Libby Gerard
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Libby Gerard has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Marcia C. Linn
University of California, Berkeley
17 shared publications Marcia C. Linn
Berkeley School of Education, University of California, Berkeley, USA
6 shared publications- Allison Bradford
University of California, Berkeley
4 shared publications - Weiying Li
Berkeley School of Education, University of California Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
4 shared publications Allison Bradford
Berkeley School of Education, University of California, Berkeley, USA
3 shared publications- Sarah Bichler
Universität Passau Passau Germany
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 107-129
AI Transformations of Science Education Goals to Prepare Students as Lifelong Investigators
- 1 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 107-129
AI Transformations of Science Education Goals to Prepare Students as Lifelong Investigators
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Instruction
- Vol. 102
Creating and testing adaptive guidance for thermodynamics classroom instruction
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Instruction
- Vol. 102
Creating and testing adaptive guidance for thermodynamics classroom instruction
- 1 January 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 117 (1) , 63-87
Impact of an adaptive dialog that uses natural language processing to detect students’ ideas and guide knowledge integration.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 117 (1) , 63-87
Impact of an adaptive dialog that uses natural language processing to detect students’ ideas and guide knowledge integration.
- Open Access
- 17 December 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 14 (12) , 1383
A Comparison of Responsive and General Guidance to Promote Learning in an Online Science Dialog
Students benefit from dialogs about their explanations of complex scientific phenomena, and middle school science teachers cannot realistically provide all the guidance they need. We study ways to extend generative teacher–student dialogs to more students by using AI tools. We compare Responsive web-based dialogs to General web-based dialogs by evaluating the ideas students add and the quality of their revised explanations. We designed the General guidance to motivate and encourage students to revise their explanations, similar to how an experienced classroom teacher might instruct the class. We designed the Responsive guidance to emulate a student–teacher dialog, based on studies of experienced teachers guiding individual students. The analyses comparing the Responsive and the General condition are based on a randomized assignment of a total sample of 507 pre-college students. These students were taught by five different teachers in four schools. A significantly higher proportion of students added new accurate ideas in the Responsive condition compared to the General condition during the dialog. This research shows that by using NLP to identify ideas and assign guidance, students can broaden and refine their ideas. Responsive guidance, inspired by how experienced teachers guide individual students, is more valuable than General guidance.
- 17 December 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 14 (12) , 1383
Open AccessA Comparison of Responsive and General Guidance to Promote Learning in an Online Science Dialog
Students benefit from dialogs about their explanations of complex scientific phenomena, and middle school science teachers cannot realistically provide all the guidance they need. We study ways to extend generative teacher–student dialogs to more students by using AI tools. We compare Responsive web-based dialogs to General web-based dialogs by evaluating the ideas students add and the quality of their revised explanations. We designed the General guidance to motivate and encourage students to revise their explanations, similar to how an experienced classroom teacher might instruct the class. We designed the Responsive guidance to emulate a student–teacher dialog, based on studies of experienced teachers guiding individual students. The analyses comparing the Responsive and the General condition are based on a randomized assignment of a total sample of 507 pre-college students. These students were taught by five different teachers in four schools. A significantly higher proportion of students added new accurate ideas in the Responsive condition compared to the General condition during the dialog. This research shows that by using NLP to identify ideas and assign guidance, students can broaden and refine their ideas. Responsive guidance, inspired by how experienced teachers guide individual students, is more valuable than General guidance.
- 29 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 255-275
Impacts of Web-Based Inquiry Learning Environments Aligned with Knowledge Integration Pedagogy
Advances in learning science research and educational technologies combined in Authoring and Customizing Environments (ACE) have the potential to transform classroom science learning. Aligning inquiry instruction and assessment using learning science pedagogy such as Knowledge Integration ensures that designs incorporate advances in research and that impacts are validly measured. ACEs support partnerships of classroom teachers, discipline experts, learning scientists, and software designers to create inquiry curricula and to customize the instruction using evidence from classroom implementations. Meta-analyses and reviews of the impact of inquiry environments document the impact of ACEs on science learning. The chapter illustrates the features of ACEs including models, simulations, graphing technologies, collaborative tools, and automated guidance in an exemplar unit. It summarizes research on the impact of each feature and discusses how aligning combinations of these features with learning science pedagogies increases ACE impacts. Supporting partnerships to customize ACE-based instruction not only improves outcomes but also strengthens the pedagogy behind the ACE. The chapter closes with recommended next steps.
