Richard P. Nelson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Richard P. Nelson has a total of 293 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Lee Hartmann
University of Michigan
10 shared publications - Oliver Gressel
Leibniz-Institut für Astrophysik Potsdam (AIP)
8 shared publications - Neal Joung Turner
California Institute of Technology
6 shared publications - Alexandros Ziampras
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Universitäts-Sternwarte
4 shared publications - Catherine Espaillat
Department of Astronomy, Boston University
4 shared publications - Moritz Fragner
Astronomy Unit Queen Mary
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 November 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 715, A272
Dust-driven vertical shear instability in an isothermal shearing box
Context . The ‘classical’ vertical shear instability (VSI) is a baroclinic instability that arises from height-dependent azimuthal velocities and is a leading candidate for driving anisotropic turbulence in discs with extended vertical modes. The classical VSI requires fast cooling times and radial temperature gradients, which are absent in an isothermal stratified (barotropic) setup. Aims . We investigate the dust-driven vertical shear instability (DVSI) in an isothermal, stratified shearing box, where the VSI is generated by drag forces acting on the gas due to dust rather than radial thermal stratification. Methods . We constructed two-fluid (gas+dust) vertically stratified equilibria including dust diffusion and use these profiles to initialise 2D (radial–vertical) hydrodynamical simulations with FARGO3D. To separate DVSI from drag instabilities, we employed a ‘dust-analogue’ model in which dust-induced drag on the gas was prescribed as a time-invariant and height-dependent acceleration, such that the underlying spatial distribution of the dust was assumed to be constant. Results . The DVSI grows from regions of strongest vertical shear away from the midplane, exciting predominantly radially short, vertically extended disturbances (large k x / k z ) and producing banded structures in the perturbed azimuthal and vertical velocities during the linear phase. In the non-linear regime, the instability saturates via a Kelvin–Helmholtz-like parasitic instability that breaks the coherent vertical-shear modes into smaller-scale eddies, which balance the growth of the vertically extended modes, driving sustained vertical stirring. Conclusions . Dust-driven vertical shear can drive anisotropic turbulence and vertical mixing in an isothermal model without invoking global thermal gradients and could play an important role in the stratified streaming instability.
- 13 November 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 715, A272
Open AccessDust-driven vertical shear instability in an isothermal shearing box
Context . The ‘classical’ vertical shear instability (VSI) is a baroclinic instability that arises from height-dependent azimuthal velocities and is a leading candidate for driving anisotropic turbulence in discs with extended vertical modes. The classical VSI requires fast cooling times and radial temperature gradients, which are absent in an isothermal stratified (barotropic) setup. Aims . We investigate the dust-driven vertical shear instability (DVSI) in an isothermal, stratified shearing box, where the VSI is generated by drag forces acting on the gas due to dust rather than radial thermal stratification. Methods . We constructed two-fluid (gas+dust) vertically stratified equilibria including dust diffusion and use these profiles to initialise 2D (radial–vertical) hydrodynamical simulations with FARGO3D. To separate DVSI from drag instabilities, we employed a ‘dust-analogue’ model in which dust-induced drag on the gas was prescribed as a time-invariant and height-dependent acceleration, such that the underlying spatial distribution of the dust was assumed to be constant. Results . The DVSI grows from regions of strongest vertical shear away from the midplane, exciting predominantly radially short, vertically extended disturbances (large k x / k z ) and producing banded structures in the perturbed azimuthal and vertical velocities during the linear phase. In the non-linear regime, the instability saturates via a Kelvin–Helmholtz-like parasitic instability that breaks the coherent vertical-shear modes into smaller-scale eddies, which balance the growth of the vertically extended modes, driving sustained vertical stirring. Conclusions . Dust-driven vertical shear can drive anisotropic turbulence and vertical mixing in an isothermal model without invoking global thermal gradients and could play an important role in the stratified streaming instability.
