Sheina Koffler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Sheina Koffler has a total of 81 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Antonio Mauro Saraiva
Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
10 shared publications - Natalia Pirani Ghilardi-Lopes
Universidade Federal do ABC
9 shared publications - Rodolfo Jaffé
Instituto Tecnológico Vale, Belém, Brazil
5 shared publications - Tiago Mauricio Francoy
Escola de Artes, Ciências e Humanidades, Universidade de São Paulo
5 shared publications - Aline Martins de Carvalho
University of São Paulo
4 shared publications - Astrid de Matos Peixoto Kleinert
Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Apidologie
- Vol. 55 (3) , 1-19
Resin foraging interactions in stingless bees: an ecological synthesis using multilayer networks
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Apidologie
- Vol. 55 (3) , 1-19
Resin foraging interactions in stingless bees: an ecological synthesis using multilayer networks
- Open Access
- 21 February 2024
- Published by GigaScience Press in Gigabyte
- Vol. 2024, 1-16
Citizen science data on urban forageable plants: a case study in Brazil
This paper presents two key data sets derived from the Pomar Urbano project. The first data set is a comprehensive catalog of edible fruit-bearing plant species, native or introduced to Brazil. The second data set, sourced from the iNaturalist platform, tracks the distribution and monitoring of these plants within urban landscapes across Brazil. The study includes data from the capitals of all 27 federative units of Brazil, focusing on the ten cities that contributed the most observations as of August 2023. The research emphasizes the significance of citizen science in urban biodiversity monitoring and its potential to contribute to various fields, including food and nutrition, creative industry, study of plant phenology, and machine learning applications. We expect the data sets presented in this paper to serve as resources for further studies in urban foraging, food security, cultural ecosystem services, and environmental sustainability.
- 21 February 2024
- Published by GigaScience Press in Gigabyte
- Vol. 2024, 1-16
Open AccessCitizen science data on urban forageable plants: a case study in Brazil
This paper presents two key data sets derived from the Pomar Urbano project. The first data set is a comprehensive catalog of edible fruit-bearing plant species, native or introduced to Brazil. The second data set, sourced from the iNaturalist platform, tracks the distribution and monitoring of these plants within urban landscapes across Brazil. The study includes data from the capitals of all 27 federative units of Brazil, focusing on the ten cities that contributed the most observations as of August 2023. The research emphasizes the significance of citizen science in urban biodiversity monitoring and its potential to contribute to various fields, including food and nutrition, creative industry, study of plant phenology, and machine learning applications. We expect the data sets presented in this paper to serve as resources for further studies in urban foraging, food security, cultural ecosystem services, and environmental sustainability.
- Open Access
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in GigaScience
- Vol. 13
Leveraging citizen science for monitoring urban forageable plants
Urbanization brings forth social challenges in emerging countries such as Brazil, encompassing food scarcity, health deterioration, air pollution, and biodiversity loss. Despite this, urban areas like the city of São Paulo still boast ample green spaces, offering opportunities for nature appreciation and conservation, enhancing city resilience and livability. Citizen science is a collaborative endeavor between professional scientists and nonprofessional scientists in scientific research that may help to understand the dynamics of urban ecosystems. We believe citizen science has the potential to promote human and nature connection in urban areas and provide useful data on urban biodiversity.
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in GigaScience
- Vol. 13
Open AccessLeveraging citizen science for monitoring urban forageable plants
Urbanization brings forth social challenges in emerging countries such as Brazil, encompassing food scarcity, health deterioration, air pollution, and biodiversity loss. Despite this, urban areas like the city of São Paulo still boast ample green spaces, offering opportunities for nature appreciation and conservation, enhancing city resilience and livability. Citizen science is a collaborative endeavor between professional scientists and nonprofessional scientists in scientific research that may help to understand the dynamics of urban ecosystems. We believe citizen science has the potential to promote human and nature connection in urban areas and provide useful data on urban biodiversity.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2023
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais
Cartilha para quem ensina: material de apoio do livreto didático: “Detetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?”
