Tamar R. Makin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tamar R. Makin has a total of 262 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heidi Johansen-Berg
University of Oxford
15 shared publications David Henderson Slater
Oxford Centre for Enablement, Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre
9 shared publicationsIrene Tracey
WIN Centre, University of Oxford
9 shared publications- Roni Or Maimon-Mor
Institute of Ophthalmology, University College London, London, United Kingdom
9 shared publications - Nicholas Paul Holmes
School of Sport, Exercise and Rehabilitation Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
8 shared publications Dani Clode
MRC Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Sensory and Motor Building Blocks of an Extra Robotic Digit Representation
Supernumerary limbs provide a unique opportunity to ask how the brain represents an entirely novel effector within an existing sensorimotor system. Here, we investigated how primary motor cortex (M1) represents a robotic extra digit (the Third Thumb; Dani Clode Design), and how this representation changes with experience. Using fMRI, we compared participants following short-term exposure with participants who had undergone longitudinal Third Thumb training. The device was controlled by the toes but operated alongside the biological fingers, while its sensory consequences were experienced on the hand. Following prolonged experience, greater activity was elicited in the M1 hand area both during Third Thumb control, and in response to its sensory consequences alone. Multivariate analyses showed that the Third Thumb representation became more distinct from its biological toe controller. Pattern component modelling further showed that the representation could be explained by a combination of its constituent motor and sensory patterns, but their relative contributions changed substantially with experience, from toe-dominated following short-term exposure to sensory-dominated following longitudinal training. These findings suggest that M1 can represent a novel effector through flexible recombination of existing sensorimotor representations, with experience altering how these pre-existing resources contribute to the emerging representation.
Open AccessSensory and Motor Building Blocks of an Extra Robotic Digit Representation
Supernumerary limbs provide a unique opportunity to ask how the brain represents an entirely novel effector within an existing sensorimotor system. Here, we investigated how primary motor cortex (M1) represents a robotic extra digit (the Third Thumb; Dani Clode Design), and how this representation changes with experience. Using fMRI, we compared participants following short-term exposure with participants who had undergone longitudinal Third Thumb training. The device was controlled by the toes but operated alongside the biological fingers, while its sensory consequences were experienced on the hand. Following prolonged experience, greater activity was elicited in the M1 hand area both during Third Thumb control, and in response to its sensory consequences alone. Multivariate analyses showed that the Third Thumb representation became more distinct from its biological toe controller. Pattern component modelling further showed that the representation could be explained by a combination of its constituent motor and sensory patterns, but their relative contributions changed substantially with experience, from toe-dominated following short-term exposure to sensory-dominated following longitudinal training. These findings suggest that M1 can represent a novel effector through flexible recombination of existing sensorimotor representations, with experience altering how these pre-existing resources contribute to the emerging representation.
- Open Access
Spatial localisation of touch on a robotic limb in the absence of direct haptic feedback
Artificial limbs typically lack somatosensory receptors, limiting users' access to haptic feedback about movement outcomes. However, indirect tactile signals generated during object interaction are transmitted to the body-limb interface and may serve as a haptic feedback source. This study investigates whether such indirect tactile signals convey distinct information that can support localisation of touch on an artificial body part. Using an additional robotic thumb (The Third Thumb, Dani Clode Design), we measured tactile signals at the interface between the Third Thumb and the hand following stimulation from four vibration motors positioned along the Thumb. We then assessed whether participants could discriminate these signals and integrate them with different Thumb postures to spatially localise touch. Measurements showed that each stimulation site produced distinct tactile signatures at the interface. Behaviourally, participants localised touch at above-chance levels. Representational similarity analyses further revealed that performance was best explained by the spatial positions of stimuli, rather than by limb-based coordinates or indirect signal patterns alone, indicating flexible mapping of indirect touch signals onto the Third Thumb posture. Together, these findings demonstrate that indirect tactile signals transmitted through an artificial limb can be discriminated and flexibly remapped to support spatial localisation of touch.
Open AccessSpatial localisation of touch on a robotic limb in the absence of direct haptic feedback
Artificial limbs typically lack somatosensory receptors, limiting users' access to haptic feedback about movement outcomes. However, indirect tactile signals generated during object interaction are transmitted to the body-limb interface and may serve as a haptic feedback source. This study investigates whether such indirect tactile signals convey distinct information that can support localisation of touch on an artificial body part. Using an additional robotic thumb (The Third Thumb, Dani Clode Design), we measured tactile signals at the interface between the Third Thumb and the hand following stimulation from four vibration motors positioned along the Thumb. We then assessed whether participants could discriminate these signals and integrate them with different Thumb postures to spatially localise touch. Measurements showed that each stimulation site produced distinct tactile signatures at the interface. Behaviourally, participants localised touch at above-chance levels. Representational similarity analyses further revealed that performance was best explained by the spatial positions of stimuli, rather than by limb-based coordinates or indirect signal patterns alone, indicating flexible mapping of indirect touch signals onto the Third Thumb posture. Together, these findings demonstrate that indirect tactile signals transmitted through an artificial limb can be discriminated and flexibly remapped to support spatial localisation of touch.