- Open Access
- 11 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 542 (3) , 1685-1704
Halting the migration of super-Earths by efficient gap opening in radiative, low viscosity discs
While planet migration has been extensively studied for classical viscous discs, planet–disc interaction in nearly inviscid discs has mostly been explored with greatly simplified thermodynamics. In such environments, motivated by models of wind-driven accretion discs, even Earth-mass planets located interior to 1 au can significantly perturb the disc, carving gaps and exciting vortices on their edges. Both processes are influenced by radiative transfer, which can both drive baroclinic forcing and influence gap opening. We perform a set of high-resolution radiation hydrodynamics simulations of planet–disc interaction in the feedback and gap-opening regimes, aiming to understand the role of radiation transport in the migration of super-Earth-mass planets representative of the observed exoplanet population. We find that radiative cooling drives baroclinic forcing during multiple stages of the planet’s migration in the feedback regime ($\sim 1.5\, \mathrm{M}_\oplus$), significantly delaying the onset of vortex formation at the gap edge but ultimately resulting in type-III runaway migration episodes. For super-thermal-mass planets ($\sim 6.7\, \mathrm{M}_\oplus$), radiative cooling is fundamentally linked to the gap-opening process, with the planet stalling instead of undergoing vortex-assisted migration as expected from isothermal or adiabatic models. This stalling of migration can only be captured when treating radiative effects, and since it affects super-thermal-mass planets its implications for both the final configuration of planetary systems and population synthesis modelling are potentially huge. Combining our findings with previous related studies, we present a map of migration regimes for radiative, nearly-inviscid discs, with the cooling-mediated gap-opening regime playing a central role in determining the planet’s orbital properties.
- 11 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 542 (3) , 1685-1704
Open AccessHalting the migration of super-Earths by efficient gap opening in radiative, low viscosity discs
While planet migration has been extensively studied for classical viscous discs, planet–disc interaction in nearly inviscid discs has mostly been explored with greatly simplified thermodynamics. In such environments, motivated by models of wind-driven accretion discs, even Earth-mass planets located interior to 1 au can significantly perturb the disc, carving gaps and exciting vortices on their edges. Both processes are influenced by radiative transfer, which can both drive baroclinic forcing and influence gap opening. We perform a set of high-resolution radiation hydrodynamics simulations of planet–disc interaction in the feedback and gap-opening regimes, aiming to understand the role of radiation transport in the migration of super-Earth-mass planets representative of the observed exoplanet population. We find that radiative cooling drives baroclinic forcing during multiple stages of the planet’s migration in the feedback regime ($\sim 1.5\, \mathrm{M}_\oplus$), significantly delaying the onset of vortex formation at the gap edge but ultimately resulting in type-III runaway migration episodes. For super-thermal-mass planets ($\sim 6.7\, \mathrm{M}_\oplus$), radiative cooling is fundamentally linked to the gap-opening process, with the planet stalling instead of undergoing vortex-assisted migration as expected from isothermal or adiabatic models. This stalling of migration can only be captured when treating radiative effects, and since it affects super-thermal-mass planets its implications for both the final configuration of planetary systems and population synthesis modelling are potentially huge. Combining our findings with previous related studies, we present a map of migration regimes for radiative, nearly-inviscid discs, with the cooling-mediated gap-opening regime playing a central role in determining the planet’s orbital properties.
- 3 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-37
Planetary Migration in Protoplanetary Disks
- Open Access
- 6 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 531 (4) , 4085-4098
BEBOP V. Homogeneous stellar analysis of potential circumbinary planet hosts
Planets orbiting binary systems are relatively unexplored compared to those around single stars. Detections of circumbinary planets and planetary systems offer a first detailed view into our understanding of circumbinary planet formation and dynamical evolution. The BEBOP (binaries escorted by orbiting planets) radial velocity survey plays a special role in this adventure as it focuses on eclipsing single-lined binaries with an FGK dwarf primary and M dwarf secondary allowing for the highest radial velocity precision using the HARPS and SOPHIE spectrographs. We obtained 4512 high-resolution spectra for the 179 targets in the BEBOP survey which we used to derive the stellar atmospheric parameters using both equivalent widths and spectral synthesis. We furthermore derive stellar masses, radii, and ages for all targets. With this work, we present the first homogeneous catalogue of precise stellar parameters for these eclipsing single-lined binaries.