- 29 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 255-275
Impacts of Web-Based Inquiry Learning Environments Aligned with Knowledge Integration Pedagogy
Advances in learning science research and educational technologies combined in Authoring and Customizing Environments (ACE) have the potential to transform classroom science learning. Aligning inquiry instruction and assessment using learning science pedagogy such as Knowledge Integration ensures that designs incorporate advances in research and that impacts are validly measured. ACEs support partnerships of classroom teachers, discipline experts, learning scientists, and software designers to create inquiry curricula and to customize the instruction using evidence from classroom implementations. Meta-analyses and reviews of the impact of inquiry environments document the impact of ACEs on science learning. The chapter illustrates the features of ACEs including models, simulations, graphing technologies, collaborative tools, and automated guidance in an exemplar unit. It summarizes research on the impact of each feature and discusses how aligning combinations of these features with learning science pedagogies increases ACE impacts. Supporting partnerships to customize ACE-based instruction not only improves outcomes but also strengthens the pedagogy behind the ACE. The chapter closes with recommended next steps.
- Open Access
- 4 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Science Education and Technology
- Vol. 34 (5) , 980-993
Combining Natural Language Processing with Epistemic Network Analysis to Investigate Student Knowledge Integration within an AI Dialog
In this study, we used Epistemic Network Analysis (ENA) to represent data generated by Natural Language Processing (NLP) analytics during an activity based on the Knowledge Integration (KI) framework. The activity features a web-based adaptive dialog about energy transfer in photosynthesis and cellular respiration. Students write an initial explanation, respond to two adaptive prompts in the dialog, and write a revised explanation. The NLP models score the KI level of the initial and revised explanations. They also detect the ideas in the explanations and the dialog responses. The dialog uses the detected ideas to prompt students to elaborate and refine their explanations. Participants were 196 8th-grade students at a public school in the Western United States. We used ENA to represent the idea networks at each KI score level for the revised explanations. We also used ENA to analyze the idea trajectories for the initial explanation, the two dialog responses, and the final explanation. Higher KI levels were associated with more links and increased frequency of mechanistic ideas in ENA representations. Representation of the trajectories suggests that the NLP adaptive dialog helped students who started with descriptive and macroscopic ideas to add more microscopic ideas. The dialog also helped students who started with partially linked ideas to keep linking the microscopic ideas to mechanistic ideas. We discuss implications for STEM teachers and researchers who are interested in how students build on their ideas to integrate their ideas.
- 4 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Science Education and Technology
- Vol. 34 (5) , 980-993
Open AccessCombining Natural Language Processing with Epistemic Network Analysis to Investigate Student Knowledge Integration within an AI Dialog
In this study, we used Epistemic Network Analysis (ENA) to represent data generated by Natural Language Processing (NLP) analytics during an activity based on the Knowledge Integration (KI) framework. The activity features a web-based adaptive dialog about energy transfer in photosynthesis and cellular respiration. Students write an initial explanation, respond to two adaptive prompts in the dialog, and write a revised explanation. The NLP models score the KI level of the initial and revised explanations. They also detect the ideas in the explanations and the dialog responses. The dialog uses the detected ideas to prompt students to elaborate and refine their explanations. Participants were 196 8th-grade students at a public school in the Western United States. We used ENA to represent the idea networks at each KI score level for the revised explanations. We also used ENA to analyze the idea trajectories for the initial explanation, the two dialog responses, and the final explanation. Higher KI levels were associated with more links and increased frequency of mechanistic ideas in ENA representations. Representation of the trajectories suggests that the NLP adaptive dialog helped students who started with descriptive and macroscopic ideas to add more microscopic ideas. The dialog also helped students who started with partially linked ideas to keep linking the microscopic ideas to mechanistic ideas. We discuss implications for STEM teachers and researchers who are interested in how students build on their ideas to integrate their ideas.