"A Saúde Planetária é uma área de estudo que reúne de forma interdisciplinar a saúde humana e suas relações com a saúde dos ecossistemas. Embora seja um campo em grande expansão frente aos desafios das mudanças globais recentes, trata-se de um assunto ainda pouco abordado no ensino básico e em escolas. Para suprir esta lacuna, nesta cartilha tratamos o tema da Segurança e Soberania Alimentar sob a perspectiva da Saúde Planetária. O material serve de apoio ao livreto didático “Detetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?”, que traz uma Sequência Didática para estudantes do Ensino Fundamental II. Assim, a presente cartilha traz subsídios teóricos e práticos para aplicação da sequência didática por professores em sala de aula, bem como possibilita adaptações ao contexto e realidade de cada escola. Os temas abordados incluem: ciência cidadã, ensino por investigação, educomunicação, segurança e soberania alimentar e nutricional."
- 10 October 2023
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais
Open AccessCartilha para quem ensina: material de apoio do livreto didático: “Detetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?”
"A Saúde Planetária é uma área de estudo que reúne de forma interdisciplinar a saúde humana e suas relações com a saúde dos ecossistemas. Embora seja um campo em grande expansão frente aos desafios das mudanças globais recentes, trata-se de um assunto ainda pouco abordado no ensino básico e em escolas. Para suprir esta lacuna, nesta cartilha tratamos o tema da Segurança e Soberania Alimentar sob a perspectiva da Saúde Planetária. O material serve de apoio ao livreto didático “Detetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?”, que traz uma Sequência Didática para estudantes do Ensino Fundamental II. Assim, a presente cartilha traz subsídios teóricos e práticos para aplicação da sequência didática por professores em sala de aula, bem como possibilita adaptações ao contexto e realidade de cada escola. Os temas abordados incluem: ciência cidadã, ensino por investigação, educomunicação, segurança e soberania alimentar e nutricional."
- Open Access
- 10 October 2023
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais
Detetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?
Antes de começar nossa caminhada no tema da alimentação, é importante que você compreenda um pouco mais sobre quem somos e o que estamos abordando aqui neste livreto. Quem somos? As pessoas que começaram a escrever este livreto fazem parte do Clube Brasileiro de Saúde Planetária (CBSP). Fazem parte desse clube estudantes universitários de todo o país e de praticamente todas as áreas de estudo! E tem mais: essa iniciativa só construiu esse material por causa do apoio de muitas pessoas, inclusive de fora do clube. E isso já nos leva a responder à segunda pergunta. O que estamos abordando aqui? Este livreto é fruto de uma decisão coletiva, baseada na união de pessoas que decidiram agir em defesa da saúde das pessoas e do planeta. E sim, esse é um trabalho gigante! Mas, trabalhando em equipe, não é tão difícil assim! Inclusive porque já existem cientistas falando que, na verdade, a saúde das pessoas e a do planeta é a mesma! Olha o que eles falam: Saúde Planetária é sobre alcançar o maior padrão possível de saúde, bem-estar e equidade em todo o mundo, com atenção aos sistemas humanos — políticos, econômicos e sociais — que definem o futuro da humanidade e dos sistemas naturais da Terra, estabelecendo limites ambientais para que a humanidade possa florescer. Essa grande aliança pela saúde planetária é o que faz a nossa força. E isso nos leva a entendermos o porquê de produzirmos este livreto: porque precisamos cada vez mais de pessoas defendendo o meio ambiente e a saúde das pessoas. Hoje, começamos nossa caminhada abordando o tema alimentação e onde plantamos nossa comida. Contamos com a sua ajuda para somar esforços nesse percurso!
- 10 October 2023
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais
Open AccessDetetives da comida: o que comemos e por que comemos o que comemos?