- 6 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 531 (4) , 4085-4098
Open AccessBEBOP V. Homogeneous stellar analysis of potential circumbinary planet hosts
Planets orbiting binary systems are relatively unexplored compared to those around single stars. Detections of circumbinary planets and planetary systems offer a first detailed view into our understanding of circumbinary planet formation and dynamical evolution. The BEBOP (binaries escorted by orbiting planets) radial velocity survey plays a special role in this adventure as it focuses on eclipsing single-lined binaries with an FGK dwarf primary and M dwarf secondary allowing for the highest radial velocity precision using the HARPS and SOPHIE spectrographs. We obtained 4512 high-resolution spectra for the 179 targets in the BEBOP survey which we used to derive the stellar atmospheric parameters using both equivalent widths and spectral synthesis. We furthermore derive stellar masses, radii, and ages for all targets. With this work, we present the first homogeneous catalogue of precise stellar parameters for these eclipsing single-lined binaries.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 678, A134
Measuring the numerical viscosity in simulations of protoplanetary disks in Cartesian grids
Context. Hydrodynamical simulations solve the governing equations on a discrete grid of space and time. This discretization causes numerical diffusion similar to a physical viscous diffusion, the magnitude of which is often unknown or poorly constrained. With the current trend of simulating accretion disks with no or very low prescribed physical viscosity, it has become essential to understand and quantify this inherent numerical diffusion in the form of a numerical viscosity. Aims. We study the behavior of the viscous spreading ring and the spiral instability that develops in it. We aim to use this setup to quantify the numerical viscosity in Cartesian grids and study its properties. Methods. We simulated the viscous spreading ring and the related instability on a two-dimensional polar grid using PLUTO as well as FARGO, ensuring the convergence of our results with a resolution study. We then repeated our models on a Cartesian grid and measured the numerical viscosity by comparing results to the known analytical solution using PLUTO and Athena++. Results. We find that the numerical viscosity in a Cartesian grid scales with resolution as approximately vnum ∝ Δx2 and is equivalent to an effective α ~ 10−4 for a common numerical setup. We also showed that the spiral instability manifests as a single leading spiral throughout the whole domain on polar grids. This is contrary to previous results and indicates that sufficient resolution is necessary in order to correctly resolve the instability. Conclusions. Our results are relevant in the context of models where the origin should be included in the computational domain, or when polar grids cannot be used. Examples of such cases include models of disk accretion onto a central binary and, inherently, Cartesian codes.
- 17 October 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 678, A134
Open AccessMeasuring the numerical viscosity in simulations of protoplanetary disks in Cartesian grids
Context. Hydrodynamical simulations solve the governing equations on a discrete grid of space and time. This discretization causes numerical diffusion similar to a physical viscous diffusion, the magnitude of which is often unknown or poorly constrained. With the current trend of simulating accretion disks with no or very low prescribed physical viscosity, it has become essential to understand and quantify this inherent numerical diffusion in the form of a numerical viscosity. Aims. We study the behavior of the viscous spreading ring and the spiral instability that develops in it. We aim to use this setup to quantify the numerical viscosity in Cartesian grids and study its properties. Methods. We simulated the viscous spreading ring and the related instability on a two-dimensional polar grid using PLUTO as well as FARGO, ensuring the convergence of our results with a resolution study. We then repeated our models on a Cartesian grid and measured the numerical viscosity by comparing results to the known analytical solution using PLUTO and Athena++. Results. We find that the numerical viscosity in a Cartesian grid scales with resolution as approximately vnum ∝ Δx2 and is equivalent to an effective α ~ 10−4 for a common numerical setup. We also showed that the spiral instability manifests as a single leading spiral throughout the whole domain on polar grids. This is contrary to previous results and indicates that sufficient resolution is necessary in order to correctly resolve the instability. Conclusions. Our results are relevant in the context of models where the origin should be included in the computational domain, or when polar grids cannot be used. Examples of such cases include models of disk accretion onto a central binary and, inherently, Cartesian codes.