- 13 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 52 (5) , 795-829
Designing for learning across disciplines: leveraging graphs to improve knowledge integration in science
- 13 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 52 (5) , 795-829
Designing for learning across disciplines: leveraging graphs to improve knowledge integration in science
- Open Access
- 9 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 388-392
Comparing Expert and ChatGPT-authored Guidance Prompts
Students bring a multitude of ideas and experiences to the classroom while they are reasoning about scientific phenomena. They often need timely guidance to refine build upon their initial ideas. In this study we explore the development of guidance prompts to provide students with personalized, real-time feedback in the context of a pedagogically grounded chatbot. In the current version of the tool, guidance prompts are authored by learning scientists who are experts in the content of the items and in Knowledge Integration pedagogy. When students engage with the chatbot, an idea detection model is used to determine the ideas that are present in a student explanation and then the expert-authored guidance prompts are assigned based on rules about which ideas are or are not present in the student explanation. While this approach allows for close attention to and control of the pedagogical intent of each prompt, it is time consuming and not easily generalizable. Further this rule-based approach limits the ways in which students can interact with the chatbot. The work in progress study presented in this paper explores the potential of using generative AI to create similarly pedagogically grounded guidance prompts as a first step towards increasing the generalizability and scalability of this approach. Specifically, we ask: using criteria from the Knowledge Integration Pedagogical Framework, how do ChatGPT 3.5-authored guidance prompts compare to human expert-authored guidance prompts? We find that while prompt engineering can enhance the alignment of ChatGPT-authored guidance prompts with pedagogical criteria, the human expert-authored guidance prompts more consistently meet the pedagogical criteria.
- 9 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 388-392
Open AccessComparing Expert and ChatGPT-authored Guidance Prompts
Students bring a multitude of ideas and experiences to the classroom while they are reasoning about scientific phenomena. They often need timely guidance to refine build upon their initial ideas. In this study we explore the development of guidance prompts to provide students with personalized, real-time feedback in the context of a pedagogically grounded chatbot. In the current version of the tool, guidance prompts are authored by learning scientists who are experts in the content of the items and in Knowledge Integration pedagogy. When students engage with the chatbot, an idea detection model is used to determine the ideas that are present in a student explanation and then the expert-authored guidance prompts are assigned based on rules about which ideas are or are not present in the student explanation. While this approach allows for close attention to and control of the pedagogical intent of each prompt, it is time consuming and not easily generalizable. Further this rule-based approach limits the ways in which students can interact with the chatbot. The work in progress study presented in this paper explores the potential of using generative AI to create similarly pedagogically grounded guidance prompts as a first step towards increasing the generalizability and scalability of this approach. Specifically, we ask: using criteria from the Knowledge Integration Pedagogical Framework, how do ChatGPT 3.5-authored guidance prompts compare to human expert-authored guidance prompts? We find that while prompt engineering can enhance the alignment of ChatGPT-authored guidance prompts with pedagogical criteria, the human expert-authored guidance prompts more consistently meet the pedagogical criteria.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 447-450
Teacher-informed Expansion of an Idea Detection Model for a Knowledge Integration Assessment
Students come to science classrooms with ideas informed by their prior instruction and everyday observations. Following constructivist pedagogy, assessments that encourage students to elaborate their ideas, distinguish among them, and link the most promising ones can capture students' potential and help teachers plan their lessons. In this investigation, we study an assessment that engages students in a dialog to refine their response to a Knowledge Integration (KI) question. Our Research Practice Partnership (RPP) initially trained a Natural Language Processing (NLP) idea detection model on 1218 student responses from 5 schools and identified 13 student ideas. The original model had an overall micro-averaged F-score of 0.7634. After classroom testing, three RPP expert teachers with 10+ years of experience reviewed the classroom data and expanded the model, adding six additional ideas including two that they described as precursor ideas because they foreshadowed more sophisticated reasoning. We trained the idea detection model on these 19 ideas using a dataset from 13 teachers and 1206 students across 8 public schools. The updated model had a somewhat lower overall micro-averaged F-score of 0.7297. The two precursor ideas were among the top four detected ideas. The assessment, using the updated model, guided students to express significantly more ideas. A regression model showed that the updated model was associated with greater KI score gains. Expanding the model, thus, created an assessment that motivated students to express more ideas and to achieve higher KI scores. It also provides teachers with deeper insights into their students' understanding of science.