Antes de começar nossa caminhada no tema da alimentação, é importante que você compreenda um pouco mais sobre quem somos e o que estamos abordando aqui neste livreto. Quem somos? As pessoas que começaram a escrever este livreto fazem parte do Clube Brasileiro de Saúde Planetária (CBSP). Fazem parte desse clube estudantes universitários de todo o país e de praticamente todas as áreas de estudo! E tem mais: essa iniciativa só construiu esse material por causa do apoio de muitas pessoas, inclusive de fora do clube. E isso já nos leva a responder à segunda pergunta. O que estamos abordando aqui? Este livreto é fruto de uma decisão coletiva, baseada na união de pessoas que decidiram agir em defesa da saúde das pessoas e do planeta. E sim, esse é um trabalho gigante! Mas, trabalhando em equipe, não é tão difícil assim! Inclusive porque já existem cientistas falando que, na verdade, a saúde das pessoas e a do planeta é a mesma! Olha o que eles falam: Saúde Planetária é sobre alcançar o maior padrão possível de saúde, bem-estar e equidade em todo o mundo, com atenção aos sistemas humanos — políticos, econômicos e sociais — que definem o futuro da humanidade e dos sistemas naturais da Terra, estabelecendo limites ambientais para que a humanidade possa florescer. Essa grande aliança pela saúde planetária é o que faz a nossa força. E isso nos leva a entendermos o porquê de produzirmos este livreto: porque precisamos cada vez mais de pessoas defendendo o meio ambiente e a saúde das pessoas. Hoje, começamos nossa caminhada abordando o tema alimentação e onde plantamos nossa comida. Contamos com a sua ajuda para somar esforços nesse percurso!
- 2 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Biodiversity
- Vol. 24 (4) , 181-185
Many possibilities for students as citizen scientists: a supplement to Forti (2023)
- 2 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Biodiversity
- Vol. 24 (4) , 181-185
Many possibilities for students as citizen scientists: a supplement to Forti (2023)
- Open Access
- 11 September 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 15 (18) , 13545
Evaluation of a Bee-Focused Citizen Science Training Process: Influence of Participants’ Profiles on Learning
In citizen science, training and evaluation are important steps in improving the pedagogical effectiveness of projects. However, evaluating learning outcomes is complex and usually requires multidimensional analysis. In this work, we analyze the influence of the profile of citizen scientists (i.e., gender, age, level of education, educational background, prior experience in beekeeping, and level of contact with nature) on their learning, considering multiple dimensions (i.e., knowledge of the nature of science, self-efficacy, knowledge of scientific process and content, interests, values and priorities, and motivations). Citizen scientists participated in a training course that focused on meliponiculture and citizen science, and they performed a contributory citizen science protocol. The evaluation was based on pre- and post-course questionnaires, (reaching 886 respondents). Learning was observed in all dimensions and, depending on the dimension, profile variables, such as gender, educational level, educational background, and prior experience in meliponiculture were influential. Participants demonstrated high levels of nature connectedness, strong personal norms, pro-environmental behavior(al intention), and high levels of trust in science. The main motivations of the participants were to learn, assist in conservation, and contribute to the production of scientific knowledge about bees. Our findings offer insight into the subsequent steps and future training courses for the #cidadãoasf citizen science project, but they could also be beneficial to other initiatives, indicating the importance of the evaluation of volunteer profiles to guide improvements in a project’s quality.
- 11 September 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 15 (18) , 13545
Open AccessEvaluation of a Bee-Focused Citizen Science Training Process: Influence of Participants’ Profiles on Learning
In citizen science, training and evaluation are important steps in improving the pedagogical effectiveness of projects. However, evaluating learning outcomes is complex and usually requires multidimensional analysis. In this work, we analyze the influence of the profile of citizen scientists (i.e., gender, age, level of education, educational background, prior experience in beekeeping, and level of contact with nature) on their learning, considering multiple dimensions (i.e., knowledge of the nature of science, self-efficacy, knowledge of scientific process and content, interests, values and priorities, and motivations). Citizen scientists participated in a training course that focused on meliponiculture and citizen science, and they performed a contributory citizen science protocol. The evaluation was based on pre- and post-course questionnaires, (reaching 886 respondents). Learning was observed in all dimensions and, depending on the dimension, profile variables, such as gender, educational level, educational background, and prior experience in meliponiculture were influential. Participants demonstrated high levels of nature connectedness, strong personal norms, pro-environmental behavior(al intention), and high levels of trust in science. The main motivations of the participants were to learn, assist in conservation, and contribute to the production of scientific knowledge about bees. Our findings offer insight into the subsequent steps and future training courses for the #cidadãoasf citizen science project, but they could also be beneficial to other initiatives, indicating the importance of the evaluation of volunteer profiles to guide improvements in a project’s quality.