- Open Access
- 27 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Current Biology
- Vol. 36 (5) , 1339-1346.e4
Broad skill generalization with an extra robotic body part
- 27 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Current Biology
- Vol. 36 (5) , 1339-1346.e4
Open AccessBroad skill generalization with an extra robotic body part
- Open Access
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 1591
Global remapping of the sensory homunculus emerges early in childhood development
Some of the most dramatic examples of neuroplasticity in the human brain follow congenital sensory deprivation, yet the plasticity mechanisms producing this large-scale cortical remapping remain poorly understood. Congenital malformation of the upper-limb provides a unique temporal dissociation of developmental plasticity mechanisms: While sensory deprivation from the absent hand is triggered before birth, compensatory motor behaviours develop gradually throughout childhood. Using paediatric neuroimaging and semi-ecological behavioural analysis in children (5-7 years old) and adults (>25 years old) with unilateral upper-limb congenital limb difference, we studied deprivation- and use-dependent plasticity in the deprived primary somatosensory cortex and beyond. We reveal that global remapping, encompassing the entire sensory homunculus, is established early and maintained in adulthood. Modelling indicates that deprivation-driven homeostatic plasticity can account for this global remapping. Hebbian-based compensatory learning further contributes to the magnitude of inter-individual differences observed at both childhood and adulthood. Our findings emphasise the early establishment and stability of cortical maps, despite extensive daily-life behavioural adaptation.
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 1591
Open AccessGlobal remapping of the sensory homunculus emerges early in childhood development
Some of the most dramatic examples of neuroplasticity in the human brain follow congenital sensory deprivation, yet the plasticity mechanisms producing this large-scale cortical remapping remain poorly understood. Congenital malformation of the upper-limb provides a unique temporal dissociation of developmental plasticity mechanisms: While sensory deprivation from the absent hand is triggered before birth, compensatory motor behaviours develop gradually throughout childhood. Using paediatric neuroimaging and semi-ecological behavioural analysis in children (5-7 years old) and adults (>25 years old) with unilateral upper-limb congenital limb difference, we studied deprivation- and use-dependent plasticity in the deprived primary somatosensory cortex and beyond. We reveal that global remapping, encompassing the entire sensory homunculus, is established early and maintained in adulthood. Modelling indicates that deprivation-driven homeostatic plasticity can account for this global remapping. Hebbian-based compensatory learning further contributes to the magnitude of inter-individual differences observed at both childhood and adulthood. Our findings emphasise the early establishment and stability of cortical maps, despite extensive daily-life behavioural adaptation.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Haptics
- Vol. 18 (4) , 821-824
From Restoration to Augmentation: New Approaches to Haptic Feedback for Artificial Limbs
Haptic feedback is essential for precise motor control, making its integration into artificial limbs a critical design challenge. Current approaches to restoring lost tactile input in patients have focused on interfacing with somatosensory pathways at the brain, nerve, or skin level, achieving partial restoration. However, augmentative artificial limbs, devices that provide novel movement capabilities beyond the biological body, pose unique challenges. These limbs lack dedicated sensory pathways, raising fundamental questions about how to deliver tactile feedback for these devices without disrupting existing somatosensory function. A promising direction lies in exploiting intrinsic tactile feedback, which emerges naturally at the interface between wearable devices and the body. When an artificial limb moves or interacts with objects, the skin detects rich tactile cues transmitted through this interface. Amplifying and refining this intrinsic feedback, via materials optimized for transmission of tactile signals and wearable designs, could enable more intuitive and interpretable haptic feedback for augmentative limbs. This approach offers a pathway toward enhancing embodiment and motor control of augmentative artificial limbs.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Haptics
- Vol. 18 (4) , 821-824
From Restoration to Augmentation: New Approaches to Haptic Feedback for Artificial Limbs