- 9 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 447-450
Open AccessTeacher-informed Expansion of an Idea Detection Model for a Knowledge Integration Assessment
Students come to science classrooms with ideas informed by their prior instruction and everyday observations. Following constructivist pedagogy, assessments that encourage students to elaborate their ideas, distinguish among them, and link the most promising ones can capture students' potential and help teachers plan their lessons. In this investigation, we study an assessment that engages students in a dialog to refine their response to a Knowledge Integration (KI) question. Our Research Practice Partnership (RPP) initially trained a Natural Language Processing (NLP) idea detection model on 1218 student responses from 5 schools and identified 13 student ideas. The original model had an overall micro-averaged F-score of 0.7634. After classroom testing, three RPP expert teachers with 10+ years of experience reviewed the classroom data and expanded the model, adding six additional ideas including two that they described as precursor ideas because they foreshadowed more sophisticated reasoning. We trained the idea detection model on these 19 ideas using a dataset from 13 teachers and 1206 students across 8 public schools. The updated model had a somewhat lower overall micro-averaged F-score of 0.7297. The two precursor ideas were among the top four detected ideas. The assessment, using the updated model, guided students to express significantly more ideas. A regression model showed that the updated model was associated with greater KI score gains. Expanding the model, thus, created an assessment that motivated students to express more ideas and to achieve higher KI scores. It also provides teachers with deeper insights into their students' understanding of science.
- Open Access
- 3 October 2023
- Published by International Society of the Learning Sciences
How Does an Adaptive Dialog Based on Natural Language Processing Impact Students From Distinct Language Backgrounds?
This study takes advantage of advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP) to build an idea detection model that can identify ideas grounded in students' linguistic experiences. We designed adaptive, interactive dialogs for four explanation items using the NLP idea detection model and investigated whether they similarly support students from distinct language backgrounds. The curriculum, assessments, and scoring rubrics were informed by the Knowledge Integration (KI) pedagogy. We analyzed responses of 1,036 students of different language backgrounds taught by 10 teachers in five schools in the western United States. The adaptive dialog engages students from both monolingual English and multilingual backgrounds in incorporating additional relevant ideas into their explanations, resulting in a significant improvement in student responses from initial to revised explanations. The guidance supports students in both language groups to progress in integrating their scientific ideas.
- 3 October 2023
- Published by International Society of the Learning Sciences
Open AccessHow Does an Adaptive Dialog Based on Natural Language Processing Impact Students From Distinct Language Backgrounds?
This study takes advantage of advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP) to build an idea detection model that can identify ideas grounded in students' linguistic experiences. We designed adaptive, interactive dialogs for four explanation items using the NLP idea detection model and investigated whether they similarly support students from distinct language backgrounds. The curriculum, assessments, and scoring rubrics were informed by the Knowledge Integration (KI) pedagogy. We analyzed responses of 1,036 students of different language backgrounds taught by 10 teachers in five schools in the western United States. The adaptive dialog engages students from both monolingual English and multilingual backgrounds in incorporating additional relevant ideas into their explanations, resulting in a significant improvement in student responses from initial to revised explanations. The guidance supports students in both language groups to progress in integrating their scientific ideas.