- 12 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 7 (6) , 702-714
Radial-velocity discovery of a second planet in the TOI-1338/BEBOP-1 circumbinary system
- 12 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 7 (6) , 702-714
Radial-velocity discovery of a second planet in the TOI-1338/BEBOP-1 circumbinary system
- Open Access
- 20 February 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 670, A135
Hydrodynamic turbulence in disks with embedded planets
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then measured its accretion and mixing capabilities by comparing the full Reynolds stress, which includes the contribution of nonaxisymmetric features, such as spiral arms and vortices, to the Reynolds stress due to the azimuthally averaged velocity field, which can be attributed to good approximation to the VSI. We verified that the VSI can contribute to the accretion stress and showed that, depending on disk conditions, an embedded planet can coexist with or suppress VSI turbulent stress. Specifically, the presence of spiral shocks launched by a planet or planet-generated vortices can interfere with the VSI near the planet’s vicinity, with the instability recovering at large enough distances from the planet or vortex. Our results suggest that observations of VSI signatures are unlikely in disks that contain massive, nonaxisymmetric features.
- 20 February 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 670, A135
Open AccessHydrodynamic turbulence in disks with embedded planets
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then measured its accretion and mixing capabilities by comparing the full Reynolds stress, which includes the contribution of nonaxisymmetric features, such as spiral arms and vortices, to the Reynolds stress due to the azimuthally averaged velocity field, which can be attributed to good approximation to the VSI. We verified that the VSI can contribute to the accretion stress and showed that, depending on disk conditions, an embedded planet can coexist with or suppress VSI turbulent stress. Specifically, the presence of spiral shocks launched by a planet or planet-generated vortices can interfere with the VSI near the planet’s vicinity, with the instability recovering at large enough distances from the planet or vortex. Our results suggest that observations of VSI signatures are unlikely in disks that contain massive, nonaxisymmetric features.
- Open Access
- 15 February 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 670, A113
Gas accretion onto Jupiter mass planets in discs with laminar accretion flows
Context. Numerous studies have shown that a gap-forming Jovian mass planet embedded in a protoplanetary disc, in which a turbulent viscosity operates, can accrete gas efficiently through the gap, and for typical parameters it doubles its mass in ~0.1 Myr. The planet also migrates inwards on a timescale that is closely related to the local viscous evolution timescale, which is also typically 0.1 Myr. These timescales are short compared to protoplanetary disc lifetimes, and raise questions about the origins of the cold gas giant exoplanets that have been discovered in abundance. It is understood that protoplanetary discs are unlikely to be globally turbulent, and instead they may launch magnetised winds such that accretion towards the star occurs in laminar accretion flows located in narrow layers near the surfaces of the disc. Aims. The aim of this study is to examine the rate at which gas accretes onto Jovian mass planets that are embedded in layered protoplanetary discs, and to compare the results with those obtained for viscous models. Methods. We use 3D hydrodynamical simulations of planets embedded in protoplanetary discs, in which a constant radial mass flux towards the star of ṁ = 10−8 M⊙ yr−1 is sustained. We consider a classical viscous α disc model, and also models in which an external torque is applied in narrow surface layers to mimic the effects of a magnetised wind. The accreting layers have a variety of depths, as parameterised by their column densities ΣA, and we consider values of ΣA in the range 0.1−10 g cm−2. Results. The viscous disc model gives results in agreement with previous studies. In accord with our recent work that examines the migration of Jovian mass planets in layered models, we find the accretion rate onto the planet in the layered models crucially depends on the ability of the planet to block the wind-induced mass flow towards the star. For ΣA = 10 g cm−2, the planet torque can block the mass flow in disc, accretion onto the planet is slow, and a mass doubling time of 10 Myr is obtained. For ΣA = 0.1 g cm−2, the flow is not blocked, accretion is fast, and the mass doubling time is 0.2 Myr. Conclusions. Our results show that although the radial mass flow through the layered disc models is always 10−8 M⊙ yr−1, adopting different values of ΣA leads to very different gas accretion rates onto embedded gas giant planets.