Haptic feedback is essential for precise motor control, making its integration into artificial limbs a critical design challenge. Current approaches to restoring lost tactile input in patients have focused on interfacing with somatosensory pathways at the brain, nerve, or skin level, achieving partial restoration. However, augmentative artificial limbs, devices that provide novel movement capabilities beyond the biological body, pose unique challenges. These limbs lack dedicated sensory pathways, raising fundamental questions about how to deliver tactile feedback for these devices without disrupting existing somatosensory function. A promising direction lies in exploiting intrinsic tactile feedback, which emerges naturally at the interface between wearable devices and the body. When an artificial limb moves or interacts with objects, the skin detects rich tactile cues transmitted through this interface. Amplifying and refining this intrinsic feedback, via materials optimized for transmission of tactile signals and wearable designs, could enable more intuitive and interpretable haptic feedback for augmentative limbs. This approach offers a pathway toward enhancing embodiment and motor control of augmentative artificial limbs.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1)
Wearable technologies for assisted mobility in the real world
Mobility impairments from aging, injury, or medical conditions limit independence and social participation. Conventional assistive devices lack adaptability in complex environments. Recent wearable technologies integrating neural sensing, electronics, and co-design offer personalized, responsive mobility support. This perspective focuses on advances in wearable sensing and multimodal fusion for intent recognition, environmental interaction, and adaptive control in exoskeletons, prosthetics, smart wheelchairs, and navigation systems. Emphasizing human-in-the-loop and cognitive–sensorimotor integration, it outlines emerging trends and challenges, promoting intelligent, user-centered solutions to restore function and enhance autonomy, accessibility, and inclusion for individuals with mobility impairments.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessWearable technologies for assisted mobility in the real world
Mobility impairments from aging, injury, or medical conditions limit independence and social participation. Conventional assistive devices lack adaptability in complex environments. Recent wearable technologies integrating neural sensing, electronics, and co-design offer personalized, responsive mobility support. This perspective focuses on advances in wearable sensing and multimodal fusion for intent recognition, environmental interaction, and adaptive control in exoskeletons, prosthetics, smart wheelchairs, and navigation systems. Emphasizing human-in-the-loop and cognitive–sensorimotor integration, it outlines emerging trends and challenges, promoting intelligent, user-centered solutions to restore function and enhance autonomy, accessibility, and inclusion for individuals with mobility impairments.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 21 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Neuroscience
- Vol. 28 (10) , 2015-2021
Stable cortical body maps before and after arm amputation
The adult brain’s capacity for cortical reorganization remains debated. Using longitudinal neuroimaging in three adults, followed before and up to 5 years after arm amputation, we compared cortical activity elicited by movement of the hand (before amputation) versus phantom hand (after amputation) and lips (before and after amputation). We observed stable cortical representations of both hand and lips in primary sensorimotor regions. By directly quantifying activity changes across amputation, we demonstrate that amputation does not trigger large-scale cortical reorganization.
- 21 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Neuroscience
- Vol. 28 (10) , 2015-2021
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessStable cortical body maps before and after arm amputation
The adult brain’s capacity for cortical reorganization remains debated. Using longitudinal neuroimaging in three adults, followed before and up to 5 years after arm amputation, we compared cortical activity elicited by movement of the hand (before amputation) versus phantom hand (after amputation) and lips (before and after amputation). We observed stable cortical representations of both hand and lips in primary sensorimotor regions. By directly quantifying activity changes across amputation, we demonstrate that amputation does not trigger large-scale cortical reorganization.
- Open Access
Motor Learning Outside the Body: Broad Skill Generalisation with an Extra Robotic Limb
Our ability to transfer motor skills across tools and contexts is what makes modern technology usable. The success of motor augmentation devices, such as supernumerary robotic limbs, hinges on users’ capacity for generalised motor performance. We trained participants over seven days to use an extra robotic thumb (Third Thumb, Dani Clode Design), worn on the right hand and controlled via the toes. We tested whether motor learning was confined to the specific tasks and body parts involved in controlling and interacting with the Third Thumb, or whether it could generalise beyond them. Participants showed broad skill generalisation across tasks, body postures, and even when either the Third Thumb or the controller was reassigned to a different body part, suggesting the development of abstract, body-independent motor representations. Training also reduced cognitive demands and increased the sense of agency over the device. However, participants still preferred using their biological hand over the Third Thumb when given the option, suggesting that factors beyond motor skill generalisation, cognitive effort, and embodiment must be addressed to support the real-world adoption of such technologies.
