IHIain Hrynaszkiewicz

Iain Hrynaszkiewicz

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Iain Hrynaszkiewicz has a total of 125 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Responsible Research Assessment of Faculty: maximizing quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research in Research-Performing Organizations

    by David Moher, Kelly Denise Cobey, Anna Catharina Vieira Armond, Annette Nicole Brown, Maximiliano Sergio Cenci, Leslie Chan, Lavinia Gambelli, Michael Halas, Susan H. Fox, Michael Hoffman, et al.

    This multi-interest holder consensus effort highlights the essential influence and responsibility of Research-Performing Organizations (RPOs) in shaping the quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research. Despite the use of metrics to assess transparency and openness by academic journals and funders, most RPOs do not yet have metrics/indicators or monitoring that address deep-rooted shortcomings in research practice and assessment. These shortcomings manifest as restricted access to research outputs, poor availability of underlying data and materials, infrequent reproducibility checks and direct replications, and ongoing incidents of research misconduct all contributing to erosion of public trust in research. Such issues are exacerbated by institutional incentive structures that reward the number of publications and journal prestige, while neglecting research credibility, societal relevance, and transparent communication. To respond comprehensively to these challenges, our working group reached consensus on six core practices for RPOs to monitor: data, code, and material sharing; open access publishing; prospective study registration; reporting transparency; disclosures of interest and funding; and verification efforts.Collectively, these six practices offer a pragmatic and flexible framework that RPOs can tailor to their local context. The paper provides an implementation guide for these practices and calls for renewed leadership by RPOs in realigning research(er) assessment and incentives to reward quality, transparency, and trustworthiness in research, closing persistent gaps, and reinforcing science’s credibility and utility for society.

  • Open Access

    Responsible Research Assessment of Faculty: maximizing quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research in Research-Performing Organizations

    by David Moher, Kelly Denise Cobey, Anna Catharina Vieira Armond, Annette Nicole Brown, Maximiliano Sergio Cenci, Leslie Chan, Lavinia Gambelli, Michael Halas, Susan H. Fox, Michael Hoffman, et al.

    This multi-interest holder consensus effort highlights the essential influence and responsibility of Research-Performing Organizations (RPOs) in shaping the quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research. Despite the use of metrics to assess transparency and openness by academic journals and funders, most RPOs do not yet have metrics/indicators or monitoring that address deep-rooted shortcomings in research practice and assessment. These shortcomings manifest as restricted access to research outputs, poor availability of underlying data and materials, infrequent reproducibility checks and direct replications, and ongoing incidents of research misconduct all contributing to erosion of public trust in research. Such issues are exacerbated by institutional incentive structures that reward the number of publications and journal prestige, while neglecting research credibility, societal relevance, and transparent communication. To respond comprehensively to these challenges, our working group reached consensus on six core practices for RPOs to monitor: data, code, and material sharing; open access publishing; prospective study registration; reporting transparency; disclosures of interest and funding; and verification efforts.Collectively, these six practices offer a pragmatic and flexible framework that RPOs can tailor to their local context. The paper provides an implementation guide for these practices and calls for renewed leadership by RPOs in realigning research(er) assessment and incentives to reward quality, transparency, and trustworthiness in research, closing persistent gaps, and reinforcing science’s credibility and utility for society.

  • Open Access

    TOP 2025: An update to the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines

    by Sean Grant, Katherine S. Corker, David Mellor, Suzanne L. K. Stewart, Evan Mayo-Wilson, Aidan G. Cashin, Malgorzata Lagisz, David Moher, Daniel Umpierre, Virginia Barbour, et al.

    Background: Transparency and openness are core scientific values that enable independent verification of reported research results. The Transparency and Openness Promotion (TOP) Guidelines, first published in 2015 (TOP 2015), provided a flexible framework for journals to design and implement publication standards promoting these values. Over the past decade, widespread use of TOP 2015 contributed to valuable evidence and feedback for refinement. Main Text: The TOP Advisory Board undertook a comprehensive update of TOP 2015 that went into effect in 2025 (TOP 2025). The update introduces an explicit conceptual framework clarifying its primary objective: improving the verifiability of empirical research claims. Standards are reorganized into three categories (Research Practices, Verification Practices, and Verification Studies) that resolve conceptual and structural limitations of TOP 2015. Research Practices include seven discrete practices implemented in three ways: Disclosed, Shared and Cited, and Certified. Verification Practices introduce standards for computational reproducibility and results transparency, while Verification Studies enumerate empirical research designs and publication formats that support verification of results. Language now centers on researchers and studies (rather than journals) to facilitate adoption by funders, research organizations, preprint servers, evidence curators, and other interest-holders. These changes promote flexible implementation and contextual tailoring. Conclusions: TOP 2025 retains the core strengths of TOP 2015 while addressing feedback from a decade of implementation and advances in open science. Rather than a universal mandate, it provides a shared, adaptable framework to coordinate the design, implementation, and communication of open policies across interest-holders.


