. However, our finding that rating changes were larger for minority than majority students could indicate that they are generally more scrutinized by assessors, which may affect them positively, but also negatively.
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 14 (1) , 991-1002
Open AccessAdjustment of Assessors’ First Impressions Differs by Student Ethnicity
Introduction: Ethnic minority medical students often receive lower grades than their majority counterparts, especially in workplace-based assessments. To unravel this phenomenon of “differential attainment”, we explore assessor bias focusing on how first impressions of students from ethnic minority groups may be adjusted differently compared to majority students when their performance changes. Methods: In an online experiment with an incomplete block design we created near-identical videos showcasing varying performances of medical students during history-taking. Eighty-one physicians were randomly assigned to watch four different videos each, two with ascending performances (poor start, good ending) and two with descending performances (good start, poor ending), featuring one ethnic minority actress (Turkish or Moroccan origin) and one ethnic majority actress (Dutch origin) as students. We evaluated ethnicity-related differences in first impression ratings (after 60 seconds), final ratings (after 5 minutes), and rating changes. Results: No significant differences in first impression ratings were found between ethnic groups. Ethnic minority students received higher final ratings than ethnic majority students for ascending performances, but only when rated by residents and not specialists. Finally, rating changes between first impressions and final ratings were larger for ethnic minority than ethnic majority students, for both ascending and descending performances. Discussion: Our results do not show evidence of assessor bias in first impressions being an explanation for ethnicity-related differential attainment. However, our finding that rating changes were larger for minority than majority students could indicate that they are generally more scrutinized by assessors, which may affect them positively, but also negatively.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 13 (1) , 423-430
Widening the Gates: Redefining Excellence in Selection for Health Professions Education for a Diverse Future Workforce
Perspectives on Medical Education’s mission is to support and enrich collaborative scholarship between education researchers and clinical educators, and to advance new knowledge regarding clinical education practices. The journal is the official journal of the The Netherlands Association of Medical Education (NVMO), which sponsors the journal as an Open Access journal that is free to read immediately upon publication. To publish in the journal, authors are required to pay an author processing charge of £996 upon publication. The journal is indexed in key databases, including MEDLINE, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Scopus and has received the DOAJ seal. In 2022, the journal was awarded an impact factor of 4.113. The journal is overseen by the Editor-in-Chief Professor Erik Driessen, PhD. He is provided by guidance by an international editorial board of leading scholars with members representing the different parental disciplines in the field of medical education, e.g. clinicians, social scientists, biomedical scientists, statisticians, and linguists.
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 13 (1) , 423-430
Open AccessWidening the Gates: Redefining Excellence in Selection for Health Professions Education for a Diverse Future Workforce
Perspectives on Medical Education’s mission is to support and enrich collaborative scholarship between education researchers and clinical educators, and to advance new knowledge regarding clinical education practices. The journal is the official journal of the The Netherlands Association of Medical Education (NVMO), which sponsors the journal as an Open Access journal that is free to read immediately upon publication. To publish in the journal, authors are required to pay an author processing charge of £996 upon publication. The journal is indexed in key databases, including MEDLINE, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Scopus and has received the DOAJ seal. In 2022, the journal was awarded an impact factor of 4.113. The journal is overseen by the Editor-in-Chief Professor Erik Driessen, PhD. He is provided by guidance by an international editorial board of leading scholars with members representing the different parental disciplines in the field of medical education, e.g. clinicians, social scientists, biomedical scientists, statisticians, and linguists.