- 15 February 2023
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 670, A113
Open AccessGas accretion onto Jupiter mass planets in discs with laminar accretion flows
Context. Numerous studies have shown that a gap-forming Jovian mass planet embedded in a protoplanetary disc, in which a turbulent viscosity operates, can accrete gas efficiently through the gap, and for typical parameters it doubles its mass in ~0.1 Myr. The planet also migrates inwards on a timescale that is closely related to the local viscous evolution timescale, which is also typically 0.1 Myr. These timescales are short compared to protoplanetary disc lifetimes, and raise questions about the origins of the cold gas giant exoplanets that have been discovered in abundance. It is understood that protoplanetary discs are unlikely to be globally turbulent, and instead they may launch magnetised winds such that accretion towards the star occurs in laminar accretion flows located in narrow layers near the surfaces of the disc. Aims. The aim of this study is to examine the rate at which gas accretes onto Jovian mass planets that are embedded in layered protoplanetary discs, and to compare the results with those obtained for viscous models. Methods. We use 3D hydrodynamical simulations of planets embedded in protoplanetary discs, in which a constant radial mass flux towards the star of ṁ = 10−8 M⊙ yr−1 is sustained. We consider a classical viscous α disc model, and also models in which an external torque is applied in narrow surface layers to mimic the effects of a magnetised wind. The accreting layers have a variety of depths, as parameterised by their column densities ΣA, and we consider values of ΣA in the range 0.1−10 g cm−2. Results. The viscous disc model gives results in agreement with previous studies. In accord with our recent work that examines the migration of Jovian mass planets in layered models, we find the accretion rate onto the planet in the layered models crucially depends on the ability of the planet to block the wind-induced mass flow towards the star. For ΣA = 10 g cm−2, the planet torque can block the mass flow in disc, accretion onto the planet is slow, and a mass doubling time of 10 Myr is obtained. For ΣA = 0.1 g cm−2, the flow is not blocked, accretion is fast, and the mass doubling time is 0.2 Myr. Conclusions. Our results show that although the radial mass flow through the layered disc models is always 10−8 M⊙ yr−1, adopting different values of ΣA leads to very different gas accretion rates onto embedded gas giant planets.
- Open Access
Hydrodynamic turbulence in disks with embedded planets
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then measured its accretion and mixing capabilities by comparing the full Reynolds stress, which includes the contribution of nonaxisymmetric features, such as spiral arms and vortices, to the Reynolds stress due to the azimuthally averaged velocity field, which can be attributed to good approximation to the VSI. We verified that the VSI can contribute to the accretion stress and showed that, depending on disk conditions, an embedded planet can coexist with or suppress VSI turbulent stress. Specifically, the presence of spiral shocks launched by a planet or planet-generated vortices can interfere with the VSI near the planet's vicinity, with the instability recovering at large enough distances from the planet or vortex. Our results suggest that observations of VSI signatures are unlikely in disks that contain massive, nonaxisymmetric features.
Open AccessHydrodynamic turbulence in disks with embedded planets
The vertical shear instability (VSI) is a source of hydrodynamic turbulence that can drive vigorous vertical mixing and moderate levels of accretion in protoplanetary disks, and it could be observable in the near future. With high-resolution three-dimensional numerical hydrodynamics simulations, we modeled the behavior of the VSI in protoplanetary disks with and without embedded planets. We then measured its accretion and mixing capabilities by comparing the full Reynolds stress, which includes the contribution of nonaxisymmetric features, such as spiral arms and vortices, to the Reynolds stress due to the azimuthally averaged velocity field, which can be attributed to good approximation to the VSI. We verified that the VSI can contribute to the accretion stress and showed that, depending on disk conditions, an embedded planet can coexist with or suppress VSI turbulent stress. Specifically, the presence of spiral shocks launched by a planet or planet-generated vortices can interfere with the VSI near the planet's vicinity, with the instability recovering at large enough distances from the planet or vortex. Our results suggest that observations of VSI signatures are unlikely in disks that contain massive, nonaxisymmetric features.