  • Open Access

    An analysis of the effects of open science indicators on citations in the French Open Science Monitor

    by Giovanni Colavizza, Lauren Cadwallader, Iain Hrynaszkiewicz

    This study investigates the correlation of citation impact with various open science indicators (OSI) within the French Open Science Monitor (FOSM), a data set comprising approximately 900,000 publications authored by French authors from 2020 to 2022. By integrating data from OpenAlex and Crossref, we analyze open science indicators such as the presence of a pre-print, data sharing, and software sharing in 576,537 publications in the FOSM data set. Our analysis reveals a positive correlation between these OSI and citation counts. Considering our most complete citation prediction model, we find pre-prints are correlated with a significant positive effect of 19% on citation counts, software sharing of 13.5%, and data sharing of 14.3%. We find large variations in the correlations of OSIs with citations in different research disciplines, and observe that the open access status of publications is correlated with an 8.6% increase in citations in our model. While these results remain observational and are limited to the scope of the analysis, they suggest a consistent correlation between citation advantages and open science indicators. Our results may be valuable to policymakers, funding agencies, researchers, publishers, institutions, and other stakeholders who are interested in understanding the academic impacts, or effects, of open science practices.


  • Open Access

    TOP 2025: An Update to the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines

    by Sean Grant, Katherine S. Corker, David Thomas Mellor, Suzanne L. K. Stewart, Aidan Gregory Cashin, Malgorzata Lagisz, Evan Mayo-Wilson, David Moher, Daniel Umpierre, Virginia Barbour, et al.

    Open science remains vital to the progress and functioning of the global research enterprise. Published in 2015, the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines (TOP 2015) was developed as a policy framework to enhance the verifiability of empirical research claims in journal articles. It has been widely used and adopted by publishers and academic journals, but despite its uptake, concerns have been raised about aspects of the TOP 2015 framework and its implementation. In response to the above, the purpose of this manuscript is to introduce an official update to the TOP Guidelines. The final version—TOP 2025—provides updated guidelines for promoting the verifiability of published empirical research claims.

  • Open Access

    Responsible Research Assessment of Faculty: maximizing quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research in Research-Performing Organizations

    by David Moher, Kelly Denise Cobey, Anna Catharina Vieira Armond, Annette Nicole Brown, Maximiliano Sergio Cenci, Leslie Chan, Lavinia Gambelli, Michael Halas, Susan H. Fox, Michael Hoffman, et al.

    This multi-interest holder consensus effort highlights the essential influence and responsibility of Research-Performing Organizations (RPOs) in shaping the quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research. Despite the use of metrics to assess transparency and openness by academic journals and funders, most RPOs do not yet have metrics/indicators or monitoring that address deep-rooted shortcomings in research practice and assessment. These shortcomings manifest as restricted access to research outputs, poor availability of underlying data and materials, infrequent reproducibility checks and direct replications, and ongoing incidents of research misconduct all contributing to erosion of public trust in research. Such issues are exacerbated by institutional incentive structures that reward the number of publications and journal prestige, while neglecting research credibility, societal relevance, and transparent communication. To respond comprehensively to these challenges, our working group reached consensus on six core practices for RPOs to monitor: data, code, and material sharing; open access publishing; prospective study registration; reporting transparency; disclosures of interest and funding; and verification efforts.Collectively, these six practices offer a pragmatic and flexible framework that RPOs can tailor to their local context. The paper provides an implementation guide for these practices and calls for renewed leadership by RPOs in realigning research(er) assessment and incentives to reward quality, transparency, and trustworthiness in research, closing persistent gaps, and reinforcing science’s credibility and utility for society.

  • Open Access

    TOP 2025: An Update to the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines

    by Sean Grant, Katherine S. Corker, David Thomas Mellor, Suzanne L. K. Stewart, Aidan Gregory Cashin, Malgorzata Lagisz, Evan Mayo-Wilson, David Moher, Daniel Umpierre, Virginia Barbour, et al.

    Open science remains vital to the progress and functioning of the global research enterprise. Published in 2015, the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines (TOP 2015) was developed as a policy framework to enhance the verifiability of empirical research claims in journal articles. It has been widely used and adopted by publishers and academic journals, but despite its uptake, concerns have been raised about aspects of the TOP 2015 framework and its implementation. In response to the above, the purpose of this manuscript is to introduce an official update to the TOP Guidelines. The final version—TOP 2025—provides updated guidelines for promoting the verifiability of published empirical research claims.

