Marco Seeber
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Marco Seeber has a total of 95 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Benedetto Lepori
5 shared publications- Emanuela Reale
National Research Council of Italy
4 shared publications Jeroen Huisman
Department of Sociology, University of Gent, Gent, Belgium
4 shared publicationsMattia Cattaneo
4 shared publications- Michele Meoli
Department of Management, Information and Production Engineering, University of Bergamo, Bergamo, Italy
4 shared publications - Benedetto Lepori
Università Della Svizzera italiana, Lugano, Switzerland
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Connecting scientists across divides through temporary proximity: evidence from COST Actions
The mechanisms that govern the formation of scientific collaborations can limit the inclusion of certain categories of scientists—such as those working in peripheral research systems, women, and early-career researchers. Yet, we still know little about which instruments can effectively address these structural barriers. This article investigates the impact of the European Cooperation in Science and Technology (COST) programme—the oldest European framework for research cooperation—designed to promote scientific integration through transnational research networks known as “Actions”. These Actions employ a range of networking tools to foster temporary proximity among participants. Using data on approximately 1.5 million publications and 18,305 scientists involved in 66 funded and 519 non-funded proposals from the 2015 call, we assess whether COST Actions enhanced scientific connectivity—especially for less-connected groups—and promoted collaborations across different types of researchers. The findings indicate that COST Actions increased connectivity, particularly for scientists from peripheral systems, women, and young researchers, and fostered more diverse collaborations. The results suggest that temporary proximity fostered by funding instruments can effectively address some of the structural barriers to scientific networking.
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessConnecting scientists across divides through temporary proximity: evidence from COST Actions
The mechanisms that govern the formation of scientific collaborations can limit the inclusion of certain categories of scientists—such as those working in peripheral research systems, women, and early-career researchers. Yet, we still know little about which instruments can effectively address these structural barriers. This article investigates the impact of the European Cooperation in Science and Technology (COST) programme—the oldest European framework for research cooperation—designed to promote scientific integration through transnational research networks known as “Actions”. These Actions employ a range of networking tools to foster temporary proximity among participants. Using data on approximately 1.5 million publications and 18,305 scientists involved in 66 funded and 519 non-funded proposals from the 2015 call, we assess whether COST Actions enhanced scientific connectivity—especially for less-connected groups—and promoted collaborations across different types of researchers. The findings indicate that COST Actions increased connectivity, particularly for scientists from peripheral systems, women, and young researchers, and fostered more diverse collaborations. The results suggest that temporary proximity fostered by funding instruments can effectively address some of the structural barriers to scientific networking.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open access increases policy citations but concentrates recognition: evidence from climate change research
There is a broad consensus that policies, and the policy documents informing them, should be based on high-quality scientific evidence. In practice, however, authors of policy documents face two major challenges: limited access to scientific outputs and limited capacity to assess their validity. This article explores this problem and the impact of the recent exponential growth of open access publishing. Drawing on the literature on citation determinants and guided by signalling theory, we hypothesize that policy documents cite open access publications displaying quality signals, in ways that differ from academic citations. To test the hypotheses, we investigate the determinants of policy and scholarly citations for all scientific publications on climate change and global warming indexed in Scopus from 1999 to 2024, along with all policy documents citing these publications from the Overton database. We found that open access had a much greater impact on citations from policy documents than from scientific documents. At the same time, the effect on policy citations is concentrated on research produced through international collaborations, by authors affiliated with highly prestigious institutions, and published in higher-ranked journals. Hence, while expanding the availability of scientific findings on the user side, open access reinforces existing hierarchies in scientific recognition on the producer side.
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessOpen access increases policy citations but concentrates recognition: evidence from climate change research
There is a broad consensus that policies, and the policy documents informing them, should be based on high-quality scientific evidence. In practice, however, authors of policy documents face two major challenges: limited access to scientific outputs and limited capacity to assess their validity. This article explores this problem and the impact of the recent exponential growth of open access publishing. Drawing on the literature on citation determinants and guided by signalling theory, we hypothesize that policy documents cite open access publications displaying quality signals, in ways that differ from academic citations. To test the hypotheses, we investigate the determinants of policy and scholarly citations for all scientific publications on climate change and global warming indexed in Scopus from 1999 to 2024, along with all policy documents citing these publications from the Overton database. We found that open access had a much greater impact on citations from policy documents than from scientific documents. At the same time, the effect on policy citations is concentrated on research produced through international collaborations, by authors affiliated with highly prestigious institutions, and published in higher-ranked journals. Hence, while expanding the availability of scientific findings on the user side, open access reinforces existing hierarchies in scientific recognition on the producer side.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Economic Papers
- Vol. 78 (2) , 309-334
Beyond the badge of honour: the effect of the academic excellence initiative on staff recruitment in Italy
Understanding how excellence-based funding affects academic recruitment is central to evaluating the broader implications of performance-oriented research policies. We study the Department of Excellence Initiative (“Dipartimenti di Eccellenza”) in the Italian higher education system. Unlike other excellence initiatives in Europe, this programme was directed at departments rather than universities. We investigate the effect of the initiative on new faculty positions, distinguishing between external recruitment and internal promotion, as well as different career stages. We also analyse heterogeneity across departmental categories, differentiating between first-tier (top-rated) and second-tier (near-elite) departments. Our findings indicate a positive effect on the creation of new faculty positions within funded departments, particularly through external recruitment and across various career stages. Notably, we provide evidence of greater benefits accruing to second-tier departments relative to their first-tier counterparts, particularly with respect to entry-level tenure-track positions.