- Open Access
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-16
Improving selection procedures in health professions education from the applicant perspective: an interview study
Introduction: Applicant perceptions of selection impact motivation and performance during selection, and student diversity. However, in-depth insight into which values underly these perceptions is lacking, creating challenges for aligning selection procedures with applicant perceptions. This qualitative interview study aimed to identify values applicants believe should underlie selection, and how, according to applicants, these values should be used to make specific improvements to selection procedures in undergraduate health professions education (HPE). Methods: Thirty-one applicants to five undergraduate HPE programs in the Netherlands participated in semi-structured interviews using Appreciative Inquiry, an approach that focuses on what goes well to create vision for improvement, to guide the interviews. Transcriptions were analyzed using thematic analysis, adopting a constructivist approach. Results: Applicants’ values related to the aims of selection, the content of selection, and the treatment of applicants. Applicants believed that selection procedures should aim to identify students who best fit the training and profession, and generate diverse student populations to fulfill societal needs. According to applicants, the content of selection should be relevant for the curriculum and profession, assess a comprehensive set of attributes, be of high quality, allow applicants to show who they are, and be adapted to applicants’ current developmental state. Regarding treatment, applicants believed that selection should be a two-way process that fosters reflection on study choice, be transparent about what applicants can expect, safeguard applicants’ well-being, treat all applicants equally, and employ an equitable approach by taking personal circumstances into account. Applicants mentioned specific improvements regarding each value. Discussion: Applicants’ values offer novel insights into what they consider important preconditions for the design of selection procedures. Their suggested improvements can support selection committees in better meeting applicants’ needs.
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-16
Open AccessImproving selection procedures in health professions education from the applicant perspective: an interview study
Introduction: Applicant perceptions of selection impact motivation and performance during selection, and student diversity. However, in-depth insight into which values underly these perceptions is lacking, creating challenges for aligning selection procedures with applicant perceptions. This qualitative interview study aimed to identify values applicants believe should underlie selection, and how, according to applicants, these values should be used to make specific improvements to selection procedures in undergraduate health professions education (HPE). Methods: Thirty-one applicants to five undergraduate HPE programs in the Netherlands participated in semi-structured interviews using Appreciative Inquiry, an approach that focuses on what goes well to create vision for improvement, to guide the interviews. Transcriptions were analyzed using thematic analysis, adopting a constructivist approach. Results: Applicants’ values related to the aims of selection, the content of selection, and the treatment of applicants. Applicants believed that selection procedures should aim to identify students who best fit the training and profession, and generate diverse student populations to fulfill societal needs. According to applicants, the content of selection should be relevant for the curriculum and profession, assess a comprehensive set of attributes, be of high quality, allow applicants to show who they are, and be adapted to applicants’ current developmental state. Regarding treatment, applicants believed that selection should be a two-way process that fosters reflection on study choice, be transparent about what applicants can expect, safeguard applicants’ well-being, treat all applicants equally, and employ an equitable approach by taking personal circumstances into account. Applicants mentioned specific improvements regarding each value. Discussion: Applicants’ values offer novel insights into what they consider important preconditions for the design of selection procedures. Their suggested improvements can support selection committees in better meeting applicants’ needs.
- Open Access
- 27 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (5) , 544-555
Self‐regulated learning profiles including test anxiety linked to stress and performance: A latent profile analysis based across multiple cohorts
Introduction: Medical educators aim to understand why students differ in performance and stress. While performance and stress are associated with student demographics, school factors and aspects of self‐regulated learning (SRL), it remains unclear how these elements interact within individuals. This multi‐cohort study identified SRL profiles among medical students and explored their associations with performance and stress. Additionally, we examined the identified profiles' associations with gender, migration status and assessment policy. Methods: We used latent profile analysis (LPA) to identify profiles on Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ) scores of six cohorts (2014–2019) of Year 1, first semester medical students (n = 1894) in a Dutch medical school. We used nine MSLQ subscales that measure test anxiety (TA), self‐efficacy, deep learning, resource management and value. The university's assessment policy varied, demanding students to obtain 100% or 75% of Year 1 credits to remain enrolled. We defined optimal performance as obtaining all credits at the end of Year 1. Two cohorts completed the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS‐14, n = 409) in the 2nd semester. Results: We identified three distinct student profiles: 693/1894(36.6%) were classified as TA high SRL high , 661/1894(34.9%) as TA low SRL high and 540/1894(28.5%) as TA moderate SRL low . Females were more likely to belong to TA high SRL high profiles compared to males (effect size [ES] Cramer's V = .13, small). Migration background was not associated with these profiles. The TA high SRL high profile was more prevalent under the 100% assessment policy (ES Cramer's V = .10, negligible). TA low SRL high students demonstrated lower stress levels (PSS = 23.9 out of 56) compared to TA high SRL high students (PSS = 28.7, ES Cohen's d = .62, medium) and TA moderate SRL low students (PSS = 28.2, ES Cohen's d = .51, medium). Performance differed among the three profiles (ES Cramer's V = .16, small): 82.5% optimal performance in the TA low SRL high , 71.9% in the TA high SRL high and 65.2% in the TA moderate SRL low profile. Discussion: Three distinct SRL student profiles associated with gender, academic performance and perceived stress were identified. Test anxiety had additional value in distinguishing subgroups with differential academic performance and stress. These profiles may aid educators to inform personalised support strategies for novice learners.