  • Open Access

    Responsible Research Assessment of Faculty: maximizing quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research in Research-Performing Organizations

    by David Moher, Kelly Denise Cobey, David Thomas Mellor, Anna Catharina Vieira Armond, Janina Ramos, Annette Nicole Brown, Maximiliano Sergio Cenci, Michael Halas, Susan H. Fox, Iain Hrynaszkiewicz, et al.

    This multi-interest holder consensus effort highlights the essential influence and responsibility of Research-Performing Organizations (RPOs) in shaping the quality, transparency, and trustworthiness of scientific research. Despite the use of metrics to assess transparency and openness by academic journals and funders, most RPOs do not yet have metrics/indicators or monitoring that address deep-rooted shortcomings in research practice and assessment. These shortcomings manifest as restricted access to research outputs, poor availability of underlying data and materials, infrequent reproducibility checks and direct replications, and ongoing incidents of research misconduct all contributing to erosion of public trust in research. Such issues are exacerbated by institutional incentive structures that reward the number of publications and journal prestige, while neglecting research credibility, societal relevance, and transparent communication. To respond comprehensively to these challenges, our working group reached consensus on six core practices for RPOs to monitor: data, code, and material sharing; open access publishing; prospective study registration; reporting transparency; disclosures of interest and funding; and verification efforts.Collectively, these six practices offer a pragmatic and flexible framework that RPOs can tailor to their local context. The paper provides an implementation guide for these practices and calls for renewed leadership by RPOs in realigning research(er) assessment and incentives to reward quality, transparency, and trustworthiness in research, closing persistent gaps, and reinforcing science’s credibility and utility for society.

  • Open Access

    A survey of how biology researchers assess credibility when serving on grant and hiring committees

    by Iain Hrynaszkiewicz, Beruria Novich, James Harney, Ross Gray, Veronique Kiermer

    Researchers who serve on grant review and hiring committees have to make decisions about the intrinsic value of research in short periods of time, and research impact metrics such Journal Impact Factor (JIF) exert undue influence on these decisions. Initiatives such as the Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment (CoARA) and the Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA) emphasize responsible use of quantitative metrics and avoidance of journal-based impact metrics for research assessment. Further, our previous qualitative research suggested that assessing credibility, or trustworthiness, of research is important to researchers not only when they seek to inform their own research but also in the context of research assessment committees. To confirm our findings from previous interviews in quantitative terms, we surveyed 485 biology researchers who have served on committees for grant review or hiring and promotion decisions, to understand how they assess the credibility of research outputs in these contexts. We found that concepts like credibility, trustworthiness, quality, and impact lack consistent definitions and interpretations by researchers, which had already been observed in our interviews. We also found that, in our sample, assessment of credibility is very important to the majority (90%, 95% CI [87–92%]) of researchers serving in these committees but fewer than half of participants are satisfied with their ability to assess credibility. This gap between importance of an assessment and satisfaction in the ability to conduct it was reflected in multiple aspects of credibility we tested, and it was greatest for researchers seeking to assess the integrity of research (such as identifying signs of fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism), and the suitability and completeness of research methods. Non-traditional research outputs associated with open science practices—research data, code, protocols, and preprints—are particularly hard for researchers to assess, despite the potential of Open Science practices to signal trustworthiness. A substantial proportion of participants (57% [52%, 61%] of participants) report using journal reputation and JIF to assess credibility of research articles and outputs, despite journal reputation and JIF being proxies for credibility that rely on characteristics of research outputs that are extrinsic, rather than intrinsic, to the output itself. While our results only describe the practices and perspectives of our sample, they may suggest opportunities to develop better guidance and better signals to support the evaluation of research credibility and trustworthiness—and ultimately support research assessment reform, away from the use of proxies for impact and towards assessing the intrinsic characteristics and values researchers see as important.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    TOP 2025: An Update to the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines

    by Sean Grant, Katherine S. Corker, David Thomas Mellor, Suzanne L. K. Stewart, Aidan Gregory Cashin, Malgorzata Lagisz, Evan Mayo-Wilson, David Moher, Daniel Umpierre, Virginia Barbour, et al.

    Open science remains vital to the progress and functioning of the global research enterprise. Published in 2015, the Transparency and Openness Promotion Guidelines (TOP 2015) was developed as a policy framework to enhance the verifiability of empirical research claims in journal articles. It has been widely used and adopted by publishers and academic journals, but despite its uptake, concerns have been raised about aspects of the TOP 2015 framework and its implementation. In response to the above, the purpose of this manuscript is to introduce an official update to the TOP Guidelines. The final version—TOP 2025—provides updated guidelines for promoting the verifiability of published empirical research claims.