Open AccessMotor Learning Outside the Body: Broad Skill Generalisation with an Extra Robotic Limb
Our ability to transfer motor skills across tools and contexts is what makes modern technology usable. The success of motor augmentation devices, such as supernumerary robotic limbs, hinges on users’ capacity for generalised motor performance. We trained participants over seven days to use an extra robotic thumb (Third Thumb, Dani Clode Design), worn on the right hand and controlled via the toes. We tested whether motor learning was confined to the specific tasks and body parts involved in controlling and interacting with the Third Thumb, or whether it could generalise beyond them. Participants showed broad skill generalisation across tasks, body postures, and even when either the Third Thumb or the controller was reassigned to a different body part, suggesting the development of abstract, body-independent motor representations. Training also reduced cognitive demands and increased the sense of agency over the device. However, participants still preferred using their biological hand over the Third Thumb when given the option, suggesting that factors beyond motor skill generalisation, cognitive effort, and embodiment must be addressed to support the real-world adoption of such technologies.
- Open Access
Muscle control of an extra robotic digit
Controlling an extra robotic finger requires the brain to adapt existing motor signals. While most current strategies exploit physical movement, there is growing interest in harnessing muscle activity directly via surface electromyography (EMG) as a more seamless interface. We systematically compared muscle- (EMG) and movement-based (force sensor) control of a Third Thumb. Using identical instructions and a counterbalanced within-participants design, we assessed initial skill, learning, and cognitive load across a variety of tasks, enabling a blinded comparison across control modalities. Both control modalities afforded successful Third Thumb control and learning, although force control consistently delivered better performance. Despite execution differences, learning rates and cognitive loads were comparable, with a similar evoked sense of agency. Signal analyses showed performance was predicted by real-time force sensor parameters but not by EMG, reflecting distinct control dynamics. Nonetheless, EMG training led to greater skill transfer to force control, suggesting it may better support generalisable learning. These findings challenge the assumption that proximity to neural signals ensures better control. Although EMG underperformed in execution, it showed unique advantages, including enhanced generalisation and access to richer signals, highlighting the need for improved real-time decoding to fully exploit its potential.
Open AccessMuscle control of an extra robotic digit
Controlling an extra robotic finger requires the brain to adapt existing motor signals. While most current strategies exploit physical movement, there is growing interest in harnessing muscle activity directly via surface electromyography (EMG) as a more seamless interface. We systematically compared muscle- (EMG) and movement-based (force sensor) control of a Third Thumb. Using identical instructions and a counterbalanced within-participants design, we assessed initial skill, learning, and cognitive load across a variety of tasks, enabling a blinded comparison across control modalities. Both control modalities afforded successful Third Thumb control and learning, although force control consistently delivered better performance. Despite execution differences, learning rates and cognitive loads were comparable, with a similar evoked sense of agency. Signal analyses showed performance was predicted by real-time force sensor parameters but not by EMG, reflecting distinct control dynamics. Nonetheless, EMG training led to greater skill transfer to force control, suggesting it may better support generalisable learning. These findings challenge the assumption that proximity to neural signals ensures better control. Although EMG underperformed in execution, it showed unique advantages, including enhanced generalisation and access to richer signals, highlighting the need for improved real-time decoding to fully exploit its potential.
- Open Access
Developing a Sensory Representation of an Artificial Body Part
Somatosensory feedback is essential for motor control, yet artificial limbs are thought to lack such feedback. We investigated how the body and brain gather informative sensory signals from a wearable augmentation interface (a robotic digit for motor augmentation), and whether naturally-mediated feedback can support technological embodiment. Participants intuitively interpreted natural feedback across perceptual tasks, performing comparably to state-of-the-art artificial feedback systems. fMRI revealed an immediate and distinct, topographically-organised representation of the robotic digit. After longitudinal training, this representation was further refined, becoming more similar to the biological digits, which correlated with increased subjective somatosensory embodiment. Our findings demonstrate that wearable devices naturally provide a powerful source of feedback which is immediately integrated with our body. Long-term use can then promote device-embodiment across the sensorimotor hierarchy.
Open AccessDeveloping a Sensory Representation of an Artificial Body Part
Somatosensory feedback is essential for motor control, yet artificial limbs are thought to lack such feedback. We investigated how the body and brain gather informative sensory signals from a wearable augmentation interface (a robotic digit for motor augmentation), and whether naturally-mediated feedback can support technological embodiment. Participants intuitively interpreted natural feedback across perceptual tasks, performing comparably to state-of-the-art artificial feedback systems. fMRI revealed an immediate and distinct, topographically-organised representation of the robotic digit. After longitudinal training, this representation was further refined, becoming more similar to the biological digits, which correlated with increased subjective somatosensory embodiment. Our findings demonstrate that wearable devices naturally provide a powerful source of feedback which is immediately integrated with our body. Long-term use can then promote device-embodiment across the sensorimotor hierarchy.