- Open Access
Gas accretion onto Jupiter mass planets in discs with laminar accretion flows
(Abridged) Studies have shown that a Jovian mass planet embedded in a viscous protoplanetary disc (PPD) can accrete gas efficiently through the gap and doubles its mass in $\sim 0.1$ Myr. The planet also migrates inwards on a timescale of $\sim 0.1$ Myr. These timescales are short compared to PPD lifetimes, and raise questions about the origins of cold giant exoplanets. However, PPDs are unlikely to be globally turbulent, and instead they may launch magnetised winds such that accretion towards the star occurs in laminar accretion flows located in narrow layers near the surfaces of the disc. The aim of this study is to examine the rate at which gas accretes onto Jovian mass planets that are embedded in layered PPDs. We use 3D hydrodynamical simulations of planets embedded in PPDs, in which a constant radial mass flux towards the star of ${\dot m} = 10^{-8}$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$ is sustained. We consider a classical viscous alpha model, and also models in which an external torque is applied in narrow surface layers to mimic the effects of a magnetised wind. The accreting layers are parameterised by their column densities $\Sigma_{\rm A}$, and we consider values in the range 0.1 to 10 g cm$^{-2}$. The viscous model gives results in agreement with previous studies. We find the accretion rate onto the planet in the layered models crucially depends on the planet's ability to block the wind-induced mass flow. For $\Sigma_{\rm A}=10$ g cm$^{-2}$, the planet torque can block the mass flow through the disc, accretion onto the planet is slow, and a mass doubling time of 10 Myr is obtained. For $\Sigma_{\rm A}=0.1$ g cm$^{-2}$, accretion is fast and the mass doubling time is 0.2 Myr. Although the radial mass flow through the layered disc models is always $10^{-8}$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$, adopting different values of $\Sigma_{\rm A}$ leads to very different gas accretion rates onto gas giant planets.Open AccessGas accretion onto Jupiter mass planets in discs with laminar accretion flows
(Abridged) Studies have shown that a Jovian mass planet embedded in a viscous protoplanetary disc (PPD) can accrete gas efficiently through the gap and doubles its mass in $\sim 0.1$ Myr. The planet also migrates inwards on a timescale of $\sim 0.1$ Myr. These timescales are short compared to PPD lifetimes, and raise questions about the origins of cold giant exoplanets. However, PPDs are unlikely to be globally turbulent, and instead they may launch magnetised winds such that accretion towards the star occurs in laminar accretion flows located in narrow layers near the surfaces of the disc. The aim of this study is to examine the rate at which gas accretes onto Jovian mass planets that are embedded in layered PPDs. We use 3D hydrodynamical simulations of planets embedded in PPDs, in which a constant radial mass flux towards the star of ${\dot m} = 10^{-8}$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$ is sustained. We consider a classical viscous alpha model, and also models in which an external torque is applied in narrow surface layers to mimic the effects of a magnetised wind. The accreting layers are parameterised by their column densities $\Sigma_{\rm A}$, and we consider values in the range 0.1 to 10 g cm$^{-2}$. The viscous model gives results in agreement with previous studies. We find the accretion rate onto the planet in the layered models crucially depends on the planet's ability to block the wind-induced mass flow. For $\Sigma_{\rm A}=10$ g cm$^{-2}$, the planet torque can block the mass flow through the disc, accretion onto the planet is slow, and a mass doubling time of 10 Myr is obtained. For $\Sigma_{\rm A}=0.1$ g cm$^{-2}$, accretion is fast and the mass doubling time is 0.2 Myr. Although the radial mass flow through the layered disc models is always $10^{-8}$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$, adopting different values of $\Sigma_{\rm A}$ leads to very different gas accretion rates onto gas giant planets.