- 27 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (5) , 544-555
Open AccessSelf‐regulated learning profiles including test anxiety linked to stress and performance: A latent profile analysis based across multiple cohorts
Introduction: Medical educators aim to understand why students differ in performance and stress. While performance and stress are associated with student demographics, school factors and aspects of self‐regulated learning (SRL), it remains unclear how these elements interact within individuals. This multi‐cohort study identified SRL profiles among medical students and explored their associations with performance and stress. Additionally, we examined the identified profiles' associations with gender, migration status and assessment policy. Methods: We used latent profile analysis (LPA) to identify profiles on Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ) scores of six cohorts (2014–2019) of Year 1, first semester medical students (n = 1894) in a Dutch medical school. We used nine MSLQ subscales that measure test anxiety (TA), self‐efficacy, deep learning, resource management and value. The university's assessment policy varied, demanding students to obtain 100% or 75% of Year 1 credits to remain enrolled. We defined optimal performance as obtaining all credits at the end of Year 1. Two cohorts completed the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS‐14, n = 409) in the 2nd semester. Results: We identified three distinct student profiles: 693/1894(36.6%) were classified as TA high SRL high , 661/1894(34.9%) as TA low SRL high and 540/1894(28.5%) as TA moderate SRL low . Females were more likely to belong to TA high SRL high profiles compared to males (effect size [ES] Cramer's V = .13, small). Migration background was not associated with these profiles. The TA high SRL high profile was more prevalent under the 100% assessment policy (ES Cramer's V = .10, negligible). TA low SRL high students demonstrated lower stress levels (PSS = 23.9 out of 56) compared to TA high SRL high students (PSS = 28.7, ES Cohen's d = .62, medium) and TA moderate SRL low students (PSS = 28.2, ES Cohen's d = .51, medium). Performance differed among the three profiles (ES Cramer's V = .16, small): 82.5% optimal performance in the TA low SRL high , 71.9% in the TA high SRL high and 65.2% in the TA moderate SRL low profile. Discussion: Three distinct SRL student profiles associated with gender, academic performance and perceived stress were identified. Test anxiety had additional value in distinguishing subgroups with differential academic performance and stress. These profiles may aid educators to inform personalised support strategies for novice learners.
- Open Access
- 20 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (1) , 17-19
Contemplating the future of competency assessment
Health education's competency models are evolving to balance universal skills with those that are job‐ and organization‐specific. These authors argue that a three‐layer framework emphasizing person‐organization fit will create better outcomes.
- 20 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 58 (1) , 17-19
Open AccessContemplating the future of competency assessment
Health education's competency models are evolving to balance universal skills with those that are job‐ and organization‐specific. These authors argue that a three‐layer framework emphasizing person‐organization fit will create better outcomes.
- 23 August 2023
- Vol. 167
[Minority GP in training more likely to 'underperform': who is to blame?].
Recent work revealed that ethnic minority gp-trainees are more at risk of underperformance than their majority peers. We argue that causes for underperformance can be identified from two perspectives, namely that of the trainees ('them') and that of the assessors and the institution ('us'). Potential impeding factors from the student perspective include lack of practical clinical skills and differences in communication styles. At the level of the assessors, it is important to consider in-group bias and individual assessors' perceptions and preferences. Finally, possible factors at the institutional level are type of evaluation system used and organizational culture. Questions are raised regarding the existence of one golden rule for doctor-patient communication and the role of the hidden curriculum in negatively influencing social and academic outcomes for minority trainees. The urge is for creating an inclusive learning environment ensuring psychological safety and talent usage for all our future doctors.