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Economic Papers
- Vol. 78 (2) , 309-334
Open AccessBeyond the badge of honour: the effect of the academic excellence initiative on staff recruitment in Italy
Understanding how excellence-based funding affects academic recruitment is central to evaluating the broader implications of performance-oriented research policies. We study the Department of Excellence Initiative (“Dipartimenti di Eccellenza”) in the Italian higher education system. Unlike other excellence initiatives in Europe, this programme was directed at departments rather than universities. We investigate the effect of the initiative on new faculty positions, distinguishing between external recruitment and internal promotion, as well as different career stages. We also analyse heterogeneity across departmental categories, differentiating between first-tier (top-rated) and second-tier (near-elite) departments. Our findings indicate a positive effect on the creation of new faculty positions within funded departments, particularly through external recruitment and across various career stages. Notably, we provide evidence of greater benefits accruing to second-tier departments relative to their first-tier counterparts, particularly with respect to entry-level tenure-track positions.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 35
The influence of research topics on ERC grant success: bottom-up, but not topic-neutral
The European Research Council (ERC) is one of the most important research funding schemes of the European Union, supporting investigator-driven, excellent, frontier research. The ERC’s governing bodies have upheld the scheme’s ‘bottom-up’ approach, resisting any attempts to promote specific research topics. However, the selection process is not necessarily topic-neutral. Research has provided very limited evidence on the influence of a proposal’s research topic on its chances to be funded. This article addresses this gap by investigating what the research topics of ERC proposals are, how the proposals’ research topics vary across framework programs, countries, type of organization and grant, and whether a proposal’s research topic predicts the chances of being funded. We use state-of-the-art natural language processing techniques to examine the textual content of the abstract of 91,273 proposals for Starting, Consolidator, and Advanced Grants in the Seventh Framework Program (FP7) and Horizon 2020 (H2020)—that is, 95.3% of all the proposals, identifying 188 unique research topics. The proportion of proposals in each topic changed substantially from FP7 to H2020 programs, with one in four increasing or decreasing by more than 20% in relative terms. The research topic of a proposal is related to variation in success rates: 37.4% of proposals fall within topics that display significantly higher or lower chances of being funded. At the same time, the composition of the research topics of the funded proposals is similar to a hypothetical scenario in which topics did not affect success (80.8% overlap). The results suggest that the selection process on what is researched does not overturn the nature of ERC as a bottom-up program.
- 8 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 35
Open AccessThe influence of research topics on ERC grant success: bottom-up, but not topic-neutral
The European Research Council (ERC) is one of the most important research funding schemes of the European Union, supporting investigator-driven, excellent, frontier research. The ERC’s governing bodies have upheld the scheme’s ‘bottom-up’ approach, resisting any attempts to promote specific research topics. However, the selection process is not necessarily topic-neutral. Research has provided very limited evidence on the influence of a proposal’s research topic on its chances to be funded. This article addresses this gap by investigating what the research topics of ERC proposals are, how the proposals’ research topics vary across framework programs, countries, type of organization and grant, and whether a proposal’s research topic predicts the chances of being funded. We use state-of-the-art natural language processing techniques to examine the textual content of the abstract of 91,273 proposals for Starting, Consolidator, and Advanced Grants in the Seventh Framework Program (FP7) and Horizon 2020 (H2020)—that is, 95.3% of all the proposals, identifying 188 unique research topics. The proportion of proposals in each topic changed substantially from FP7 to H2020 programs, with one in four increasing or decreasing by more than 20% in relative terms. The research topic of a proposal is related to variation in success rates: 37.4% of proposals fall within topics that display significantly higher or lower chances of being funded. At the same time, the composition of the research topics of the funded proposals is similar to a hypothetical scenario in which topics did not affect success (80.8% overlap). The results suggest that the selection process on what is researched does not overturn the nature of ERC as a bottom-up program.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 6, 281-304
The effect of public funding on long-term relocation of experienced researchers: An analysis of the Marie Curie Career Integration Grant
Scientific mobility often benefits researchers’ productivity and networks but may lead to unbalanced flows from less to more attractive countries. This is the first quantitative study to examine a mobility program aimed at tackling this problem by favoring relocation within a geographical domain, by supporting the long-term relocation of experienced researchers: the Career Integration Grant (CIG), a funding scheme of the Marie Curie Actions under the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme. The CIG aimed to reinforce the European Research Area and counter the European brain drain to third countries by supporting the long-term relocation of experienced researchers in EU member states or associated countries. We consider three yearly calls between 2011 and 2013 and explore the effect on the chances of long-term relocation at country and institutional level. We find that obtaining the grant related to greater chances of long-term relocation in the host institution (+9.4%) and country (+8.2%). The grant was particularly effective for applicants’ subcategories that typically have less access to alternative funding sources: (a) nontenured, (b) scientists from soft sciences, (c) non “returnees,” and (d) moving to nonhigh-ranked institutions. We do not find a relationship with the probability of obtaining a tenured position or on scientific productivity.