- Open Access
- 5 September 2023
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Biodiversity Information Science and Standards
- Vol. 7, e112009
Optimizing the Monitoring of Urban Fruit-Bearing Flora with Citizen Science: An Overview of the Pomar Urbano Initiative
The "Pomar Urbano" (Urban Orchard) project focuses on the collaborative monitoring of fruit-bearing plant species in urban areas throughout Brazil. The project collected a list of 411 fruit-bearing plant species (Soares et al. 2023), both native and exotic varieties found in Brazil. This list was selected from two main sources: the book Brazilian Fruits and Cultivated Exotics (Lorenzi et al. 2006) and the book series Plants for the Future, which includes volumes specifically dedicated to species of economic value in different regions of Brazil, namely the South (Coradin et al. 2011), Midwest (Vieira et al. 2016), Northeast (Coradin et al. 2018) and North (Coradin et al. 2022). To ensure broad geographic coverage, the project spans all 27 state capitals of Brazil. The data collection process relies on the iNaturalist Umbrella and Collection projects. Each state capital has a single collection project, including the fruit-bearing plant species list, and the locality restriction to that specific city. For example, the collection project Pomar Paulistano gathers data from the city of São Paulo. The Umbrella Project Urban Orchard was set to track data from all 27 collection projects. We firmly believe that these fruit-bearing plant species possess multifaceted value that extends beyond mere consumption. As such, we have assembled a dynamic and multidisciplinary team comprising professionals from various institutions across Brazil in a collaborative effort that encompasses different dimensions of biodiversity value exploration and monitoring, especially phenological data. One facet of our team is focused on creating products inspired by the diverse array of Brazilian fruit-bearing plants. Their work spans across sectors of the creative industry, including fashion, painting, and graphic design to infuse these natural elements into innovative and sustainable designs (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2). A group of nutrition and health scientists in conjunction with communication and marketing professionals is working to produce engaging media content centered around food recipes that incorporate Brazilian fruits (Fig. 3). These recipes primarily feature the fruit-bearing plants most frequently observed on iNaturalist in the city of São Paulo, allowing us to showcase the local biodiversity while promoting culinary diversity. Some of these recipes are based on the book Brazilian Biodiversity: Flavors and Aromas (Santiago and Coradin 2018). This book is an extensive compendium of food recipes that use fruits derived from native Brazilian species.
- 5 September 2023
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Biodiversity Information Science and Standards
- Vol. 7, e112009
Open AccessOptimizing the Monitoring of Urban Fruit-Bearing Flora with Citizen Science: An Overview of the Pomar Urbano Initiative
The "Pomar Urbano" (Urban Orchard) project focuses on the collaborative monitoring of fruit-bearing plant species in urban areas throughout Brazil. The project collected a list of 411 fruit-bearing plant species (Soares et al. 2023), both native and exotic varieties found in Brazil. This list was selected from two main sources: the book Brazilian Fruits and Cultivated Exotics (Lorenzi et al. 2006) and the book series Plants for the Future, which includes volumes specifically dedicated to species of economic value in different regions of Brazil, namely the South (Coradin et al. 2011), Midwest (Vieira et al. 2016), Northeast (Coradin et al. 2018) and North (Coradin et al. 2022). To ensure broad geographic coverage, the project spans all 27 state capitals of Brazil. The data collection process relies on the iNaturalist Umbrella and Collection projects. Each state capital has a single collection project, including the fruit-bearing plant species list, and the locality restriction to that specific city. For example, the collection project Pomar Paulistano gathers data from the city of São Paulo. The Umbrella Project Urban Orchard was set to track data from all 27 collection projects. We firmly believe that these fruit-bearing plant species possess multifaceted value that extends beyond mere consumption. As such, we have assembled a dynamic and multidisciplinary team comprising professionals from various institutions across Brazil in a collaborative effort that encompasses different dimensions of biodiversity value exploration and monitoring, especially phenological data. One facet of our team is focused on creating products inspired by the diverse array of Brazilian fruit-bearing plants. Their work spans across sectors of the creative industry, including fashion, painting, and graphic design to infuse these natural elements into innovative and sustainable designs (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2). A group of nutrition and health scientists in conjunction with communication and marketing professionals is working to produce engaging media content centered around food recipes that incorporate Brazilian fruits (Fig. 3). These recipes primarily feature the fruit-bearing plants most frequently observed on iNaturalist in the city of São Paulo, allowing us to showcase the local biodiversity while promoting culinary diversity. Some of these recipes are based on the book Brazilian Biodiversity: Flavors and Aromas (Santiago and Coradin 2018). This book is an extensive compendium of food recipes that use fruits derived from native Brazilian species.