- 23 August 2023
- Vol. 167
[Minority GP in training more likely to 'underperform': who is to blame?].
Recent work revealed that ethnic minority gp-trainees are more at risk of underperformance than their majority peers. We argue that causes for underperformance can be identified from two perspectives, namely that of the trainees ('them') and that of the assessors and the institution ('us'). Potential impeding factors from the student perspective include lack of practical clinical skills and differences in communication styles. At the level of the assessors, it is important to consider in-group bias and individual assessors' perceptions and preferences. Finally, possible factors at the institutional level are type of evaluation system used and organizational culture. Questions are raised regarding the existence of one golden rule for doctor-patient communication and the role of the hidden curriculum in negatively influencing social and academic outcomes for minority trainees. The urge is for creating an inclusive learning environment ensuring psychological safety and talent usage for all our future doctors.
- Open Access
- 16 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-9
The association between how medical students were selected and their perceived stress levels in Year-1 of medical school
Background: The prevalence of medical students’ mental distress is high. While schools apply various methods to select a well-performing and diverse student population, little is known about the association between different selection methods and the well-being of these students during medical school. The present retrospective multi-cohort study assessed whether students selected by high grades, assessment, or weighted lottery showed different stress perception levels in Year-1 of medical school. Methods: Of 1144 Dutch Year-1 medical students, 650 (57%) of the cohorts 2013, 2014, and 2018 who were selected by high grades, assessment, or weighted lottery completed a stress perception questionnaire (PSS-14). A multilevel regression analysis assessed the association between selection method (independent variable) and stress perception levels (dependent variable) while controlling for gender and cohort. In a post-hoc analysis, academic performance (optimal vs. non-optimal) was included in the multilevel model. Results: Students selected by assessment (B = 2.25, p < .01, effect size (ES) = small) or weighted lottery (B = 3.95, p < .01, ES = medium) had higher stress perception levels than students selected by high grades. Extending the regression model with optimal academic performance (B=-4.38, p < .001, ES = medium), eliminated the statistically significant difference in stress perception between assessment and high grades and reduced the difference between weighted lottery and high grades from 3.95 to 2.45 (B = 2.45, p < .05, ES = small). Conclusions: Selection methods intended to create a diverse student population – assessment and lottery - are associated with higher stress perception levels in Year-1 of medical school. These findings offer medical schools insights into fulfilling their responsibility to take care of their students’ well-being.
- 16 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-9
Open AccessThe association between how medical students were selected and their perceived stress levels in Year-1 of medical school
Background: The prevalence of medical students’ mental distress is high. While schools apply various methods to select a well-performing and diverse student population, little is known about the association between different selection methods and the well-being of these students during medical school. The present retrospective multi-cohort study assessed whether students selected by high grades, assessment, or weighted lottery showed different stress perception levels in Year-1 of medical school. Methods: Of 1144 Dutch Year-1 medical students, 650 (57%) of the cohorts 2013, 2014, and 2018 who were selected by high grades, assessment, or weighted lottery completed a stress perception questionnaire (PSS-14). A multilevel regression analysis assessed the association between selection method (independent variable) and stress perception levels (dependent variable) while controlling for gender and cohort. In a post-hoc analysis, academic performance (optimal vs. non-optimal) was included in the multilevel model. Results: Students selected by assessment (B = 2.25, p < .01, effect size (ES) = small) or weighted lottery (B = 3.95, p < .01, ES = medium) had higher stress perception levels than students selected by high grades. Extending the regression model with optimal academic performance (B=-4.38, p < .001, ES = medium), eliminated the statistically significant difference in stress perception between assessment and high grades and reduced the difference between weighted lottery and high grades from 3.95 to 2.45 (B = 2.45, p < .05, ES = small). Conclusions: Selection methods intended to create a diverse student population – assessment and lottery - are associated with higher stress perception levels in Year-1 of medical school. These findings offer medical schools insights into fulfilling their responsibility to take care of their students’ well-being.