- 12 March 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 6, 281-304
Open AccessThe effect of public funding on long-term relocation of experienced researchers: An analysis of the Marie Curie Career Integration Grant
Scientific mobility often benefits researchers’ productivity and networks but may lead to unbalanced flows from less to more attractive countries. This is the first quantitative study to examine a mobility program aimed at tackling this problem by favoring relocation within a geographical domain, by supporting the long-term relocation of experienced researchers: the Career Integration Grant (CIG), a funding scheme of the Marie Curie Actions under the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme. The CIG aimed to reinforce the European Research Area and counter the European brain drain to third countries by supporting the long-term relocation of experienced researchers in EU member states or associated countries. We consider three yearly calls between 2011 and 2013 and explore the effect on the chances of long-term relocation at country and institutional level. We find that obtaining the grant related to greater chances of long-term relocation in the host institution (+9.4%) and country (+8.2%). The grant was particularly effective for applicants’ subcategories that typically have less access to alternative funding sources: (a) nontenured, (b) scientists from soft sciences, (c) non “returnees,” and (d) moving to nonhigh-ranked institutions. We do not find a relationship with the probability of obtaining a tenured position or on scientific productivity.
- Open Access
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in ChemTexts
- Vol. 10 (3) , 1-8
Changes in scientific publishing and possible impact on authors’ choice of journals
Choosing the journal to which submit the results of a scientific work constitutes an important and challenging decision. It is especially crucial to correctly assess the reputation and prospects of the journal. This article describes and comments on the major changes that recently deeply modified the scientific publishing system and analyzes how they potentially undermine the reliability of the bibliometric indicators commonly used to assess a journal’s quality. In view of these elements, some key points are highlighted and discussed that can condition the choice of the journal. The article aims to be especially informative for future scientists navigating the complex world of the current scientific publishing system.
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in ChemTexts
- Vol. 10 (3) , 1-8
Open AccessChanges in scientific publishing and possible impact on authors’ choice of journals
Choosing the journal to which submit the results of a scientific work constitutes an important and challenging decision. It is especially crucial to correctly assess the reputation and prospects of the journal. This article describes and comments on the major changes that recently deeply modified the scientific publishing system and analyzes how they potentially undermine the reliability of the bibliometric indicators commonly used to assess a journal’s quality. In view of these elements, some key points are highlighted and discussed that can condition the choice of the journal. The article aims to be especially informative for future scientists navigating the complex world of the current scientific publishing system.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
Improving the efficiency of research proposals evaluation: A two-stage procedure
An important share of research funding is allocated via competitive programs, which entail considerable direct and indirect costs, such as to develop and evaluate the proposals. The goal of this article is to explore whether adopting a two-stage evaluation procedure could improve the efficiency of the process. For this purpose, we study the evaluation system designed by the Foundation Dam (Stiftelsen Dam), one of the largest foundations in Norway supporting health research. In 2020, Foundation Dam adopted a new evaluation procedure consisting in a short proposal for a first stage of selection and, for those selected, a second-stage evaluation of a long proposal. We explore whether such a procedure reduces the evaluation costs and how the evaluation procedures compare in terms of reliability. Survey responses from 94 of the 594 applicants in the one-stage procedure (2018–19) and all the 668 applicants in the two-stage procedure (2020–21) show that the two-stage procedure reduced the average time that applicants spent in drafting the proposal(s) by 38%. According to the reviewers’ estimate, the two-stage procedure also reduced by 28% the time they spent on average to evaluate an applicant’s proposal(s). The analysis of the evaluation data of 594 long proposals in the one-stage procedure and 668 short proposals in the two-stage procedure shows that reviewers’ scores of short proposals display greater reliability and agreement than the reviewers’ scores of long proposals in the old one-stage procedure. Our findings suggest that a two-stage procedure can substantially improve the efficiency of grant writing and review, without harming the reliability of the evaluation.
