PGPetra Gümplová

Petra Gümplová

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Justice on the Seafloor: A Critical Appraisal of the Extension of Sovereign Rights to Natural Resources on the Continental Shelf

    by Petra Gümplová

    This Article looks critically at the extension of sovereign rights to natural resources into the ocean commons. It focuses specifically on the continental shelf. I first account for the novelty of the continental shelf claims and the legal regime set by United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Then, I look at the structure, scope, and practice of sovereign rights to natural resources and assess the consequences of their application to this legally constructed underwater resource domain attached to the territory of a coastal state. The overall argument of this Article is that in the current form, sovereign rights do not promote justice in the ocean commons. Three distinct problematic consequences from the perspective of justice are analyzed: Distributive inequality, unjust politics of resource sovereignty, and legal and economic reification of marine ecosystems. In the conclusion, I raise the question of the role of sovereignty in the global commons and how to restructure it so that it meets the demands of safeguarding the ocean commons as an environmental planetary domain. The Article argues for the possibility of rethinking sovereignty in terms of Earth Trusteeship of the global commons based on a normative concept of sovereignty as trusteeship of humanity and the environment recently proposed in the philosophy of international law.


  • Open Access

    Greenland and the Dangers of Becoming a US Estate

    by Petra Gümplova

    This article critically analyzes the imperiality and illegality of the Trump's administration goals to acquire Greenland and argues that any plans for Greenland other than realizing the right to self-determination through a constitutional democratic process are unacceptable. The President Trump's advances are discussed in the context of the US's security and economic interests, with special attention being paid to risks of the US's control of Greenland's recently acquired sovereignty over natural resources and its recently adopted system of resource governance that emphasizes environmental sustainability, social license, and economic benefit for Greenland's people.

  • Open Access

    Justice on the Seafloor: A Critical Appraisal of the Extension of Sovereign Rights to Natural Resources on the Continental Shelf

    by Petra Gümplova

    This Article looks critically at the extension of sovereign rights to natural resources into the ocean commons. It focuses specifically on the continental shelf. I first account for the novelty of the continental shelf claims and the legal regime set by United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Then, I look at the structure, scope, and practice of sovereign rights to natural resources and assess the consequences of their application to this legally constructed underwater resource domain attached to the territory of a coastal state. The overall argument of this Article is that in the current form, sovereign rights do not promote justice in the ocean commons. Three distinct problematic consequences from the perspective of justice are analyzed: Distributive inequality, unjust politics of resource sovereignty, and legal and economic reification of marine ecosystems. In the conclusion, I raise the question of the role of sovereignty in the global commons and how to restructure it so that it meets the demands of safeguarding the ocean commons as an environmental planetary domain. The Article argues for the possibility of rethinking sovereignty in terms of Earth Trusteeship of the global commons based on a normative concept of sovereignty as trusteeship of humanity and the environment recently proposed in the philosophy of international law.

  • Natural Resources

    by Petra Gümplová

  • Open Access

    Normative View of Natural Resources—Global Redistribution or Human Rights–Based Approach?

    by Petra Gümplová

    This paper contrasts conceptions of global distributive justice focused on natural resources with human rights–based approach. To emphasize the advantages of the latter, the paper analyzes three areas: (1) the methodology of normative theorizing about natural resources, (2) the category of natural resources, and (3) the view of the system of sovereignty over natural resources. Concerning the first, I argue that global justice conceptions misconstrue the claims made to natural resources and offer conceptions which are practically unfeasible. Concerning the second, I show that contemporary philosophy of justice downplays the plurality of meanings resources have for collectives and argue that conflicts over natural resources can best be accounted for using human rights. Finally, the paper looks at sovereignty over natural resources and argues that rather than dismissing it as unjustifiable on moral grounds, it should be reformed in line with valid principles of international law, most importantly with human rights.


  • Open Access

    Sovereignty over natural resources – A normative reinterpretation

    by Petra Gümplová

    This article provides a normative account of sovereign rights to natural resources on the basis of moral principles which underlie its international legal structure – the right to self-determination and human rights. The first part locates the emergence of the system of sovereign rights to natural resources in the process of the decolonisation and justifies it as a correction of historical injustice of violent appropriation of natural resources. The second part identifies the key moral component and justificatory principle of the system of sovereign rights to natural resources – the right to self-determination. I outline a justice-based interpretation of the right to self-determination and show why rights to natural resources are its corollary. The last part connects rights to self-determination and rights to natural resources to human rights and shows how human rights define the permissible scope of rights to natural resources in two dimensions – the dimension of political legitimacy of the exercise of resource rights and the dimension of the distribution of resource benefits.


  • Popular sovereignty over natural resources: A critical reappraisal of Leif Wenar’sBlood Oilfrom the perspective of international law and justice

    by Petra Gümplová

    The article discusses the concept of popular sovereignty over natural resources and its possible applicability to a broader account of natural resource justice based on a moral interpretation of international law. Leif Wenar’s recent proposal to entrench popular resource sovereignty as a counterclaim to illegitimate uses of natural resources by corrupt and authoritarian regimes serves as the starting point for the discussion of the possible meaning of popular resource sovereignty and its role in an account of natural resource justice. Three key aspects of Wenar’s conception are in focus: 1) the framing of popular resource sovereignty within the current system of sovereign territoriality, 2) the notion of collective ownership of natural resources as the content of popular resource sovereignty, and 3) civil and political rights as the key set of norms determining the conditions of legitimate exercise of resource sovereignty. The article argues that collective sovereignty claims over natural resources can neither be framed exclusively through boundaries of current sovereign states, nor understood in terms of full and unlimited property rights. Concerning civil and political rights, I argue we need to move past the liberal conception of legitimacy toward a more comprehensive human rights-based conception of justice serving as a standard for assessment of legitimacy of both sovereign and non-sovereign entities which have rights over natural resources.