- Open Access
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Biodiversity Information Science and Standards
- Vol. 7, e111545
Flower-Insect Timed Counts (FIT Count): Protocol Adaptation and Preliminary Results in Brazil
FIT Count (Flower-Insect Timed Counts) is a citizen science initiative that seeks to monitor flower visitation by diverse pollinator groups, including bumblebees, stingless bees, honeybees, flies, hummingbirds, among others. The protocol entails determining a 50 x 50 cm plot area around a target plant species, photographing the plant and conducting a standardized 10-minute survey on this area to estimate the frequency of flower visits by different pollinator groups. Conducting FIT Counts in different habitats and locations produces data on the temporal and spatial dynamics of these interactions (Carvell 2022, UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme 2018). FIT Count methodology was originally developed by the UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme (PoMS) and has been used in the United Kingdom since 2017, with over 8,500 counts conducted to date. In 2021, the FIT Count application (app) was launched in the United Kingdom, and became available in Brazil, Chile, Argentina, and some other European countries in 2022. After installation, users may select in which country the observations will be conducted and their preferred language, either English or the main native language of participating countries. The adaptation of the application for use by Brazilian citizen scientists involved not only the translation of the interface, but also relied on the expertise of a local team who helped select which plant species and pollinator groups would be appropriate and representative of biodiversity within the country (Fig. 1). The application is supported by a website that features a dedicated page for each country. Users can download the app on Google Play or App Store (Fig. 2). To allow the participation of non-experts, who generally are not familiar with taxonomy or species identification, the flower visitors are identified in general categories such as bumblebees and carpenter bees (grouped together), flies, and others (see Fig. 1), representing the main functional groups of pollinators. If a flower visitor cannot be identified, it should be classified as "other insect" or marked as "I don't know". Including the possibility of uncertainty in flower visitor identification was a suggestion of the Brazilian team for quality assurance during data collection. Currently, 834 flower visits have been counted by 15 participants, who performed 109 FIT Counts across Brazil as a pilot testing phase of the app. Two training workshops were held to disseminate the app, and an illustrated guide was published to help participants identify flower types and flower visitor groups (Koffler 2022). Nineteen plant species were monitored, but most flower-visits counted were on basil (Ocimum basillicum, n = 47) and false heather (Cuphea hyssopifolia, n = 33). The mean number of flower visitors per FIT Count was 8 (min = 0, max = 45). While most visits were performed by honeybees, participants also recorded visits by beetles, butterflies or moths, small insects, solitary bees, wasps and other insects. Next steps include assessing data quality and promoting strategic partnerships to further disseminate this citizen science initiative. For instance, quality control measures may include assessing whether participants perform the protocol steps according to instructions and whether plants and flower visitors are correctly identified and counted. Also, we are exploring the prospective implementation of the Darwin Core standard (Darwin Core Task Group 2009) along with the Plant-Pollinator Interactions vocabulary (Salim 2022) to standardize data description.