- 15 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
Open AccessImproving the efficiency of research proposals evaluation: A two-stage procedure
An important share of research funding is allocated via competitive programs, which entail considerable direct and indirect costs, such as to develop and evaluate the proposals. The goal of this article is to explore whether adopting a two-stage evaluation procedure could improve the efficiency of the process. For this purpose, we study the evaluation system designed by the Foundation Dam (Stiftelsen Dam), one of the largest foundations in Norway supporting health research. In 2020, Foundation Dam adopted a new evaluation procedure consisting in a short proposal for a first stage of selection and, for those selected, a second-stage evaluation of a long proposal. We explore whether such a procedure reduces the evaluation costs and how the evaluation procedures compare in terms of reliability. Survey responses from 94 of the 594 applicants in the one-stage procedure (2018–19) and all the 668 applicants in the two-stage procedure (2020–21) show that the two-stage procedure reduced the average time that applicants spent in drafting the proposal(s) by 38%. According to the reviewers’ estimate, the two-stage procedure also reduced by 28% the time they spent on average to evaluate an applicant’s proposal(s). The analysis of the evaluation data of 594 long proposals in the one-stage procedure and 668 short proposals in the two-stage procedure shows that reviewers’ scores of short proposals display greater reliability and agreement than the reviewers’ scores of long proposals in the old one-stage procedure. Our findings suggest that a two-stage procedure can substantially improve the efficiency of grant writing and review, without harming the reliability of the evaluation.
- Open Access
- 10 May 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Academic publishing business models: self-citations and the selectivity-reputation trade-off
The growth of scientific journals is constrained by a trade-off between selectivity and reputation. A strong reputation attracts submissions but enhancing reputation requires selectivity, meaning many submissions must be rejected. Conversely, lowering selectivity allows journals to publish more papers but also lowers the average quality of published work, undermining reputation and eventually attracting fewer submissions. Because of this trade-off, scientific journals display moderate growth rates. In recent years, however, some publishers whose revenues depend largely on gold open access (OA) article processing charges (APC) have displayed staggering growth rates. One strategy to circumvent the selectivity–reputation trade-off is to inflate self-citations contributing to the journal impact factor (JIF). We investigate the citation flows of 8,360 journals from the 20 largest for-profit publishers included in the Journal Citation Report by Clarivate, over a period of 25 years (1997–2021). Using a gravity model of journal citation flows, we find that Gold OA journals display high self-citation rates, particularly to articles contributing to the JIF. This pattern is much more pronounced among journals owned by two large Gold OA publishers. Moreover, the intensity of self-citations for these two publishers’ journals increased with growth rate, suggesting that self-citations contributed to counteracting a decline in citations resulting from rapid expansion.
- 10 May 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessAcademic publishing business models: self-citations and the selectivity-reputation trade-off
The growth of scientific journals is constrained by a trade-off between selectivity and reputation. A strong reputation attracts submissions but enhancing reputation requires selectivity, meaning many submissions must be rejected. Conversely, lowering selectivity allows journals to publish more papers but also lowers the average quality of published work, undermining reputation and eventually attracting fewer submissions. Because of this trade-off, scientific journals display moderate growth rates. In recent years, however, some publishers whose revenues depend largely on gold open access (OA) article processing charges (APC) have displayed staggering growth rates. One strategy to circumvent the selectivity–reputation trade-off is to inflate self-citations contributing to the journal impact factor (JIF). We investigate the citation flows of 8,360 journals from the 20 largest for-profit publishers included in the Journal Citation Report by Clarivate, over a period of 25 years (1997–2021). Using a gravity model of journal citation flows, we find that Gold OA journals display high self-citation rates, particularly to articles contributing to the JIF. This pattern is much more pronounced among journals owned by two large Gold OA publishers. Moreover, the intensity of self-citations for these two publishers’ journals increased with growth rate, suggesting that self-citations contributed to counteracting a decline in citations resulting from rapid expansion.
- Open Access
- 8 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Higher Education
- Vol. 85 (5) , 1083
Correction to: Exploring the effects of mobility and foreign nationality on internal career progression in universities
- 8 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Higher Education
- Vol. 85 (5) , 1083
Open AccessCorrection to: Exploring the effects of mobility and foreign nationality on internal career progression in universities