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Biodiversity Information Science and Standards
- Vol. 7, e111545
Open AccessFlower-Insect Timed Counts (FIT Count): Protocol Adaptation and Preliminary Results in Brazil
FIT Count (Flower-Insect Timed Counts) is a citizen science initiative that seeks to monitor flower visitation by diverse pollinator groups, including bumblebees, stingless bees, honeybees, flies, hummingbirds, among others. The protocol entails determining a 50 x 50 cm plot area around a target plant species, photographing the plant and conducting a standardized 10-minute survey on this area to estimate the frequency of flower visits by different pollinator groups. Conducting FIT Counts in different habitats and locations produces data on the temporal and spatial dynamics of these interactions (Carvell 2022, UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme 2018). FIT Count methodology was originally developed by the UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme (PoMS) and has been used in the United Kingdom since 2017, with over 8,500 counts conducted to date. In 2021, the FIT Count application (app) was launched in the United Kingdom, and became available in Brazil, Chile, Argentina, and some other European countries in 2022. After installation, users may select in which country the observations will be conducted and their preferred language, either English or the main native language of participating countries. The adaptation of the application for use by Brazilian citizen scientists involved not only the translation of the interface, but also relied on the expertise of a local team who helped select which plant species and pollinator groups would be appropriate and representative of biodiversity within the country (Fig. 1). The application is supported by a website that features a dedicated page for each country. Users can download the app on Google Play or App Store (Fig. 2). To allow the participation of non-experts, who generally are not familiar with taxonomy or species identification, the flower visitors are identified in general categories such as bumblebees and carpenter bees (grouped together), flies, and others (see Fig. 1), representing the main functional groups of pollinators. If a flower visitor cannot be identified, it should be classified as "other insect" or marked as "I don't know". Including the possibility of uncertainty in flower visitor identification was a suggestion of the Brazilian team for quality assurance during data collection. Currently, 834 flower visits have been counted by 15 participants, who performed 109 FIT Counts across Brazil as a pilot testing phase of the app. Two training workshops were held to disseminate the app, and an illustrated guide was published to help participants identify flower types and flower visitor groups (Koffler 2022). Nineteen plant species were monitored, but most flower-visits counted were on basil (Ocimum basillicum, n = 47) and false heather (Cuphea hyssopifolia, n = 33). The mean number of flower visitors per FIT Count was 8 (min = 0, max = 45). While most visits were performed by honeybees, participants also recorded visits by beetles, butterflies or moths, small insects, solitary bees, wasps and other insects. Next steps include assessing data quality and promoting strategic partnerships to further disseminate this citizen science initiative. For instance, quality control measures may include assessing whether participants perform the protocol steps according to instructions and whether plants and flower visitors are correctly identified and counted. Also, we are exploring the prospective implementation of the Darwin Core standard (Darwin Core Task Group 2009) along with the Plant-Pollinator Interactions vocabulary (Salim 2022) to standardize data description.
- Open Access
Body size affects specialization and modularity in the global resin foraging meta-network of stingless bees
Bees are in global decline and specialized species might be the most vulnerable to extinctions. Bee conservation can be studied using interaction networks, whose relative importance of nodes might correlate with morphological traits. Specifically, body size could affect flying range and thus influence the set of plant-bee interactions. Although several studies have reported botanical sources of resins in stingless bees, resin foraging networks were rarely assembled. Here we aim to describe the global resin-foraging meta-network of stingless bees, identify the most specialized species, and test how body size influences modularity and specialization. We found a modular and nested structure, in which some modules exhibit significant differences in body size and specialization. Melipona beecheii is the most specialized stingless bee in collecting resins. Body size is positively correlated with specialization, in which larger bees are more specialized to collect resins from a subset of plants, possibly because larger bees with broader flying ranges avoid competition by collecting less disputed resources. Our results demonstrate how resin collection can be analyzed in a meta-network framework to test ecological hypotheses and identify specialized species as candidate priorities for the conservation of stingless bees.
Open AccessBody size affects specialization and modularity in the global resin foraging meta-network of stingless bees
Bees are in global decline and specialized species might be the most vulnerable to extinctions. Bee conservation can be studied using interaction networks, whose relative importance of nodes might correlate with morphological traits. Specifically, body size could affect flying range and thus influence the set of plant-bee interactions. Although several studies have reported botanical sources of resins in stingless bees, resin foraging networks were rarely assembled. Here we aim to describe the global resin-foraging meta-network of stingless bees, identify the most specialized species, and test how body size influences modularity and specialization. We found a modular and nested structure, in which some modules exhibit significant differences in body size and specialization. Melipona beecheii is the most specialized stingless bee in collecting resins. Body size is positively correlated with specialization, in which larger bees are more specialized to collect resins from a subset of plants, possibly because larger bees with broader flying ranges avoid competition by collecting less disputed resources. Our results demonstrate how resin collection can be analyzed in a meta-network framework to test ecological hypotheses and identify specialized species as candidate priorities for the conservation of stingless bees.